OSCE Minsk Group Mission Visiting Qarvatchar

OSCE MINSK GROUP MISSION VISITING QARVATCHAR
Azg/arm
01 Feb 05
The OSCE Minsk group co-chars accompanied by OSCE monitoring mission
left Stepanakert for Qarvatchar region yesterday morning. This region,
Qelbajar as Azeris called it, belonged to Soviet Azerbaijan but today
is supervised by Nagorno Karabakh forces. The monitoring mission
visited several villages ofQ arvatchar as well as the region’s
center. The mission headed by German ambassador Emily Haber includes
10 members some of who are well-informed about Karabakh
issue. Mrs. Haber spent few years in German embassy to Ankara and was
the head of OSCE Division First Counselor Federal Foreign Office. The
OSCE Minsk group co-chairs are accompanying the monitoring mission in
Qarvatchar but they are not engaged in fact-finding. They are
observing the territories whereas the monitoring group is visiting
every house asking people where they came from, who brought them there
and whether the state supports them. Questions from an enquirer are
supposed to unveil the background of the settlers.
Answering daily Azg’s question as to what the mission’s goal is,
Mrs. Haber said that they will travel across territories that are
administratively outof Nagorno Karabakh and are under the Armenians’
control, will monitorand apparently will report on the situation to
the Minsk group in 1-2 months. Ihad the impression that Russian and
American co-chairs, Yuri Merzlyakov and Steven Mann, were not
enthusiastic about visiting the territories. They think thatsuch steps
change the issue’s direction. Supposedly, they mean that Azerbaijan is
more concerned with secondary issues instead of trying to find a
solution for the conflict.
On their way to Qarvatchar from Stepanakert the OSCE mission halted at
Dadivank, this medieval pearl of Armenian architecture, and put a
candle (the thought that this Armenian monastery and the whole
territory was once introduced as Azeri made me edgy).
The route from Stepanakert to Qarvatchar takes few hours but the
monitoring mission kept on in radio-equipped vehicles when one of
Karabakh representatives was telling stories from Karabakh war. We
were passing through territories that were under Azeri military’s
control in 1992, and the ruined settlements stood as witnesses of the
past war. They saw settlements notable for the Azeris atrocities when
40 percent of Karabakh was under their control. Vasili Nalbandian,
head of Qarvatchar region’s administration, was tellingthe mission
that he lost his home at the other side of Mrav mountain and moved to
Qarvatchar having no other place to go.
Having spent all day in Qarvatchar the mission will go south in the
direction of Iranian border to see other territories under Karabakh’s
control. It is supposed that they will stay there 7-10 days trying to
get the overall picture of the region. The mission is armed with
documents from Azerbaijan with indication of regions and settlements
that Armenia is allegedly inhabiting on state level.
Though we didn’t witness mission members’ talks with the local
population, I have the impression from what I heard that 99 percent of
refugees are from Shahumian, Getashen and other parts of Azerbaijan. I
want to remind that the mission’s visit to these regions was
Azerbaijan’s initiative.
By Tatoul Hakobian in Qarvatchar

Defence Spending Tops Armenia’s 2004 Budget

DEFENCE SPENDING TOPS ARMENIA’S 2004 BUDGET
Arminfo, Yerevan
31 Jan 05
YEREVAN
The biggest portion of Armenia’s budget expenditure in 2004 (2.8 per
cent of the GDP) fell to defence, Arminfo has learnt from the Armenian
National Statistics Service.
According to the source, compared to 2003, defence spending grew by
18.4 per cent and totalled 52,476m drams (106m dollars).
(Passage omitted: education spending)

BAKU: Azeri Analyst Hits Out at CoE Reporter’s “Dual” Statement

AZERI ANALYST HITS OUT AT COUNCIL OF EUROPE REPORTER’S “DUAL” STATEMENT
Yeni Musavat, Baku
29 Jan 05
An Azeri political analyst has said that the rapporteur of the
Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe on Nagornyy Karabakh
is performing a balancing act between Azerbaijan and Armenia. In
remarks to opposition daily Yeni Musavat, Rasim Musabayov said that
David Atkinson is using “a dual language of traditional European
policy in order to preserve balance”. Musabayov also called on
Azerbaijan to pursue a “flexible” policy on Nagornyy Karabakh and not
to dramatize the situation. The following is the text of Elsad
Pasasoy’s report by the Azerbaijani newspaper Yeni Musavat on 29
January headlined “Atkinson’s ‘dual language’ statement” and subheaded
“Rasim Musabayov: ‘It is not a tragedy to start negotiations with
Karabakh Armenians'”; subheadings have been inserted editorially:
Apart from commendable points in the resolution of the Parliamentary
Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE), there are some provisions
that could upset Azerbaijan. These are the recognition of the right of
Armenians in Nagornyy Karabakh to self-determination and the
recommendation that Azerbaijan “should start negotiations without any
conditions” with them.
No self-determination for Karabakh
Guided by these factors, Armenia’s official propaganda tells its
people not to worry and claims that the passed resolution will not be
that bad for Yerevan and Karabakh’s Armenians. Some statements by the
PACE rapporteur on Nagornyy Karabakh, David Atkinson, alleviate
Azerbaijani concerns, but, on the other hand, the tip of the iceberg
can be seen in an issue threatening our country. Thus, Atkinson’s
statement that “the principle of ‘the right of nations to
self-determination’ cannot be applied to the Karabakh issue” was a
kind of cold shower in winter for those who claim (setting up) the
“Nagornyy Karabakh Republic”. The rapporteur stressed that any changes
to borders can be possible with the mutual consent of the parties. He
also added that Azerbaijan will never agree to the independence of
Nagornyy Karabakh. He stressed that “the CE and other international
organizations cannot recognize the independence of Nagornyy
Karabakh. Therefore, the right of nations to self-determination cannot
be applied to Karabakh.”
“Preserving balance”
However, the second part of Atkinson’s statement gives grounds for
concern. “We are expecting the Azerbaijani government to start
establishing contacts with representatives of Nagornyy Karabakh and
discussing the problem with them following the adoption of the
resolution.”
As may be seen, the officials are hastily drawing official Baku,
without giving it any chance to enjoy the PACE resolution, in
negotiations with the regime they called “separatist”.
Political analyst Rasim Musabayov believes that Atkinson is speaking
in a dual language of traditional European policy in order to preserve
balance.
“On the one hand, he says he does not recognize the right of
(Karabakh) Armenians to self-determination, but on the other hand he
calls on Azerbaijan to negotiate with Karabakh’s Armenians. But, the
Karabakh Armenians want independence. What is there to discuss with
them in this case?”
“Frame”
Yet, the political analyst says it is necessary to note an innovation
in the resolution.
“They had been saying for many years to “go and negotiate with
Karabakh’s Armenians” and that “we support Azerbaijan’s territorial
integrity including Karabakh”. But they had been trying not to call
Armenia an occupier and the Karabakh regime separatist. Now they are
saying that and it is positive factor”.
This assessment shows the Armenians a framework. “They want to say
that this is the way to peace. Otherwise, you would not be able to go
beyond the framework. Because Azerbaijan will never recognize your
independence and you are exposing your people to difficulties by
prolonging time.”
“No tragedy”
The expert does not see the condition for Azerbaijan to negotiate with
Karabakh’s Armenians as a tragedy.
“In fact, we have never said that we do not want to negotiate with
Karabakh’s Armenians. We have said that we want to talk about the
status, but only after the liberation of the occupied territories. I
do not think it is a tragedy to have contacts on any level with
them. It is not imperative that (Azerbaijani President) Ilham Aliyev
negotiates with (leader of Karabakh separatists) Arkadiy Gukasyan
face-to-face. The negotiations can be held on a lower level. We can
sit and listen to the Armenians”.
No negotiations between communities
Musabayov says there is no need for holding negotiations between the
Azerbaijani and Armenian communities (of Nagornyy Karabakh).
“The Armenians in Karabakh have problems not with the Azerbaijani
community, but with the Azerbaijani government. I do not believe that
any talks with Karabakh’s Armenians could yield results. If Kocharyan,
a person who has done all this and controls the occupied territories,
is the president of Armenia, it is no use expecting anything from
Karabakh’s Armenians. We have been negotiating with the Armenians for
10 years and we cannot start negotiations with Karabakh’s Armenians
now. But we should not be afraid of any contacts. It does not mean
recognizing Karabakh as a party to negotiations.”
Non-constructive party
He also touched on the experience of neighbouring countries. “The
Georgian government is negotiating with the unrecognized Abkhaz and
Ossetian leaders. The Moldovan president opts for negotiations with
the concocted structure in Dniester (region of Moldova). We must not
dramatize the situation. We need to pursue quite a flexible policy
here. We must take steps for the opposite party to be seen as wrong
and non-constructive. In the end, either the non-constructive party
will came under pressure, or the international community will
understand that we have taken all steps, but the Armenians have not
come to common sense.”
In that case, there will not be a serious obstacle to Azerbaijan
resorting to a military way (of resolving the conflict), he said.

Georgia Accuses Russia Of Delaying Tank Repair Plant Handover

GEORGIA ACCUSES RUSSIA OF DELAYING TANK REPAIR PLANT HANDOVER
Rustavi-2 TV, Tbilisi
31 Jan 05
(Presenter) The Russian tank repair plant (in Tbilisi) still belongs
to its old owner. Russia was supposed to have the plant handed over to
Georgia on 30 January, but the Russians are not in a hurry.
The plant, which is situated in Moskovis Avenue, is used as a service
centre for equipment belonging to the Russian and Armenian armed
forces.
The Defence Ministry says that Russia has failed to meet its
obligations.
(Davit Sikharulidze, deputy defence minister) As in all other cases,
in this specific case the Georgian side has honoured all its
obligations. As I said before, unlike all other civilized countries,
this is how you negotiate with Russia: first, you need to make a lot
of effort to agree with it about something and sign a document, but
then you need to do even more to make sure that this document is
implemented.

US May Use Armenian Genocide to Pressure Turkey in Iraqi Issue

US MAY USE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE TO PRESSURE TURKEY IN IRAQI ISSUE
YEREVAN, JANUARY 31. ARMINFO. The US may use the Armenian Genocide as
a trump for pressuring Turkey in the issue of Iraq, says Milliyet
(Turkey).
This concern is due to the 2005 commemoration of the 90th anniversary
of the Armenian Genocide in Armenia and many countries and to the fact
that many European parliaments are considering the Armenian Genocide
recognition. Especially worrisome is the statement by a European
ambassador that Condoleeza Rice may be not very much included to
prevent initiatives for the Armenian Genocide acknowledgement unlike
the previous US state secretary and that “Washington may wish to use
the problem to pressure Turkey in the Iraqi issue.”
The Turkish FM is sensing a potential problem here. Ankara is taking
no step without considering the Armenian Genocide problem. The
Institute of Turkish History is preparing a series of articles on the
issue. Historian Betul Aslan has published a book entitled “The
Armenian Events in Erzurum” which is one more attempt to mislead the
international community. In fact Aslan is trying to prove that 50,000
Turks were killed in Erzurum and neighboring areas in 1918-1920.
Milliyet regrets that the May 2005 Vienna conference of Armenian and
Turkish historians will not take place because of Armenia’s refusal.

Iran Advocates Armenian-Azeri Cooperation

IRAN ADVOCATES ARMENIAN-AZERI COOPERATION
YEREVAN, JANUARY 31. ARMINFO. Iran’s Ambassador to Azerbaijan Afshar
Sumeymani has supported the statement by his counterpart to Russia
Gulam Rza Shafai that the involvement of Azerbaijan and Armenia in the
North-South transport corridor will promote Azeri-Armenian
rapprochement.
Suleymani says that the restoration of the railroad communication
between Iran and Russia via Julfa, Nakhichevan Autonomous Republic,
will play an important role for ensuring the region’s secure economic
development. Iran advocates peace and cooperation in the region and
the Kazvin-Resht-Astara section of the North-South transport corridor
will give wider transit opportunities to Azerbaijan and Armenia while
the whole project will promote the development of their transport
infrastructures.
To remind, the Yerevan (Armenia)-Julfa (Azerbaijan)-Tebriz (Iran)
railroad was stalled in 1992 because of the Karabakh conflict. In the
Soviet times it carried 5 mln tons of cargo a year.

Armenia Sets No Conditions For Diplomatic Ties With Turkey

ARMENIA SETS NO CONDITIONS FOR DIPLOMATIC TIES WITH TURKEY, DIPLOMAT SAYS
Mediamax news agency
31 Jan 05
YEREVAN
Armenian Prime Minister Andranik Markaryan met French President
Jacques Chirac, Lithuanian Prime Minister Algirdas Brazauskas and
Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul on 27-28 January during a
ceremony to mark the 60th anniversary of the liberation of the
Auschwitz concentration camp.
This was announced at a briefing today by Armenian Deputy Foreign
Minister Ruben Shugaryan, who accompanied the prime minister during
his visit to Poland.
At a brief meeting with the Turkish foreign minister, Andranik
Markaryan confirmed Armenia’s readiness to establish diplomatic
relations with Turkey without any conditions, Ruben Shugaryan said.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Karabakh Leader Confirms Armenian Refugees Settled in Azeri Lands

KARABAKH LEADER CONFIRMS ARMENIAN REFUGEES SETTLED IN AZERI LANDS
Arminfo
31 Jan 05
YEREVAN
Yesterday evening the president of Nagornyy Karabakh, Arkadiy
Gukasyan, met Emily Margarethe Haber (from Germany), head of the OSCE
fact-finding mission, and also the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs, Yuriy
Merzlyakov from Russia; Steven Mann from the USA and Bernard Fassier
from France.
Gukasyan stressed the importance of the OSCE initiative to visit the
territories currently controlled by the Karabakh government, the
information department of the Karabakh president has told Arminfo. He
said Stepanakert had repeatedly appealed to the OSCE co-chairs to
carry out this kind of monitoring in order to get familiarized with
the real situation in the territories to rule out all Azerbaijani
insinuations on the issue.
Regarding the current situation in the territories which make up a
security strip for Nagornyy Karabakh to be monitored by the OSCE
mission, Gukasyan said the Karabakh government has no state programme
to settle those territories. He said that the Armenians who had been
forcibly expelled from Azerbaijan were mainly living there. The
activities of the state in those territories are limited to providing
the people with normal living conditions and establishing appropriate
controls there, he said.
Gukasyan said that the Nagornyy Karabakh authorities are ready to do
their utmost to help the mission fulfil its work and expressed the
hope that the report the mission will prepare will help create a
constructive atmosphere for resolving the Karabakh conflict
peacefully. In order to get a bigger picture of the situation,
Gukasyan suggested that the OSCE mission visit Nagornyy Karabakh’s
territories that are under the occupation of the Azerbaijani army.
In turn, Ms Haber thanked the Karabakh government for providing the
10-day-long mission with necessary conditions. She said that the
mission will make no political assessments as it is mainly technical
by nature.
Andrzej Kasprzyk, special envoy of the OSCE chairman-in-office, also
attended the meeting.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

BAKU: Opp. Activist Accuses Russia, France of Pro-Armenian Stand

AZERI OPPOSITION ACTIVIST ACCUSES RUSSIA, FRANCE OF PRO-ARMENIAN STAND
Yeni Musavat, Baku
29 Jan 05
Text of Kanan report by Azerbaijani newspaper Yeni Musavat on 29
January headlined “The mediators are trying to dodge responsibility”
and subheaded “Qabil Huseynli: ‘Great powers have complicated the
conception to resolve the problem'”
The French co-chairman of the OSCE Minsk Group, Bernard Fassier, made
an interesting statement during his familiarization visit to Baku. The
French diplomat said that the resolution of the conflict depends on
the governments of Azerbaijan and Armenia. Noting that the Minsk Group
can only give support to the sides in building dialogue and peace,
Fassier said on the question of the liberation of Azerbaijan’s
occupied territories in 2005: “The presidents, not the co-chairman,
can order the pull-out of troops from those territories.” Like some of
his colleagues, the diplomat also gave a hint that concessions are
expected from Azerbaijan.
The French diplomat’s statement is not the first one of this
kind. Russian co-chairman Yuriy Merzlyakov has also made similar
statements recently. The resolution passed by the Parliamentary
Assembly of the Council of Europe on Nagornyy Karabakh several days
ago stressed that the resolution of the conflict by and large depends
on the parties.
Can Fassier’s statement be regarded as a sign that the Minsk Group is
disavowing its responsibility? A deputy leader of the Musavat party,
Qabil Huseynli, told us that the French and Russian representatives
put forward the proposals, which contradict Azerbaijan’s interests,
under a strange scenario.
“First, Russia makes a proposal, then France starts supporting it. The
fact that the Russian diplomat insists on Nagornyy Karabakh being
recognized as a party (to negotiations) is clearly indicative of that
country’s pro-Armenian position, whereas the new French co-chairman
says that the resolution of the problem depends on the parties.”
The countries which are directly interested in deadlocking the
Karabakh conflict are trying to insure themselves by making such
statements, he said.
“Today, the great powers have complicated the resolution of the
problem so much, allowed so many double standards and made so many
ideological and political mistakes that finding a solution has become
even more difficult. These countries refuse to accept the notions of
the occupier and of the country under occupation despite this being
the ABC of any conflict. Today, they do not want to accept the fact
that Azerbaijani territories were occupied by the Armenian armed
forces and the entity called Nagornyy Karabakh functions as part of
Armenia and under the influence of its authorities. They are still
saying that there is no separatist regime, but a national liberation
movement in Karabakh. They are openly saying that the Nagornyy
Karabakh conflict cannot be compared with Dniester, Abkhaz and other
conflicts. In other words, there are enough double standards in their
approach. In this case, there must be a mistake in the very approach
to a solution to the problem. Those states have intentionally made
mistakes in their approach to the problem. Now they are saying that
the parties themselves should find a common language.”
The expert regards the statement by the new co-chairman as a call for
Azerbaijan to make concessions.
“Armenia does not accept any concessions and faces no pressure, while
Azerbaijan is being persuaded to make concessions over the launch of
some projects and pressure. France and Russia have not recognized
Armenia as an occupying country so far. They stress the importance of
self-determination of nations when it comes to Azerbaijan, but when it
comes to other states they underline the importance of territorial
integrity. This insincerity brings the problem to deadlock.”
It is not right to implicate the OSCE Minsk Group, because the
co-chairing countries have the ultimate responsibility, he said.
“We need to look at the policy of the countries in the group. The
French co-chairman implements the instructions of his state. France
and its nationalist president Jacques Chirac blatantly support the
Armenians and Russia backs Armenia with which it has a strategic
cooperation treaty in every possible way. In other words, these
countries have made so many mistakes testifying to their pro-Armenian
position that these statements sound hypocritical.”

When planning the recent EU enlargement, we were aware….

Caucaz
europenews
02/01/2005 06:45 Tbilisi
«When planning the recent EU enlargement, we were aware of building tensions
between those countries – the countries joining EU and the new neighbors » –
Torben Holtze [EU]
By Célia CHAUFFOUR, François GREMY in Tbilisi
On 31/01/2005
At the head of the European Commission delegation to Georgia and Armenia
since fall 2001, Torben Holtze comes back on the absence of any of the three
South-Caucasus countries in the first Action Plans implemented by the
European Union (EU), in the framework of the New Neighborhood Policy.
Moldova, Ukraine, Morocco, Tunisia, Jordan, Israel and the Palestinian
Authority will soon benefit from the first Action Plans under EU’s New
Neighborhood Policy. The South Caucasus is strikingly absent from those.
Would this mean that Europe does not really know what to do with the three
South-Caucasian countries?
The Action Plans are coming. Everything takes time. It is only two and a
half years ago that EU began to think about the role and the function of
future Member States. And at this time, there was not yet any political
desire nor any decision to invite other neighboring countries.
When planning the recent EU enlargement, we were aware of building tensions
between those countries – the countries joining EU and the new neighbors. So
we had to offer those countries also a form of integration. Indeed they are
also to become EU members.
Let’s consider the example of Norway. Obviously the situation is totally
different. But Norway is economically fully integrated in the EU. It has
also adopted most of the European legislation and integrated numerous
European committees. It even payed money into EU.
However this requires that the country has reached a development similar to
the one of other European countries. And for some countries this process
will be achieved only over time.
On the other hand, this form of integration is clearly not EU membership.
That’s why, in the framework of this integration process, the EU adopted a
specific system, the so-called New Neighborhood Policy.
Even if the New Neighborhood Policy offers to some countries a special form
of integration to the EU, it is not about future membership.
Regarding the first steps for this New Neighborhood Policy, one of the
concerned countries, Belarus, will have to wait for a transition toward a
more democratic regime. As for Russia, although it was not considered as an
ordinary neighbor, but rather as an equal to the EU, it did not want to take
part in the New Neighborhood Policy and is more enclined to become a
strategic partner for the EU.
It’s true that, in some way, the South-Caucasus countries got left out. This
happened because of a combination of several factors, but definitely it was
not we not considering them as neighboring countries. Most of EU Member
States were not satisfied with the situation within those countries.
For they were being temporarily set aside, what was the reaction of the
South-Caucasus countries?
Naturally, they protested – especially Georgia: `Aren’t we a European
neighbor country? Aren’t we going to become one after the possible
membership of Romania and Bulgaria via Black Sea, and also after Turkey’s
membership?’
We have to recall that at the beginning, Brussels didn’t wish to include the
South Caucasus countries in the New Neighborhood Policy. These three
countries exerted an important pressure, via the European Parliament which
was in favor of their request, and via some Member States. Some countries,
notably Belgium and Netherlands, regularly broached this subject during
European summits.
EU’s change of position toward them was triggered by the Roses Revolution,
but also in some way, by the elections of 2003 in Azerbaijan. In spite of
some persistent problems, these elections were considered to be fairer than
the previous ones. And under the pressure of some Member States of the
European Parliament, the EU agreed to include these three countries in the
New Neighborhood Policy.
Is the EU able to develop efficient Partnership and Cooperation agreements,
especially with Tbilisi, when most of its Member States have diverging
interest in this zone?
The Member States’ policy in South Caucasus is not that different from each
other. If you take a look at most of the European countries, you will see
that their do not have vital interests in Georgia and Armenia, with the
exception of Germany and its presence in Georgia. But despite strong
German-Georgian relations, you won’t find here massive German investments.
In this region, the large States are more especially interested in the BTC.
That’s why there are large foreign companies, such as BP. The EU also got
interested in South Caucasus for it is a transport corridor : for oil and
gas, but also for humans and goods coming from Central Asia. And this is
clearly a common position of EU and its Member States.
The EU in Georgia, reality or theory? Are the actions programs of the EU
delegation in Tbilisi implemented as you would like those to be?
In 2002, the Commission proposed to the Member States to elaborate a country
strategy paper for each one of the South-Caucasus countries. That’s when we
evaluated the situation within those countries so as to define what should
be the approach of the European Commission.
The projects that we identified together with the Georgians as the ones that
should be supported through the TACIS (Technical Assistance to the CIS
countries) program and other programs, can be divided into three fields of
action.
The first one is based upon the Partnership and Cooperation agreements. In
the framawork of those agreements, the Georgian authorities committed to
establish a democracy and a market economy. As for the European authorities,
we committed to help them to change their economic, social and
administrative structures so as to get the closest possible to the European
system.
The second field of action is the economic development, since there is still
a part of the population suffering from poverty. Thus there are social
programs in each one of those three countries, via the EU Food Security
Program, which come up to 10-15 million euros a year.
The last field of action is rule of law, human rights and elections. There
are still problems, but by signing an agreement the local authorities
committed to work toward democracy, the respect of human rights and the rule
of law.
What do you think about the Georgia of Mikhail Saakashvili?
In the middle of the 1990s, the Georgian population was starving. The
country was largely depending on humanitarian aid, alike the other
South-Caucasus countries. Then Georgia had to go through a long process.
Tbilisi notably adopted a legislation that was drafted with the help of our
consultants. But in order to change a system, you also have to change
mentalities. And this cannot be done overnight.
The EU tries to help these countries as much as possible and to establish a
legislative system near the closest possible to West-European standards.
Through training and information, mentalities are changing, and getting
gradually closer to ours. But this is not yet the case today. If the
government was to adopt the right clauses, the process could go very fast.
Do you assume that the government did not comply with EU directives?
Not all of them. One just has to look at the way privatizations are done.
And yet, I’m deeply optimistic about Georgia’s future and evolution,
otherwise I would not be here.
Translated by Marie Anderson.