Skip to main content

PACE calls on Azerbaijan and Armenia to investigate crimes of last fall’s war

Caucasian Knot, EU
Sept 28 2021

The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) has adopted a resolution demanding from Azerbaijan to release all the Armenian prisoners of war (POWs), and urging both parties to conduct an inquiry into the committed war crimes.

The “Caucasian Knot” has reported that on September 27, marked one year since the start of the Karabakh war in 2020.

The full-scale combat actions took place in Nagorno-Karabakh in the period from September 27 to November 9, 2020. The “Caucasian Knot” has released a map marking the deployment of peacekeepers in Nagorno-Karabakh. Another map prepared by the “Caucasian Knot” indicates what territories Azerbaijan got after the autumn war.

80 PACE members voted for the resolution; the delegations of Azerbaijan and Turkey voted against it.

“The PACE is concerned about the information of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), addressed to the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe, about 188 Armenians allegedly held in Azerbaijan. Some of them have been returned to Armenia since then. The fate of 30 Armenians, whose captivity, according to Armenia, is supported by video and photo evidence, and who may have been killed, is causing concern and worry. Azerbaijan should investigate the facts and provide information to the ECtHR and Armenia,” the resolution states.

The PACE has also expressed concern over the fate of 48 Armenian POWs, most of whom were prosecuted. “The PACE calls on the Azerbaijani authorities to release all the remaining captives and return them to Armenia without any further delay,” says the document.

The PACE has also expressed concern over the war crimes and other illegal acts, both against Armenia and against Azerbaijan, committed during the autumn war. “The PACE calls on Armenia and Azerbaijan to investigate the charges and bring to justice anyone, including at the command level, who is found guilty of such crimes,” says the resolution.

This article was originally published on the Russian page of 24/7 Internet agency ‘Caucasian Knot’ on September 28, 2021 at 06:45 am MSK. To access the full text of the article, click here.

Author: Tigran PetrosyanSource: CK correspondent

Source: 
© Caucasian Knot

CivilNet: Lessons we learned from the 2020 Karabakh War

CIVILNET.AM

27 Sep, 2021 10:09

In the latest edition of Insights with Eric Hacopian, Eric discusses the lessons Armenia and Armenians learned from last year’s 44-day war. Eric explains why the actions of Azerbaijan and Turkey were fascistic, racist and immoral in their intent and why Armenia now must develop economically to overcome this environment. 

Azerbaijani press: Azerbaijan, Iran eye regional situation, mutual co-op

By Vugar Khalilov

Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov and his Iranian counterpart Hussein Amir Abdullahiyan discussed the regional situation and prospects of cooperation in economic, energy and other spheres, the Foreign Ministry reported on September 24.

The meeting, which was held on the sidelines of the 76th UN General Assembly session, stressed the importance of mutual cooperation between the two countries. The sides noted that bilateral relations are developing in all spheres.

The future development of cooperation in the economic, energy, trade, agriculture, and other spheres topped the agenda of talks.

Hussein Amir Abdullahiyan stressed that Iran is interested in developing comprehensive relations with Azerbaijan.

The two ministers also discussed the current regional situation as well.

Bayramov briefed his counterpart on the restoration, reconstruction and reintegration processes in the liberated areas after the signing of the trilateral statement by Azerbaijan, Russia and Armenia.

Other topics, including international and regional issues, were discussed during the meeting, the ministry said.

It should be noted that Azerbaijani and Iranian government officials held several meetings to discuss the new conditions of traffic on the Gorus-Gafan road that emerged following Azerbaijan’s liberation of its territories.

The Gorus-Gafan highway connects Armenia with Iran. A small section of this route passes through the territory of Azerbaijan in Eyvazli village of Gubadli region.

Recently, a number of Armenian media published panic reports that Azerbaijani police and customs officers were inspecting Iranian trucks crossing the territory of the republic.

On September 11, the Azerbaijani media outlets reported that a lot of Iranian trucks continue to enter the Azerbaijani territories in Karabakh under the temporary Russian peacekeeper control without Baku’s consent.

Later, the Defence Ministry stated that foreign legal entities, individuals and their vehicles cannot enter the Azerbaijani territories without the country’s consent and such cases violate Azerbaijan’s laws.

Tehran to host Iran-Azerbaijan-Turkey foreign ministerial meeting

Save

Share

 13:44,

YEREVAN, SEPTEMBER 23, ARMENPRESS. The foreign ministers of Iran, Azerbaijan and Turkey will hold a meeting in Tehran, according to Tasnim news agency.

According to the report the agreement to hold the meeting in Tehran was reached during Turkish FM Mevult Cavusoglu and Iranian FM Hossein Amir-Abdollahian’s recent meeting at the 76th session of the United Nations General Assembly.

The Iranian FM said at the meeting that the new developments taking place in the region require regular consultations between the countries.

Editing and Translating by Stepan Kocharyan

Zakharova: Russia has told Baku about its position on the Turkish-Azerbaijani joint military exercises

News.am, Armenia
Sept 16 2021

Russia has told Baku about its position on the Turkish-Azerbaijani military exercises. This is what Spokesperson for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation Maria Zakharova said during her weekly briefing.

According to her, the Azerbaijani side has accepted the position with understanding.

Zakharova added that she will refrain from making comments, but clarified that the Russian MFA is always in contact with its Azerbaijani colleagues and is closely following the situation in certain sectors of the border between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Ankara and Baku recently held three joint military exercises, and servicemen of Pakistan’s armed forces participated in one of them, that is, the “Three Brothers-2021” military exercises.


Is it time for the US to leave Incirlik airbase in Turkey?

The Greek Current Podcast
Sept 2021

Michael Rubin joins The Greek Current to discuss his op-ed titled “The one foreign base Biden should abandon”, and explains why it’s time for the US to end its military presence in Turkey. We also look at what impact the US withdrawal from Afghanistan and the broader region will have on the Middle East, as countries in the region begin to adjust to this new reality.

Prospects of Armenia-Turkey Rapprochement

Germany – Sept 10 2021

Potential Armenia-Turkey rapprochement could have a major influence on South Caucasus geopolitics. The opening of the border would allow Turkey to have a better connection with Azerbaijan beyond the link it already has with the Nakhchivan exclave. Moscow will not be entirely happy with the development as it would allow Yerevan to diversify its foreign policy and decrease dependence on Russia in economy. The process nevertheless is fraught with troubles as mutual distrust and the influence of the third parties could complicate the nascent rapprochement.

Over the past month Armenian and Turkish officials exchanged positive statements which signaled potential rapprochement between the two historical foes. For instance, the Armenian PM Nikol Pashinyan said that he was ready for reconciliation with Turkey “without preconditions.” “Getting back to the agenda of establishing peace in the region, I must say that we have received some positive public signals from Turkey. We will assess these signals, and we will respond to positive signals with positive signals,” the PM stated. Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said Ankara could work towards gradual normalization if Yerevan “declared its readiness to move in this direction.”

On a more concrete level Armenia has recently allowed Turkish Airlines to fly to Baku directly over Armenia. More significantly, Armenia’s recently unveiled five-year government action plan, approved by Armenia’s legislature, states that “Armenia is ready to make efforts to normalize relations with Turkey.” Normalization, if implemented in full, would probably take the form of establishing full-scale diplomatic relations. More importantly, the five-year plan stresses that Armenia will approach the normalization process “without preconditions” and says that establishing relations with Turkey is in “the interests of stability, security, and the economic development of the region.”

So far it has been just an exchange of positive statements, but the frequency nevertheless indicates that a certain trend is emerging. This could lead to intensive talks and possibly to improvement of bilateral ties. The timing is interesting. The results of the second Nagorno-Karabakh war served as a catalyzer. Though heavily defeated by Azerbaijan, Armenia sees the need to act beyond the historical grievances it holds against Turkey and be generally more pragmatic in foreign ties. In Yerevan’s calculation, the improvement of relations with Ankara could deprive Baku of some advantages. Surely, Azerbaijan-Turkey alliance will remain untouched, but the momentum behind it could decrease if Armenia establishes better relations with Turkey. The latter might not be as strongly inclined to push against Armenia as it has done so far, and specifically during the second Nagorno-Karabakh war. The willingness to improve the bilateral relations has been persistently expressed by Ankara over the past years. Perhaps the biggest effort was made in 2009 when the Zurich Protocols were signed leading to a brief thaw in bilateral relations. Though eventually unsuccessful (on March 1, 2018, Armenia announced the cancellation of the protocols), Ankara has often stressed the need of improvement of ties with Yerevan without demanding preconditions.

Beyond the potential establishment of diplomatic relations, the reopening of the two countries’ border, closed from early 1990s because of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict and Turkey’s solidarity with and military and economic support for Azerbaijan, could also be a part of the arrangement. The opening of the 300 km border running along the Armenian regions of Shirak, Aragatsotn, Armavir, and Ararat could be a game-changer. The opening up of the border is essentially an opening of the entire South Caucasus region. The move would provide Armenia with a new market for its products and businesses. In the longer term it would allow the country to diversify its economy, lessen dependence on Russia and the fragile route which goes through Georgia. The reliance on the Georgian territory could be partially substituted by Azerbaijan-Armenia-Turkey route, though it should be also stressed that the Armenia transit would need considerable time to become fully operational.

Economic and connectivity diversification equals the diminution of Russian influence in the South Caucasus. In other words, the closed borders have always constituted the basis of Russian power in the region as most roads and railways have a northward direction. For Turkey an open border with Armenia is also beneficial as it would allow a freer connection with Azerbaijan. Improving the regional links is a cornerstone of Turkey’s position in the South Caucasus. In a way, the country has acted as a major disruptor. Through its military and active economic presence Turkey opens new railways and roads, thus steadily decreasing Russian geopolitical leverage over the South Caucasus.

As mentioned, both Ankara and Yerevan will benefit from potential rapprochement. It is natural to suggest that the potential improvement between Turkey and Armenia, Russia’s trustful ally, would not be possible without Moscow’s blessing. Russia expressed readiness to help Armenia and Turkey normalize their relations, saying that would boost peace and stability in the region. “Now too we are ready to assist in a rapprochement between the two neighboring states based on mutual respect and consideration of each other’s interests,” the Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman, Maria Zakharova, said. Yet, it is not entirely clear how the normalization would suit Russia’s interests. One possibility is that the Armenia-Turkey connection would allow Russia to have a direct land link with Turkey via Azerbaijan and Armenia. However, here too the benefits are doubtful. The route is long and will likely remain unreliable. For Russia trade with Turkey via the Black Sea will remain a primary route.

Presenting a positive picture in the South Caucasus could however be a misrepresentation of real developments on the ground. The Armenian-Turkish rapprochement is far from being guaranteed because of ingrained distrust between the two sides. Moreover, there is also the Azerbaijani factor. Baku will try to influence Ankara’s thinking lest the rapprochement goes against Azerbaijan’s interests. Moreover, as argued above, Russia too might not be entirely interested in the border opening. This makes the potential process of normalization fraught with numerous problems which could continuously undermine rapport improvement.

Thus, realism drives Turkish policy toward Armenia. Ankara needs better connections to the South Caucasus. Reliance on the Georgian transit route is critical, but diversification is no less important. The results of the Second Nagorno-Karabakh war present Turkey and Armenia with an opportunity to pursue the improvement of bilateral ties. Yet, the normalization could be under pressure from external players and deep running mutual distrust. Moreover, the two sides will need to walk a tightrope as a potential blowback from nationalist forces in Turkey and Armenia can complicate the process.

Emil Avdaliani is a professor at European University and the Director of Middle East Studies at Georgian think-tank, Geocase.


https://caucasuswatch.de/news/4072.html
The above also appears at
https://moderndiplomacy.eu/2021/09/10/prospects-of-armenia-turkey-rapprochement/

CSUN Lecturer Documents Stories From the Last Armenia/Azerbaijan Conflict


Sept 7 2021


CSUN criminology and justice studies lecturer Megan Mangassarian, front right, 
with a group of displaced children at a refugee hotel in Armenia. Photo courtesy of Megan Mangassarian.

They are stories California State University, Northridge criminology and justice studies lecturer Megan Mangassarian will never forget: Women and children fleeing bombings and drone attacks in the middle of the night, with no time to grab shoes or jackets. The young mother who still doesn’t know if her husband is dead or a prisoner of war after he volunteered to fight against the latest incursion by Azerbaijan forces.

Mangassarian is part of a team of lawyers in the United States and Armenia who founded the nonprofit Center for Truth and Justice earlier this year to document the stories of Armenian civilians caught in the latest conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

“When the war started, everyone in the U.S. Armenian community wanted to help,” Mangassarian said. “Everyone tried to figure out what their skillset was and in what way they could use those skills to help those being impacted by the war. We decided, as a group, that we were going to preserve testimonials and evidence of the war so that these stories never get lost.”

Megan Mangassarian shopping for underwear for displaced women in Armenia. Photo courtesy of Megan Mangassarian.

A tenuous ceasefire negotiated by Russia last November halted a 44-day war over the disputed region of Nagorno-Karabakh, known as Artsakh by Armenians. Who has control over Nagorno-Karabakh has been the subject of often violent clashes between the two countries since the early 20th century. At least 6,500 people were killed, including dozens of civilians, in the latest conflict, which has forced thousands from their homes and led to the destruction of churches and other historical sites that date as far back as the fifth century.

Mangassarian and her colleagues at the Center for Truth and Justice are drawing on their professional expertise in collecting evidence and interviewing witnesses to preserve the accounts of the Armenian civilians caught in the middle of the latest conflict, for possible future court cases and to memorialize what has happened.

“There really is pressure to make sure that we are doing everything the right way, making sure we are following all the legal requirements and that we conduct ourselves with dignity and integrity, and with respect for what these people have gone through,” she said.

Mangassarian, who earned her bachelor’s degree in sociology, with an emphasis in criminology and criminal justice, from CSUN in 2012, teaches victimology — the study of the psychological effects on victims, relationships between victims and offenders, and the interactions between victims and the criminal justice system — as well as ethics in the criminal justice system, at CSUN. As a lawyer, she specializes in working with women and children who have been the victims of violence and sexual assault. She drew on those experiences for her work with the center.

Megan Mangassarian at the Armenian Noravank Monastery, built in the 13th century. Photo courtesy of Megan Mangassarian.

She traveled to Armenia last winter to see firsthand what survivors of the conflict were going through. She returned shortly thereafter to set up the Center for Truth and Justice as the country director for the organization.

During one of those trips, Mangassarian visited a hotel that was hosting more than 100 refugees from the conflict.

“While the hotel could give them a place to stay for free, it couldn’t give them everything they needed,” she said. “There were mostly women and children who fled their homes with practically nothing but the clothes on their backs. Some didn’t even have a chance to stop for shoes or jackets, or any form of identification.”

While Mangassarian was bringing clothes for the families, women would ask her if she had any underwear she could give them.

“My mind was blown,” she said. “It’s winter and we think we need to get them shoes and jackets so they don’t freeze. But they needed more than that. They needed the basic necessities — underwear, feminine hygiene products, diapers. They were displaced families, wives and mothers who had no idea where their sons and husbands were.”

Recognizing the need, Mangassarian, outside of her work with the center, spent time connecting the refugees with agencies and individuals who provided them with the goods they needed.

“I did my own fundraising for jackets and shoes and then specific items like underwear — and delivered them myself in various regions,” she said. “I also did a photoshoot for all of the kids and used that to create a sponsorship program to connect these families with U.S. families. Each family in Armenia was assigned a U.S. family as a sponsor to continue to help meet their needs.”

Mangassarian said CSUN’s virtual-learning environment, due to the pandemic, provided her the opportunity to continue teaching her classes while she was in Armenia.

“I would share with them where I was and what I was doing,” she said. “One of the subjects I teach is victimology, and I was able to use what I was doing in Armenia to give them a first-hand look at the importance of understanding and respecting the needs of the victims of violent crimes, and how to advocate on their behalf.”

They were lessons she also shared with the Armenian law students working with the center to document the stories of civilians impacted by the conflict.

“It’s a rare opportunity for law students to train with attorneys from another country, to expand their understanding of law and gain another country’s perspective of how law works, particularly in the relatively new field of victimology,” Mangassarian said. “I feel honored that I was able to do that, not just with the Armenian students I was working with, but also to share what I was doing with the students in my classes at CSUN.”


Renewed efforts necessary to fulfil unconditional release of Armenian POWs – EPP

Panorama, Armenia
Sept 7 2021

The European People’s Party (EPP) Political Assembly (PA) met in a hybrid format in Brussels on 6 and 7 September to update on political developments across member states, adopt a position paper on Afghanistan with a focus on Afghan women and discuss the situation in Belarus and Armenia, EPP said in a statement.

“EPP Political Assembly was informed about the current situation with Armenian prisoners of war in Azerbaijan, who are still detained in violation of the Trilateral Statement of November 9 and international humanitarian law. The necessity for renewed efforts from the European institutions to fulfil the proper and unconditional release of Prisoners of War was stressed,” reads the statement.

The EPP delegates were updated on the preparations for the next Congress taking place on 17 and 18 November in Rotterdam.