Lucy Der Manuelian, pioneering US scholar of Armenian architecture and art, dies at 93

Boston Globe
Oct 3 2021

Nearly 50 and pursuing a doctorate after raising two sons, Lucy Der Manuelian took a four-hour climb up a mountain in Soviet Armenia one day in 1977 to study and photograph a 13th-century monastery.

“I had spent the first part of my life as a Belmont housewife chauffeuring my two sons around town, and then I found myself on this mountain peak,” she recalled a few years later in a Globe interview.

Through determination and a willingness to shoulder camera equipment to remote places — not to mention going toe-to-toe with the KGB — she brought the first images of that monastery and other churches back to Western academics.

A pioneering US scholar of Armenian art and architecture, Dr. Der Manuelian died Sept. 20 at home of complications from dementia. She was 93 and had lived in her Belmont house since 1965.

Dr. Der Manuelian was the first to hold the Arthur H. Dadian and Ara T. Oztemel chair of Armenian art in Tufts University’s department of the history of art and architecture, and she had been the force behind securing endowment funding for the position.

Focusing academically on the architecture and art of Armenia was all but unheard of in the United States when she began her doctoral work nearly 50 years ago.

“Her dissertation is also widely considered to be the first American dissertation dedicated to Armenian art,” wrote Christina Maranci, who chairs the history of art and architecture department at Tufts, in a tribute.

In an interview posted on YouTube, Dr. Der Manuelian said she had come to think of Armenian art and architecture “as a kind of lost treasure.”

When she spoke to audiences about her work, “everyone became enthralled and I felt very happy because many of them said that, you know, the lectures opened their eyes to a different part of the world — a part of the world they hadn’t known anything about — and to different periods of history that were important for Western civilization.”

Dr. Der Manuelian was drawn to her academic focus almost by happenstance.

“I was sitting in on courses at Harvard, and I kept running across these footnotes about Armenian art and architecture,” she said in the video interview.

“And it was very surprising to me because I had never run across any mention of Armenian art and architecture in any of the textbooks on the history of art,” she added. “And I began to realize that — on the basis of what the footnotes said — some more research in the field of Armenian art and architecture might answer some of the most important unanswered and haunting questions in the history of medieval art.”

Among those questions, Dr. Der Manuelian said, was how did “the medieval architects of Western Europe learn the building techniques that made it possible for them to build those towering Gothic cathedrals?”

Though some scholars believed there was a connection between European cathedrals and Armenian architecture techniques that were developed centuries earlier, there was no documentation in the art history books she studied.

“I thought,” she said, “why not pursue this field?”

Born on June 7, 1928, Lucy Der Manuelian grew up in Boston and Arlington, the youngest of three siblings.

Her mother, Armenouhy Altiparmakian Der Manuelian, had fled the Istanbul area in 1915 at the outset of the genocide that decimated the Armenian population of the Ottoman Empire. In later years, she wrote an autobiography and stories about her family.

Dr. Der Manuelian’s father, Manuel Der Manuelian, was a successful realtor.

She graduated from Girls’ Latin School in 1946 and received a bachelor’s degree in 1950 from Radcliffe College, where she majored in English.

A few months after graduating, she married Dr. Richard L. Sidman, a neuropathologist.

Their marriage ended in 1972 after she had raised her sons David Sidman, now of Brooklyn, N.Y., and Peter Der Manuelian, now of Boston, and had settled in Belmont.

“She was totally devoted to us,” Peter said, “but she was also feeding her insatiable curiosity.”

When her sons were young, she was auditing courses at Harvard University. And in a written tribute, they both noted that she also was “perfecting her gourmet cooking skills.”

Befriending Julia Child and her husband, Paul, Dr. Der Manuelian invited them over for dinner at a time when most people would have been too intimidated to prepare a meal for the famous chef.

“It was an evening full of pleasure and satisfaction,” Child and her husband said afterward in a July 1968 handwritten thank-you note.

“She was an inspiration,” David said of his mother, who he said passed along traits such as “optimism, entrepreneurship, persistence, and caring about other people.”

Her curiosity, he added, was not confined to academic pursuits.

“She would never be able to go to a restaurant without asking the waiter where she or he was from,” David said. “She would strike up conversations with everybody. She was very interested in their stories.”

Advertisement



Once Dr. Der Manuelian’s marriage was over, she enrolled for doctoral work in Boston University and a Harvard professor, Oleg Grabar, helped supervise her dissertation on Geghard, an Armenian monastery whose cathedral was finished in the 13th century. She graduated in 1980.

Her research was partly inspired by her godfather, Arshag Fetvadjian, an Armenian artist, designer, and painter known for his paintings of architectural monuments in the ancient city of Ani, which was the region’s capital before modern-day Armenia.

Dr. Der Manuelian used photography to record her explorations in Armenia, and was awarded a fellowship by what was then the Bunting Institute at Radcliffe to study Armenian churches.

“I had taken something like 60 rolls of film with me,” she recalled with a chuckle in the video interview. “I had two cameras, four lenses, and no experience in taking pictures.”

Maranci, who now holds the Dadian and Oztemel chair at Tufts, said in her tribute that “Lucy was fearless, physically and psychologically. Before the era of drones, she hung out of helicopters to take good aerial shots of monasteries and churches.”

During tense times between the United States and the Soviet Union, “the KGB suspected that she was a spy because of all her travel and photography,” Maranci added, and that led to an encounter in Armenia’s capital city.

Advertisement



“One night they visited her in Yerevan and, to avoid handing over the film, Lucy hid it inside her dress, daring them to manhandle her,” Maranci wrote. “Art history won and we have the photographs.”

In addition to her two sons, Dr. Der Manuelian leaves two grandsons and a great-granddaughter.

A memorial service will be held at 2 p.m. Oct. 23 in Story Chapel in Mount Auburn Cemetery in Cambridge.

Dr. Der Manuelian “was always just doing a hundred things at once,” Peter said, mixing fund-raising for her academic work with attending the Boston Ballet and Boston Symphony Orchestra.

“As everyone who knew her can attest, Lucy was unconventional and indomitable,” Maranci wrote. “An avid tennis player, she had boundless energy. She believed in using every minute: She kept a stack of books in the car and read at every stoplight (often to the consternation of drivers behind her).”

Whether she was teaching or hanging out of a helicopter to shoot photos, Dr. Der Manuelian could improvise her way through any challenge.

If no parking spots were available at Tufts, Maranci wrote, “Lucy sometimes held office hours in her car.”

Remains of two more Karabakh soldiers discovered in Varanda

PanArmenian, Armenia
Oct 6 2021

PanARMENIAN.Net – The remains of two more Nagorno-Karabakh servicemen were recovered on Tuesday, October 5 from Varanda (Fizuli), which came under Azerbaijan’s control during the 44-day in fall 2020, authorities report.

The bodies will be identified through DNA analysis, Karabakh’s State Service for Emergency Situations said.

Since November 13, the rescue teams have found the bodies and remains of 1680 people, including dozens of civilians, who had failed to leave their homes when their settlements went under Azerbaijan’s control.

Urgency of Armenian PoWs’ repatriation raised in Vatican

PanArmenian, Armenia
Oct 6 2021

PanARMENIAN.Net – Armenian Human Rights Defender Arman Tatoyan has raised the urgency of the return of Armenian captives illegally detained in Baku and Azerbaijan’s violation of the rights of the border residents of Armenia during a meeting with the Cardinal Secretary of State at the Vatican.

Tatoyan is currently in Rome as part of a delegation led by the Catholicos of All Armenians, Karekin II. Meeting with Cardinal Pietro Parolin on Wednesday, October 6, Tatoyan handed over to the Vatican Secretary of State his reports on and evidence of Azerbaijan’s torture and ill-treatment of Armenian captives in the aftermath of the Second Karabakh War in fall 2020.

The Ombudsman stressed the urgency of the repatriation of the Armenian captives, emphasizing Baku’s gross violations of international law and adding that the Armenian PoWs are being used as bargaining chips.

Tatoyan also weighed in on the Azerbaijani military’s incursion into Armenian soil and their deployment on roads connecting civilian settlements, which he said has endangered people’s lives and health and is accompanied by looting, threats and indiscriminate shootings.

Azerbaijani forces violated Armenia’s border in several sections in the provinces of Syunik and Gegharkunik on May 12 and 13 and are still refusing to withdraw their troops from the area. Since then, almost a dozen Armenian servicemen have been killed in Azerbaijan’s shooting, a dozen others have been wounded.

Iran offers to help build transit motorway through Armenia to avoid Azerbaijani tolls

Oct 6 2021

Iran-Azerbaijan tensions are all about Israel and geopolitics

Oct 6 2021
Fardin Eftekhari
If the situation deteriorates and Baku opts not to address Tehran’s concerns and warnings, a direct confrontation could be on the cards

The 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh war between Azerbaijan and Armenia had profound repercussions for Iran’s influence and policies in the South Caucasus. Tehran neither impacted the trajectory of the conflict nor exerted significant diplomatic influence in ceasefire negotiations and the ensuing peace agreement. 

Though Iran was the most relevant regional power in the conflict, bordering both Armenia and Azerbaijan, it was sidelined by Turkey and Russia. Tehran was obliged to align with Ankara and Moscow in supporting Baku’s territorial conquests, revealing a significant departure from its traditional pro-Armenia stance. 

From Iran’s point of view, it is Tel Aviv that provokes Baku to take a belligerent policy against Tehran and to challenge the geopolitical status quo

But Azerbaijan did not reciprocate Iran’s good faith. According to Iranian officials, Baku knowingly isolated Tehran in Nagorno-Karabakh’s reconstruction, while prioritising Israel and Arab and European countries.

Backed by mighty military powers such as Turkey, Israel and Pakistan, Azerbaijan felt it could flex its muscles against Iran’s regional power projection. Last month, Baku hosted a joint military drill with Ankara and Islamabad, aiming to further strengthen ties among the three countries and to bolster counterterrorism efforts. 

The joint drill contradicts the provisions of the Convention on the Legal Status of the Caspian Sea, which bans the “presence in the Caspian Sea of armed forces not belonging to the Parties” (Azerbaijan, Iran, Kazakhstan, the Russian Federation and Turkmenistan). On the margins of the drill, Baku tacitly challenged Iran’s connectivity with Armenia by disrupting Iranian trucks transiting a road that passes through Azerbaijan’s newly captured territories. Azerbaijan set up checkpoints, began charging fees to Iranian trucks, and even detained two Iranian truckers.

Unlike Azerbaijan’s attempt to depict recent incidents as routine procedure, Tehran sees this new, assertive Azerbaijan in a bigger picture, where Baku plays the anti-Iran “puppet” role for other regional powers hostile to Iran, such as Israel. 

Tehran initially tasked the Revolutionary Guard Corps with deploying equipment and troops across the country’s northwestern border. But this was just a small part of Iran’s grand plan to intimidate Baku. Days later, Tehran launched its own military drill near the Azerbaijani border, saying “we will never tolerate the presence of the fake Zionist regime” near the Iranian border, nor “any changes in the regional borders and geopolitics”.

This rare move, alongside hawkish comments by Iranian officials, suggests that Tehran is indeed concerned about the potential for grave geopolitical changes near its borders. 

Iranian army equipment near the Azerbaijani border on 1 October 2021 (Iranian Army Office/AFP)

Iran’s Kayhan newspaper, a publication close to hardliners, claimed that based on a Turkish-American plan, Armenia’s “western-oriented president”, in “collusion” with Baku, “intends to concede Armenia’s Syunik province to Azerbaijan”. This is the only conceivable reason for Iran’s outrage at Azerbaijan. 

Syunik province separates the rest of Azerbaijan from the Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic exclave, and constitutes the Armenian border with Iran. The 2020 peace deal between Azerbaijan and Armenia guaranteed Azerbaijan a corridor to connect Nakhchivan to the rest of Azerbaijan via Syunik province. Previously, all connections were made through Iran in the south or Turkey in the west. 

Baku is apparently not satisfied with this plan, and maintains an ambitious goal to take all of Syunik province, which could put Iran in a disadvantageous geopolitical position. Tehran would lose its connection to Armenia and convenient access to the region, while being compelled to deal with a newly emboldened regional power that is heavily backed by Iran’s arch-enemy, Israel. 

From Iran’s point of view, it is Tel Aviv that provokes Baku to take a belligerent policy against Tehran and to challenge the geopolitical status quo. The title Tehran has chosen for its ongoing drills in the country’s northwest drives this point home: Fatehan-e Khaybar is a callback to the Battle of Khaybar in the year 628, in which the Prophet Mohammed confronted the Jews of the Khaybar region, who were inciting Arabian tribes against the Muslims of Medina. 

How the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict could ignite a Middle East flare-up

Read More »

Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei recently warned Azerbaijan against aligning with Israel, noting: “Those who think that their security will be ensured by relying on foreigners should know that they will pay a hefty price.”

The type and scale of military equipment stationed at the border suggests that Iran intends to deter Baku from territorial adventurism, but Tehran ultimately wants to avoid an armed clash. If the situation deteriorates and Azerbaijan opts not to address Tehran’s concerns and warnings, Iran may cross the border to push preemptive deterrence from Armenian soil. A key factor at that point would be the extent to which Azerbaijan’s allies, primarily Turkey, would be prepared to support Baku and participate in a direct confrontation with Iran. 

Meanwhile, Iran seems determined not to step back without affirming its national security red lines, establishing a credible level of deterrence, and asserting its undeniable regional role, which has been somewhat tarnished amid the recent security developments in the South Caucasus. 

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Eye.


Catholicos of All Armenians discusses consequences of 44-day war with Pope Francis

Public Radio of Armenia
Oct 6 2021

His Holiness Karekin II, Supreme Patriarch and Catholicos of All Armenians, met with His Holiness Pope Francis in the Vatican. During the conversation, the Catholicos touched upon the catastrophic consequences of the 44-day war, the current challenges facing Armenia and the Republic of Artsakh, especially emphasizing the issue of the return of prisoners of war and other detainees held by Azerbaijan.

His Holiness Karekin II also thanked Pope Francis for his support to the Armenian people and Armenia during the war.

At the end of the meeting, the Pontiff blessed the members of the delegation led by the Catholicos of All Armenians.

Afterwards, the delegation led by the Catholicos met with Vatican’s Secretary of State, Cardinal Petro Parolin. During the conversation, reference was made to the situation in the region after the 44-day Artsakh war.

In particular, issues related to the security of the people of Artsakh, the encroachments on the sovereign territories of Armenia, as well as the preservation of the Armenian spiritual and cultural heritage in the territories under the control of Azerbaijan were discussed.

The Catholicos of All Armenians attached great importance to the role of the international community in overcoming the existing challenges and problems.

Ground broken for Armenian church in Iraqi Kurdistan

Public Radio of Armenia
Oct 6 2021

The groundbreaking ceremony of the Armenian St. Mariam Astvatsatsin (Mother Mary) Armenian Church was held in the city of Zakho in Iraqi Kurdistan.

The ceremony was presided over by Primate of the Iraqi Diocese of the Armenian Church Archbishop Avag Asaturyan.

Attending the event were Consul of the Armenian Embassy in Iraq Alik Gharibyan and Armenian Consul to Erbil Andranik Harutyunyan.

According to the ritual of the Armenian Apostolic Church, 16 stones washed by water and wine were placed in the foundations of the church under the singing of hymns and psalms.

Baku-Nakhijevan flight carried out through Armenia’s airspace, Civil Aviation Committee confirms

Public Radio of Armenia
Oct 6 2021

Armenia’s Civil Aviation Committee has confirmed that on October 6 a flight on the Baku-Nakhijevan route was carried out over the airspace of the Republic of Armenia.

The use of the airspace of both Armenia and Azerbaijan has never been restricted for civilian aircrafts, except during the 44-day war, the Committee said in a statement.

Flights on the mentioned route were regularly carried out before November 8, 2014, after which the Azerbaijani side chose to stop using the airspace of the Republic of Armenia.

At the same time, the Civil Aviation Committee said flights from Zvartnots Airport to other countries and in the opposite direction have been carried out all this time.

It added that the transit aviation permits are not issued by the Armenian aviation authorities, as according to the procedures, no permit is required for the implementation of transit flights by civil aircrafts.

The right to choose the routes is reserved for the aircraft operators.

Azerbaijan returns one more captive to Armenia – Deputy PM

Public Radio of Armenia
Oct 6 2021

The Azerbaijani side has returned one more captive to Armenia, Deputy Prime Minister Suren Papikyan said at the Q&A session at the National Assembly.

“Artur Davtyan, who had crossed the Artsakh border on August 22, 2021, has already returned to Armenia,” Papikyan said.

According to the Deputy PM, the Armenian authorities are doing their best to ensure the return of all captives.

One Armenian POW returns from Azerbaijan, Deputy Prime Minister says

TASS, Russia
Oct 6 2021
Suren Papikyan stressed that the POW was already on Armenian territory

YEREVAN, October 6. /TASS/. One Armenian citizen held by Azerbaijan returned to his home country, Armenian Deputy Prime Minister Suren Papikyan told lawmakers Wednesday.

“At this very moment, one POW is returning to – or actually already is on – Armenian territory. This is Artur Davidyan, born in 1989, who crossed the [Nagorno-Karabakh] border on August 22, 2021,” Papikyan said, according to a livestream on YouTube.

The situation in Nagorno-Karabakh escalated on September 27, 2020, with hostilities sparking at the disputed territory. On November 9, Russian President Vladimir Putin, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev signed a joint statement on complete cessation of hostilities. According to the document, Armenia and Azerbaijan stopped at their actual positions at the moment, a number of districts went under Baku’s control, and Russian peacekeeping forces were deployed along the contact line and the so-called Lachin corridor.