15:04,
STEPANAKERT, OCTOBER 24, ARMENPRESS. The Artsakh Defense Army reported an additional 36 KIAs, bringing the total death toll in the Artsakh military amid the Azeri attacks to 963.
Editing and Translating by Stepan Kocharyan
15:04,
STEPANAKERT, OCTOBER 24, ARMENPRESS. The Artsakh Defense Army reported an additional 36 KIAs, bringing the total death toll in the Artsakh military amid the Azeri attacks to 963.
Editing and Translating by Stepan Kocharyan
14:58,
YEREVAN, OCTOBER 24, ARMENPRESS. American actor, filmmaker and producer Sean Penn commented on Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s policy on Armenians.
“As too many of us sit on our butts, Armenians are being slaughtered by Trump pal Erdogan with weapons WE provided. THIS is NOT America! Biden for America’s new birth!” Sean Penn said on Twitter.
On September 27 Azerbaijan, with the support of Turkey, launched a massive attack against the Republic of Artsakh (Nagorno Karabakh), by using all its ammunition, targeting also the civilian infrastructures both in Artsakh and Armenia. There are confirmed reports that there are mercenaries in the Azerbaijani army brought from Syria by Turkey for fighting against the Armenian side.
Editing and Translating by Aneta Harutyunyan
by Lisa Gulesserian (Harvard University) and David L. Phillips (Columbia University)
Armenian demonstration blocks Spain-France highway
15:35,
YEREVAN, OCTOBER 24, ARMENPRESS. The highway linking Spain with France is blocked amid a major Armenian demonstration where protesters are voicing about the Turkish-backed Azerbaijani aggression on Artsakh.
The demonstrators demand Spain not to remain silent and to officially recognize Artsakh as an independent country.
Protesters are chanting “Erdogan is a terrorist”, “Wake up Spain”, “Stop the War”.
Editing and Translating by Stepan Kocharyan
Share
15:21,
YEREVAN, OCTOBER 24, ARMENPRESS. The Armenian Defense Ministry has released a video showing the Artsakh Defense Army striking an Azerbaijani TOS-1A heavy multiple rocket launcher.
October 24, 2020
The author, Alec Minassian, with his classmates at a fund-raising event at Ferrahian
BY ALEC MINASSIAN
Following years of unprecedented turmoil and dispute along the Artsakh border with Azerbaijan, the aggression by the Azerbaijani regime has prompted overwhelming activism and decisive work in paving a path toward a more peaceful, stable condition in the region. In the face of civilian bombings, Syrian mercenaries, and authoritarian propaganda, the Armenian people and their undying spirit have proven more resilient and steadfast than any opposing force.
In the diaspora, I am met with faces of concern and prayer, but more optimistically, I’ve been enlightened and inspired by the courage and determination my classmates, teachers, friends, and family have shown. My classmates and I have taken on the initiative of putting together necessary action to overcome the current hardships we face in the homeland. Within the last few days, students, teachers, faculty, and parents have come together in unprecedented fashion to host medical supply drop-offs, social media awareness calls, Congressional text banks and petitioning, and even a car wash fundraiser that generated thousands of dollars for our soldiers fighting for their ancestral homeland.
Our community united immediately to give generously and work peacefully. Over the last three weeks, we’ve proven our strength, humility and capacity to outlive the cruel and inhumane aggression of the Azeri regime. Internationally, the Armenian community has and will continue to persevere beyond financial, social, or political downturn, because ultimately, the Armenian spirit is one of inherent determination, passion, and optimism. The work I’ve been proud to share is testament to that reality, and from it comes a certainty and an open-mindedness that is unique to the Armenian people. A certainty that ancestry, culture, diversity, and history will always overcome hatred, greed, and evil.
As a Diaspora made up of inspired, passionate Armenians, this work defines us, and the contributions we make to the homeland are both necessary and incredibly valued. Petitioning Congress, raising funds, employing social media, and inspiring the international community will prove the difference in this horrific exposal of indecency, and ultimately, there is an abundant faith and sincerity that permeates throughout the Armenian diaspora and Armenian homeland, and that sincerity and optimism is certainly an extension of the fighting spirit we are never to abandon.
We remain committed to our efforts, individually and collectively. Continue your activism through the Armenian National Committee of America. Be inspired by our schools and churches and the thousands of volunteers dedicated to the Armenian Relief Society, ArmeniaFund and other humanitarian aid organizations. Remain active. Remain committed. Remain spirited.
Alec Minassian is a senior at Holy Martyrs Ferrahian Armenian School.
15:42,
YEREVAN, OCTOBER 24, ARMENPRESS. Member of Parliament of the Netherlands Sadet Karabulut has called on the Dutch government to take action to stop Turkey and Azerbaijan in the attacks on Artsakh. She tweeted the Human Rights Watch report on the Azeri use of prohibited cluster munitions against Artsakh and said that the Azeri actions are “unacceptable”.
“Scandalous. Unacceptable. The Cabinet must speak out strongly and do something to stop Azerbaijan and Turkey. Every minute counts. Break the silence,” she said in a tweet addressed to PM Mark Rutte.
Editing and Translating by Stepan Kocharyan
Saturday, U.S. Still Sees No ‘Military Solution’ To Karabakh Conflict U.S. - U.S. National Security Adviser Robert O'Brien (L) meets with Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov, Washington, . U.S. National Security Adviser Robert O’Brien insisted that there can be no “military solution” to the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict after meeting with Armenia’s and Azerbaijan’s foreign ministers in Washington late on Friday. “In my meeting with Azerbaijani FM [Jeyhun Bayramov] I pressed for an immediate ceasefire, then a return to Minsk Group-facilitated negotiations with Armenia and rejection of outside actors further destabilizing the situation. There is no military solution,” the U.S. National Security Council quoted O’Brien as saying on its Twitter page. O’Brien made a somewhat different comment on his separate talks with Armenian Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanian. He said they met to “discuss the need for an immediate ceasefire” and the resumption of Armenian-Azerbaijani peace talks mediated by the three Minsk Group co-chairs: the U.S., Russia and France. “The U.S. will continue our strongest diplomatic efforts at all levels until the conflict is resolved,” added President Donald Trump’s key adviser. U.S. - Armenia's Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanyan meets with U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo to discuss the conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh, at the State Department in Washington, U.S., The Trump administration invited Bayramov and Mnatsakanian to Washington as part of its efforts to stop the nearly month-long war in and around Karabakh. The two ministers also separately met with U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo earlier on Friday. Pompeo said he discussed with them “critical steps to halt violence in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.” He did not report any fresh Armenian-Azerbaijani agreements that effect. Trump spoke afterwards of “really good progress” made in U.S. mediation efforts. But he did not elaborate. “We don’t yet know what progress they are talking about,” a spokesman for Russian President Vladimir Putin told the RIA Novosti news agency on Friday night. Putin expressed hope on Thursday that Washington will contribute to Russian efforts to get the conflicting parties to respect a ceasefire agreement that was brokered by Moscow on October 10. A similar “humanitarian” truce agreement brokered by France on October 17 has also not been observed. Both warring sides reported on Friday fresh fighting and shelling of civilian areas in the conflict zone. NAGORNO-KARABAKH -- Pople mourn during the funeral of a soldier who died in recent military clashes Karabakh, Stepanakert, At his meeting with O’Brien, Mnatsakanian again held Turkey responsible for the continuing bloodshed. According to the Armenian Foreign Ministry, he claimed that Ankara is keen to destabilize the region by recruiting Middle Eastern “terrorist fighters” for the Azerbaijani army and providing other military assistance to Baku. The Turkish and Azerbaijani governments deny Turkey’s direct involvement in the ongoing war. Pompeo criticized Ankara’s role in the Karabakh escalation last week. “We now have the Turks, who have stepped in and provided resources to Azerbaijan, increasing the risk, increasing the firepower that’s taking place in this historic fight,” he said. Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL Copyright (c) 2020 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc. 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
Since Azerbaijan launched its assault on Armenian forces in the Nagorno-Karabakh region on September 27, there has been a torrent of violent imagery from both sides on social media.
Video after video depict drone strikes setting military vehicles ablaze and unsuspecting troop formations abruptly vanishing in spasms of artillery fire. Photos reveal urban apartment buildings torn apart by massive rockets, and corpses piled up like cordwood after deadly ambushes in narrow valleys. Reporters venturing to Armenian and Azerbaijani communities mid-bombardment have shared images of devastation and tales of suffering.
It’s possible to draw upon this huge but disturbing body of evidence to gain insight into what is happening on the ground—even while remaining mindful that what gets recorded on camera and shared on the internet is by no means the whole picture.
Here’s what open sources and journalistic accounts can and can’t tell us about territorial changes in the conflict, vehicle losses, the number of dead, drone losses, attacks on civilians, war crimes, and the role played by Turkey in the war.
Azerbaijani Ground Force Have Captured Significant Territory
The war is over Nagorno-Karabakh, a region which has an Armenian majority population, but which de jure is generally recognized as Azerbaijani territory.
Since a war in the 1990s, a de facto Armenian government called Artsakh or the Nagorno-Karabakh Republic (NKR) has controlled the region, and several Azerbaijani districts outside of it, with support from Armenia.
A mutual history of atrocities and ethnic cleansing predating the fall of the Soviet Union has resulted in decades of border skirmishes and deepening enmity and mistrust between Armenians and Azerbaijanis, with little progress towards a peaceful resolution.
As of October 22, Azerbaijani forces have seized a number of towns and strategic heights from Armenian troops across the breadth of the frontline in Nagorno-Karabakh, including the (until recently) populated towns of Hadrut, Mataghis and Zangilan, as well as many depopulated ghost towns such as Füzuli, Jabrayil and Talish.
While Armenian and Azerbaijan have offered conflicting accounts, some of the territory changes can be verified by geo-locating photos of Azerbaijani troops in these areas.
Using geo-location of photos, one analysis on October 22 estimates Azerbaijan has occupied nearly 10% of the territory in Nagorno-Karabakh formerly held by Armenian forces, up from an estimated 2.8% according to different analysts in an article published October 14.
In a speech on Oct. 20, Azerbaijani leader Ilham Aliyev suggested expansive objectives for expelling Armenian forces from the Nagorno-Karabakh region. Despite earlier signaling openness to negotiations, Armenian Prime Minister Pashinyan subsequently stated Armenians would have “victory or defeat, nothing in between.”
Azerbaijan’s military will hope its territorial gains will rupture the cohesion of the Armenian defensive lines, allowing them to advance with greater momentum at lower cost.
The naturally-occurring fortifications created by Nagorno-Karabakh mountainous terrain assist such defensive strategy. Commanding heights overlook ground largely devoid of cover and narrow road chokepoints create abundant opportunities for lethal ambushes.
Armenian troops also appear in recent videos to have fallen back to wooded terrain providing cover from aerial observation and attack.
But mountainous terrain holds perils for the defender too, constraining lines of resupply, retreat and counterattack. Notably, if Azerbaijan succeeds in physically occupying the Lachin highway connecting Stepanakert to Armenia, than the de facto Nagorno-Karabakh Republic could become untenable and even civilian refugees may find themselves without a route through which to flee the fighting.
This coincides with a second issue: behind the frontline fighting, Armenian support units and lines of communication have come under an aerial assault of unprecedented scale in the long-running conflict.
Hundreds of videos released by Azerbaijan show drones blasting Armenian fighting vehicles and heavy weapons, as well as destroying resupply and reinforcement convoys. Azerbaijan’s government is posting the strike footage on digital billboards for public viewing.
Azerbaijan’s attack helicopters, by contrast, have only seen limited use. Armenian aviation has not been active, save for an Su-25K attack jet sortie which ended with the loss of the plane under disputed circumstances.
We can quantify some of the scale of the material losses suffered by Armenian forces due to work by open-source intelligence bloggers Stijn Mitzer and Jakub Janovsky, who document and classify vehicle losses confirmed by visual media from both sides, taking care to avoid counting the same damaged or destroyed vehicle more than once.
Of course, their tally cannot account for all the losses which haven’t been recorded and shared on the internet, or that otherwise escaped their notice. However, they do offer a minimum count of the damaged, destroyed or captured vehicles that can be visually verified.
Air defense vehicles damaged or destroyed include:
Two loitering munition strikes early in the conflict struck dummy air defense vehicles. However, the successful use of such decoys has not been documented since.
After the first few days, drone strikes were primarily directed at vehicles, facilities and artillery behind or approaching the frontline.
The following is a non-comprehensive list of Armenian vehicles that have been shown to be damaged, destroyed or captured. In aggregate, they amount to the loss of around five armored or mechanized battalions.
Armenian artillery losses appear equally staggering as of Oct. 22, equivalent to the destruction of six or seven artillery battalions in aggregate:
Starting around mid-October, drone footage showed a new emphasis on hitting infantry positions, presumably near the frontline.
Meanwhile, since the beginning of hostilities, the destruction or capture of the following Azerbaijani armored vehicles were recorded, mostly using anti-tank guided missiles, artillery and rocket propelled grenades:
There are several important caveats to bear in mind when considering these numbers.
First, because Armenian forces aren’t operating combat drones, they inevitably are recording less imagery of vehicles getting destroyed.
As detailed in this earlier article, both Armenia and Azerbaijan are unleashing long-range artillery on each other’s civilian population centers. Armenia has reported 37 civilian dead so far, while Azerbaijani media reports 61 dead.
Azerbaijan has continuously bombarded the Nagorno-Karabakh regional capital of Stepanakert and the nearby cultural center of Shusha/Shushi.
Armenian forces also reportedly used Tochka (SS-21 Scarab) and Scud ballistic missiles in four separate attacks on Ganja between Oct. 5through Oct. 17, killing 25 civilians.
Cluster munitions, which are banned in many countries, but not by the combatants in question, were identified showering down on Stepanakert. The munitions are reportedly of Israeli manufacture.
The deliberate attacks on civilians, which are war crimes, are likely intended to demoralize their respective civilian populations, and decrease support for a continued war effort. The ultimate effect can only be to deepen the enmity between the two nations.
War Crime On Video
A video shared on Azerbaijani social media appear to show an incident in which two Armenian soldiers surrender to Azerbaijani troops at Hadrut. A subsequent video (not shared here) appears to show the killing of the same two POWs.
The Azerbaijani government later took down the videos and claimed they were fake. However, a detailed investigation by Bellingcat concluded they appeared to be authentic.
Other crimes have been alleged by both sides but have not been verified as far as the author knows.
Just how involved is Turkey?
Ankara openly supports Azerbaijan’s campaign in Nagorno-Karabakh. However, journalists and open source intelligence has illuminated aspects of the relationship that were unconfirmed or contested.
Most importantly, Turkey quietly transferred TB2 drones to Azerbaijan prior to the commencement of hostilities. Their activity over Nagorno-Karabakh was discerned through open-source analysis a week before Azerbaijani officials admitted their presence.
Multiple and distinct press outlets have also seemingly confirmed rumors denied by Ankara that Turkey had transported mercenaries recruited from Syrian rebel groups to support Azerbaijan’s campaign.
Armenian sources have also claimed Turkish F-16 fighters have attacked Armenian targets. A New York Times NYT investigation released satellite photos confirming the presence of two Turkish F-16s in Ganja International Airport in Azerbaijan.
However, this does not necessarily prove the F-16s have been used in a combat role—they may have been detached to escort Turkish cargo planes transporting arms to Azerbaijan instead.
Final Thoughts
Earlier in October, several observers remarked that the huge destruction apparently inflicted by Azerbaijan’s drones interdicting vehicles behind the frontline had not resulted in major territorial gains, the objective of Azerbaijan’s offensive.
Air forces tend to prefer interdiction missions rather than close air support at the frontline because vehicle convoys and conspicuous rear-are bases and bivouacs are more vulnerable than well-camouflaged and entrenched frontline units.
But interdiction strikes have a delayed payoff: they reduce an enemy’s ability to resupply and reinforce frontline units and concentrate fresh forces to mount counteroffensives.
It’s too early to tell whether Azerbaijani ground forces will sustain the advance or get bogged down by Armenian defenses, difficult terrain and forthcoming winter weather. However, if Azerbaijani troops manage to cut off the logistical link connecting Stepanakert to Armenia, the position of Armenian forces in Nagorno-Karabakh may become highly precarious.