Armenian PM says army chief considered dismissed

Ahram Online, Egypt
March 11 2021
Xinhua , Thursday 11 Mar 2021
  – International – World – Ahram Online

Chief of the General Staff of the Armenian army Onik Gasparyan was considered as removed from office, the Armenian Prime Minister’s Office said late on Wednesday.

Gasparyan is considered dismissed because Armenian President Armen Sarkissian did neither sign his dismissal order nor did he apply to the constitutional court within the deadline prescribed by law, the office said in a statement on the official website.

Shortly after this, Gasparyan said in a statement that his dismissal is unconstitutional, and that he is filing a lawsuit to the administrative court, according to the local Armenpress.

Meanwhile, Sarkissian posted a statement on the official website, saying he has applied to the constitutional court to determine whether the Law on Military Service and Status of Servicemen is constitutional or not.

According to Armenian law, the Armenian president has three days to either approve a motion from the prime minister or return it with objections. But if the motion is sent to the president again, he has to choose to sign it or apply to the constitutional court within a certain number of days.

The statements came amid rising tension between Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and the Armenian army’s general staff and opposition parties on the resignation of the government.

Pashinyan submitted a second request to Sarkissian on Feb. 27 to seek the dismissal of Gasparyan shortly after the president refused to sign the request and said the motion to fire the military chief is unconstitutional.

On Feb. 25, Pashinyan dismissed Gasparyan and sent the motion to the president, accusing him of attempting a military coup.

Earlier that day, Gasparyan, his deputies and dozens of top military commanders had signed a statement, demanding Pashinyan and his cabinet resign. 

Government shortens VAT refund waiting cycle for businesses

Save

Share

 11:53, 11 March, 2021

YEREVAN, MARCH 11, ARMENPRESS. The Armenian government is introducing amendments to the tax code that will enable businesses to get their VAT refunds every month, instead of the currently active quarterly refunds.

The head of Armenia’s tax authority Edvard Hovhannisyan said at the Cabinet meeting that the move is aimed at enabling businesses to more periodically and quickly manage their working capital and inject it into the economy.

Editing and Translating by Stepan Kocharyan

French-Armenian MP: My thoughts are with Maral Najarian on international women’s rights day

Panorama, Armenia
March 8 2021

French-Armenian lawmaker Danièle Cazarian has extended full support to Maral Najarian, a Lebanese-Armenian being held captive by Azerbaijan, as well as other female prisoners arbitrarily detained all over the world, on International Women’s Day on March 8.

“On this international women’s rights day, my thoughts are with Iranian human rights defender Nasrin Sotoudeh imprisoned since 2018.

“My thoughts are also with all female political prisoners arbitrarily detained all over the world. One of them, Maral Najarian, has been held captive by Azerbaijan for almost four months,” the MP wrote on Facebook.

“I extend my full support to them and continue to ask on International Women’s Day for the release of Nasrin, Maral and all those women who see their freedom and basic rights violated,” she said.  

Turkish press: Human rights, mock fights and taking US seriously

U.S. President Joe Biden speaks during a meeting with Vice President Kamala Harris, Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi and the chairs of the House committees to discuss a coronavirus relief package in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., Feb. 5, 2021. (EPA Photo)

Aletter from members of the U.S. House of Representatives last week for Secretary of State Anthony Blinken demanded that President Joe Biden increase the pressure on alleged human rights abuses in Turkey.

In February last month, U.S. senators, this time in a letter to Biden, criticized Turkey’s fight against the terrorist organizations PKK/YPG and again demanded that it stop operations in Syria over the same so-called human rights rhetoric.

There are many reasons to think that these letters to the Biden administration from members of Congress are a good cop, bad cop game. In fact, they appear to be an act of consultation that seem to be a mock fight between the U.S. Congress, the Senate, the White House and the State Department.

However, every time Turkey says that a controversial issue between the two countries should be resolved through dialogue and calls on the Washington administration to “talk,” it is very doubtful that Congress will receive the opposite statement. So it is possible to say that this bad policing of Congress has given the Biden administration time and comfort in relation to Turkey.

How can it be explained that the U.S. Congress, on one hand, is trying to lecture Turkey on human rights, which played a key role in solving the murder of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi, and on the other hand, is turning its back to the facts in U.S. intelligence reports?

How can Turkey’s state, intelligence, judiciary, police and media, as well as its role and effort in shedding light on this murder, be ignored?

Although all the findings in the U.S. intelligence report indicated that Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman (MBS) was behind the Khashoggi murder, the world did not hear from Biden about a sanctions decision against him. However, perhaps one of the most inhumane murders of this century was committed against a journalist, and the U.S. Congress could not even pass or even appeal for a sanction resolution against MBS.

What about the human rights of civilians killed by the PKK terrorist organization and its Syrian branch, the YPG, who continue to slaughter innocent people in Syria? Did the U.S. Congress pay tribute to the 13 unarmed Turkish citizens the PKK massacred after holding them captive for six years? Now that a U.S. Congress that is so selective about human rights is criticizing Turkey, it brings to mind that famous Indian proverb: “’If you point a finger at someone, three fingers are pointing back at you.”

All these hypocritical stances actually allow us to understand the answer to the questions of “who, what and why” Congress puts an emphasis on human rights. If the debate were really for human rights, a strong and decisive counter-stance would be expected from the U.S. administration and Congress against terrorist organizations and states or persons using terrorist methods.

Moreover, if democracy was the real issue here, wouldn’t the United States be expected to condemn the coup attempt in Armenia? Whether or not the U.S. State Department wants Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian to be overthrown by the Armenian military, it should be supported by democratic principles and moral norms – but the U.S. has not offered such support. Instead, he declared that there were not enough conditions to describe the events in Armenia as a coup.

It is clear Washington will run with the hare and hunt with the hounds in the coming period. For instance, the initial statement of the U.S. State Department spokesperson against the Turkish citizens who were massacred by the PKK, and his following statements could be explanatory evidence of this situation. Spokesperson Ned Price hinted that they could condemn the massacre if they were certain that the PKK had killed the 13 Turkish citizens. On one hand, the U.S. government cannot be sure that the PKK/YPG has killed them, and on the other hand, he can openly say that Turkey and the U.S. share interests and signaled for cooperation in Syria where the U.S. is still a major guarantor of the PKK/YPG’s presence in there.

In addition, the same spokesperson issued a condemning statement on behalf of the U.S. government over the brutal attack by forces loyal to Bashar Assad’s regime that killed 34 Turkish soldiers in northwestern Syria’s Idlib province a year ago.

Another striking statement this week came from Blinken. In the statement, he said that using people as pawns for political purposes is unacceptable behavior, no matter what the country does.

Based on this explanation, the list of people, nonstate actors or groups that the U.S. has used as a pawn against other countries in the past is quite bulky. Turkey has a long list relating to this issue, including the leaders of the Gülenist Terror Group (FETO) and the PKK/YPG.

In this regard, Biden’s confession to supporting opposition groups in Turkey during the elections remains fresh. Based on all this, it seems necessary that future messages from Washington about human rights, the fight against terrorism, alliances, common interests and relations with Turkey should first be submitted to a polygraph.

In the coming period, we will see whether the future messages from the U.S. Congress, the White House and the State Department toward Turkey are really a difference of opinion or good police, bad police diplomacy.

PACE co-rapporteurs consider statement of Armenian Armed Forces General Staff unacceptable

Save

Share

 15:59,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 26, ARMENPRESS. PACE’s co-rapporteurs for the monitoring of Armenia, Boriana Aberg (Sweden, EPP/CD) and Kimmo Kiljunen (Finland, SOC) have expressed their concern over the ongoing developments in Armenia.

“We are extremely concerned by recent developments in Armenia. In particular, we found the statement issued yesterday by the office of the General Staff of the Armed Forces, calling for the resignation of a democratically-elected government, to be unacceptable.

We call upon all political forces and state actors to fully respect democratic principles and the Constitution of Armenia, and to take all necessary steps to immediately de-escalate the current situation,” the PACE co-rapporteurs said.

“Armenia is going through a very difficult phase in its recent history and – more than ever – needs calm, restraint, wisdom and unwavering support for democratic principles by all concerned in order to resolve the political crisis it is facing”, they added.

On February 25 the General Staff of the Armenian Forces of Armenia issued a statement, demanding the resignation of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and his Cabinet.

In his turn Pashinyan commented on the statement, calling it as a “military coup attempt”. He invited all his supporters to the Republic Square to discuss the ongoing developments.




Members of Sasna Tsrer sentenced to prison terms for 2016 Yerevan hostage crisis

Save

Share

 12:48,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 24, ARMENPRESS. The ringleaders of the 2016 Yerevan police station attack were sentenced to prison terms today by Judge Mesrop Makyan of the Yerevan Court of General Jurisdiction.

Pavel Manukyan, the leader of the group known as the Sasna Tsrer (Daredevils of Sassoun), was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment. Another member of the syndicate, Smbat Barseghyan, was sentenced to 25 years on aggravated murder charges for the killing of the on-duty police officers during the ambush. Eight others received sentences ranging from 4 to 9 years each.

Two years after they ambushed the police station, the Sasna Tsrer became a political party and unsucessfully ran for parliament amid their ongoing trial. 

Editing and Translating by Stepan Kocharyan

COVID-19: Armenia reports 273 new cases over past day

 11:07,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 24, ARMENPRESS. 273 new cases of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) have been confirmed in Armenia in the past one day, bringing the total number of confirmed cases to 170,945, the National Center for Disease Control and Prevention said today.

188 patients have recovered in one day. The total number of recoveries has reached 162,517.

4 patients have died, raising the death toll to 3175.

2993 tests were conducted in the past one day.

The number of active cases is 4445.

The number of patients who had coronavirus but died from other disease has reached 808 (2 new such cases).

Editing and Translating by Aneta Harutyunyan

RFE/RL Armenian Report – 02/22/2021

                                        Monday, 
Opposition Leader Under Investigation
        • Artak Khulian
Armenia -- Vazgen Manukian (C) and other leaders of the opposition Homeland 
Salvation Movement talk during a rally at Liberty Square, Yerevan, February 20, 
2021.
Police launched criminal proceedings against a veteran Armenian politician on 
Monday after he said that opposition forces trying to topple Prime Minister 
Nikol Pashinian must be ready to stage an uprising.
Vazgen Manukian made the statement in a speech delivered at a weekend rally held 
by the Homeland Salvation Movement, an alliance of more than a dozen opposition 
parties.
“At any moment -- it could be today, one week later or ten days later -- we must 
be ready for revolting and taking power at lightning speed,” said Manukian.
He described that as “Plan B” of the opposition campaign for Pashinian’s 
resignation involving peaceful protests. “We will follow Plan A but must always 
be ready for Plan B,” said the 75-year-old politician whom the opposition 
alliance wants to head an interim government to be formed after Pashinian’s 
resignation.
A spokeswoman for Prosecutor-General Artur Davtian said that the Armenian police 
launched a criminal investigation into public calls for a violent overthrow of 
the government. He told RFE/RL’s Armenian Service that the criminal case has 
been sent to the Investigative Committee for further inquiry.
The law-enforcement authorities did not say whether Manukian will be summoned 
for questioning.
Manukian already floated the idea of an “uprising” when he met with opposition 
supporters late last month. His calls have not been officially endorsed by the 
Homeland Salvation Movement.
The alliance rallied thousands of supporters in Yerevan’s Liberty Square on 
Saturday in what its coordinator, Ishkhan Saghatelian, described as a “new 
start” of its drive to oust Pashinian. Saghatelian said the opposition forces 
will stage “nonstop” street protests in the coming days.
On Monday evening, a smaller crowd of opposition supporters marched to downtown 
Yerevan from the city’s northern Arabkir district. Opposition leaders addressed 
the protesters after blocking a key street intersection in the city center. They 
condemned the criminal case opened against Manukian.
“We want to save the Armenian nation and this state,” declared Manukian. He 
scoffed at the authorities’ reaction to his weekend statement, saying that 
“government buildings will fall into our hands like ripe pears.”
Armenian Government Critics Prosecuted Over ‘Fake’ Facebook Page
        • Naira Bulghadarian
        • Artak Khulian
Armenia - Karen Bekarian (L) and Ara Saghatelian.
Four anti-government activists were arrested and indicted over the weekend for 
allegedly creating a social media account that regularly spreads offensive 
comments about Armenia’s leadership.
Two of them were set free on Sunday and Monday in accordance with court orders.
The National Security Service (NSS) charged Ara Saghatelian, a former chief of 
the Armenian parliament staff, Karen Bekarian, a veteran pundit and former 
lawmaker, and two other men with calling for violence and criticizing government 
actions in breach of martial law declared during the autumn war in 
Nagorno-Karabakh.
In a statement, the NSS claimed that the “group” led by Saghatelian did that 
through a Facebook page opened in the name of a certain “Gagik Soghomonyan.” It 
cited in particular the “fake” Facebook user’s abusive statuses blaming Prime 
Minister Nikol Pashinian for Armenia’s defeat in the war, branding him a 
“traitor” and insulting his supporters.
The Facebook page continued to be updated after the arrests.
All four suspects denied any connection with “Gagik Soghomonyan.” Lawyers 
representing them dismissed the accusations as politically motivated.
A Yerevan court sanctioned on Sunday the two-month pre-trial arrest of 
Saghatelian, who had also run a government-funded public relations agency during 
former President Serzh Sarkisian’s rule. His lawyer said he will appeal against 
the decision.
Another, little-known suspect, Aram Sargsian, was also remanded in custody.
At the same time the court ordered Bekarian and the fourth suspect, Mher 
Avagian, released from jail. Avagian heads a non-governmental organization 
called the International Center for the Development of Parliamentarianism.
Bekarian described the criminal case as “political persecution” when he spoke to 
reporters following his release on Monday.
“When you can’t understand the essence of the case, can’t understand what is 
being prosecuted, when you see no logic [behind it] you quickly realize that the 
[investigators’] motive is completely different,” he said.
Bekarian used to represent Sarkisian’s Republican Party (HHK) in Armenia’s 
former parliament. He is a co-founder of the Qaryak Media company comprising a 
TV channel, a radio station and an online news website. All three media outlets 
are highly critical of the current government.
Representatives of the HHK and other opposition groups strongly condemned the 
arrests.
Yerevan Sees Stronger Russian Military Presence In Armenia
Armenia -- Russian and Armenian troops hold joint military exercises at the 
Alagyaz shooting range, September 24, 2020.
Russia is helping Armenia modernize its armed forces after the recent war in 
Nagorno-Karabakh and will also expand Russian military presence in the South 
Caucasus state, according to Defense Minister Vagharshak Harutiunian.
“The issue of expanding and reinforcing the Russian military base in the 
Republic of Armenia has always been on the agenda and the Armenian side has 
always been interested in that,” Harutiunian told the RIA Novosti news agency in 
an interview published on Monday.
“Of course, the leadership of Russia’s Defense Ministry has taken into account 
existing military-political realities in the region and taken right steps 
towards strengthening and rearming the base, and I’m sure that this is going to 
be a long-term process,” he said without elaborating.
Harutiunian stressed that there is “no need” to open a second Russian base in 
Armenia. “It’s probably more correct to speak about the possibility of a 
redeployment of a detachment of the [existing] Russian base, given its 
expansion, to Armenia’s eastern direction,” he said, adding that Moscow and 
Yerevan are already working on that.
Harutiunian referred to Armenia’s Syunik province bordering districts southwest 
of Karabakh which were retaken by Azerbaijan during and after the six-week war 
stopped by a Russian-brokered ceasefire on November 10. Russia deployed soldiers 
and border guards to the region to help the Armenian military defend it against 
possible Azerbaijani attacks.
Yerevan announced plans to further deepen Russian-Armenian military ties shortly 
after the war. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian stated on New Year’s Eve that his 
country now needs “new security guarantees.” Pashinian reaffirmed those plans at 
a January 11 meeting in Moscow with Russian President Vladimir Putin.
Later in January, a delegation led by Colonel-General Sergei Istrakov, the 
deputy chief of the Russian military’s General Staff, visited Yerevan for nearly 
weeklong negotiations with the Armenian army’s top brass.
Harutiunian told RIA Novosti that the talks were aimed at “assisting us in the 
reform and modernization of Armenia’s armed forces.” The two sides worked out 
concrete “recommendations” on how to modernize the Armenian army in the current 
circumstances, he said.
“A very serious emphasis was put on the military-technical component of the 
matter,” the minister added in reference to arms acquisitions.
Russian military officials are thus already involved in Armenian defense reforms 
in “in the most direct way,” he said.
Armenia has long received Russian weapons at knockdown prices and even for free 
thanks to its bilateral defense agreements with Russia and membership in the 
Russian-led Collective Security Treaty Organization.
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2021 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

RFE/RL Armenian Report – 02/20/2021

                                        Saturday, 
Armenian Opposition Resumes Anti-Government Protests
        • Artak Khulian
Armenia -- Opposition supporters demonstrate in Yerevan to demand Prime Minister 
Nikol Pashinian's resignation, February 2021.
Traffic was brought to a standstill in much of central Yerevan on Saturday as an 
alliance of more than a dozen Armenian opposition parties resumed street 
protests aimed at forcing Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian to resign.
The Homeland Salvation Movement alliance rallied several thousand supporters in 
the city’s Liberty Square in what its coordinator, Ishkhan Saghatelian, 
described as a “new start of our movement” sparked by the autumn war with 
Azerbaijan.
“As long as Nikol [Pashinian] is in power there will be no stability, peace and 
calm in our country,” Saghatelian told the crowd that gathered in the square 
amid a heavy snowfall. The opposition forces will continue “nonstop” civil 
disobedience actions in the days ahead, he said.
At the organizers’ urging, the protesters split and marched in four different 
directions after the rally, chanting “Armenia without Nikol!” and blocking major 
street intersections in the city center. Riot police did not attempt to disperse 
them and guarded key government buildings instead.
The opposition alliance blames Pashinian for Armenia’s defeat in the six-week 
war in Nagorno-Karabakh stopped by a Russian-brokered ceasefire on November 10. 
It staged a series of demonstrations later in November and December in a bid to 
force him to hand over power to an interim government.
Armenia -- The opposition Homeland Salvation Movement holds a rally at Liberty 
Square in Yerevan, .
Those protests did not attract large crowds, leading Pashinian to insist that he 
still has a popular mandate to govern the country.
The prime minister also expressed readiness on December 25 to hold snap 
parliamentary elections to end the political crisis in the country. Opposition 
leaders continued to insist on his resignation.
The ruling My Step bloc pointed to the opposition stance when it stated on 
February 7 that Pashinian and his allies see no need to dissolve the current 
parliament. It also claimed that most Armenians do not want snap elections. The 
Homeland Salvation Movement announced afterwards its decision to resume 
anti-government rallies.
“As long as there are upheavals there will be no development in our country. If 
they don’t resign things will get even worse,” Gagik Tsarukian, the leader of 
the movement’s largest party, Prosperous Armenia, said in a speech delivered 
during the Liberty Square rally.
“Armenia must boil. There must be daily rallies. The city must be paralyzed,” 
said Vazgen Manukian, another opposition leader whom the alliance wants to take 
over as a caretaker prime minister after Pashinian’s resignation.
Armenia -- Prosperous Armenia Party leader Gagik Tsarukian speaks at an 
opposition rally in Yerevan, .
Manukian also declared that the opposition should be prepared to mount an 
“uprising” if it fails to topple Pashinian with conventional street protests. 
“We will follow Plan A but must always be ready for Plan B,” he said.
Saghatelian, who is affiliated with the Armenian Revolutionary Federation 
(Dashnaktsutyun), backed the idea when he spoke with journalists after the 
rally. He said Armenians have a right to revolt against “this government of 
evil.” He stressed at the same time they must be patient and ready for a 
prolonged struggle against Pashinian’s administration.
While demanding Pashinian’s resignation, Tsarukian and another opposition 
leader, former National Security Service Director Artur Vanetsian, again made 
clear that their parties would participate in possible fresh elections organized 
by the current authorities. Other alliance leaders, notably Manukian, believe 
the opposition should boycott such a vote.
Saturday’s rally was timed to coincide with the 33rd anniversary of the start of 
a popular movement for Karabakh’s unification with Armenia.
Pashinian issued a statement on the anniversary. “I am sure that, like many 
peoples who have faced serious problems throughout their history, the Armenian 
people will soon heal the wounds of the past war and take even more decisive and 
firm steps into the future,” he said.
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2021 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

CivilNet: Syunik: The Reality on the Ground

CIVILNET.AM

06:18

[OPINION]

By Gevorg Tosunyan

It’s impossible to get a full picture of what’s taking place in Syunik from Yerevan or from any other city․ You have to be on the ground, climb the military posts, visit the villages, and talk to the people. While on a reporting project, I traveled the entire length of Armenia’s southernmost Syunik Province, from Goris to Meghri. With Azerbaijan now on the other side, this is the reality on the ground. 

Russian border guards in Syunik

We were interviewing a volunteer serviceman in a military post in one of the villages in Syunik, near the town of Kapan, when we heard shots being fired in the distance. We wrapped up the interview, and the servicemann called the commander to ask which fired the weapon. The commander responds that it didn’t come from an Armenian position. So it was the Azerbaijanis.

“The Russians will get unsettled now. They want to know who did it. They don’t allow a single shot to be fired. Even firing drills are not allowed,” the serviceman tells us.

On our way back to Kapan from the military post, we noticed a Russian border guard speeding to the frontline.

Away from this region, the general public seems to have the impression that the Russian border guards are only stationed on the Shurnukh road, which in some places passes through the territories handed over to Azerbaijan. The reality is that Russian border guards are roaming Syunik’s entire frontline. At times, the Russians find out about certain tensions and respond even before the Armenian or Azerbaijani armies.

The eight kilometers of the Chakaten-Kapan road and most of the Shurnukh-Vorotan road pass through the territory handed over to Azerbaijan. Azerbaijanis have placed the now famous “Welcome to Azerbaijan” sign on those sections of the road. We are told that a few days ago, some people from nearby villages shot at the sign, and in response, the Azerbaijani army blocked the road. The situation was resolved with Russian mediation. Since that day, a Russian border guard vehicle has been parked in front of the sign day and night.

The military posts

Earlier in February, the Armenian border guards announced that any journalist wishing to travel to and film in Syunik must obtain permission from the National Security Service. So why doesn’t the government want journalists to go near military positions and speak with servicemen? I found the answer after visiting more than 20 military posts near the frontline. I saw Armenian volunteers and soldiers who with their own means are creating living and bathing conditions for themselves on the mountains. Meanwhile, the opposing Azerbaijanis have and continue to establish well-built tent settlements.

Azerbaijanis and Armenians deployed to this area at the same time, but the opponent was more prepared, at least that’s how it looks from Syunik.

Armenian volunteers and servicemen in the military positions have poor living conditions. But no matter how unpleasant, the volunteers don’t even consider leaving. They say that if they leave, the Azerbaijanis will move forward and position themselves in their place. So the volunteers stay and wait for the army to replace them. The Armenian army is in the process of setting up official military posts and deploying soldiers to the entire frontline of Syunik.

There won’t be any official news about this situation. But now, more than ever, we must be honest, raise the issues and find solutions.

Don’t underestimate the opponent and don’t overestimate us

I am from the generation that was fed a tale in which the Armenian soldier is smart and the Azerbaijani soldier is cowardly and ignorant. This short-sighted approach was one of the factors that led to our defeat.

After spending just a few days in Syunik, I was convinced that the enemy knows how to make us anxious, how to remind us of our defeat. At the moment, this is not done with weapons but with ordinary psychological tricks. The “Welcome to Azerbaijan” sign on the road is an example.

Most of the Vorotan road is now under Azerbaijani control. Once you exit that section, on the left side of the road you see Russian and Azerbaijani soldiers. Azerbaijanis have placed a fence on their side, and their flag accompanied by a soldier with a gun is always visible to both passing and arriving vehicles.

Azerbaijanis have also set up large white tents in their positions, at least four in each. Three out of four might be empty, but they try to give the impression that the area is controlled by a lot more of them than there really are.

For the dreamers

From Meghri, a southern town in Syunik near the border with Iran, we decided to return to Yerevan not via the main road, but by the secondary one, which passes through Shvanidzor, Tsavov, and Chakaten. At the foot of one of the mountains, there is a small village, or rather a collection of homes․ There are about 50 houses and churches — all abandoned, destroyed or half-destroyed. This village is not even on the map, but it is an important reminder for everyone who passes by it that we are indifferent towards our homeland. 

The villages near Kapan, especially the communities closest to Karabakh, are half-ruined and abandoned, while the natural beauty remains indescribable.

When I am told that we will bring back Kars, Ardahan, and the rest of Artsakh, these abandoned villages come to my mind. At times, it seems that those who dream of an Armenia from sea to sea cherish that dream more than they cherish what we have now.