Armenia and Iran have not signed any document on pasture lease

Armenia and Iran have not signed any document on pasture lease

YEREVAN, December 28. /ARKA/. There is no any agreement between
Armenia and Iran about rent of pastures in Siunik in exchange for
Iranian agricultural machinery, Armenian minister of territorial
administration and vice premier of Armenia Armen Gevorgyan told a
press conference Friday.

Earlier Iranian mass media reported that an agreement is expected to
be signed during the visit of head of Siunik region of Armenia to
Eastern Azerbaijan province of Iran. Under the alleged document,
Siunik region was to lease pastures for some 5,000 cow head from the
province of Eastern Azerbaijan in exchange for agricultural equipment
produced in the province.

`At the moment there is no such a document in circulation. These kinds
of proposals are brought up and discussed from time to time, not only
in relation to Siunik region, but to lease of pastures in other
regions as well. No such agreement exists,’ Gevorgyan said.

The minister also said that governor of Siunik has not travelled to Iran yet.

`If such agreements are made, we will notify immediately,’ the
minister said adding that Armenia needs all its pastures, and efforts
will be made to efficiently use the pastures for ensuring local
community budget receipts.

According to the ministry of agriculture, only 30% of overall 1
million 118,000 hectares of Armenian pastures is used efficiently.
-0-

Nearly 40 apartment buildings commissioned in Gyumri in 2012

Nearly 40 apartment buildings commissioned in Armenia’s Gyumri in 2012- minister

YEREVAN, December 28. /ARKA/. Armenia’s Urban Development Minister
Samvel Tadevosyan said Friday 38 apartment buildings with 1,756
apartments were commissioned in Gyumri suburbs Mush 2-2 and Ani in
October.

`In the framework of the program aimed at providing lodging to the
families who lost their apartments after the earthquake, we managed to
improve the lodging conditions for 3,700 families, and in the near
future we plan to provide another 1,700 families with apartments,’ he
said.

Tadevosyan added the construction is currently being conducted in
order to provide 750 families with lodging.

Minister informed the government invested into this program 85 billion
drams. The program was launched in 2008 and will be finished in 2013.
`Upon finishing the program we will have provided nearly 5,500
families with dwelling,’ he noted.

Minister also said another 330 Gyumri families received 3 million
drams each to buy one- bedroom apartment.

Gyumri city, former Leninakan, is the second largest city in Armenia
and the capital of the Shirak Province in the northwestern part of the
country. It suffered a disastrous damage during Spitak earthquake on 7
December 1988. ($1 – 403.27 drams). -0-

Libération de prison de Soner Yalçin, journaliste d’opposition connu

TURQUIE
Libération de prison de Soner Yalçin, journaliste d’opposition connu

ISTANBUL, 2012 (AFP) – Une Cour d’Istanbul a décidé jeudi de libérer
un journaliste d’investigation connu, Soner Yalçin, jugé pour complot
contre le gouvernement islamo-conservateur turc, près de deux ans
après son incarcération. M. Yalçin avait été arrêté en mars 2011 avec
une dizaine d’autres personnes, dont des journalistes, et inculpé pour
avoir aidé le réseau dit Ergenekon, soupçonné d’avoir tenté de créer
un terrain favorable à un coup d’Etat militaire en multipliant les
attentats et les campagnes de désinformation.

La Cour lui a interdit de quitter le territoire turc et il devra
comparaître en tant que prévenu libre aux prochaines audiences dans
son procès, rapportent les médias. Dans une lettre publiée en novembre
dernier dans le journal français Le Figaro, le journaliste avait écrit
: `Je sens déjà que vais être condamné à être oublié`. A 47 ans, dont
25 consacrés au journalisme, M. Yalçin était un ancien chroniqueur du
quotidien Hürriyet, et était, avant son incarcération, le rédacteur en
chef du site d’information OdaTV, connu pour sa farouche opposition au
gouvernement du Premier ministre Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

Soner Yalçin a également rédigé une autre lettre, publiée par le
journal français Humanité, dans laquelle il a décrit les terribles
conditions de détention de ses confrères journalistes en Turquie. `Je
continuerai sans relche à écrire. Nous avons appris à mourir, mais à
ne pas céder`, a-t-il dit jeudi soir à la presse à sa sortie de la
prison de Silivri, située dans une lointaine banlieue d’Istanbul.

La Turquie est régulièrement montrée du doigt sur le dossier des
libertés et des droits de l’Homme. Le gouvernement de M. Erdogan est
accusé de dérive autoritaire et soupçonné de procéder à une campagne
d’intimidation contre la presse. Deux autres journalistes connus,
emprisonnés dans le cadre de ce procès, avaient été libérés en mars
2012, un an après avoir été incarcérés.

Selon l’Institut international de la presse (IPI), plus de 100
journalistes sont actuellement emprisonnés en Turquie. D’après le
Comité de protection des journalistes (CPJ), dont le siège est aux
Etats-Unis, la Turquie est le `premier geôlier mondial` de
journalistes, suivi par l’Iran et la Chine.

A la date du 1er décembre, la Turquie détenait au moins 49
journalistes, dont des dizaines de journalistes kurdes accusés de
`terrorisme`, affirme le CPJ. D’autres journalistes emprisonnés sont
accusés de comploter contre le gouvernement.

vendredi 28 décembre 2012,
Ara ©armenews.com

Newly opened Armenian chair of crucial importance for Bucharest U.

Newly opened Armenian chair is of crucial importance for Bucharest
University. Romanian Ambassador to Armenia

21:23, 27 December, 2012

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 27, ARMENPRESS: Armenian Education and Science
Minister Armen Ashotyan received certificate of honor from Romanian
Ambassador to Armenia Rodica Crina Prunariu in connection with the
fifteenth anniversary of Armenian-Romanian diplomatic ties. As
Armenpress was informed from the Ministry of Education Congratulating
the Minister, the Ambassador stressed Ashotyan’s personal contribution
to the strengthening of Armenian-Romanian relations, specifically in
the expansion of cooperation in the field of education, the Education
and Science.

During the meeting, the interlocutors noted that, as a result of the
Armenian-Romanian cooperation in the domain of education, an Armenian
chair was opened at the University of Bucharest, and its students have
become more active.

Expressing gratitude for award, Armenian Education and Science
Minister Armen Ashotyan noted that bilateral cooperation especially
the student exchange programs have prospects for development.

Ambassador of Kuwait: Armenia not open for investments

Ambassador of Kuwait: Armenia not open for investments
ArmInfo’s interview with Ambassador of Kuwait to Armenia Bassam
Mohammed Al-Qabandi

by Marianna Lazarian

Thursday, December 27, 19:34

Among the issues discussed during the recent visit by Armenian Foreign
Minister Edward Nalbandian to Kuwait was possible visit of Emir of
Kuwait, Sheikh Jaber III al-Ahmad al -Jaber al-Sabah to Armenia. At
what stage is that issue at present?

Nalbandian’s visit was quite successful by all criteria, first of all,
because it finally took place after several postponements by both
Armenia and Kuwait due to some objective reasons in the political
situation in both the countries. One of the positive arrangements made
during that visit was cancellation of visas for the two countries’
diplomats and the invitation for the Emir of Kuwait to visit Armenia.
Emir confirmed his desire to visit Armenia and I think the visit will
take place in the near future. In addition, among other achievements
of the two countries were many agreements signed earlier. During their
meeting the Kuwaiti Prime Minister and the Armenian Foreign Minister
made an arrangement of economic cooperation. A meeting was held with
the Finance Minister of Kuwait, who is also the Kuwaiti Co-Chair the
Intergovernmental Commission. The parties agreed to discuss the terms
of a second business forum of the two countries within the coming 3
months. I’d like to recall that the Armenian co-chair of the
Armenian-Kuwaiti Intergovernmental Commission is the Minister of
Territorial Administration.

Kuwait Fund For Arab Economic Development (KFAED) has announced an
intention to implement projects in Armenia. What projects are in
question and how much they will cost?

There are two funds, Kuwait Fund For Arab Economic Development (KFAED)
and Kuwait Investment Authority (KIA). Nalbandian had a meeting with
the head of KFAED. The two parties discussed an issue of repair of
some 10-11 Armenian polyclinics. We have received a letter from the
Healthcare Ministry of Armenia requesting assistance in repair of the
above polyclinics, but KFAED has not studied the request, because it
studies requests only from the finance ministries of countries. Since
the procedure was not observed, the issue has not been discussed.
Nalbandian promised to tackle the issue on his return to Armenia and
address the Fund from the Finance Ministry. I’d like to say that
repair of medical establishments in the regions is a very important
task because Armenia needs it. Our Fund operates also in Africa and
Asia and in some other countries, but there are procedural rules of
KFAED that must be observed.

Thus, the obstacles are of technical nature… Is it known what
particular regions in Armenia will be involved in the project?

Surely, these are procedural and technical issues. Receiving a request
from the Finance Ministry of Armenia, it will be possible to start
studying the request that will contain also a cost estimate for the
needs of regional polyclinics. Only after signing the given agreement
it will become known what particular polyclinics will receive
assistance of the Fund. I am sure that issue will be settled as
Nalbandian himself promised to tackle it.

As for the KIA, I’d like to say that it is a separate structure that
was founded in 60s of the last century. The state budget allocated
quite a significant amount of sum to establish it. Some 10%-15% of
profits from the oil recovery are directed to the given Fund annually.
It is also called the Fund of the future generation. All the funds
directed to KIA are spent on investment projects. In order the Fund
makes investments in Armenia it is necessary to pave the way for it.
First of all, I mean the infrastructures. Our countries lack air
communication and a Kuwaiti investor is reluctant to arrive in Armenia
via third countries losing over 8 hours in the way. In the meanwhile,
a direct flight to Armenia would take 1 hour and 50 minutes. The Fund
cannot persuade a private investor to leave for Armenia unless there
are relevant conditions for investing. The two countries have an
agreement on tourism development, which is not implemented also for
the same reason. We hope Armenia will create all the conditions for
direct air communication.

As far as I know during your meeting with Armenian Diaspora Minister
Hranush Hakobyan you mentioned some technical reasons that impede
direct flights. What reasons are these?

The civil aviation departments of the two countries need an agreement
wherein they must observe the parity principles in line of the rules
of ICAO, and an opportunity should be provided for the use of the
fifth freedom right. A question arises as to whether an investor will
arrive in your country if it is not favorable for investments.

You are right, there has been such problem in the country for a long
period of time already. This is because the Armenian aviation market
is not only monopolized but also it has limited possibilities.
Therefore, the parity principles cannot be observed with many
countries. I’d like to know what contractual basis is there between
Armenia and Kuwait? In what fields do the countries cooperate and in
what fields do they plan to launch cooperation?

We have signed an agreement on mutual protection of investments, on
abolition of double taxation, agreement on exchange of students. Every
year 4 Armenian students receive education in Kuwait. Last year, 2
students arrived in Kuwait to study. Don’t forget that we have an
Armenian community comprising nearly 6,000 people. There is an
Armenian school that was established 50 years ago. The Kuwaiti people
are familiar with the Armenian culture and traditions. During his
meeting with Nalbandian, our Emir highly appreciated the Armenian
community. The Armenians in Kuwait are very hardworking and honest.
They have never complained during such long period of residence in our
country. The Armenian community is among the most respectful ones in
Kuwait.

Have you got any statistics on Kuwait’s investments in Armenia?
Official statistics keeps silence. In what fields may Kuwait’s
investments be used most effectively?

Unfortunately, no investments in Armenia from Kuwait and its citizens
have been registered; everything is at a standstill. It is necessary
to create relevant conditions for investments; a relevant ground is
needed.

We also tried to learn the statistics on foreign trade turnover
between our countries, but we have not found it either.

I have already said that, unfortunately, there are no more or less
developed trade and economic relations between our countries. If
Armenia is not open for some reason, there are no basic conditions for
development of any partner relations. Nobody will agree to waste time;
Armenia is not open for Kuwait’s investments. Furthermore, I invited
representatives of Kuwait’s civil aviation to Armenia, and we held a
consultation that covered the issue of air communication. Some
promises were given, but the issue did not get off the ground.

The Government of Kuwait has announced its intention to allocate
100,000 USD to support the Syrian Armenians. What stage is this issue
at?

We are cooperating with the Armenian Diaspora Ministry. There is a
Center for Coordination of Syrian-Armenians’ Issues NGO that deals
with distribution of the aid. The amount should be converted into
coupons for the beneficiaries to make use of food and commodities.
This program is underway. As soon as the coupons are printed, we will
start distributing them. Due to these coupons, the beneficiaries will
be able to acquire goods of first priority, except alcohol drinks and
cigarettes. The whole amount will be distributed among 200 families.
This money will supposedly be enough for 4 months.

As far as I remember, Armenian Diaspora Minister Hranush Hakobyan
offered you to renovate a building consisting of 50 apartments for
Syrian Armenians’ families. What stage is this offer at?

We visited the building and saw that it really needs to be renovated.
In order to implement the project, we photographed it and sent these
photos to benevolent organizations of Kuwait. This building belongs to
a Catholic church, and now we request them to provide us with
documents giving a complete idea of the building and the scope of
work. We are interested in implementation of this offer.

Does this building belong to a Catholic church? Why doesn’t the
Diaspora Ministry apply to Vatican?

I do not know, but this building belongs to a Catholic church, it is a
very good building, but needs to be renovated. The building is meant
for Syrian Armenians and orphans. The fact that this activity is of
charity nature is very important to us.

Does the Kuwait Investment Authority (KIA) work on the basis of
business mechanisms? What programs being implemented in other
countries may later be implemented in Armenia?

In this case, the country itself should present projects for
investments. Armenia needs hotels, as well as projects for development
of Lake Sevan. Jermuk also needs to be developed, but KIA investors
will not come to Armenia for the sake of $30 mln, their business and
interests start from at least $150 mln. Nobody will invest in small
and medium business. The Kuwait Investment Authority has its programs
in Europe. Your country itself should invite investors to make the
investments and develop the infrastructures.

What would you say about the Armenian-Kuwaiti business forum? Where
would it be reasonable to hold the forum?

We are working in this dimension. It is necessary to hold the forum
jointly with the Chamber of Commerce and Industry. This year is
already over and we hope that this plan will be carried out by mid
2013. However, first we hope for establishment of direct air
communication, as we will hardly persuade our businessmen to spend a
whole day on the trip. Armenia has a favorable investment potential,
it has a lot of opportunities and the most important thing is that it
is a very safe country. Here people are very amicable and nothing
threatens the tourists.

Have the Armenian tourists discovered Kuwait for themselves?

I do not know. There is an agreement, but I do not know whether it
works. I think there should be no obstacles in this matter.

Where can one receive a visa? At the Embassy of Kuwait or in the airport?

As the visa regime is not facilitated, it is possible to visit Kuwait
if there is an invitation letter. Armenia needs tourists more than
Kuwait does. If you remember, last year very few tourists visited
Armenia during Novruz. The hotels, restaurants and markets were
complaining of the few number of tourists.

But if there are direct air flights between our countries, I won’t
doubt the flow of tourists from Kuwait, who will visit Armenia 12
months a year, both in winter and in summer. The tourists will come to
Armenia and spend money, and the Armenian market will only benefit
from it. Now Kuwait has a new government, and new processes are
expected. We hope that new mutually beneficial agreements will be
signed in the course of the work of the Intergovernmental Commission.
Certainly, much depends on the political situation in our countries,
parliamentary elections in Kuwait and forthcoming presidential
elections in Armenia. I have been in Armenia for a year already, and a
lot of things have been done over that period. I hope that even more
various and useful projects will be implemented.

And, finally, I would like to wish a Happy New Year and a Merry
Christmas to Armenian people, especially given that Christmas is of
special importance to you. All the best to Armenian people!

http://www.arminfo.am/index.cfm?objectid=95E6FBB0-5043-11E2-AD81F6327207157C

Hrant Bagratyan not commenting on ANC’s decision not to back any pre

Hrant Bagratyan not commenting on ANC’s decision not to back any
presidential candidate

19:06 27/12/2012 » COMMENTS

Armenian National Congress (ANC) issued today a statement that it
`considers it senseless to participate in the elections that have
turned into a farce and to support any presidential candidate, which,
in the current situation, would only contribute to the legitimization
of the illegal regime.’

So, Armenian National Congress in fact refuses to back presidential
candidate Hrant Bagratyan, Liberty party leader, former member and
supporter of ANC.

Commenting on the reasons of this decision of ANC, Aram Manukyan,
board chairman of Armenian National Movement party, refused to give an
exact answer and only said, `I can say nothing beyond what has been
announced.’

Hrant Bagratyan, for his part, also refused to comment on the
statement of ANC when contacted by a Lragir.am reporter. `I did not
participate in the adoption of this statement. It is their business.’

Source: Panorama.am

HAK Declares Elections in Armenia a Farce; Says It Won’t Take Part i

HAK Declares Elections in Armenia a Farce; Says It Won’t Take Part in
Presidential Race

;-says-it-wont-take-part-in-presidential-race.html
16:45, December 27, 2012

The opposition Armenian National Congress (HAK) has released a
statement today arguing that it considers it senseless to participate
in the upcoming presidential election in Armenia and that it will not
back any other candidate in the race.

HAK states that during the past five years since the fraudulent 2008
presidential election, President Sargsyan has consistently destroyed
any chance of conducting democratic and competitive elections in
Armenia.

The statement says that despite all the lofty promises made to the
public in Armenia and internationally, the 2009 Yerevan mayoral and
2012 parliamentary elections were essentially falsified as well.

Given this reality, HAK declared that it wouldn’t be participating in
such a farce and would not support any other candidate since such a
move would only further legitimize the illegal regime now in power.

http://hetq.am/eng/news/21935/hak-declares-elections-in-armenia-a-farce

A Mere Bone of Contention Between Two Political Forces

Sport in Armenia: A Mere Bone of Contention Between Two Political Forces
Vahe Sarukhanyan

21:44, December 26, 2012

The Association of Sports Reporters in Armenia (ASRA) has just
published its list of the top athletes for 2012.

As expected, Greco-Roman wrestler Arsen Julfalakyan, who won an
Olympic silver medal in London, was named the top athlete of the year.

He was followed by Artur Aleksanyan, another Greco-Roman wrestler who
walked away with a bronze medal at the London Olympics. In third place
was Olympic bronze medallist in weightlifting Hripsimeh Khurshudyan.

There is no doubts that these three are worthy of being recognized as
the top three in Armenian sports. Their victories at the London games
are not an insignificant achievement for such a small nation as
Armenia.

Many fans and sports organizers were baffled, however, that no
football player made it to the top ten. Henrikh Mkhitaryan, clearly
the best player in Armenia today, wound up in 11th place. Footballer
Yura Movsisyan was picked for the 14th spot, Roman Berezovsky the 15th
spot, and Sargis Hovsepyan tied for the 17th spot with wrestler Yuri
Patrikevi.

Last year. Henrikh came in 4th and Yura in 7th. This year was the best
in Mkhitaryan’s football career, so why did he wind up at a lower spot
than 2011?

There are two possible reasons. First, Mkhitaryan is a footballer and
football is a team sport. Since Armenia’s national team didn’t display
such an explosive game as in 2011, the number of votes for individual
players decreased. Some pundits hold this view.

However, we cannot forget that our footballers are held in high esteem
and widely followed not only due to the successes of the national
team, but due to their personal high level of play. For example, the
same Mkhitaryan, is perhaps the most recognized and highly rated
player in Armenia today. First and foremost, this is due to his
successful appearances in team level play in Europe.

>From this perspective, footballers are regarded by sports fans firstly
as individuals and not members of a team. This, despite the fact that
in both cases, Mkhitaryan’s successes are clear – Ukraine champion,
cup winner, super cup winner, and chosen the best footballer in many
surveys.

It is here that the main reason for the `failures’ of footballers
becomes clear. This was the first time that the selection process of
the ASRA was conducted according to protocol. Accordingly, preference
is given, in descending order, to medal winners in the Olympics, World
Championships, European Championships, and then followed by other
international competitions. Bringing up the rear, are those engaged in
mass appeal sports.

It should be also noted that not all sports reporters participated in
the selection; it’s as if they boycotted the process. It is well known
that the ASRA survey has constantly been a point of contention on the
part of some pundits. Those who did take part followed the above
described protocol.

If this principle is adhered to, Armenia’s footballers can forget
about their chances to appear in the top three spots since athletes in
individual sports, say someone who wins a bronze at the European
Championships, will receive a higher ranking than those engaged in
mass appeal sports.

Naturally, this isn’t all that fair, and we must stress that certain
sports reporters, taking into account the veneration of football in
Armenia and overseas, ranked non-medal holder footballers higher than
any wrestler, weightlifter or other athlete possessing a World or
European championship medal.

This year, at least, Mkhitaryan should have won a spot in the top ten.
>From this perspective, one can perhaps understand Armenia’s Football
federation President Ruben Hayrapetyan who, in his own inimitable
style, put the organizers of sport in Armenia in their place.

In a press interview after the results of the ASRA survey were
published, Hayrapetyan said the ranking was yet another attempt to
discredit sports in Armenia and charged those responsible for
overseeing sports in Armenia as inept. He said they gave sports a bad
name.

What’s going on is pretty apparent. Hayrapetyan was most likely
referring to the Ministry of Sports and Armenia’s National Olympics
Committee; institutions closely linked to the Prosperous Armenia Party
led by Gagik Tsarukyan. Most in Armenia are aware of the long-standing
`bad blood’ between Republican Party stalwart Hayrapetyan and
Tsarukyan.

Even though Hayrapetyan failed to name names in his press statement,
he was probably referring to footballers and chess players. Levon
Aronyan, the strongest chess player around, came in 4th place in this
year’s ASRA survey. We shouldn’t forget that the Republican Party
members, led by President Sargsyan, oversee chess in Armenia.

Thus, the ASRA selection has served as an opportunity for the next
confrontation between Republican and Prosperous Armenia forces. Even
though Prosperous Armenia wasn’t the one conducting the survey, it got
the bulk of the blame, especially in social internet sites, for the
stumbling of footballers and chess players.

As we see, it wasn’t possible to avoid the politicization of sport in
Armenia yet again or to tarnish such a healthy and honest sector with
political mudslinging.

However, we must also recall the tasteless incidents that took place
this year at the London Olympics when Serzh Sargsyan’s advisor Yuri
Vardanyan rushed to offer an evaluation of the performance of
weightlifter Arakel Mirzoyan and the actions of Olympics Committee
president Gagik Tsarukyan. This was followed by an equally ugly
response by Mirzoyan. Then too, Republican Party MP Levon Martirosyan
described the performances of Armenian Olympians as appalling. He, in
turn, received a public response from those very same athletes.

It’s tragic but a fact. This situation continues today and will most
likely carry on in the New Year to come.

At the hands of the Republican and Prosperous Armenia parties, sport
in Armenia has been denigrated into a mere object of wheeling and
dealing for cheap political dividends.

http://hetq.am/eng/articles/21909/sport-in-armenia-a-mere-bone-of-contention-between-two-political-forces.html

BAKU: Elmar Mammadyarov: `Azerbaijan and Turkey are acting in coordi

Elmar Mammadyarov: `Azerbaijan and Turkey are acting in coordination
in pursing foreign policy’

[ 30 December 2012 14:13 ]

`TANAP will have a great importance in the future as a reliable source
in ensuring energy security of Europe’

Baku. Victoria Dementeva – APA. `Azerbaijan and Turkey are two
countries united by fraternal and historical ties. We are proud to say
that the relations between Azerbaijan and Turkey are at the highest
level,’ Azerbaijan’s Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov said in his
interview to a group of information agencies, APA reports.

The minister recalled that Azerbaijan and Turkey supported each other
at bilateral, regional and international levels and were acting in
coordination in pursing the foreign policy: `The High-Level Strategic
Cooperation Council was established between the two countries on
September 15, 2010 and one of the major tasks lying ahead is the
implementation of the matters arising from the declaration of this
Council. The high-level meetings of the Council have already been held
in Izmir and Gabala and we are working towards the diversification of
our cooperation. The agreement signed between Azerbaijan and Turkey on
the implementation of TANAP project shows the great potential in joint
activities of our countries.’

The minister mentioned that the two countries have already agreed on
the construction of the Trans-Anatolian natural gas pipeline project
(TANAP): `The gas agreement signed in Izmir last year envisages
constructing a new pipeline for transportation of Azerbaijani gas
through Turkey. SOCAR, BOTAS and Turkish Petroleum Corporation (TPAO)
have established joint Consortium on the basis of the memorandum on
the TANAP project. The other international oil-gas companies will
participate in the construction of the pipeline in the future. `TANAP
will have a great importance in the future as a reliable source in
ensuring energy security of Europe.’

Elmar Mammadyarov said that the cooperation between the two countries
is not restricted to the TANAP project: `Azerbaijan’s President Ilham
Aliyev and Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyib Erdogan laid the
foundation of the new oil refinery `Star’ of Petkim company in Izmir
last year. The joint investment in Petkim and TANAP project will be
about $15-20 billion. Azerbaijan is currently actively investing in
the Turkish economy.’

http://en.apa.az/news_elmar_mammadyarov_____azerbaijan_and_turke_185430.html

ISTANBUL: Turkey’s anti-deep state fight may set example

Turkey’s anti-deep state fight may set example

Retired Brig. Gen. Veli Küçük, a suspect in the trial against the
Ergenekon network, is depicted giving testimony during a hearing in
this drawing. (Court sketch: Salih Tekin)

30 December 2012 / BETÃ`L A. DEMİRBAÅ? / ALİ A. KILIÇ, ANKARA,

A fight that Turkish security forces and judicial bodies have been
engaged in for several years against clandestine networks nested in
various state bodies, an alliance that is often referred to as the
`deep state,’ may set an example for other countries which suffer from
similar networks, according to political analysts.
Turkey’s fight against the deep state has, on various occasions, been
praised by many, including domestic and foreign observers. They
believe a country like Turkey, which has been a place where hidden
powers inside the state staged events to mold public opinion according
to their own political agenda, is unlikely to democratize or normalize
unless it roots out the deep state.

They also think the experience Turkey has gained in its fight against
the deep state and criminal gangs is indeed a good example for other
countries that also host such a clandestine phenomenon, but whether
they too start an anti-deep state fight is dependent on certain
conditions.

`Turkey’s experience [in the fight against the deep state] may set an
example for other countries, but it depends on some conditions. For
example, events ahead of the constitutional referendum in Egypt
suggests that the deep state is stronger there [than in Turkey], and
an element of the deep state seeks opportunities to block the
country’s transition to full democracy. Those elements also attempt to
show any mistake [made in the administration of the country] as a
mistake of democracy and look for ways to return to the old days,’
Professor Vedat Bilgin of Gazi University told Sunday’s Zaman.

According to Bilgin, countries should meet certain conditions to
launch a fight against the deep state. Among those conditions is the
strengthening of civil society so that people will demand a stronger
democracy. `In addition, political parties should grow stronger, and
they should have a better perception of civilian opposition,’ he
stated, and added: `Our neighbors [countries] have a long road to go
[to launch an anti-deep state fight]. Turkey now has a great deal of
experience to set an example for them. They may benefit from Turkey’s
experience and use it as a roadmap in the long run.’

In Turkey, the term deep state became popular after a car accident in
1996 — widely known as the Susurluk incident — in which a member of
Parliament and a senior police official were traveling together with a
fugitive ultranationalist. The incident made clear that intelligence
units employed gangs to do their dirty work. Several people were taken
into custody in the investigation of the Susurluk gang — and in
dozens of similar cases — but most suspects have been released.

Associate Professor Yusuf Tekin, a political analyst and deputy
minister of youth and sports, also praised Turkey’s struggle against
the deep state, but believes that it could be strengthened. He said
the fight against the deep state initially aimed to root it out, but
in time, the fight changed course. `Our problem with the deep state is
whether to root it out or change its form. Turkey has not made a
radical decision on this issue. But there is a perception that they
[opponents of the deep state] preferred the state to change its form.
Anyway, it is praiseworthy that the fight has remained within the
boundaries of the law. With this point in mind, Turkey’s fight against
the deep state may set an example to other countries,’ he noted.

He also said the anti-deep state fight has stretched over time and
therefore is taking longer than expected, which could be a point of
criticism, and that the fight has yet to be concluded. `A more healthy
evaluation [over whether Turkey’s experience against the deep state
may set an example for other countries] may be possible after the
fight is concluded,’ he added.

In Turkey, the term deep state brings to mind Ergenekon, a criminal
network believed to be nested within the state bureaucracy. The group
is accused of being behind a number of political assassinations and
mass murders that rocked Turkey in the past and was believed to be
working to overthrow the government. Dozens of its suspected members
are on trial on coup charges.

Prosecutors investigating Ergenekon have found that the gang is linked
to the deep state that staged attacks in the past, using
`behind-the-scenes’ paramilitary organizations to stir up chaos to
urge governments to act in line with interests of the deep state or to
get rid of the governments.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip ErdoÄ?an said last week that it is not
possible to say that Turkey has managed to eradicate the deep state.
`Our fight against this [deep state] will continue. I would not
possibly claim that we have rooted out or eliminated the deep state.
There is a deep state in every country, and they cannot get rid of it
completely. The deep state is like a virus; it re-emerges when
favorable conditions come into existence,’ he said.

For Professor Mehmet Altan, who teaches in İstanbul University’s
department of political economy, Turkey had a good start in its fight
against the deep state, but it later slowed down due to the reluctance
of the government. `Had this not happened, Turkey could have rooted
out the deep state and become a very good example for other
countries,’ he said, adding, though, that Turkey is very late in
getting rid of the deep state because other countries managed this
shortly after the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Altan believes Turkey has a long path to go in order to successfully
conclude its fight against the deep state and criminal gangs. `The
political power [or the government] is not fighting the deep state
with due diligence. Such a fight without changing the legislation
enacted after the 1980 coup or making the legal amendments [to become
a more democratic country] will not yield any positive results. ¦ How
can you do civilian politics in a country where the Law on Political
Parties [a product of the coup] remains unchanged? And how can you end
military tutelage without abolishing the National Security Council
[MGK]?’ he asked and added that it is very unlikely Turkey will make
such amendments with its own dynamics and without a push from the EU.

http://www.todayszaman.com/news-302569-turkeys-anti-deep-state-fight-may-set-example.html