BAKU: EU official threatens sanctions if Azerbaijan goes to war

EU official threatens sanctions if Azerbaijan goes to war
Ekspress, Baku
5 Jan 05

A senior EU official has warned that sanctions may be imposed on
Azerbaijan and Armenia if the countries opt to resume hostilities. In
an exclusive interview with Azerbaijani newspaper Ekspress, an
official representative of the EU commission for security and conflict
settlement, Pierre Garton, said that the future integration of the two
Caucasus republics into Europe depends on the resolution of the
dispute over Azerbaijan’s breakaway region of Nagornyy Karabakh. He
also complained about what he thinks to be the “monopoly” of the OSCE
Minsk Group, a team of international mediators put in charge of
settling the conflict, and termed its activities as sterile. The
following is the text of Alakbar Raufoglu’s report by Azerbaijani
newspaper Ekspress on 5 January headlined “The EU will impose
sanctions if there is war” and subheaded “Pierre Garton: ‘Integration
of Azerbaijan and Armenia into Europe depends on the Karabakh issue'”;
subheadings are as published:
“If military operations resume in Nagornyy Karabakh, the European
Union may take tough steps against the two conflicting parties,” an
official representative of the EU commission for security and conflict
settlement and former rapporteur of the European Parliament
[Commission] on the South Caucasus, Swedish diplomat Pierre Garton,
said in an exclusive interview with Ekspress yesterday [4 January].
He said that Europe called on the leaders of Azerbaijan and Armenia in
1992 to freeze military hostilities. “Since these calls went unheard
then, certain restrictions were introduced to the two countries’
cooperation with the EU. These sanctions will be imposed on
Azerbaijan and Armenia again should there be any clashes on the front
line.”
What is Brussels concerned about?
The EU’s attitude to the Karabakh conflict remains unchanged. “We are
interested in continued dialogue between the two countries. The
conflict should be resolved peacefully. It concerns both Azerbaijan
and Armenia.”
Garton believes that the EU’s cooperation with Armenia and Azerbaijan
is now based on three factors: economic cooperation, the development
of democracy and a peaceful solution to the Nagornyy Karabakh
conflict. “We are having a close and balanced cooperation with both
countries and do not distinguish between them. But the parties to the
conflict often try to disrupt this balance,” the diplomat complained.
The EU’s high-ranking officials have recently visited both Azerbaijan
and Armenia to become familiar with the domestic situation here and
the settlement process. “We understand that the delay in the peace
talks is accompanied by certain tension in both countries. But it is
wrong to exaggerate this concern as if it could lead to war, and this
seriously worries us. At the same time we regret the fact that
Azerbaijan and Armenia have failed to officially appeal to the
European Union for mediation.”
The EU’s main concern is that calls for war are being made in the
conflicting countries at a time when peace talks are under way. “It
undermines the dialogue. The situation should be duly evaluated and
these occurrences should be eliminated.”
Armenian Defence Minister Serzh Sarkisyan did not rule out a military
option in the Karabakh settlement at a briefing in Moscow last
week. He said that “if the limits of negotiations are depleted, the
tension that will follow may provoke military operations.”
Monopolist co-chairmen
Garton believes that the takeover of the “mediation monopoly” in the
Karabakh talks by the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairmen restricts active
involvement of other European entities in the issue. “This problem can
only be eliminated with joint efforts of the international
community. Someone’s reigning the process will not bear fruit. The
conflicting countries do not seem to have understood this
necessity. They may be thinking that if there are other mediators, the
Minsk Group will dodge its mandate. But its activity is sterile
anyway. In a settlement everything depends on the parties. It is not
possible to lead the parties to peace with one [mediating] party.”
Liberating five districts still on agenda
Touching upon the proposals the EU has made on the Karabakh settlement
to date, Garton said that “the fate of those ideas shows that acting
as a mediator, which is outside intervention in the process, is
difficult and ineffective”. “The EU possesses more possibilities and
leverage to solve the Karabakh problem.”
If so, why does the EU not back up its proposals such as five
districts [Armenian-occupied districts around Nagornyy Karabakh] in
exchange for railway communications or other solution models and put
pressure on Yerevan to ensure their implementation?
The refusal to accept the EU’s solution options does not mean that it
will not provide new proposals for a Karabakh solution, Garton
said. Simply, Europe “thinks it is better not to increase the number
of solution models which are being disputed by the parties and
remaining on paper”.
“Moreover, the liberation of five districts is still on the agenda,”
the rapporteur said.
Saying that Armenia’s position in the negotiation process “is
explained with rather heavy arguments”, Garton refused to call that
country “non-constructive”. “It would imply putting [the blame for]
the failure of the talks on one party. It can be just considered that
Yerevan’s position in the peaceful settlement requires more
concessions than Azerbaijan’s.”
Conflict can be resolved in 12 months
Garton also said that the EU’s increasing activity in the Karabakh
settlement is the main priority of the union’s future performance,
since Azerbaijan and Armenia have been included into Europe’s New
Neighbourhood programme and integration of both countries into the EU
depends on Karabakh.
“Negotiations will start with Ankara in 2005 on Turkey’s integration
into the EU, thus bringing the borders of Europe closer to
Azerbaijan. As for the EU, it does not want problems like Karabakh to
persist in territories close to Europe,” he said.
“I hope that the conflict will not last for another 12 years. Armenia
and Azerbaijan have already demanded that the [Minsk Group]
co-chairmen should increase their efforts. It builds up confidence
that the Minsk Group will increase activity and the conflict will be
resolved in 12 months.”
Baku is optimistic
Commenting on the EU representative’s statements to Ekspress,
Azerbaijani Deputy Foreign Minister Araz Azimov said: “The EU is our
strategic partner and supports Baku’s position in the settlement
process. We are optimistic about war. Naturally, Azerbaijan has never
promised to observe eternal peace. Even in Europe it is not ruled out
that military operations may resume if the peace talks fail.”

Armenia Maybe of Less Importance for Russia, A Russian Analyst Says

ARMENIA MAYBE OF LESS IMPORTANCE FOR RUSSIA, A RUSSIAN ANALYST SAYS
YEREVAN, JANUARY 17. ARMINFO. In return for Russia’s support, Armenian
President Robert Kocharyan expresses readiness to further favor the
strengthening of Russian economic presence in Armenia, writes Gennadiy
Sisoyev in his article in the Russian newspaper “Kommersant.”
In his words, in the establishment of relations with Yerevan, Russia
actively used the interest of President Robert Kocharyan in the
political support of Moscow in connection with activation of the
Armenian opposition after “rose revolution” in Georgia. The author
writes that in the course of implementation of the bilateral agreement
“Property for Debt,” the main part of power capacities of Armenia were
transferred under control of Russia (80% of energy generation in
Armenia). The Armenian monopolist in the sphere of gas, “ArmRosgasprom,”
is also controlled by Russian structures. And finally, the author
writes, full packages of shares of a number of enterprises of the
defense complex of Armenia have been transferred to Russia. Armenia’s
importance as a major strategic partner of Russia in the Transcaucasus
may considerably decrease if Moscow fails to maintain its influence on
Georgia, the analyst says.
He said that although the relations between Moscow and the new
authorities of Georgia overcame the phase of tension at the end of
2004, they are still unsatisfactory. As regards the relations with
Azerbaijan, the author says that the Kremlin is concerned that Aliyev
Jr. may correct the balanced policy of his father in direction of
closer cooperation with the West in order that Azerbaijan receives the
role of the regional leader. The author says that official Moscow is
dissatisfied that Baku avoids conclusion of a long-term agreement with
Russia on oil transit to supply the whole Caspian oil through the
pipeline BTC via Georgia and Turkey. Besides, Moscow is concerned over
lack of process in the sphere of military and technical cooperation
with Baku and suspects the new authorities of Azerbaijan in the secret
intention to change over to western standards of armament.

Yerevan Intends to Regulate Street Trading Within 2 Month

ARMENIAN MUNICIPALITY INTENDS TO REGULATE ISSUE OF STREET TRADING
WITHIN 2 MONTHS
YEREVAN, JANUARY 17. ARMINFO. Regulation of the issue of street
trading requires some 2 months, Vice Mayor of Yerevan Arman Sahakyan
said at a briefing, Monday.
He said that street trading in Yerevan was banned starting from
January 14, 2005. In connection with New Year and Christmas shopping,
Yerevan authorities allowed street trading during the holidays.
Already on January 7, there were notices prohibiting street trading at
all the shops. Relevant words are currently in process in the
communities of Center, Shengavit, Kanaker-Zeitun. Sahakyan assessed
these works as satisfactory. Representatives of municipality, local
prefectures and police participate in the works.
As regards mini-markets created in the spring of 2004, Sahakyan said
that they have justified themselves only by 30-40%. According to
traders, the mini-markets are not located in crowed areas, so they
prefer trading in the streets. To note, daily payment for a trading
point at mini-markets is some 500-2000 AMD, which is by 10-15% lower
than the payment for a place at markets. In response to the question
of ARMINFO’s correspond concerning the guarantees that street trading
will not be launched again after a time, Sahakyan said that this issue
will be strictly controlled by the municipality and the police.

FM and League of Arab States to Sign MOU in Cairo

ARMENIAN FOREIGN MINISTRY AND LEAGUE OF ARAB STATES TO SIGN MEMORANDUM
OF MUTUAL UNDERSTANDING IN CAIRO
YEREVAN, JANUARY 17. ARMINFO. Armenian Foreign Minister Vardan
Oskanyan will leave for Egypt on January 18.
The Public Relations Office of the Armenian Foreign Ministry told
ARMINFO that the major goal of Vardan Oskanyan’s visit to Cairo is
signing of a Memorandum of Mutual Understanding between the Armenian
Foreign Ministry and the Chief Secretariat of the League of Arab
States. This document will factually provide Armenia with a status of
an observer at the League of Arab States, the source reports.
The same day, Minister Oskanyan will meet his Egyptian colleague Ahmed
Abul Gheit. In the course of his visit, Vardan Oskanyan will meet
Secretary General of the League of Arab States Abu Musai and Minister
for International Cooperation of Egypt, Head of the Intergovernmental
Commission of Armenian-Egyptian Cooperation on the Egyptian party
Faiza Abul Naga.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenian president raises pensions of disabled servicemen

Armenian president raises pensions of disabled servicemen
Arminfo
17 Jan 05

YEREVAN
Armenian President Robert Kocharyan signed a decree on 15 January on
making changes to the law on social security of servicemen and their
families, the Armenian president’s press service has told Arminfo.
The decree envisages a 20-per-cent rise in pensions of the servicemen
who incurred different degrees of disability while defending the
borders of the republic and of the families of killed servicemen.
The decree also suggests that the compensation paid to disabled
servicemen for public utilities be raised from 3,000 drams [6 dollars]
to 5,000 drams [10 dollars] starting from 1 January 2005 and funeral
expenses be covered by the state should they die. In connection with
the rise in servicemen’s social security payments, it is planned to
allocate another 350m drams [700,000 dollars] from the state budget.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Russian DM Urges Allies to Preserve Unified Military Training System

Russian defence minister urges allies to preserve unified military
training system
RIA news agency
17 Jan 05
MOSCOW
Russia intends to spare no effort to preserve the unified system of
military training both within the framework of the ODKB [Collective
Security Treaty Organization, comprising Russia, Belarus, Armenia,
Tajikistan, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan] and with Kazakhstan in
particular, Russian Defence Minister Sergey Ivanov told journalists
after the Kazakh Dostyk order was presented to him.
“This award is an advance recognition of my modest contribution to the
cause of strengthening military cooperation between Russia and
Kazakhstan,” he said. According to the minister, he often meets his
Kazakh counterpart [Mukhtar Altynbayev] to discuss ways to step up
security.
Sergey Ivanov said an ODKB treaty under which prices for arms
deliveries are determined by Russia’s domestic prices came into force
in January 2005. “Russia will spare no efforts to ensure that the
unified system of military training is preserved,” Sergey Ivanov said.

Ever Farther from Moscow

KOMMERSANT Dengi, JANUARY 17, 2005

Ever Farther from Moscow
Last year started with the presidential elections in Georgia and ended
with the third round of elections in Ukraine. Moscow looked at the CIS
with fixed attention all year and tried to prop up its waning
influence, while the former Soviet countries came closer and closer to
replacing their political elites.
Ukraine
The most important events for all of the CIS probably were those that
took place in Ukraine. The opposition, headed by Viktor Yushchenko,
accused the authorities of falsifying the results of the second round
of the presidential election on November 21, and called out hundreds
of thousands of people to the streets. The West backed the
opposition’s demands, as did all influential international
organizations. The Ukrainian government, which had already declared
its candidate, Viktor Yanukovich, the winner, was forced go to back on
its word. The Supreme Court nullified the second round of elections
and set a revote for December 26. At the moment when this went to
press, the results of that vote were not yet known, but we have
guessed it has opened the way for Yushchenko and marked the beginning
of a change in that country’s political elite.
The crisis in Ukraine was a serious setback for Russia’s position in
that country and all the CIS. Moscow had set all its hope on
government candidate Yanukovich. Putin himself even came to campaign
for him and had congratulated him twice on his victory. That has
complicated Moscow’s chances for normal relations with the new
political powers in Ukraine and alarmed the elite in all the former
Soviet republics.
Moldova
Russian-Moldovan relations took a heavy chill at the end of 2003 when
Moldovan President Vladimir Voronin refused to sign off on the
Kremlin’s proposal for regulating the internal conflicts in that
country. Their differences were not overcome in 2004. Voronin pointed
ignored almost all CIS activities and made efforts to improve his
country’s relations with the West. That course was also dictated by
Voronin’s attempts to withstand a quickly growing opposition that is
longing for a revolution of roses along the lines of Georgia’s.
Voronin’s westward turn has not strengthened his political position,
however, and the opposition sees big opportunities in this year’s
parliamentary elections.
Kazakhstan
Although relations between Moscow and Astana remain superficially
cheerful, Russian for the first time last year addressed lengthy
criticism to its key ally. This happened during Putin’s visit to
Astana in January. The main complaint from Moscow was about
Kazakhstan’s increasingly pro-Western orientation, especially in the
military and fuel realms, and the exclusion of the Russian-speaking
population of Kazakhstan from political and public life. Putin made it
clear to his Kazakh counterpart Nursultan Nazarbaev that relations
between their countries would be seriously complicated if those
problems continued.
A change of the political elite is Kazakhstan is looking ever more
likely. In spite of the seemingly solid victory of the
pro-presidential Otan party in September’s parliamentary elections,
Nazarbaev cannot feel completely secure. Western pressure to create
true democratic conditions is growing, the opposition is uniting and
the ruling party is divided. This last fact became glaringly obvious
when speaker Zharmkhan Tuyakbay mutinied, accusing the government of
falsifying the vote and becoming the leader of the opposition.
Belarus
Moscow’s discontent with Aleksandr Lukashenko’s Belarus is mounting as
well. The discord is mainly economic. Last fall, Lukashenko publicly
confirmed that there would be no common Russian-Belarusian currency,
which Moscow was pushing for. Lukashenko has still not ratified
documents passed by his parliament to give Russia property rights to
oil pipelines crossing Belarusian territory and he hasn’t been
cooperative about gas lines either.
There are been talk recently to the effect that Moscow has begun
examining Belarusian politicians in search of a successor to Poppa
Lukashenko, one more pliable and less repulsive. So, even though
Lukashenko was given the right to hold a third, fourth, fifth (and so
on) term in the referendum held in October, his future is still less
than rosy. This is even more so since the United States stated openly
for the first time at the end of the summer that it will make efforts
to remove the authoritarian Belarusian from power.
Georgia
The year 2004 began with presidential elections in Georgia, in which
Mikhail Saakashvili rode the tide of change to a victory with more
than 90 percent of the vote.
Relations between Moscow and the new powers in Tbilisi had overcome
their initial tension by the end of the year, but remain
unsatisfactory nonetheless. And they are far from any agreement on the
conditions under which they can normalize their relations. In Tbilisi,
they are insisting on absolute equality between partners in deciding
what compromises to make about what. Moscow agrees in general that
compromise should be mutual, but wants to make them with a view to the
actual situation: Georgia has more problems than Russia has, it should
be the more cooperative. Moscow’s hope for the destabilization of the
new government in Tbilisi didn’t pan out. Saakashvili is holding fast.
Moscow informed Tbilisi of its views on their bilateral problems in
the first half of last year. In October, Tbilisi responded, much to
Moscow’s displeasure. The Kremlin was especially annoyed with two
points: the demand that Russia close its military bases in Georgia by
January 1, 2006, and that the peacekeeping operations in South Ossetia
and Abkhazia be transferred to UN or OSCE control. Those operations
are now being overseen by Russia. These key issues that are holding up
the signing of an agreement on relations between the two states.
Armenia
Russia has been taking advantage of Armenian President Robert
Kocharyan’s need for its support. After the affairs in Georgian took
the course they did, the opposition in Armenia was vitiated. In April,
Kocharyan faced the most serious challenge from the opposition that he
has seen while in office. The government had to use force to break up
protests. Even though the situation was brought under control, the
president’s associates are concerned that that is not the last move by
the opposition.
In exchange for Russian support, Kocharyan has expressed his readiness
to increase that country’s economic presence in Armenia. Russia
received the bigger part of the Armenian energy sector in an agreement
to write off Armenian debt and now controls about 80 percent of
Armenia’s electricity production. Armrosgazprom, the Armenian natural
gas monopoly is also controlled by Russian structures. And Russia has
received stock packages in a number of Armenian defense enterprises.
However, Armenia’s significance as Russia’s strategic ally in the
Transcaucasus will be substantially diminished if Russia loses its
influence in Georgia.
Azerbaijan
Moscow made efforts to establish relations with Azerbaijan’s new
president Ilkham Aliev last year. The Kremlin is concerned that Aliev
Junior will lean further toward the West than his father had in order
to make Azerbaijan a regional leader. Moscow is unhappy that
Azerbaijan has avoided making a long-term on oil transit with it and
will in the future send its oil down the Baky – Tbilisi – Ceyhan
pipeline, that is, across Georgia to Turkey. Moscow is also concerned
about the lack of progress in military and technical cooperation with
Baku and suspects the new leadership of secret intentions to go over
to Western armament standards. These suspicions were confirmed by
Azerbiajan’s announcement of its plans to step up its integration into
NATO and its willingness to allow NATO military bases on its territory.
During Ilkham Aliev’s visit to Moscow in February, he was offered the
alternative of strengthening military ties with Russia, with close
ties with Russian forces and a place in the CIS Antiterrorism Center.
Baku has yet to give a firm answer. That is partially because Ilkham
Aliev has yet to consolidate his forces fully within the country.
Tajikistan
Russia was able to establish satisfactory relations with this
strategic CIS ally only at the end of the year. Before Putin’s visit
to Dushanbe in October, Tajikistani President Emomali Rakhmonov had
been hinting that Russia’s rent-free military base in Tajikistan was
no longer acceptable and that the Russians needed to open up their
wallet according to the example set by the generous Americans.
Dushanbe further demanded ownership of the Nurek space tracking
station, so that it could then rent it back to Russia. Moscow got the
picture. Tajikistan had decided to make some money off the Russian
military’s presence there, and good money at that. The Kremlin reacted
badly to that and began to think up strong countermeasures.
Setbacks in trade with the United States and fear of facing his
American-backed opposition alone made Rakhmonov think again about
relations with Moscow. During Putin’s visit to Dushanbe, an agreement
was signed giving the Russian military base legal status, turning
Nurek over to Russia in exchange for a debt write-off, finishing the
Sangtudin Hydroelectric Plant (with Tajikistan’s $50 million state
debt to Russia reinvested in the plant in the form of Russian-owned
stock) and the introduction of Russian border guards into Tajikistan.
Kyrgyzstan
Russian relations with this Central Asian state, like everything else
there, passed the year without strong jolts. The Kyrgyzstani
opposition is preparing for the presidential elections scheduled for
2005, and Kyrgyzstani President Askar Akaev has repeatedly stated that
he will not run for another term in office. During Akaev’s November
visit to Moscow, Akaev agreed to turn the most profitable parts of his
country’s military-industrial complex to Russia against its
$180-million debt to Russia. About the only stumbling block left in
Russian-Kyrgyz relations is the American plan to station several
American Air Force AWACs near Manas Airport. Moscow sees that as a
violation of Bishkek’s military and political obligations to it as
part of the Collective Security Agreement Organization.
Uzbekistan
Uzbekistani President Islam Karimov was badly shaken by the major
terrorist acts there in March and July 2004. He broke up his moderate,
liberal opposition several years ago, only to see a radical opposition
fill the vacuum. Karimov remains true to his motto, Better a hundred
arrested than a thousand killed. His intelligence agents conduct mass
arrests. It’s either me or the terrorists, and if I go, the Islamists
come in, the argument goes, although it is not too convincing. That is
why his position is looking shakier.
Karimov is reserved in his relations with Moscow. He doesn’t want to
spoil them, although he is also playing making advance to Washington,
which is interested in strengthening its position in Central Asia.
Turkmenistan
Turkmenistan, headed by Saparmurat Niyazov, is a model of stability.
Two years ago, Turkmenbashi crushed the opposition. But Niyazov is
still not completely calm. In February, a book appeared in the stores
of Turkmenistan entitled My Accomplices and I Are Terrorists, written
by former minister of foreign affairs Boris Shikhuradov, who has been
sentenced to life imprisonment for attempting a coup d’etat. In the
book, the former opposition leader tells how a a bunch of renegades
organized an assassination attempt on the great Turkmenbashi. Many in
Ashkhabad, and in the West too, have doubts about the authenticity of
the authorship of the strange confessional. Turkmenbashi has also
taken steps toward liberalization. In January, exit visas were
eliminated in Turkmenistan. That was seen as a gesture to Moscow,
whose support he is counting on if the United States should turn up
its pressure on Niyazov. Making it easier to leave the country is most
of all to the advantage of the ethnic Russians living there.
by Evegeny Sysoev
Russian Article as of Jan. 10, 2005
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenian president amends law on parties

Armenian president amends law on parties
Arminfo
17 Jan 05
YEREVAN
Armenian President Robert Kocharyan signed a decree on 15 January on
making changes to the law on political parties, the Armenian
president’s press service has told Arminfo.
The decree is aimed at stimulating the process of enlarging
parties. In particular, it says that a party should have no less than
2,000 members, including no less than 100 members in every district.
Under the law, the currently functioning parties should meet the
requirements outlined in the amendments to the law within a year after
they take effect.
Sixty-five parties have been registered with Armenia’s Ministry of
Justice so far.

Wholesale petrol prices rise in Armenia

Wholesale petrol prices rise in Armenia
Arminfo
17 Jan 05
YEREVAN
One of Armenia’s largest companies trading in oil, Flash, has raised
wholesale petrol prices by five points and reduced wholesale diesel
prices by the same amount.
The Flash limited liability company told Arminfo today that a litre of
Regular-91 petrol is being offered for 275-280 drams [55-56 cents],
Premium-95 for 285-290 drams [57-58 cents], Super-98 for 305-310 drams
[61-62 cents] and diesel oil for 238-245 drams [48 cents] at its
wholesale points.
Petrol and diesel fuel prices at Flash’s filling stations have not
changed. In particular, a litre of Regular-91 costs 290 drams [58
cents], Premium-95 320 drams [64 cents] and diesel oil 250 drams [50
cents].

BAKU: Azeri politician says forthcoming elections to be democratic

Azeri politician says forthcoming elections to be democratic
Yeni Musavat, Baku
17 Jan 05

I can see no progress in Azerbaijani-Armenian talks on the Nagornyy
Karabakh settlement, Eldar Namazov, president of the public forum For
Azerbaijan, has said.
“I believe that the continuing negotiations are a well-thought-out
game of the authorities of the two sides. Azerbaijan and Armenia have
always intensified talks ahead of elections,” Namazov said in an
interview with Azerbaijani Yeni Musavat newspaper.
They want others to believe that they are close to striking a peace
deal. But after elections are rigged, it emerges that there was no
deal whatsoever, the politician said.
But Namazov said he could see very serious positive changes in
society. I am confident that democratic forces will unite ahead of the
parliamentary elections this year, he noted.
“Opposition parties, NGOs, business people and the intelligentsia
agree that democratic changes are inevitable. Everyone understands
that the only way out of the current situation in the country is to
establish democratic principles and hold free and fair elections,” the
politician told the newspaper.
Namazov stressed that the processes in Georgia and Ukraine were not
accidental. He said he believed that democratic elections would be
eventually conducted in all former Soviet republics, including
Azerbaijan.