Despite ceasefire in Nagorno-Karabakh, much more needs to be done to guarantee durable peace, says OSCE PA head

Panorama, Armenia
Sept 17 2021

In her first address to the OSCE Permanent Council as OSCE Parliamentary Assembly President, Swedish parliamentarian Margareta Cederfelt on Thursday urged stronger co-operation within the OSCE, noting that recent developments such as the announced closure of the OSCE Observer Mission at the Russian Checkpoints Gukovo and Donetsk and the imminent danger of cancelling the 2021 OSCE Human Dimension Implementation Meeting are troubling in this regard.

Stressing the need to bolster confidence-building mechanisms and guarantee the contribution of civil society, President Cederfelt highlighted the OSCE Special Monitoring Mission (SMM) in Ukraine as a sign of hope for greater co-operation and welcomed the Women, Peace and Security agenda, which has been a top priority of Sweden’s Chairpersonship in 2021, the OSCE PA said in a press release.

She highlighted the presence of three women at the head table of the Permanent Council, representing the OSCE Chair, the OSCE Secretariat, and the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly. “Our presence together today is a reminder of the contribution of many other women – at the Secretariat, in our institutions, in our field operations, with other international or non-governmental organizations – to peace and security in the OSCE region and beyond,” President Cederfelt said.

Regarding the SMM, she emphasized the need for monitors to be able to work unhindered and to be present along the entire border between Ukraine and the Russian Federation. She reiterated the OSCE PA’s repeated condemnation of the occupation of Ukrainian territory and expressed concern over the recent military build-up in and around Ukraine.

“In Afghanistan,” Cederfelt said, “since the fall of Kabul a month ago, there have been growing concerns over a security spill over in Central Asia and beyond. We will have to determine how we handle the Partnership with Afghanistan in the future. It is important that the OSCE PA remains plugged in, as the situation develops on the ground.”

On the topic of Georgia, Cederfelt regretted that 13 years after the August 2008 conflict, there has been no significant progress towards the implementation of the six-point ceasefire agreement. “I call on all the parties to secure its application, in letter and spirit, in particular by granting access to humanitarian aid,” Cederfelt said.

Despite the ceasefire in the Nagorno-Karabakh region, Cederfelt stressed that much more needs to be done to guarantee a durable peace to ease the suffering of civilians on the ground. “Building on our good co-operation with the parliaments of Armenia and Azerbaijan, the OSCE PA remains ready to foster interparliamentary dialogue to support this peace process,” she said.

On Moldova, Cederfelt expressed hope that the clear mandate delivered by voters during the last presidential and parliamentary elections will unlock progress in the Transdniestrian settlement process. “I would encourage all actors to support the OSCE Chair’s efforts to convene a 5+2 meeting in the coming months,” she said.

The President underlined the importance of the work of OSCE PA Ad Hoc Committees and Special Representatives, noting their co-ordination with the OSCE’s executive structures in several key areas. With growing concern over climate change, she also noted the heightened level of co-operation in the OSCE’s economic and environmental dimension, as well as strong synergies in the field of counter-terrorism. In this regard she highlighted a regional policy dialogue on foreign terrorist fighters with legislators from Southeast Europe the PA is holding next month in co-ordination with the OSCE Secretariat and with the support of OSCE field operations.

Regarding developments in Belarus, although exchanges with the Parliamentary Assembly in the past have yielded some positive results, she regretted that the authorities in Minsk have not accepted offers to facilitate inclusive dialogue. Cederfelt also expressed concern that migrants are being used to manufacture a crisis at the border between Belarus and the European Union.

Armenian, Indian FMs discuss developments around International North-South Transport Corridor

Panorama, Armenia
Sept 17 2021

Foreign Minister of Armenia Ararat Mirzoyan on Thursday held a meeting with Foreign Minister of India Subrahmanyam Jaishankar.

The interlocutors touched upon a wide range of bilateral agenda, commending the high level of traditional Armenian-Indian warm relations based on close ties. Both sides expressed readiness to raise the cooperation to a qualitatively new level, the Armenian Foreign Ministry said in a statement.

The sides agreed to start substantive discussions on cooperation on specific programs in various fields. In this context, the importance of activating high-level reciprocal visits was emphasized.

Ministers Mirzoyan and Jaishankar commended the mutual support of Armenia and India within the framework of international organizations.

The interlocutors also discussed the developments around the International North-South Transport Corridor.

The foreign ministers of Armenia and India touched upon regional and international security issues. Mirzoyan briefed his counterpart on the situation resulting from the infiltration of the Azerbaijani armed forces into the sovereign territory of the Republic of Armenia. In this context, the minister commended India’s principled position, as well as its continued support for a peaceful and comprehensive settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict within the framework of the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairmanship. Ararat Mirzoyan reiterated Armenia’s position on supporting India in the issue of Jammu and Kashmir.

The sides also discussed the situation in Afghanistan.

The meeting of the foreign ministers took place in the capital of Tajikistan, Dushanbe, where Ararat Mirzoyan is to participate in the works of the CSTO bodies.

On what basis did Armenia file a suit against Azerbaijan at UN court?

Panorama, Armenia
Sept 17 2021
See also Armenia institutes proceedings against Azerbaijan before International Court of Justice

Armenia has instituted proceedings against Azerbaijan before the International Court of Justice, the principal judicial organ of the United Nations, stating that Azerbaijan has violated the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (CERD).

Armenia contends that “[f]or decades, Azerbaijan has subjected Armenians to racial discrimination” and that, “[a]s a result of this State-sponsored policy of Armenian hatred, Armenians have been subjected to systemic discrimination, mass killings, torture and other abuse”, the court said in a press release on Thursday.

According to the filing, these violations are directed at individuals of Armenian ethnic or national origin regardless of their actual nationality. Armenia claims that “[t]hese practices once again came to the fore in September 2020, after Azerbaijan’s aggression against the Republic of Artsakh and Armenia” and that “[d]uring that armed conflict, Azerbaijan committed grave violations of the CERD”.

Azerbaijan has “continued to engage in the murder, torture and other abuse of Armenian prisoners of war, hostages and other detained persons” even after the end of hostilities, following the 10 November ceasefire, the suit said.

Armenia claims, inter alia, that Azerbaijan “is responsible for violating the CERD, including Articles 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7”. Armenia further contends that “[a]ll good-faith efforts by Armenia to put an end to Azerbaijan’s violations of the CERD through other means [have] failed”. Armenia therefore requests the court “to hold Azerbaijan responsible for its violations of the CERD, to prevent future harm, and to redress the harm that has already been caused”.

As a basis for the court’s jurisdiction, the applicant invokes Article 36, paragraph 1, of the Statute of the UN court and Article 22 of the CERD, to which both states are parties.

The suit also contains a request for the indication of provisional measures, filed pursuant to Article 41 of the Statute of the Court of Justice and Articles 73, 74 and 75 of the Rules of Court. According to the applicant, the purpose of its request is to “protect and preserve Armenia’s rights and the rights of Armenians from further harm, and to prevent the aggravation or extension of this dispute, pending the determination of the merits of the issues raised in the Application”.

Armenia thus requests the International Court of Justice to indicate certain provisional measures “as a matter of extreme urgency”.

Opposition I Have the Honor faction MPs refuse cash bonuses awarded on 30th anniversary of Armenia’s independence

Panorama, Armenia
Sept 17 2021

MPs from the opposition I Have the Honor faction in the Armenian parliament have decided to refuse the one-time cash bonuses awarded to lawmakers on the occasion of the 30th anniversary of Armenia’s independence.

“Today we were informed that on the occasion of the 30th anniversary of independence of the Republic of Armenia, all Armenian MPs have been awarded a one-time cash bonus,” it said in a statement on Friday.

In this regard, the bloc highlighted that there are many social problems in the country that need to be addressed.

“As a result of last year’s war in Artsakh, thousands of Armenians were killed, many of whom were the only breadwinners of their families, thousands of war participants still require quality medical care, tens of thousands of displaced persons, lacking permanent housing and stable income, rely on state support and social assistance from other sources, as well as there are numerous other social issues that require urgent solutions.

“Taking all this into account, the MPs from the I Have the Honor faction cannot be among the deputies, who continue to get bonuses and live a normal life, as if nothing has happened.

“The I Have the Honor faction announces that the awarded cash bonuses will be used to solve those social problems,” reads the statement.

Renaud Muselier: In the face of ongoing barbarism Armenians turn to the international law to defend their right to live in peace

Panorama, Armenia
Sept 17 2021

French politician Renaud Muselier, serving as President of the Regional Council of Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur and former Member of the European Parliament (MEP), has commented on the case filed by Armenia against Azerbaijan before the International Court of Justice (ICJ).  

“I support Armenia’s case against Azerbaijan filed at the International Court of Justice. Mass killings, torture, the use of chemical weapons and continuous border violations cannot go unpunished.

In the face of the ongoing barbarism, Armenians appeal to the international law, institutions, to defend their right to live in peace in Artsakh and Armenia. The Hague-based  International Court of Justice must now live up to this challenge, and face with dignity the Aliyev-Erdogan axis alongside the Armenians calling on it!” Muselier wrote on his Facebook. 

As reported earlier Armenia filed a case at the ICJ accusing Azerbaijan of violating the international treaty on racial discrimination. 

Artur Vanetsyan transferred his cash bonus to Homeland Defender’s Rehabilitation Center

Panorama, Armenia
Sept 17 2021

The leader of “I have the Honour” bloc Artur Vanetsyan has transferred the cash bonus awarded on 30th anniversary of Armenia’s independence to the Homeland Defender’s Rehabilitation Center. 

“As per decision of “I have the Honour” bloc, Artur Vanetsyan transferred the cash bonus received today to the Homeland Defender’s Rehabilitation Center,” the press secretary of Homeland party wrote on his Facebook page. 

As reported earlier, MPs from the opposition I Have the Honor faction in the Armenian parliament have decided to refuse the one-time cash bonuses awarded to lawmakers on the occasion of the 30th anniversary of Armenia’s independence. In this regard, the bloc highlighted that there are many social problems in the country that need to be addressed.

Armenian, French FMs point to the need of resuming the NK peace process under the auspices of OSCE Minsk Group

Panorama, Armenia
Sept 17 2021

Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan held on Friday a phone conversation with Foreign Minister France Jean-Yves Le Drian. The interlocutors commended the consistent development of Armenian-French privileged relations and reiterated their interest in expanding the multidimensional cooperation. The sides agreed to discuss in detail in the near future the prospects of promoting the cooperation in the economic sphere, including through the implementation of new development programs in Armenia.

The Foreign Ministers touched upon the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, emphasizing the need of resuming the peace process within the framework of the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairmanship. Ararat Mirzoyan noted that Armenia and Armenian people highly appreciate the position of the French government and parliament and the steps undertaken during and following the aggression unleashed by the Azerbaijani side against Artsakh.

The sides also exchanged views on the humanitarian issues following the 44-day war, in this context specifically emphasizing the immediate repatriation of Armenian prisoners of war and captured civilians held in Azerbaijan.

The sides touched upon the situation resulting from infiltration of the Azerbaijani armed forces into the sovereign territory of Armenia. The need to make efforts aimed at de-escalating and stabilizing the situation was stressed. Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan also expressed gratitude to the French side for its continued support in the fight against COVID-19.

U.S. Representatives file eight amendments to hold Azerbaijan and Turkey accountable

Panorama, Armenia
Sept 17 2021

U.S. Representatives are leading the charge to block U.S. arms and aid to Azerbaijan, as part of a series of eight pro-Artsakh/Armenia amendments to the Fiscal Year 2022 National Defense Authorization Act (H.R.4350) filed this week, reported the Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA). 

Other amendments demand Azerbaijan’s immediate release of Armenian POWs; call for an investigation of the use of U.S. technology in Turkish drones used against Artsakh and Armenia; explore ways to expand U.S. aid to Artsakh; and, designate Turkey’s “Grey Wolves” as a terrorist group.

The ANCA is leading a nationwide grassroots effort – anca.org/ndaa – to secure cosponsors for each of the amendments, which are set to be considered by the House Rules Committee as early as Monday, September 20th. The full U.S. House will have the opportunity to vote on each of the amendments ruled “in order” during consideration of H.R.4350. Amendments with strong, bipartisan backing are generally considered more favorably by Rules Committee members.

“We thank Representatives Cardenas, Pallone, Schiff, Sherman, Speier, Titus, and Valadao for offering their Congressional colleagues a long-overdue opportunity for an up-or-down vote on zeroing out all U.S. military aid to oil-rich Azerbaijan and other key pro-peace initiatives,” said Aram Hamparian, Executive Director of the ANCA. “In the wake of Azerbaijan’s ethnic cleansing last year of 100,000+ indigenous Armenians from Artsakh – amid Aliyev’s ongoing invasion and occupation of Armenian territory – the Congress must act in a bipartisan manner to hold both Azerbaijan and Turkey accountable for their violent anti-Armenian aggression.

Newspaper: Armenia-Azerbaijan agreement details known

News.am, Armenia
Sept 17 2021

YEREVAN. – Hraparak daily of Armenia writes: According to our sources, negotiations were taking place in Moscow with the Azerbaijani side over the so-called “peace agreement.”

We were told that the negotiations are over, and the Armenian side was very pleased with the results. It seems that an agreement was reached to start the process of [border] demarcation and delimitation without specifying the status of Artsakh [(Nagorno-Karabakh)], within the framework of the maps of the Soviet Union.

It was managed to extend the presence of the Russian side indefinitely, without the limitations for 5 years.

Armenia opposition MP: Border demarcation occurs when countries have no problems with each other

News.am, Armenia
Sept 17 2021

The [border] demarcation process takes place only when the countries do not have any problems with each other. Hayk Mamijanyan, a lawmaker from the opposition “With Honor” Faction, noted this Friday during the traditional briefings in the National Assembly of Armenia—and answering reporters’ questions.

The opposition MP was asked, in particular, that if the Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan is guided by the maps of the ex-Soviet Union for border demarcation, then why a bill is not tabled to the Armenian parliament for debates, and which would prepare legal and historical grounds for ensuring proper demarcation and which would take into account historical justice.

“It will be very painful and insulting for me if there are people in Armenia’s parliament who will consider that Armenia has no problem with Azerbaijan,” Mamijanyan responded.