No biography, no experience. Iveta Tonoyan’s answer to Pashinyan

In response to the requests of my colleagues from various mass media, I will briefly respond to today’s statements of the head of the authorities.

The vast majority of the members of the political team that came to power in 2018 did not even have a work book and their first job was to occupy a minister, deputy or other high-ranking government positions. We are all facing the painful consequences of running the country with lack of biography and experience.

Perhaps this is the reason why the head of today’s political force has a pronounced antagonism towards those figures who built, not destroyed, created good, not destroyed values ​​in Armenia and Artsakh throughout their lives.


Iveta Tonoyan




—

Verelq: Pashinyan told yet another disgusting lie

Lilit Galstyan, member of the ARF Bureau, member of the National Assembly “Hayastan” faction, writes:


“Today, another disgusting lie was told once again. At the press conference, Pashinyan announced that the director of the Genocide Museum-Institute, E. Gzoyan, was fired by J. D. Van for dedicating the book “The Artsakh Question” and disrupting the peace process. A LIE and a disgusting LIE…


The book dedicated to Vance has the following title: “Azerbaijani aggression against Armenians in Transcaucasia in 1905-1921 according to American press/sources”.


First, let me remind you that the “Armenian Genocide Museum-Institute” is a foundation, and the appointment and dismissal of the director is carried out by the board of trustees.


Nevertheless, Pashinan publicly admitted that Gzoyan was fired on his orders. And Minister Andreasyan devoted himself to the cause and the idea.


In an awkward situation, the KGMS minister had to give up the initial hypothesis that he put into circulation that the removal of the director was related to the construction of the memorial complex, but the facts speak of something else.


A few days ago, Hranush Kharatyan, a member of the board of trustees, in his post and in an interview with “Aravot” (March 11) confirmed that “According to their official information, the reason is construction, it is related to the renovation of the memorial complex.” We are talking about the meeting of the board of trustees, in which Minister Andreasyan participated.


Now Zh. Andreasyan circulates on another basis. “It’s about governance,” he declares from the top of the bastion of democracy, continuing his sophistic and revealing speech. or “There was a situation that shouldn’t have happened and it found its conclusion”, then he continues: “I don’t need to present an explanation to anyone”.


The name of that situation is “foreign policy and protocol,” Pashinyan reveals.


Which foreign policy? the one approved by the government’s 2021-2026 program, where Artsakh is mentioned 16 times, or the foreign policy chapter, where the recognition and prevention of the Genocide is a foreign policy priority? Why do you continue to deceive the public?


Which protocol? And what protocol did you provide to the Museum? Are you aware that the relevant US authorities have checked and approved their protocol and procedure on the spot?


In that case, why wasn’t the actual culprit, the person in charge of the “protocol” of the CP, dismissed from his job?


And do you know that the given book was given to several dozen guests and it was done very well, because the revision of history and identity to which the regime and its slavish henchmen are engaged has one name: NATIONAL DENIAL.


And how good it is that the five members of the Board of Trustees of the Museum-Institute, the French-Armenian Raimon Gevorgyan, the American-Armenian Stepan Asturyan, Hranush Kharatyan and Harutyun Marutyan, and AGBU Armenia’s head Yaghubyan, did not have their scientific and national dignity undermined.


The problem is not really the book and its title, nor the dismissal of one official.


You can humiliate yourself as much as you can, this is your choice, your vision of a small person and your will.


You can become a merchant of the Turkish dream, but no one has allowed you to auction our identity, our past and our future…”

—

Asbarez: Dr. C. L. Max Nikias: The American Trojan

Max Nikias


BY NANE AVAGYAN

At the heart of the University of Southern California’s campus stands the iconic statue of a Trojan warrior, a symbol of strength, resilience, and honor that has come to embody the spirit of the university.

It is a fitting emblem for an institution that, under its 11th president, C. L. Max Nikias, rose to the highest echelons of American academia. General David Petraeus once called Max Nikias “The American Trojan,” and the title carries the full weight of myth.

It is also the title of his book, “American Trojan,” in which Max Nikias chronicles the remarkable journey from war-torn Cyprus to the pinnacle of American higher education. Like the ancient heroes of Greece, Nikias is a man forged by loss, driven by vision, and defined by an unshakable will to build something lasting from the ruins of what was taken from him.

A descendant of a civilization steeped in philosophy and courage, Max Nikias has lived his own odyssey — one that began in a small village in Cyprus and led him to the United States. Yet his journey was not myth; it was marked by war, displacement, and loss.  “In less than a month, our families had gone from living happy and successful lives to losing everything,” he recalls of the 1974 Turkish invasion of Cyprus. “To escape the deadly bombs being dropped by Turkish aircraft, they left overnight without any of their possessions, believing they would be able to return once the bombing stopped. But they soon realized they were now refugees.” 

It was during this time that Nikias came to understand the true meaning of the Greek word “apatris” — stateless. It is a wound that does not heal. And yet, rather than be defined by that wound, he chose to be defined by what he would build despite it. He arrived in America carrying nothing but intellect, character, and the deep cultural inheritance of a civilization that had survived far greater storms. “I never used the word ‘refugee’ from day one we arrived in America,” he has said. “I wanted to be judged by my work, not by sympathy for past experiences. I did not want to be seen as a victim in any shape or form.”

America gave him the ground to grow, and he never forgot to give back. As president of USC, he raised $7.16 billion in eight years, transforming the university into one of the nation’s most prestigious private research universities. His scientific research contributed to national defense. His leadership philosophy, rooted in humility, accountability, and the conviction that true leadership means serving others, became the architecture of an educational empire. 

His influence would extend far beyond academia. Four decades after the Turkish aircraft bomb his homeland, the man he had become helped prevent another crisis from spiraling out of control. In August 2020, a dangerous Greek-Turkish military standoff over the island of Kasos was escalating rapidly, and only Turkey’s narrative was reaching the White House. Greece’s ambassador in Washington was struggling to reach National Security Adviser until C. L. Max Nikias stepped in. With a single phone call, he helped shift the balance at a critical moment for his homeland.

Max Nikias’ story resonates with particular depth within the Armenian American community, whose own history of displacement, survival, and renaissance mirrors his own. He has spoken openly of his special affinity for Armenians rooted in a childhood in Cyprus spent alongside Armenian neighbors, and later expressed through his championship of the USC Institute of Armenian Studies and his commitment to recruiting Armenian American students to the university.

“American Trojan” by C.L Max Nikias

“This memoir is the story of the American Dream,” wrote Robert C. O’Brien, the 27th U.S. National Security Advisor. 

Days before the release of “The American Trojan”, Dr. Nikias reflects on all of it in the conversation that follows the trauma and the triumphs, the philosophy of leadership, the meaning of home, and the profound conviction that education is not merely a path to success, but the most powerful force we possess to heal the wounds of history and build a future worthy of those who came before us.

The Beginning of an Odyssey

Nane Avagyan: Your book tells the story of a refugee who lost everything during the Turkish invasion of Cyprus in 1974. Can you take us back to that moment? What were your emotions when you first realized you had to leave your homeland and begin an entirely new life?

C. L. Max Nikias: It was a life-changing moment.  Once you lose everything – your property and your possessions, the businesses you’ve built, and photo albums that collect your memories – there is no going back. It is then that you understand the true meaning of “apatris”, which is the Greek word for “stateless.” In many ways, it is a scar that always stays with you, a wound that never heals, a trauma that stains the soul.  And yet, amid tragedy, being stateless also contains the hope for its opposite – a chance to find a new home, which we would later do in America.  For the rest of your life, you never get “too relaxed” because you know evil forces may always arrive and sometimes the best you can do is to minimize their impact because you are not able to stop them.

Nane Avagyan: Arriving in America as a refugee, what were the most difficult personal challenges you faced as an immigrant? Were there moments of doubt, times when you questioned whether starting over was truly possible, and if so, what gave you the strength to persevere. What empowered you to pursue your goals?

C. L. Max Nikias: I never used the word “refugee” from day one we arrived in America. I wanted to be judged by my work and not from any sympathy from past experiences. I did not want to be seen as a “victim” in any shape of form. The first time I have used the word characterizing myself as “refugee” is when I started writing this book a few years ago. Arriving to America as an immigrant, I was full of insecurities and not having a clear path how to plan our future. However, I dedicated myself to my university studies and very quickly developed a “drive” and “determination” to succeed in my graduate studies in engineering. The refugee experience and my heritage— rich in classical history and philosophical inquiry—instilled in me “unshakable optimism” that propelled me through “near penniless” arrivals and professional ascents. This is the immigrant spirit, isn’t it?

Nane Avagyan: What did you find in America that no other country could have offered you?

C. L. Max Nikias: America welcomed my wife and me with open arms! America offered us first class education and opportunity; if you work hard, watch your behavior, realize that you are here as a guest initially, focus on your work to impress people with your accomplishments, prove yourself, and eventually you will reap the benefits of what America has to offer. There is no other country in the world that can embrace immigrants like me and offer them so many different opportunities for a better life. If I were to characterize America in one word, it is OPPORTUNITY!

Nane Avagyan: At what point did you stop feeling like a refugee and begin to feel like an American? Was there a defining moment or a gradual transition?

C. L. Max Nikias: When did I feel like an American? It happened gradually not overnight. From day one I knew I did not come to America to remain Cypriot. I came to America to become an American! And yes, when my wife and I became naturalized citizens, it was a day of celebration – we were Americans!! We were full of gratitude to this country. This is the reason in the book that the chapter where I described our experiences becoming naturalized citizens is entitled “Second Homecoming.”

Nane Avagyan: America welcomed you and your wife when you arrived with nothing. How that experience shaped your sense of responsibility or obligation to give back?

C. L. Max Nikias: Absolutely! You feel so grateful to this country that you do want to give back as an American! I want to believe that I did give back through my technical contributions to national defense and through my leadership positions at USC where the programs we put in place made it possible to offer first class education to students from all walks of life. In some regard, I want to believe that through my efforts I contributed to American exceptionalism especially in the areas of technology innovation and education.

Leadership Philosophy & Education

Nane Avagyan: Coming from a land that is one of the cradles of world civilization, you carry a legacy that includes Plato, Aristotle, Epicurus, and countless other philosophical giants. You brought your wisdom and expertise to the United States, playing a pivotal role in shaping USC into one of the nation’s leading universities. How have the ideals of these ancient philosophers influenced your approach to leadership?

C. L. Max Nikias:I have always believed it is essential to go back to the wisdom found in the classical works of our civilization. We can examine the timeless truths that have guided humanity during past periods of change. There, we find that those truths can guide us reliably in our own moment. We gain wisdom for our leadership circumstances. For example, we can draw parallels to, and metaphors for, the particular challenges we face. Let’s don’t forget that our founding fathers who gave us this United States of America were very well educated in the Greco-Roman classics.

This is the reason why, at the beginning of most of the chapters in my book “American Trojan,” there is an excerpt from the Greek classics.

Nane Avagyan: How do you define true leadership in higher education and which qualities do you believe matter most?

C. L. Max Nikias: There’s a reason I started the book with a quote from the ancient Greek philosopher Heraclitus: “If you do not expect the unexpected, you will not find it, for it is hard to be sought out and difficult.” Leadership is fundamentally about navigating the unexpected. You can have a bold vision, create a strategy, assemble the best team, but invariably, the unexpected will find you.  How you respond defines you and your leadership. 

The ability to inspire others, the capacity to make difficult decisions under pressure, the willingness to take responsibility for outcomes both good and challenging, and the humility to recognize that leadership is not about your own accomplishments, but about serving others. Leadership demands love for humanity, endurance, and self-restraint. The key is to lead with integrity.

Building USC – Vision & Strategy

Nane Avagyan: The transformation of USC into America’s leading research universities. didn’t happen overnight. Was there a specific turning point, a faculty hire, a research breakthrough, or a competitive victory, when you realized USC had crossed into the upper echelon?

C. L. Max Nikias:I tell the story in the book! It was the publication of the WSJ ranking in 2016 with a cover news story singling USC out as the surprise success story. The Wall Street Journal ranked USC at #15 nationally, ahead of some prestigious institutions. West of Chicago, only USC, Stanford and CalTech ranked in the top 20!

I felt at that moment that USC had finally arrived at the top tier of schools!  It is important to note that this ranking was published for the very first time; nobody knew their ranking formula; nobody was going to “game” the formula; and it turned out to be a much more comprehensive ranking formula than other publications. 

Nane Avagyan: You raised billions of dollars for student scholarships, medical research, working with donors who each brought their own temperament, priorities, and expectations։ How did you navigate these diverse personalities and competing interests while preserving USC’s mission and institutional integrity

C. L. Max Nikias:We need to remember that donors are very successful and very smart people. It’s important to build the trust with them and get them to buy into the vision you pursue for the institution. You need to articulate to donors their return-on-investment (ROI)– how their support will make a difference for the institution, students, faculty and society at large.

Donors have many choices to donate their money. They will give to your institution if they trust the leadership to see through their commitments. It’s about trust and commitment.

Nane Avagyan: Your book offers behind-the-scenes insights into major decisions and strategic moves that helped build an educational empire. Can you share one pivotal decision or defining moment that best illustrates your approach to institutional transformation?

C. L. Max Nikias: In the book you read the story of the USC medical enterprise being in real crisis in 2005 when I became provost and the behind-the-scenes decisions and pivotal moments over a period of three years to turn the crisis into a great opportunity of growth and academic ascent by buying the hospitals form Tenet Healthcare Corporation. Relevant sections in the book provide an insider’s perspective on the relentless planning, meticulous preparation, strategic announcement, and disciplined execution of a fundraising campaign that raised $7.16 billion in eight years, with the endowment expanding from $2.77 billion to $6.8 billion during the same period.

Nane Avagyan: In an era when universities face intense pressure to make political and social statements, you’ve maintained that institutions should stay neutral on issues outside their core mission. Yet students, faculty, and alumni often demand the university ‘take a stand’ on controversial issues. How do you hold that line without appearing indifferent to injustice or important social movement?

C. L. Max Nikias:It is not easy and has always been very challenging. The university is not a foreign or a domestic government that must comment on any political event around the world. The policies of a university need to change at the Board of Trustees level and make it clear to everybody that university leadership doesn’t comment on any political event or ideology, it only comments on issues that may affect higher education and the university itself. Ensure a neutral environment where all ideas/opinions can be debated in a civilized manner without any threats expressed against any students or other faculty.

Nane Avagyan: You launched a massive fundraising campaign that created a ‘war chest’ for recruiting what you called “better than excellent” faculty. Why is strategic fundraising so critical for universities aspiring to greatness, and how did you convince donors to invest in this vision?

C. L. Max Nikias:For private universities like USC with a medical enterprise and active research programs in engineering, medicine and sciences, they do not break even financially without philanthropy money. There is no way to elevate a university academically by executing a strategic vision without massive resources to support the academic ascent. Without raising the financial resources needed, your plans and vision are only words like fireworks that become a “pipedream.”

You inspire donors with your plans and vision for the institution and if they trust the leadership then they become enthusiastic supporters.

Nane Avagyan: The rising cost of higher education has become a national crisis. Yet you increased USC’s financial aid commitment from $180 million to $336 million, the largest at any private university in America. Why was this investment so crucial, and how does it fit into your vision of balancing excellence with accessibility?

C. L. Max Nikias:We strongly believed that the only way to keep college education affordable for students was to increase the financial aid pool. The success of our fundraising campaign allowed us to do just that. We also kept tuition increases no greater than the inflation rate which was very low when I was president. The average student loan debt of our graduating class when I was president was $25,000 for the graduating students.

Higher Education & Current Challenges

Nane Avagyan: In your book, you discuss a growing crisis in higher education. What do you see as the root causes of this crisis?

C. L. Max Nikias: Universities have, to a large extend, lost sight of their core mission in recent years, and cancel culture, microaggressions, safe spaces, trigger warnings and the mob mentality of different activist groups along with antisemitism have shaken the university campuses. Certain campuses transformed from places to face challenging ideas to places where some believed they should never be challenged. Outside agitators, activist faculty of various and competing ideologies, and impressionable students hijacked the intellectual power of universities.

Nane Avagyan: For students or young professionals feeling disillusioned about the future or the American Dream, what message would you share?

C. L. Max Nikias: I tell them to embrace the moment because they live in the best country of the world where hard work gets rewarded, where there are individual freedom and economic opportunity. 

Greek-Armenian Historical Commonalities, Resilience, and Recovery

Nane Avagyan: The Greek and Armenian communities share parallel histories of profound tragedy, including the Armenian Genocide, Turkey’s invasion of Cyprus, all resulting in lost homelands, countless lives, and mass displacement. These shared traumas have created a deep bond between our nations. Do you address this experiences in your book?

C. L. Max Nikias: Through the many stories and experiences described in the book, I hope the Armenian community identifies with them because they are not different from their own!

Nane Avagyan: What recommendations do you offer regarding collective recovery, healing, and the preservation of historical memory?

C. L. Max Nikias:As I described earlier the moment I became a refugee, it is a scar that always stays with you, a wound that never heals, a trauma that stains the soul. After our second homecoming in America, the importance of remembering and the historical memories especially for the future generations become very important. They are part of the healing. “Do not forget”what happened.

Nane Avagyan: Rather than being broken by trauma, you transformed it into a powerful commitment to education, investing in USC to advance teaching human rights, resilience, and historical truth. You view education as preventative tool against future atrocities. USC’s Shoah Foundation and its Dimensions in Testimony project have created an extensive archive of genocide survivors’ testimonies, including those from the Armenian Genocide. How can educational institutions like USC not only preserve truth, but also foster a culture where acknowledgment, remembrance, and justice are inseparable from academic excellence?

C. L. Max Nikias: I’m very proud of the fact that I secured the transfer to USC of the Shoah Foundation archives produced by Steven Spielberg, the 380 interviewees of Armenian genocide produced by Dr. J. Michael Hagopian and the more than 1,000 interviews of the Richard G. Hovannisian Armenian Genocide Oral History Collection. These testimonies provide critical material for curriculum development and for teaching the current and future generations of students remembrance and acknowledgement. They provide material for academic scholarship in history and social sciences. 

Nane Avagyan: You have strong connections with the Armenian community and played a major role in championing the USC Institute of Armenian Studies. You also established a targeted strategy to recruit Armenian American students to USC. What motivated these initiatives, and what impact do you hope they will have on both the students and the broader Armenian community?

C. L. Max Nikias: Given the large population of Armenian Americans in California and especially in the LA basin, I felt strongly that we should reach out to the Armenian American community in a similar manner the university did for the Asian American and other communities. I must confess that I have a special affinity for the Armenian American community given my upbringing in Cyprus – I grew up socializing with many Armenian children in my neighborhood – and our common culture and religion. I’m very proud that I worked closely with Charly Ghailian, Judge Tevrizian and many other leaders of the Armenian community to establish the USC Institute of Armenian Studies. 

Nane Avagyan: How do you envision the relationship between USC and the Armenian community evolving, and what role do you see the Institute playing in preserving Armenian cultural heritage?

C. L. Max Nikias: The role of the institute is that of a catalyst between USC, the Armenian American community, and the universities in Armenia, bringing all of them together for the benefit of academic scholarship and culture. USC’s Viterbi School of Engineering has established partnerships with a number of universities in Armenia, and the USC Institute of Armenian Studies can help strengthen and expand those partnerships. 

Nane Avagyan: You visited Armenia two years ago, served as a keynote speaker at the 2024 WCIT Conference. What aspects of Armenia, whether its people, culture, innovation ecosystem, left the strongest impression on you?

C. L. Max Nikias: I must confess that I was very impressed by the high-tech industry sector and the people I met and interacted with. This is an enormous economic strength of Armenia. Having served on the board of directors of Synopsys (SNPS) – an S&P 500 company; largest tech employer in Armenia – for 13 years, I knew about the brain power of Armenia in engineering, sciences, and mathematics. But still, I was pleasantly surprised how strong it is!

The delicious food and culture as well as the various monasteries and churches and the stunning view of Mount Ararat made a lasting impression on me! Finally, the visit to The Genocide Museum-Institute dedicate to the victims of the Armenian genocide was a very emotional experience.   

Nane Avagyan: What message did you share with the WCIT audience?

C. L. Max Nikias:My keynote address at WCIT was on semiconductor chips as the brains behind the artificial intelligence revolution. I should also point out that Synopsys in Armenia develops software for the design and verification of semiconductor chips!

Nane Avagyan: During your visit, you toured the TUMO Center for Creative Technologies, and you’ve since endorsed TUMO Los Angeles. What excites you most about TUMO, and how do you see it shaping the future for youth?

C. L. Max Nikias: The exciting part about TUMO in Los Angeles is that it will give the opportunity to young people of LA to experience this state-of -the-art self-learning high-tech environment in creative technologies. It is a contribution of an Armenian innovative program to the benefit of the children of LA.

The TUMO visit was very impressive, putting the young children in charge of their own learning in creative technologies! TUMO is an investment for the high-tech future of the country! 

Nane Avagyan: America has become your second home, yet you’ve remained deeply connected to your Greek heritage. How important is it to maintain this dual identity, being both a dedicated American citizen and someone faithful to their ancestral culture, history, language, and homeland?

C. L. Max Nikias:Very frequently remind our daughters who were born here in America that they should feel fortunate because the democratic ideals of the American culture are, in many ways, the same ideals of the Athenian democracy of Pericles and those of the Spartan constitution. I hope our daughters and in the near future our grandchildren as they grow up are proud of the fact that their ancestral heritage dovetails so clearly with the American culture they have been born into.

Nane Avagyan: Your story is one of resilience, vision, and mission-driven work. How do you want readers to be inspired by “American Trojan”?

C. L. Max Nikias: I hope they will be inspired by the many parallels they can draw from the stories in the book into their own experiences. I hope they appreciate the importance of endurance, hard work, resilience as well as the importance of family.

—

Ruben Vardanyan’s Wife Wants Red Cross to Clarify Legal Status of Armenian Pr

Ruben Vardanyan and his wife, Veronika Zonabend at the Samsung lab at UWC Dilijan, circa 2021


Veronika Zonabend, the wife of Ruben Vardanyan, has addressed a letter to International Committee of the Red Cross President Mirjana Spoljaric Egger on the legal status of the Armenian prisoners in Azerbaijan.

Vardanyan, who was the former state minister of Artsakh, was sentenced to a 20-year prison term, after a staged sham trial in Baku found him guilty of various trumped up charges.

The government of Azerbaijan effectively banned the ICRC from the country. The international organization’s mandate ended last fall and any contact with Armenian prisoners illegally held in Azerbaijan became limited to non-existent.

Below is the text of Zonabed’s letter.

Dear President Spoljaric,

I am writing to you on behalf of my husband, Ruben Vardanyan, an Armenian citizen, philanthropist, and former State Minister of Nagorno-Karabakh, who was illegally detained by the Azerbaijani authorities on 27 September 2023 while attempting to leave Nagorno-Karabakh for Armenia.

I would like to express my sincere appreciation for the work of the International Committee of the Red Cross. ICRC’s role and mandate are truly unique and unparalleled. In times of cruelty, war, and injustice, the ICRC remains a rare symbol of dignity, compassion, and humanity with the noble mission of protecting the vulnerable. The ICRC is one of the few international organizations in which team members have not lost their sense of mission and continue to approach their work with humanity and care. We deeply appreciate the ICRC delegates’ visits to Ruben at his place of detention in Azerbaijan. For our family, and I am sure for the families of other detained Armenians, your visits mean far more than a formal procedure.

I write with full understanding of the ICRC’s humanitarian mandate, as well as its long-established principles of confidentiality, impartiality, and neutrality. At the same time, for the families of individuals who remain unlawfully detained, it is of profound importance to receive an impartial and professionally grounded understanding of the detainees’ legal status in Azerbaijan at the time of the ICRC delegates’ visits.

This need for clarity is rendered all the more urgent in light of the manifestly deficient judicial proceedings in Azerbaijan, including trials that lack fundamental guarantees and charges that appear devoid of factual and legal basis. The suffering inflicted on the families of the detainees as a result of their unlawful detention and the conduct of proceedings that lack fundamental fairness is further aggravated by the dissemination of misleading information and the deliberate misrepresentation of the detainees’ status by the Azerbaijani authorities, who publicly and repeatedly label them as “terrorists.”

In this context, I respectfully ask for clarification of the specific legal status under which Ruben and other Armenian detainees were visited by ICRC delegates. In particular, we seek to understand whether they were considered by the ICRC as persons deprived of liberty in relation to an armed conflict, and as such whether they were prisoners of war, security detainees, internees, or have another status under applicable rules of international humanitarian law.

Such clarification would be of exceptional value. It would provide much-needed reassurance to families and contribute meaningfully to an objective understanding of how the detainees are regarded under international humanitarian law and the ICRC’s humanitarian visiting standards.

Allow me to conclude by expressing sincere gratitude for the humanity and dignity the ICRC brings to its work, qualities that remain indispensable in a world where they are too often in short supply.

Finally, I address you not only in your official capacity, but also with a deeply personal appeal to the organization whose mission has always been to place the protection of human life, dignity, and justice above formalities and political considerations. For families like ours, who are living through the anguish of prolonged and unlawful detention of our loved ones, this belief in the ICRC’s humanitarian conscience is a source of hope. I sincerely trust that this same spirit will guide your attention to the situation of Ruben and other Armenian detainees.

Yours sincerely,
Veronika Zonabend
Wife of Ruben Vardanyan

—

Asbarez: Citing Aliyev’s Demand for Constitution Change, U.S. Says ‘Hurdles’

Highlighting Azerbaijan’s demand for Armenia to change its constitution, the U.S. National Intelligence Office, in its Annual Threat Assessment report released on Wednesday, said “hurdles” still remained to a final peace deal between Yerevan and Baku.

“President [Ilham] Aliyev [of Azerbaijan] continues to insist that Armenia change its constitution to remove a reference that he characterizes as claiming Nagorno-Karabakh is part of Armenia, a step which would require Armenia to hold a constitutional referendum whose passage is not guaranteed,” the report said.

The report noted that the talks held at the White House between Aliyev, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and President Donald Trump on August 8, 2025 “has created an opportunity for the two countries to establish a lasting peace deal and contributed to increasing regional stability.”

The U.S. Intelligence Community also stressed that “the results of the Peace Summit included a provisional agreement on the terms of a peace treaty and plans to establish the ‘Trump Route for International Peace and Prosperity’ (TRIPP), managed by the U.S., that will connect Azerbaijan to its exclave of Naxcivan across southern Armenia, unlocking trade flows for both nations and the region.”

The report assessed that these developments represent “a significant change in direction for Armenian-Azerbaijani relations.” The report recalled that “in 2020 and 2023, Azerbaijan militarily retook control of its Nagorno-Karabakh region from an ethnic Armenian population supported by Yerevan.”

“Since August 8, both sides have appeared willing to maintain the momentum from the Peace Summit. Border ceasefire violations between Armenia and Azerbaijan have plummeted and now are almost nonexistent,” the report stated, noting Azerbaijan’s shipments of gasoline and permitted transshipments of wheat to Armenia.

“In October 2025, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev announced that Azerbaijan had lifted restrictions on cargo transit through Azerbaijan to Armenia, a move that Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian reciprocated within days,” the report added.

Armenia’s Justice Minister Srbuhi Galyan on Wednesday did not clarify whether a newly drafted constitution retains a reference to the Declaration of Independence.

Speaking to reporters in parliament, Galyan was vague, saying that the current draft does not yet include a preamble, where the reference appears in Armenia’s existing constitution. She added that discussions on the draft are still ongoing within the government and the ruling party’s parliamentary faction, and that the full text, including the preamble, will be published at a later stage.

While speaking to reporters on Thursday, Pashinyan, reiterated his earlier position and called the Declaration of Independence a document that sows conflict.

“The Declaration of Independence is not a declaration of independence; it is a declaration of conflict, and as a result, a declaration of dependence,” Pashinyan said, explaining that in such an environment, it is possible to live only by expecting external assistance, and expecting external assistance will place one in a continuously increasing dependence on those from whom that assistance is expected.

—

168: Global arms trade. facts and trends

March: 19, 2026

In the light of the Ukrainian conflict that has been going on for four years and the US and Israeli military action against Iran since the end of February, the statistics of the global arms trade are becoming especially relevant.

O՞v and o՞Who is selling the weapon and where?՞Do they use it and how?՞How have sales figures changed over the past ten years? Stockholm Institute for Peace Studies (SIPRI) on March 9 presented data that partially provide answers to these and other questions. No՞ that military conflict is, in fact, impossible without the use of weapons and their production or purchases abroad.

It is obvious՝ the largest producer and seller of weapons has long been the USA։ «Leader of the free worldn” with its sales in the last five years (2021-2025) occupied 42% of the arms export market. This is more than the seven arms exporting countries, which together have only 40.8% of the market: France 9.8%, Russia 6.8%, Germany 5.7%, China 5.6%, Italy 5.1%, Israel 4.4% and Britain 3.4%.

During the mentioned period, 99 countries of all regions bought American weapons, for 76 of which the USA was among the top three importers of weapons. Naturally, the most weapons were bought in Europe (35 countries received 38% of all American supplies). Latin American countries (18 countries) took the second place in the number of countries, Asia and Oceania (17 countries) and Africa (17 countries) shared the third place.

Read also

  • TRUMP IS IN A PANIC, IRAN WILL WANT A BIG PRICE. ALIEV HAS BEEN GIVEN AN ADVANCE, HE IS FEARFULLY WAITING FOR THE DAY OF QADDAFI. MIHRAN HAKOBYAN
  • The US has serious weapons problems. Arman Grigoryan
  • THERE IS AN UNSHOWABLE IDEA: IRAN WILL NOT SELL ITS INDEPENDENCE TO ANY POWER. IT IS STOPPED WITH ALL ITS POWER. KHALIL SHIRGHOLAMI, AMBASSADOR OF IRAN TO RA

Notably, US arms exports increased by 27 percent over the previous five-year period (2016-2020), while global arms exports grew by only 9.2 percent.

In addition, arms sales in Europe increased more than three times (215%). Naturally, a significant part of them are arms supplies to Ukraine, which were provided by the Biden administration in order to prevent Russia from achieving its goals within the framework of the Ukrainian conflict resolution.

It should be noted: The Middle East, where only 12 countries were buyers of American weapons, received a third (33%) of all American supplies, compared to 45% in the previous period. Taking into account the significant increase in US arms sales in 2021-2025 and the fact that the first place among buyers is Saudi Arabia (12% of all sales), and the top ten importers are Qatar (7.4%) and Kuwait (4.2%), the total volume of purchases by Middle Eastern countries decreased by 6%.

It can be assumed that one of the reasons why the US unleashed the “epic fury” military operation against Iran was the desire to increase its arms sales to the region. And all the statements about democracy and human rights are just a fig leaf with which Washington tries to cover its economic and political interests.

After all, taking into account the cost of the American Patriot air defense systems, as well as their anti-missile systems, which were mostly used by the countries of the region to protect themselves from the Iranian “Martyrs” during several days of military operations, the countries of the Middle East will have to significantly expand their budgets in order to replenish their reserves. On the other hand, only according to official data, the first weeks of hostilities cost the US $2 billion a day, so the Americans will have to sell a lot of weapons.

As the above figures show, comparing the US and other arms exporters is quite difficult, so SIPRI tried to estimate together the EU countries, which represent 28% of the global market, or two-thirds of US sales.  That volume exceeded the sales of Russian arms four times and Chinese arms five times. In general, EU arms exports increased by 36 percent in 2021-2025 compared to the previous period.

France is the second largest exporter of weapons (9.8% of the world market), supplying its products to 63 countries around the world.. About 31% of sales go to Asia and Oceania, 28% to the Middle East, and 21% to European countries. The top three arms buyers are India (24%), Egypt (11%) and Greece (10%). In addition, French arms supplies to European countries increased 5.5 times, and the total export volume increased by 21 percent.

Fourth place Germany (5.7%) increased its sales by 15%directing them to other countries in Europe (41%), the Middle East (33%), as well as Asia and Oceania (17%).

Oddly enough, Italy increased its arms exports the most (2.5 times), representing 5.1 percent of world sales and ranking sixth in terms of sales. Most of them go to the Middle East, 59%, while other regions are less interested in Italian weapons: Asia and Oceania, 16%, Europe, 13%.

Having completed the observation of EU countries, we cannot ignore Russia, which ranks third in the list of global exporters (6.8% of the market).  The main buyer of Russian weapons is India (48% of sales), and the second place is shared by Belarus and China (13% each). Unlike all other countries in the top ten exporting countries, Russia is the only country that not only did not increase, but also decreased arms exports (by 64%). The reasons for this are quite obvious, considering that all NATO countries are fighting against it at the hands of Ukraine.

It remains to mention China, which occupies the 5th place in the list of exporters, with a share of 5.6 percent of the world market., which supplies its products mainly to Asian countries. The top three buyers of Chinese arms are Pakistan (61%), Serbia (6.8%) and Thailand (4.7%).

Who became the main arms importer in 2021-2025?

There was no doubt that over the past five years, Ukraine has become the largest arms buyer in the world with a 9.7% share of the entire arms market. Although he can be called a buyer only with quotation marks, because he received most of the supplied weapons either for free or on credit, which he is unlikely to ever be able to repay.

To understand the full volume of weapons received by Kiev, it is enough to say that a quarter of all American supplies to Europe (or 9.4% of all arms exports from the United States) were transferred directly to Ukraine. Despite the fact that in 2025 information on arms received from abroad was kept secret by Kiev, SIPRI noted that the largest suppliers to Ukraine are the USA (41%), Germany (14%) and Poland (9.4%).

These data allow us to claim that the complete cessation of the supply of American weapons to Kiev will allow a quick end to the Ukrainian conflict.  Maybe not in the way the globalists would like, because Russia would unconditionally achieve its goals by military means, which the West does not want to allow in any way.

India ranks second among arms importers (8.2% of global sales). Its main suppliers are Russia (40%), France (29%) and Israel (15%).

The third and fourth places are occupied by two Middle Eastern countries: Saudi Arabia (6.8% of the market) and Qatar (6.4%). Their main supplier is the USA (77% and 48% of imports, respectively). And the top five buyers of weapons in the world is Pakistan (4.2 percent of the market), which is supplied with weapons mainly by China (80 percent of supplies).

If we divide all the buyers of weapons in the world by regions, then one third of all deliveries in 2021-2025 were made to Europe (33%), which took the first place in importing weapons. Asia and Oceania are in second place (31%), and the Middle East is third (26%). In the previous five-year period, Asia and Oceania (42%) and the Middle East (32%) were the main buyers of weapons, while Europe remained in third place (12%).

Noticeable is՝ over the years there has been a definite redirection of global arms imports to Europe, where d:its main the importer It was Ukraine. It cannot be ruled out that Europe, which is preparing for a military conflict with Russia, the Middle East, which urgently needs to buy new air defense systems and missiles for them (and the conflict with Iran is not known how and when it will end), as well as the countries of Asia, will compete for the first places in the coming years. Taiwan is wary of a military conflict with the PRC, and the US’s regional partners (South Korea and Japan) have already committed to increasing purchases of American weapons.

Peaceful life on earth, it seems, does not have to wait.

Yegor: VOLKOV

fondsk.ru

Translation by Zhanna Avetisyan




—

Iran’s adversary will resort to complex and multi-level scenarios, including the South

March: 19, 2026

Ali Larijani, secretary of the Supreme National Security Council, who was killed as a result of American-Israeli missile strikes, was bid farewell in Tehran.

Israel Defense Minister Israel Katz announced the other day about his murder, which took place during the attack on Tehran. Larijani was responsible for negotiations on key national security issues, including Iran’s nuclear program.

Ali Larijani was one of the most influential figures of the last decades of the Islamic Republic of Iran, thanks to whom the work of the state apparatus was preserved in the most critical stages for Iran. Perhaps this was also the reason why Israel targeted Larijani as well, thereby trying to turn the tide of the war. In an interview with Al Jazeera, Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi stated that the assassination of the Secretary of the Security Council of Iran, Ali Larijani, will not deal a fatal blow to the leadership of the Islamic Republic.

He added that the United States and Israel have not yet realized that the Iranian government does not rely on one individual. “I don’t know why Americans and Israelis haven’t understood this point yet. The Islamic Republic of Iran has a strong political structure with established political, economic and social institutions. The presence or absence of one individual does not affect this structure. Of course, individuals are influential, and each person plays a role; Some are better, some are worse, some are less, but the important thing is that the political system of Iran is a very strong structure,” he said. The loss of Larijani is great for Iran, but the Iranian system does not depend on one person and his decisions. It is also this belief Iranian analyst, journalist Khayal Muazzin.

Read also

  • WE WILL HAVE GOOD AND BAD SURPRISES UNTIL MAY. THE CHURCH IS THE ONLY STABLE FORCE, AROUND WHICH SHOULD ALWAYS COME TOGETHER. ARTHUR ATANESIAN
  • “It would be good if Nikol Pashinyan simply left before the elections.” Shahe Achemyan
  • Iran has mixed the energy “cards”. Why is Trump trying to de-escalate the war?

168.amIn a conversation with , Muazin said that the war between Iran, the USA and the Zionist regime is entering a new phase day by day. In his opinion, the course of the conflict is largely determined and controlled by Iran.

“The Zionist regime and the USA, acting in a state of panic, are trying to get out of the situation in a chaotic way, but day by day they are sinking deeper into the strategic impasse. Moreover, we have not yet passed the key stage of the conflict.

This war is gradually gaining a regional character and will determine the fate of the entire region, so the most significant events are yet to come. Iranian society, on the contrary, is coming together. people unite around the state, go to the squares, showing their support. Even the Iranian women brought their gold jewelry, transferring it to the needs of the army, to ensure the continuation of the resistance until the final breakthrough of the situation.

Thus, it can be said that the initial calculation of a quick resolution was not justified, and the protracted nature of the conflict favors the side that has greater internal stability and strategic depth,” the analyst said.

Khayal Muazin believes that the ceasefire has no meaning without achieving a breakthrough and forcing the enemy to recognize the reality. According to him, until the enemy understands that the language of threats and pressure against Iran does not work, and the factor of war is not completely removed from the agenda, the conflict will continue.

“Regardless of the USA’s desire to stop hostilities, a ceasefire is unlikely at this stage. “Political and diplomatic channels are practically exhausted, and now the situation is determined not by the statements of diplomats, but by actions on the battlefield. In this logic, the military factor becomes the key tool of influence and restraint,” he said.

Referring to the impact of the conflict on the countries of the South Caucasus, Muazin said that Iran’s opponent will inevitably resort to complex and multi-level scenarios.

“One such tool can be provocations and attempts to draw additional countries into the conflict through destabilization and creating artificial crises.

Iran has already repeatedly officially warned neighboring states about the risks of such scenarios and called on them not to become part of these plans. Ignoring such warnings, as the experience of a number of Arab countries has shown, leads to serious consequences.

In this regard, the countries of the region should show maximum caution and strategic restraint. The South Caucasus remains a sensitive area, and any involvement in the conflict could lead to prolonged instability. Balance and neutrality become the main security factors here,” said Muazzin. By the way, let’s remind that the Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi had a telephone conversation with the Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov hours ago. According to the message spread by the Iranian side, the head of Iran’s foreign political department stated that Tehran has the right to attack any country that provides the USA and Israel with space for aggression against it.

In a conversation with his Azerbaijani counterpart, Araghchi emphasized that according to international law, no state has the right to provide its territory and facilities to other countries for aggressive actions.

Khayal Muazin also referred to the humanitarian needs of the Islamic Republic of Iran, which the official representative of the Russian Foreign Ministry, Maria Zakharova, spoke about during her briefing the other day, stating that Iran has appealed to partner countries for humanitarian aid.

“We express our gratitude to the neighboring countries, Russia and Azerbaijan, as well as Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan, which have joined in providing assistance. It shows a responsible attitude towards regional stability and humanitarian situation.

At the same time, it is unfortunate that against the background of the happening events, Armenia has not yet formed a clear and balanced position at the state level. An impression is created that the risks occurring in the immediate vicinity are underestimated.

Such an approach cannot be considered strategically justified. Regional processes inevitably involve all participants, and timely decision-making plays a key role. There is hope that the appropriate position will be formed before the situation becomes more complicated and requires urgent steps,” said the analyst, assessing the passive position of the Armenian authorities regarding the issue of sending humanitarian aid to Iran.

—

What materials were attached to the 44-day report that “augmented” the report before?

March: 19, 2026

yesterday 168.am“Is the 44-day report now more than 200 pages or more than 400? What is Andranik Kocharyan messing up and what important things does he not remember? article: published, where we noted that Andranik Kocharyan, the chairman of the RA NA Standing Committee on Defense and Security Affairs, has always stated that the 44-day report is about 200 or 215 pages long, moreover, even when it was already forwarded to NA Speaker Alen Simonyan.

But on March 17, on the air of “Armenia” TV Company, the chairman of the RA NA Standing Committee on Defense and Security Issues declared.

“The report of the investigative commission became more than 400 pages, with its video recordings, text part, minutes.”

Agree that the difference is big.

Read also

  • “It would be good if Nikol Pashinyan simply left before the elections.” Shahe Achemyan
  • Why did Andranik Kocharyan remember the famous incident now? Who does Vazgen Sargsyan’s story about the helicopter remind you of?
  • The National Security Service wants to leave the “protection” of the National Security Service and carry out the interceptions independently.

It should be noted that when Andranik Kocharyan mentioned about 200 pages, they were mentioned again the recordings, videos, 16,000 documentary materials.

After the publication of the article, we managed to find out some things that, for example, Andranik Kocharyan attached to the report of the investigative commission as an appendix the written analysis of Onik Gasparyan, the former head of the Armed Forces of the Republic of Armenia, on 70-80 pages.

In addition to this, Andranik Kocharyan’s several-page letter-analysis related to the Su-30s, which he presented to Pashinyan, and which was also mentioned during Pashinyan’s questioning by the investigative commission, was also attached to the 44-day report.

“The much-discussed fact about the Su-30s. As a political authority, I have set a simple task before the army. say what you need and you will have it. They said: Su-30 is needed. Can you imagine an airplane from time to time? If I remember correctly, Mr. Kocharyan, you wrote me a letter on that topic and presented an analysis. I took that letter and wrote to the Ministry of Defense how appropriate it is to acquire these planes. I signed that letter to the Ministry of Defense, I said: there is such a point of view, discuss and tell. I received an answer that we discussed it, and our conclusion is that we need it,” on June 27, 2023, in the Investigative Committee. had announced Pashinyan.

By the way, Andranik Kocharyan in an interview given to Factor in February 2024 had said. “Our equipment did not fly from the beginning, then it flew partially, then it was detected and shot down. Now, in order to solve the combat problem, the General Assembly has given its consent to go to the full stage, and many have gone to the full stage.”

He then continued. “We had wrong acquisitions of weapons, by the way, I sent the information gathered by the Investigative Commission to the Prosecutor General of RA.”

Then we write We sent inquiries Andranik Kocharyan, including in connection with the Su-30s, to which he replied:

“Answers to questions about weapons and others will be included in the above report.”

And “The subjective aspect of the Investigative Commission’s report. “Following the facts” in our article we reported that an expert working in the Investigative Commission had a significant role in the preparation of the 44-day report General Staff of the Armed Forces of the Republic of Armenia Former head of the radio electronic warfare department, colonel Vahan Avetisyan, which went through the well-known arms case of 42 million to “metal scraps”, but years later the criminal prosecution against him was stopped.

However, in April 2020, when he was still in “Yerevan-Kentron” prison, open letter corrected Nikol Pashinyan, saying that “he is being harassed by the head of the State Security Service Artak Davtyan and his deputy Stepan Galstyan”.

The letter also referred to the Su-30s.

“After the velvet revolution of 2018, I had the courage to express a professionally substantiated opinion and question the feasibility of acquiring Su-30 aircraft for the RA Armed Forces.

Immediately after that, I was persecuted by the Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces Artak Davtyan and his deputy Stepan Galstyan…” the letter stated.

By the way, SUs were used in the 44-day war and solved a certain combat problem.

—

“Renunciation of the declaration of independence is Azerbaijan’s demand. are recorded only

March: 19, 2026


Today, after the regular session of the Government, Nikol Pashinyan again held a briefing with journalists, during which he explained at length what a “dangerous declaration” the declaration of independence of the Republic of Armenia is and what “conflicts it can bring to the country”.

“Imagine that you have moved to a new apartment, live on a common platform, threaten the neighbors in front, back, and next door, thus declaring independence as well. What does that mean? how are you going to live in that environment under the conditions of those threats… Only and only with external help, and that will continue to put you in a growing dependence on those from whom you expect that help.” mentioned Pashinyan.

He promised to prove it by analyzing the text in the near future.

As for the amendments to the RA Constitution, he mentioned.

Read also

  • “It would be good if Nikol Pashinyan simply left before the elections.” Shahe Achemyan
  • Why did Andranik Kocharyan remember the famous incident now? Who does Vazgen Sargsyan’s story about the helicopter remind you of?
  • The National Security Service wants to leave the “protection” of the National Security Service and carry out the interceptions independently.

“And so the Declaration of Independence is a declaration of conflict and dependence. We need the constitution and this conversation, it is a matter of our internal agenda. We have not discussed it with any external force, we are not discussing it and we will not discuss it. We are discussing it with our people.”

On the same day last week, he announced that there will be no reference to the Declaration of Independence in the new Constitution.

Human rights defender of Vardan Harutyunyan In other words, Nikol Pashinyan’s move and statement that the Declaration of Independence will not be mentioned in the new Constitution is not at all surprising.

“This was a demand, an external demand, coming from Azerbaijan, which Nikol Pashinyan, of course, could not resist.

As for the confrontation of the Armenian nation, I cannot say what will happen, or what kind of uprisings may or may not occur. But since they write the Constitution, the authorities, they can’t resist, so they submitted to the demand.” 168.amVardan Harutyunyan said in a conversation with

Continuing, the human rights defender said that this is not the first demand from Azerbaijan to RA, there were many demands in the past that were fulfilled by the authorities.

“For example, demarcation and demarcation, which was supposed to start from Tavush and continue, but it started and did not continue. Retreats are recorded in all fields, only retreats and concessions are recorded after the great defeat of 2020. Azerbaijan still gets what it demands, that’s all,” Vardan Harutyunyan emphasized.

Let’s remind that from the beginning, the Communist Party planned constitutional reforms, there was no mention of having a new Constitution, but after the defeat in the 44-day war in Artsakh in 2020, Nikol Pashinyan started talking about the need to have a new Constitution.

In parallel with all this, the President of Azerbaijan constantly declares that “the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia hinders the peace process”.

—

“Please clarify the specific legal status on the basis of which ICRC p

March: 19, 2026

The letter of Ruben Vardanyan’s wife, Veronika Zonabend, to ICRC President Miryana Spolyarich Eger, about the legal status of Armenian prisoners in Azerbaijan.

Relatives of Armenian prisoners held in Baku have been deprived of the opportunity to see them for more than two years. Families are deeply concerned about their health. Representatives of the International Committee of the Red Cross last had independent access to the Armenian prisoners. The ICRC was the only organization visiting their places of detention, but on September 3, 2025, it ceased operations in Azerbaijan at the request of the country’s government.

Under these conditions, the question of the legal status of prisoners, in the sense in which it is considered by international humanitarian law, takes on a special significance. Veronika Zonabend turned to the president of the International Committee of the Red Cross, Mirjana Spoliarich Eger, with a request for clarification regarding this issue.

We publish the letter and reiterate the request to provide clarification on the legal status of the Armenian prisoners for the period when the ICRC representatives visited them, and to consider the possibility of answering this question.

“Dear President,

I am writing to you on behalf of my husband, Armenian citizen, philanthropist and former Minister of State of Nagorno-Karabakh, Ruben Vardanyan, who was illegally detained by the Azerbaijani authorities on September 27, 2023, while crossing from Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia.

I would like to express my sincere appreciation for the activities of the International Committee of the Red Cross. The ICRC’s role and mandate are truly unique and unprecedented. In times of brutality, war and injustice, the ICRC remains a rare symbol of dignity, compassion and humanity, carrying out a noble mission to protect vulnerable people. ICRC is one of the few international organizations whose members have not lost their sense of mission and continue to approach their work with compassion and care. We sincerely appreciate the visits of representatives of the Red Cross to Ruben in the Azerbaijani detention center. For us and, I’m sure, for the families of other detained Armenians, your visits are much more important than just being an official procedure.

I am writing to you in full awareness of ICRC’s humanitarian mandate, confidentiality, impartiality and neutrality, long established principles. At the same time, it is extremely important for the families of the illegally detained to know what legal status their relatives had at the time of the ICRC representatives’ visits to Azerbaijan.

The need for clarification becomes even more urgent in light of the clearly flawed judicial proceedings in Azerbaijan, taking into account trials lacking fundamental safeguards and accusations lacking factual and legal basis. The suffering caused to their families due to illegal detention and unjustified trials is deepened when the Azerbaijani authorities publicly and regularly call these people “terrorists”, distorting the status of the detainees and spreading misleading information.

Considering the above, with all due respect, I would like to clarify the specific legal status on the basis of which ICRC delegates visited Ruben and other Armenian prisoners.

In particular, we are trying to understand whether the ICRC considered them as persons deprived of their liberty, whose deprivation of liberty was related to the armed conflict, according to which, they were considered as prisoners of war, detained for security reasons, interned or had any other status within the framework of international humanitarian law.

The clarification of this issue is extremely important. It will give families much-needed reassurance and insight into how detainees are treated under international humanitarian law and ICRC humanitarian visitation standards.

Let me conclude by expressing my sincere gratitude for the compassion and dignity that the Red Cross provides through its work. These are irreplaceable qualities, the lack of which is felt all over the world.

In the end, I want to address you not only in the form of an official letter, but also with a deeply personal appeal, as an organization whose mission has always been to put human life, dignity and justice above formalities and political considerations. For families like ours, who are experiencing the pain of long-term and illegal detention of a relative, faith in ICRC’s humanity is a source of hope. I sincerely believe that this spirit will guide you to pay attention to what is happening to Ruben Vardanyan and other detained Armenians.

Sincerely,

Veronika Zonabend”.

—