Azerbaijani press: Pashinyan hints at returning Azerbaijani lands… through his 2018 bestseller?

9 November 2018 15:12 (UTC+04:00)

Baku, Azerbaijan, Nov. 9

By Fikret Dolukhanov – Trend:

“Reason says: the whole cannot be endangered because of the part, and, at a minimum, it is necessary to declare, loudly declare that we do not need these fields, that we are ready to return these lands for the sake of peace.”

The above line is from a translated fragment of the biographical novel of the acting Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan entitled “The Other Side of the Earth”, which became a bestseller in the country in 2018.

The excerpt was published under the same headline on the Armenian analytical portal “Voskanapat”.

Pashinyan, who became Prime Minister of Armenia as a result of the velvet revolution, who was sometimes considered a “protégé” of Levon Ter-Petrosyan, was remembered in 2015 for his claims to to return the occupied regions around Nagorno-Karabakh to Azerbaijan.

In 1997-1998, then-President of Armenia Levon Ter-Petrosyan proposed a plan to resolve the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, implying the demilitarization of the occupied territories and the return of a number of settlements to Azerbaijan.

As a result, Prime Minister Robert Kocharyan, Minister of Internal Affairs and National Security Serzh Sargsyan and Minister of Defense Vazgen Sargsyan, dissatisfied with such a plan, actually forced him to resign before the end of his Presidential tenure – February 3, 1998.

During the 2008 presidential election, Ter-Petrosyan, made an attempt to return to power, and as a result he gathered 21.5 percent of the votes and settled for the second place. Serzh Sargsyan, the protege of the incumbent President Robert Kocharyan, won the election.

The opposition, however, did not recognize the election results and accused the authorities of fraud. Thousands of people went out to the streets of Yerevan. The confrontation turned into unrest, during which 131 people were injured, eight of whom died from gunshot wounds. On the same day, Kocharyan announced the state of emergency for 20 days in Yerevan.

The mentioned political biographical novel “The Other Side of the Earth”, was published in parts in May-December 2008 in the “Haykakan Zhamanak” newspaper when Pashinyan was hiding.

The author describes in the book how he, allegedly, illegally left Armenia, since he was on the wanted list after the events of March 1, 2008. That is, the book was a direct result of the riots of 2008, when Pashinyan was still a supporter of Ter-Petrosyan. However, we assume that he still remains a supporter of Ter-Petrosyan.

As we see, Pashinyan, like Ter-Petrosyan, even then understood that the solution of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict is impossible without the return of Azerbaijani lands, about which, as it turns out, he even openly wrote.

So why did Pashinyan change his rhetoric after coming to power? Is the fact that the power struggle in the country, as the Turkish expert on the Caucasus Mehmet Fatih Oztarsu told Trend earlier, is being built around the Karabakh issue, and if someone tries to change the country’s position on this issue, then he can be dismissed from the government the next day?

As we remember, the US Ambassador Richard Mills, in an interview with the Armenian portal EVN Report, stated that Armenia would have to make compromises with Azerbaijan in order to resolve the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, and expressed hope that the transition period which Armenia had entered would lead to a discussion of the options which the country has and the compromises which the country is ready for, because what he heard before was worrisome.

The topic of returning the lands has recently been heard and is being discussed more and more often in Armenia. Perhaps, instead of engaging in populism in order to preserve power, it is worthwhile to start preparing the people for the compromises that the country will have to make anyway?

Follow the author on Twitter: @FDolukhanov


Commentary: Quantum politics and predicting the US-China rivalry

Channel News Asia, Singapore
Nov 11 2018

A paradigm shift is needed to understand modern geopolitics, says University of Hong Kong’s Andrew Sheng.

China is currently in an escalating trade war with the Trump administration (Photo: AFP/STR)

HONG KONG: US President Donald Trump’s recent United Nations address provoked a number of responses. One of the most interesting came from former physicist and current President of Armenia, Armen Sarkissian. 

In an interview with the Financial Times, Sarkissian argued that we need to think about politics like we think about “quantum behaviour”. He went on to suggest that “we are living through a dynamic process of change” and that “we have to look at our world in a completely different way”.

But what has “quantum politics” got to do with geopolitical rivalry?

The West’s underlying worldview derives from an empirical perspective of science that emerged during the scientific revolution. 

In the 18th century, leading thinkers pushed for scientific methodologies that were both rational and mechanical. They assumed the world could be observed and objectively measured independently of human sentiment.

This paradigm began to dominate Western philosophy and the human sciences. Ever since science and mathematics began being taught in schools, this classical paradigm has dominated non-Western and Western societies alike. 

It was a comforting view of the world — science could remove uncertainty in the quest for human improvement.

But when Albert Einstein’s theories of relativity emerged in the early 19th century — followed by the quantum theory of Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg’s uncertainty principles — views began to diverge as to what science was telling us. This uncertainty also spread to the social sciences.

WORLD FILLED WITH UNCERTAINTIES

Flora Lewis was the first to observe this schism in scientific thought, arguing that modern physics proves that “the world is a mass of uncertainties” where “predictions of reality must be based only on waves of probability”. 

The social sciences appeared to be offering solutions with certainty under circumstances where apparently there was none. Lewis suggests that “the quantum mechanics of politics” demands from us an understanding that flux is inevitable.

Armen Sarkissian, who was chosen by Armenia’s parliament as the country’s new president, attends a parliamentary session in Yerevan, Armenia March 2, 2018. (Photo: REUTERS/Vahram Baghdasaryan/Photolure)

When the Global Financial Crisis broke out in 2007, the British Academy admitted to the Queen of England that they failed to see the crisis coming. It was an admission that mainstream economic and political theory did not correspond with reality.

Indeed, the failure of polls to predict Brexit or Trump’s election confirms that expert paradigms are flawed. The idea that economic systems are inherently stable is being challenged. Without economic stability, political instability is a likely consequence.

So what concepts in quantum theory might help us understand international relations today? The non-classical world is one of multi-states, entanglement and relativity — all of which put uncertainty at the heart of natural and human behaviour.

Classical social science suggests that everything is well defined and either good or bad, so truth is absolute. But quantum theory suggests that multiple states can exist simultaneously, like Schrodinger’s cat, both dead and alive simultaneously. 

This leads to entanglement, where purity becomes unattainable. In economic terminology, the externalities are always non-zero.

US-CHINA RIVALRY

What relevance is this to current US–China tensions?

Henry Kissinger once said that to Americans, every foreign policy problem has a unique and elegant solution. For the Chinese, every solution brings multiple problems. Historian Wang Gungwu suggests that Americans think in terms of ideology, whereas the Chinese think in terms of systems.

With is obsession with the US–China bilateral trade deficit, the President Donald Trump thinks that any deficit is a win for China. Classical game theory suggests that, absent knowledge, the two countries will not cooperate so as to avoid costly tariffs. 

But even in situations of uncertainty, cooperation on global issues can be a win–win. Global and national political problems are more complicated than ever and classical paradigms cannot readily explain how this has come to pass.

China’s trade deficit with the US jumped almost 20% in the first quarter of the year (Photo: AFP/Johannes EISELE)

Brexit and the US–China trade war are all about disentanglement, an unravelling of systems and processes that will be extremely costly and unpredictable. 

Classical thinking suggests that the shift to unilateral decision-making and bilateralism might be a win for the United States in the short-term. But the complex long-term consequences for the global system will not come cheap.

Sarkissian’s observation suggests we need to break out of classical modes of thinking in order to understand how a complex world is affected by what is akin to “quantum behaviour”. 

Trump is hard to predict using conventional logic, but his strategies and tactics have a pattern — he uses uncertainty to disrupt opponents that presume conventional thinking.

The current trade war is more psychological than real — it will take time for the effects of higher tariffs to impact on the macro economy and consumer decisions. But the rules of psychological warfare seem to suggest that threats have zero marginal cost, with high payoff if opponents yield to threats.

Sun Zi’s classical phrase is embedded in over 3000 years of Chinese thinking — know yourself before knowing your enemy. 

There are no easy battles, only long wars and the most difficult task of all is conquering one’s self. In this, the insights of quantum theory, which have similarities with Chinese systemic thinking, might just help.

Andrew Sheng is Distinguished Fellow at the Asia Global Institute, University of Hong Kong. This commentary first appeared in East Asia Forum.


"Killing Orders": Clark University professor discusses Armenian Genocide

The Gatepost: Framingham State College
November 9, 2018 Friday
“Killing Orders”: Clark University professor discusses Armenian Genocide
 
by  Gordon Rupert
 
These writings have been discredited by the Turkish government because there is no copy of the original documents, and they argued there was never a bureaucrat named Naim Efendi. This claim was considered valid by many academics for years.
 
Akcam said Andonian moved to Paris after WWI to be part of the Armenian Tribunal in 1921, where he became the curator of a museum, in which his documents were placed and have since been lost.
 
There is still, however, one record of these documents that is known.
 
In the 1960s, an Armenian Orthodox priest by the name of Krikor Guerguerian was allowed access to the restricted section of the museum, where the documents were stored. He brought a camera hidden under his robes and recorded Andonian’s collection of documents, Akcam said.
 
This recording ended up in the hands of Guerguerian’s nephew, who moved to New York, and was kept from the public for years.
 
In 2015, Akcam gave him a call.
 
After more than 50 years, the video of these documents was released to someone who could make sense of them.
 
In the documents, Akcam found encoded messages sent within the Turkish army, talking openly about the murder and displacement of Armenians. When these were denied by the Turkish government as false codes, Akcam found the original codebooks from the years the genocide happened, several of which were released by the Turkish government, Akcam said.
 
Junior Natalie Chaprazian, an FSU student of Armenian heritage, said, “I’ve never been to something like this before where they have documentation proving it. We don’t talk about documentation in the Armenian community because we know it happened. You don’t need documentation like that. You have family that went through that. They have stories that were passed down. It’s hard to see things like, ‘Go hunt. Go kill,’ because that’s your history.”
 
Akcam said he plans to release all of the documentation he found onto the internet later this year.
 
When asked about future plans, he said, “There won’t be any other big documents or discoveries. We have more direct evidence in the Armenian Genocide case than the Holocaust. We don’t have so many direct killing orders in the Holocaust. In the Armenian case, we have several direct telegrams that include direct killing orders.”

During the February Munich Security Conference, the key topic will be the Karabakh settlement

Arminfo, Armenia
Nov 2 2018
During the February Munich Security Conference, the key topic will be the Karabakh settlement

Yerevan November 02

Tatevik Shahunyan. During the February Munich Security Conference, the key issue will be the Karabakh settlement. The President of Armenia Armen Sargsyan said this in a conversation with journalists.

He noted that the initiative to discuss the Karabakh issue at the next conference belongs to him. “This will in no way hinder the activities of the OSCE Minsk Group, but rather contribute to it,” said Sargsyan, adding that the Prime Minister of Armenia and the President of Azerbaijan will also attend the conference. According to the president, the Armenian side is the initiator in the Karabakh settlement.

“After all, it’s in Armenia’s Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan that offered to President Ilham Aliyev the agreements that provide for an armistice regime today,” Sargsyan said, adding that Armenia cannot stay away from global geopolitical processes. “At such conferences, we understand that our destiny is in our hands,” he stressed. During the conference itself, Sarkitsyan responded to the accusation of the Azerbaijani delegates that the second and third presidents of Armenia did not have the right to govern the country, since they were not its citizens: “Only the Armenian people have the right to raise questions of the legitimacy of the presidents of Armenia.” Further, Sargsyan expressed concern about the militarization of Azerbaijan. “With this in mind, it can be stated that time does not play for the benefit of the world. There is a possibility of a chain reaction. There will soon be elections in Armenia, after which a legitimate power will be fully formed in the country, people who sit at the negotiating table will be elected, everyone the hands of the people “, – said Sargsyan. Calling to listen to the will of the Artsakh people, Sargsyan thanked the OSCE Minsk Group for the peacemaking efforts. “There is no military way of the Karabakh conflict if the war resumes, everyone will suffer – – Artsakh, Armenia, Azerbaijan,” he concluded.


Azerbaijani Press: Internet freedom in Azerbaijan is deteriorating – Freedom House

Turan Information Agency, Azerbaijani Opposition Press
November 1, 2018 Thursday
Internet freedom in Azerbaijan is deteriorating - Freedom House
Baku/01.11.18/Turan: Freedom House, an international human rights
organization, published a report on the state of the world Internet
freedom in 2018 Freedom on the Net 2018. The report says that
governments around the world are stepping up control over citizen
information, using fake news to harass dissent and thus undermine
trust in the Internet and the foundations of democracy. Internet
propaganda and misinformation are increasingly poisoning the digital
realm. All this contributed in 2018 to the decline of Internet
freedom.
At the same time, it is especially noted that China applies and
transfers equipment for tracking users to the Internet to other
countries. Such technology of persecution from Beijing buy Azerbaijan
and Armenia too. The report explores the situation in 65 countries.
Estimates are given on a 100-point scale. At the same time, 0 is an
indicator of higher freedom, - 100 - the lowest freedom. In the
interval 0, the freedoms of the country are assigned, 31-60 -
partially free 61-100 - not free countries. Azerbaijan appeared on the
60th place - on the border between partially free and not free
countries. Azerbaijan is located between Cambodia (59) and Kazakhstan
(61). Azerbaijan"s neighbors Georgia and Armenia occupy 25th and 27th
places. The authors note a decrease of internet freedom in 2017-18.
The transition of Armenia from among partially free countries to the
category of free, according to the authors of the report, is connected
with the decisive role of the velvet revolution in this country. The
three most free countries were Estonia (6 points), Iceland (6 points)
and Canada (15 points). The top five free countries also include the
USA (22 points) and the United Kingdom (23). - 16D06-

EU Ambassador recommends that Armenian cheese makers bring traditional Armenian cheeses to European market

Arminfo, Armenia
Oct 31 2018
EU Ambassador recommends that Armenian cheese makers bring traditional Armenian cheeses to European market

Yerevan October 31

Alina Hovhannisyan. “In the European markets, Armenia should promote the traditional varieties of Armenian cheeses – Chanakh and Lori,” he said during a press tour in Yelpin (Vayots Dzor region), where the cooperative for the production of high-grade cheeses is located: EU Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Ambassador to Armenia Piotr Switalsky.

After tasting, the European diplomat noted that he was impressed with the taste and quality of the cheeses produced in the cooperative. At the same time, he expressed the hope that cheeses will find their consumers in the markets of the EU and EAEU countries. “Any market is good. But in the European there should be exclusively traditional Armenian cheeses, “he stressed.

Meanwhile, production today satisfies only the domestic market, and is represented on the shelves of metropolitan supermarkets. From next year, according to a preliminary agreement, the cooperative will begin to export a large batch of cheeses to the Russian Federation. “Every year, we provide about 35 tons of cheese from the produced milk with a tonnage of 250-300 tons of milk. From next year we want to increase production. In addition to Russia, we also think about deliveries to the markets of European countries, since we are in no way inferior in terms of quality indicators, “said the head of the cooperative.

To note, the cooperative was established in 2016 as part of the ENPARD program (European Neighborhood Program on Agriculture and Rural Development), which includes 18 farmers. The cooperative provided work for 7-8 people.

To recall the ENPARD program aims to assist Armenian cooperatives in the processing of agricultural products, and its implementation. The main partner of the program is the Ministry of Agriculture of Armenia. The project started in January 2015 and will end in November 2018. The ENPARD program was implemented in the Lori, Shirak, Gegharkunik, Aragatsotn, Kotayk and Vayots Dzor regions of the republic. -sh–

These are the fastest-growing destinations in Europe

Greensboro News & Record
Oct 28 2018


These are the fastest-growing destinations in Europe

  •                                                  

France, Spain, Italy and the United Kingdom may be among the world’s most frequented vacation hubs —with France taking the global crown with a staggering 86.9 million international tourist arrivals annually — but these already popular places can only stand to grow so much year over year.

This leaves such lesser known destinations as the Republic of Moldova to jump farther faster. According to new data from the UN World Tourism Organization, in 2017, for instance, French tourism grew by 5.1 percent; its landlocked competitor — nestled between Ukraine and Romania — saw a visitation spike of 19.6 percent when it welcomed 145,000 visitors last year.

“When you’re talking about these fast-growing destinations in Europe, there’s often a lack of name recognition, compared to more popular countries,” says Warren Chang, chief operating officer for bespoke travel outfitter Cox & Kings’ Americas division. “But so many of these places have robust histories and a really understated romantic feel-plus diversity of culture and beautiful nature.”

Another benefit, he says, is accessibility.

“Off-the-beaten-path travel is more comfortable in Europe, where English is more commonly spoken, and while it might take time for a place like Moldova to develop as a stand-alone destination, it’s easy for people to tack short explorations of these countries onto their existing itineraries,” Chang says.

For the well-traveled Europhile — and those whose definitions of Europe stretch beyond Western Europe to include, as UNWTO does, countries in Central Asia and the Middle East — these are the top 10 places to go next. They’re ranked by year-on-year growth.

10. Armenia — 18.65 percent year-on-year growth: Among the destinations Chang expects to surge in 2019 is Armenia; in fact, Cox & Kings is slated to debut a new itinerary pairing the country with Georgia in the next few weeks. Among the outfitters already serving the destination are Abercrombie & Kent, Ker & Downey, and TCS World Travel, who collectively tout historical riches such as Mt. Ararat (where Noah’s Ark is said to have made landfall), the charming capital of Yerevan, and-yes-its most famous cultural descendants, the Kardashians. On trips with Abercrombie & Kent, guests also get in deep with local traditions: visiting brandy distilleries, meeting carpet makers, hearing spiritual chants in ancient monasteries, and learning to make lavash (a type of local flatbread) with an Armenian family.

9. Bosnia and Herzegovina — 18.66 percent: “Croatia and Montenegro have long been popular destinations for us, but this year we’ve seen demand for experiences in Slovenia and Bosnia increase,” said Tom Marchant, co-founder of luxury travel outfit Black Tomato. As Croatia deals with extreme over-tourism (it notched a record 15 million arrivals last year), the remaining Balkan locales are emerging as a fascinating, crowd-free alternative. Bosnia and Herzegovina is leading the pack, with its 16th century mosques, Ottoman architecture, and vibrant street art scene. Many travelers take day or weekend trips to scenic Mostar-a quick way to scratch the surface-but it’s also possible to dedicate a whole vacation to this historically rich country, including the diverse capital of Sarajevo, the towering waterfalls at Kravica, and the mountain village of Lukomir, said to be the country’s most isolated enclave.

8. The Republic of Moldova — 19.6 percent: The sharp percentage growth in tourism to Moldova reflects what is, in reality, an incredibly nascent tourism scene: This little republic (population: 2.5 million) has in recent years held the title of least-visited destination in Europe. But that’s changing. Luxury group tour operator Intrepid Travel cites a cultural resurgence-marked by a burgeoning wine scene and unspoiled natural beauty-as the reason and has introduced new itineraries and more than doubled its bookings to the country this year, compared to last year. “The country has some of the best up-and-coming vineyards on the continent, including a vineyard that sits on top of 125 miles of underground cellar tunnels-the largest quality wine collection in the world,” says Darshika Jones, North American director for Intrepid Travel.

7. Azerbaijan — 20 percent: Yes, the World Tourism Organization places Azerbaijan in Central/Eastern Europe in its report. Now that that’s out of the way, here’s another surprising fact: Bookings with Intrepid Travel to visit Azerbaijan have increased by a full 322 percent. The Caspian Sea-facing capital, Baku, is a fascinating hodgepodge of old and new. Its cobbled Old Town streets are lined with market stalls and well-preserved buildings, while the Flame Towers downtown are a modern architectural marvel in the vein of the Burj Khalifa. That the city likens itself to the “new Dubai” is no accident — it’s an oil-rich, fast-growing hub at the intersection of Europe, Asia, and the Middle East. Combine a visit to the capital with some of Azerbaijan’s more remote delights, such as seeing copper artisans in Lahic or petroglyphs in Qobustan National Park.

6. Macedonia — 23.5 percent: Riding the Balkan heat wave is Macedonia, whose longtime claim to fame stems from hometown hero Alexander the Great. Like Moldova, its visitation numbers are exceedingly small — it claimed just 631,000 arrivals in 2017 — making it one of the least-discovered destinations in Europe. Few luxury outfitters plan trips here, though Cox & Kings is an exception; on an itinerary that combines Macedonia with several of its neighbors, such as Croatia and Montenegro, the operator includes places that include the 10th century Byzantine church, Sveti Naum, set high on a cliff near Lake Ohrid.

5. Iceland — 24.11 percent: Haven’t been to Iceland yet? What are you waiting for? The country has been skyrocketing to the top of bucket lists for years and has multiplied its arrivals by 450 percent since 2010. That kind of red-hot growth shows no signs of slowing down as the country ramps up its luxury infrastructure with posh hotels (some with secret VIP suites) and exclusive experiences. That’s making it a focus for Black Tomato, says Marchant. “We’re developing new, once-in-a-lifetime programs everywhere from underground hot springs to vast highland lakes and waterfalls-think meditation in glacial caves, private hot spring spas, and heli-yoga atop a volcano.”

4. Turkey — 24.14 percent: Political turmoil, followed by fast and furious rebounds, chased by economic woes have kept Turkey’s tourism industry on a rollercoaster. At the moment, it’s booming. “Turkey is Intrepid Travel’s fastest-growing destination to date in 2018,” said Intrepid Travel’s Jones. The company is adding three new itineraries for 2019 to keep up with the demand: a winter-themed trip focusing on iced lakes and snow-capped mountains, a culinary journey, and a week-long “highlights” tour for time-crunched travelers. Black Tomato’s Marchant has seen similar growth. “Enquires and bookings to Turkey in the last year have more than doubled,” he tells Bloomberg. He credits pristine beaches and new hotels, such as the Edition Bodrum, which just opened its doors in the country’s top resort town in July.

3. Israel — 24.6 percent: It may be surprising to see the World Tourism Organization categorize this Middle Eastern country as part of Europe, but anyone who’s eaten their way through Tel Aviv or Jerusalem will understand how well tiny Israel competes with its mainland continental rivals. The country’s diverse culinary traditions have become a big draw for Intrepid travelers, but other companies are putting the spotlight on Israel’s perennial appeal: its religious and historical significance. That’s what Abercrombie & Kent is focusing on in its latest small-group journeys, which focus on the dramatic landscapes and ancient towns that literally bring the Bible to life. “It’s not about what’s new in this ancient land,” says the company’s vice president of product development, Stefanie Schmudde. Inquiries from culturally curious travelers have experienced a triple-digit increase in the last year alone, she adds.

2. Georgia — 27.9 percent: You heard it here first: Georgia is next on the lips of serious globetrotters. To many industry insiders, including Marchant, this next-big-thing seemed to come out of nowhere. “Admittedly this is a country where we didn’t expect to see such a surge this year, but once you look behind the surface, it makes sense,” he says. Why? “As culinary adventures become an increasingly prevalent catalyst for travel, Georgia’s historic cuisine is offering the perfect excuse to visit this untouched corner of Europe.” Add a batch of ultra-cool hotels, bars, and restaurants in the capital of Tbilisi-take Stamba, a new Design Hotel property in an old publishing house, with a surprisingly posh, Orient Express-inspired casino-and you’ll see what all the fuss is about.

1. San Marino — 31.1 percent: If you can’t pinpoint the tiny republic of San Marino on a map, you’re probably not alone: The medieval micro-state sits in northern Italy, on a cluster of mountain peaks that lead down to the Adriatic city of Rimini. In 2017, San Marino claimed more than two visitors for each of its 33,000 residents, notching 78,000 arrivals in total. It’s not a lot, but for a microstate that’s just 24 square miles, it’s nothing to sneeze at, either.

Despite UNWTO figures, no company points to San Marino as a particularly burgeoning destination. Abercrombie & Kent, however, said it fields rare requests here, wrapping together visits to the three castles that are marvelously situated on Monte Titano. It’s especially popular with stamp and coin collectors, said Liam Dunch, the company’s product manager for Europe, since the local versions are rare and in high demand. Consider this an indicator of a slow-paced trip: here, you’ll probably spend your days — or, let’s be real, a day — looking at frescoes in the 15th century Church of San Francesco or surveying the landscape from San Marino’s funicular. Its main destination? The postal museum, of course.

168: The norms of professional ethics and copyrights are grossly violated, the architectural appearance of the buildings is being distorted (photos)

Category
Society

President of the Chamber of Architects of the Republic of Armenia
Mr. Mkrtich Minasyan

To the Chairman of the State Urban Development Committee
of the Republic of Armenia
Mr. A. Eloyan

Honorable gentlemen,

Days ago, in presence of the Presidents of France and Armenia, a project of a “reconstruction” of the Yerevan Aznavour Center was presented to the public in the mentioned center. This project has never been discussed and never agreed in any competent authority of the Republic of Armenia.

A French-Armenian architect Aris Adamian was named as the author of the project.

It was a very disturbing fact that the author of the center, honored architect of the Republic of Armenia Mr. Narek Sargsyan refused to participate to the mentioned event, who, as it turns out, by virtue of copyright didn’t gave his consent to such modifications.

This unacceptable occurrence of arbitrary modifications of the creations of Armenian architects by foreign promoters is unfortunately becoming ordinary nowadays, considering the multitude of similar examples of the past years.

The norms of professional ethics and copyrights are grossly violated, the architectural appearance of the buildings is being distorted.

Recently, with the joint efforts of the RA Government and the Union of Architects of the Republic of Armenia, the RA National Assembly adopted the RA Law on Architectural Activity, on the basis of which the Chamber of Architects of the Republic of Armenia was created with the aim of, beside other functions, protecting the rights of RA architects in Armenia.

The law also envisages the process of obtaining a corresponding license for foreign architects to operate in Armenia.

Architectural ethics are of international character and are mandatory for architects of all countries.

Considering the fact that the arbitrary modifications of the Aznavour Center without the consent of the author can become a very bad precedent for the future of the architectural works of each of us, we hereby request to take steps in order to prevent the sacrifice of yet another unique building in Yerevan as prescribed by the above-mentioned law.

We call on foreign partners to be respectful in our country and to our creative approach. We welcome the participation of our Diaspora partners in the construction processes of Armenia, the use of the foreign advanced experience through them, but only in the atmosphere of professional solidarity and mutual respect, and not at the expense of our professional dignity.

Honored architect of the Republic of Armenia Ashot Aleksanyan

Honored architect of the Republic of Armenia Hovhannes Mutafyan

Honored architect of the Republic of Armenia Levon Vardanyan

19 Oct. 2018


Alaverdi Copper Plant asks the government for support, otherwise the operation of the enterprise may be suspended

Arminfo, Armenia
Oct 13 2018
Alaverdi Copper Plant asks the government for support, otherwise the
operation of the enterprise may be suspended
Yerevan October 12
The workforce of the Alaverdi copper-smelting copper smelter launched
protest actions calling on the country's government to provide an
opportunity for the enterprise to significantly increase sulfur
dioxide emissions. Otherwise, the fines imposed on the company by
environmental supervisory authorities make the operation of the
enterprise unprofitable. The employees of the enterprise on Wednesday
passed a protest rally and even for a short time blocked the
interstate road leading to the Armenian-Georgian border.
In connection with the holidays, ArmInfo correspondent was unable to
contact the management of the Vallex industrial group, which owns the
company, however, according to the information contained in social
networks, it becomes clear that the original ultimatum to the
government is connected with the position of the State Inspectorate
for Environmental Protection, which recently fined the plant 380
million drams ($ 700 thousand) due to a serious violation of
environmental legislation, adopted in 2005. According to independent
observers, the position of the supervisory authority undoubtedly fits
into the fabric of the behavioral line governments aiming to regulate
the behavior of players in the country's mining industry, which, until
the April velvet revolution, tended to regulate some of their
"painful" issues with the state on the basis of informal agreements
that allowed to bypass certain standards in order to increase
production efficiency. Apparently, something similar happened at the
Alaverdi Combine and, according to a new approach, the company fined
the enterprise, gave it a 2-month period to comply with the emission
standard, for which the company simply was not ready.
In an interview with the Public Radio of Armenia, plant manager Lusine
Mezhlumyan recently reported that the practical impossibility of
fulfilling the requirements of environmental inspectorate requirements
brings to the agenda the issue of shutting down the plant, which
employs over 600 people. The problem is complicated by the fact that
the property complex of the enterprise is secured by a loan of $ 500
million, previously received from VTB Bank for the development of a
large Teghut copper- molybdenum deposit, the operation of which was
also stopped due to environmental problems even last year after the
suspension of co-financing by one from overseas lenders. Under these
conditions, servicing a VTB loan becomes extremely unaffordable for an
enterprise and a serious decline in the level of profitability of the
Alaverdi plant, in fact, may lead to its bankruptcy.
Experts with whom ArmInfo correspondent was able to talk, note that
the new government, despite the legitimacy of its position regarding
the inclination of mining enterprises to the need to strictly adhere
to environmental standards, cannot be cut off without thinking about
the undesirable economic, investment and social consequences. Note
that the Alamerda copper smelter was built in the 50s of the last
century. Its modernization under the modern enterprise is extremely
difficult and inefficient. One solution to the problem of processing
copper raw materials inside the country is the construction of a new
plant of average capacity, the interest to which is shown by Chinese
investors. By a decision of Deputy Prime Minister of Armenia Tigran
Avinyan of July 12 of this year, a working group was established to
provide state support to the preparatory work in the framework of the
construction program of the new copper smelting plant by Armenian Kopr
Program CJSC (ACP), also part of the VallexGroup. According to
preliminary estimates, the investment value of the enterprise will be
about $ 80 million. The group included representatives of 4 ministries
- economic development and investments, ecology, finance, as well as
energy infrastructures and natural resources. The work of the
enterprise will allow to get pure copper in Armenia, thanks to which
in the country it will be possible at least partially to restore
various related production. Note that Vallex Group (Vallex Group) was
established in 1998 and unites 20 subsidiary and affiliated companies.
Among them, Teghut CJSC, founded in May 2006, 100% of the shares of
CJSC belong to Teghut Investments Limited of Cyprus, 100% of which
voting shares in turn belong to Armenian Kopr Program CJSC, which is
fully owned by Valery Mejlumyan, and also CJSC "Base Metals",
operating the copper-gold deposit in the village of Drmbon, Martakert
region, NKR, Armenian Copper Program CJSC (ACP), operating the
Alaverdi Copper Smelter.

Revolutionary Elections?

Garen Yegparian

BY GAREN YEGPARIAN

Revolutions don’t need elections, except to consolidate and legitimize what they’ve already achieved. Once elections are being held, or even discussed, a de-revolutionizing process has already commenced.

In light of this, being questioned as to whether I’m “with or against” the revolution (referring to developments in our homeland since April) is trite and annoying but it is happening, and that seems to be because I dare address some potential pitfalls. Questioning my support for revolution is laughable, given my membership in the Armenian Revolutionary Federation and my very public history of positions taken and ideas espoused. It is especially comical when it is done from a place of assessing my support for, and agreement with, Armenia’s current leader who seems to have drunk the neo-liberal Kool-aid when it comes to economic policy. But that’s a topic for another time.

The current challenge the Republic of Armenia faces is transitioning from a kleptocratic system foisted on it as a result of the ridiculous prescriptions western “advisors” (the same neo-liberal types mentioned above) rushed to write for the countries emerging from the collapsed Soviet Union and its satellites. This abomination saw the obscene enrichment of the few and immiseration of the many, leading to the uprising of Spring, 2018.

The leaders, principally Pashinyan, of the uprising tapped into a deep font of dissatisfaction, but it was no “revolution” with all that the word connotes – years of organizing, preparation, and a guiding ideology. What started out as a tiny group of people swelled into a real popular movement that swept away the first, outermost, layer of a system built on the rot of corruption.

Naturally, that corruption was the first target of the new regime. Very public actions were taken. This built confidence and allowed the new regime time to consolidate its new-found power. The next step taken was also very clever and aptly timed – the pursuit of the culprits of March 1, 2008. This further solidified support for the regime. But none of this could be permanent without an election to bring into office, formally, the people who led the movement in the streets.

The first step was electing a new city council and mayor for Yerevan. In this case I think the new regime did better than it initially imagined. The election was belatedly and artificially labeled a “referendum” and when the new regime’s candidates garnered 81% of the vote, its leadership realized the time was ripe to strike.

Despite some agreement/arrangement/understanding among the parties in parliament (back when Pashinyan was first elected Prime Minister) that snap parliamentary elections would be called in May or June of 2019, the new regime wanted to consolidate and legitimize itself through an election immediately while its support was at its peak. This is where the heavy-handedness and public relations tone-deafness of the other three parliamentary caucuses (Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Prosperous Armenia party, Republican Party of Armenia) manifested itself. Concerned that the new regime would marshal its supporters into the streets and prevent parliament from convening, they passed legislation (as yet unsigned by the president) on October 2nd to circumvent such a possibility. Yet, instead of getting out front and explaining what they were doing and why, they tried to do it stealthily and ended up further empowering the new regime.

All hell brook loose, or so it seemed. But analyst/commentator Tatoul Hagopian/Tatul Hakobyan explained it well when he said in a recent interview that “manipulation” (of public opinion) is what defines politics. He attributed that behavior to both sides of this kerfuffle, and contended, rightly, that all this should be taken in stride. Indeed, what seemed like an explosive situation when the October 2nd legislation passed has already settled down with one party, PAP, already agreeing with Pashinyan to hold snap elections in December. Sixteen members of the RPA have also stated they support early election. The ARF has said that it, too, supports snap elections as long as certain conditions – reforms to the country’s election laws – are met.

So the whole crescendo of people being labeled anti-revolutionary over a relatively minor political conflict was ridiculous. The descent to the streets and takeover of parliament’s grounds may have re-energized Pashinyan’s activists, but unfortunately, it also opened the doors to attacks on the Republic of Armenia from other quarters.

A retired American diplomat turned lobbyist, Joseph Adam Ereli, penned an article titled “Anarchy in Armenia” for the Washington Times. While this is not the most reliable of news sources, it still has significant reach. Arming people such as Ereli with opportunities to attack Yerevan does Armenians a disservice. It’s not clear to me why he did so. He has an association with Mercury/Clark & Weinstock, a Washington D.C. lobbying firm, which was hired earlier this year by both the Turkish Embassy and Turkey-U.S. Business Council. Yet the type of attack contained in the article reeks more of Azerbaijan’s style. On the other hand, it might even have been done at the behest of Robert Kocharian, similar to the case documented by Ara Khachatourian in “Kocharian Hires Western Lobbyist Who Worked for Azeri Interests” a few weeks ago.

If we want improvements to continue to our quarter-century-old third republic’s political, and consequently economic and social life, we had better stop fetishizing events and idolizing people and stick to the hard work of making up for the missed opportunities and abuses of the last 27 years while saving and expanding the few bright lights that shone through that period of relative darkness.