Turkish Press: Turkey’s minority leaders sign joint declaration denying ‘pressure’ on communities

Daily Sabah, Turkey
Turkey’s minority leaders sign joint declaration denying ‘pressure’ on communities
File photo shows President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan shaking hands with leaders of the Bulgarian Orthodox Church in Istanbul. (AA Photo)

Leaders of every non-Muslim community in Turkey came together Tuesday to sign a joint declaration saying they are free to follow their faith in Turkey and denying allegations that members of minority faiths have experienced “pressure” on their communities.

Among the leaders of the group were Greek Orthodox Patriarch Bartholomew I of Constantinople, Turkey Armenian Deputy Patriarch Archbishop Aram Ateşyan and Turkey’s Chief Rabbi Ishak Haleva.

The declaration sought to address allegations against the Turkish government that people of minority religions – including Orthodox Christianity, Syriac Christianity, Judaism and others – had been persecuted or hindered from worship and free _expression_ of their faith.

“As religious representatives and directors of different faiths and beliefs who have been residing in our country for centuries, we live out our faiths freely and practice our worship freely according to our traditions,” the statement said.

“The statements that claim and/or imply that [our faiths] are under pressure are totally unfounded and exceed reality. Many troubles and instances of victimization experienced in the past have been resolved in time,” the leaders wrote.

They added that they are “constantly in consultations” with state institution in mutual goodwill to find solutions to issues faced by the minority communities.

The statement specified that the leadership felt the need to make a clear, joint declaration in order to provide the public with correct information.

Apart from Armenian, Greek Orthodox and Jewish leaders, heads of foundations running places of worship and schools for non-Muslim minorities also signed the declaration. Among them were patriarchal vicar of the Syriac Orthodox Church, Yusuf Çetin; Archbishop Levon Zekiyan, who serves as Armenian Catholic archeparch; François Yakan, acting patriarch of the Chaldean community; Orhan Çanlı, acting patriarch of the Syriac Catholic Church of Turkey; and Pastor Kirkor Ağabaloğlu on behalf of the Armenian Protestant Church. Heads of foundations representing non-Muslim communities, from Jewish community leader İshak İbrahimzadeh to Bedros Şirinoğlu, who represents an umbrella organization of Armenian foundations, also signed the declaration.

In the past decade, Turkey has moved to reinstate the rights of minorities and help their survival as their numbers have dwindled over time. Long treated as second-class citizens, the Greek, Jewish, Armenian and Syriac communities have praised the efforts for the return of their rights, though they have complained about it being a slow process. Actions such as the controversial wealth tax imposed in 1942 that targeted rich non-Muslims, a pogrom in 1955 and the deportation of non-Muslim Turkish citizens in 1964 have added to “a fear of the state” among non-Muslim minorities in the past and forced a large number of people to leave the country.

The declaration did not specify any allegation, but a recent report by the U.S. State Department on religious freedoms painted a grim picture for Turkey’s non-Muslim minorities by claiming violations of religious freedoms. Turkey has slammed the report and a Foreign Ministry spokesman said in May that it was “a repetition of certain baseless [yet] repeatedly made claims.”

Tehran: Restoration commences on St. George Church

Tehran Times, Iran
  1. Society

TEHRAN – A new round of restoration project has recently started on the centuries-old Saint George Church, which is located in Haftvan village, northwestern West Azarbaijan province.

Flooring, landscaping, fresco paintings, perimeter walls, and its indoor amphitheater are being rehabilitated, ISNA reported.

The church dates from the late Safavid era (1501–1736) and is inscribed on the National Heritage List. 

In 2008, UNESCO registered Monastery of Saint Thaddeus (Qareh Klise), St. Stepanos Monastery and the Chapel of Dzordzor, altogether under the title “Armenian Monastic Ensembles of Iran”.

PHOTO: A view of Saint George Church in Haftvan

AFM/MQ/MG

Asbarez: Azerbaijan Organizes its Own Diaspora to Compete With the Armenian Diaspora

Harut Sassounian

BY HARUT SASSOUNIAN

For many decades, the Turkish government has had an inflated image of the Armenian Diaspora, describing it as a giant worldwide force. In recent years, Azerbaijan has been infected with the same fear of the global Armenian Diaspora. Pres. Ilham Aliyev has described the ‘Armenian lobby’ as the greatest enemy of Azerbaijan. Consequently, the Azeri leaders have started pouring massive resources into the formation of their own diaspora in various countries as a counterpart to the “powerful Armenian lobby.”

Ironically, while the Armenian government is making plans for the repatriation of Armenians from overseas, Azerbaijan is trying to do the exact opposite by encouraging Azeris to move to formerly Soviet countries, Europe and the United States in order to enlarge its Diaspora!

Nazim Ibrahimov, Chairman of Azerbaijan’s State Committee for Work with the Diaspora, recently announced that “the establishment of coordination centers for world Azerbaijanis continues and that this affair is one of Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev’s priorities…. The state of Azerbaijan has created massive financial conditions for this. Upon the president’s orders, we offer support to our diaspora organizations around the world. On account of this activity, the Azerbaijani diaspora not only responds to the Armenian lobby decently, but also overpowers them at times.”

Last year, Sergey Rumantsev, a graduate of Baku State University, wrote an article in the OpenDemocracy.net website, titled: “Long Live the Azerbaijani Diaspora,” stating that “Baku is going to great lengths to mobilize, or even create, an international Azerbaijani diaspora.” The main purpose of the Azeri Diaspora is to counter Armenians in the Karabagh (Artsakh) conflict. Azeri leaders view the Armenian Diaspora “as immensely influential and strongly united in solidarity,” hence, “for Azerbaijan’s ruling Aliyev regime, a diaspora is synonymous with an overseas political lobby.”

Azeris have such an exaggerated view of the Armenian Diaspora that when the Russian Supreme Court decided to annul the registration of the All-Russian Azerbaijani Congress last year, “many [Azeri] commentators rushed to conclusions about Armenian plots and intrigues,” Rumantsev wrote. The truth is that the Azeri organization had violated Russian laws. Armenians had nothing to do with its closing.

Azeri authorities were so impressed by the Armenian Diaspora’s political clout that since the early 2000s they “have invested large sums of financial and symbolic capital into this project. They’ve tried to conjure up a diaspora to their liking as quickly as possible.”

It all started when Heydar Aliyev, the father of the current president, was the leader of Soviet Azerbaijan in the 1970’s-80s. He arranged for the education of many Azeri students in universities throughout the Soviet Union and encouraged the relocation of Azeris to various Soviet Republics!

Prior to the Second World Congress of Azerbaijanis, held on March 16, 2016, “the state committee for working with Azerbaijanis abroad produced a documentary film with the telling title, ‘we’re a nation of 50 million,’ ” Rumantsev wrote. The committee stated that 10 million Azerbaijanis were living in about 70 countries.

Rumantsev asserted that Azeris living overseas are not a coherent group; there is a considerable difference among Azeri immigrants: “Azeri Diaspora activism is generally limited to quite a small circle of ethnic Azerbaijani businessmen and their family members.”

Rumantsev described the origins of the organizational efforts for Azeris abroad: “In November 2001, Baku held the inaugural World Congress of Azerbaijanis at the initiative of Heydar Aliyev. The following year saw the foundation of the state committee for working with Azerbaijanis abroad — Nazim Ibrahimov was appointed its permanent leader. Its first convention led to the creation of yet another body, the ‘Coordinating Council of World Azerbaijanis’, led by, of course, pan-Azerbaijani president Heydar Aliyev. The success of diaspora-building henceforth came to be measured in how many organizations existed, and how to unify them into one structure.”

The World Congress of Azerbaijanis consists of local/regional bodies, followed by Azeri organizations in various countries and finally by the World Congress which takes its orders directly from the Azeri government.

President Ilham Aliyev proudly told attendees of a recent conference of World Congress of Azerbaijanis: “if we had 336 diaspora organizations five years ago, now we have 416.” At the Fourth World Congress in 2015, “delegates stated that there are now 462 such organizations.”

The few activities Azeris participate in worldwide are represented by Azerbaijan’s official media in an exaggerated fashion, as if a large number of Azeris in Europe or the U.S. are involved in pro-Azerbaijan activities, in support of the Aliyev regime. For example, when Armenia’s President Serzh Sargsyan visited Berlin in 2016, a small number of Azeris held a protest, and sent the following message to Pres. Aliyev: “Mr. President — you have the support of Azerbaijanis across the world!”

Rumantsev concluded his article by stating that the Azerbaijani Diaspora cannot be compared to the classical Diasporas of Armenians, Jews or Greeks. Most Azeri organizations overseas “exist only on paper.”

Ejmiatsin city shuts down kindergartens for 1 month citing weather-related health concerns

Category
Society

The City Hall of Ejmiatsin (Vagharshapat) is declaring holidays at local kindergartens from July 23 to August 20 citing weather-related health concerns.

Acting Mayor of Ejmiatsin Diana Gasparyan said on Facebook that a heat wave is expected from July 25, and “unfortunately many of the kindergartens are in poor conditions, and the children’s attendance in such conditions can be hazardous for their health”. Gasparyan was apparently referring to the lack of ACs in the kindergartens.

She said they even had cases of staff losing consciousness due to extreme heat.

The acting mayor said they even carried out a survey among parents, and only 25 from 1194 parents opposed the idea of the special holidays.

Head of the meteorology department at the ministry of emergency situations Gagik Surenyan told ARMENPRESS that up to 40 degrees Celsius is expected from July 25 in Armenia.

‘EU stands ready to support Armenian government’s reforms agenda’ – Katarína Mathernová

ArmenPress, Armenia
‘EU stands ready to support Armenian government’s reforms agenda’ – Katarína Mathernová


YEREVAN, JULY 20, ARMENPRESS. Katarína Mathernová, Deputy Director-General for Neighbourhood and Enlargement Negotiations at the European Commission is on a visit to Armenia on 19-21 July. She underlined the importance of deepening relations on the basis of the EU-Armenia Comprehensive and Enhanced Partnership Agreement (CEPA) for the benefit of the citizens of Armenia. The visit of Deputy Director-General Mathernová is an important milestone in EU-Armenia relations as it is the first senior-level visit by the European Commission to the country since the new government took office. It takes place after the last week’s high-level meetings of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan in Brussels, the EU delegation to Armenia said.

During her visit, Deputy Director-General Mathernová said: “Since the provisional entry into force of the EU-Armenia Comprehensive and Enhanced Partnership Agreement on 1 June, the EU’s relations with Armenia are closer than ever. The EU stands ready to support the Government’s reforms agenda and will continue to work together with the Government to best meet the hopes and expectations of Armenia’s citizens. Our recent opinion polls show that 80% of citizens across the country describe relations between Armenia and the EU as positive. The EU is the biggest trade partner in Armenia and the main donor with increasing support over the years providing €46 million in 2018 in bilateral assistance only. Working jointly towards achieving the “20 Deliverables for 2020” within the framework of the Eastern Partnership is another major objective of our cooperation to bring tangible benefits to our citizens.”

Discussions with the government during the visit, including with Deputy Prime Minister Mr. Mher Grigoryan, focused on how to maximise the impact of EU-Armenia cooperation by concrete actions: (1) deepening engagement by providing EU expertise through High Level Advisors to help formulate and implement reforms; (2) a CEPA facility which can mobilise around €80 million for private sector investment; (3) hold an EU week in Armenia in September with a series of events around the Partnership Committee in Trade configuration. Deputy Director-General Mathernová also met Minister of Economic Development and Investments Mr. Artsvik Minasyan, as well as with Armenian private sector representatives and International Financial Institutions. They discussed how to best develop together Armenia’s economic potential, including by unlocking the full capacity of the private sector and supporting small and medium size enterprises.

Reinforcing the effectiveness of public services was also high on the agenda during the visit. Together with Deputy Prime Minister Tigran Avinyan, Deputy Director-General Mathernová launched the project “EU for Armenia – E-Gov Actions”. This brings together all the government applications supported by the EU under one platform, such as e-register.am and e-request.am. These online portals have transformed the way in which citizens and businesses interact with their local and national administration by increasing quality of service, efficiency and transparency. Moreover, Deputy Director-General Mathernová met with leading civil society representatives to discuss key issues of governance and human rights as well as EU support.

Looking ahead, Deputy Director-General Mathernová and Armenian Government representatives agreed to continue and enhance close cooperation in view of the government’s ambitious reform programme to achieve concrete results for the benefit of Armenian citizens.


Head of EU Delegation: European leaders ready to convey peace messages to Azerbaijan

Arminfo, Armenia
Head of EU Delegation: European leaders ready to convey peace messages to Azerbaijan

Yerevan July 16

Naira Badalian. The heads of European countries took seriously the words of Nikol Pashinyan about Karabakh, voiced in Brussels, and are ready to convey peace messages to Azerbaijan. This was stated to journalists by the head of EU delegation to Armenia Piotr Swatalsky.

According to the ambassador, it is necessary to do everything possible to reduce the escalation of the conflict. “We are doing our best, including assisting the OSCE Minsk Group on the Karabakh settlement,” the European diplomat said.

As Switalski pointed out, the first meeting of the Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan was held in Brussels. The Karabakh issue was among the priorities also during the Brussels meetings of the Armenian prime minister with high-ranking EU officials. “We listened to the concerns of the Armenian side and will do everything possible to send peace and peace messages to Azerbaijan,” the ambassador said.

To note, while in Brussels, Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan gave an interview to the Euronews television channel. In connection with the Karabakh problem, Pashinyan said in particular: “This conflict should be resolved only peacefully. Unfortunately, from the first days of my tenure as prime minister of Armenia, I see that Azerbaijan is increasing its aggressiveness towards Armenia. In my opinion, now we see that the situation is changing, because this aggressive policy is directed not only against Armenia, but also against democracy, because now Armenia is really a democratic country. ” “I think the leadership of Azerbaijan is afraid that its own people, inspired by the Armenian processes, will start democratic changes in Azerbaijan,” Pashinyan said. Answering the question about the possible role of NATO in the settlement of the Karabakh conflict, the prime minister noted that it would be very useful if NATO sends a strong signal to Azerbaijan that any attempt to resolve the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict using force will meet strong reaction from the international community.

A1+: Two foreigners in various regions steal money

On July 6, the Masis police department received a message that in one of the banks operating in Masis, foreign men exchanged money, one of them secretly stole 1,300 euros.

On the same day, a message was sent to the Sevan Police Station that foreigners came to the gas station on the pretext of exchanging money, diverted the attention of the employee and stole money from the cash register.

Employees of various police units, through joint work, found out their whereabouts. A few hours after the messages, two foreigners were found and brought to the Sevan police station.

Measures are being taken to detect the third person.

Ethnic Armenian blogger alarms about danger threatening his life after Azerbaijan visit

Category
World

Belarussian blogger of Armenian origin Vladislav Mosesov, who visited Azerbaijan recently with a Belarussian passport, alarms that his life is under danger, the blogger said in a video message.

The blogger said that on July 13 Azerbaijan declared him wanted, however, he has already left Belarus.

“Yesterday Azerbaijan declared me wanted. I have already left my country, but I cannot say yet where I am going for security reasons. I ask all those countries which consider me as their associate to take actions in connection with my situation. All those followers, who cannot help with anything, please share this video. My life is now under danger. I am followed at any moment, believe me, I know what I am saying. If I do not get in touch after three days, it will mean that something bad happened to me”, the blogger said.

The blogger clarified his visit to Azerbaijan, noting that he visited the country with peace, for tourism.

He said the threats include allegations that a certain country has paid him to intentionally defame Azerbaijan, and that his video made in the country contains provocations.

“I visited Azerbaijan with peace, like I visit any other country. I mentioned in my video that the purpose was to show people like they are. I showed people who gave me shelter, food, helped me to navigate, however everyone somehow saw something negative in it,” he said.

At the same time, he emphasized that the aggression and hostility towards tourists which he saw in Azerbaijan he hadn’t seen anywhere else, and naturally he gave a response.

Azerbaijan’s behavior questions Baku’s commitment to peace process: Armenian PM delivers remarks at NATO summit

ArmenPress, Armenia
Azerbaijan’s behavior questions Baku’s commitment to peace process: Armenian PM delivers remarks at NATO summit


YEREVAN, JULY 12, ARMENPRESS. Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan delivered remarks during the NATO summit in Brussels at the meeting of the heads of states and governments contributing to the Resolute Support mission in Afghanistan.

Armenpress presents the full text of the PM’s speech:

“Respectful Prime Minister Michel, Respectful President Ghani,

Respectful Secretary General,

Dear colleagues,

First of all I want to thank Prime Minister Michel for the warm reception. Participating in this event, which is dedicated to the international efforts for peace and stability in Afghanistan, is an honor for me. Peace and security are vital for the sustainable development: the democracy and free market economy are also such. As you know, Armenia recently launched drastic changes with the goal to build its democratic future. The victory of velvet revolution in Armenia was the clear manifestation of the maturity of the Armenian society, the advocate of its commitment to human rights and fundamental freedoms.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Today’s meeting once again highlights the issues of international security and the need to maintain the existing collective approach on this matter. Firm belief and readiness to bring peace, security and stability to the good people of Afghanistan unites all of us.

We highly appreciate the efforts of the Afghan government to increase the state-building and security level. This would be impossible without the unconditional dedication and sacrifice of the Afghan people, army and security forces. However, still a lot needs to be done so that the progress becomes irreversible.

As an advocate of collective security, Armenia will continue contributing to the efforts aimed at strengthening international peace and security.

The peace process requires constructive approach and discussion of positions of all sides. Therefore, we need to unite the efforts of the international community to reach exclusively a peaceful settlement, which is very important for the European security in general.

Since 2010 Armenia contributed to the NATO’s actions on establishing peace in Afghanistan, also within the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) and the Resolute Support mission. We appreciate the productive cooperation between Armenia and Germany, which, in my opinion, is one of the best and vivid examples of partnership between a NATO member and partner states.

We are ready to continue our engagement to the mission with up to 130 troops. We have also expressed our readiness to participate in NATO’s sustainable partnership mission when it comes to replace the Sustainable support mission.

Armenia will continue supporting the inclusive peace process led and participated by Afghanistan. I want to once again state that we will continue supporting the international efforts aimed at establishing comprehensive peace, prosperity and stability in friendly Afghanistan.

As there was a talk on the Nagorno Karabakh conflict, I have to touch upon the settlement of this conflict, although I think that this issue is incompatible with the format of these discussions as this meeting pursues other goals. NATO has constantly and comprehensively stated that it plays no role in this conflict settlement process.

Nevertheless, as the issue has already been raised, I would like to briefly comment on and make clarifications in the context of the already made statement. Armenia, like any other democratic country, reaffirms its commitment to the exclusively peaceful settlement of the Nagorno Karabakh conflict within the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairmanship format. Any attempt to settle this conflict through military means should be viewed as an attack on democracy, human rights and peace.

The recent ceasefire violation and provocation cases provoked by Azerbaijan on the border with Armenia and the line of contact with Artsakh seriously question Baku’s commitment to the peace process.

We reaffirm the importance of the implementation of the previous agreements, in particular, those reached during the meetings in Vienna, St. Petersburg and Geneva, which aim at creating favorable conditions for peace and making confidence-building measures”.

Edited and translated by Aneta Harutyunyan

Political analysts are sceptical about Babayan’s chances of coming to power in Nagorno-Karabakh

Kavkazsky Uzel , Russia
July 10 2018
Political analysts are sceptical about Babayan’s chances of coming to power in Nagorno-Karabakh

by Tigran Petrosyan
[Armenian News note: the below is translated from Russian]

A change of power in [Azerbaijan’s breakaway] Nagorno-Karabakh is possible only at the discretion of the new Armenian government, but they supported president Bako Sahakyan and the reforms he has started, political analysts interviewed by Kavkazsky Uzel have said. Yerevan does not contemplate Samvel Babayan as an important figure in Nagorno-Karabakh, Boris Navasardyan believes. He enjoys a high approval rating, but the public has not forgotten Babayan’s non-democratic approaches in the times he was in power [Babayan was commander of the Nagorno-Karabakh army until 1999], Hakob Badalyan noted. Babayan himself will not destabilise the situation, Ruben Mehrabyan said. He does not have a serious political weight to have claims to power, Armen Badalyan thinks.

Kavkazsky Uzel reported that on 6 July, Babayan’s supporters urged residents of [Karabakh capital] Stepanakert [Xankandi] to assemble on 10 July to meet former Nagorno-Karabakh defence minister, when he would enter the town. Babayan himself told journalists on 6 July that he was ready to go to Nagorno-Karabakh, if the Armenian government and public regarded this as necessary. [Babayan was sentenced to six years in prison on charges of delivering PZRK (portable antiaircraft missile systems) to Armenia. Babayan and the opposition described the sentence as politically motivated. After the velvet revolution in Armenia, on 15 June, the Armenian Court of Appeals returned the case to the court of the original jurisdiction and ruled to release Babayan from custody.]

Pashinyan supported reforms launched by Sahakyan

Samvel Babayan’s reputation is ambiguous. On the one hand, he enjoys unconditional standing in certain circles, but opposing opinion is also expressed about him, as the public still has questions regarding the period, when he was in power, political observer Hakob Badalyan said.

“People in Artsakh [Nagorno-Karabakh] remember, to put it mildly, his non-democratic approaches, when he was in power during the post-war years. However, the problem lies not in what approval rating he enjoys and whether it is higher or lower than the approval rating of president Bako Sahakyan. It may be higher, but this does not mean that if he [Sahakyan] resigns, it will happen because of Samvel Babayan,” Badalyan told Kavkazsky Uzel.

He believes that Babayan will visit Nagorno-Karabakh without any political claims. “The Armenian government supported president Bako Sahakyan and [Armenian Prime Minister] Nikol Pashinyan supported the reforms he had launched. Bako Sahakyan has effectively become a locum tenens, who is to carry out reforms in the government and depart. It is another issue, whether this is to happen before 2020 or earlier [phrase as published], but reforms should be carried out. And things have remained within the frames of this logic so far,” the political observer explained.

Certain consensus between the government and society has taken shape in Nagorno-Karabakh, Badalyan believes: “This provides grounds to presume that there are going to be no attempts to destabilise the situation. However, if someone decides to use his [Babayan’s] approval rating for his own political purposes, it will be, first, a marginal force and second, the attempt is going to be unsuccessful, as this goes contrary to relations between Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh,” he said.

Consensus has been reached in Nagorno Karabakh on the need of carrying out reforms and there are no grounds for Sahakyan’s resignation before his term in office expires, Ruben Mehrabyan, an expert of the Centre for Political ad International Studies, believes.

“Nagorno-Karabakh, its leadership, and president Bako Sahakyan, who will remain in the post until 2020, enjoy unconditional support from the Armenian government and there are no grounds to believe that the president will depart before his term in office expires. Moreover, Samvel Babayan himself said that he does not intend to destabilise the situation,” Mehrabyan told Kavkazsky Uzel.

He said that domestic political destabilisation posed threats to Nagorno-Karabakh’s security and Babayan would not resort to this step. “It is another issue that Babayan is a man, who has unique experience and his personal qualities may be highly sought in military affairs, state-building, and reinforcement of national security,” Mehrabyan noted.

Destabilisation in Nagorno-Karabakh to harm Armenia’s foreign policy

Spin doctor Armen Badalyan thinks that there are no grounds to regard Babayan as a rival of Sahakyan. “Bako Sahakyan has said that he is not going to run in the election in 2020. Correspondingly, they cannot be competitors or rivals… The Armenian government are sending messages that they support reforms and that the government must be replaced according to the planned scenario,” Badalyan told Kavkazsky Uzel.

He said that the Armenian government would not allow domestic political destabilisation in Nagorno-Karabakh, taking into account tensions on both the frontline and the border with Naxcivan. He believes that destabilisation in Nagorno-Karabakh will harm Armenia’s foreign policy.

“The new government is now focused on the domestic political situation in Armenia proper, settlement of the Karabakh conflict, and development of relations with the EU and Nato, so destabilisation in Nagorno-Karabakh is not advantageous for them. That is why it is important to maintain stability,” the spin doctor stressed.

Badalyan nevertheless did not rule out that two former Armenian presidents Robert Kocharyan and Serzh Sargsyan, who are natives of Nagorno-Karabakh, may try to retrieve their losses, but, according to the spin doctor, they will fail to use for their own purposes both Bako Sahakyan and Samvel Babayan.

“Bako Sahakyan will not cede his positions. It will be not so easy to remove him. If such a demand comes from the new [Armenian] government, he will cede… As regards Samvel Babayan, he does not have serious political weight to lay claims to power. It should be born in mind that he was accused of attempting on [former Karabakh] president Arkadi Ghukasyan’s life [on 22 March 2000, when two people wounded Ghukasyan and his bodyguard and driver. On 26 February 2001, Babayan was sentenced to 14 years in prison, but was pardoned on 17 September 2004 because of his deteriorating health]. In addition, he was distinguished with his ‘heavy-handed’ policy, when he was in power. People in Nagorno-Karabakh remember this. On top of this, he is very experienced in clannish struggling. It will be difficult to use him for someone’s own purposes,” Badalyan noted.

Babayan failed to secure support from new Armenian government

In order to lay claims to power in Nagorno-Karabakh, you need to be trusted by the new Armenian government. However, they do not regard Samvel Babayan as an “important political figure in Nagorno-Karabakh“, the head of the Yerevan Press Club, Boris Navasardyan believes.

He noted that Nikol Pashinyan and his team enjoyed popularity in society in Karabakh and the opinion of the new government was decisive. “I do not think that the former defence minister has any good prospects. It is not the question of the Armenian government’s desire to avoid destabilisation. Some replacement will be found for Bako Sahakyan by the end of his term in office. Samvel Babayan’s candidacy is simply not very attractive with all due respect for his military exploits,” Navasardyan told Kavkazsky Uzel.

At the same time, the head of the Press Club believes that the former minister has supporters, who have supported him since he was in opposition to president Arkadi Ghukasyan. There are also people linked to him in the government, the army, and business. “However, Samvel Babayan will not resort to destabilisation. He is one of those people, who could bid defiance, having a real opportunity to do so. However, it is senseless to launch anything without support from Yerevan. Therefore, the ex-minister’s behaviour is going to be accurate,” he believes.

An early presidential election is possible in Nagorno-Karabakh, if a real figure, who enjoys support both in Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia emerges, he added. “No such figure can be seen at this stage. Therefore, it is expedient for both Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia to maintain stability, allowing Bako Sahakyan to exhaust his term in office,” Navasardyan believes.