Meta Oversight Board upholds decision to leave Armenian POW video on Facebook

June 14 2023
 14 June 2023

Footage alleged to show injured Armenian soldiers being captured by their Azerbaijani counterparts will remain on Facebook, after Meta’s Oversight Board decided to uphold an earlier decision by the company.

The video, which was published on Facebook in October 2022, was not removed from the platform at the time despite violating Facebook’s Coordinating Harm and Promoting Crime Community Standard. Meta, Facebook’s parent company, cited the video’s newsworthiness and argued that public interest in seeing the content outweighed the risk to the captured soldiers’ safety and dignity. 

Meta’s Oversight Board launched an investigation into the case in March of this year. 

The video was not widely shared following its publication on the platform, and it remains unclear whether it remains on Facebook or has since been taken down.

According to Meta, the video was published on a page which identified itself as documenting Azerbaijani war crimes committed against Armenians in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, and appeared to show prisoners of war being captured.

‘The video shows people who appear to be Azerbaijani soldiers searching through rubble. The video has been edited so that their faces cannot be seen. They find people in the rubble who are described in the caption as Armenian soldiers. Some appear to be injured, others appear dead. They pull one solider [sic] from the rubble, who cries out in pain. His face is visible and he appears injured’, the description of the video by the board read.

The video reportedly ends with an unseen person berating an injured soldier sitting on the ground in Russian and Turkish.

The video was published less than a month after the September 2022 Two-Day War between Armenia and Azerbaijan, which took place within Armenia, and resulted in Azerbaijan gaining territories and the two sides losing around two hundred soldiers in total.

In the weeks following the conflict, footage appearing to show Azerbaijani soldiers committing war crimes appeared online, including the mutilation of female soldiers and the execution of a group of Armenian soldiers.

Graphic evidence of war crimes in the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict has in recent years frequently been published online, especially on platforms such as Telegram, which exercise little control over the content published. In some cases those posting celebrate the pictured actions, while others share the footage to discredit the other side. 

A number of Telegram channels were created during the September fighting, sharing images and video of dead and wounded Armenian soldiers, as well as Armenian prisoners of war. 

Tuesday’s decision by Meta’s Oversight Board found that Meta ‘correctly applied the newsworthiness allowance’ in deciding to allow the video to remain on Facebook, while adding a ‘mark as disturbing’ warning screen to it. 

‘These decisions were consistent with Meta’s values and human rights responsibilities’, the decision reads.

The text of the decision also notes that it sets a precedent for Meta, raising ‘important questions’ about Meta’s content moderation in conflict situations, particularly in relation to revealing the identities and locations of prisoners of war. 

While the decision notes that such footage could expose those pictured to immediate harm, it adds that it can also contribute to public debate and raise awareness of ‘violations of international human rights and international humanitarian law’. 

‘It can also build momentum for action that protects rights and ensures accountability’, the board stated. ‘Meta did not have evidence that videos of this kind were producing […] negative effects but did see evidence that international organisations were using such videos to increase pressure on Azerbaijan to end mistreatment of prisoners of war.’

The Board’s decision was largely welcomed by Armenian media experts. Some, however, expressed concerns about the psychological effects of such content and its use in ‘hybrid’ warfare. 

‘I still think that the video should not be allowed on the platform, as it constitutes information war against the Armenian society’, cyber security expert Artur Papyan wrote on Twitter. However, he described the board’s counter-arguments as ‘valid’ and deemed the judgement a ‘balanced’ one, especially in the context of similar cases in Ukraine and elsewhere. 

https://oc-media.org/meta-oversight-board-upholds-decision-to-leave-armenian-pow-video-on-facebook/

Unveiling the Thriving Commodity Markets in the Caucasus: A Closer Look at Azerbaijan, Georgia, and Armenia

June 14 2023

The bustling world of commodity trading is a vital cog in the global economic machinery, shaping international trade and influencing market dynamics. In the spotlight, we turn our attention to the Caucasian countries, nestled between Europe and Asia, renowned for their diverse landscapes, rich history, and burgeoning economies. This article delves into the realm of commodity trading in this region, shedding light on the intricate web of transactions, market trends, and economic forces at play. From Azerbaijan’s oil exports to Georgia’s agricultural prowess and Armenia’s mineral resources, we uncover the unique challenges, opportunities, and evolving strategies shaping commodity trading in these Caucasian nations.

Commodity trading in Caucasian countries holds significant popularity and plays a crucial role in their respective economies. These nations, including Azerbaijan, Georgia, and Armenia, possess abundant natural resources and have strategically positioned themselves as key players in the global commodities market.

Azerbaijan, blessed with substantial oil and gas reserves, stands as a prominent player in the energy sector. Crude oil and natural gas dominate its commodity trading landscape. The country’s strategic location between Europe and Asia, along with its ambitious infrastructure projects, has propelled Azerbaijan to become a vital energy supplier to regional and international markets. The oil-rich Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline, connecting the Caspian Sea to the Mediterranean, has enhanced Azerbaijan’s trading capabilities.

In Georgia, agriculture takes centre stage in the commodity trading arena. The country boasts fertile lands and a favourable climate, fostering the production of diverse agricultural commodities. Wine, hazelnuts, fruits, vegetables, and tea are among the leading products traded. Georgia’s reputation for high-quality wine has contributed to its rising prominence in global markets, while its agricultural sector has become a cornerstone of its export-driven economy.

Armenia, with its mineral wealth, particularly in copper, gold, and molybdenum, has established itself as a significant player in the mining industry. Commodity trading in these minerals has bolstered the country’s economic growth and attracted foreign investments. Additionally, Armenia’s skilled workforce and competitive production costs contribute to its favourable position in the global mining market.

The trading of these commodities in Caucasian countries brings various benefits. It generates substantial revenue, promotes economic growth, and provides employment opportunities. Moreover, commodity exports contribute to the diversification of the region’s economies, reducing their reliance on specific sectors.

To regulate commodity trading, Caucasian countries have established regulatory frameworks that ensure transparency, fair competition, and compliance with international standards. Azerbaijan’s State Oil Fund and the State Commodity Exchange play critical roles in overseeing the energy sector and regulating commodity trading. In Georgia, the Ministry of Agriculture and the National Wine Agency monitor agricultural exports and quality standards. Armenia’s Ministry of Territorial Administration and Infrastructure oversees the mining sector and enforces regulations to promote responsible mining practices.

These regulatory frameworks aim to attract foreign investments, protect domestic industries, and ensure sustainable resource management. They also foster an environment conducive to fair trade practices, bolstering confidence among international partners.

In conclusion, commodity trading in Caucasian countries is highly popular, driven by their abundant natural resources and strategic geographical locations. Leading commodities, such as oil and gas in Azerbaijan, agricultural products in Georgia, and minerals in Armenia, contribute significantly to their respective economies. These commodities bring numerous benefits, including revenue generation, economic growth, and employment opportunities. To maintain transparency and compliance, regulatory frameworks are in place to oversee and regulate commodity trading activities. With their rich resources and robust regulatory frameworks, Caucasian countries continue to position themselves as key players in the global commodities market.

Commodity trading in Georgia is experiencing steady development, driven by the country’s diverse agricultural sector and favorable geographic location. The agricultural commodities that dominate Georgia’s commodity trading landscape include wine, hazelnuts, fruits, vegetables, and tea.

Georgia has gained international recognition for its high-quality wines, making it a sought-after destination for wine enthusiasts. The country’s unique winemaking techniques, rich soil, and favorable climate contribute to the production of a wide variety of exquisite wines. The trading of Georgian wines has witnessed significant growth, with exports reaching various markets worldwide.

Another popular commodity is hazelnuts. Georgia is among the top global producers of hazelnuts, known for their exceptional taste and quality. The country’s favorable climate and fertile soil provide ideal conditions for hazelnut cultivation. Georgia’s hazelnut exports have surged in recent years, contributing to the country’s economic growth and global market presence.

In addition to wine and hazelnuts, Georgia’s fertile lands yield an array of other agricultural commodities. Fruits, including citrus fruits, apples, and berries, are exported to international markets. Vegetables, such as tomatoes, cucumbers, and peppers, are also significant contributors to Georgia’s commodity trading activities. Furthermore, Georgia’s tea production, particularly in the region of Guria, has gained recognition for its distinct flavour and aroma.

The development of commodity trading in Georgia has been supported by government initiatives to enhance agricultural productivity, improve quality standards, and promote exports. These efforts, combined with Georgia’s reputation for high-quality agricultural products, have facilitated the growth of commodity trading and opened doors for increased international market access.

Armenia’s commodity trading landscape is marked by its rich mineral resources, with copper, gold, and molybdenum standing out as the top traded commodities in the country.

Copper, with its versatile applications in various industries, holds a prominent position in Armenia’s commodity trading sector. The country possesses substantial copper reserves and has a long history of mining this valuable metal. Copper is in high demand globally for its conductivity, making it a crucial component in electrical wiring, machinery, and electronics. Armenia’s copper exports contribute significantly to its economy and attract foreign investments.

Gold is another highly traded commodity in Armenia. The country has sizeable gold deposits, and its mining industry focuses on extracting and trading this precious metal. Gold holds a strong position as a store of value and is sought after as an investment asset and for jewelry production. Armenia’s gold exports contribute to its foreign exchange reserves and foster economic growth.

Molybdenum, a metallic element with exceptional heat resistance and strength, is another top commodity traded in Armenia. The country has significant molybdenum reserves and is known for its high-quality production. Molybdenum is widely used in industries such as construction, energy, and transportation, as it enhances the strength and durability of alloys. Armenia’s molybdenum exports contribute to its industrial sector and global market presence.

The trading of these commodities in Armenia brings economic benefits, including revenue generation, employment opportunities, and foreign investments. Armenia’s rich mineral resources and focus on responsible mining practices position it as an important player in the global commodities market, particularly in the copper, gold, and molybdenum sectors.

Azerbaijan, with its abundant oil and gas reserves, is primarily known for its energy commodities, making crude oil and natural gas the most popular commodities to trade in the country.

Crude oil holds a significant position in Azerbaijan’s commodity trading landscape. The country possesses vast oil reserves, particularly in the Caspian Sea region. Azerbaijan’s strategic location between Europe and Asia, coupled with its robust infrastructure, including pipelines and terminals, has established it as a key player in the global oil market. Crude oil exports contribute significantly to Azerbaijan’s economy, generating substantial revenue and attracting international investments.

Natural gas is another highly traded commodity in Azerbaijan. The country boasts substantial natural gas reserves, both onshore and offshore. With increasing global demand for cleaner energy sources, natural gas has become a crucial component in the energy mix. Azerbaijan’s natural gas exports, facilitated by pipelines such as the Southern Gas Corridor, play a pivotal role in diversifying energy supplies to regional and international markets.

The popularity of these energy commodities in Azerbaijan stems from the country’s favorable geological conditions, its strategic location for transportation routes, and its commitment to developing the energy sector. The revenue generated from the trading of crude oil and natural gas contributes significantly to Azerbaijan’s economic growth and positions the country as an important player in the global energy market.

MP: Azerbaijan trying to dictate its terms to Armenia

Panorama
Armenia – June 14 2023

Armenian opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan has reacted to the latest Azerbaijani ceasefire violations on the border with Armenia near the village of Yeraskh, deploring the Armenian government’s conciliatory policy towards Baku.

"Amid the Armenian authorities' unilateral concessions, Azerbaijan has decided that they can act as they please," Abrahamyan, secretary of the Pativ Unem faction, wrote on Facebook on Wednesday. "Thus, Azerbaijan is trying to dictate its will [to Armenia] by escalating the situation near Yeraskh."

Two foreign nationals were injured on Wednesday after Azerbaijani forces opened fire on a metallurgical plant under construction in Yeraskh, the Defense Ministry of Armenia said.

The Armenian combat positions and civilian facilities in the area also came under Azerbaijani gunfire on Tuesday.

“Experience shows that the more the authorities announce their readiness to make new concessions, the sharper Azerbaijan’s aggression increases," Abrahamyan stated.

Yerevan court refuses to release ex-defense minister

Panorama
Armenia – June 14 2023

The Anti-Corruption Court in Yerevan has rejected a request to release Armenia’s former Defense Minister David Tonoyan from custody, his lawyer Sergey Hovhannisyan told 24News on Wednesday.

At the previous court hearing, Tonoyan’s legal team filed a motion to the court to free him given that 11 out of 15 witnesses in the case had already been questioned.

“The court has denied the motion," Hovhannisyan said, unveiling plans to challenge the decision in a higher court.

Tonoyan was arrested in 2021 on fraud and embezzlement charges related to purchases of faulty weaponry and ammunition for Armenia's armed forces.

Armenian-French project for preservation of Ererouyk receives Europe’s top heritage award

 16:10, 14 June 2023

YEREVAN, JUNE 14, ARMENPRESS. The Armenian-French Scientific-Archaeological Studies for the Preservation of Ererouyk is among the winners of the European Heritage Awards / Europa Nostra Awards 2023.

The European Commission and Europa Nostra have announced today the winners of the European Heritage Awards / Europa Nostra Awards 2023. This year, 30 outstanding heritage achievements from 21 countries have been awarded Europe’s top honour in the field (see the full list below).

The Awards, funded by the Creative Europe programme of the European Union, are granted in five categories:

  • Conservation & Adaptive Reuse;
  • Research;
  • Education, Training & Skills;
  • Citizens’ Engagement & Awareness-raising; and
  • Heritage Champions.

 

Armenian-French Scientific-Archaeological Studies for the Preservation of Ererouyk won the award in the Research category.

This year’s impressive collection of award winners ranges from the true renaissance of the Royal Gardens of Venice (Italy), a most treasured green space in the heart of this unique heritage city, to the fascinating research project Safeguarding of the Artisanal Fishing Technique “Arte-Xávega” (Portugal), which helps secure the future of one the last examples of artisanal and sustainable fishing in Europe; from ACTA VISTA (France), an innovative heritage skills training programme which helps individuals marginalised from employment return to work, to the annual festival Budapest 100 (Hungary), which celebrates the built heritage of this World Heritage City; and the transfrontier network of volunteers of SUCHO: Saving Ukrainian Cultural Heritage Online (Ukraine/International Project), which web archived over 50TB of data from Ukrainian cultural institutions in the first months of the war in Ukraine.

The Award winners were selected by the Jury, composed of heritage experts from across Europe, upon evaluation by the Selection Committees that are responsible for examining award applications, which this year were submitted by organisations and individuals from 35 European countries.

Reacting to the announcement of the 2023 winners, Margaritis Schinas, Vice-President for Promoting our European Way of Life, who is currently in charge of Culture, stated: “Each winning achievement of this year’s European Heritage Awards/Europa Nostra Awards is the result of extraordinary skills and commitment, collective and individual, spanning heritage places and traditions across Europe. By honouring these achievements, we also reiterate our firm commitment to protecting our shared cultural heritage, because it is vital for our sense of togetherness as citizens and communities of Europe.”

 

Cecilia Bartoli, the world-renowned mezzo-soprano and President of Europa Nostra, stated: “I warmly congratulate this year’s winners of the European Heritage Awards / Europa Nostra Awards on their well-deserved recognition. They are inspiring examples which truly contribute to building a more beautiful, sustainable and inclusive Europe. Their success stories demonstrate how adversity can be overcome through pooling expertise, dedication, creativity and innovation. I look forward to meeting them in person and celebrating all the winners at the European Heritage Awards Ceremony in our beloved World Heritage City of Venice.”

 

The winners will be celebrated at the European Heritage Awards Ceremony on 28 September in the Palazzo del Cinema in Venice. This prestigious event will be honoured with the participation of Cecilia Bartoli, President of Europa Nostra. Margaritis Schinas, Vice-President of the European Commission, is also expected to attend this high-level event.During the ceremony, the Grand Prix laureates and the Public Choice Award winner, chosen from among this year’s winners and entitled to receive €10,000 each, will be announced. The ceremony will be a highlight of the European Cultural Heritage Summit 2023, organised by Europa Nostra with the support of the European Commission, on 27-30 September in the World Heritage City of Venice.

Heritage supporters and enthusiasts are now encouraged to discover the winners and vote online to decide who will win the Public Choice Award 2023, entitled to receive a monetary award of €10,000.

 

From France to Armenia, from Portugal to Ukraine:

these are the winners of the European Heritage Awards / Europa Nostra Awards 2023

 

Research

 

Scientific-Archaeological Studies for the Preservation of Ererouyk, ARMENIA/FRANCE

The Early Christian and Medieval complex of Ererouyk was researched with a scientific, multidisciplinary and environmentally progressive approach between 2009 and 2021 by experts of various nationalities.

 

Proto-Industrial Architecture of the Veneto in the Age of Palladio, ITALY

This three-year study of Veneto's proto-industrial heritage is unprecedented in both Italian and European contexts. It provides insight into the history of innovation and the transfer of knowledge at a European level, focusing on the merits of hydraulic power.

 

Safeguarding of the Artisanal Fishing Technique “Arte-Xávega”, PORTUGAL

Through the transfer of knowledge and know-how, this research project showcases exemplary practices of safeguarding “Arte-Xávega”, one of the last examples of artisanal and sustainable fishing in the European Union.

 

 

Conservation & Adaptive Reuse

 

Steam Engine Brewery, Lobeč, CZECHIA

For over 15 years, the architects Jana and Pavel Prouza worked to revive this brewery with a rich history dating back to 1586. It was reopened with a mix of cultural and business activities to ensure its sustainability.

 

Friluftsskolen Open-Air School, Copenhagen, DENMARK

This masterpiece of functionalism, designed by the architect Kaj Gottlob and built in 1938, demonstrates the way in which architecture can contribute to health and well-being. Its restoration serves as a model for other schools in Europe.

 

Hôtel de la Marine, Paris, FRANCE

An extensive, high-quality project brought this mid-18th century building at the Place de la Concorde in Paris back to its original splendour, while creating a new cultural hub. The restoration is also notable for its innovative financing model.

 

Royal Gardens of Venice, ITALY

Following complex renovation works, these abandoned gardens from the Napoleonic-era have been given new life and their architectural link to St. Mark’s Square reinstated. Today, these gardens are a beautiful, ecologically sustainable oasis that can be enjoyed by everyone.

 

Museum of Urban Wooden Architecture, Vilnius, LITHUANIA

This 19th-century wooden building was restored using high-level craftsmanship and authentic techniques. It now houses a museum and community centre, serving as an example for other similar buildings in Vilnius and beyond.

 

Wit Stwosz Altarpiece in St. Mary’s Basilica, Kraków, POLAND

The altarpiece carved from 1477 to 1489 by Wit Stwosz, renowned German-born sculptor who moved from Nuremberg to Krakow, is widely regarded as a masterpiece of Gothic art. Its meticulous restoration, based on thorough research, was undertaken in situ for over 1,000 days and involved a team of top professionals from across Europe.

 

Mudéjar Ceilings of the Cathedral of Funchal, Madeira, PORTUGAL

The restoration of these rare Mudéjar style ceilings, covering 1500 m2, was carried out using the best practices in wood conservation and involved an interdisciplinary team of top professionals of various nationalities.

 

Deba Bridge, Gipuzkoa, SPAIN

The remarkable rehabilitation of this 19th-century stone bridge, an exquisite example of civil engineering, required extensive historical research into materials and forgotten techniques and benefitted from interdisciplinary technical cooperation.

 

Ruins of the Monastery of San Pedro de Eslonza, Gradefes, SPAIN

The ruins of this 16th-century monastery have undergone an intervention that included archaeological investigation, consolidation and rehabilitation for tourist visits. Its technical, economic and social sustainability is commendable.

 

 

Education, Training & Skills

 

MADE IN: Crafts and Design Narratives, AUSTRIA/CROATIA/SLOVENIA/SERBIA

This European platform brings together designers, researchers and curators, who are all dedicated to exploring heritage through contemporary production. It promotes the invaluable role of crafts in shaping local identities and ensuring the sustainability of communities.

 

ACTA VISTA, Marseille, FRANCE 

Since its creation in 2002, this association has developed training projects in heritage trades, involving 5,000 individuals marginalised from the labour market. Its innovative approach, which combines training for vulnerable citizens, social support and a cultural dimension accessible to all, is unparalleled in Europe.

 

Carpenters without Borders, Paris, FRANCE

Since 1992, Carpenters without Borders have fostered a movement of wood carpentry professionals who volunteer their expertise on an international scale. A groundbreaking project showcases their ability to reconstruct the frame of the fire-ravaged Notre-Dame Cathedral using materials and techniques reminiscent of the 13th century.

 

National Centres for Restoration of Historic Vessels, NORWAY

These centres undertake significant work to preserve the skills related to the construction and repair of historic ships, an important element of Norway’s rich maritime heritage. This initiative stands out for its comprehensive approach, creating a wholesome experience that sets an impressive example for other countries in Europe and beyond.

 

Pathfinders of the Waters, Danube Delta, ROMANIA

This project targets villages along the Danube with limited access to cultural activities, using the traditional canoe (lotca) as a means to promote the value of local heritage and the acquisition of new skills among children.

 

 

Citizens’ Engagement & Awareness-raising

 

Village Square Meer, Antwerp, BELGIUM

This remarkable citizens’ initiative has breathed new life into a historic convent in a small village by creating a new central hub for cultural activities. It is a strong example of how a heritage site can serve as a strong connecting force within a community.

 

Budapest100, HUNGARY

This annual weekend festival celebrates the built heritage of the World Heritage City of Budapest, showcasing the intrinsic value of every house. Through guided visits and engaging exhibitions, visitors and residents share stories, knowledge and experiences, fostering connections and mutual understanding. 

 

Museum of Literature Ireland (MoLI), Dublin, IRELAND

The Museum of Literature Ireland celebrates Ireland's literary heritage and inspires future generations to engage with the art of writing and reading. Its participatory approach aims to dismantle elitist perceptions of literature.

 

Open for You, ITALY

This outstanding initiative has opened over 80 heritage sites in 35 cities throughout Italy that would otherwise be closed to the public. The secret of its success lies in the strong dedication of a large network of over 1,600 volunteers.

 

ALMADA Project, Lisbon, PORTUGAL

This multidisciplinary project utilises scientific research to present the mural art of Almada Negreiros, one of Portugal's most influential artists of the 20th century, in a new light. Its public outreach to diverse communities is exemplary.

 

Via Transilvanica, ROMANIA

At 1,400 km, the Via Transilvanica is Romania’s longest hiking trail which connects as many as 12 UNESCO World Heritage sites. It serves as a vital connection between local communities and diverse facets of heritage, encompassing both built and natural heritage as well as intangible traditions. 

 

Un-archiving Post-industry, UKRAINE

This smart and multifaceted project digitally preserves endangered industrial heritage collections in the East part of Ukraine. It fosters engagement with this heritage among and between local communities in Ukraine and the United Kingdom.

 

 

Heritage Champions

 

Hambis Tsangaris, CYPRUS

Hambis Tsangaris is remarkable for his achievements in fostering connections and understanding among communities in Cyprus through his work with the intangible heritage of printmaking.

 

Sergio Ragni, ITALY

Thanks to the remarkable efforts of the musicologist Sergio Ragni, over a period of over 60 years, a wealth of knowledge about the life and cultural significance of one of Europe’s most influential composers, Gioachino Rossini, has been collected, analysed and shared with the public.

 

Cláudio Torres, PORTUGAL

For over 40 years, the archaeologist Cláudio Torres and the research centre that he created in Mértola have played a pivotal role in fostering the appreciation and conservation of Islamic heritage in Portugal.

 

Saving Ukrainian Cultural Heritage Online (SUCHO), UKRAINE/INTERNATIONAL PROJECT

In the first months of the war in Ukraine, the large network of SUCHO volunteers from across the world archived over 50TB of data from Ukrainian cultural institutions. Their rapid response is an impressive example of the power of collective action in a crisis situation.

 

 

Europa Nostra Awards 2023 for outstanding projects from the UK

 

This year, Europa Nostra Awards go to two remarkable heritage projects from a European country not taking part in the EU Creative Europe programme.

 

Cleveland Pools, Bath, UNITED KINGDOM (Conservation & Adaptive Reuse)

Driven by the local community, the restoration project of these 19th-century open-air pools used green energy and a holistic approach to reinstate the site's original function while adapting it to 21st-century standards.

 

MINIARE: The Art & Science of Manuscript Heritage, Cambridge, UNITED KINGDOM(Research)

This research project (2012-2022) revolutionised understanding of manuscript illumination across Europe’s Middle Ages. By employing non-invasive analysis and cutting-edge technology, MINIARE identified artists' materials and techniques, offering insights into cultural, political and socio-economic contexts like never before.

 

The European Heritage Awards / Europa Nostra Awards were launched by the European Commission in 2002 and have been run by Europa Nostra ever since. For 21 years, the Awards have been a key tool to recognise and promote the multiple values of cultural and natural heritage for Europe’s society, economy and environment. 

 

Scientific-Archaeological Studies for the Preservation of Ererouyk, Armenia/France

 

The Early Christian and Medieval complex of Ererouyk is an outstanding example of Armenian artistic achievements. Nevertheless, it was only recently that this enigmatic site has been researched with a scientific, multidisciplinary and environmentally progressive approach. This has created new knowledge about the Late Antique/Early Christian period in Ererouyk, through the study of the remains of its 6th-century basilica, ancient mausoleum and cemetery, ancient village and dam.

This research project was carried out between 2009 and 2021 by the Laboratory of Medieval and Modern Archaeology in the Mediterranean of Aix-en-Provence (LA3M), France, the Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography of the Armenian Academy of Sciences, and the Shirak Regional Museum in Gyumri, Armenia, alongside several experts of different nationalities. 

Annual missions lasting almost a month were carried out every autumn, complemented by a programme of analysis, elaboration and interpretation of the data collected at the associated institutions. Ererouyk was conceived as a training site for local and international students; and a full-day conference was organised each year at Aix-Marseille University to present the progress of the research to students and the public. 

Among the concrete results achieved, the researchers succeeded in dating the basilica and conducting a detailed analysis of its carved decoration. Through comparative research, the project also highlighted the particularities of Armenian Christianity and funerary customs. Also notable is the assessment of the place and role of the site of Ererouyk in the life of the region and in particular in its relationship with the city of Ani. The publication of numerous papers gained the recognition of the international scientific community and provided concrete elements for the study of the basilica, allowing for the design of a conservation project respectful of its authenticity. The results of this comprehensive research project raised the visibility of the site at a European level, contributing to its listing among the 7 Most Endangered heritage sites in Europe in 2016 by Europa Nostra and the European Investment Bank Institute.

This project serves as an outstanding example of how the collaboration between experts of different nationalities and the implementation of a rigorous historical and scientific method can provide new insights and knowledge on cultural heritage sites.

[see video]

Armenian national football team off to Cardiff for UEFA Euro 2024 qualifier against Wales

 16:23, 14 June 2023

YEREVAN, JUNE 14, ARMENPRESS. The Armenian national football team left for Cardiff on June 14, where they face a UEFA Euro-2024 qualification round group stage match against Wales on June 16, the Football Federation said in a press release.

The following players left for Cardiff:

Arsen Beglaryan – FC Urartu
Stanislav Buchnev – FC Pyunik
Ognjen Cancarevic – FC Alashkert
Andre Calisir – IF Brommapojkarna (Sweden)
Varazdat Haroyan – FC Astana (Kazakhstan)
Georgi Harutyunyan – FC Krasnodar (Russia)
Nair Tiknizyan – FC Lokomotiv Moscow (Russia)
Styopa Mkrtchyan – BKMA
David Davidyan – FC Pyunik
Kamo Hovhannisyan – FC Astana (Kazakhstan)
Zhirayr Margaryan – FC Urartu
Erik Piloyan – FC Urartu
Eduard Spertsyan – FC Krasnodar (Russia)
Hovhannes Harutyunyan – FC Pyunik
Vahan Bichakhchyan – Pogon Szczecin (Poland)
Zhirayr Shaghoyan – CSKA Sofia (Bulgaria)
Ugochukwu Iwu – FC Urartu 
Artak Dashyan – FC Pyunik 
Wbeymar Angulo – FC Alashkert
Grant Leon Ranos – Borussia Monchengladbach (Germany)
Tigran Barseghyan – FC Slovan Bratislava (Slovakia)
Artur Serobyan – FC Ararat-Armenia

Lucas Zelarayan and Norberto Briasco Balekian will join the team in Wales. 




Azerbaijan’s disinformation campaign seeks to misrepresent own provocations as Armenian aggression, warns minister

 16:55, 14 June 2023

YEREVAN, JUNE 14, ARMENPRESS. Azerbaijan’s intensified disinformation campaign seeks to misrepresent the reality and falsely accuse Armenia of aggression, Minister of Defense Suren Papikyan has warned.

“By constantly spreading disinformation over the past week, Azerbaijan is creating the foundation to be able to misrepresent its own provocations as attacks by the Armenian side,” Papikyan told lawmakers during question time in parliament.

Minister Papikyan said the Ministry of Defense of Armenia is constantly releasing reports on the border situation.

“The reasons of this all is Azerbaijan’s goal to accuse the Armenian side of seeking aggressive actions. There is no such thing, in line with all our statements, the Armenian side will continue to advance the peace agenda around the negotiation table, certainly also by defending the sovereign territory of our country,” Papikyan said.

Earlier on Wednesday, the Azerbaijani forces shot and wounded two Indian construction workers at a construction site of a steel plant in Yeraskh, a village in the Ararat Province. 

Modernization of Iran-Armenia Border Checkpoint by 2026

Financial Tribune
Iran – June 14 2023

The process of modernizing the Meghri border checkpoint on the Armenian-Iranian border will continue until 2026, the State Revenue Committee of Armenia has said, according to Sputnik Armenia.

Work on the restructuring and modernization of the customs checkpoint in Meghri has already begun. According to the committee, a modern checkpoint will be built to meet international standards, PanARMENIAN.Net reported.

"To fully ensure the work of the border checkpoint in Meghri, it is planned to build a two-story administrative building with a building area of 4,000 square meters. The border checkpoint will have buildings for a thorough check of incoming vehicles, X-rays for trucks, customs and cars and other infrastructure," the statement said.

Earlier, Rustam Badasyan, chairman of the committee, said that in 2022 it was planned to allocate 1.2 billion drams ($3.1 million) for the project, but there were delays in procedures for preparing for construction, and the project was postponed to 2023.

The customs checkpoint in Meghri is being renovated with an EU grant and a loan from the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development. Earlier, under the EU program, three border crossings on the border with Georgia were modernized – Bagratashen, Bavra and Gogavan-Privolnoe.

Ground for the new facility was broken earlier this month in a ceremony attended by Badasyan, the head of the Yerevan Office of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, George Akhalkatsi, Syunik Governor Robert Ghukasyan, representatives of international structures and other state bodies, Public Radio of Armenia reported.

The current infrastructure at the Meghri border checkpoint is outdated. Its operational, technical, engineering, environmental and safety conditions need to be improved to meet modern safety and security requirements and adhere to international border management standards.

The project aims to rebuild and modernize the road border checkpoint facilities at Meghri. The project involves demolition of outdated buildings, the construction of new modern facilities and installation of modern equipment for the performance of border, customs and other controls in line with modern standards.

Construction works will be carried out by Tana Energy Management Company, winner of an international tender. Roughton International Limited Company will carry out technical quality control of the construction works.

 

Starlink: Bringing High-Speed Internet to Armenia’s Remote Areas

TIAN SHAN NET

Starlink, the satellite internet service provided by SpaceX, is now available in Armenia. This is great news for the people living in the remote areas of the country who have been struggling with slow and unreliable internet connections for years.

Armenia is a small country located in the South Caucasus region of Eurasia. It has a population of around 3 million people, and its economy is heavily dependent on agriculture and mining. The country has a high literacy rate, and its people are known for their entrepreneurial spirit. However, the lack of high-speed internet has been a major obstacle for the country’s development.

Starlink promises to change that. The service uses a constellation of low Earth orbit satellites to provide high-speed internet to even the most remote areas of the world. The satellites are much closer to the Earth than traditional geostationary satellites, which means that the latency is much lower, and the connection is more stable.

The service is still in beta testing, but it has already attracted a lot of attention from people all over the world. The initial feedback has been overwhelmingly positive, with users reporting speeds of up to 150 Mbps. This is a significant improvement over the speeds offered by traditional internet service providers in Armenia, which are often less than 10 Mbps.

One of the main advantages of Starlink is that it can be set up quickly and easily. All you need is a Starlink kit, which includes a satellite dish, a modem, and a power supply. The dish is small and easy to install, and it can be placed on the roof of your house or in your backyard. Once the dish is set up, you just need to connect the modem to your computer or router, and you’re ready to go.

Another advantage of Starlink is that it is not affected by the terrain or the weather. Traditional internet service providers in Armenia often struggle to provide reliable service in the mountainous regions of the country, where the terrain can be challenging. Starlink, on the other hand, can provide high-speed internet to even the most remote areas, regardless of the terrain or the weather.

The cost of the service is also very competitive. The initial cost of the kit is around $500, which includes the satellite dish, the modem, and the power supply. The monthly subscription fee is around $99, which is comparable to the prices offered by traditional internet service providers in Armenia.

The availability of high-speed internet is a game-changer for Armenia. It will open up new opportunities for education, business, and communication. Students will be able to access online resources and participate in online classes. Entrepreneurs will be able to start and grow their businesses online. And families will be able to stay connected with their loved ones, no matter where they are in the world.

In conclusion, Starlink is a game-changer for Armenia. It is bringing high-speed internet to even the most remote areas of the country, and it is doing so at a competitive price. The service is easy to set up, reliable, and not affected by the terrain or the weather. This is great news for the people of Armenia, who have been struggling with slow and unreliable internet connections for years. With Starlink, they can finally join the digital age and take advantage of all the opportunities that come with it.

https://aboutxinjiang.com/starlink-in-armenia/

Sports: Wales left with plenty to prove after painful throwback defeat to Armenia [+Links]

Ben Fisher



Home loss to team ranked 97th in the world adds to poor run of form making Monday’s game in Turkey feel make-or-break

The inquest into Wales’s humbling by Armenia began in earnest on Saturday morning, a few hours before an afternoon flight to Samsun, the Turkish city on the Black Sea where suddenly it all feels rather make or break when it comes to qualifying for Euro 2024.

The grave mood in the stands at full time in Cardiff, as the remnants of a sold-out crowd wondered whether they had inadvertently been teleported back to the bruising days when Wales were nestled below Guatemala and Guyana in the Fifa rankings, married with what is now a bleak forecast.

In recent years Wales have never had it so good, but Friday provided an unwanted and brutal throwback to more testing times. The nation has simply, owing to the team’s unprecedented recent success, come to expect much better.

The last time Wales conceded more than three goals in a competitive home game a 17-year-old left-back by the name of Gareth Bale scored his first of 41 goals for his country, a stunning free-kick in a 5-1 defeat by Slovakia.

In isolation, being picked off 4-2 at home to Armenia is unquestionably one of the worst results this millennium for Wales but burrow a little deeper and the cold reality is that it had been coming. Since qualifying for the World Cup 12 months ago, via a deflected Bale free-kick, they have won one of their 11 matches.

A blinding result in Split in March, when Nathan Broadhead salvaged a 1-1 draw with Croatia on debut with Wales’s only shot on target, in the third minute of second-half stoppage time, masked a poor performance. Wales edged past Latvia a few days later and at that point all appeared dandy.

Perhaps that was what Rob Page, the Wales manager, was getting at when he said everybody was getting starry-eyed as he tried to explain the humiliating defeat. Page insists Wales did not underestimate their opponents and before the game Aaron Ramsey, the Wales captain, alluded to the goal Armenia scored in defeat to Turkey in March as evidence of how they can hurt teams.

As Wales discovered to their detriment. Ramsey spoke of a streetwise side who would likely sit in a low block and prove awkward opponents but Armenia were not plucky winners. They were strong and sharp, incisively carving Wales open time and again, and scored four fine goals.

The thing is, should anyone really have been surprised? A quick sift through Wales’s team is a revealing exercise. Of the starting lineup only Ben Davies and Harry Wilson finished the season as first-choice starters in the Premier League. The goalkeeper Danny Ward lost his place at relegated Leicester and the centre-backs Chris Mepham and Joe Rodon spent much of last season playing second fiddle at Bournemouth and Rennes, respectively.

Ethan Ampadu, fresh from suffering the third relegation of his career, as Spezia tumbled into Serie B last Sunday, was fighting a losing battle at the base of midfield alongside Ramsey, who was easily bypassed. Daniel James will be in the Championship with Leeds next year. And let’s not forget this is Page’s first senior manager role since being sacked by Northampton.

Of course, if Wales beat Turkey on Monday, the picture will not look anywhere near as bleak. Page knows Wales need a win to repair the damage. “If we win, we go back into a position of power,” said the winger David Brooks, who was given a standing ovation as he came on against Armenia for his first Wales appearance in two years after treatment for Hodgkin lymphoma.

“I think people will be starting to doubt us, but we have got to go and try and put in a performance to prove all those people wrong. We all want to get to a major tournament, so nothing has changed.”

Page maintained afterwards that this is a team in transition in the post-Bale era. That much is true. Brennan Johnson, who laid on James’s opener, is surely Wales’s most exciting talent, while the 18-year-olds Luke Harris and Jordan James, of Fulham and Birmingham, respectively, will likely be integrated in the coming months.

It is too easy to point to the absence of Bale as a factor in Wales’s return to type, not least because by the end he was in effect a mannequin. Nevertheless, Bale unmistakably carried Wales at times and came to the fore when his country needed him most. Was the harrowing Armenia episode a one-off or is this what Wales are now? Time will tell.

https://www.theguardian.com/football/2023/jun/17/wales-euro-2024-qualifying-turkey-armenia

ALSO READ OTHER REPORTS:
Wales stunned by Armenia in Euro blow – Times of India (indiatimes.com)
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/football/top-stories/wales-stunned-by-armenia-in-euro-blow/articleshow/101059111.cms?from=mdr
Wales’s embarrassing defeat by Armenia puts pressure on Rob Page (thetimes.co.uk)
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/waless-embarrassing-defeat-by-armenia-puts-pressure-on-rob-page-t59ngqs70
Wales 2-4 Armenia: Kieffer Moore sent off in chaotic Euro 2024 qualifier as Wales flounder | Football News | Sky Sports
https://www.skysports.com/football/news/19692/12902359/wales-2-4-armenia-kieffer-moore-sent-off-in-chaotic-euro-2024-qualifier-as-wales-flounder
Euro 2024 qualifying: Wales humiliated 4-2 at home by Armenia – BBC Sport
https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/65852138
Wales 2-4 Armenia: Rob Page's side slump to a shock home defeat in Euro qualifiers | Daily Mail Online
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-12204477/Wales-2-4-Armenia-Rob-Pages-slump-shock-home-defeat-Euro-qualifiers.html
Euro 2024 qualifiers: Wales stunned by Armenia as Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland both lose
https://www.standard.co.uk/sport/football/euro-2024-qualifiers-wales-republic-of-ireland-results-b1088461.html
Cymru shocked by Armenia – FAW
https://faw.cymru/news/cymru-shocked-by-armenia/
"It really shocked me," says Wales manager Robert Page after 4-2 loss to Armenia (aninews.in)
https://www.aninews.in/news/sports/football/it-really-shocked-me-says-wales-manager-robert-page-after-4-2-loss-to-armenia20230617133037/
Humiliation as Wales lose 4-2 to Armenia | ITV News Wales
https://www.itv.com/news/wales/2023-06-17/humiliation-as-wales-lose-4-2-to-armenia
Wales manager Robert Page says Euro 2024 loss to Armenia 'nowhere near' good enough – BBC Sport
https://www.bbc.com/sport/av/football/65939577
Highlights: Wales 2-4 Armenia | Highlights | European Qualifiers | UEFA.com
https://www.uefa.com/european-qualifiers/video/highlights/0282-1845f6175608-292cfa1aab70-1000–highlights-wales-2-4-armenia/
Wales 2-4 Armenia: Hosts condemned to embarrassing defeat on dark night for Rob Page
https://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/wales-armenia-final-score-report-27139076
Wales 2 Armenia 4: Rob Page's boys booed off after first Euro Qualifier home defeat for TWELVE years | The Sun
https://www.thesun.co.uk/sport/22723484/wales-2-armenia-4-rob-page-euro-qualifier/
Dirty goalkeeping keeps Armenia ahead
https://www.herald.wales/national-news/dirty-goalkeeping-keeps-armenia-ahead-moore-should-not-have-been-sent-off/
Wales 2-4 Armenia: Rob Page's side suffer a shock home defeat (msn.com)
https://www.msn.com/en-gb/sport/football/wales-2-4-armenia-rob-page-s-side-suffer-a-shock-home-defeat/ar-AA1cEN76
Euro 2024 qualifying: Armenia defeat a 'slap' Wales need, says boss Rob Page – BBC Sport
https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/65930879
Wales’ Euro 2024 qualifying defeat to Armenia a necessary ‘slap’ – boss Rob Page | The Independent
https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/armenia-wales-rob-page-turkey-latvia-b2359311.html
Alexander Peters: I want to reduce the importance of the Armenian victory? – Game News 24 (game-news24.com)
https://game-news24.com/2023/06/16/alexander-peters-i-want-to-reduce-the-importance-of-the-armenian-victory/
Watch columbus midfielder's two golazos in Armenia
https://www.socceramerica.com/publications/article/96458/watch-columbus-midfielders-two-golazos-in-armeni.html