ANKARA: Corpse-Lotto: How Many Armenians Killed?

Journal of Turkish Weekly, Turkey
Jan 30 2007

Corpse-Lotto: How Many Armenians Killed?
Sedat Laciner

Tuesday , 30 January 2007

During World War I, like all other groups, so many people among
Armenians lost their lives, and many of them were forced to leave
their homes. However, the dispute on how many Armenians died during
the war is the maybe one of the most complicated debates in the
world.

Comparing the various historians’ answers to the question of `how
many Armenians died’ is really difficult. Each historian, Turkish,
Armenian or from any other origin, reaches quite surprising results.
One says 1 million, the other says 2 millions. It is worse than
guessing the true numbers in lotto; at least you have just 49 numbers
in lotto. Turkish historians and their formal institutions try to
show these numbers as low as they can. Among these people, there are
some historians who say this number is below 200.000 while some
others can increase the number to 400.000 etc. And there are also
people who draw down the number to even 10.000. But, even the Turkish
historians cannot reach a mutual understanding. Almost every number
between 10.000 and 800.000 people have mentioned in Turkey. If you
regard Orhan Pamuk as a `Turkish historian’ (!), it is possible to
increase this estimation up to 1.5 million people.

If you look at the numbers of the Armenian side, you surprise more.
The numbers start from 500.000 and increase up to 1 million, 1.5
million even 2 millions. In recent years, in one of the meetings in
Wales, the Armenians have increased the number up to 2.5 millions.
Henceforward, it cannot be known that, if this number is going to be
increased up to 3 millions, 4 millions, or even over the total
population of Ottoman Empire at that period.

Unfortunately, the debates on the number of the killed Armenians
resemble the auction rooms. But with one difference, while Armenians
increase the number, Turkish people tries to decrease it…

`1 million…’

`There is someone who gives 1.1 million …’

`Yes, they say 1.5 millions. Who increases it?’

`Mr. Pamuk, they say 1.5 millions. Do you increase this number? Or
you Mr.? Isn’t there any historian who increases the number? Isn’t
there any scientist who increases the number?’

***

The scene is cursorily awful. The policy is made on the corpses.
So-called historians, play corpse-lotto. There is not a single person
who is abashed of this. The people who say 2.5 million people died
and who say 500.000 people died can argue with a same tone of voice…
However, this is very clear: some people lie without blushing. They
also lie without scruple. They are not abashed of this… They make
business on the corpses, in order to defend their benefits they use,
they abuse the corpses.

***

`500.000. Isn’t there anybody who decrease it?’

`There is someone who says 400.000. Yes, is there someone who
decrease to 300.000? Isn’t there any professor who decrease the
number, isn’t there any historian who decrease it to 10.000 even less
than that?

If there are this much different numbers, some people anyhow lie. Or,
some people do not fulfill the requirements of their jobs. If there
are tens of dead-toll, we cannot say `historian’ to the so-called
historians who speak. It also cannot be said `the historians should
come together and solve this problem ‘. It’s necessary for the
historians who are at this picture not to appear on the scene, not to
show themselves…

Another 24 April is close again … And, again the number of the people
who play corpse-lotto increases … People who want to satisfy their
interests and desires are going to give an estimate one more time and
they are going to call it `science’ … Let’s see this year; up to what
number will the Armenian researchers increase the number…

By the way, how many Turks and Armenians live right now to live
together, any guess?


Assoc. Prof. Dr. Sedat LACINER: Director of the USAK (International
Strategic Research Organization, Ankara & Davos Economic Forum Young
Global leader 2006.

[email protected]
translated by Zerin Acar and Kemal Tuzcu (JTW)

id=2450

http://www.turkishweekly.net/comments.php?

T. Torosian: Sky Won’t Fall Down In Case of Unsuccessfull Elections

TIGRAN TOROSIAN: THE SKY NOT TO FALL DOWN IN CASE OF UNSUCCESSFULL
ELECTIONS BUT THE COUNTRY TO MISS A VERY IMPORTANT POSSIBILITY FOR ITS
DEVELOPMENT

YEREVAN, JANUARY 30, NOYAN TAPAN. After officially making public soon
the date of holding the parliamentary elections of Armenia, a
consultation will be held at the country President’s Office on the
occasion of inviting international observers. RA National Assembly
Speaker Tigran Torosian stated about it at the January 29 press
conference, responding the journalists’ question. In his words, the
list of organizations to be invited will be defined and according to
it, the state structures to be invited will be decided.

At the journalists’ request touching upon the demand of holding the
coming elections in correspondence with the international standards,
T.Torosian again attached importance to the necessity of parties’
displaying political will. In his opinion, the parties must
completely understand that the coming elections have an exclusive
meaning for Armenia. In his words, "the sky will not fall down" in the
case of unsuccessful elections, but Armenia will miss a too important
possibility for its development. In the speaker’s words, he himself is
sure that bad process of elections does not arise from interests of
any political forces, irrespective of the fact if that force is in the
opposition or among the authorities. He expressed a hope that
political forces will correctly estimate the situation and see
possibility of cooperation for the sake of good elections.

The NA Speaker mentioned on this occasion that during the meeting with
Christian Shtrohal, the Director of the OSCE Office for Democratic
Institutions and Human Rights, who visited Yerevan recently, he
proposed to representatives of the NA factions to create a working
group which will make an attempt to coordinate work with the
observation missions, Central Electoral Commission, authorities. In
the case of possible alarms, the mentioned group will attempt to
initiate steps to correct the noticed faults. T.Torosian stated that a
preliminary agreement on cooperation with some of the factions heads
has already been reached, and the prospect of creation of the group
will be finally defined during the coming 10 days.

ANKARA: Turkish party official accuses "Westerners" of Dink Murder

Anatolia News Agency, Turkey
Jan 26 2007

Turkish party official accuses "Westerners" of instigating murder of
journalist

Adana, 26 January: Grand Unity Party [BBP] Deputy General Chairman
Edip Ozbas charged that it was "Westerners" who instigated the
assassination of Agos General Publishing Manager Hrant Dink.

Speaking at a press conference in Adana where he was visiting his
party’s province organization, Ozbas said that certain circles have
been using Dink’s assassination as an excuse to bring out the
"poison" accumulated inside them against the Turkish nation.

Charging that Western states have pursued various objectives in
Turkey’s geography for many centuries, Ozbas said: "The same game is
being played today. We have never lost our faith that independent
judicial organs will lift the veil of secrecy behind the Dink murder,
which we condemn strongly. However, the real powers behind this
murder and similar acts of terror, the ones who instigate them, are
Westerners who have forced Turkey to adapt to the EU acquis."

Ozbas continued: "Politicians and so-called intellectuals who have
been trying to impose the EU acquis on Turkey irrationally for many
years bear primary responsibility for the murders, the muggings, and
the corruption that have been perpetrated, and the surrender of
[Turkish] lands to foreigners. Those who have levelled accusations
against the BBP and General Chairman Muhsin Yazicioglu will have to
give a reckoning in the future for what they have done to the
nation."

Answering a question, Ozbas said that Western states want Article 301
of the Constitution [as published] to be amended in accordance with
their wishes. He added: "[They want] insults against the Turkish
identity to be permitted but any remarks to the effect that ‘there
was no Armenian genocide’ to be a crime. This cannot be accepted. For
the past 84 years, the Turkish state has included in its constitution
provisions that protect it. It will preserve those provisions in the
future also."

Ode to a Murdered Turkish Editor

TIME/in Partnership with CNN
Jan 25 2007

Ode to a Murdered Turkish Editor

Istanbul, Turkey
Dear Hrant,

Friday, Jan. 19. The day you were murdered. I stare at the TV, at
your tall, thin body lying dead on the sidewalk of a busy street in
Istanbul . You are in front of your office, the office of the
Turkish-Armenian weekly you worked so hard to launch and sustain. I
cannot take my eyes off the soles of your shoes. Worn out and tired,
your shoes are a mute response to all those ultranationalists who
accused you of being in the pay of the Armenian diaspora to disrupt
the status quo in Turkey .

I feel numb. And I know you wouldn’t approve of that. All your life
you have struggled to encourage both Turks and Armenians to shake off
the mutual numbness in their hearts so that they can start feeling
each other’s emotions and hearing each other’s words.

On the day you were finally given a passport, after being denied one
by the state for many years, you were as happy as a kid. "Can you
believe it?"

You said. "I can travel now!" And so you did, commuting between
America , Europe , Turkey and Armenia , bridging gaps that people on
all sides took for granted. Always a maverick, you never just gave
your audience what they wanted to hear. The myriad prejudices and
generalizations in the Armenian diaspora about Turkey and the Turks
frustrated you. "Yes, there are bigoted Turks," you would say, "but
there also countless progressive, open-minded ones, and they are my
friends, brothers and sisters."

The myriad prejudices and generalizations in Turkish society about
Armenians saddened you, too. You also wanted us Turks to break the
deep silence regarding the massacres and deportation of Armenians in
1915, to question our collective amnesia. Nevertheless, you fervently
opposed the Armenian genocide bill approved by the French Parliament,
which would make it a crime to say that the events of 1915 were not a
genocide, because, first and foremost, you believed in freedom of
expression. You said it was not up to Western politicians to write
our history. Turks and Armenians had to do that, build a dialogue
and, eventually, learn to reconcile.

You could have gone abroad to live in greater safety and comfort. But
you were passionate about Istanbul and would always say, "This city
belongs to us all, regardless of religion and ethnicity."

Tuesday, Jan. 23. The day we buried you. "Yes," you once said, "we
Turkish Armenians do have a claim to the soil of this country, but
not to take it away, as some accuse us of secretly plotting, but to
be buried deep under it." Your funeral was spectacular. Tens of
thousands marched. They carried signs that said, WE ARE ALL HRANT, WE
ARE ALL ARMENIANS.

The Turkish press, left and right, condemned your assassination. You
united people of all ideological backgrounds and made them recognize
their common faith in democracy.

At the Armenian cemetery, the crowd was asked to wait outside, but
people refused.

Muslims and Christians buried you together. On your gravestone there
sits a marble angel, her eyes turned toward the sky, as if awaiting
an explanation, or else, consolation. But that solace won’t come from
above. It will come from Turkey, from the land you loved.

ELIF SHAFAK

Shafak, a longtime friend of Dink’s, recently published her novel The
Bastard of Istanbul, about Turks and Armenians, in English

/0,9171,1582145,00.html?cnn=yes

http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article

Manuk Gasparian’s Health Condition Stabilizes

MANUK GASPARIAN’S HEALTH CONDITION STABILIZES

YEREVAN, JANUARY 24, NOYAN TAPAN. The health condition of RA MP Manuk
Gasparian, Chairman of Democratic Way Party, who is at Nairi medical
center, has become stable. Noyan Tapan correspondent was informed
about it from Party Vice-Chairman Vardan Grigorian.

In his words, efficient medical treatment has greatly contributed to
the deputy’s recovery "and the members of his party hope to see him
soon on the front line of political struggle." He also stated that
M.Gasparian was taken to hospital on January 20 with the diagnosis
of heart attack.

U.S. calls slaying of journalist tragic

International Herald Tribune, France
Jan 20 2007

U.S. calls slaying of journalist tragic
The Associated PressPublished: January 19, 2007

WASHINGTON: The State Department said Friday the slaying of an
Armenian-Turkish journalist in Istanbul was a "tragic incident."

Deputy spokesman Tom Casey noted that Hrant Dink, 53, a Turkish
citizen, had received threats for his writing.

"Certainly we never want to see a situation in which individuals are
intimidated or in fact suffer retribution of any kind simply for
freely expressing their views," Casey said.

ANKARA: ATAA Condemns Killing Of Turkish Armenian Journalist Dink

Anatolian Times, Turkey
Jan 20 2007

ATAA Condemns The Killing Of Turkish Armenian Journalist, Hrant Dink
Washington, DC – The Assembly of Turkish Americans strongly condemns
the killing earlier today of Turkish Armenian journalist, Hrant Dink,
in Istanbul. The ATAA urges the Turkish Republic to dedicate its best
assets to the capture, trial and punishment of the perpetrator(s) of
this heinous murder.
The killing of Mr. Dink is a great loss to Turkey. Mr. Dink was the
editor of Agos, an Armenian-language newspaper in Istanbul, and also
wrote for the Turkish daily, Zaman. He was a respected member and
voice of Istanbul’s prosperous and growing Armenian community. He
advocated reconciliation on the Ottoman Armenian Tragedy of WWI.
Unfortunately, he was also the subject of prosecution for his
characterization of WWI Armenian deaths as genocide.

ATAA reaffirms that people are entitled to their own opinions and the
expression of the same. Turks are struggling for the same rights in
Europe and America.

The Turkish Court of Appeals was right to vacate the conviction and
remand the case that charged Dink under Law 301 for `insulting the
Turkish identity.’ ATAA is confident in Turkish democracy’s ability
to address the difficulties of Law 301.

ATAA expresses that the killing of Dink ranks among the worst acts
against the best interest of Turkey and regional peace and stability.
ATAA urges all concerned parties that the Ottoman Armenian Tragedy is
an extremely sensitive matter, the treatment of which requires the
utmost care not to fuel the flames of extremism, particularly at a
time when security, peace and stability in the Middle East is
critical.

ATAA mourns the death of this fellow countryman, Mr. Hrant Dink, and
the loss of this very important part of our community. We convey our
deepest sympathies to his family and friends, and to the people of
Turkey.

Turkey’s Early Christian Roots — Religion & Ethics Newsweekly, PBS

Religion & Ethics Newsweekly, PBS
COVER STORY:
Turkey’s Early Christian Roots
January 19, 2007 Episode no. 1021
k1021/cover.html

RELIGION & ETHICS NEWSWEEKLY Cover Story Transcript: "Turkey’s Early
Christian Roots" Show #1021, PBS National Feed Date: January 19, 2007

BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: Christian holy sites in Israel are popular
pilgrimage destinations, but perhaps the most extensive ruins from
Christian antiquity are in the predominantly Muslim nation of
Turkey. Several books of the New Testament were written in and to
communities in what is now Turkey, and many foundational Christian
doctrines were established there. Kim Lawton explored Turkey’s early
Christian legacy.

KIM LAWTON: Sunday morning in Istanbul. Members of Turkey’s tiny
Christian minority gather for worship carrying on traditions that have
been practiced here for nearly two millennia. Turkey may be 99 percent
Muslim today, but Christianity has deep roots in this land the New
Testament calls Asia Minor, and that history is still literally part
of the landscape.

Allen Callahan is a scholar with the Society for Biblical Studies and
has visited Turkey several times.

Professor ALLEN CALLAHAN (Society for Biblical Studies): Pound for
pound, as it were, we have more remnants of Christian antiquity in
Turkey than anywhere else.

LAWTON: After Jesus was crucified in Jerusalem, his followers
scattered across the ancient world. What is now called Turkey was a
key crossroads between Europe, Asia, and the Middle East, and the
fledgling Christian faith took hold in this Roman province with a rich
Greek heritage. One of the most important cities was Ephesus, site of
a huge temple to the Greek goddess Artemis.

ALTAY GUR (Tour Guide): A lot of people were coming to visit the
temple of Artemis, and that was extremely good for the economic life
of the city, which brought Ephesus at that time period as the third
biggest city in the world.

LAWTON: Tour guide Altay Gur specializes in early church history. He
showed me around Ephesus, which has some of the most extensive and
best preserved Roman ruins in the world. One of the most famous views
is captured on the Turkish 20 lira bill.

Mr. GUR: On the right side you can see the temple of Hadrian, and you
can see the beautiful library of Ephesus, which was the third largest
one, and you can see the columns here.

LAWTON: According to biblical tradition, the Apostle Paul lived in
Ephesus for perhaps as long as three years, and he used it as a
stopping point during his missionary journeys.

Mr. GUR: So these are the streets where Saint Paul was walking 2,000
years ago.

LAWTON: The New Testament Book of Ephesians was addressed to the
Christians here, and scholars say Paul wrote several other books of
the Bible while staying here.

Mr. GUR: We call this library Celsius library, and Celsius was the
Roman governor.

LAWTON (to Mr. Gur): Was this here when the Apostle Paul lived here?

Mr. GUR: Yes, yes it was.

LAWTON: For many tourists, seeing the place firsthand can bring the
Bible stories to life.

Prof. CALLAHAN: Especially if one has, really, if one has a guidebook
in one hand, the Book of Acts in the other, you can creatively connect
the dots.

LAWTON: A case in point, the 24,000-seat theater. The Book of Acts in
the New Testament tells the story of a riot against the Apostle Paul,
which took place in this amphitheatre. It was instigated by a
silversmith named Demetrius who made small figurines of the goddess
Artemis. He was worried that Paul’s preaching about Christianity could
threaten his business, and he began a riot that ended up here with the
townspeople in this amphitheatre. The Bible says Paul left Ephesus
shortly after that.

The Ephesus area was also important for another early Church leader,
Saint John, known in the Bible as "the disciple whom Jesus loved."
Although some scholars disagree, tradition holds that John presided
over the churches of Asia Minor and died here of old age. In the sixth
century, Byzantine Emperor Justinian built a massive basilica over the
place where Christians say John is buried. Much of it still stands.

Mr. GUR: So now we are on the way to the house of Mother Mary.

LAWTON: John is also connected to another Church tradition that ties
the Virgin Mary to Turkey. Some Christians, especially Catholics,
believe Mary accompanied John to Asia Minor and spent her last days in
a small house outside Ephesus. That belief is based on a story in the
Gospel of John that puts Mary and the disciple at the foot of the
cross.

Prof. CALLAHAN: These two are together in that poignant moment, and
Jesus says from the cross, "Mother behold your son," then turns to the
beloved disciple and says, "Son behold your mother." He entrusts his
mother to the care of the beloved disciple, this disciple whom he
loves.

LAWTON: The Bible says from then on John took Mary into his home, but
it doesn’t say where. Sister Antonia Velasco lives on the grounds and
believes it was here.

Sister ANTONIA VELASCO: It’s known that Saint John was in Ephesus,
that he wrote the Gospel here, and that’s how we believe that Mary was
somewhere in the zone here, and then you have to believe in faith that
she was here.

LAWTON: Many other Catholics believe Mary was taken into heaven from
Jerusalem. But the Turkish tradition gained popularity after an
eighteenth-century nun who never left Germany said she saw Mary’s last
house in some mystical visions. Her descriptions matched this house,
which had long been revered by local Christians. Sister Antonia says
the place has a peace that she believes suits Mary.

Sister ANTONIA: Imagining her overlooking the ocean, with all of her
memories of the life of Christ here, contemplating, you know,
contemplating and praying over what she had lived through.

LAWTON: The New Testament does talk about many other early church
leaders who lived and worked in Asia Minor. In addition to the Book of
Ephesians, the books of Galatians and Colossians were written to
congregations here. A host of other cities in Turkey make biblical
appearances as well, if only as an aside.

The city of Hierapolis is only mentioned once in the New Testament. In
the Book of Colossians, Paul speaks briefly about the early church
leaders’ concern for the Christians here.

Asia Minor also plays a prominent role in the apocalyptic Book of
Revelation, which is addressed to seven churches, all of them in what
is now Turkey. One was Laodicea. Christians here were rebuked for
being lukewarm. In contrast to Ephesus, only a little excavation has
been done on this vast site.

Christianity flourished after Emperor Constantine officially
recognized the religion in the year 313. Seven ecumenical church
councils met here to formalize foundational doctrines of the
faith. Among them, the influential Council of Nicea in 325, which
established the creed still recited in churches around the world.

Prof. CALLAHAN: The decisions of those councils, the sort of
intellectual fruit of those councils, remain with us today.

LAWTON: Constantine proclaimed Constantinople, modern-day Istanbul,
the new capital of the Holy Roman Empire in 330, and the city remained
a center of global Christianity until it was conquered by the Ottomans
in 1453. Callahan says the lingering remnants provide both
inspiration and caution.

Prof. CALLAHAN: Life among the ruins can be sobering. So many people
invested so much time, effort, energy, and wealth into the
architectural expressions of their faith and their commitments, and
most of those expressions are in various states of decay.

LAWTON: Many visitors are surprised Turkey hasn’t done more to
excavate and develop its Christian holy sites. Callahan says it’s
been a complicated issue for predominantly Muslim Turkey.

Prof. CALLAHAN: A government or a society sees itself as standing in
one tradition. But it sees all around it the remnants, the residue, of
another tradition with which it’s had an ambivalent relationship. So,
what to do about those?

LAWTON: And there is the always challenging question of finances.

Mr. GUR: Even the U.S. government could not finance the excavations in
Turkey, because we have more than 4,000 ancient sites in Turkey, and
the economy of Turkey compared to the U.S. is very little.

LAWTON: Gur urges others to step in and help.

Mr. GUR: I believe that these ruins here belong to you as much as it
belongs to me because these are world heritage, so it belongs to us
all.

LAWTON: It’s vital, he says, that this history not be lost
forever. I’m Kim Lawton in western Turkey.

http://www.pbs.org/wnet/religionandethics/wee

OSCE Called Hrant Dink’s Assassination a `Cowardly Act’

PanARMENIAN.Net

OSCE Called Hrant Dink’s Assassination a `Cowardly Act’
20.01.2007 14:19 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ OSCE representative on Media freedom Miklós
Haraszti released a statement, which condemns Armenian journalist
Hrant Dink’s assassination in Istanbul. Particularly, the statement
says violence against journalists must not remain unpunished. `We call
upon Turkish authorities to find the murderers as soon as possible,’
says Haraszti.

`Hrant Dink was one of the most famous representatives of the Armenian
Diaspora in Turkey, who was speaking on its problems publicly. His
assassination is a cowardly act,’ Haraszti underlines, `Yerkir Media’
reports.

ANKARA: Turkish-Armenian editor shot dead in Istanbul

Yeni ªafak, Turkey
Jan 19 2007

Turkish-Armenian editor shot dead in Istanbul

A Turkish-Armenian editor, who had been convicted of insulting
Turkey’s identity over his comments on Armenians, was shot dead
outside his newspaper office in Istanbul on Friday.

A Turkish-Armenian editor, who had been convicted of insulting
Turkey’s identity over his comments on Armenians, was shot dead
outside his newspaper office in Istanbul on Friday.

Turkish broadcaster NTV said Hrant Dink, a controversial writer and
journalist, was shot by an unknown assailant as he left his newspaper
Agos around 1300 GMT in central Istanbul.

A colleague of Dink’s confirmed he had died. Police released no
further information.

Last year Turkey’s appeals court upheld a six-month suspended jail
sentence against Dink, a Turkish-born Armenian, for referring in an
article to an Armenian nationalist idea of ethnic purity without
Turkish blood.

The court said the comments went against an article of Turkey’s
revised penal code which lets prosecutors pursue cases against
writers and scholars for "insulting Turkish identity".

Dink was one of dozens of writers who have been charged under laws
against insulting Turkishness, particularly over issues related to an
alleged genocide of Armenians by Ottoman Turks during World War One.

Turkey denies genocide was committed.

The government has promised to revise the much criticised article of
the penal code. The European Union has repeatedly called on Ankara to
change the law.

Dink was editor-in-of chief of the bilingual Turkish and Armenian
weekly Agos.

Fehmi Koru, a columnist at the Yeni Safak newspaper, said the murder
was aimed at destabilizing Turkey.

"His loss is the loss of Turkey," Koru said.