EU Talks With Turkey Could Alter Landscape

EU Talks With Turkey Could Alter Landscape
By CONSTANT BRAND
The Associated Press
12/18/04 16:21 EST
BRUSSELS, Belgium (AP) – Turkey can expect to be put through a test
of fire when it launches negotiations to join the European Union, and
the process – which will last more than a decade – could transform the
political and social landscape of both Turkey and the 25-nation bloc.
It took a tough, two-day summit to hammer out a compromise agreement
allowing the talks to begin, and now Ankara is looking at an Oct. 3,
2005 date to start negotiations.
The decision is among the most important the EU has made in its
46-year existence but there were few signs of euphoric celebration of
the deal amid deep concerns among many Europeans over the prospect
of letting in a Muslim nation that – with 71 million people – would
be one of the largest members of the club.
French President Jacques Chirac, reflecting staunch opposition among
French citizens, had few positive words at the end of the gathering.
“The route will be long and difficult for Turkey to take all measures
to meet all the conditions demanded to join Europe,” he said.
The divided Mediterranean island of Cyprus was the most prominent
obstacle at the summit, which ended Friday. In the end, Turkey met the
EU demand that it agree to sign a customs deal with the 10 nations –
including Cyprus – that joined the bloc this year. But Turkish Prime
Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said later the signing does not mean
official recognition of the Greek Cypriot-led government.
So the question of Cyprus – where Turkey has troops stationed in
Turkish-Cypriot-run enclave in the north – remains open. The summit
also set a number of other conditions on internal reforms before the
start of talks.
And many EU states are lukewarm to even starting talks with Turkey –
so they may try to appease opposition at home by putting up added
stumbling blocks during the negotiations to delay its entry.
Chirac, who has promised a referendum on Turkish membership if the
talks succeed, said Ankara would have to recognize the mass killings
of Armenians in the early 20th century.
Austrian Chancellor Wolfgang Schuessel said he would also call a
referendum because bringing a Muslim country into the EU “must not
be decided in an ivory tower … We cannot be indifferent about
public opinion.”
While Turkey takes on changes to win membership, some Europeans fear
that Turkey’s entry would mean devastating change for the union, even
causing the bloc’s collapse setting back the nearly 50-year drive to
unify the continent so it can rival the United States and China.
Countries may be less willing to tear down barriers within the bloc
if it means dealing with the economic and social consequences of a
Muslim nation of Turkey’s size.
For example, France and Poland, who benefit most from EU farm
subsidies, have said they are opposed to granting similar benefits
to Turkey’s agricultural sector, which will dwarf all others, and so
put an end to joint handouts.
Also many countries fear that further integrating rights of free
movement across the EU would lead to a mass migration of poorer Turks
to other EU countries, something they want to avoid, fearing they
will take away local jobs.
Then there is the widespread worry among many Europeans that Turkey’s
Muslim culture – though its government is resolutely secular – will
not click with their Judeo-Christian values.
Jacques Attali, a former adviser to French President Francois
Mitterand, wrote in the Belgian daily Le Soir, advocating a breakaway
“core” of countries pursuing closer ties within the EU. “We need to
recreate the federation with only a few states, but not with the same
EU structures,” he said.
Several critical newspapers said the deal with Turkey would mark
the end of the EU’s political ambitions to become a power on the
world stage.
Germany’s Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung said German Chancellor Gerhard
Schroeder, who staunchly backed Turkey’s bid, “could go down in history
… as the German chancellor during whose term in office and with
whose approval the idea of a politically united Europe was abandoned.”
The Czech Republic’s biggest daily, Mlada Fronta Dnes said Turkey’s
membership might be a “bite too hard for Brussels to swallow.”
“The individual states … will lack will to closely cooperate,”
it said in an editorial.
European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso had to deny rumors
this week of fears that the EU’s constitution, which still faces
ratification, would have to be scrapped to reformulate how the EU
makes decisions ahead of Turkey’s entry to ensure its influence would
not dominate over older members.
Although Turkey’s current population of 71 million is smaller than
that of Germany – currently 82 million – it is expected to grow to
80-85 million by 2020 and nearly 89 million by 2025, while Germany’s
population is predicted to fall slightly. As the largest country in
the EU, Turkey would have the most votes in the bloc’s decision-making
bodies.
The clock has already started ticking for Turkey to meet the conditions
prior to starting the October negotiations, which the EU warned offered
“no guarantee” of success.
It will have to deliver results in meeting “benchmarks” on a number of
key issues from Kurdish rights to ensuring “zero-tolerance” of torture,
and passing additional penal code reforms. Erdogan will also have to
make good on recognizing Cyprus.
Jumping that first hurdle, Turkey then faces a test in a vast array
of policy areas to meet minimum standards before talks begin in such
complex policy issues like environmental protection laws or food
safety standards.
And during the negotiations, any of the EU’s 25 nations can call for
a freeze in the talks if they feel Turkey is backtracking on reforms.
Josep Borrell, president of the European Parliament reiterated calls
that EU leaders as well as Turkey had to sell the negotiations to
their citizens if they wanted them to succeed and be welcomed.
“Turkey … is not a candidate like any other,” Borrell wrote in
Le Soir. “The question of Turkey divides Europeans. It pushes the
geographical, historic and political limit of Europe … but Turkey
should not be rejected because the majority of its population is
Muslim.”
EDITORS NOTE: Constant Brand has covered European Union affairs for
The Associated Press in Brussels since 1999.

Armenian minister sees no need for NATO membership,hails ties with R

Armenian minister sees no need for NATO membership, hails ties with Russia
Azg, Yerevan
18 Dec 04
Text of Tatul Akopyan report by Armenian newspaper Azg on 18 December
headlined “Armenian-Russian strategic alliance has no alternative
today”
Armenian Defence Minister Serzh Sarkisyan sees no need for Armenia
to join NATO.
Serzh Sarkisyan stated yesterday 17 December that relations between
Armenia and NATO will deepen and develop as long “as there are
not in conflict with our obligations under the Collective Security
Treaty”. There is currently no need for Armenia to put the issue
of NATO membership on its foreign policy agenda but this does not
mean that we should not develop our relations with the organization,
Sarkisyan said during a round table on the issue of regional security.
Yerevan and Brussels have made an obvious progress in their relations
in the last few years. Speaking about Armenia-NATO relations,
Sarkisyan said that Armenia has participated in 47 events and five
military exercises of the organization in 2004 and is going to increase
the number.
Armenian and Russian political leaders and US representatives took
part in the round table discussion. Serzh Sarkisyan took the floor to
speak about Armenia-NATO, Armenia-Russia, Armenia-EU relations and
the system of regional security in particular. “The Armenia-Russian
military alliance has no alternative today,” he said, adding that
relations with Russia won’t get in the way of its efforts to integrate
more closely with Europe especially in the event that Russia and
Europe will come closer together. The minister noted that cooperation
between Armenia and Russia in the military sphere has been reflected
in dozens of pages.
Serzh Sarkisyan hailed Armenia’s relationship with the European
Union as the key one. Our country exports 40 per cent of its goods
to Europe. He praised “brilliant military interaction” between the
Armenian and Greek peacekeepers in Kosovo. The Minister of Defence
noted that Armenia is the only country in the South Caucasus which
pursues a balanced policy. He thinks that cooperation between regional
countries will be possible one day, having recalled the fact that
European states such as England, France and Germany have the history
of centuries-long enmity but they are now allies.
Levon Lazarian, representative of the Armenian Revolutionary
Federation – Dashnaktsutyun, spoke about other areas of cooperation on
top of the one mentioned by the minister. He singled out relations with
Iran and the Arab world. Lazarian recalled two facts from the past:
firstly, Iran provided Armenia with a road, which was the only road at
the time when Armenia was blockaded on three sides, secondly by taking
a neutral stance on the Karabakh conflict, Tehran prevented it from
turning into a religious one, something which Azerbaijan strived for.

Accession to NATO isn’t on current agenda of Armenia – minister

Accession to NATO isn’t on current agenda of Armenia – minister
By Tigran Liloyan
ITAR-TASS News Agency
December 17, 2004 Friday
YEREVAN, December 17 — The accession to NATO is not on the current
foreign political agenda of Armenia, Defense Minister Serzh Sarkisyan
said at Friday debates organized by the Public Dialog and Development
Center.
He was speaking about regional security in the South Caucasus.
“At the same time, Armenia is realistic about regional security. It
does not make premature statements but develops cooperation with
the North Atlantic Alliance step by step,” the minister said. “In
this light relations with NATO have a serious role in the provision
of Armenian security. Finally, our country has chosen European
development, and NATO is a leading organization ensuring European
security.”

Armenia comes out for creating reg security system in S Caucasus

Armenia comes out for creating reg security system in S Caucasus
By Tigran Liloyan
ITAR-TASS News Agency
December 17, 2004 Friday
YEREVAN, December 18 — Armenia comes out for the creation of a
regional security system in the South Caucasus, Armenian Defence
Minister Serzh Sarkisyan said in his report “South Caucasus: issues
of regional security” during the debates that were organised by the
Center of public dialogue and development on Friday.
He noted that “the constructive policy and interest to ensure
stability by external forces – Russia, the United States, European
Union, Iran and Turkey is important in order to ensure security in
the South Caucasus.” “However, the position and policy of countries
of the region have primarily the decisive significance in this issue,”
the minister emphasised.
According to him, “real guarantees of regional development can be
provided only with the system of comprehensive security, atmosphere
of stability and mutual trust.” “Armenia will pursue the policy for
the development of a multipolar system of country’s security till
these conditions are not provided yet,” the minister pointed out.

Chirac insta a Turquia a reconocer genocidio contra armenios

Chirac insta a Turquia a reconocer genocidio contra armenios
Deutsche Presse-Agentur
December 17, 2004, Friday
Bruselas, 17 dic — El presidente frances, Jacques Chirac, insto hoy
a Turquia a reconocer el genocidio cometido en Armenia durante la I
Guerra Mundial.
“El trabajo de la memoria debe ser visto como una necesidad
irrenunciable”, indico el mandatario en Bruselas tras la cumbre de
la Union Europea (UE).
En caso de que esto no suceda, los franceses seguramente lo tendran
en cuenta para el planificado referendum sobre el ingreso de Turquia
a la UE.
En 1915 Francia abrio las puertas a muchos inmigrantes armenios.

Russia-Armenia relations play key role for Armenia security

Russia-Armenia relations play key role for Armenia security
By Tigran Liloyan
ITAR-TASS News Agency
December 17, 2004 Friday
YEREVAN, December 18 — Armenian-Russian relations are strategic
and play a key role for Armenian security, Armenian Defence Minister
Serzh Sarkisyan said in his report “South Caucasus: issues of regional
security” during the debates organised by the Center of public dialogue
and development on Friday.
“Armenian-Russian military and technical cooperation meets Armenian
interests and is a reliable pledge of military security in the region,”
the minister emphasised. According to him, “the Russian military base
deployed in the republic demonstrates this.”
He noted that “the Armenian-Russian strategic union plays an
inestimable role in terms of reliable guarantees of security.”
Armenia is guided by this principle in its security policy in the
current military and political situation in the region.
“Armenian-Russian military cooperation provides for the needs of
the Armenian Armed Forces in armaments and staff, in military and
military-technical spheres, ensures Armenian military security and
keeping the balance of forces in the region,” the minister pointed out.

Cooperation with CSTO, NATO gives more security to Armenia

Cooperation with CSTO, NATO gives more security to Armenia
By Tigran Liloyan
ITAR-TASS News Agency
December 17, 2004 Friday
YEREVAN, December 17 — The accession to NATO is not on the current
foreign political agenda of Armenia, Defense Minister Serzh Sarkisyan
said at Friday debates organized by the Public Dialog and Development
Center.
He was speaking about regional security in the South Caucasus.
“At the same time, Armenia is realistic about regional security. It
does not make premature statements but develops cooperation with
the North Atlantic Alliance step by step,” the minister said. “In
this light relations with NATO have a serious role in the provision
of Armenian security. Finally, our country has chosen European
development, and NATO is a leading organization ensuring European
security.”
“Relations between Armenia and NATO will develop as long as there is
no contradiction between international commitments of the republic
to the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) and NATO,”
the minister said. “Cooperation in the CSTO and NATO is mutually
supplementary and gives additional security guarantees to Armenia
and the region at large,” he said.
“The CSTO Charter does not put limits on contacts with other countries
and international organizations,” the minister said. “Also, we think
that rapprochement between the CSTO and NATO in a number of issues
and common threats and tasks give us rather broad possibilities in
the development of relations with NATO,” he said.
“Relations with NATO do not have specific political goals, they are
developing naturally and are based on the need to neutralize dangers
and threats the country is facing,” Sarkisyan said.

With deal on Turkey in hand, Europe’s borders set to press into Asia

With deal on Turkey in hand, Europe’s borders set to press into Asia
Agence France Presse — English
December 18, 2004 Saturday 1:35 AM GMT
BRUSSELS Dec 18 — Barely seven months after its biggest ever
enlargement, the European Union has taken a bold step to push its
eastern-most borders deep into continental Asia’s western frontier
in Turkey.
After a bruising two days of summit haggling, and not a little
nail-biting, leaders of the 25 EU member states agreed terms to begin
EU accession talks with Ankara on October 3 next.
Then, on Friday, Turkey accepted its long-cherished invitation.
“We did not obtain all that we wanted 100 percent,” said Turkish
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, “but we can say that it was a
success… We have reached a point where Turkey is rewarded for 41
years of efforts.”
“We have been writing history today,” added Dutch Prime Minister
Jan Peter Balkenende, savouring success as his nation wraps up its
six-month turn at the rotating EU presidency.
He called the outcome — which EU leaders welcomed with a robust
round of applause — “an important and brave decision by Turkey,
by Cyprus and by the EU as a whole”.
Significantly, the European Union pledged Turkey nothing less than
full membership at the end of the process — and not a second-class
“partnership” as some skeptical EU members, led by Austria, proposed.
Accession talks, plus a raft of economic and political reforms to
bring Turkey closer to EU standards, are likely to run a decade or so.
So no one should expect to see Turkey as a bona fide European power
before 2015 or so.
When it does join, however, it will be the EU’s first predominantly
Muslim member state — and bring Europe’s political borders right up
to Iraq, Iran, Syria and the Caucasus states of Armenia, Azerbaijan
and Georgia.
The significance was not lost on British Prime Minister Tony Blair,
a staunch supporter of EU membership for NATO-member Turkey, which he
sees as a beacon of secularism and democracy for the wider Middle East.
“It shows that those who believe that there is some fundamental clash
of civilisations between Christians and Muslims are actually wrong,
that we can work together, that we can cooperate together,” he said.
The United States was delighted, too.
“Turkey’s full integration into the EU will be good for Europe and
the world. The announcement of accession talks brings this step closer
than ever,” said a White House spokesman.
Smiling for their own reasons Friday were ex-communist EU hopefuls
Bulgaria and Romania, who were told that they will sign accession
treaties in April next year, ahead of their planned entry in January
2007.
Croatia, born out of the violent break-up of the old Yugoslavia,
was meanwhile told it can start accession talks in March next year,
but under a strict condition — that it “fully cooperate” with the
UN war crimes tribunal.
Closing a deal with Turkey turned out harder than expected when a
rift emerged Friday over extending a 1963 customs protocol between
Ankara and the then European common market to include the 10 newest
EU member states, which joined last May 1.
One of the 10 is the ethnic Greek republic of Cyprus — a problem
because Turkey only recognises an ethnic Turkish statelet on the north
side of the Mediterranean island that it militarily helped to create
30 years ago.
Deft diplomacy meant that language in the final agreement was
rewritten to allow Turkey to promise that it will sign the protocol not
immediately, but sometime before the October 3 start of negotiations.
Cypriot President Tassos Papadopoulos said he was “satisfied”. But he
warned that once Turkey signs on the dotted line, it must fully live
up to its obligations under the protocol, which covers free movement
of people as well as goods.
“The implementation of the protocol is not only the commitment to
sign, but its (actual) implementation… If they don’t do it, simply,
they don’t start negotiations,” he said.

Turkey taken to task over Armenia

Turkey taken to task over Armenia
EuroNews – English Version
December 17, 2004
Braving bad weather, protesters have gathered in Brussels to urge
EU leaders to keep Ankara out of the club. That is because of the
importance of the “G” word – genocide – the term at the heart of a
bitter dispute.
For the demonstrators, Ottoman Turks committed nothing short of
systematicgenocide against the Armenian people.
They say up to 1.5 million lives were lost between 1915 and 1923 and
they want Turkey to recognize what happened, as such.
Ankara, however, sees things differently.
It admits that thousands of Turks and up to 300,000 Armenians died
in clashes but vehemently denies that genocide took place.
For one expert on Turkey at the Free University of Brussels, semantics
might be getting in the way.
“There were certainly more than a million dead in this massacre,”
says Robert Anciaux.
“But can we talk about genocide? For me, it is just a question of
words. It is something for historians to sort out.
“The problem is that the Turks must recognize that in some way there
was a massacre of Armenians.” But, for those whose ancestors were
caught up in the turmoil, acknowledging the full horror of what
happened is hugely important.
They say that long before Rwanda and the Holocaust, this was the
first genocide of the 20th century.

Armenia seeks to balance relations with Russia, NATO

Armenia seeks to balance relations with Russia, NATO
Associated Press Worldstream
December 18, 2004 Saturday 10:56 AM Eastern Time
YEREVAN, Armenia — Armenia wants to deepen its relations with NATO
but sees no alternative to its military alliance with Russia, at
least for the time being, the former Soviet republic’s defense and
security chief said Saturday.
“With the aim of creating a guaranteed security for Armenia, the
leadership of the country will continue focused work in various
directions,” Defense Minister Serzh Sarkisian, who is also secretary
of the country’s Security Council, said at a conference on regional
security attended by Armenian political leaders and foreign diplomats.
However, he said that “the Armenian-Russian military alliance has
no alternatives today” and that Armenia would develop relations with
NATO only up to the point of conflict with its obligations under the
Collective Security Treaty, a pact that links Russia with Armenia,
Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan.
Sarkisian said that at the moment Armenia sees no need to join NATO,
but he added that its ties with the Western alliance are tightening.
He said Armenia plans to take part in 50 NATO events and eight NATO
exercises next year – up from 47 and five, respectively, this year.
He said Armenia’s close ties with Russia won’t get in the way of its
efforts to integrate more closely with Europe.
Armenia, which hosts a Soviet-era military base, is Russia’s closest
ally in the Caucasus region, where Georgia is trying to shed Russian
influence and Azerbaijan – Armenia’s enemy – is courting the West
while seeking to maintain friendly relations with Moscow.
Russia’s parliament chairman recently called Armenia a Russian
outpost in the region, and Russian Defense Minister Sergei Ivanov
told foreign military attaches that Russia’s military presence in
ex-Soviet republics such as Armenia are a key element of security.