Armenian Genocide on CBC radio ONE on Sunday Feb. 6

PRESS RELEASE
Armenian Cultural Foundation of Ottawa
P.O. BOX 23153
Ottawa, CANADA, K2A 4E7
Tel: (613) 234-1890
Fax: (613) 234-2568
E-mail: [email protected]
Armenian Genocide on CBC radio ONE on Sunday Feb. 6
Ottawa, Friday, February 04, 2005 – The Armenian Cultural Foundation
in Ottawa has learned from a reliable source, and is pleased to
announce that CBC Radio One, will interview Prof. Taner Akcam on its
weekly program: the Sunday Edition on February 6, 2005.
The interview has been prompted by the publication in “The Literary
Review of Canada (LRC)” of a powerful book review on the Armenian
Genocide and the Turkish Government’s policy of denial. The review,
by David Warner, is of Turkish historian Taner Akcam’s book “From
Empire to Republic: Turkish Nationalism and the Armenian Genocide.”
The review, spreads over two oversized pages, and is titled “History
Denied: A brave Turkish historian calls it the Armenian genocide. Are
his fellow citizens listening?” It is featured prominently on the
Jan/Feb cover of the LRC magazine in form of cover lines and an
illustration.
CBC Radio One program, “The Sunday Edition” will interview Prof. Akcam
on Feb 6, 2005. The Sunday Edition is a lively three-hour program of
conversation, documentaries and music. Michael Enright, an
accomplished and famous Canadian journalist and broadcaster, is the
host and tackles everything from politics to pop culture, in Canada
and around the world. Michael Enright is one of the most respected
journalists in Canada. He thrives on debate and ideas and each program
begins with his own thoughts. He has already interviewed twice, very
favorably, on his program Canadian Soprano, Isabel Bayrakdarian.
The Sunday Edition regularly airs on: CBC Radio One Sundays,
9:11a.m.-12:00 p.m.
“We have learned that the Turkish Embassy in Ottawa made an effort to
block the segment from being aired.” Said Vahe Balabanian, President
of the Armenian Cultural Foundation.
The program on CBC’s internet service is at:
To reach the CBC: E-mail: [email protected]
Phone: 416-205-3700 (audience inquiries)
Fax: 416-205-6461
Mail: The Sunday Edition
P.O. Box 500, Station A
Toronto, Ontario
M5W 1E6

To reach the magazine: e-mail: [email protected]
Ms. Bronwyn Drainie
Editor, Literary Review of Canada
581 Markham Street, Suite 3A
Toronto, Ontario
M6G 2I7
Tel. (416) 531-1483

Format of Karabakh settlement talks distorted – minister

Format of Karabakh settlement talks distorted – minister
Arminfo, Yerevan
4 Feb 05
YEREVAN
The format of the negotiations on the peaceful settlement of the
Nagornyy Karabakh conflict is distorted, the foreign minister of the
Nagornyy Karabakh Republic [NKR], Arman Melikyan, said at a press
conference in Stepanakert today.
The minister pointed out that using this, Azerbaijan is trying to
present Armenia as an aggressor that has territorial claims to
Azerbaijan. Speaking about British MP David Atkinson’s report on
Nagornyy Karabakh, Melikyan pointed out that “we should not identify
Atkinson with the whole of Europe. After all, there are very specific
interests – European, American, Azerbaijani or Russian, and these
interests require each country to resolve certain tasks. We also have
our own interests, which should be purposefully defended in the
general contexts of interests. However, everything boils down again to
the distorted format of the negotiations in which the NKR is not
participating,” Melikyan stressed.
The minister stressed that it is very difficult to find a solution
within the framework of such a distorted format. “It is hardly
possible to find any mutually acceptable solution without the
participation of Nagornyy Karabakh in the negotiations. But this
depends not only on our desire – there are international and
Azerbaijani interests, and our task is to make the aims and interests
of Nagornyy Karabakh understandable and acceptable to others,” the
minister said.

Designer Zaytsev Sure Armenia Middle Class can Afford $300 Clothes

VYACHESLAV ZAYTSEV IS SURE THAT MEDIUM STRATUM OF ARMENIA CAN BUY
CLOTHES CUT OUT BY HIM FOR $300-600
YEREVAN, January 25 (Noyan Tapan). The collection of women’s clothes
of classical style cut out by Vyacheslav Zaytsev, Director of Moscow
Fashion House, for the first time will be represented in autumn in
Yerevan. The well-knowm modeller informed about this during the
January 25 press conference. He is in Yerevan on the occasion of
watching of the video-recording of the show of “2005-2006
Autumn-Summer” collection held on January 13 in Paris. The watching
was organized in the “Apollo” shop.
According to V.Zaytsev, mainly black and white colors predominate in
the clothes created by him, which symbolizes purity and harmony. He
assured that they will also interest the Armenian women “as they like
to dress with taste.” V.Zaytsev mentioned that everybody wants to
have good clothes, that’s why his clothes are sold at affordable
prices, for $300-600. For comparison it was mentioned that Valentin
Yudashkin’s clothes are sold for 10-15 thousand euros. Answering a
journalist’s question V.Zaytsev assured that the medium stratum of
Armenia will be able to buy the clothes cut out by him at the
above-mentioned prices.

The Guide: Previews film: The London Armenian Film Festival London

The Guide: PREVIEWS film: The London Armenian Film Festival LONDON
The Guardian – United Kingdom;
Feb 05, 2005
PHELIM O’NEILL

Apparently the first UK season of Armenian cinema for 25 years, so
there’s clearly a lot of catching up to do. The dark spectre of
genocide still features heavily in their movies, directly or
otherwise. But these are not doomy works – the culture is rich, if
little known here. Ararat and Calendar by Atom Egoyan – the big name
in Armenian cinema – are showing. Recent hit Vodka Lemon provides a
droll look at romance, Komitas tells the story of a traumatised
composer, and the dialogue-free Lovember charts a luckless couple’s
creation of a new god. po’n
Cine Lumiere, Instituit Francais, SW2, Fri 11 to Feb 17

Film: The Five Best Revivals

FILM: THE FIVE BEST REVIVALS
The Independent – United Kingdom
Feb 05, 2005

1
Every Little Thing & Nicolas Philibert in conversation (today 6.45pm &
8.45pm NFT1)
The inmates and staff of a French psychiatric institution stage their
annual theatrical experience in this documentary from the much-lauded
director of tre et Avoir, interviewed onstage after the screening.
2
Pierlequin (Fri 8.30pm Lumiere)
The first season of Armenian films in the UK for 25 years kicks off
with this award-winning, low-budget love story about a clown, made by
Tigran Xmalian who will be present at the screening.
3
Chain (Tue 6.40pm Curzon Soho)
This first feature by New York film-maker Jem Cohen, which describes
the world as one corporate shopping mall, was shot in seven countries
and took more than six years to make.
4
Pawel Pawlikowski Quadruple Bill (Sun 2.30pm Riverside)
The poet Yerofeev, a war report in Bosnia, a trip round St Petersburg
with the great-grandson of Dostoevsky, and Russian nationalist
Vladimir Zhirinovsky – all the subjects of documentaries by the
talented, UK-based director.
5
The Minders & The Liberace of Baghdad (Wed 7pm Barbican)
Sean McAllister presents two of his documentaries from Iraq – pre and
post the US-led invasion. The first concerns Saddam’s minders sent to
“look after” journalists; the second an eccentric former
concert-pianist now scratching a living in Iraqi bars.

Oil-for-U.N.

OIL-FOR-U.N.
Yahoo News
Friday, February 4, 2005
By William F. Buckley Jr.
A wild thought passes through my mind, which is that maybe Benon Sevan
is in fact innocent! Innocent of receiving money directly from his
buddy Fakhry Abdelnour, the Egyptian whose company (AMEP — African
Middle East Petroleum) wanted some Iraqi chits to permit oil purchases.
Benon Sevan was certainly not innocent of using his influence in
behalf of his friends and of failing to blow any whistles when suspect
contractors were designated to oversee the oil-for-food program, a
cover-up for easing the life and enhancing the fortunes of Saddam
Hussein (news – web sites). The U.N. had evolved into a bureaucracy
besotted by people who were contriving to get around the freeze on the
full production and sale of Iraqi oil.
There is one concrete item that Paul Volcker’s commission of inquiry
brought out. During the period being examined, Benon Sevan received
gifts totaling $160,000 from — not Saddam, not Abdelnour, not Amir
Mohammad Rashid, the former Iraqi oil minister. But from an aunt. An
aunt greatly devoted to Sevan, we plausibly assume, though she is dead
and can’t be questioned. She was a photographer who lived in
Cyprus. Now, many transactions can amount to $160,000. For instance,
two transactions, added together, of $80,000 each. But the Volcker
commission focuses on a figure of $160,000, paid by Abdelnour to
Saddam Hussein as an illegal surcharge for oil purchased.
So it’s odd, but there is no evidence that the aunt in Cyprus gave
another $160,000 to Abdelnour. And anyway, those would have been
discrete benefactions. Sevan says he is entirely innocent. High
U.N. officials who worked with him for many years before his
retirement express worry and annoyance that Sevan should have got
himself so embedded in the sticky oil-for-food situation, but it isn’t
likely that he will be yanked from his retirement in Cyprus, deprived
of his diplomatic immunity and charged with grand larceny.
No, the debacle of oil-for-food demonstrates the difficulty in
managing, without leakage, a sum like the extraordinary $64 billion
involved. That is the value of the oil that Iraq (news – web sites)
was permitted to sell in order to raise money to feed hungry Iraqis
and to look after medical and other needs. The component parts of the
operation, which took place under the supervision of the United
Nations (news – web sites), begged for exploitation. There were a
myriad of people eager to get the coupons for that oil, because it was
being merchandised at a price lower than the price of oil in the world
market.
A reporter for The New York Times summarizes the handling of the
matter: “Iraq did not sell oil to just anyone. Under the guidance of
Taha Yassin Ramadan, an Iraqi vice president, and the Revolutionary
Command Council, headed by Mr. Hussein, a large portion of the oil
allocations were handed out to a select group that included
businessmen, politicians, journalists and diplomats who were perceived
to be sympathetic to Iraq.”
The friendly people negotiated the sale of $64 billion in oil. It
beggars the imagination that anything on such a scale, going through
so many hands, could have got safe, hygienic passage from Iraqi oil
wells to bread for kids.
Mr. Volcker’s commission has put off for months the completion of its
investigation. What we can say at this point is that, quoting the news
item, the “United Nations’ largest relief effort was riddled with
political favoritism and mismanagement.”
“I am reluctant to conclude that the U.N. is damaged beyond repair,”
commented Rep. Henry Hyde (news, bio, voting record), chairman of the
House International Relations Committee. “But these revelations
certainly point in this direction.” Sen. Norm Coleman (news, bio,
voting record) of the Senate Permanent Committee on Investigation
wants action taken against Mr. Sevan, just to begin with.
But whatever steps are taken concretely, they aren’t — based on the
evidence of the Volcker commission — going to tell us very much that
we don’t already take for granted, namely the attractions of
larceny. If what happens is the demystification of the United Nations
as a vessel of incorruptibility, then that belated introduction to
reality is welcome. It doesn’t tell us what exactly a renewed
relationship with the U.N. should stress. It doesn’t even tell us what
has happened to all that money Saddam accumulated, some of it with the
connivance of U.N. officials.
;u=/ucwb/20050205/cm_ucwb/oilforun

Dialogue sans concessions entre =?UNKNOWN?Q?Debr=E9_et?= Erdogan

Le Figaro, France
04 février 2005
Dialogue sans concessions entre Debré et Erdogan;
TURQUIE Le président de l’Assemblée a rencontré le premier ministre
turc à Ankara
Sophie HUET
« Soyons comme deux amis, des gens qui se disent la vérité. » Cette
phrase de Jean-Louis Debré résume le climat sans concession, ni du
côté français, ni du côté turc, qui a régné tout au long de la
première journée de rencontres à huis clos de la délégation conduite
par le président de l’Assemblée nationale à Ankara. Accompagné par
les quatre présidents de groupes de l’Assemblée nationale, Bernard
Accoyer (UMP), Hervé Morin (UDF), Jean-Marc Ayrault (PS) et Alain
Bocquet (PCF), Jean-Louis Debré a rencontré à sa descente d’avion le
premier ministre turc, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, puis le président de
l’Assemblée nationale de Turquie, Bulent Aric. Avec les deux hommes,
Jean-Louis Debré a d’emblée abordé les questions les plus sensibles :
Chypre, la reconnaissance du génocide arménien, les réformes
législatives à effectuer en Turquie (concernant le code pénal, le
code de procédure pénale, les droits de l’homme…) tout au long du
processus d’adhésion, qui aboutira, ou non, à l’entrée de ce pays
dans l’Union européenne. Au premier ministre, Jean-Louis Debré a
expliqué que l’attitude de la Turquie à l’égard du génocide arménien
« était un vrai problème en France ». Ce à quoi Erdogan a répondu
très directement : « Je suis déçu de la France… Je ne savais pas
que 400 000 Arméniens pourraient faire échouer le référendum » sur la
Turquie, prévu dans dix à quinze ans.
Lors d’une conférence de presse commune, les présidents des deux
Assemblées nationales n’ont quasiment pas échangé un regard. Bulent
Aric a déclaré qu’il ne demandait « aucun traitement spécial » pour
son pays, qu’il jugeait « tout à fait normal » que des opinions
contre l’entrée de la Turquie s’expriment en France. Mais il a
aussitôt adressé un « message au peuple français » pour lui dire que
« la Turquie de l’opinion publique française est très différente de
la Turquie réelle », déplorant « les malentendus, les images et les
symboles qui ne sont absolument pas représentatifs de la véritable
Turquie ». Les affiches de Philippe de Villiers prônant le non à la
Turquie ont d’ailleurs été publiées, avec des commentaires acides,
dans les journaux du pays.
Bulent Aric n’a pas non plus caché que « nos relations avec l’Union
européenne ne sont pas sentimentales ». Et il a ajouté : « Nous ne
sommes pas deux jeunes qui se sont rencontrés à la discothèque et se
sont aimés. Nous nous basons sur un accord de plus de quarante ans. »
Allusion à la célèbre formule du général de Gaulle, en 1963 : « La
Turquie a vocation à être européenne. »
Devant un parterre fourni de journalistes turcs et de caméras,
Jean-Louis Debré n’a pas trop usé de la langue de bois diplomatique.
« Nous avons à vous écouter et vous avez à nous entendre. (…)
Est-ce que la société turque est capable, dans un laps de temps
précis, d’accepter des réformes qui vont la changer ? », s’est
interrogé le président de l’Assemblée. Lequel a expliqué à ses hôtes
qu’ils avaient « une référence idéologique commune, la révolution
française, qui a aussi influencé l’oeuvre de Kemal Atatürk ». C’est
donc avec « un esprit critique » mais « sans préjugé ni opposition de
principe » que Jean-Louis Debré, visiblement sur le qui-vive, aborde
ce voyage.
Mais les questions des journalistes turcs ont révélé un vrai fossé
entre les deux pays. Ceux-ci ne comprennent pas qu’un référendum soit
nécessaire pour l’entrée de la Turquie dans l’UE, mais pas pour la
Roumanie, la Croatie ou la Bulgarie. « Comme pour l’adhésion de la
Grande-Bretagne, il est légitime que le peuple de France se prononce
» a répondu Debré. Un confrère d’Ankara a jugé « très blessante pour
les Turcs » la reconnaissance du génocide arménien par la France. «
C’est une loi (du 18 janvier 2000) je l’applique », a rétorqué le
député de l’Eure.
La délégation française a été un peu surprise par ces rencontres «
sans sujet tabou », selon Alain Bocquet (PC). « Les Turcs sont
demandeurs de l’adhésion à l’Europe, c’est très clair », commentait
Jean-Marc Ayrault (PS). « Leur désir d’Europe est très fort. C’est un
consensus politique dans le pays », ajoutait Bernard Accoyer. « Ils
veulent l’adhésion pure et simple, et considèrent qu’ils ont déjà un
partenariat privilégié avec l’Europe », a aussi affirmé Hervé Morin
(UDF), pour lequel « il y a vraiment un besoin de dialogue, car ils
nous parlent sans cesse de nos préjugés, de nos arrière-pensées ».
From: Baghdasarian

Inquiry on Food-for-Oil Plan Cites U.N. Diplomat for Conflict

The New York Times
X-Sender: Asbed Bedrossian
X-Listprocessor-Version: 8.1 — ListProcessor(tm) by CREN
Inquiry on Food-for-Oil Plan Cites U.N. Diplomat for Conflict
By JUDITH MILLER and WARREN HOGE
Published: February 4, 2005
An interim report by a commission investigating the United Nations
oil-for-food program in Iraq said the former head of the program had
violated the United Nations Charter by helping a company owned by a friend
to obtain valuable contracts to sell Iraqi oil.
The conduct of Benon V. Sevan, a Cypriot official who ran the program from
1997 until its demise in 2003, was a “grave and continuing conflict of
interest” and had “seriously undermined the integrity of the United
Nations,” the report concludes.
The 219-page report, issued yesterday by the Independent Inquiry Committee,
the United Nations-appointed panel headed by Paul A. Volcker, the former
Federal Reserve chairman, depicts what was the United Nations’ largest
relief effort as riddled with political favoritism and mismanagement.
The $64 billion program, under which Iraqi oil revenues were used to buy
relief goods for Iraqis, is also being investigated by five Congressional
committees and a federal prosecutor in New York.
The report also says officials violated United Nations competitive bidding
rules in hiring contractors for the program. It says important parts of the
program were not audited, allowing evidence that Saddam Hussein was
demanding and receiving kickbacks from companies selling his oil to go
undetected.
A senior United Nations official announced yesterday that Secretary General
Kofi Annan would try to discipline Mr. Sevan, who retired last year, and
another senior official, Joseph Stephanides, who oversaw the selection of
the program’s major contractors.
The report does not say that Mr. Sevan, or other officials it criticizes,
benefited personally from their actions.
But it discloses that Mr. Sevan received $160,000 in cash between 1999 to
2003 from an aunt in Cyprus, a retired government photographer who has since
died. Mr. Volcker did not tie that money to his efforts on behalf of his
friend’s company, but the report says that the aunt’s way of life did not
suggest that she was wealthy and that the panel was continuing to
investigate “the full scope and extent of benefits received by Mr. Sevan.”
It also discloses that the Swiss-based company that Mr. Sevan helped, Africa
Middle East Petroleum, made a $1.5 million profit by selling the oil
allocations that Mr. Sevan had repeatedly solicited on its behalf from
senior Iraqi officials. The report accuses the company of paying an illegal
surcharge of $160,088 to Iraq in 2001.
In a statement yesterday, Eric L. Lewis, a lawyer for Mr. Sevan, denied his
client had acted improperly. He said Mr. Sevan had no interest in any oil
company and had never “accepted anything from anyone.” The statement said he
had always acted “in the best interests” of the oil-for-food program and the
United Nations.
Mr. Lewis accused the panel of trying to “scapegoat” Mr. Sevan for
“mentioning a company to the Iraqis as part of his role in advancing the
process of trading oil for food.”
“Mr. Sevan never took a penny,” Mr. Lewis said, accusing the commission of
succumbing to “massive political pressure.”
Describing Mr. Sevan as “proud” of his 40-year service to the United Nations
in some of the world’s most dangerous places, the statement said that Mr.
Sevan had fully disclosed the income he had received from his aunt.
The report accuses Mr. Sevan of not having been “forthcoming” with the
committee about his relationship with the oil company, AMEP, or its owner,
Fakhry Abdelnour, a distant relative of Boutros Boutros-Ghali, the former
United Nations secretary general, whom the report criticizes separately for
his role in selecting the program’s main banker.
Reached by telephone in Paris, Mr. Boutros-Ghali said he had done nothing
improper, calling Mr. Volcker’s investigators “ignorant” of the United
Nations system and their allegations about his conduct “silly.”
Mr. Volcker said yesterday that the panel was continuing to investigate Mr.
Sevan and his connections to Mr. Abdelnour, his company and other friends
and associates.
Efforts to locate Mr. Abdelnour for comment yesterday were not successful. A
call placed to his office in Geneva was not answered yesterday evening.
Mr. Stephanides, who oversaw contractor selection, did not return messages
left on his office phone Wednesday night and yesterday morning.
(Page 2 of 3)
Mark Malloch Brown, Mr. Annan’s new chief of staff, said Mr. Stephanides
could pay a high price as a result of disciplinary action up to and
including dismissal, but he acknowledged that there was little the United
Nations could do about Mr. Sevan, since he had retired. He said Mr. Annan
would immediately lift the diplomatic immunity of any United Nations
official charged with criminal conduct.
Mr. Volcker said, “This is a painful episode for everyone in the U.N.”
This interim report defers judgment on fundamental issues of responsibility
for corruption in the oil-for-food program, saying its investigations are
continuing. Mr. Volcker and the two other commissioners – Richard Goldstone,
a South African judge, and Mark Pieth, a Swiss financial expert –
specifically deferred comment, for example, on allegations that the
secretary general had a conflict of interest because his son Kojo had worked
for Cotecna Inspection, a Swiss-based company hired to inspect the aid
bought by Iraq.
Mr. Annan, who became secretary general in 1997, has previously said he had
no role in selecting contractors.
Mr. Volcker said he hoped to issue his final report this summer.
The interim report, however, criticizes the way in which United Nations
officials selected all three of the program’s major contractors: Banque
Nationale de Paris, a French bank that the panel said was not even on the
United Nations’ initial “long list” of the most technically qualified banks
for the program; Saybolt Eastern Hemisphere BV, a Dutch oil inspection
company that Mr. Stephanides was said to have promoted; and Lloyd’s Register
Inspection Ltd. of Britain, which the report said was chosen partly to
balance lucrative contracts geographically among member nations.
The panel’s investigators found “convincing and uncontested evidence” that
the selection process had been “tainted” by irregularities in the case of
all three contractors. The report does not accuse the contractors of acting
illegally.
Both the report and Mr. Volcker emphasized that the major source of Mr.
Hussein’s illicit money was not kickbacks from the oil-for-food program but
the estimated $8 billion in illegal oil sales to Jordan, Turkey and Syria
that occurred even before the program was created. Mr. Volcker said that
those sales were known to Security Council members, including the United
States, and that Washington had specifically waived American laws barring
such sales.
The report reserves its harshest criticism for Mr. Sevan, whose contacts
with Iraqi officials on behalf of Mr. Abdelnour and his company AMEP, it
details. The report states that Mr. Sevan first asked senior Iraqi officials
for an allocation of oil “to help a friend” who was from Egypt in mid-1998,
soon after the Security Council permitted Iraq to use up to $300 million of
oil revenues to purchase spare parts for renovations. It was “highly
unlikely,” the report notes, “that Iraq would sell oil to a company such as
AMEP unless sponsored by a beneficiary that Iraqi officials wished to
favor.”
Citing several Iraqi documents, the report concludes that Iraqi officials
gave the allocations to AMEP at Mr. Sevan’s requests hoping that this would
“ensure a good relationship with him” and would help them obtain Mr. Sevan’s
assistance in lifting holds on spare part sales that Security Council
members had placed on them.
The former Iraqi oil minister, Muhammad Rashid, specifically told the
panel’s investigators that the Iraqi government had allocated oil to Mr.
Sevan “because ‘he was a man of influence,’ ” the report states.
After Mr. Sevan turned out not to be “as helpful as hoped,” it continues,
the allocations for AMEP were reduced. “Neither Mr. Sevan nor Mr. Abdelnour
was pleased with the reduction in the oil allocation,” the report says. Mr.
Sevan spoke to Mr. Rashid about it at an OPEC conference in Vienna in March
1999.
In the next phase of the program, AMEP’s allocation was restored within five
days after Mr. Sevan traveled to Iraqi to meet with Mr. Rashid again in the
summer of 1999 to “discuss an expansion of the oil spare parts program.”
The report says Mr. Sevan “denies that he asked for oil allocations or
recommended any company to Iraqi officials for purchasing oil.”
(Page 3 of 3)
“But these claims are contradicted by the firsthand accounts of Iraqi
officials involved,” as well as by Iraqi oil company documents that list
both Mr. Sevan and AMEP as recipients, “often following occasions when Mr.
Sevan met with Oil Minister Rashid,” the report states.
The report says Mr. Abdelnour said Mr. Sevan did not assist him in obtaining
the allocations from Iraq.
Advertisement
It says Mr. Sevan initially told investigators he had met Mr. Abdelnour only
briefly at the OPEC Vienna conference in 1999. But in later interviews he
“admitted that he had passed at least one inquiry from Mr. Abdelnour to the
Iraqi oil minister.”
The report says that after being confronted with United Nations telephone
records showing calls between himself and Mr. Abdelnour, Mr. Sevan
acknowledged that the two men had “developed an acquaintanceship” lasting
“over several years.” It quotes Mr. Sevan as telling investigators: “I came
to like the guy. He is an interesting character you know, he’s been around
the world.”
At the United Nations, Mr. Malloch Brown said the secretary general was
shocked at the report’s findings about Mr. Sevan in particular.
“The secretary general is shocked by what the report has to say about Mr.
Sevan, terribly dismayed that a colleague of so many years’ standing is
accused of breaching the U.N. code of conduct and staff rules in the ways he
did, and he very much doubts that there can be any extenuating circumstances
for the behavior which appears proven in the report,” Mr. Malloch Brown
said.
The mood toward Mr. Sevan, a longtime friend and confidant of Mr. Annan’s,
appeared unforgiving.
Mr. Malloch Brown said: “Let me be clear that while Benon Sevan is a very
dear friend of many of us – I’ve worked with him for years – when you put
together three international investigators, $34 million worth of
investigations, 65 investigators, you don’t then set yourselves up as a
court of appeal over the results of that investigation.” Any further
investigation, he said, would be in “a judicial process.”
Reaction to the report from Congressional investigators was mostly
supportive of Mr. Volcker’s work.
Representative Henry J. Hyde, the Illinois Republican who is the chairman of
the House International Relations Committee, said in a statement that the
report painted a picture of “mismanagement, neglect and political
manipulation that resulted in significant corruption of the oil-for-food
program.”
“I am reluctant to conclude that the U.N. is damaged beyond repair,” he
said, “but these revelations certainly point in this direction.”
A similar, but even harsher reaction came from Senator Norm Coleman, a
Minnesota Republican and chairman of the Senate Permanent Committee on
Investigations, who called on Mr. Annan to lift Mr. Sevan’s diplomatic
immunity immediately. “The report shows that he repeatedly lied to
investigators, has misled the inquiry about the source of $160,000 in cash
deposits and unethically steered oil-for-food contracts to close associates
and lied about those relationships to authorities,” he said.

U.N. Diplomat Reportedly Sought Iraqi Oil Deals for Egyptian

U.N. Diplomat Reportedly Sought Iraqi Oil Deals for Egyptian
The New York Times
February 4, 2005
By SUSAN SACHS
Benon V. Sevan, a career United Nations diplomat who headed the
oil-for-food program for Iraq, solicited favors from Saddam Hussein’s
government on behalf of an Egyptian trader who made more than $1.5
million in profits from his privileged access to Iraqi oil contracts,
according to an investigative report released yesterday.
The trader, Fakhry Abdelnour, who is based in Geneva, also paid an
illegal surcharge of $160,000 to the Iraqis, in violation of the
United Nations sanctions against Iraq, while he and Mr. Sevan were
lobbying for more business, said the report, which was issued by a
United Nations-appointed panel headed by Paul A. Volcker.
In securing the oil contracts for Mr. Abdelnour, Mr. Sevan introduced
him into one of the byways of the giant program, one that enriched a
small group of traders while pouring money that was meant to buy food
and medicine into secret Iraqi slush funds, it said.
Through the intercession of Mr. Sevan, the report said, Mr. Abdelnour
was put on a list of individuals who received coupons, or allocations,
that gave him the right to buy millions of barrels of Iraqi crude oil,
starting in 1998.
The allocations were of little use to people who were not in the oil
business and did not have the means, or desire, to lease tankers to
ship the oil to refineries and other users. But they were valuable to
Mr. Abdelnour, as the profits on his dealings with Iraq demonstrated.
Oil companies were hungry for Iraqi crude oil, especially in the early
years of the oil-for-food program when prices for Iraqi oil were below
world market prices. But Iraq did not sell oil to just anyone.
Under the guidance of Taha Yassin Ramadan, an Iraqi vice president,
and the Revolutionary Command Council, headed by Mr. Hussein, a large
portion of the oil allocations were handed out to a select group that
included businessmen, politicians, journalists and diplomats who were
perceived to be sympathetic to Iraq. According to traders and Iraqi
officials, many people who received allocations sold them to an oil
company at a premium.
Mr. Abdelnour did the same, the report said, selling his first
allocation of 1.8 million barrels in the fall of 1998 to two oil
companies for a $300,000 profit and selling another 5.5 million
barrels for a $1.2 million profit over the next three years.
His company stopped buying oil in late 2000, the report added, after
Iraq started demanding that oil buyers pay under-the-table surcharges
on each barrel of oil they received. Many other traders in Mr.
Abdelnour’s situation have said they also pulled out around the same
time because paying the surcharges meant that they could not make as
much profit from selling their allocations as they previously had
done.
By telling senior Iraqi officials like Mr. Ramadan that he wanted to
“help a friend” get into the business of buying their oil, Mr. Sevan,
played an important role, the investigators said.
“At that time in the program, it was highly unlikely that Iraq would
sell oil to a company such as AMEP unless sponsored by a beneficiary
that Iraqi officials wished to favor,” the report said, referring to
Mr. Abdelnour’s oil-trading company, African Middle East Petroleum.
Senior Iraqi officials, the report added, were pleased with the chance
to do Mr. Sevan a favor.
“He was a man of influence,” the former Iraqi oil minister, Amir
Muhammed Rashid, told investigators, and the government hoped, in vain
as it turned out, that he had the power to speed up United Nations
approval for Iraq to acquire spare parts for its oil industry.
;adxnnl=1&adxnnlx=1107588769-ce/wGo9FC9jfXgsQ6YomNw

Iraq food aid chief ‘sought oil quotas’

Iraq food aid chief ‘sought oil quotas’
Financial Times
February 4 2005
By Mark Turner at the United Nations and Claudio Gatti in New York
Benon Sevan, head of the United Nations office that administered
Iraq’s multi-billion dollar oil-for-food programme, “repeatedly
solicited” oil allocations from Baghdad, a UN-appointed inquiry said
yesterday.
“Iraqi officials provided such allocations for the purpose of
obtaining Mr Sevan’s support on several issues, particularly their
desire for funds to repair and rebuild the Iraqi oil infrastructure,”
it found.
The conclusions, in an interim report from an independent committee
led by Paul Volcker, deal a severe blow to the United Nations and to
Kofi Annan, its secretary-general.
Critics of the international body in the US Congress and elsewhere
accuse it of allowing Saddam Hussein’s regime to develop illicit
sources of funding as a result of corruption in the programme.
The Volcker report identified failings in the way the programme, set
up in 1996 to alleviate shortages created by international sanctions,
was administered and audited.
Mr Volcker also noted that the most serious violations of the
sanctions occurred outside the programme, and involved oil smuggling.
But the “most disturbing” findings concerned Mr Sevan’s role, which
“created a grave and continuing conflict of interest”.
“His conduct was ethically improper and seriously undermined the
integrity of the United Nations.”
The Financial Times revealed on Tuesday that the UN investigation was
targetting Mr Sevan’s efforts to steer lucrative contracts for Iraqi
oil to African Middle East Petroleum, a Panama-registered company
owned by a Swiss-based oil trader.
The report says Mr Sevan “was not forthcoming to the committee when he
denied approaching Iraqi officials and requesting oil allocations on
behalf of AMEP”. He also “failed to disclose the full nature and
extent of his contacts” with Fakhri Abdelnour, AMEP’s boss.
The report also queries declarations made by Mr Sevan about the source
of additional cash income – disclosed in a UN disclosure form –
between 1999-2003. Mr Sevan said the $160,000 (123,000,
£85,000)received over that period came from an aunt in Cyprus.
The woman, the Volcker report says, was “a retired government
photographer living on a modest pension”. Mr Sevan’s explanation was
“not adequately supported” by the information reviewed by the
committee.
A separate line of inquiry, into investigations into the procurement
of a contractor that employed Mr Annan’s son, Kojo Annan, were “well
advanced” and would be the subject of a further interim report.
Writing in The Wall Street Journal yesterday, Mr Volcker said UN
procurement procedures were “tainted, failing to follow the
established rules of the organisation” and that “political
considerations intruded in a manner that was neither transparent nor
accountable”.