Turkey still has resources to resort to deceptive maneuvering actions between Russia and the West – Turkologist

 10:19,

YEREVAN, 11 JULY, ARMENPRESS. At this moment, we are witnessing the emphatic diplomatic behavior of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan in the last years of his tenure. Turkey is either getting closer to Russia or a little closer to the West. This is also characteristic of Turkey’s comprehensive foreign policy of the last period. They conduct this policy with the intention that Ankara will get the dividends it seeks for a long time.

In an interview with ARMENPRESS, Ruben Safrastyan, Turkologist-academic, Counselor of Director of the Institute of Oriental Studies of the National Academy of Sciences of Armenia, expressed said this, referring to the changes in the relations between Turkey and the West.

NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg announced that Turkey agreed to confirm Sweden’s membership in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, and Turkish media noted that after that the Turkish government received full support from the West in lifting sanctions and liberalizing the visa regime.

“The supply of modernized American F-16 aircraft is also extremely important for Turkey. That issue was raised again two days ago during a telephone conversation with US President Joe Biden organized by Erdogan’s initiative, and probably the Turkish leader received certain promises. The financial and economic support of the West is certainly important for Turkey, especially since after the devastating earthquake, the Turkish economy and especially the financial system is in a very difficult condition,” Safrastyan said.

According to him, the situation of Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan has major role in that matter. It should not be forgotten that he received higher education and has experience in the USA and has been involved in the works carried out with NATO for many years. Fidan has a more pro-Western mentality, in contrast to Çavuşoğlu, and represents the circle of the Turkish political elite that is more pro-American.

According to Safrastyan, Ankara once again raised the issue of EU membership, especially since the process has been suspended by the EU in recent years. If Turkey supports Sweden in becoming a member of NATO, the latter has promised to support Turkey in European integration, although it is a rather difficult and long process. Regardless of everything, Erdogan is trying to turn the situation to its advantage in return for once again showing reverence to the West and realizing his long-standing goals.

Safrastyan reflected on the statement of German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, according to which Sweden’s membership in NATO cannot be connected with Turkey’s European integration, and emphasized that the EU will never allow this issue to become a subject of negotiation.

“This problem is related to fundamental phenomena. The EU has set demands for Turkey, and only after fulfilling them, the latter can become a member of the European Union, while Ankara has no intention of fulfilling those demands. The demands include the protection of human rights in that country, the repressions that still exist, therefore, at this stage, Erdogan’s purpose to join the European Union is not serious, it is just a part of a big plan. “The Turks understand that it is not possible to become EU member by non-fulfillment of demands. The contradictions are very deep,” said the Turkologist-academic.

Speaking about the Turkish mediation efforts in the Russian-Ukrainian conflict, Safrastyan said that although Turkey, violating the agreement with Moscow, returned 5 commanders of the “Azov” battalion to Ukraine with Vladimir Zelensky, who had visited Turkey, however, even that step should not be considered as a sharp turn of policy towards Russia.

“That is also calculated. Ankara and Moscow understand very well that the current level of relations is of great benefit to the parties. Turkey does not join the sanctions against Russia, taking into account the implementation of large joint projects in various areas. Even in case of demarches and tough position from Moscow, the two countries will not abandon a very high level of interaction. On the other hand, Turkey has resources to resort to deceptive maneuvering actions between Russia and the West, despite the fact that its range is relatively small. The reason is that Turkey is strategically an inseparable part of the West, an ally of the USA and a loyal member of NATO,” explained Safrastyan.

He did not exclude the point of view circulating among experts that the above-mentioned political course of Ankara with its expected new manifestations may gradually cause problems in relations with Moscow, which will have a certain impact on the situation in the South Caucasus.

“Judging from the current stage of the processes, it can be concluded that in our region there may be a certain hardening of Russia’s positions towards the Turkish-Azerbaijani duo. But this will not lead to big changes or drastic shifts in Russian policy towards Turkey. As for the Armenian-Turkish relations, Ankara definitely connects this process with the settlement of the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict and here Ankara will never change its attitude towards Armenia. If the Armenian side agrees to the maximalist demands of Azerbaijan, on the basis of which some agreement will be signed, then Turkey will take some positive steps, but not complete. Otherwise, it is not worth expecting anything from Ankara,” concluded the Turkologist.

Manvel Margaryan




EU reiterates its call for Azerbaijan to ensure the unrestricted movement of people and goods via the Lachin corridor

 15:36,

YEREVAN, JULY 12, ARMENPRESS. The European Union strongly supports the activities of the ICRC as the only major humanitarian organization present in the South Caucasus, the statement made by the EU Spokesperson on ICRC activities in Southern Caucasus says.

“The EU strongly supports the activities of the ICRC as the only major humanitarian organization present in the South Caucasus. It is providing crucial humanitarian assistance and protection to those in need, in accordance with the humanitarian principles of neutrality, independence and impartiality.

Their work along the Lachin corridor has been exclusively focused on providing the essential needs for the Armenian population in Karabakh and much needed humanitarian assistance. It is the responsibility of the Azerbaijani authorities to ensure that ICRC can continue its operations and prevent a potential humanitarian crisis.

The EU strongly supports the crucial role of the ICRC in the region, and reiterates its call for Azerbaijan to ensure the unrestricted movement of people and goods via the Lachin corridor”, the statement says.

Armenpress: UN Security Council should take urgent measures to implement the February 22 ruling of International Court of Justice

 11:49, 8 July 2023

YEREVAN, JULY 8, ARMENPRESS. Artak Beglaryan, adviser to the Minister of State of Artsakh, referred to the July 6 decision of the UN International Court of Justice regarding Armenia’s application over the installation of an Azerbaijani checkpoint in the Lachin Corridor.

“What does the July 6 decision of the UN International Court of Justice mean regarding Armenia’s application over the installation of an Azerbaijani checkpoint in the Kashatagh (Lachin) corridor?

First, the Court confirmed its decision of February 22, 2023, by which it obliged Azerbaijan to take all measures to ensure uninterrupted movement of citizens, vehicles and cargo in both directions through the Lachin Corridor. This confirmation already means the position of the court that Azerbaijan has not fulfilled that decision and is obliged to fulfill it.

Second, the Court found that there is no need to supplement the judgment of February 22, 2023. In other words, it is assumed that the court did not prefer to delve into various political and technical issues. In any case, the details of this decision will be clear when the reasons for it are published in a few days.

Thirdly, it is obvious that this decision does not mean the legitimization of the illegal Azerbaijani checkpoint, but it can also have a contradictory interpretation, as it confirms the presence of obstructed traffic. The court did not address the means by which the Azerbaijani side obstracts the traffic (checkpoint, army, concrete barriers, activists-terrorists).

It remains for the international community (first of all, the UN Security Council) to take comprehensive and urgent measures for the proper implementation of the court’s February 22 judgment, especially in the conditions of the complete suspension of humanitarian supplies from June 15”, Beglaryan wrote on Twitter.

Karekin II visits Armenian College in Kolkata, India

 12:06, 7 July 2023

YEREVAN, JULY 7, ARMENPRESS. Catholicos Karekin II of the Armenian Apostolic Church has paid a “surprise visit” to the Armenian College and Philanthropic Academy in Kolkata, India.

The Armenian College and Philanthropic Academy has been functioning for over 200 years.

During a meeting with the clergy, school managers, teachers and students, Karekin II thanked them for their dedicated work and great contributions in educating and raising the children.

The Catholicos thanked the members of the administrative board and board of trustees of the Armenian Holy Church of Nazareth, in person of Mrs. Susan Ruben and Mr. Sunil Sobti, for ensuring excellent care and attention to Armenian churches and various Armenian institutions in Kolkata. Karekin II urged the students to study well and achieve success.

Putin, Armenian premier Pashinyan discuss situation around Nagorno-Karabakh — Kremlin

 TASS 
Russia – July 5 2023
The Russian leader also “confirmed Russia’s readiness to continue providing practical assistance to facilitate the process of working out an Armenian-Azerbaijani peace agreement”

MOSCOW, July 5. /TASS/. Russian President Vladimir Putin has held a telephone conversation with Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, the Kremlin press service reported in a statement.

“The parties discussed the situation around Nagorno-Karabakh, including the issue of ensuring an unimpeded flow of traffic through the Lachin Corridor,” the statement reads.

In addition, the leaders’ conversation “emphasized the fundamental importance of consistently implementing the entire set of agreements reached by the leaders of Russia, Armenia and Azerbaijan in 2020-2022.”

Putin also “confirmed Russia’s readiness to continue providing practical assistance to facilitate the process of working out an Armenian-Azerbaijani peace agreement.”

In addition, the parties agreed to continue maintaining contact at various levels.

https://tass.com/world/1642965

​ Disney called out for glorifying genocidal killer Mustafa Kemal Ataturk



themanews.com
Greece – July 3 2023

The Armenian Genocide refers to the systematic massacre that took place between 1915 and 1923, committed by the Turkey under Kemal Ataturk

In the age of international awareness and cultural respect, a group called Disney out in an effort to stop a new series from reaching the air, citing the glorification of a “genocidal killer.”

The show in question is the forthcoming Disney Atatürk Series. It’s a historical piece slated for release on October 29, coinciding with the centennial anniversary of the Republic of Turkey. After seeing the trailer, a prominent Armenian-American committee (ANCA), called Disney out for its glorification of “a dictator and genocide killer.”

The ANCA went on to claim that “Half of Turkish Twitter is desperately denying Atatürk was a genocidal killer. The other half is joyfully celebrating that Atatürk was a genocidal killer.”

The claims that Emma Watson is reportedly cast in the film are even more alarming.

The Armenian Genocide refers to the systematic massacre that took place between 1915 and 1923, committed by the Turkey. It occurred both after and during WWI. Effective 2023, 34 countries officially recognize the genocide. Amongst those who acknowledge the genocide are the United States, Germany, France, Brazil, and Canada.

Azerbaijan’s lies exposed: Nagorno Karabakh releases documents debunking Baku’s fake news

 16:17, 1 July 2023

YEREVAN, JULY 1, ARMENPRESS. The Artsakh (Nagorno Karabakh) Human Rights Defender Gegham Stepanyan has published documents debunking the Azerbaijani claims alleging that Armenia has troops in Artsakh.

Armenia does not maintain any military presence in Nagorno Karabakh but Azerbaijan is falsely accusing it of having troops there.

The most recent false accusation happened after the June 28 Azeri attack in Nagorno Karabakh, which left four Nagorno Karabakh troops dead. Azerbaijan falsely claimed that two of the four fallen troops were members of the Armed Forces of Armenia. 

Stepanyan published documents proving that the troops were Nagorno Karabakh Defense Army servicemen, and made the following post:

“The request of the parents to transport the bodies of Samvel Torosyan and Yervand Tadevosyan, two of the four soldiers who died as a result of Azerbaijan’s aggression (օn the night of June 27-28, 2023) against Artsakh, to Armenia and bury them in Yerablur, and the circumstances of their transportation by the ICRC are used by the Azerbaijani propaganda machine to claim that Armed Forces of Armenia are allegedly deployed in Artsakh.

“With this claim, Azerbaijan is openly preparing an information ground for initiating new attacks against Artsakh, which is already being discussed in the Azerbaijani media․

“Azerbaijan’s claims are false and have nothing to do with reality. In order to prove it, with the permission of the relatives of the fallen servicemen, we are publishing the facts collected by the Human rights defender of Artsakh.

“Samvel Tigran Torosyan was born in Stepanakert, Nagorno-Karabakh Republic on December 16, 2003 (Picture 1: Samvel Torosyan’s birth certificate).

He attended Stepanakert No. 7 primary school. He continued his education in the secondary vocational educational program (college) of the Shushi Technological University with the qualification of urban cadastre (Picture 2: Samvel Torosyan’s diploma).

He was receiving higher education at the Faculty of Economics and Law of Mesrop Mashtots University in Stepanakert, majoring in information systems (Picture 3: Samvel Torosyan’s student card).

Samvel Torosyan was a citizen of the Republic of Artsakh, registered in the city of Stepanakert (Picture 4: Samvel Torosyan’s passport).

He was drafted into the army from the military commissariat of Stepanakert. The family and relatives permanently live in Stepanakert.

“Yervand Hovhannes Tadevosyan was born on May 27, 2003 in the city of Berdzor, Kashatagh region of the Nagorno Karabakh Republic (Picture 5: Yervand Tadevosyan’s birth certificate).

He attended secondary school No. 2 named after V. Zatikyan of Berdzor. He completed primary education in 2018 (Picture 6: Yervand Tadevosyan’s primary education certificate).

Yervand Tadevosyan was a citizen of the Republic of Artsakh, he was registered in the city of Berdzor (Picture 7: Yervand Tadevosyan’s passport).

He was drafted to army from the military commissariat of Kashatagh. After the 2020 war, Yervand Tadevosyan’s family, as a forcibly displaced family, found refuge in the Ararat province of the Republic of Armenia, continuing to maintain the citizenship of the Republic of Artsakh.

“To prevent possible speculations about the presented documents, we remind that the identity documents of all citizens of the Republic of Artsakh are issued by the Republic of Armenia, with the difference of their registration address. It is a well-known approach, which is used due to the non-recognition of Artsakh, so that Artsakh residents can travel and exercise their rights in other countries as well. This approach is applied to citizens of almost all unrecognized states in the world, taking into account the gaps in international law and international relations with regard to human rights protection.

“Samvel Torosyan and Yervand Tadevosyan’s parents decided to bury their children in the “Yerablur” military memorial-pantheon of the Republic of Armenia in accordance with their rights. It is noteworthy that this is not a new approach, and in previous years, many servicemen of the Artsakh Republic were also buried in Yerablur, taking into account the nationwide importance of that pantheon.

“Regarding the false claims of Azerbaijan about the military service of RA citizens (residents) in the ranks of the Artsakh Defense Army, the continuous fact-finding efforts of the Human rights defender prove that since 2021, only citizens and residents of the Republic of Artsakh perform military service in Artsakh. Hence, we draw the attention of the responsible actors of the international community to the fact that the Azerbaijani side, encouraged by the impunity for the blockade of Artsakh and its military aggressions against it, is looking for new justifications to carry out new criminal actions against the people of Artsakh.”



VIDEO: Azerbaijan Again Opens Fire On U.S. Affiliated Facility in Yeraskh

GTB Steel that operates the U.S. affiliated company targeted by Azerbaijan raised the American and Armenian flags at the construction site on June 20


Hours before the foreign ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan met Tuesday in Washington for peace talks, Azerbaijani forces continued their ongoing attacks on a U.S.-affiliated company’s construction site in Yeraskh in Armenia’s Ararat Province.

GTB Steel, the U.S. affiliated company that is constructing a steel mill in Yeraskh, released footage of Tuesday’s attack. Azerbaijani forces began firing at the construction site on June 13, when two Indian nationals working on the project were injured.

Armenia’s Defense Ministry reported that at 1:15 p.m. local time on Tuesday Azerbaijani forces opened fire at the site.

While the State Department voiced concern soon after the June 13 incident, Azerbaijani forces have continuously attacked the facility, with official Baku claiming that the project poses environmental risks to nearby Nakhichevan.

Last week, per a decision of the GTB Steel board of directors, the flags of the U.S. and Armenia were raised at the construction side, with company officials vowing to continue the working on the project.

Artsakh reports fresh ceasefire violation by Azerbaijan

Panorama
Armenia –

Artsakh’s military authorities reported a new ceasefire breach by Azerbaijani forces on Sunday and early on Monday.

“From 9:30am June 18 to 1:08am June 19, the Azerbaijani armed forces violated the ceasefire in directions of the towns of Martuni and Martakert, using small arms,” the Artsakh Defense Ministry said in a statement.

The Artsakh militray did not suffer casualties.

The ceasefire violation was reported to the command of the Russian peacekeeping contingent.

“As of 9:15am June 19, the situation on the line of contact is relatively stable,” the ministry said.

‘Nemesis’ Monument Disrupts Turkish–Armenian Normalization

June 14 2023
The Nemesis Monument (Source: Jam-news.net)

On May 3, Turkey suddenly closed its airspace to Armenian aircraft. Later, former Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu announced that Ankara had indeed closed its airspace due to the opening of the so-called “Nemesis” Monument in Yerevan (Ntv.com.tr, May 3). On April 25, with the participation of Deputy Mayor of Yerevan Tigran Avinyan, who is a member of the ruling party, and other officials, the unveiling ceremony of the monument took place in the Armenian capital (Armenpress, April 25). The memorial itself was unveiled during a period of steady normalization between Turkey and Armenia as well as peace talks between Baku and Yerevan. However, in response, the Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry and the Turkish Foreign Ministry, successively, strongly condemned the unveiling of an homage to the memory of Operation Nemesis. In both statements, it was made clear that the monument is a provocative step that is incompatible with the spirit of normalization and will in no way contribute to the efforts for establishing sustainable peace and stability in the region (Mfa.gov.az; Mfa.gov.tr, April 26). For its part, Ankara also demanded the removal of the monument and declared it would take additional measures if that did not happen (Ntv.com.tr, May 3). While it is unclear what “additional measures” means in this context, it could have been in reference to the estimated tens of thousands of Armenian citizens who work illegally in Turkey, as tourism and trade is carried out between the two countries via Georgia.

Yet, instead of taking steps to remove the monument, the Armenian authorities have attempted to avoid responsibility for the decision. Although Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan stated that the monument and its implementation may have been the wrong decision, he added that “one of the shortcomings of democracy” is that the authorities do not control everything and everyone (Armenpress, May 5). The Armenian Parliament Speaker Alen Simonyan, who was in Ankara for the Black Sea Economic Cooperation Organization meeting on the same day, argued that this decision was made by the local government and that he did not want the installation of the monument to be perceived as a display of Yerevan’s foreign policy or an unfriendly step against Turkey and Azerbaijan (Armenpress, May 5).

Some officials, on the other hand, went further and argued that this decision was a domestic issue and the right move. Security Council Secretary Armen Grigoryan, in declaring the opening of the Nemesis Monument “Armenia’s internal affair,” added that “no one has the right to interfere in this matter” (Aravot-en.am, May 9). Meanwhile, a statement by the Yerevan City Administration on May 9 insisted that the authorities have no intention of removing the memorial (Armenpress, May 9). Former Yerevan Mayor Hrachya Sargsyan, currently an advisor to Pashinyan, also defended the monument’s installation, stressing that Operation Nemesis “is a historical fact” and that Turkey “should not interfere in our internal affairs” (Panorama.am, May 10). Moreover, the Armenian diaspora and more nationalist Armenians have argued that removing the monument would be “treason.”

In September 2021, the Yerevan city government began considering the idea of building a monument to the participants in Operation Nemesis, which organized assassinations against state officials of the Azerbaijan Democratic Republic (ADR) and the Ottoman Empire who Armenia alleged were the perpetrators of what it considers to be a “genocide.” Interestingly, the decision was made only now, almost two years later, at a time when Turkish-Armenian normalization was progressing. Thus, it has created new tensions in those relations that threaten to reverse the process.

“Nemesis” was an operation created during a meeting of the Dashnaktsutyun Party in Yerevan in 1919 (JAM-news, May 9). Participants created a list of 600 individuals from the Ottoman Empire and state officials of the ADR, including Armenians from both countries, and decided to assassinate them. This decision was made on the basis that those targeted were all responsible for the “genocide” of 1915. As a result, many officials of the ADR from 1918 to 1920 and those of the Ottoman Empire from 1920 to 1922 were assassinated. These included former Azerbaijani Prime Minister Fatali Khan Khoyski; former Deputy Chairman of the Azerbaijani Parliament Hasan bey Aghayev; former Minister for Internal Affairs Behbud Khan Javanshir; former Prime Minister Nasib bey Yusifbeyli (Mfa.gov.az, April 26); former Ottoman Minister for Internal Affairs Talaat Pasha; former Prime Minister Said Halim Pasha; founder of the Ottoman intelligence agency, Teshkilati Mahsusa Bahaeddin Shakir; Trabzon Governor Jemal Azmi; and other state officials.

After Azerbaijan liberated its territories during the Second Karabakh War, the normalization process between Turkey and Armenia gained new impetus and hope grew for the opportunity to establish diplomatic relations and open borders between the two neighbors. Both sides appointed special representatives—Armenia on December 22, 2021, and Turkey on January 11, 2022—for the normalization process, and talks were officially initiated. During one meeting in July 2022, the Turkish and Armenian representatives even agreed to open borders for third-country citizens and holders of diplomatic passports (see EDM, November 2, 2022). Moreover, the dramatic earthquakes that took place in Turkey in February 2023 opened the borders between the two countries for humanitarian aid from Armenia. This created a positive atmosphere for continued normalization of relations between the two countries (see EDM, March 20). Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan also announced that the borders would be opened for third-country nationals and diplomatic passport holders during the holiday season (News.am, March 24).

However, based on the recent developments, both Turkey and Azerbaijan are worried that the emergence of the Nemesis Monument will deepen anti-Turkish and anti-Azerbaijani sentiments, as the memorial seemingly supports this mindset. One of the greatest obstacles to the normalization of relations between Armenia and Turkey and the signing of a peace agreement between Yerevan and Baku is the perpetuation of historical enmity. The Nemesis Monument serves to support the continued influence of this animosity. Such a move also provides an opportunity for third-party powers that do not want to see Armenian relations with Turkey and Azerbaijan normalized, as they believe such a process would undermine their regional influence. Therefore, such a monument serves the geopolitical aims of these powers, rather than the governments and peoples of the region.

Yet, while the Nemesis Monument threatens to disrupt normalization between Turkey and Armenia as well as peace negotiations between Baku and Yerevan, some recent developments give hope that both processes could get back on track. In a speech on May 28, Pashinyan declared that Armenians should enjoy a comfortable life “now rather than in the remote future” and that this safety and well-being will come “only if relations with neighbors [Turkey and Azerbaijan] are settled and there is peace” (Primeminister.am, May 28). Furthermore, on June 3, the Armenian premier attended the inauguration of Turkish President Tayyip Recep Erdogan for the first time in history, seemingly in a gesture of good faith in continuing the normalization process (Armenpress, June 3). Nevertheless, if events such as the opening of the Nemesis Monument continue to take place, both the normalization and peace processes will be further undermined, inhibiting any hope for sustained progress in the future.

https://jamestown.org/program/nemesis-monument-disrupts-turkish-armenian-normalization/