Package yet step-by-step solution to Karabakh issue

AZG Armenian Daily #149, 24/08/2005

Karabakh issue

PACKAGE YET STEP-BY-STEP SOLUTION TO KARABAKH ISSUE

Why Aliyev Turns Skeptic? – Analysts Comment

The Foreign Affairs Ministry of Armenia responded to the last statement of
Azerbaijani President on Saturday. Vartan Oskanian replied to the Azeri
comprehension of Karabakh regulation methodology, to “arming race” in the
neighboring state and to aggressive and belligerent statements of Ilham
Aliyev.

“Everybody is well aware, including the Azeris, that the status of Nagorno
Karabakh is primary in the Karabakh regulation and it should be decided
based on the right of people of Karabakh on choosing its own destiny. Other
issues – elimination of conflict aftereffects, return of territories and
refugees – stem out of the primary one and will follow it. The package
regulation, certainly, can be realized step by step, and we can and are
ready to display flexibility”, Armenian foreign minister told Armenpress.

What shall we understand from Oskanian’s comment? Davit Babayan, political
analyst from Stepanakert, voices his opinion: “This means that the
conflicting sides come to an agreement, sign a peace treaty itemizing all
necessary issues of regulation – status of Nagorno Karabakh, territories
under Karabakh control, refugees, blockade etc. They settle secondary issues
through step-by-step alternative. The package regulation is to be applied
for the status of Karabakh as recognition is of declarative character, i.e.
Baku should recognize Karabakh as part of Armenia or as a sovereign state.
All other issues, demanding technical preparation and finances, can be
settled gradually”.

Stepan Safarian, expert at the Armenian Center for Strategic and National
Research, thinks that Oskanian’s approach suggests the following: reaching
written agreement over all issues, including status, but informing the
public about the phases and realizing them gradually in course of time. “In
that case, Aliyev can avert serious problems with the public opinion on the
threshold of parliamentary elections. Moreover, first steps regarding
territories and refugees can be in favor of the Azeri society. Those issues
will be settled once Azerbaijan agrees to present guarantees for the status
of Karabakh”, Safarian says.

Armenian foreign minister explained earlier what he means by “flexibility”.
“We tend to document the right of self-determination of the people of
Karabakh and can be flexible as regards the time of the final
materialization”. This means that self-determination can be realized in
10-15 years, otherwise Azerbaijan may refuse the status that Yerevan and
Stepanakert strive for, once getting Karabakh-controlled territories.

“If we settle issues concerning conflict aftereffects without deciding the
status of Karabakh, then one of the sides may reject its obligations
changing thus military-political situation”, Babayan says.

A few days prior to Kazan meeting between Armenian and Azeri presidents,
Ilham Aliyev displays skepticism over negotiation process. The Azeri
President noted in particular that “he tends to peaceful regulation”. “But,
as you can see, there is no visible progress here. Therefore we should be
ready to liberate our lands by force if needed. To do that, Azerbaijan has
to be twice as powerful as Armenia”, Aliyev said, pointing out that the
Prague Process suggests step-by-step regulation and, regarding the status,
Karabakh can get the highest autonomy within Azerbaijan.

“Azerbaijan, as a rule, either picks at the Minsk group or expresses
skepticism over the talks process whenever it fails to get what it wants.
Regarding the Azeri definition or estimation of the Prague Process, they
pose their wishes as reality”, Oskanian told Armenpress.

Stepan Safarian explains the reason of Ilham Aliyev’s skepticism: “Aliyev
pleases Russia by hinting at the prospect of no soon regulation, especially
when the immediate regulation is somehow connected with the prospect of
locating US military bases in Azerbaijan, regarding which America expects
Aliyev’s reply (in an interview to News Week Aliyev stated that Azerbaijan
“is no outpost to any country”). The Azeri President, in this regard, tries
to make the US understand that it is not satisfied with current agreements
and wants more for the price of “its agreement”.

Besides, the expert thinks, Aliyev tries to demonstrate “his own rebellion”
against the West’s pressure in demanding Azerbaijan to hold democratic
elections and in supporting the opposition.

Vartan Oskanian also noted in his comments that “the increase of
Azerbaijan’s military budget owing to dollars from oil does not give them
much in essence”. “Azerbaijan can neither attract us with oil, nor, even
more so, frighten us. Armenia always has the capacity to counterbalance any
military budget of Azerbaijan. In fact, the privilege of the Armenians is
not in the military expenses or arming but in being just in their claim.
Armenians believe in their righteousness in the Karabakh issue and in case
of a war will fight for their land and home – something that the Azeris did
not do and will not do”, Oskanian said.

By Tatoul Hakobian

Pros. General’s Corruption Office Investigated 6 Cases in 6 months

PROSECUTOR GENERAL’S OFFICE DEPARTMENT COMBATING CORRUPTION
INVESTIGATED 6 CRIMINAL CASES WITHIN SIX MONTH OF ITS ACTIVITY
X-Sender: Asbed Bedrossian <[email protected]>
X-Listprocessor-Version: 8.1 — ListProcessor(tm) by CREN

YEREVAN, AUGUST 23. ARMINFO. The Department for struggle against
corruption of the Armenian Prosecutor General’s Office investigated 6
criminal cases within 6 months of its activity. Head of the department
Mihran Minasyan made this statement at a press conference organized by
the “Hakastver” (Anti-shadow) NGO.

The department was established in April 2004. At present 8 prosecutors
operate at the department. The department’s activity is coordinated
directly by the Prosecutor General. The department also considers the
complaints of the citizens which number already 100 related to
corruption in all the spheres, especially the judicial
system. Agreeing that the number of complaints is less than the real
cases of corruption, Minasayan at the same time stated that the
employees of the department have no right to lodge criminal cases, as
it requires at least complaints. At the same time, Minasyan said that
he is not informed of the numerous publications in the press related
displays of corruption.

His statements often contradicted to each other: at first he stated
that a department of 8 people cannot answer all the questions
interesting, at the same time adding that there are enough employees
at the department. He also refrained from an answer to the question
related the percentage of the efficiency factor of its department.

In his turn, attending the press conference Head of OSCE Office in
Yerevan Ambassador Vladimir Pryakhin pointed out the importance of
cooperation of the Prosecutor’s Office and the press as a
representative of the people’s interests. He pointed out the
continuing cooperation with the Prosecutor’s Office adding that an
anti-corruption textbook will be published under this cooperation, as
well as events for Armenian specialists are organized.

Dram Depreciation Conditioned By Fall in Prices of Agri Products -CB

ARMENIAN DRAM DEPRECIATION IS CONDITIONED BY A FALL IN PRICES OF
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS, CBA CHAIRMAN SAYS

YEREVAN, AUGUST 22, NOYAN TAPAN. The depreciation of the Armenian dram
over the last two months has been mainly conditioned by a fall in the
prices of agricultural products. This is how Chairman of the Central
Bank of Armenia (CBA) Tigran Sargsin explained the Armenian dram
depreciation at the August 22 presentation of BTA Invest Bank.

According to him, the effects on the currency exchange rate are
numerous and multifarious, ranging from the ratio of demand to supply
on the domestic market to processes taking place on iternational
markets. The speaker indicated that the reduction of the excessive
dollar liquidity in the global economy has gradually led to a growth
in dollar savings. At the same time, the dollar’s profitablity against
the euro has sharply risen in the market. According to T. Sargsian,
the profitabilty of the euro has remained the same, whereas that of
the dollar has increased from 1% to 3.5%.

BAKU: Chances high for progress in peace talks

Chances high for progress in peace talks

AzerNews, Azerbaijan
Aug 18 2005

A high-ranking Azeri official expects progress from the upcoming talks
on the settlement of the long-standing Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict
over Upper Garabagh. The two countries’ foreign ministers will meet in
Moscow on August 24 and the presidents in Kazan, Russia on August 26.

“Chances are high for positive results in the talks… But much depends
on the extent of Armenia’s readiness for another step toward a peace
agreement”, Deputy Foreign Minister Araz Azimov said.

Azimov told journalists on Monday that liberation of Azerbaijan’s
seven districts around Garabagh, the return of Azeri refugees
home, restoration of communications in the occupied districts and
determination of the status of Garabagh residents will be discussed
at the meetings.

“Freeing all occupied regions altogether is impossible. Liberation
of Upper Garabagh may be discussed only after the seven districts
around it are freed.”

Co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group mediating the conflict resolution
stated during their recent visits to the region that the conflicting
sides’ positions have drawn closer due to mutual compromises.

Azimov seemingly confirmed that the Azerbaijani side has made
compromises. However, he chose not to mention the details, as
elaborating on the matter may impede peace talks.

Azeri and Armenian government sources said earlier that an agreement
envisioning ‘package and stage-by-stage’ conflict settlement was
deemed possible at the meeting of the two presidents.

The US OSCE MG co-chair Steven Mann earlier expressed optimism on
the prospects for signing a peace accord by the year-end.

Mann’s deputy Elizabeth Ruth told Radio Liberty last week that
there are ‘great hopes that conditions will emerge for reaching a
peace accord’. “We therefore consider the Kazan meeting of the two
presidents a real opportunity.”

Ruth noted, however, that no final agreement should be expected at
this point, and peace talks between Azerbaijan and Armenia should
continue. “Peace will be achieved either now or in distant future –
everything depends on the decisiveness and the will of both sides.”

A confidential source from the Azeri government said following the
visit by the mediators to the region in July that the sides reached
a final agreement on returning five occupied districts to Azerbaijan.

It also said that according to a plan agreed upon with Armenia, this
would be followed by signing of a peace agreement and subsequent
liberation of the other two districts occupied by Armenia.

An Armenian government source cited talks on holding a referendum in
Upper Garabagh in 10-15 years to determine its status. Both countries’
diplomats said that the sides are discussing opening communications,
return of Azeri refugees to their homes and stationing of OSCE
peacekeepers in the conflict zone.

Some analysts say that the course of talks shows that a settlement
remains a distant prospect. Despite the intensifying negotiations, the
Azeri and Armenian governments are restrained in taking ‘compromising’
decisions and pushing for a peace accord among the public in their
countries, as a compromise would not suit the ambitions of the
sides. On the other hand, a peaceful conflict resolution does not
appear possible without major concessions.

Nicosia: The families that were wiped out

The families that were wiped out
By Jean Christou

Cyprus Mail, Cyprus
Aug 17 2005

TWELVE entire Cypriot families, including a family of four Armenian
Cypriots, were wiped out in Sunday’s horrific air crash that killed
121 passengers and six crew members of the doomed Helios flight that
went down north of Athens.

Among the dead were also six representatives of Libra Holidays,
which owns Helios, a Greek Naval officer, a Greek Cypriot National
Guard officer, and a Cyprus Airways employee.

The youngest victim was four years old. In all, 17 children under
the age of 16 died in the crash. Three of the children, aged 16,
14 and five died along with their parents.

The oldest passengers were a couple aged 63 and 65.

Included in the six crew members who died was the daughter of Lonias
Efthyvoulou, artist and brother of veteran journalist Alex Efthyvoulou,
who was due to be married next month.

Few people in Cyprus did not know one of the victims, but places like
Paralimni and Dhali lost more than most.

Sixteen resident of Paralimni died, half of them children.

Three entire families from the town were wiped out, including Christos
Pyrillis 40, his wife Antonia, 36 and their three children Eva 12,
Xenios 10 and Marcos six, who had gone on a week-long holiday.

Reports yesterday said Antonia had been worried about flying and had
called her brother Andreas from the airport; he reassured her that
she was flying with an EU airline and that it would be safe.

All day Monday and Tuesday, friends and neighbours gathered at the
homes of the three bereaved families, while the town’s Mayor declared
40 days of mourning. He also said his municipality would cover the
cost of the burials.

Another Cypriot family in Paralimni, who were visiting from Australia,
left their 20-month old baby at home with its grandparents because
it had a fever. The boy, George Xiourouppa, is now an orphan.
His father Demos, 39, his mother Margarita, 34, and sisters Sophia,
10, and Joanna, nine, died in the crash. Reports said that Demos
didn’t actually want to go on the trip but his daughters begged him.

“You don’t know what to do,” one resident in Paralimni told
reporters. “If someone loses a grandparent or a mother or a father,
you go round to their house and talk about the person who’s gone
and you have a wake. But what are we supposed to do when we’ve lost
whole families?”

One woman from Nicosia, who had not gone on the trip, lost her husband
and three children, two boys and a girl aged 10, 8 and five.

You Appreciate Your Own Country in a Foreign Land

You Appreciate Your Own Country in a Foreign Land

HETQ ONLINE – [August 8, 2005]

“There are between 40 and 50 thousand Armenians in Greece , 16-17
thousand of which are Greek-Armenians born here. The rest are people
who have come from Armenia over the last ten or fifteen years.” This
we were told by Hovsep Parazian, the editor-in-chief of Azat Or,
the official newspaper of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation
(ARF/Dashnaktsutiun), when we met with him in Athens . No one knows
exactly how many Armenians there are among the one million immigrants
in Greece today. “Many people come and move to the islands to work;
they aren’t registered anywhere,” said David Aivazian, editor of the
newspaper that the Hayastan Social-Cultural Center of Athens puts out.

The Armenian community in Greece is not united; like Diasporan
communities elsewhere, it is divided along party lines, Church
affiliation (subordinated to Echmiadzin or Antelias), and
Hayastantsi-Hunastantsi identification.

[IMAGE]

“The problem that our compatriots who have recently arrived have
is that they haven’t been able to find their place within Armenian
circles, clubs, and unions. In the Diaspora everything is partisan
– you either belong to one of the parties or you’re isolated. The
Antelias See implemented a policy of not accepting newcomers,
especially regarding children – they would not accept children into
their schools. A large number of children couldn’t go to Armenian
schools, so they went to Greek schools. The boarding schools run
by the Dashnaktsutiun party or the Ramkavar party had the potential
to accommodate the children from Armenia but they didn’t do so. And
this is how the children from Armenia are becoming Greek. The party
bureaucrats say that by not helping them, they encourage people who
have come from Armenia to go back. But the problem is that if they
can’t settle here [in Athens ], the newcomers go to the islands,
where no one can keep track of them. And if they left Armenia it
means that they had problems there, doesn’t it?” Aivazian said.

I’m in Armenia

There are three places in the city where you can encounter Armenians –
Ramkavars get together at the offices of the Ramkavar-Azatakan Party,
Dashnaks at the offices of the ARF, and people who have no without
party affiliation at the Hayastan Social-Cultural Center .

The ARF is the strongest group here, and no doubt aware of its
position, has little contact with the Ramkavars or non-partisan
Armenians. “They don’t even invite us to their events, or their
holiday celebrations,” said the regulars at the Hayastan Center .

The Ramkavars have a three-storey office building in one of the
central districts of Athens , which also houses the editorial offices
of their party organ Nor Ashkhar. According to Armenians from Armenia
, the building’s large playground, its state-of-the-art gym, and
its well-equipped music club, are almost always empty, and newly
arrived young people are not invited to use them. Two members of the
party, Comrade Sargis and Comrade Hakob, complained to us about the
indifference of Armenian youths toward the party, and political and
national problems. The Ramkavars were aware that generational change,
revitalizing its ranks with young, people, particularly from Armenia,
was a big problem for the party, but they also admitted that they
were doing little to address it.

[IMAGE]

For Minas Minasyan, who came from Armenia to Athens with his family in
1996, the Hayastan Center represents the only possibility of remaining
Armenian and maintaining contact with Armenia. “They didn’t admit my
son into the Armenian school; they said they had no room.

But there were places in both the Dashnak school and the Ramkavar
school. I was forced to send him to a Greek school,” he said. His
son, Karapet, has adapted to this society and has no intention of
returning to Armenia . “I might move to the US from here to devote
myself to professional music, but I doubt I’ll go to Armenia -or if
I do, I’ll go as a tourist,” Karo said.

Minasyan and David Aivazyan founded the Hayastan Social-Cultural
Center in 2000. “I had just come from Iran ,” Aivazyan recalled. The
main problem that our newly arrived compatriots had was that they
had no place within Armenian circles, clubs, unions. Wham they first
arrive, they don’t have residence permits or jobs, they don’t know
the language, they’re isolated and hanging in the air. We saw their
problems; they were in a crazy situation. At the same time, there were
students from Armenia who had come through the interstate students’
exchange agreement who faced similar problems. Nobody met them when
they arrived, they didn’t know how to get to the university. We met
with some of these boys who are now back in Armenia . They tried
several times to establish contacts with some Armenian circles here,
to found a students’ union of local Armenians, but they didn’t succeed,
since they were told from the very beginning that they had to join
a political party.

“So we got together with our compatriots working here and decided to
create this center to assist newly arrived Armenians. At that time,
many young women were coming here and marrying Greeks just to get the
necessary papers. The students built this center, voluntarily, without
any pay. The main assistance was provided by those Greek-Armenians
who are cut from the local politicized and partisan community. Many
of them don’t even speak Armenian, but are constantly making donations
to the center.”

[IMAGE]

In 2000, the center began publishing its newspaper, Hayastan, which
mainly provides information about Armenia and has a circulation of
about 1,500. The center offers Armenian, Greek and English language
courses for children free of charge, with the help of students and
teachers who have come from Armenia to live permanently in Greece
They run an Armenian Sunday school as well. Parents and teachers
organize. performances and holiday festivities for the children.

Marietta , a teacher from Vanadzor came to Athens nine years ago;
she subsequently brought her only daughter, and then, two years ago,
she brought her father and mother to live with her as well. She teaches
Armenian language and history at the Hayastan Center on Sundays. On
weekdays Armenians from Armenia gather at the center at 8 p.m. to learn
about each other’s “Armenian and Greek” worries and problems, and to
exchange news and information from the homeland. Every conversation
here turns to Armenia.

“Now when people phone each other and ask: `Where are you?’ the
answer is. `In Armenia ‘ We’ve created a little Armenia here. And
we have one principle – we won’t allow the center to be politicized,
to become partisan,” David Aivazyan said.

One day, we’ll all go home

[IMAGE]

“It’s hard for an artist to leave his country at 40 and to create
an environment in a new place. It’s like uprooting a tree,” said
Armen Gizgizyan, a painter. He, his wife, and their two children left
Armenia to live in Athens temporarily in 2001. “At first we decided to
come here for six months, to save some four or five thousand dollars
and go home. At that time, 2001, $ 5,000 was quite a sum. I could
at least solve my family problems, and I wouldn’t have to sell my
paints or melt high-voltage cable for 2,000 drams (about $4) a day
to buy a little bread, and to go to the Vernissage on weekends to
sell some paintings. If I had earned $200 a month in Yerevan at that
time I would have stayed there. Now I earn 1,500 Euros a month here,
though I still don’t live normally; I pay my bills every month and
send a little bit of money to Armenia.

[IMAGE]

“I dream about stabilizing my financial situation and going back,
because I’m getting tired… I’m tired of being alone. There’s no on
here of my color to relate to, to curse your fate, to just sit with,
without talking. Because I grew up in another environment, it’s like
cutting a person from his roots and bringing him here. Now you can
say: no one brought you here by force, you came yourself. There are
so many tens of thousands of Armenians with a status like mine.

People look at them and say, they are traitors, they left their
fatherland. But I assure you that many of the people who are living
in a foreign land deserved to be called Armenian much more than the
people doing the talking,” Gizgizyan said.

“True, an Armenian is first of all a person who lives in the
homeland, but you appreciate your own country when you’re in a
foreign land. Perhaps the people of Armenia should be taken to another
place to live for a few years to understand what their homeland is,
then be brought back in order to live with each other with love and
without grievance.”

All the Armenians from Armenia we met in Athens dreamed of returning to
Armenia, but few of them saw it as a real possibility. “The problem is
that the children are growing up here and it’s hard to imagine their
future in Armenia. If I take my son there, how is he going to fit in
with the kids there? My children don’t even understand Armenian jokes
now. In Yerevan they would say, who is this fool? This is one of my
biggest problems, one that really upsets me, that my child will be
like a Diasporan in Armenia. I’m from Yerevan, and my child will be
a stranger in Armenia.”

Liana Sayadyan, Edik Baghdasaryan
Athens-Yerevan

BAKU: Issues of integration of Azerbaijan to EU structures discussed

AzerTag, Azerbaijan
Aug 15 2005

ISSUES OF INTEGRATION OF AZERBAIJAN TO EU STRUCTURES DISCUSSED
[August 15, 2005, 23:06:06]

Foreign minister of the Azerbaijan Republic Elmar Mammadyarov on 15
August met the delegation headed by the secretary of state of the
Swedish Premier office Lars Danielsson, now visiting the country.

Noting that the key goal of the visit is to have comprehensive
information on the current situation in the country, discuss
opportunities for bilateral relations between two countries, Mr. Lars
Danielsson expressed pleasure to visit Azerbaijan.

Minister Mammadyarov highlighted on the economic and socio-political
situation in the Republic, on the Armenia-Azerbaijan, Nagorno Karabakh
conflict and current status of the peace negotiations to resolve the
question, on the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil and Baku-Tbilisi-Erzurum
gas and Baku-Tbilisi-Kars transport large-scale energy and transport
projects, as well as on the works to integrate to the Europe and
Euro-Atlantic structures as priorities of the foreign policy of
Azerbaijan.

Minister Mammadyarov informed that Armenia has occupied 20 percent of
territory of the country, and pursued the policy of ethnic cleanse,
underlining necessity of resolution to the problem in the frame of
territorial integrity of Azerbaijan and noted that the occupation
factor is inadmissible in the XXI century, and that the problem
should find its solution in peace way and negotiations. Existent
of conflict in the region is major obstacle for integration to the
European structures, Mr. Mammadyarov emphasized.

The Minister spoke of the prospects of the cooperation of Azerbaijan
with the European structures, its steps made towards the “New
Neighboring Policy of Europe” and participation of the country in
the frame of NATO’s PfP program, as well as the democratic society
building process in the Republic.

In the meeting, also were exchanged views on a number of other
questions of regional and international significance, the reforms in
UN, humanitarian and social-economic situation in the Northern Cyprus
and others.

BAKU: Armenian side fired at Azerbaijani positions

ARMENIAN SIDE FIRED AT AZERBAIJANI POSITIONS
2005-08-13 17:47

Azerbaijan News Service
Aug 13 2005

Armenian armed forces in occupied Kuropatkino village of Khojavend
region opened machine gun fire to opposite positions of Azerbaijani
army at night from August 12 to 13 for half an hour informs press
service of Defense Ministry. Azerbaijani army put down the opposite
side with an answering fire. There is no report of human loss.

CENN Daily Digest – August 12, 2005

CENN – August 12, Daily Digest
Table of Contents:

1.. Oil crosses into the Georgian section of the BTC pipeline
2.. Environmentalism Slam Award for Dead Wolves
3.. Quest for Georgian oil continues
4.. World’s Largest Environmental Awareness Program
5.. Analysis – Global Warming May Take Economic Toll
6.. Call For Papers – Towards the UN Decade of Education for Sustainable Development

1. Oil crosses into the Georgian section of the BTC pipeline

Source: The Messenger, August 10, 2005

BP, as operator of the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan (BTC) crude oil pipeline, is pleased to announce that the first barrels of oil through the line have crossed the border from Azerbaijan into Georgia. The oil has been received at Pump Station 1 (PSG1) near Gardabani, following the commissioning i and inauguration of the pipeline in Baku in May.

With construction of the BTC pipeline now complete in Georgia, Mr. Wref Digings, BP Georgia Head of Country said: “This is a very significant day for Georgia, for the investors in the BTC pipeline – and for BP, as constructor and operator of the pipelines. It is j a day when we see the first tangible results in Georgia of the completion of one of the I most challenging pipeline projects ever undertaken; and it shows how good co-operation between the Government of Georgia and private investors can achieve extraordinary results.”

Staged filling of the pipeline along its entire 1,770-km route-from the Sangachal terminal near Baku through Georgia to the newly built Ceyhan marine terminal on the Mediterranean coast of Turkey-is a gradual process over a period of several months and involving more than 10 million barrels of crude oil. Oil production comes from the Azeri-Chirag-Gunashli (ACG) field in the Azerbaijan sector of the Caspian Sea and loading of the first tanker at Ceyhan is expected in 40 2005.

Official First Oil Celebrations, hosted by the Government of Georgia and BTC Co, in the presence of invited national and international guests, will take place in Tbilisi on October 12th 2005.

The BTC Co. shareholders are: BP (30.1 %); AzBTC (25.00%); Unocal (8.90%); Statoil (8.71 %); TPAO (6.53%); Eni (5.00%); Total (5.00%), Itochu (3.40%); INPEX (2.5C%), ConocoPhillips (2.50%) and Amerada Hess (2.36%).

For further information, please contact: Tamila Chant/adze

Tel: + 995 32 593 400

2. Environmentalism Slam Award for Dead Wolves

Source: The Messenger, August 10, 2005

Environmental groups have criticized an order issued by the presidential representative in the Mtskheta-Mtianeti region Vasil Maghlaperidze to issue an award of GEL 100 for any residents who kill a wolf in the region.

The order came in the wake of a wolf attack in the Dusheti district of the Mtskheta-Mtianeti region at the beginning of August. A wolf mauled three children from a Dusheti village.

Two of them, 10 and 13 years old, were placed a Tbilisi hospital with bite injuries. Doctors say one boy was significantly injured in his face.

The Georgian environmental group Green Alternative slammed the order of Maghlaperidze as a call to eradicate wolves as a species.

“According to Article 36 of the Georgian law on the animal world, the existence of an award system for preying on separate animal species is prohibited. Consequently we think that Maghlaperidze violated the law,” says the group’s statement.

The NGO also says reports I describing a fine of GEL 400 for killing a wolf are incorrect and ignore a part of the law that allows for controlled hunting.

“It’s not true, because according to the same article 36 of the law, it is allowed to control the amount of wild animals if a certain animal creates a danger for the health and life of the population,” explains the group.

Green Alternative says this measure in the law allows for the destruction or isolation of an individual animal creating danger but not announcing a call to kill any and all members of an animal species.

“It’s the same as if the American government instead of setting an award for the liquidation of Osama Bin Laden would give an award for the liquidation of all dark-haired men with long beards,” Green Alternative says about Maghlaperidze’s order.

The group says the order by the Mtskheta-Mtianeti administration violate national environmental laws as well as international environmental principles that Georgia is obliged to follow under signed conventions.

Article 36 of the law also says “the control [of animal populations] should be held by humane means” and that the list of species to be controlled must be developed together with input from scientific organizations and state structures.

“We will apply to international organizations over this fact,” warns Green Alternative. Another environmental group, the Center for Conservation of Species, also criticized Maghlaperidze’s order.

However, according to the deputy governor of Mtskheta-Mtianeti Shadiman Shamanidze the award system is an urgent necessity and temporary. “If this wolf bites other wolves they would be infected with rabies as well and it would create more danger for the population,” he said according to Rezonansi.

Doctors say the wolf almost certainly was infected rabies to attack the three people. The National Center for Disease Control says there has been just one case of rabies registered in Georgia in the first four months of 2005.

The newspapers reported that a man in Tskhinvali region died this year after a rabies-infected wolf bit him.

The National Center for Disease Control warns the danger of being bitten by animals, especially by dogs, rises in summertime. The Center advises pet owners to vaccinate their animals against rabies and for the country in general to control the animal population. If a person is bitten or scratched, they should immediately turn to a doctor for vaccinations.

3. Quest for Georgian oil continues

Source: The Messenger, August 11, 2005

The search for petroleum in Georgia continues. Many specialists say that the investments placed in such efforts will pay off in the near future and the country, which until today has been primarily a transit country for oil, will become a petroleum exporter itself.

In early August at well No. 60 in the Kakheti town of Teleti, a fountain of crude oil gushed forth from the earth. The well is currently producing 13 tons of petroleum every 24 hours. According to analysts’ calculations, if oil drilling becomes a systematic practice, the state budget will receive an additional GEL 3.5 million per year.

The Teleti well was drilled in November of 1990, though at that time no crude oil was found and the well was labeled “dry” and closed. However, in June of this year, drillers returned to the well and drilled deeper, down to 950 meters, where the oil made its appearance.

According to the paper Rezonansi, the general director of the national oil company Saknavtobi, Vano Nakaidze, has stated that from the Soviet period to today, a total of 1,300 various types of oil wells have been drilled in Georgia. Of these the number yielding oil today is at most 200. Oil drilling began in Georgia in 1929 and one of the first deposits was that of Mirzaani in Kakheti.

By far the most generous, however, was the Samgori deposit, which was drilled in 1974. In 1980, the oil yield reached 3 million tons. This continued for three or four years and then began to fall sharply. According to the newspaper Rezonansi, since 1929 a total of 27 million tons of oil have been found in Georgia, of this 24 million were from the Samgori deposit.

The search for oil has been especially intense since Georgia reclaimed its independence. From 1992 to 2004, a total of USD 250 million was invested in the petroleum and natural gas sectors. This money, however, was not directed towards finding new deposits, but rather improving old ones. The result, from the standpoint of the oil found, has not been very successful.

In 1992, 202,000 tons of oil was found, in 2004, however, a mere 98,000. The new management of Saknavtobi considers this to be a result of incorrect policy. “There is oil in Georgia, it just needs to be found. We must make investors focus not exhausting the resources of old deposits, but rather on opening new ones; we should approach them about holding new surveys and investigations. If we fail to open new deposits, finding the resources that remain in Georgia will take a maximum of five years,” said Nakaidze according to Rezonansi.

An especially bright prospect for prospectors is considered the Black Sea coast. The American company Anadarko has been working in this area since 2000. In March 2005, after the company conducted surveys of the area, a consortium was created including British Petroleum (BP), the Turkish National Oil Company and the company Unocal. Drilling wells on the Black Sea shelf will cost approximately 110-120 million dollars. If this search proves successful, Georgia may indeed become an oil exporting country.

5. WORLD’S LARGEST ENVIRONMENTAL AWARENESS PROGRAM

Source: Planet Ark, August 11, 2005

Inventor & CEO of Hooked On Recycling & The Original Bottle Cap Lure Company is on fire. He is starting the world’s largest bottle cap recycling program. He’ll be recycling metal beer and soda caps that have been thrown away for 116 yrs. Why do our world’s governments allow this? Why do we allow it?

Norm Price has been in contact with major beverage companies to educate them about how easy it would be to collect the bottle caps as they are collecting their bottles. They all told him to get stuffed and that people have been throwing them away for years. He said that’s the point. Your customers have been throwing them into our lakes, rivers and parks & cities. Special events, bars, sporting events discard them by the billions here in North America alone. This is reusable metal.

That is not even the best of it yet. He told them that he makes fishing lures out of them and they would make a great promotional gift. They told him that they are their caps and that he cannot use them for fishing lures. Mr. Price told them to get stuffed. Round, round we go. Even the government has been shy about getting involved. He has volunteers collecting for him at schools, bars, pubs, events, campsites, marinas, tackle shops, and many other places. He will be having a national fishing contest, free for the public. It will be called… the Battle of The Brands.

Beer vs. Beer …Soda vs. Soda. Which one will win?

Told you it gets better.

College and university students manufacture the lures that are made out of these bottle caps. This product has many pluses and no downfalls. Mr. Price’s friend, Andy Vander Ploeg, is the three-time Canadian sport fishing champion. Vander Ploeg, with the help of this functional lure, has won the title three years in a row. The Bottle Cap Lure was featured on the front page of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel’s Business page, in July’s issue of Field & Stream and the UK’s Tackle Trade World magazine & the September issue of FHM US swimsuit magazine, with more yet to come.

This is a fun project for Mr. Price and he is even custom printing company’s & group’s logos on bottle caps and the packaging. Hooked On You Promotions… Hooked On Education….. Hooked On Recycling… Hooked On Beer…. Hooked On Employment….. Hooked On World Peace.

Norm is hoping to pick up sponsors along the way. Meanwhile sales are helping him right now. For those who have tossed caps away, you too can make a difference now. Vote in the online poll on his website.

Find out more online at: and

He has no support from the beverage industry and no support from governments. Both have declined. All his profits are going into collecting more bottle caps.

CONTACT:

Norm Price

THE ORIGINAL BOTTLE CAP LURE COMPANY

416-628-9750

6. ANALYSIS – Global Warming May Take Economic Toll

Source: Planet Ark, August 12, 2005

Washington – The White House’s refusal to consider government caps on greenhouse gas emissions may save the US economy short-term pain, but experts warn unchecked global heat could exact a heavy long-run toll.

“While there are costs associated with reducing emissions, there are certainly costs associated with not doing anything,” said Kevin Forbes, head of Catholic University’s economics department. “It would be, in my opinion, folly not to try to do something.”

According to Ralph Cicerone, president of the National Academy of Sciences, earth surface temperatures could be up to 10.4 degrees Fahrenheit above 1990 levels by 2100, potentially worsening storms, raising sea levels and eating away ice caps.

After shunning the Kyoto Protocol on greenhouse gases, which President George W. Bush said would have “wrecked” the economy, the United States last month joined Japan, Australia, China, India and South Korea in a pact focused on technology-sharing, without set targets.

The world’s richest economy is also its biggest carbon dioxide emitter, pushing out 5.8 billion metric tons in 2003. China, in second place, emitted 3.5 billion, with all of Western Europe at 3.9 billion.

US emissions are projected to keep rising, despite plans to lower carbon intensity, or use per unit of economic growth.

The White House wants cuts to be voluntary and resists measures that would impose restrictions on output of such gases as carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide, seen as culprits behind global warming, saying this would hurt economic growth.

“We oppose policies like mandatory caps on emissions, that would achieve reductions by raising energy costs, slowing the economy, and putting Americans out of work,” said White House spokeswoman Dana Perino.

While experts agree new technologies are vital, many see the economic argument as spurious. Higher costs may also be a necessary evil since they spur innovation and companies will act more aggressively if inaction hits where it counts.

John Reilly of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Joint Program on the Science and Policy of Global Change has examined the economic effects of several proposals.

“When we looked at implementing Kyoto … we estimated that would be 6/10ths or 1 percent of the economy. We thought that was costly but that’s not wrecking the economy,” he said.

Still, even those who back government restrictions agree Kyoto isn’t the answer for the United States.

They call its targets too tough, its deadline too near and say the absence of developing countries such as India and China could distort the global economic playing field.

What is needed, they say, is a world-spanning deal with fair goals. “You will never be able to solve this problem without all of the major emitters being involved,” said Katie Mandes of the Pew Center on Global Climate Change.

Experts say economic risks could be eased with a Kyoto-like allowance trading system so the regions best able to make affordable cuts can sell their achievement to those less able.

While the United States can’t fix the problem alone, Reilly said it should lead the way with meaningful steps.

“I think it’s one of the great tragedies of our era that the administration hasn’t risen to the occasion on this. It’s committing future generations to extraordinary costs and problems,” said James Gustave Speth, dean of the Yale School of Forestry & Environmental Studies. “In the same breath, I have to say I wish the prior administration had done more itself.”

The great unknown is the price of inaction.

“There are real economic costs associated with not taking action, including changes to water supply infrastructure, industrial capital, like pipelines, and with human health,” said Janet Peace, senior research fellow, economics at Pew.

“With droughts, there’s a cost. With increased flooding, there’s a cost (and) with increased hurricanes and tornadoes.”

Cap critics say real change would take many Kyotos.

“Scientists who support Kyoto have estimated that emissions cuts equivalent to 30 Kyotos will be needed,” said Myron Ebell, director of global warming at the Washington-based Competitive Enterprise Institute, which supports “free enterprise and limited government.”

He said costs would rise with each new target since companies make the cheapest cuts first. “I can’t imagine that any informed person could claim that the total costs will be anything less than astronomical.”

Reilly admitted the ultimate price will be high although solutions can and should include economic safety valves.

“Starting on a path isn’t committing to the entire path,” he said. “If the cost becomes too great for the economy, we have to reconsider where we go. If the climate effects become more severe, or less severe, then we reconsider as we go.”

And a fix may cost less than feared.

“When you turn the genius of the private sector loose on solving the problem, they do things,” said Speth.

Chemical giant DuPont has cut emissions by 72 percent, beating both its 65 percent target and its self-imposed 2010 deadline at a cost of $55 million.

Tom Jacobs, DuPont’s senior adviser on global affairs, said the company sees caps as inevitable and exploited “unique opportunities” for big, low-cost reductions, though he admits cheap options are not limitless.

7. CALL FOR PAPERS – Towards the UN Decade of Education for Sustainable Development

V Annual International Conference of REC Caucasus

Education for Sustainable Development

November 1-2, 2005

Tbilisi, Georgia

Background

V Ministerial Conference “Environment for Europe” (Kiev, 2003) has endorsed a number of documents in the field of Sustainable Development, including the Statement on Education for Sustainable Development.

Environment ministers from UNECE countries recognized that education is a fundamental tool for environmental protection and sustainable development. They stressed that cooperation on education for sustainable development can build and strengthen mutual understanding, trust, tolerance and friendly relations between nations, respect for cultural values, and contribute to peace, security and welfare.

At the High-level Meeting of Education and Environment Ministries of UNECE Countries (Vilnius, 2005) was officially declared the beginning of the United Nations Decade of Education for Sustainable Development (UNDESD) 2005-2014. The meeting adopted the UNECE Strategy for Education for Sustainable Development and decided on the framework for its implementation, according to which member States take the responsibility for its implementation in cooperation with UN, UNESCO, OSCE and the Regional Environmental Centres.

Taking into account the special role of RECs in this process it was decided to dedicate the REC Caucasus Annual Conference to Education for Sustainable Development in the South Caucasus.

The overall goal of the REC Caucasus Annual Conference “Education for Sustainable Development” is to discuss problems and prospects of Education for Sustainable Development in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia and to identify ways of its development.

In parallel the “Students and Education for Sustainable Development”- event shall take place.

Objectives of the Conference and issues to be covered

Conference aims to:

Provide a forum for all the stakeholders: Ministries of Education, Environment, Economy, Health, Parliaments, NGOs and individual experts from Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia;

Get acquainted with the trends in education for sustainable development followed by governments, parliaments, NGOs and scientists, as well as by international organisations working in Azerbaijan, Armenia and Georgia;

Work out proposals on further development of environmental education in Azerbaijan, Armenia and Georgia taking into account the experience and recommendations of international organisations and region specific conditions;

Promote information exchange and transfer of experience within and beyond the region;

Raise awareness among target groups;

Identify the ongoing activities undertaken by the countries corresponding to the UNECE Strategy for Education for Sustainable Development and define priorities of further actions required for implementation of the Strategy by the countries;

Revise current policies, existing legal and operational frameworks.

Main issues to be discussed at the Conference

General Issues

Environmental Education and Education for Sustainable Development;

Management of transboundary decision making process through education;

Objectives and framework of Education for Sustainable Development;

Education for Sustainable Development in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia;

Education for a Sustainable Future;

Legal basis of Education for Sustainable Development in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia.

Formal education

Preschool and secondary education

General review of environmental educational systems in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia;

Sustainable Development and integrated education approach in formal education in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia;

Sustainable Development at all stages of school educational programmes;

Sustainable schools;

Trainings and Education for Sustainable Development.

Higher education

Education for Sustainable Development in curricula of higher educational institutions of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia;

Training for trainers and tutors

Informal education

How to introduce Sustainable Development principles into informal educational systems;

Role of NGOs in formal and informal education systems;

National Parks and Education for Sustainable Development;

Media and Education for Sustainable Development;

Promoting educational processes for ensuring public participation in decision making processes;

Networking activity of NGOs and private persons directed towards the UN Decade of Education for Sustainable Development.

The papers shall be originally prepared for the Conference, and shall not be earlier presented at any other conference, or printed in any edition. The papers shall be sent in electronic format to the below address. They shall be prepared in English or Russian, in MS Word format, with 12 font size. The papers shall have the following structure:

1. Name of the paper;

2. Name of the author and his/her regalia;

3. Resume (200-250 words, in Russian or English)

4. Paper (4-5 A4 format pages, with upper and lower margins of 2.5 cm, and left and right margins of 2.2 cm)

5. Bibliography

The papers shall be sent to: [email protected]

Deadline for submission of papers – September 20, 2005

Only resumes of the selected papers will be published in conference report. The papers not complying with the above requirements will be disqualified.

Authors of the best papers will receive compensation for accommodation and transportation fees (train or minibus tickets). Organizers will be able to pay such compensation only to one of the authors; co-authors (if any) shall undergo official registration procedure for participation in the Conference.

Registration forms can be found at:

For further details, please visit:

or contact: [email protected]

Regional Environmental Centre for Caucasus

Office 901, 74 Chavchavadze Ave.

Tbilisi 380062, Georgia

Tel./Fax: +995 32 253649/ 253648

E-mail: [email protected]

CENN INFO
Caucasus Environmental NGO Network (CENN)

Tel: ++995 32 75 19 03/04
Fax: ++995 32 75 19 05
E-mail: [email protected]
URL:

http://www.bottlecaplure.com
http://hookedonrecycling.com
www.rec-caucasus.org
www.rec-caucasus.org
www.cenn.org

Armenian expert sees revolution as only way to establish democracy

Armenian expert sees revolution as only way to establish democracy

Mediamax news agency
10 Aug 05

YEREVAN

“A revolution is the only way to establish democracy in Armenia,”
Narine Lazarian, chairwoman of the board of the National Press Club,
said in Yerevan today.

There are all preconditions for a revolution to take place in the
country, she said addressing a seminar entitled “Possibility of a
revolution in Armenia: preconditions and consequences”.

The head of the National Press Club said that “the incumbent political
elite in Armenia is losing its position and is not capable of
resolving current problems”. Lazarian said that “the incumbent
authorities have established a monopoly on politics, are hindering
healthy political competition and are openly promoting corruption”.

She went on to say that a revolution was the only way to establish
democracy in Armenia as “it will provide tools for fighting crime and
building a true civic society”.