A South Caucasus alliance or friendship with ‘big countries’ – a choice for Azerbaijan, Armenia, and Georgia




  • Iraj Iskenderov

Countries of the South Caucasus

Among all the terrible news about the Russian invasion of Ukraine, one, oddly enough, made me jealous. It was a BBC report about Baltic countries preparing for a military conflict with Russia.

When looking at Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia from the South Caucasus, the contrast becomes even more apparent. These three countries have united in the face of the Russian threat. In the meantime, the governments of Armenia and Azerbaijan, with the blessing of the majority of their respective peoples, would be happy to finish each other off while Russia is distracted by Ukraine.

In times of crisis, such as now, it has become especially clear how vulnerable the South Caucasian region is – precisely because of its disunity and conflicts. In particular, it is vulnerable to the Russian Federation, which very skillfully uses our contradictions, stubbornness and complexes for its own purposes.

Will Russia remain the main mediator in the settlement of the Karabakh conflict, or will Turkey take its place?

Today it is obvious that the restrained position of the states of the South Caucasus on Ukraine is directly related to their economic and political dependence on Russia.

Georgia stands apart in this respect – it has its own history with Russia. And in the case of Armenia and Azerbaijan, everything rests on the Karabakh conflict. Without it, Russia (meaning Putin) would lose its main lever of pressure not only on both our countries but also on the region as a whole. The results of the second Karabakh war, which were supposed to put an end to this, in fact, did not change anything.

The South Caucasus is located at the intersection of the zone of interests of too many major geopolitical players: in addition to the US and Russia, it is also Turkey. And each of them is trying to pull over the blanket of the state course and public mood in our countries.

Can this completely remove responsibility from governments and societies themselves? Or do we just need to admit our own immaturity and inability to have a mind of our own?

Why did 30 years of Minsk Group’s monopoly on negotiations end and what to expect next?

Another important question is how ready are the societies themselves for the unification of the region if such an opportunity arises? To what extent are they able to refuse to sacralize their historical wounds and stop arguing about who is ‘cooler’ and who lived here longer? 

To what extent would the inhabitants of the three countries of the region be able to push their national ideas into the background and instead discuss the prospects for joint development – both economic and political?

Before the arrival of the Red Army in the Caucasus, there was a utopian territorial alliance: at first, it was the Transcaucasian Democratic Federative Republic. When Sovietization had already begun, its analog was created: the Transcaucasian Socialist Federative Soviet Republic.

Will Armenians and Azerbaijanis be able to live together and treat each other as equals, or will they remain enemies, trying to solve the conflict by force?

No, I do not mean that our countries could unite into another federation. I’m talking about allied relations of independent republics.

I had an Italian acquaintance who thought that the complete independence of small states was unnatural: they had to stick to big powers in order to survive. I jokingly called it his ‘Roman-Imperial manners’.

However, probably, small states from the same region (even though, with a population of 10 million, Azerbaijan can hardly be called small) should stick together in order to maintain their real, and not formal, independence from the major powers.


Trajectories is a media project that tells stories of people whose lives have been impacted by conflicts in the South Caucasus. We work with authors and editors from across the South Caucasus and do not support any one side in any conflict. The publications on this page are solely the responsibility of the authors. In the majority of cases, toponyms are those used in the author’s society. The project is implemented by GoGroup Media and International Alert and is funded by the European Union

https://jam-news.net/a-south-caucasus-alliance-or-friendship-with-big-countries-a-choice-for-azerbaijan-armenia-and-georgia/

Armenia between Turkey and Azerbaijan

Greece –
OPINION

The post-Soviet region is known for turbulent internal and external political processes. The hotspots inherited by states after the collapse of the Soviet Union remain to this day, and are hindering stability in this region. One of these hotspots is Nagorno-Karabakh, an independent unrecognized state with an Armenian population between Armenia and Azerbaijan, formed as a result of a military conflict (1991-94) between the two countries. Despite the fact that the international community recognizes Azerbaijan as the owner of these territories, until recently Armenia insisted on recognizing these lands as Armenian.

The Armenian Revolution

After the end of the war, power passed into the hands of military officials in both Armenia and Azerbaijan. In Armenia, despite the periodic change of power, people from the highest military level, who came to Yerevan from Karabakh, became presidents. This caused dissatisfaction among the people, especially against the backdrop of an unstable economic situation. In 2015, the former president of Armenia, Serzh Sargsyan, initiated amendments to the constitution, changing the country from a presidential to a parliamentary republic. Despite Sargsyan’s promises that he would not put forward his candidacy for the post of prime minister in 2018, he did, and was elected. In the spring of 2018, mass protests began in Armenia, which led to Sargsyan’s resignation, and Nikol Pashinyan, leader of the revolutionary movement, oppositionist and former MP, became the prime minister. Two years later, in 2020, Azerbaijan launched a large-scale offensive operation against Nagorno-Karabakh, and most of the territories came under its control. In the history of the post-Soviet region, this military conflict was called the 44-Day War, in which about 5,000 people died on each side.

Economic relations

The war ended with the signing of a ceasefire agreement between Armenia, Azerbaijan and Russia as an intermediary, which sent peacekeeping forces to Nagorno-Karabakh to ensure military stability. However, this ceasefire document also included clauses on establishing economic relations in the region without any further clarification. Now, the discussion on these economic relations has opened.

After the collapse of the Soviet Union, Azerbaijan was left with an enclave in the south of Armenia, Nakhichevan, bordering Armenia, Iran and Turkey. For 30 years, before the 2020 war, Azerbaijan had no land access to this territory. Therefore, it was expected that the discussion on the establishment of economic relations would include the opening of a land road through southern Armenia to Nagorno-Karabakh, and hence Azerbaijan. The opening of this road spurred border skirmishes between Azerbaijan and Armenia and the issue of delimitation and demarcation of the borders between the two countries arose. Without clarifying the borders first, and despite the fact that the bilateral military-political situation was still not “prosperous” enough, Pashinyan proceeded with the process of opening routes. Azerbaijan, taking good advantage of this opportunity, increased pressure by delaying the start of the delimitation and demarcation of borders, moving forward along the sovereign territory of Armenia, and demanding that the routes’ opening process be accelerated. What is even more surprising is that the prime minister of Armenia seems willing to initiate this process not only with Azerbaijan, but also with Turkey, with which there is the question of recognizing the 1915 genocide and the issue of the territorial demands of Western Armenia.

What does Pashinyan want?

‘The hostility between Azerbaijan and Armenia will not disappear with economic relations and the opening of routes. This step carries risks for Armenian national interests’  

It is known that Turkish ambitions to translate the plan of Pan-Turkism into reality are growing increasingly stronger. Establishing economic relations without preconditions (at least on the recognition of the genocide) gives the green light not only to Turkey but also to its closest ally, Azerbaijan. The Armenian government is conducting a large information campaign about the benefits of economic relations with Turkey and Azerbaijan in a manner that makes people wonder whether national interests have been put aside. It’s perfectly understandable that, for 30 years, Armenia was in a state of semi-isolation in the region. The country has borders with Azerbaijan, Georgia, Iran and Turkey, and the bulk of its foreign economic activity is with Georgia and Iran. However, the hostility between Azerbaijan and Armenia will not disappear with economic relations and the opening of routes. This step carries risks for Armenian national interests in the mid- to long term.

In economic terms, according to expert calculations, the opening of the railway from Nakhichevan to Azerbaijan through Armenia will give Armenia $1.2 million in profit per year – the payback period for the project, taking into account the planned investments, is 100 years. In addition, the economies of both Turkey and Azerbaijan are several times that of Armenia’s. When opening access to investments in the country, the economy could be captured by large Turkish and Azeri companies, which in future could be used also for political purposes.

Geopolitical situation

On this large regional football field, Azerbaijan, Turkey and Russia remain in the game, Armenia has become the ball, and Georgia and Iran have been left on the sidelines. With the opening of economic routes in the South Caucasus, Russia could diversify the ways of foreign trade in goods with Iran, Turkey and even India, whose path to Russia lies through Iran. On the other hand, Tehran is dissatisfied with the latest regional developments: firstly, because previously Azerbaijan could only trade with the southern part of Turkey through Iran, but now there will be an alternative; and secondly, because Turkey and Azerbaijan will strengthen their positions in the region, at the expense of Iran, which is already fighting for its position in the Persian Gulf.

The development of economic relations in the region at the moment seems to work against the national interests of Armenia. Is Pashinyan betraying his state or is he being subjected to political pressure from outside? It is possible that Pashinyan is afraid of a new war, therefore making friends with the enemies looks like a solution. However, in the case of Azerbaijan, Pashinyan could insist on clarifying the borders first, and in the case of Turkey, an emphasis could be given to recognizing the 1915 genocide. Also, Pashinyan could rely more on the Armenian diaspora for economic support rather than hoping for benefits from economic relations with Turkey and Azerbaijan. The Armenian diaspora, even in the recent past, has often raised funds to support the state.


Elias Hadjikoumis is a foreign, security and defense policy expert and a member of the International Institute for Strategic Studies.

UEFA to continue supporting development of football in Armenia: President Čeferin tells PM Pashinyan

Save

Share

 16:03,

YEREVAN, JUNE 16, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan received today UEFA President Aleksander Čeferin, who arrived in Armenia to attend the celebrations dedicated to the 30th anniversary of the Football Federation of Armenia (FFA), the PM’s Office said.

PM Pashinyan highlighted the programs being implemented with UEFA’s support aimed at developing football in Armenia and stated that the government of Armenia attaches importance to the close cooperation between UEFA and FFA.

Pashinyan also emphasized the importance of projects aimed at improving football infrastructure in Yerevan and provinces. He highlighted the role of football having not only social, but also important educational and psychological aspects.

Aleksander Čeferin once again offered his congratulations on the 30th anniversary of the Football Federation of Armenia, adding that UEFA will continue actively supporting the development of football in Armenia. He said that the programs will be directed to building new football fields, infrastructures, and the assistance volumes will constantly expand.

Ruling Civil Contract faction to nominate Anna Vardapetyan’s candidacy for Prosecutor General of Armenia

Save

Share

 16:22,

YEREVAN, JUNE 16, ARMENPRESS. The ruling Civil Contract faction of the Armenian Parliament will nominate Anna Vardapetyan’s candidacy for the position of the Prosecutor General of Armenia, faction head Hayk Konjoryan told reporters at a briefing.

“With both her professional qualities, high moral and value features and the requirements of the law, Mrs. Vardapetyan corresponds to the key mission, which, in our view, the future Prosecutor General of Armenia should have”, he said.

Konjoryan is sure that if elected, Anna Vardapetyan will definitely fulfill the actions authorized to her by the Armenian Constitution and laws and will be responsible before the Constitution, the legislation and her conscience.

Armenian, Russian Prosecutors General meet in St. Petersburg

Save

Share

 16:31,

YEREVAN, JUNE 16, ARMENPRESS. Prosecutor General of Armenia Artur Davtyan met with Russian Prosecutor General Igor Krasnov on the sidelines of the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum, the Office of the Prosecutor General of Armenia said.

Artur Davtyan wished success to the activities of the Forum, calling it a major platform to discuss the development of economic relations between countries in context of contemporary global challenges.

Davtyan said that recently many Russian citizens, businessmen visited Armenia, noting that the Prosecution of Armenia keeps under its spotlight the security, protection of rights and business interests of these people, keeping a stable contact with the Russian Embassy in Armenia for this purpose.

The Russian Prosecutor General highly valued the participation of his Armenian counterpart to the Forum. He praised the high level of the cooperation between the Russian and Armenian Prosecutions, highlighting the role of the Prosecutor General of Armenia in this process and expressing readiness to further deepen this partnership.

The issues on observing the agreements reached between the Prosecutors General of Armenia, Russia and Azerbaijan last year during the trilateral meetings were also discussed during the meeting. Particularly, the sides emphasized the importance of jointly investigating the ceasefire violations and their consequences and not making the exchange of information on incidents formal.

Artur Davtyan thanked Igor Krasnov for his personal contributions to solving the humanitarian problems of the conflict settlement and to launching a communication format between the sides. He said that Azerbaijan continues not fulfilling the requirements of point 8 of the 2020 November 10 trilateral statement on the ceasefire in Nagorno Karabakh, although the unconditional return of all persons and prisoners of war held in Azerbaijan is a key factor for regional peace and secure partnership. Davtyan called for uniting efforts for quickly solving this issue.

‘The welcome I received shows science is valued in Armenia’ – Ardem Patapoutian

Save

Share

 16:47,

YEREVAN, JUNE 16, ARMENPRESS. The Presidency of the National Academy of Sciences of Armenia held a session today hosting Armenian-American scientist, Nobel Prize laureate and molecular biologist Ardem Patapoutian.

During the meeting a diploma of an honorary member of the National Academy of Sciences of Armenia was handed over to Ardem Patapoutian.

NAS President Ashot Saghyan congratulated Mr. Patapoutian for the great achievement, calling it also one of the achievements of the Armenian people. “We have agreed with Mr. Patapoutian. Next time he will visit Armenia at the invitation of the Academy. There will be meetings, reports”, he said.

In his turn the Armenian-American scientist said that the welcome he received in Armenia shows that science and scientific achievements are valued in Armenia. “I started my work in a laboratory, but I never imagined that science could be a profession. But then I fell in love with that work. Surprisingly, the Nobel Prize was the motivation for me that I am proud of my biography and institutions where I studied. I have been engaged in science with pleasure and dedication”, he said.

Ardem Patapoutian was elected honorary member of the National Academy of Sciences of Armenia by the June 9 decision of the NAS general assembly.

Central Bank of Armenia: exchange rates and prices of precious metals – 16-06-22

Save

Share

 17:27,

YEREVAN, 16 JUNE, ARMENPRESS. The Central Bank of Armenia informs “Armenpress” that today, 16 June, USD exchange rate up by 3.11 drams to 427.53 drams. EUR exchange rate down by 0.08 drams to 444.67 drams. Russian Ruble exchange rate up by 0.07 drams to 7.56 drams. GBP exchange rate up by 3.25 drams to 516.29 drams.

The Central Bank has set the following prices for precious metals.

Gold price up by 256.73 drams to 25068.19 drams. Silver price up by 5.22 drams to 294.98 drams. Platinum price stood at 16414.1 drams.

Armenia committed to continue the democratic path: PM receives CoE Secretary General

Save

Share

 17:34,

YEREVAN, JUNE 16, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan received the delegation led by Secretary General of the Council of Europe Marija Pejčinović Burić, the PM’s Office said.

Welcoming the visit of the CoE Secretary General to Armenia, the Prime Minister said that Armenia, as a CoE member state, will continue the democratic path and is attaching importance to the cooperation in the field of protection of human rights, democracy development and development of independent judiciary.

Pashinyan called the work with PACE, ECHR productive and touched upon the issue of the return of Armenian prisoners of war, hostages and other civilians held in Azerbaijan, stating that the government is working closely with the ECHR on this direction. The PM highlighted the support of the international community, including that of the CoE to the solution of the issue and thanked the CoE Secretary General for addressing the issue for many times.

Marija Pejčinović Burić said the Council of Europe values the partnership with Armenia, and the purpose of her visit is to further strengthen it. She welcomed Armenia’s democratic reforms, over which the country is registering a visible progress, and highly valued the holding of snap parliamentary elections in 2021 in accordance with the international standards, which were free and competitive.

The sides also touched upon issues on the agenda of the bilateral relations. The discussion also focused on the course and challenges of the reforms in the justice sector. Pashinyan highlighted the importance of raising public trust towards judiciary, and in her turn the CoE Secretary General reaffirmed the readiness to support this process with the CoE consulting assistance, experience and knowledge.

Promoting women engagement into different spheres of public life was also touched upon. The implementation of the Armenia-CoE Partnership Program 2019-2022 was discussed.

Views were exchanged on the domestic and foreign political situation in Armenia, the regional and international security challenges. The importance of dialogue on the path of achieving peace and prosperity was emphasized.

PM Pashinyan presented the positions of Armenia on the Armenia-Azerbaijan border demarcation and delimitation, the activity of the border security commission and the peace agenda, emphasizing the importance of the addressed response of the international community to the provocative statements and actions that distort the regional stability.

PM Pashinyan presents the situation around Nagorno Karabakh to the OSCE PA President

Save

Share

 17:57,

YEREVAN, JUNE 16, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan received a delegation led by the President of the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly Margareta Cederfelt, ARMENPRESS was informed from the Office of the Prime Minster.

The Prime Minister attached importance to the close cooperation and permanent dialogue between the Armenian parliament and the OSCE PA. Nikol Pashinyan referred to the democratic reforms being implemented in Armenia and stressed the important role of the international community in their effective implementation. The Prime Minister added that the development and strengthening of democratic principles and institutions will continue to be among the priorities of the Armenian Government.

Margareta Cederfelt highly appreciated the cooperation with the Armenian parliamentary delegation, noted the latter’s dynamic activity in the Assembly. She welcomed the democratic reforms of the Republic of Armenia and highly assessed the holding of the snap parliamentary elections in accordance with international standards in 2021.

At the request of the OSCE PA President, the Prime Minister referred to the domestic political situation in Armenia, the processes taking place in the South Caucasus, and presented the situation around Nagorno Karabakh.

The Prime Minister highlighted regional stability and peace and stressed the need for an adequate response by the international community to provocative statements and actions undermining regional stability, as well as to the steps aimed at destroying Armenian cultural heritage in areas that have passed under Azerbaijani control.

At the same time, Prime Minister Pashinyan stressed the need for a comprehensive settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict within the framework of the OSCE Minsk Group.

Armenia-Iran cooperation will always contribute to strengthening of regional peace – Iranian FM receives Alen Simonyan

Save

Share

 19:16,

YEREVAN, JUNE 16, ARMENPRESS. President of the National Assembly of Armenia Alen Simonyan, who is in the Islamic Republic of Iran on an official visit, met with the Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Islamic Republic of Iran Hossein Amir Abdollahian on June 16, ARMENPRES was informed from the National Assembly of Armenia.

After the exchange of greetings, the parties spoke about 30 years of diplomatic relations between the two countries, which gave a start to the process of development of Armenian-Iranian interstate cooperation, the foundation of which was laid hundreds of years ago. Alen Simonyan noted that the bilateral relations with friendly Iran, built on mutual respect and trust, are of great importance for the Republic of Armenia, as Iran is not only a neighboring country, but also an important, reliable trade partner for us.

The sides also attached importance to the development of inter-parliamentary cooperation, agreeing that the intensification of parliamentary contacts in both bilateral and multilateral formats contributes to the strengthening of mutual understanding and trust, the expansion of scope of common positions and the development of cooperation between the countries.

The President of the National Assembly of Armenia noted that Armenia, always taking into account the interests of friendly Iran on various platforms, supported its position as much as possible and expects a respective attitude from Iran, adding that the Armenian-Iranian cooperation has always contributed and will contribute to the strengthening of regional peace and stability.

The sides touched upon the war unleashed by the Azerbaijani-Turkish tandem against Nagorno Karabakh and the situation created as a result, as well as many unresolved humanitarian issues, in particular, the return of prisoners of war.

“I think that friendly Iran’s impartial approach to pro-Azerbaijani initiatives circulating in the international and regional arenas will make a significant contribution to the peaceful settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict,” Alen Simonyan said.

During the meeting the sides highlighted the importance of the strategic dialogue with Iran and hoped for significant progress of bilateral relations in all directions.

During the discussion, the parties spoke about the investment interests of the Iranian side in the Syunik region of Armenia.

In this regard, the President of the National Assembly of Armenia highlighted the establishment of the Consulate General of the Islamic Republic of Iran in Kapan, as well as the need to open a Consulate General of the Republic of Armenia in Tabriz.

The Iranian Foreign Minister expressed confidence that the Armenian-Iranian cooperation has a great potential for development and expansion and is ready to support the development of Armenia-Iran mutually beneficial cooperation for the benefit of our friendly peoples.