There Is No Arms Race In The Caucasus – Expert

THERE IS NO ARMS RACE IN THE CAUCASUS – EXPERT

Vestnik Kavkaza
Nov 25 2011
Russia

One cannot talk about an arms race in the Caucasus, Azerbaijani
political analyst Fikret Sadykhov believes.

Azerbaijan is indeed trying to improve its defense system, but that
doesn’t mean that it’s the beginning of a new arms race. It’s quite
natural for a country that hasn’t managed to establish peace treaty
with its neighbour for twenty years to be ready to defend its land,
Sadykhov says.

Claims that Azerbaijan is turning into a militaristic state are
baseless, the expert underlines. 20 per cent of the country’s territory
is occupied, so of course it has to have a proper army, he adds.

Sadykhov wonders why the world’s superpowers don’t force Armenia to
leave the territory of Karabakh, if they are interested in peace and
stability in the region.

Elmira Tariverdiyeva, Baku

Authorities Are Preparing For Election Fraud

AUTHORITIES ARE PREPARING FOR ELECTION FRAUD

November 25, 2011

Armenian authorities are not preparing for recurrent elections, they
are preparing for election fraud, Yerevan’s ex-mayor, economist Vahagn
Khachatryan announced during the rally of Armenian National Congress
(ANC) opposition alliance in Yerevan.

“Otherwise, the authorities would have brought oligarchs to the tax
field,” he said reminding the authorities of their economic promises.

“The authorities said that state revenues would amount to 19 percent,
while only 17 percent is predicted for 2012.”

Then he referred to the 2012 draft budget, saying it cannot provide
economic growth.

Only the change of power and conduct of fair elections can change
the situation,” said Vahagn Khachatryan.

http://www.a1plus.am/en/politics/2011/11/25/vahagn-khachatryan

Archbishop Pargev Martirossian: The Face Of Karabagh

ARCHBISHOP PARGEV MARTIROSSIAN: THE FACE OF KARABAGH
By Alin Gregorian

Mirror-Spectator Staff
Posted on November 25

The Atinizian and Mardiros families had dinner with Archbishop Pargev
Martirossian during his visit.

BOSTON – Stepanakert, the home of Archbishop Pargev Martirossian,
the Primate of the Karabagh Diocese, is a world away from the US,
but for this ambassador of this tiny republic and man of God, no
distance is too great to spread the word about Karabagh.

Martirossian is Karabagh’s first archbishop since the 1930s. The
late Catholicos of All Armenians Vazken I appointed him in 1989 to
the post. “Moscow allowed it,” he said, much to the chagrin of Azeri
authorities. Martirossian, who was given the name Gurgen at birth, was
born in Sumgait, Azerbaijan, to a family from the northern Karabagh
town of Chardakhly. He entered the Gevorkian Seminary in Echmiadzin
in 1980. He was ordained in 1983 and graduated in 1984. In 1985 he
was ordained a celibate priest and given the name Pargev. He was made
a bishop by Vazken I in 1988 and was named an archbishop by the late
Catholicos of All Armenians Karekin I in 1999.

Martirossian stopped for an interview during his short visit to Boston,
part of his tour of the US in support of the Armenia Fund Telethon,
scheduled to take place on Thanksgiving Day.

During his visit, Martirossian attended the Knights of Vartan’s annual
program, dedicated this year to raise funds for Armenia Fund USA and
the World Bank program in Armenia. He visited the Armenian Library
and Museum of America, where he spoke at length with curator Gary
Lind-Sinanian and toured the new exhibit of photographs by Yousuf
Karsh.

He also met with Ruth Thomasian, founder and executive director of
Project SAVE. He visited the site of the Armenian Heritage Park in
Boston and performed the Divine Liturgy at Holy Trinity Armenian
Church in Cambridge. Kevork and Jacqueline Atinizian then hosted him
at a private dinner.

The prelate had nothing but praise for Armenia Fund USA and all the
other chapters of Armenia Fund, suggesting that several layers of
controls ensured that the funds went where they were intended.

This year’s theme for Armenia Fund USA is water. Martirossian said,
“It is enormous work. First there was the Road of Life, linking Goris
[Armenia] and Stepanakert, then the North-South Highway, which is
the backbone of Karabagh and then many schools and hospitals.”

“These heroes who have won and kept our borders, if we don’t give
them clean water, shame on us,” he added with emphasis.

Water, he said, affects every part of life, clearly, and its absence
hinders the republic’s programs to boost its population. He recalled
that Prime Minister Araik Haroutunian visited a village recently and
spoke with a farmer who had three sons and asked the patriarch if
any of the sons were married and if not, why. The archbishop said,
the farmer had replied, “We work with animals and can bathe only
once a week. How can we bring a young girl here to live under these
circumstances?”

The current population of Karabagh is 150,000, Martirossian said,
but noted that it should have been 300,000 by this time. Everything,
including a larger population, requires money, he said.

“To bring people in Karabagh, we need to spend $70,000 per person,”
he said. That money, he said, is the cost of building infrastructure
and creating a high living standard, including roads, light, gas,
water, schools, clubs and sports arenas.

“We need help from the diaspora,” Martirossian said.

Martirossian said that the one thing that hinders growth in Karabagh
is that the country is not recognized internationally, and thus is
not qualified for many loans and other assistance programs. Their
only source of help, thus, is Armenia.

Martirossian said that the Azeri government “talks with ultimatums”
but that it needs to “recognize that Karabagh can never stay under
Azeri rule.” He added that the republic needs a tacit agreement from
the Azeri government guaranteeing its safety, but that agreement,
he said, is not forthcoming.

He noted, however, “sooner or later, the Karabagh Question will be
solved.” After all, he said, Kosovo, Abkhazia and Eritrea have all
set precedents.

“We are very grateful to the OSCE [Organization for Security and
Cooperation in Europe] who are moderating and organizing meetings,”
he noted.

Martirossian was happy about the change in the fortunes of Shushi,
which had been in ruins after the war for liberation. The city,
he said, has two new hotels and life is improving there, though he
cautioned that improvements were still needed.

Martirossian was most proud that 75 percent of the republic has
access to gas and electricity and that the Internet and cell phones
have become readily available.

“Of course, life is easier, but it still is not enough. People want
everything quickly,” he said, adding, “Paris, Moscow or New York,
none of them became what they are overnight.”

He said that Karabagh is looking into attracting more tourists with
its majestic mountains and monasteries. The region’s old Christian
past should also attract religious tourists, he noted.

When asked how he was able to cope with all that he has to with
all the difficulties that the republic has faced, Martirossian got
philosophical: “It’s like a father in a house with his children. The
children need to be taken care of no matter what. It is my job. They
are my 150,000 children. I am accountable to God. You need to take
care of them. That the duty of every cleric.”

Issues Of NK And Armenian Genocide Recognition Unite Political Force

ISSUES OF NK AND ARMENIAN GENOCIDE RECOGNITION UNITE POLITICAL FORCES OF ARMENIA

ARMENPRESS
NOVEMBER 25, 2011
YEREVAN

Ruling political parties of Armenia have a number of commonalities in
their way of thinking and ideas over the foreign policy. This viewpoint
was in the core of the discussion over the topic of “The Foreign
Political Agenda of the Parties”, summoned November 25 in Yerevan.

Member of NA RPA faction Artak Zakaryan noted the foreign policy of
Armenia is aimed at preservation of balance and peaceful coexistence,
as well as at involving foreign political, economic and social
resources for solution of home issues, and reinforced organization
of the issues of own foreign security provision.

In foreign policy the parliamentarian attached importance to peaceful
regulation process of Artsakh conflict, and to the prospects of
regional development. He also singled out the peaceful settlement
process of Armenian-Turkish relations and the deepening of the
European integration.

In response to the question which one should be a prospective
direction for Armenia – the North or the East, the parliamentarian
said that Armenia has not assumed a uni-vector policy, and has never
contradicted the political vectors in foreign policy, as international
politics is very complicated and multi-vectoral. Armenia has also
registered a number of successes: we have managed to maintain the
peace, the format of Minsk Group activity, the thing that NKR and RA
are perceived as parties in the negotiation process.

ANC representative Vladimir Karapeyan expressed an opinion that one of
the keystones of our country’s foreign policy is the Armenian-Turkish
relations and NK conflict settlement issue.

ARF member Kiro Manoyan also attached importance to Javakhkh issue. In
Armenian-Turkish relations the position of ARF essentially differs
from the viewpoint of other political forces.

As a result of the discussion, it became clear that the parties
expressing different viewpoints have two common troublesome issues –
NK conflict and Armenian Genocide recognition issue.

Arkady Ter-Tadevosyan: True Heroism And Modesty Are Inseparable

ARKADY TER-TADEVOSYAN: TRUE HEROISM AND MODESTY ARE INSEPARABLE
Alisa Gevorgyan

“Radiolur”
25.11.2011 18:16

True heroism and modesty are inseparable, Major General Arkady
Ter-Tadevosyan said at an open lesson at the Yerevan State Economic
University.

The Comandos modestly said the liberation of Shushi was not his merit,
adding that the people and the soldiers were the true heroes of the
liberation war. It was their trust that made Commander Ter-Tadevosyan
believe that liberation of Shushi was possible.

“I have applied only my military skills in the liberation of Shushi,”
he said.

Arkady Ter-Tadevosyan had understood from the stories told by his
grandparents that the migrant was the one who had been deprived of
his land and disrooted. Later he came to understand the vale of that
land and the Motheland. He came to understand that he could not and
did not want to yield at least an inch of his native land.

Poster Honoring National Hero Monte Melkonyan Installed In Artsakh

POSTER HONORING NATIONAL HERO MONTE MELKONYAN INSTALLED IN ARTSAKH

PanARMENIAN.Net
November 25, 2011 – 15:24 AMT

PanARMENIAN.Net – Media Group Fedayi with the assistance of Artsakh
(Nagorno Karabakh Republic) authorities has inaugurated a poster to
honor the national hero of Armenia and Artsakh, legendary commander,
philosopher and warrior, activist of national-liberation struggle of
the Armenian people – Monte Melkonyan, whose 54th birth anniversary
is marked on November 25.

The was installed in Kashatagh administrative region of NKR, near
Berdzor town, on Goris-Stepanakert highway.

NKR Must Initiate International Recognition Campaign – Manoyan

NKR MUST INITIATE INTERNATIONAL RECOGNITION CAMPAIGN – MANOYAN

PanARMENIAN.Net
November 25, 2011 – 16:02 AMT

PanARMENIAN.Net – Nagorno Karabakh Republic must initiate international
recognition campaign parallel to ongoing settlement talks, according
to ARF Dashnaktsutyun Hay Dat and Political Affairs Office Director.

As Kiro Manoyan stated during a foreign policy forum, Armenia should
have recognized Karabakh independence in 1991-1992, while, now, in
view of ongoing settlement negotiations the move would be unreasonable.

Commenting on current stage of negotiations, he noted, ~Smediators long
ago understood that the future of Artsakh is beyond the Azeri control,
with the focus shifted on the search of a settlement formula to save
Azerbaijan~Rs face. ~SThough peaceful settlement progress may benefit
from Baku consent, it may well do without the latter,~T the expert
noted citing Kosovo experience as an example.

The forum was organized by the Armenian Center of Political and
International Studies with the assistance of U.S. National Democratic
Institute.

Heritage: Armenia Must Follow European Integration Course

HERITAGE: ARMENIA MUST FOLLOW EUROPEAN INTEGRATION COURSE

PanARMENIAN.Net
November 25, 2011 – 17:10 AMT

PanARMENIAN.Net – Heritage opposition party stands against Armenia’s
joining the Eurasian Union, seeing the country’s future in cooperation
with Europe, Heritage parliamentary group leader said.

As Stepan Safaryan stressed during foreign policy forum, “Yerevan
must adhere to the course of European integration with the country’s
Eurasian Union bid rendering Armenia-EU Association Agreement
impossible.”

As Safaryan noted, Heritage spoke against extension of Russian
military base deployment in Armenia to promote Armenia’s European
integration course.

On November 18, Russia, Belarus and Kazakhstan have signed a decree to
set up a joint body to oversee and regulate the economy and trade in
the three former Soviet countries. The Eurasian Economic Commission
will be set up in January to regulate and to gradually take over
functions in shaping and executing trade and economic policies from
Russian, Belarusian and Kazakh authorities in a way similar to the
economic bodies of the European Union.

The forum was organized by the Armenian Center of Political and
International Studies with the assistance of U.S. National Democratic
Institute.

Hetq: Yerevan-Found And Lost

YEREVAN-FOUND AND LOST
Jaana Davidjants

HETQ

November 24, 2011

Ten years ago when I lived in Yerevan I was completely in love with the
city. Armenia felt like home in its post-war sincerity and patriotism,
as well as in the complete hospitality of its people.

Everything seemed possible, the overall mood was bright, and everyone
looked to the future with hopeful expectations.

I guess this was the reason I was so taken aback while visiting
this time.

The triumph of ghost houses

The first thing that perplexed me was the view of the city. I noticed
with surprise that Yerevan is in worse ruins than it was back then,
the city centre now filled with empty houses and building carcasses.

It took me a while to realize that these are completely new
constructions, the city is covered with “modern ruins”. Instead of
valuing its history and architecture, and renovating its buildings,
Yerevan´s official policy seems to favor sheer destruction, demolition
and later construction of bad quality ghost houses.

Yet, there are amazing places in Yerevan, for example the outdoor
cinema next to the main square which is soon set to be demolished.

Places like this can make every tourist envious.

Despite prevalent nationalistic sentiments, it becomes clear that
Yerevan values its own identity little and looks longingly towards
Europe. This can be seen while strolling down a sidewalk in the
center of the city, lined with cafes named: London, Paris, Rio and
so forth. But it seems that Armenians are trying to copy Europe from
what they’ve seen in music videos, or as told by a distant relative
who knows someone who went there a long time ago. The outcome is a
cheap and absurd imitation which has nothing to do with those cities.

Furthermore, as much as Yerevan tries, it will never become Paris or
London (and why should it?).

A great example of ghost houses can be found on the main street in
the city centre. If one walks on Abovyan during the day, things seem
quite glamorous, as every building carries a big logo like Hugo Boss
or Versace. But during the night, it becomes clear that something
doesn’t add up, on the whole street only few windows are lit up. The
rest of the apartments sit empty since they were built, more than two
years ago. Certainly one explanation is the poor construction quality,
as well as the high prices which exceed some cities in the heart of
Europe, for example Berlin (keeping in mind that Armenian medium wage
is 200-300 dollars per month). The city is full of empty apartments
while the actual need for new ones is very small. Foreign Armenians
with their desire for summer apartments in Yerevan have created a
real-estate bubble with no connection to reality which will burst soon.

Public space and trade

There is a noticeable absence of public space. People seem to exist for
the city, not the other way around. And so it happens that when in a
park with a little child who walks on the grass, suddenly a security
guard appears and announces it is strictly forbidden. This gives one
an impression that the park is not there for spending a good time but
for admiring it from afar. How to explain this concept to a 1,5 year
old is altogether another subject.

Caucasian trading mentality mixed with raging capitalism is far
from charming. One starts to tire when it turns out that from ten
identical tables you happen to be sitting at the one unmarked “VIP”
table with a large extra fee. Or when a taxi driver tries to convince
you that the rate has doubled as you place a small bag into the trunk
(per the driver’s request). And so now the pack is somehow considered
as some kind of separate traveller in the trunk.

One could think that Armenians are just not very blessed with any kind
of mathematical talent. Somehow though not one of those miscalculations
happen to be in favor of the client. It seems that the locals have
learned only one side of the business making, that is the part where
you ask for the money without understanding that there is at least
some degree of well-being you have to provide in return.

If for no other reason, at least because you might need the client
at some later point. As we know, good business is done with a stable
client base.

Cutting the branch you sit on

And the sad paradox? The only ones suffering from all this are the
locals themselves who are consistently cutting the branch they sit
on. Statistics shows that a big part of Armenian economy is supported
by foreign Armenians. And most of the tourists are foreign Armenians.

Why bite the hand that feeds you? And when my friends ask me how
Yerevan is and whether they should travel there I don´t know how to
answer. Because I am not sure anymore what Yerevan has to offer. The
architecture of the city has been ruined, life is more expensive
than in Europe and the story of Armenian hospitality has turned into
an old myth from a distant time. And so I tell them: better go to
Tbilisi. Georgians at least value their city and in big part have
been able to get rid of the sickness common to the Caucasus region:
corruption. Or then go to Istanbul, which is truly vibrant, a good
mixture of East and West and where a tourist doesn´t feel taken for
a fool at every step.

I understand that I´m being unfair to many amazing Armenians, to some
that I met during my stay. But then again, it isn´t about the common
person. It´s about a society with an extreme level of corruption, a
society where the only value is money, a society which doesn´t cherish
its own people. It is ugly and very far from anything sustainable. And
it produces a large number of small criminals who are sadly louder
than nice people.

And because of everything mentioned above, I am not surprised to hear
that Armenia is loosing a large part of it’s youth to emigration. As
in Estonia, no official media campaign can bring back young people,
only the real knowledge that there is a possibility of building
something in your homeland can stop this emigration.

I deeply hope that when I travel to Armenia again in a couple of
years I will be positively surprised. I hope that things will have
changed for the better.

http://hetq.am/eng/opinion/7206/yerevan-found-and-lost.html

ISTANBUL: Erdogan aims to destroy Ataturk’s legacy: CHP

Hurriyet, Turkey
Nov 23 2011

ErdoÄ?an aims to destroy Atatürk’s legacy: CHP

Tuesday, November 22, 2011
ANKARA ` Hürriyet Daily News

Debate over the Dersim killings deepens as PM ErdoÄ?an promises to
reveal new documents on the military operations while the main
opposition leader accuses ErdoÄ?an of trying to discredit Mustafa Kemal
Atatürk

Main opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) leader Kemal
KılıçdaroÄ?lu addresses his party’s lawmakers at a group meeting. DAILY
NEWS photo, Selahattin SÃ-NMEZ

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip ErdoÄ?an’s active involvement in a debate
over the 1938 Dersim killings is a reflection of his underlying
intention to discredit the legacy of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, Turkey’s
main opposition leader has said.

`Your intention is to settle scores with Atatürk, to dispose of the
Republic. We are aware of that,’ Kemal KılıçdaroÄ?lu said yesterday at
the parliamentary group meeting of his Republican People’s Party
(CHP).

KılıçdaroÄ?lu spoke shortly after ErdoÄ?an said he would today disclose
documents exposing the CHP’s role in a military crackdown on a 1938
Alevi rebellion in Dersim, now Tunceli, in which thousands perished.

ErdoÄ?an challenged KılıçdaroÄ?lu, himself an Alevi from Tunceli, to
face up to his party’s responsibility for the killings which took
place at a time when the CHP ruled Turkey in a single-party regime.

`It’s a golden opportunity for the CHP to face up to the Dersim
tragedy as its chairman is a tribe member from Tunceli. You’re from
Tunceli, why do you shy away?’ ErdoÄ?an said.

In an unusually emotional outburst, KılıçdaroÄ?lu said: `Yes, I’m from
Dersim, and I am a son of this nation. Now, I’m the chairman of the
CHP and I am proud of it. God willing, I will also be prime minister
soon.’

Denouncing ErdoÄ?an’s rhetoric as `provocative and divisive,’ the CHP
leader ridiculed his advocacy of the people of Tunceli, a province
where the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) has never won a
parliamentary seat.

`You cannot be the mouthpiece of the people who suffered in Dersim.
The people of Dersim would consider your advocacy an insult,’
KılıçdaroÄ?lu said.

He said the CHP had nothing to be ashamed of in its past, while
accusing ErdoÄ?an of being an heir to those who opposed Atatürk’s quest
for independence after World War I but favored instead a British or
U.S. mandate.

`Yesterday you were advocates of a mandate and today you are
sub-contractors,’ he said, echoing his earlier accusations that the
AKP’s foreign policy was dictated by Washington.

KılıçdaroÄ?lu chided the 12 lawmakers who issued a joint declaration
last week against Hüseyin Aygün, the CHP’s Tunceli deputy who
re-ignited the debate over Dersim and stirred intra-party tensions
with remarks asserting that the CHP was responsible for the killings.

`You may harm me, but you cannot harm the CHP, I will not allow this
to happen,’ he said.

ErdoÄ?an dismissed KılıçdaroÄ?lu’s suggestion that incumbent prime
ministers should apologize for past atrocities on behalf of the
Turkish state.

Tuesday, November 22, 2011