How did the first meeting between the special envoys of Armenia and Turkey end?

Vetsnik Kavkaza
Jan 16 2022
 16 Jan in 2:00  Robert Gazaryan, exclusively for Vestnik Kavkaza

On January 14, the first meeting of representatives of Armenian and Turkish diplomacy in many years was held in the Russian capital. The readiness of Armenia and Turkey to work on the normalization of their relations was welcomed in Moscow, Brussels, and Baku.

The meeting between the special representatives of Armenia and Turkey, Ruben Rubinyan and Serdar Kılıç, on the issues of normalization of bilateral relations was preceded by diplomatic preparations, which were actively promoted by Russian diplomacy. As a result of the one and a half hour meeting, the foreign ministries of the three countries published brief conclusions.

Although the Armenian Foreign Ministry expects to gradually establish diplomatic relations between the two countries without any preconditions, the mood of the Armenian side on the eve of the meeting was emphatically skeptical. Foreign Ministry spokesman Vahan Hunanyan expressed hope for the effectiveness of the upcoming talks, but Yerevan has no illusions that the Armenian-Turkish differences will be resolved by the results of a diplomatic meeting alone. Perhaps the skepticism is explained by the choice of the Turkish side to appoint 63-year-old Serdar Kılıç, the former Turkish ambassador to the United States, who is known as one of the most active opponents of the policy of Armenian lobbyists in the US Congress, as a special representative. 30-year-old Ruben Rubinyan, a young diplomat, a member of the “Civil Contract”, for whom the meeting became a kind of baptism of fire, went from Yerevan to Moscow. Perhaps the Armenian side thus unwittingly emphasized the technical nature of the negotiations, allowing critics of the ruling political elite to assume that all significant issues will either be or have already been secretly settled through alternative channels of communication.

Now Ankara is making the most cautious steps towards Yerevan, not questioning the effectiveness of the Russian peacekeeping policy in the region, but at the same time, trying to influence the Armenian foreign policy doctrine. Turkey initiated the reset of the Armenian-Turkish talks. At the same time, the Armenian government is slowly trying to prepare the public for the opening of borders in Turkey. Many understand that the normalization of relations will benefit landlocked Armenia, both economically and politically.

It is also obvious that with the liberation of Karabakh and the reintegration of this region into Azerbaijan, a new page in history has been opened. However, the format of the last meeting does not affect the acceleration of the process of delimitation of the Armenian-Azerbaijani border: the special representatives don’t have special political levers capable of significantly influencing this process. At the same time, in general, there is no need for anyone outside of Azerbaijan to supervise the Zangezur corridor project or put pressure on the Armenian leadership, since an agreement in principle on unblocking regional transport links has been reached. The atmosphere accompanying the signing of the document will allow Ankara to offer Yerevan to conclude a similar agreement, which will remove the remaining questions about any territorial claims from Armenia to Turkey.

One way or another, the negotiations that took place were predictably declarative. The published the Turkish and Armenian Foreign Ministries statements’ texts are almost identical. It is still unknown when and where the next meeting will be held. It is possible that the intensity of the post-war settlement process will affect the timing of its implementation.

Armenian peacekeepers return from Kazakhstan

Save

Share

 21:04,

YEREVAN, JANUARY 14, ARMENPRESS.  The Armenian unit that completed its mission in the CSTO Collective Peacekeeping Forces in the Republic of Kazakhstan returned to Armenia on January 14, ARMENPRESS was informed from the Ministry of Defense.

100 servicemen of the Armenian Armed Forces were sent to Kazakhstan on January 7 as part of the CSTO peacekeeping force to carry out protection of strategic buildings and infrastructure.




Architects Unveil Vision For Self-Sufficient Valley In Armenia

Yahoo! UK
Jan 12 2022
Wed, , 7:02 pm·2-min read

Netherlands-based architecture firm MVRDV have unveiled their vision for a self-sufficient valley in Armenia.

MVRDV was commissioned by the Armenian non-profit organisation DAR Foundation for Regional Development and Competitiveness to develop a design that will make the 34,000-hectare area more sustainable and ecologically diverse.

In the Gagarin Valley, 10,000 plant species will soon flourish on as many plots. With the help of innovative facilities and future-proof housing that will add 12,000 new housing units, the valley will become an ideal base for sustainable agriculture and ecotourism and welcome a new generation of residents.

Armenia’s Gagarin Valley is located near Lake Sevan, the largest lake in the Caucasus and only 50 kilometres from the capital Yerevan. Surrounded by mountains, roughly 11,000 inhabitants live in several villages spread throughout the valley.

MVRDV founding partner Winy Maas: “The area is named after Yuri Gagarin, who was the first human to orbit the earth; he saw the planet’s vulnerability, a house in need of extra care, as many other astronauts have since stressed. I share that concern: stimulating biodiversity, improving water management and the ecosystem is of great importance for the future of the Gagarin Valley and the world.”

The landscape consists of a patchwork of different pieces of land, of which the local community owns about one third. Commissioned by the DAR Foundation for Regional Development and Competitiveness, MVRDV designed a vision for the area in which the potential of the valley is optimised and various facilities are added. The ambition, which will be realised in consultation with local parties, is to turn the valley into a versatile and future-proof landscape that is suitable for sustainable agriculture on various scales.

Maas adds: “The valley can be seen as a series of test fields for the 10,000 species that will soon flourish there, an enrichment that will give the area the appearance of a garden of Eden.”

It is hoped Gagarin Valley must become a more attractive place to live in, as well as an area for ecotourism and recreation, serving as a destination for people to walk, hike, cycle, and ride horses. By 2026, the country aims to attract some 2.5 million tourists a year, to which the transformed Gagarin Valley will make a significant contribution.

https://uk.sports.yahoo.com/news/architects-unveil-vision-self-sufficient-170232063.html 

More at 

Armenian FM informs US Assistant Secretary of State about ceasefire violations by Azerbaijan

Armenian FM informs US Assistant Secretary of State about ceasefire violations by Azerbaijan

Save

Share

 18:52,

YEREVAN, JANUARY 11, ARMENPRESS. Foreign Minister of Armenia Ararat Mirzoyan held a phone talk with Karen Donfried is the Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs. During the conversation initiated by the American side the sides congratulated each other on the occasion of the 30th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between the two countries and expressed satisfaction over the dynamics of the development of US-Armenia dialogue, which is based on common values: democracy, rule of law, protection of human rights.

As ARMENPRESS was informed from the MFA Armenia, the sides emphasized the importance of the peaceful settlement of Nagorno Karabakh conflict under the mandate of the OSCE Minsk Group Co-chairs, and the necessity to fully restore works in this format. Humanitarian issues that need to be addressed urgently were addressed. Minister Mirzoyan highlighted the statement of the Bureau of European and Eurasian Affairs on the release of prisoners of war, clarification of the fate of the missing, exchange of remains.

Ararat Mirzoyan informed about the recent violations of the ceasefire regime by the Azerbaijani armed forces and highlighted the steps to defuse the situation.

The interlocutors touched upon the process of dialogue between Armenia and Turkey.

The situation in Kazakhstan was also discussed during the telephone conversation. Minister Mirzoyan presented the position of the Armenian side on the issue.

The parties touched upon other issues of regional and international security.

Armenia MP: Turkey, Azerbaijan’s regional calculations have mixed up

 NEWS.am 
Armenia – Jan 10 2022

The events taking place in Kazakhstan are presented under a rather noteworthy light in the Azerbaijani and Turkish press. Tigran Abrahamyan, an MP from the opposition “With Honor” Faction in the National Assembly of Armenia and a security expert, wrote this on Facebook. He added as follows:

“If in the first days of the Kazakhstan crisis mostly ordinary news was given in Azerbaijan, then after the transfer of the CSTO rapid reaction forces to Kazakhstan, the Azerbaijani websites and Telegram channels, which are obviously under state control, have launched a not only anti-Russian campaign, but also against the Kazakh authorities.

The regional calculations of Turkey and Azerbaijan have mixed up, and they, forgetting about Kazakhstan which has close, multilateral, deep relations with them, also target Kazakhstan, with various anti-propaganda doses.

The signals coming from the EU, the US, and NATO have also undergone some changes, on whose basis—in the visible part—is the issue of the deployment of CSTO forces in Kazakhstan, engagement in the ongoing processes, and long-term stay.

However, it is clear that in reality the processes are much deeper, and there is a matter of control over the zones of influence and important communications.

Now it is already clear that after the events taking place in Kazakhstan, the forces manifesting activeness in the Eurasian region will make revisions in their policy, and from now on the processes will proceed under a different logic.”

Turkish press: Daesh, Gülenists behind riot in Kazakhstan: Former Russian MP Balbek

Riot police officers block a street during a protest rally over a hike in energy prices in Almaty, Kazakhstan, Jan. 5, 2022. (EPA Photo)

Members of Daesh and Gülenist terrorist groups are behind the ongoing riots in Kazakhstan, a former member of the Russia’s State Duma said in a statement late Thursday.

Ruslan Balbek, who is also the former deputy prime minister of the internationally unrecognized administration of Crimea, told Russia’s state-run Ria Novosti that the “hands of ISIS and Gülenists are visible” in the protests, he said, using an alternate acronym for Daesh.

Recalling that Gülenist Terror Group (FETÖ) was behind the July 15 coup attempt in Turkey, Balbek claimed that they are also at play in the Kazakh riots.

“The hands of ISIS are visible in organizing riots on the territory of Kazakhstan,” he said.

“It is in their style – brutal killings and absurd demands,” Balbek added.

“But those Kazakhs, who were trained in Turkey at the educational institutions of Fetullah Gülen, the organizer of the coup attempt in Ankara, are at the helm,” he said, referring to the schools – which are now under Turkish government control – formerly run by the Gülenists.

Protesters “picked up an ideological virus” from Fetullah Gülen, the leader of the Gülenist cult, Balbek concluded.

Kazakhstan’s armed forces have been called in to restore order and break up riots that seem to have grown into general revolt, President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev said earlier on Thursday.

“Terrorist gangs” were engaged in a fight with paratroopers in Almaty, he said, adding that this is “not a threat, but an undermining of the integrity of the state.”

A Russia-led military alliance of six countries, Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), said Thursday that it will dispatch peacekeeping forces to Kazakhstan after the country’s president asked for help in controlling protests that escalated into violence, including government buildings being seized and set alight. In a Facebook post, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian confirmed that the CSTO will send peacekeepers to Kazakhstan at the country’s request.

A day after the pledge, Armenia sent some 70 soldiers to Kazakhstan as part of the contingent. According to Sputnik Armenia, the troops are expected to ensure the protection of objects of strategic importance.

Ershan Babakumarov, the deputy mayor of Almaty, reported that an occupation of the city’s airport had ended. Multiple airlines had canceled flights to the city after people occupied it on Wednesday.

Coronavirus: 29 new cases, 6 deaths in Armenia

Save

Share

 11:17, 3 January, 2022

YEREVAN, JANUARY 3, ARMENPRESS. 29 new cases of COVID-19 were confirmed in the last 24 hours, bringing the cumulative total number of confirmed cases to 345,036, the Armenian Ministry of Healthcare said on January 3.

2840 tests were administered (total 2,577,537).

140 patients recovered (total 331,998).

6 people died, bringing the death toll to 7,983.

As of January 3, the number of active cases stood at 3,546.

Putin, Erdogan discuss boosting bilateral ties

India – Jan 3 2022

SNS | New Delhi | 

Russian President Vladimir Putin and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Sunday discussed ways to enhance bilateral relations and exchanged views on regional developments, Turkey’s presidency said.

They discussed “steps to improve Turkey-Russia relations,” said the statement, noting that Erdogan reiterated his determination to advance the cooperation between the two countries in all fields, Xinhua news agency reported.

The two leaders evaluated regional issues and international developments, especially in the Caucasus, Syria, and Libya, it added.

Tensions between Ankara and Moscow heightened recently over Turkey’s sales of armed drones to Ukraine. Russia is angered over Ukrainian forces using Turkish-made Bayraktar drones in their conflict in the Donbass region.

Russia and Turkey jointly operate an observation centre in Nagorno-Karabakh to ensure the ceasefire is maintained between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

(With IANS inputs)

https://www.thestatesman.com/world/putin-erdogan-discuss-boosting-bilateral-ties-1503035805.html

Armenia 2nd President: These authorities will ‘throw’ Karabakh issue into Russia’s ‘pockets’

 NEWS.am 
Dec 27 2021

The alternative to Armenia-Azerbaijan border delimitation is not to have delimitation; they do not sign. The second president of Armenia, leader of the opposition “Armenia” Bloc Robert Kocharyan stated about this during his year-end press conference Monday.

“When they say, the alternative to delimitation is simply not to go to that process because you are in a very weak state. You have a thousand opportunities to substantiate: you do not have diplomatic relations, you do not have any bilateral relations, delimitation moves ahead nowhere without diplomatic relations. After all, when a person wears clothes, first he wears underwear, then some things, finally he wears a coat; that is, the opposite does not happen,” said Kocharyan.

To a reporter’s remark that not signing a border delimitation agreement means not having a specified border with Azerbaijan, and to the question whether in that case Azerbaijan may carry out any encroachment on the borders of Armenia, the second president responded as follows: “I do not consider it right to simplify the situation in this case because we do not say there is no border. Not going to delimitation at this moment is not to say we have no borders at all, but it bears the following consequences in it: The confirmed delimitation means that you recognize the territorial integrity of Azerbaijan, which will enable Azerbaijan to tell us and Russia once and for all that ‘You have recognized my territorial integrity,’ we will say, ‘Yes,’ ‘If you have recognized, then I put a customs point in the Lachin corridor.’ What will you say? You will say, ‘It is not envisaged by the November 9 [2020] document. Yes, I will wait for 3.5 years, when the issue of continuity of the mandate of the [Russian] peacekeeping troops [in the Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) conflict zone] must be discussed, then during the ‘dry’ negotiations I will say to Russia, there is no need anymore, the issue is settled, there is no problem, the peacekeepers can go.’ After 1-2 months of negotiations, you take a step back and say, ‘On only one condition: my [military] post must be here.’ They will put up that post, which will stand quietly for a few months, will watch, as it happened in [Armenia’s] Kapan [city].

We do not even control huge areas today, the danger of delimitation is to make this scenario possible. You should always put yourself in the opponent’s shoes, you should ask what you will do to solve this problem, at the same time say what argument you have against it; there is none. These [Armenian] authorities want to do that so that after that they can say, ‘What do I have to do with it? The Karabakh issue has nothing to do with me anymore and I ‘threw’ it in the ‘pockets’ of the Russians.’ I am somewhat informed that such questions are happening now, they say, ‘Let them negotiate with the Russians. What does it have to do with us?”’

According to the second president, Karabakh was strong in the past, and Armenia was the guarantor of its security.

“Then speaking in place of Karabakh is one question, today not speaking for Karabakh is a completely different thing. It is simply not possible to manipulate the society in this way. Then, the voice of Karabakh should have been heard more, today the voice of Armenia should be heard more,” Kocharyan added.

Azerbaijan releases 10 Armenian POWs

Save

Share

 11:59, 19 December, 2021

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 19, ARMENPRESS. 10 Armenian prisoners of war were released by Azerbaijan and sent back to Armenia, the Foreign Ministry spokesperson Vahan Hunanyan said in a statement.

He said the repatriation was carried out at the mediation of the President of the European Council Charles Michel.

Hunanyan released the identities of the released POWs.

  1. Galstyan Hrachik A. (Date of Birth: 25․01․1990)
  2. Dilanyan Mkrtich V. (Date of Birth: 13․11․1982)
  3. Harutyunyan Gagik V. (Date of Birth: 10․11․1982)
  4. Poghosyan Radik R. (Date of Birth: 19․01․1990)
  5. Ghevondyan Andranik G. (Date of Birth: 16․11․1973)
  6. Nazaryan Artur S. (Date of Birth: 23․11․1978)
  7. Shahinyan Marat Zh. (Date of Birth: 06․01․1977)
  8. Petrosyan Sevak A. (Date of Birth: 14․11․1984)
  9. Stepanyan Karlen R. (Date of Birth: 21․01․1974)
  10. Vasilyan Hayk L. (Date of Birth: 19․10․1984)