ISTANBUL: Kamel: France should face its own massacres first

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Dec 23 2011

Kamel: France should face its own massacres first

Algerian Deputy Parliament Speaker Bounah Kamel, calling the `yes’
vote on Armenian genocide in France hypocritical, said that France
should accept its own massacres in Algeria first.

Kamel, attending a conference organized with the assistance of the
Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) in İstanbul on Friday, on
the topic of `Change in Muslim Societies and the Role of Women’ said,
`Algeria’s population was eight million in 1830 before the French
occupation started. When France left the country in 1962, the
population was six million, as if Algerian people never gave birth in
a century.’

Abdelaziz Bouteflika, the Algerian president since 1999, demanded an
apology from the Sarkozy government in 2006 for France’s bloody
activities in Algeria. Kamel stated, however, that France negatively
responded to Algerian calls.

`The Algerian people always fought against the French colonial system
in their country, which violently exploited their natural, economic
and human resources. The French military response was violent against
the Algerian struggle, killing people or expelling them out of their
own territory. Once, in May 1945, the French army killed more than
45,000 Algerians in two or three days,’ he stated, further emphasizing
French brutality.

`Apart from turning down Algerian calls to face the bloodshed in
Algeria, France issued a bill in 2003 honoring the French occupation
of Algeria, which rewarded killers of Algerian people, especially
French commanders,’ Kamel added.

`They condemn the Turkish activities allegedly organized against
Armenians but don’t discuss their own bloody activities,’ he stated,
claiming that the French initiatives on the Armenian issue are
hypocritical. Another attendee at the conference, Zahra Nouojahida, a
living witness to the Algerian war of independence that lasted from
1954 to 1962, mentioned humiliating crimes committed against woman
during this war, including `rapes of young women in front of their
fathers.’ Nouojahida, sadly remembering these French activities during
the war years, noted that `France should correct its own mistakes
before giving advice to other nations,’ in a criticism of the Armenian
genocide bill voted upon in France on Thursday.

Mayor is chief kazak in Gyumri

Mayor is chief kazak in Gyumri

06:50 pm | December 24, 2011 | Social

Among those attending today’s assembly held by the “International
Union for the Armenian-Kazak Friendship and Cooperation” were
representative of the RA Ministry of Defense Felix Grigoryan, Deputy
Mayor of Gyumri Rudik Hovhannisyan, guests from the Land Defenders’
Union and the governors of the provinces where the organization is
represented.

Chief ataman of the Shirak province Ashot Simonyan is certain that the
St. Artemis Orthodox Church, spiritual and cultural centers, the
international Kazak Cadet Corpus will soon be built on the 8 ha land
provided by Mayor of Gyumri, chief ataman Vardan Ghukasyan and that
they will serve for the Armenian-Kazak friendship.
The “International Union for the Armenian-Kazak Friendship and
Cooperation” was founded in Gyumri on January 10, 2006.

“Our organization currently has 1,200-1,300 members from the entire
province. We have mainly accepted men who have fought and have served
in the army, and there are only 10 percent Kazak descendants. Our goal
is to protect the nation and defend the borders. We educate our
organization’s members with the spirit of patriotism. Twenty of our
men are currently defending the Armenian-Georgian border,” Ashot
Simonyan told “A1+”.

The Russian Federation will be sponsoring the restoration of the
Orthodox Church and the centers in Gyumri.

http://www.a1plus.am/en/social/2011/12/24/kazak

ISESCO denounces French National Assembly’s bill regarding Turkey

Saudi Press Agency (SPA)
December 23, 2011 Friday

ISESCO denounces French National Assembly’s bill regarding Turkey

Rabat, Muharram 28, 1433, Dec 23, 2011, SPA — The Islamic
Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (ISESCO) denounced
the bill passed by France’s National Assembly which would criminalize
any public denial of what the bill calls “the Armenian genocide at the
time of the Ottomans”.

In a communiqué released today, ISESCO called for upholding freedom of
expression and of academic research and not imposing restraints on
intellectuals and researchers via such unjust laws as this one which
is incompatible with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

ISESCO expressed its support to the Republic of Turkey against this
selective and racist position and its attending repercussions.

ISESCO also called on OIC Member States to condemn this decision and
stand by the Republic of Turkey, in support of the principles of
Islamic solidarity.

French Law Criminalising Genocide Denial Prompts Turkish Retaliation

Global Insight
December 23, 2011

French Law Criminalising Genocide Denial Prompts Turkish Retaliation

BY: James Goundry

French legislators in the lower house of parliament passed a law
yesterday (22 December) criminalising the denial of genocide. The vote
prompted an angry backlash from Turkey and increases the risk of
significantly damaged relations between the two countries.

IHS Global Insight Perspective

Significance- French members of the National Assembly, the lower house
of parliament, passed a bill yesterday (22 December) criminalising the
denial of genocides recognised by the state. France recognises the
Nazi genocide during the Second World War and the Armenian genocide of
1915-17.

Implications- The vote prompted an angry response from Turkey, which
denies the genocide claim. Turkey recalled its ambassador from Paris,
suspended military co-operation, and withdrew from a Franco-Turkish
economic committee meeting scheduled for January 2012.

Outlook- The dispute brings relations between Turkey and France to a
new low. Although the vote could improve support for the French
government among the Armenian diaspora in France, it threatens to have
significant negative political and economic consequences for relations
with an important emerging market and diplomatic power in the Middle
East.

Turkish prime minister Recep Tayyip Erdo an, seen here ona visit to
Tripoli, does not accept that genocide occurred

French legislators in the National Assembly, the French lower house of
parliament, yesterday (22 December) passed a bill criminalising the
denial of genocides formally recognised by the French state. France
recognises only two genocides, the holocaust of the Second World War
and the Armenian genocide of 1915-17. Given that separate legislation
introduced in 1990 already criminalised denial of the former, this
latest vote effectively targets the Armenian issue. The law was
proposed by members of the ruling centre-right Union for a Popular
Movement (UMP), but received support from across the political
spectrum and was passed with ease. The bill will now be debated and
voted on in the French upper house, the Senate, before returning to
the lower house for final adoption. Given that parliament will be
dissolved in February 2012 ahead of presidential and legislative
elections in April, May, and June, and given lingering question-marks
over the bill’s constitutionality, it is far from a certainty that it
will become law.

The proposal to criminalise denial of the Armenian genocide does not
come out of the blue. France initially recognised the deaths of over 1
million Armenians in the dying days of the Ottoman Empire as genocide
in 2001. Bills seeking to criminalise denial of the genocide were
introduced in 2006 and in May 2011, but both were defeated in the then
UMP-dominated Senate.

The Turkish government reacted angrily to the vote. The Turkish
ambassador to France was called back to Ankara, and Turkish prime
minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan suspended political visits and military
co-operation between the two NATO member states. Crowds of ethnic
Turkish protestors gathered outside the French National Assembly for
the vote, and crowds in Ankara were reported to have gathered and
expressed anti-French feelings. Erdogan decried the move as “politics
based on racism, discrimination and xenophobia” and warned of
“irreparable damage” to relations between the two nations. Late
yesterday (22 December), Turkish economy minister Zafer Caglayan
announced that Turkey would withdraw from an economy and trade
committee meeting with France planned for early 2012.

Political Opportunism

The Turkish government, and domestic French political opposition, has
criticised the timing of the bill as a cynical piece of political
opportunism ahead of presidential and legislative elections scheduled
for April, May, and June 2012. France is home to a significant
Armenian minority numbering almost 500,000, and the UMP, and the MPs
proposing the bill, are likely to be aware of the boost such a law
would provide to their poll numbers. Given this, the timing may also
be an attempt by the UMP to steal a march on its Socialist Party (PS)
rivals. PS presidential candidate Francois Hollande suggested at the
end of September that the proposed law might make a reappearance
following a historic victory for the left in Senate elections. Shortly
after this announcement, President Nicolas Sarkozy indicated that he
would consider supporting such a bill in a meeting with the Armenian
president in Yerevan if Turkey did not recognise the events as
genocide. Nonetheless, wider public opinion across France appears to
be more sceptical of the bill, with polls by major newspapers on both
the centre-right and centre-left suggesting majorities against
criminalising genocide denial.

The French vote is a setback for the Turkish government, which had
hoped to contain the issue by launching internationally mediated
normalisation talks with Armenia from 2000 to 2010. Neither party,
however, ratified the protocols that would have seen Turkey lifting a
blockade on its eastern neighbour. At the same time, Turkey hoped that
the contentious issues would be confined to its relations with
Armenia. The strong Turkish reaction was predictable, given the
similar response to recognition of the Armenian genocide by at least
19 other countries, including Canada, Belgium, Italy, the Netherlands,
Russia, and Sweden, as well as the European Parliament.

Outlook and Implications

The vote marks a new low for Franco-Turkish relations, already
strained by vocal French objections to Turkish accession to the EU.
However, although undoubtedly damaging for diplomatic relations in the
short term, the longer-term political and economic consequences may
well be less severe. Each French move towards criminalising genocide
denial since 2001 has been met with strong Turkish objections,
including the recall of the Turkish ambassador in 2001 and foreboding
comments of the damage such moves would cause to bilateral relations.
Nonetheless, Franco-Turkish trade has continued to increase, with
trade between the two estimated to be worth EUR12 billion (USD15.6
billion) a year. The two countries have also co-operated on a number
of international diplomatic issues from Afghanistan to Syria and the
Mediterranean. Moreover, the EU and Turkey established a customs union
in 1995, which provides for free trade between them in industrial and
processed agricultural products, and both countries are members of the
WTO. These factors will limit Turkey’s scope for economic retaliation,
although French companies may suffer in public procurement tenders.
The current Turkish government may also up the populist rhetoric in an
attempt to placate growing concerns over the curbing of individual
freedoms within Turkey.

EU official hails Armenia’s preparation for talks on free trade area

Mediamax, Armenia
Dec 23 2011

EU official hails Armenia’s preparation for talks on free trade area

Yerevan, 23 December: EU Chief Negotiator Gunnar Wiegand said in his
exclusive interview to Mediamax that “Armenia has indeed made very
good progress in the preparations for negotiations of a Deep and
Comprehensive Free Trade Area (DCFTA) with the EU on the basis of the
key recommendations made by European Commission”.

“Many of the requirements needed for the start of the negotiations
have already been addressed,” said Gunnar Wiegand.

According to him, despite this very positive overall picture, some
specific further progress still remains to be achieved, notably in the
areas of Technical Barriers to Trade and the protection of
Intellectual Property Right, where the national legislative framework
should be reformed in line with the EU law.

“According to the Decree of Armenian Prime Minister of 10 August these
remaining requirements would be met by the end of this year. In the
light of this commitment, I look forward to confirmation from our
experts whether the last requirements have indeed been met,” said
Gunnar Wiegand in an exclusive interview to Mediamax.

“Let me also take the opportunity to underline that the launch of
negotiations is only one step on the road to concluding DCFTA. For the
full benefits of new trade opportunities to be exploited, Armenia
should fully implement the reforms,” concluded Gunnar Wiegand.

On 16 December, answering Mediamax’s question Armenian Minister of
Economy Tigran Davtyan expressed the hope that the negotiations on
establishing a Free Trade Area with the EU will start in the first
half of 2012. “We have realized large-scale work and I think if we
keep working like this we may finish the negotiations, which mainly
last 5 years, within 2-3 years,” stated Tigran Davtyan.

Erdogan denounces "genocide" committed by France in Algeria

Algeria Press Service
December 23, 2011 Friday

Erdogan denounces “genocide” committed by France in Algeria

ALGIERS – The tone upped between Ankara and Paris, following the
adoption by the French National Assembly of a law criminalizing the
negation of the “Armenian genocide,” Turkish Prime Minister Recep
Tayyip Erdogan accused France of committing “genocide” in Algeria
while Paris said it “regrets” retaliatory decisions taken by Turkey.

AP:Anti-Putin protests Saturday draw tens of thousands

Anti-Putin protests Saturday draw tens of thousands
By LYNN BERRY and VLADIMIR ISACHENKOV
Associated Press
December 24, 2011 2:26PM

Armenian President Serge Sarkisian, left, and Iranian President
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad review honor guards during a welcome ceremony at
the Presidential Residence in Yerevan, Armenian capital on Friday,
Dec. 23, 2011. (AP Photo/ Hayk Badalyan, Photolure)

View Gallery MOSCOW – Tens of thousands of Russians jammed a Moscow
avenue Saturday to demand free elections and an end to Prime Minister
Vladimir Putin’s 12-year rule, in the largest show of public outrage
since the protests 20 years ago that brought down the Soviet Union.
Gone was the political apathy of recent years as many shouted `We are
the Power!’

The demonstration, bigger and better organized than a similar one two
weeks ago, and smaller rallies across the country encouraged
opposition leaders hoping to sustain a broad protest movement ignited
by a fraud-tainted parliamentary election on Dec. 4.

The enthusiasm also cheered Mikhail Gorbachev, the last Soviet leader
who closed down the Soviet Union on Dec. 25, 1991.

`I’m happy that I have lived to see the people waking up. This raises
big hopes,’ the 80-year-old Gorbachev said on Ekho Moskvy radio.

He urged Putin to follow his example and give up power peacefully. If
Putin stepped down now, he would be remembered for the positive things
he did, Gorbachev said. The former Soviet leader, who has grown
increasingly critical of Putin, has little influence in Russia today.

But the protesters have no central leader and no candidate capable of
posing a serious challenge to Putin, who intends to return to the
presidency in a March vote. In a fair election, the veteran Communist
Party leader would pose the strongest threat, and he has joined the
Kremlin in disparaging the protests.

Even at Saturday’s rally, some of the speakers were jeered by the
crowd. The various liberal, nationalist and leftist groups that took
part appear united only by their desire to see `Russia without Putin,’
a popular chant.

Putin, who gave no public response to the protest Saturday, initially
derided the demonstrators as paid agents of the West. He also said
sarcastically that he thought the white ribbons they wore as an emblem
were condoms. Putin has since come to take their protests more
seriously, and in an effort to stem the anger he has offered a set of
reforms to allow more political competition in future elections.

Kremlin-controlled television covered Saturday’s rally, but gave no
air time to Putin’s harshest critics.

Estimates of the number of demonstrators ranged from the police figure
of 30,000 to 120,000 offered by the organizers. Demonstrators packed
much of a broad avenue, which has room for nearly 100,000 people,
about 2.5 kilometers (some 1.5 miles) from the Kremlin, as the
temperature dipped well below freezing.

A stage at the end of the avenue featured banners reading `Russia will
be free’ and `This election Is a farce.’ Heavy police cordons
encircled the participants, who stood within metal barriers, and a
police helicopter hovered overhead.

Alexei Navalny, a corruption-fighting lawyer and popular blogger,
electrified the crowd when he took the stage. He soon had the
protesters chanting `We are the power!’

Navalny spent 15 days in jail for leading a protest on Dec. 5 that
unexpectedly drew more than 5,000 people and set off the chain of
demonstrations.

Putin’s United Russia party lost 25 percent of its seats in the
election, but hung onto a majority in parliament through what
independent observers said was widespread fraud. United Russia, seen
as representing a corrupt bureaucracy, has become known as the party
of crooks and thieves, a phrase coined by Navalny.

`We have enough people here to take the Kremlin,’ Navalny shouted to
the crowd. `But we are peaceful people and we won’t do that – yet. But
if these crooks and thieves keep cheating us, we will take what is
ours.’

Protest leaders expressed skepticism about Putin’s promised political reforms.

`We don’t trust him,’ opposition leader Boris Nemtsov told the rally,
urging protesters to gather again after the long New Year’s holidays
to make sure the proposed changes are put into law.

He and other speakers called on the demonstrators to go to the polls
in March to unseat Putin. `A thief must not sit in the Kremlin,’
Nemtsov said.

The protest leaders said they would keep up their push for a rerun of
the parliamentary vote and punishment for election officials accused
of fraud, while stressing the need to prevent fraud in the March
presidential election.

Former world chess champion Garry Kasparov was among those who sought
to give the protesters a sense of empowerment.

`There are so many of us here, and they (the government) are few,’
Kasparov said from the stage. `They are huddled up in fear behind
police cordons.’

The crowd was largely young, but included a sizable number of
middle-aged and elderly people, some of whom limped slowly to the site
on walkers and canes.

`We want to back those who are fighting for our rights,’ said
16-year-old Darya Andryukhina, who said she had also attended the
previous rally.

`People have come here because they want respect,’ said Tamara
Voronina, 54, who said she was proud that her three sons also had
joined the protest.

Putin’s comment about protesters wearing condoms only further
infuriated them and inspired some creative responses. One protester
Saturday held a picture montage of Putin with his head wrapped in a
condom like a grandmother’s headscarf. Many inflated condoms along
with balloons.

The protests reflect a growing weariness with Putin, who was first
elected president in 2000 and remained in charge after moving into the
prime minister’s seat in 2008. Brazen fraud in the parliamentary vote
unexpectedly energized the middle class, which for years had been
politically apathetic.

`No one has done more to bring so many people here than Putin, who
managed to insult the whole country,’ said Viktor Shenderovich, a
columnist and satirical writer.

Two rallies in St. Petersburg on Saturday drew a total of 4,000 people.

`I’m here because I’m tired of the government’s lies,’ said Dmitry
Dervenev, 47, a designer. `The prime minister insulted me personally
when he said that people came to the rallies because they were paid by
the U.S. State Department. I’m here because I’m a citizen of my
country.’

Putin accused the United States of encouraging and funding the
protests to weaken Russia.

Putin’s former finance minister surprised the protesters by saying the
current parliament should approve the proposed electoral changes and
then step down to allow new parliamentary elections to be held. Alexei
Kudrin, who remains close to Putin, warned that the wave of protests
could lead to violence and called for establishing a dialogue between
the opposition and the government.

`Otherwise we will lose the chance for peaceful transformation,’ Kudrin said.

Kudrin also joined calls for the ouster of Central Election Commission
chief Vladimir Churov.

Putin has promised to liberalize registration rules for opposition
parties and restore the direct election of governors he abolished in
2004. Putin’s stand-in as president, Dmitry Medvedev, spelled out
those and other proposed changes in Thursday’s state-of-the nation
address.

Gorbachev, however, said the government appears confused.

`They don’t know what to do,’ he said. `They are making attempts to
get out of the trap they drove themselves into.’

Copyright 2011 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material
may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Paris And Ankara Locked In Armenian Genocide Dispute

PARIS AND ANKARA LOCKED IN ARMENIAN GENOCIDE DISPUTE
Igor Siletsky

The Voice of Russia

Dec 23 2011

A large number of historians and 18 nations including Russia, Canada,
Argentina, Venezuela, Chile and powers in the EU agree with Armenia
that the Ottoman Empire slaughtered 1.5 million of its ethnic Armenians
in 1915, leaving Turkey with hardly any Armenians left at all. They
also agree that the slaughter amounted to genocide. Turkey disputes
both the death toll and the nature of the 1915 events. It argues the
killings were part of WWI, in which Turks also died, and had nothing
to do with genocide.

In the latest turn of the dispute, Turkey has recalled its Ambassador
from France after the Lower House of the French Parliament passed
a bill to make it a criminal offence to deny that the mass killing
of Armenians in the Ottoman Empire almost 100 years ago amounted to
genocide. Speaking in Istanbul Friday Turkish Prime Minister Recep
Tayyip Erdogan also accused France of unleashing genocide during the
independence war in Algeria, where French forces are believed to have
killed 15 percent of the country’s population.

If the French bill is passed by the Senate, France will have as many
as two genocide denial bans – one applying to the Nazi Holocaust
of the European Jews, and the other to the Ottoman slaughter of
the Armenians. Offenders will face at least a year in jail or a
45-thousand-euro fine. By pushing through the latter ban, Sarkozy
is delivering on his 2007 campaign pledges to France’s influential
Armenian community.

Dr Boris Dolgov of the Institute of Oriental Studies of the Russian
Academy of Sciences also sees a link to France’s next presidential
elections:

“The French government argues that Turkey cannot be allowed to join the
European Union as long as it refuses to recognize its responsibility
for the 1915 genocide. In fact, however, Sarkozy’s party is seeking
to boost his support base in the next presidential elections in 2012
by an estimated half a million Armenian votes in France.”

Nor is Turkey prepared to climb down. We have an opinion from Dr
Alexander Sotnichenko of the Moscow-based Institute of the Middle East:

“Turkey is highly unlikely to admit that is has something like
the Holocaust on its national conscience. Indeed, admitting its
responsibility for the slaughter would revive Armenia’s claims to the
parts of Turkish territory that became Turkey under the 1921 peace
treaties signed in Moscow and Kars. It would also lead to massive
compensation claims.”

Turkey’s current row is with France. The two previous ones were with
Sweden and the United States. In its row with Sweden, Turkey recalled
but subsequently returned its Ambassador to Stockholm. In its spat
with the US, it recalled but subsequently returned its Ambassador
to Washington. The recall followed a committee resolution in the US
Congress to regard the 1915 slaughter as an instance of genocide. The
return followed a speech by Barack Obama on Slaughtered Armenians
Memory Day on April 24th in which he carefully avoided using the word
‘genocide’. Observers believe the current row between Turkey and
France will eventually follow a similar scenario.

http://english.ruvr.ru/2011/12/23/62785574.html

Sarkozy Hits Back Over Turkish Claims Of French Genocide

SARKOZY HITS BACK OVER TURKISH CLAIMS OF FRENCH GENOCIDE

EuroNews

Dec 23 2011
France

A war of words is heating up between Paris and Ankara.

The Turkish prime minister has accused France of genocide in Algeria.

This a day after France’s lower house approved a draft law that will
make it a crime to deny that the massacre of Armenians by Ottoman
Turks was genocide.

Recep Tayyip Erdogan said: “This is a clear example of how racism,
discrimination and anti-Muslim sentiment have reached new dangerous
levels in France and in Europe. French President Sarkozy’s ambition
is to win an election based on promoting animosity against Turks
and Muslims.

“Around 15 percent of the population in Algeria was massacred by the
French, starting in 1945,” he said. “That was a genocide. The Algerians
were burned en masse in ovens. They were mercilessly martyred.”

Erdogan added: “If French President Sarkozy isn’t aware of this
genocide, he should go and ask his father, Paul Sarkozy. His father
served in the French Legion in Algeria in the 1940s. I am sure he
would have lots to tell his son about the French massacres in Algeria.”

Turkey has recalled its ambassador and cancelled bilateral political,
economic and military activities.

The French President has hit back at the latest comments from Ankara.

“Every country must make an effort to reexamine its past,” said Nicolas
Sarkozy. “France gives lessons to no one, but it doesn’t expect to
receive them. I respect the conviction of our Turkish friends, it’s
a great country, a great civilisation, but they should respect us.”

Paris also denies claims by Ankara that the bill, still to be approved
by the French Senate, is aimed at winning votes among France’s Armenian
community for President Sarkozy in elections next year.

http://www.euronews.net/2011/12/23/sarkozy-hits-back-over-turkish-claims-of-french-genocide/

Turks Protest At French Genocide Bill

TURKS PROTEST AT FRENCH GENOCIDE BILL

NowLebanon.com
Dec 23 2011

Around 100 people gathered in front of the French consulate in
Istanbul on Friday, protesting at a bill criminalizing the denial of
the Armenian genocide in 1915 in Ottoman Turkey.

“Down with France” and “Allahu Akbar” chanted the group, comprising
supporters of the small, Islamist, Felicity Party (SP). The protestors
carried banners reading “genocide is a lie,” and “France, drop
defamation and face your own history.”

The group also left red carnations on the stairs of the consulate
building. “Do not sleep Sarkozy, the Ottomans are here,” they chanted
in a message to French President Nicolas Sarkozy.

The demonstrators were protesting at Thursday’s vote in the French
lower house approving a bill imposing a jail term and a 45,000 euro
fine on anyone in France who denies that mass killings of Armenians
during World War I at the hands of Ottoman forces were genocide.