Asbarez: ‘Yeva’: Looking for Paradise

Anahid Abad’s “Yeva”

BY ZAREH AREVSHATIAN

Anahid Abad’s film, “Yeva,” opens in darkness. It is raining. A woman, holding an umbrella, walks briskly into a building at night. There she sees her young daughter who’s been waiting for her alone. We don’t really understand their situation until a few scenes later. She is escaping but despite the absence of pursuers, the film gradually becomes the tale of a woman’s attempt to run away from a violent domestic life; a narrative based on too many true stories.

Narine Grigoryan plays the title character, a woman trapped by circumstances and personal choices. Accused by her in-laws of killing her husband, Yeva is forced to flee Yerevan with her daughter Nareh and take refuge in a small remote village of Dadivank in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabagh) where Rouben, a friend and a war veteran, and his wife Sona, unreservedly welcome her into their house. Yeva’s inner life remains hidden. We only get a hint of what has happened to her and as the narrative reveals its secrets, the film places us in a contradictory state between optimism and fatalism, and leaves us alarmingly alone with her daughter.

The film may sound like it has the makings of a strained domestic melodrama, filled with teary speeches and dangerous acts of parental selfishness, but viewers should expect a more contemplative affair. The film looks and sounds like something formed by TV conventions but it shows itself concerned with a very particular kind of female experience. This is not simply a film about an Armenian woman on the run. It is about domestic tensions, the story of women in Armenia.

Yeva is the Armenian name for the Biblical figure, Eve but as mentioned earlier, the film is not just about her. It is about generations of women living in an Armenian patriarchal society. Whereas a traditional Armenian family simply reacts to will of fate, here we have women who attempt to change theirs. The women in the film are objects of reflection and vehicles for cultural and social change. The women of “Yeva” are survivors.

Domestic violence in Armenia is often dismissed as a “family matter.” These “matters” don’t leave the boundaries of the house and are rarely reported to the police. Men also have property rights and are usually the prime owners of the house. Moreover, there is the issue of protection and/or deprivation of parental rights in Armenia and how it is handled by the law. Even though none of these issues are referenced explicitly by the film, they do form the backbone of the drama and it is to Anahid Abad’s credit that the film takes the onus to hopefully start a trend in Armenian cinema, whereby pressing and relevant social issues are discussed in a non-dismissive and non-trivial manner as they are in the violent serials flooding the television channels.

By focusing on the women, Abad has created a contradictory film: a gesture of benevolence tinged with the guilt and celebration of female power. With the exception of the police officer in charge of enforcing the law, men are not at the center of this film. They are present but the film does not revolve around them. Sympathetic to Yeva’s cause, all of them try to extend a helping hand but fail eventually.

Co-produced between Iran’s Farabi Cinema Foundation and the National Cinema Center of Armenia, “Yeva” is the first Armenian-Iranian co-production, the first Armenian film with an Iranian production crew, and the first feature film directed by an Armenian-Iranian woman. Born to an Armenian family in Tehran, Iran, Anahid Abad holds a BA in film directing. During her career, she has served as first assistant director and production manager on many Iranian films. It should come as no surprise that Abad’s first feature is set in Artsakh – a region where her paternal lineage hails from.

In her collaboration with cinematographer Hassan Karimi, Abad creates an impressive colored tableau, almost entirely in medium shots, that capture the warmth of the villagers and their home lives without seeming to intrude upon their space. There is a visual tension between the spectacular shots of the village landscapes and the drab and muted colors of the interiors as if to indicate a feeling of entrapment within a historical and ancestral space. And even though the “War” is consistently referred to and is clearly felt in the background, “family” is the thematic focus of “Yeva.”

Parts of the movie’s pleasure are to be found in scenes depicting the communal dimension of the dinner table, be it a welcoming dinner party or a local wedding. It is no secret that an Armenian dinner table is an _expression_ of generosity. Family, friends, even strangers are not discriminated at such gatherings and Anahid Abad captures these moments quite masterfully. Nonetheless, it is how these scenes act as bridges between intimate family moments and the shocks that follow that manifest Abad’s ability to conjure up a mixed emotional atmosphere that is tender and yet poignant. The movie runs only 94 minutes, but captures magnificently the cultural and social forces at play by making the village a microcosm of an entire nation.

“Yeva” presents a full cast of actors from Armenian stage and cinema in surprisingly fresh portrayals. Shant Hovhannisyan, known to many from the police drama “Special Unit,” plays the very mild-mannered and sympathetic Rouben. Fans of the sitcom, “Full House,” might not even recognize Marjan Avetisyan, the landlady, Mrs. Tamara, from the show, as Hasmik in the movie and Rosie Avetisova, who has mostly appeared in soap operas and episodic serials, appears in a small but pivotal role in the film. The film is also populated by non-professional villagers who simply appear as themselves. It is interesting to note that lead actress Narineh Grigoryan, who is by birth from Artsakh, is the only native actor who does not speak with a local accent. All other actors in the film are from Yerevan but speak with a local dialect.

In 2018, “Yeva” was banned from participating at the International Filmmor Women’s Film Festival in Turkey at the behest of the Azerbaijani Government, which claimed the film “creates the impression that Artsakh is an Armenian territory.” Inconsequentially, the film has gone on to garner numerous awards and accolades worldwide.

“Yeva,” was Armenia’s submission for the Best Foreign Film Category at the 2018 Academy Awards and is now being distributed by New York-based Venera Films. It is scheduled to have its North American theatrical release in late October.

“Yeva” will open in New York on October 25 and in LA on November 1 at Laemmle Glendale, located at 207 N Maryland Ave, Glendale, CA 91206. For more info follow “Yeva” on Facebook.

Zareh Arevshatian is a Los Angeles-based independent film scholar.




Asbarez: Ardy Kassakhian Announces Campaign for Glendale City Council

Ardashes “Ardy” Kassakhian

GLENDALE—This week, longtime Glendale City Clerk Ardashes “Ardy” Kassakhian announced his campaign for Glendale City Council. Kassakhian, who was elected as City Clerk in 2005, made his announcement through an email to his supporters and friends. The email is available below.

Dear Friends and Neighbors,

When my wife and I became parents five years ago, we quickly learned that being a parent and raising a child is both the hardest and simultaneously most important job we will ever have. It’s been a great blessing to raise our son in the city of Glendale – the same city I grew up in. As a parent and your elected city clerk, I ask myself everyday, “What can I do to leave a brighter future for my child and to coming generations?”

Like many of you, I have watched our nation divide itself along political lines, and I cannot sit back and watch the impact it is having both nationally and locally, without rolling up my sleeves to bring common sense solutions to the challenges we face. Many of you have encouraged, urged and asked that I run for city council and I took all of your calls, emails, and comments to heart.

It is for this reason that I’m writing to let you, my closest supporters, know that I have decided to run for the vacant seat on the Glendale City Council in the upcoming election in March of 2020.

Over the last 14 years, I’ve been fortunate enough to follow and be engaged with all matters and affairs concerning our Jewel City. I’ve witnessed what Glendale was, what it is, and what it is becoming. But most importantly, I know what it can be if we work together. Given my breadth of experience in City Hall, I know our city’s strengths, and I definitely know where it needs change and improvement. Despite all progress and everything we have accomplished, we have work to do.

In the coming weeks and months, you will hear more from my campaign about where I stand and why, but I wanted you to be the first to know about this important step I am taking. In these trying times, the national stage deserves our attention, but let’s not forget that change starts here, at home. Nowhere do our actions matter more than at the local level. I have devoted myself to the City of Glendale, and now humbly ask for your support as I seek to continue serving our Jewel City by joining the City Council.

The Glendale City Council elections will be held on March 3, 2020.

Asbarez: Archaeologists Discover New Temple in Armenia’s Erebuni Fortress

Archaeologists excavating Armenia’s Erebuni Fortress

BY STEPAN KOCHARYAN

YEREVAN (Armenpress)—The foundation of a new temple has been discovered at the Erebuni Fortress in Yerevan by a joint Armenian-French expedition team, bringing the number of temples at the site to three, which in turn allows the fortress to be considered a “cultural-historical complex.”

A gravel ground mosaic existed in front of one of the temples, which suggests that, during the days of Urartu, there was a tradition of holding certain rituals in front of the temples, explained archaeological expedition team leaders Stefan De Champ and Erebuni Museum Director Michael Badalyan during a press conference.

“These excavations are important not only for Armenia’s history and archaeology but for the archaeological study of the entire Ancient Middle East. The excavations prove that we must re-value what we know about Erebuni,” Badalyan said.

“The temple’s existence proves that, at some point, the Erebuni religious site had three shrines which functioned simultaneously – the Khald temple, the Iyubsa temple, and the newly discovered temple with powerful foundations. The fantastically beautiful gravel ground mosaic in front of Iyubsa temple was also interesting,” continued Badalyan.

Yerevan City Hall Department of Culture Director, Gor Sargsyan, said the iconic fortress must become one of the top tourism destinations in 2020.

French Ambassador to Armenia Jonathan Lacote highlighted the cooperation between Armenian and French archaeologists in terms of experience exchange and cooperation in academic field. He also noted that he has numerously visited the Erebuni Fortress.

“I came here two weeks after being appointed ambassador because I wanted to see the area by the name of which Yerevan is called,” said Lacote.

Armenian and French archaeological teams are carrying out excavations at the site since 2008.

Krekorian Blasts Azerbaijan’s Attempt to Prevent Pashinyan’s L.A. Speech

L.A. City Councilman Paul Krekorian

LOS ANGELES—Los Angeles City Councilmember Paul Krekorian has condemned an effort by the Los Angeles Consulate General of Azerbaijan to prevent Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan from speaking at a massive rally in downtown Los Angeles on Sunday, September 22.

In a letter addressed to LA Mayor Eric Garcetti, the consul general, Nasimi Aghayev, urged the City “not to allow the misuse of the Grand Park by the Government of Armenia.”

Krekorian responded with his own letter to the consul general this week that excoriated the attempt to enlist LA City leaders, including Mayor Garcetti, in this effort.

“(Your) letter urges the elected leaders of Los Angeles to violate the United States Constitution by censoring free _expression_,” wrote Krekorian. “Our country is founded on the idea that the free exchange of ideas makes us stronger and in fact is necessary to make our democratic government possible.”

“Please allow me to be as clear as I can be,” proclaimed Krekorian, “Prime Minister Pashinyan absolutely will be my guest in Los Angeles City Hall, he absolutely will address the public in Grand Park, and he absolutely will be welcome to say anything about any topic he chooses to speak about, without limitation.”

The rally is scheduled to begin at 2 p.m., with the prime minister speaking around 4 p.m.

Mass baptism of children of the fallen heroes in April war took place in Artsakh

Panorama, Armenia
Sept 16 2019

The Cathedral of Holy Christ the Savior in the Artsakh city of Shushi hosted a mass baptism ceremony of children and relatives of servicemen who fell victim during the four-day war in April 2016.

Veteran of the April war became godfathers of the children at the event that brought some 250 guests from Artsakh and Armenia.

The Union of the participants of the April military actions congratulated on all baptized and thanked the initiators of the ceremony in the name of Ruben Mkhitaryan. 

Armenian parliament votes to criminalize animal cruelty

Panorama, Armenia
Sept 16 2019

The Armenian National Assembly adopted in the first reading a bill making animal cruelty a criminal offence at a regular session on Monday.

The draft law was authored by lawmakers from the Prosperous Armenia opposition faction.

The bill was passed by a vote of 74 to 11, with 17 abstentions.

Prosperous Armenia MP Naira Zohrabyan hailed the measure as one of the most important draft laws passed by the parliament ever.

“Thanks to all those who backed the bill. And rest assured that even if one day people forget a good deed of yours, animals never do,” she wrote on her Facebook page. 

Alexis Ohanian to attend presentation of his bestselling book’s Armenian translation

Public Radio of Armenia
Sept 16 2019
Alexis Ohanian to attend presentation of his bestselling book’s Armenian translation

The Armenian translation of Alexis Ohanian’s bestselling book  “Without Their Permission” will be presented in Yerevan. The Reddit and Initialized Capital co-founder will be present at the event on October 8.

In the book, Alexis shares his ideas, tips and even his own doodles about harnessing the power of the web for good, and along the way, he shares his philosophy with young entrepreneurs all over the globe.

The author sets out the path to success, from childhood to the founding of Reddit and subsequent events, motivating the reader not to wait for anyone’s permission and move on.

The book has been translated from English by Anna Mirzoyan at the initiative of Karap Company and has been published by Edit Print.

Speaker: National Assembly, within the framework of its powers, should express its position on the situation around Armenia`s Constitutional Court

Arminfo, Armenia
Sept 16 2019
Speaker:  National Assembly, within the framework of its powers,  should express its position on the situation around Armenia`s  Constitutional Court 

ArmInfo. The National  Assembly of Armenia, within the framework of its authority, should  express its position on the situation around the Constitutional Court  of the Republic of Armenia. The Speaker of the National Assembly of  the Republic of Armenia Ararat Mirzoyan announced this on September  16.

According to him, the appeals of the Constitutional Court to the  Venice Commission and the European Court of Human Rights, adopted on  the basis of a statement by Robert Kocharyan, cannot but cause  concern. “Considering the situation that has arisen in and around the  Constitutional Court of the Republic of Armenia, I cannot but share  the public’s concern about this,” said the speaker, pointing out  primarily to the decisions of the Constitutional Court of September  4. According to Ararat Mirzoyan, when considering the case on the  basis of Robert Kocharyan’s statement and making a decision, the  Constitutional Court did not make this issue a subject of proper  discussion. Moreover, without a justified reason, the Court rejected  the CC judge’s statement that it was impossible for three members of  the CC to participate in the consideration of the case, which  demonstrates a clear bias against the applicant, thus calling into  question the provision of a fair trial.

In addition, in one of the special opinions submitted in connection  with the decision of Constitutional Court-1476, the co-rapporteur in  this case explicitly stated that the court had shown unreasonable  haste in making this decision and, in fact, stated that the decision  could be different if there was no such rush.  In the same opinion,  stating the complexity and public resonance of the problem underlying  the case, the co-rapporteur indirectly raised the need to consider  the issue in the oral procedure in the manner prescribed by the RA  Law “On the Constitutional Court”, which, however, did not happen. At  the same time, the decision made in this way directly relates to the  case being considered in another court, in the framework of which the  prosecution concerns encroachments on democracy and the  constitutional order in Armenia and, therefore, has historical and  political importance for Armenia. The speaker also emphasized that  the Constitutional Court, without any obvious justification,  significantly deviated from the legal positions expressed by it for  more than ten years. Secondly, as the speaker noted, to this day  doubts remains about the procedure by which the Constitutional Court  submitted applications to the ECHR and the Venice Commission, given  the important circumstance that on July 18 the Constitutional Court  suspended consideration of these cases in accordance with the  procedural decisions of Constitutional Court 81. The Constitutional  Court has not yet provided the Armenian National Assembly, recognized  as the defendant in cases arising from the March 1 trial, the text of  its appeals to the ECHR and the Venice Commission in Armenian.

In response to the letter of the National Assembly’s office addressed  to the Constitutional Court’s office, an official letter was received  stating that the defendant in these cases is not the National  Assembly’s apparatus, and the Armenian version of the statement  cannot be transferred to it. As regards the autonomy and political  influence of the Constitutional Court, Ararat Mirzoyan believes that  constitutional regulation, which entered into force in April 2018,  granted the judges of the Constitutional Court the right to elect the  chairman of the court. Meanwhile, a few days before the entry into  force of these regulations, on March 23, 2018, a member of the  Constitutional Court, political figure Gevorg Kostanyan ( previously  member of the RPA, member of the RPA parliamentary faction) was  appointed to the post of chairman of the Constitutional Court. This  appointment as well as Tovmasyan’s tenure until 2035  in fact,  deprived the judges of the Constitutional Court of the opportunity to  elect the chairman of the court. “This was perceived by society as an  arbitrariness on the part of the ruling political party, aimed at  appointing its representative to the post of chairman of the  Constitutional Court, as well as an encroachment on the autonomy of  the Constitutional Court,” the head of the Armenian parliament noted.

To recall, on September 4, the Constitutional Court of Armenia  granted the defense claim of Robert Kocharian – Article 35 of the RA  Criminal Code is recognized as unconstitutional, since it does not  provide for the functional inviolability of officials who are  specially protected by the Constitution, including circumstances that  exclude criminal proceedings or criminal prosecution. “This article  is found to be contrary to clause 4 of part 1 of article 27, part 1  of article 61, part 1 of article 63, articles 75 of the  Constitution,” the Constitutional Court said. On the second appeal of  Kocharyan’s defense on the review of compliance with the Constitution  of Part 2 of Article 135 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the  Republic of Armenia, the Constitutional Court recognized it as  complying with the main law of the country. Thus, the Constitutional  Court ruled that the verdicts adopted, in accordance with part 2 of  Article 179 of the Constitution, are final and come into force from  the moment they are published. It should be noted that Robert  Kocharian was arrested on charges of overthrowing the constitutional  order.

Armenian government will not make decision under pressure – Pashinyan on Amulsar issue

Arminfo, Armenia
Sept 16 2019

ArmInfo. In search of truth in  the Amulsar gold mine, the Armenian government intends to go all the  way. Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyanl stated this at a  press conference on September 16, answering the question of whether  he thinks that 400 thousand dollars (this is exactly what the  taxpayer cost the expertise – Ed. note) were wasted.

The funds, according to the prime minister, were spent to clarify the  truth in Amulsar’s issue. “I don’t think that any funds spent on  finding the truth can be considered wasted, “he said

The head of government assured that all actions of the government on  Amulsar are 100% transparent.  According to him, during a Skype  conference with experts from Earthlink & Advanced Resources  Development (ELARD), which was instructed to conduct an EIA study on  Amulsar, new circumstances were revealed. Regarding the security of  the project, as the prime minister pointed out, the ELARD team said  that Lydian was the guarantor of security in any case.

Touching on the blocking of the road to the Amulsar mine, Pashinyan  stated that there is a decision of the Administrative Court to open  the road. “My position and the government are ready to go to the end,  in order to reveal the truth. Truth will lead us to one or another  decision. And the public should not give in to manipulations,  including from the side of my respected friends,” said Pashinyan,  calling the manipulation those citizens traveling with a device to  measure the level of radiation in the vicinity of Amulsar. He noted  Teghut as a vivid, in his opinion, example of a successful solution,  again recalling the inconsistency of talking about the poor condition  of the dam. “In the matter of seeking the truth on Amulsar, we will  go to the end. The Armenian government will not make a decision under  pressure,” he concluded.

To recall, Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan today stated  that at the moment there are no legal grounds to prohibit the  operation of the Amulsar mine. Nikol Pashinyan also formally called  on the residents of Jermuk to open all roads leading to the Amulsar  mine. Meanwhile, on August 19, experts at Earthlink & Advanced  Resources Development (ELARD) said during a video conference that the  Lydian source data was not complete and, in general, the 2016 EIA was  insufficient to guarantee the environmentally operation of the mine. 

ACNIS reView

Free chair   

 

SEPTEMBER 13, 2019   

On September 6, the Eurasia Daily (EADaily) Transcaucasian editorial office of the Russian news agency published an article with the title “Pashinyan prepares for any counterattack before the “stormy autumn” in Armenia.” Analyzing Pashinyan’s actions during the last 20-25 days, the editors come to the conclusion that the prime minister has taken a number of steps which, as the publication implies, are strongly anti-Russian. The journalist did not like that Pashinyan, in his opinion, “instructed two pro-Western non-governmental organizations related to the American billionaire George Soros to allocate enough money from the government fund impressive financial resources for observing the elections of the local self-government bodies of the unrecognized Nagorno-Karabakh”. And the day before, on September 5, the Prime Minister, according to the columnist, “again surprised everyone by having a meeting with the leadership of the “Sasna Trees” party, which is on the political sidelines. The latter is an extremely anti-Russian political association…”

For the umpteenth time, all the pro-Russian websites and newspapers accuse Armenia, and the public organizations financed by Soros allegedly have a strong anti-Russian orientation. Let us remind the uninformed that the Soros Foundation, the official name of which is Open Society Foundations (OSF), is a network of charitable organizations and grant programs founded by the American philanthropist George Soros.

The following website published a detailed list of non-governmental organizations financed by Soros in RA. Those who wish to get acquainted with the direction of the activities financed by George Soros can be convinced that the main goal of these organizations is the development and strengthening of human rights and freedoms in our country, the fight against corruption, the holding of free and transparent elections of local and state level bodies, and the maintenance of equality of law before everyone. In other words, the strengthening of democracy in Armenia. Not a single word does it say that the purpose of the fund is to finance anti-Russian sentiments in Armenia, anti-Russian propaganda or to sow inter-ethnic discord between the Armenian and Russian peoples.

Then the same agency claims that “his (Soros-KK) funds have been repeatedly accused of organizing a change of power in a number of states and interfering in their internal affairs. The latest country where the Soros Foundation has suspended its work is Turkey, after President Erdogan accused the billionaire of financing protests against his government in 2013. And the General Prosecutor’s Office of Russia announced that “Soros’ organizations are a threat to the constitutional order of the Russian Federation and the security of the state.” Moreover, according to clever-news.ru, the Soros Foundation intended to implement a plan “according to which: true Russian values ​​had to be replaced by “liberal” values.” In this regard, the fund is illegal in Russia. As for Erdogan, he has significantly limited the rights and freedoms of the Turkish people in recent years. A vivid example of this was the forced re-election of the mayor of Istanbul, because the elected mayor did not represent Erdogan’s interests. But what does Soros have to do with this?

It is quite obvious that all this propaganda of the Russian media is aimed at creating the impression in the Armenian public that the change of power that took place was financed by the Soros Foundation. The people of Armenia know very well that the “velvet revolution” of 2018 has absolutely nothing to do with Soros money. By the way, Nikol Pashinyan later published the list of people who really sponsored that revolution. But there is not even a trace of Soros in that list. Yes, the revolution was aimed at overthrowing the totalitarian corrupt regime that had seized power and ruled the country. And secondly, after the events of March 1, our people already had some experience of holding protest actions without force: it was “Mashtots Park”, “Electric Yerevan”, “100 AMD” and others. Maybe it was all organized with Soros’s money… If someone makes such a statement in Yerevan, they will make him an object of laughter.

Unlike Russia, Armenia is a small country, and the activities of the corrupt former ruling elite were in front of everyone’s eyes. That revolution was purely an internal affair of our people. Neither the USA, nor Europe, nor Russia have anything to do with it. Everyone knows that very well. So why make a fuss that it’s all the fault of Soros, who finances it all?

Coming to power, the new leadership immediately announced that Armenia’s partnership and strategic relations with Russia are unchanged and will be strengthened more intensively. We fully fulfill our partnership obligations not only to Russia, but also to other EAEU and CSTO countries. We are trying to move the vertical relations with Russia that existed before the revolution to the horizontal plane, preserving the interests of Russia and Armenia. There are many opponents of this concept in both Russia and Armenia, but we consistently work in that direction, and on both sides the number of politicians and experts who understand the perspective and profitability of this path in terms of the interests of both Russia and Armenia is gradually increasing.

But does Soros have something to do with all this?

 

Karapet Kalenchyan