Tuesday, France Calls For ‘Lasting Political Solution’ In Nagorno-Karabakh French President Emmanuel Macron (archive photo) French President Emmanuel Macron on Tuesday called for a “lasting political solution” to the conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh after Armenia and Azerbaijan agreed a deal to end weeks of fierce fighting, AFP reports. Macron also urged that Turkey, which backs Azerbaijan, to “end its provocations” in the conflict. “France firmly calls on Turkey to put an end to its provocations about Nagorno-Karabakh, to show restraint and to do nothing that compromises the possibility of a lasting agreement being negotiated between the parties and within the framework of the Minsk Group,” the French president said. He added that a long-term deal should also “preserve Armenia’s interests.” Macron’s office quoted him as saying that efforts should be made “without delay” to try to come up with a “lasting political solution to the conflict that allows for the Armenian population of Nagorno-Karabakh to remain in good conditions and the return of tens of thousands of people who have fled their homes.” The French president said he will actively pursue his consultations with Russia and will meet “very soon” with the Armenian and Azerbaijani leaders. Macron said that France, which is home to a strong Armenian community, “stands by Armenia at this difficult time.” Along with Russia and the United States, France is a co-chair of the OSCE Minsk Group that has for nearly three decades spearheaded international efforts to broker a negotiated peace for Nagorno-Karabakh. France Calls For ‘Lasting Political Solution’ In Nagorno-Karabakh French President Emmanuel Macron (archive photo) French President Emmanuel Macron on Tuesday called for a “lasting political solution” to the conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh after Armenia and Azerbaijan agreed a deal to end weeks of fierce fighting, AFP reports. Macron also urged that Turkey, which backs Azerbaijan, to “end its provocations” in the conflict. “France firmly calls on Turkey to put an end to its provocations about Nagorno-Karabakh, to show restraint and to do nothing that compromises the possibility of a lasting agreement being negotiated between the parties and within the framework of the Minsk Group,” the French president said. He added that a long-term deal should also “preserve Armenia’s interests.” Macron’s office quoted him as saying that efforts should be made “without delay” to try to come up with a “lasting political solution to the conflict that allows for the Armenian population of Nagorno-Karabakh to remain in good conditions and the return of tens of thousands of people who have fled their homes.” The French president said he will actively pursue his consultations with Russia and will meet “very soon” with the Armenian and Azerbaijani leaders. Macron said that France, which is home to a strong Armenian community, “stands by Armenia at this difficult time.” Along with Russia and the United States, France is a co-chair of the OSCE Minsk Group that has for nearly three decades spearheaded international efforts to broker a negotiated peace for Nagorno-Karabakh. Armenia, Azerbaijan Sign Russia-Brokered Truce Deal, Triggering Unrest In Yerevan A woman wheels a stroller with a child as police officers guard in front of the government building in Yerevan, The leaders of Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Russia have signed an agreement to end six weeks of military conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh, triggering a political crisis in Armenia where angry protesters stormed government buildings and parliament. The November 10 announcement of the Russian-brokered agreement to end the fighting between Azerbaijan and ethnic Armenians came after Azerbaijani forces made major battlefield gains, including reports they were approaching the region’s capital, Stepanakert. Pashinian first announced the trilateral agreement in a Facebook post, saying he had signed a statement with the presidents of Russia and Azerbaijan on the "termination" of the war as of 1 p.m. local time. Pashinian said the deal, which includes the long-term deployment of Russian troops to the region, was "the best possible solution for the current situation." Armenia Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian on November 10. "I made this decision as a result of an in-depth analysis of the military situation and an assessment of the people who know it best," Pashinian wrote. Russian President Vladimir Putin said he believed the agreement "will create [the] necessary conditions for a long-term and full-fledged settlement of the crisis around Nagorno-Karabakh on a fair basis and in the interests of the Armenian and Azerbaijani people." Nagorno-Karabakh's de facto ethnic-Armenian leader, Arayik Harutiunian, said he had agreed with Pashinian to end hostilities "given the current dire situation" and to avoid even greater military defeats and losses. Under the deal, Azerbaijan will keep territory in Nagorno-Karabakh and surrounding areas captured during the conflict. It also calls for Armenian forces to hand over some areas it held outside the borders of Nagorno-Karabakh, including the eastern district of Aggdam and the western area of Kelbajar. Armenians will also forfeit the Lachin region, where a crucial road connects Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia. The agreement calls for a 5-kilometer wide area in the so-called Lachin Corridor to remain open and be protected by around 2,000 Russian peacekeepers. Russia said later its troops had already been sent to the South Caucasus to be deployed for a peacekeeping mission in Nagorno-Karabakh. Russian peacekeepers boarding a military plane in Russia heading for Nagorno-Karabakh, The agreement also calls for Russian border services to monitor a new transport corridor through Armenia connecting Azerbaijan to its western exclave of Nakhijevan, which is surrounded by Armenia, Iran, and Turkey. Aliyev said that Turkey, a close ally of Baku, would take part in the peacekeeping center to monitor the cease-fire. Since fighting erupted in late September, several thousand people are believed to have been killed on both sides. Azerbaijan said on November 8 its forces had taken the key town of Shushi (Shusha), offering strategic heights over Nagorno-Karabakh's main city, Stepanakert, just 10 kilometers away. Shushi also lies along the main road connecting Stepanakert with Armenia. Thousands of people fled Nagorno-Karabakh in recent days to Armenia as the Azerbaijani forces were closing in on both Shushi and Stepanakert. Azerbaijan's forces in recent weeks have also retaken several regions outside Nagorno-Karabakh that were controlled by ethnic Armenian forces. Unhappy with the situation, several thousand angry protesters gathered in Yerevan in the early hours of November 10 after Pashinian announced he had signed the cease-fire agreement, with mobs storming the government headquarters and parliament, ransacking offices and smashing windows in an outburst of anger. Parliament Speaker Ararat Mirzoyan was injured in a mob attack and hospitalized, drawing a sharp rebuke from the government. Dozens of men also tried to break into RFE/RL's bureau in Yerevan, calling the Armenian Service "traitors." The Union of Journalist of Armenia and Armenia's ombudsman condemned the attacks and any threats against media. Later in the morning the Armenian police formed cordons to protect government offices and the parliament building. Meanwhile, President Armen Sarkissian's office said later on Tuesday that he was launching "political consultations" to build national unity and "coordinate…solutions arising from our agenda of protecting national interests." Sarkissian said in a statement he had learnt about the agreement to end the fighting in and around Nagorno-Karabakh from the media. "Unfortunately, there were no consultations or discussions with me, as the President of the Republic, regarding this document, and I did not participate in any negotiations," he said, insisting that the signing of such an important document involving Armenia’s "vital security interests" and the "whole Armenian nation" should have been subjected to "comprehensive consultations and discussions." The previous day, 17 opposition parties issued a joint statement calling for Pashinian’s resignation amid a series of military defeats suffered by Armenia-backed ethnic Armenian forces fighting against Azerbaijan in Nagorno-Karabakh. Among the parties that signed the statement were the main parliamentary opposition party, Prosperous Armenia, led by tycoon Gagik Tsarukian, the former ruling Republican Party of ex-President Serzh Sarkisian, the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaktsutiun), and the Hayrenik (Homeland) party led by former director of the National Security Service Artur Vanetsian, who was relieved of his duties in 2019 over differences with Pashinian. Angry protesters stormed the parliamentary assembly in Yerevan on November 10 after Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian said he had signed an agreement with the leaders of Russia and Azerbaijan to end the war in Nagorno-Karabakh. In his comments following the night of chaos, Pashinian implied that corruption in previous governments was also to blame for the current situation. "We must prepare for revenge. We haven’t dealt properly with the corrupt, oligarchic scoundrels, those who robbed this country, stole soldiers' food, stole soldiers' weapons,” said Pashinian, a reformist pressing an anti-corruption campaign who came to power in 2018 in the wake of mass popular protests. "I call on citizens with dignity to be ready for us going after the rioters and their bosses, after the corrupt part of Dashnaktsutiun, after the robbers from the Republican Party, the Prosperous Armenia Party, the deserters from the Hayrenik party who left their combat positions and fled, and must be tried for desertion," he charged. Meanwhile, Armenia’s Defense Ministry and the General Staff of the Armed Forces issued a statement, calling on all to refrain from actions that could “undermine the foundations of [Armenia’s] statehood.” Armenian President Initiates ‘Political Consultations’ Armenian President Armen Sarkissian during an address to the nation on November 6, 2020 Armenian President Armen Sarkissian issued a statement on Tuesday, initiating “political consultations” as the country appeared to be plunged into a political crisis following the announcement of a Russian-brokered deal with Azerbaijan over Nagorno-Karabakh. As quoted by his office, President Sarkissian, who unlike the prime minister has limited powers under Armenia’s constitution, said that he was immediately initiating the consultations “in order to coordinate, within the shortest possible period, solutions arising from our agenda of protecting national interests.” “I learned from the media that a statement on ending the Nagorno-Karabakh war was signed with the presidents of Russia and Azerbaijan. It was also from the media that I learned about the conditions for ending the war,” Sarkissian said. “Unfortunately, there were no consultations or discussions with me, as with the President of the Republic, regarding this document, and I did not participate in any negotiations,” he added. The president emphasizes that “the settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict is a matter of national importance, and any step, action, decision related to the vital security interests of Armenia, Artsakh [the Armenian name for Nagorno-Karabakh], the entire Armenian nation, moreover, the signing of a document in this respect, should be a subject of comprehensive consultations and discussions.” “I emphasize that the fate of Artsakh, and consequently of the Armenian people, can be decided only taking into account our national interests and only on the basis of a national consensus. “Taking into account the deep concerns of the large mass of the people conditioned by the current situation, I immediately initiate political consultations in order to coordinate solutions, within the shortest possible period, arising from our agenda of protecting national interests,” he said. “As the President of the Republic, at this crucial moment of national preservation, I consider the formation of national unity to be my current mission. I hope that within ten days we will all be able to build such a unity under which I will consider that I have used the opportunities to serve my homeland,” the Armenian president concluded. Riots began in Armenia early on November 10 upon the news that Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian signed a Russian-brokered agreement with Azerbaijan, putting an end to more than six weeks of fighting in Nagorno-Karabakh. The country was plunged into a political turmoil after opposition groups called on Pashinian to resign. This was followed by a night of unrest leaving government buildings ransacked. In chaotic scenes in the capital, hundreds of opposition supporters in the early hours of November 10 stormed the government headquarters and parliament in Yerevan, ransacking offices and smashing windows in an outburst of anger. Protesters inside the Armenian parliament during the night of riots in Yerevan following the announcement of a Russian-brokered agreement with Azerbaijan to end the war in Nagorno-Karabakh. . Parliament Speaker Ararat Mirzoyan was injured in a mob attack and hospitalized, drawing a sharp rebuke from the government. The backlash over the agreement signed by Pashinian came after 17 opposition parties issued a joint statement on November 9 calling for the prime minister’s resignation amid a series of military defeats suffered by Armenia-backed ethnic Armenian forces in Nagorno-Karabakh fighting against Azerbaijan. Among the parties that signed the statement were the main parliamentary opposition party, Prosperous Armenia, led by tycoon Gagik Tsarukian, the former ruling Republican Party of former President Serzh Sarkisian, the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaktsutyun), and the Hayrenik (Homeland) party led by former director of the National Security Service Artur Vanetsian, who was relieved of his duties in 2019 over differences with Pashinian. In his comments following the night of chaos, Pashinian implied that corruption in previous governments was also to blame for the current situation. The premier said in a live broadcast on Facebook that the decision to sign the agreement to put an end to hostilities in Nagorno-Karabakh was conditioned by the request of the military that he said had no further resources to continue to wage the war. Nagorno-Karabakh’s ethnic Armenian leader Arayik Harutiunian also admitted this reality in his live broadcast on Facebook the same day. He said if the decision were not made today, within days or weeks ethnic Armenian forces in Nagorno-Karabakh would suffer even greater military defeats and have even more losses. Meanwhile, Armenia’s Defense Ministry and the General Staff of the Armed Forces issued a statement, calling on all to refrain from actions that could “undermine the foundations of [Armenia’s] statehood.” Parliament Speaker Injured In Riots Over Karabakh Deal As Political Tensions Grow In Armenia Armenian Parliament Speaker Ararat Mirzoyan (archive photo) Armenian Parliament Speaker Ararat Mirzoyan has been hospitalized with injuries after being attacked by a crowd of protesters angered by the news of a Russia-brokered deal with Azerbaijan over Nagorno-Karabakh perceived by them as surrender, a government official said. Edurad Aghajanian, a spokesperson for the Prime Minister’s Office, wrote on Facebook: “He [Ararat Mirzoyan] suffered injuries that luckily are not life-threatening.” Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian also confirmed in a live broadcast on Facebook that Mirzoyan’s life is not in danger at this moment. He said the parliament speaker was undergoing surgery. “Ararat Mirzoyan is one of the people who accepted or rather did not accept the decision [to sign a deal] with tears in his eyes. There is no person in our political team who did not cry upon learning about that decision. And now some scoundrels have attacked Ararat Mirzoyan and his child,” Pashinian said. “We must prepare for revenge. We haven’t dealt properly with the corrupt, oligarchic scoundrels, those who robbed this country, stole soldiers’ food, stole soldiers’ weapons. I apologize for that, and I call on all the citizens who understand what is happening to prepare for revenge,” Pashinian said. The prime minister also said that he was thinking of organizing a rally in the near future. “Those who have sold their homeland, those who have sold the liberated lands for money will not succeed, it is excluded. Your mansions will be returned to the people. I call on citizens with dignity to be ready for us going after the rioters and their bosses, after the corrupt part of Dashnaktsutyun, after the robbers from the [former ruling] Republican Party of Armenia, the Prosperous Armenia Party, the deserters from the Hayrenik party who left their combat positions and fled, and must be tried for desertion,” he charged. The four political parties mentioned by Pashinian were among 17 others that issued a joint statement on November 9 calling for Pashinian’s resignation amid what appeared to be a series of military defeats suffered by Armenia-backed ethnic Armenian forces in Nagorno-Karabakh fighting against Azerbaijan. Hours later Pashinian signed a deal with Azerbaijan brokered by Russia to put an end to fighting in Nagorno-Karabakh, triggering protests. Over the night groups of angry protesters stormed the government and parliament buildings in Yerevan. Pashinian called on those people not involved in the riots to go home. In remarks on Facebook Pashinian implied that corruption in previous governments was also to blame for the current situation. “All those who are responsible, including myself if I am responsible, will be held to account,” he said. Armenian PM Calls For Calm Amid Unrest Over Karabakh Deal Protesters inside the Armenian parliament during the night of riots in Yerevan following the announcement of a Russian-brokered agreement with Azerbaijan to end the war in Nagorno-Karabakh. . Unrest in Yerevan started early on November 10 after the news that the leaders of Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Russia signed an agreement putting an end to 44-day-long fighting over Nagorno-Karabakh as rioters perceived the deal as surrender. Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian has called on people not involved in riots to go home after angry protesters stormed government and parliament buildings in Yerevan early on November 10 following the news of a Russia-brokered deal with Azerbaijan over Nagorno-Karabakh viewed by them as surrender. “All those citizens who have nothing to do with the disturbances, please go home. All those citizens who believe me, believe us, please prepare for struggle,” Pashinian wrote on Facebook, addressing his words to citizens who gathered near the buildings of the government and the National Assembly in Yerevan. “Do not doubt for a second that we have not done anything dishonest. We did not agree to any bargain. I have acted in a way so as to have answers to all questions and be clean in front of my homeland and the people,” Pashinian said. “At this difficult time, we must stand side by side against mice stealing seeds. You, who fish in muddy waters, we will still talk,” the premier added in an apparent reference to his political opponents. Unrest in Yerevan started after the news that the leaders of Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Russia signed an agreement putting an end to 44-day-long fighting over Nagorno-Karabakh as rioters perceived the deal as surrender. Still on November 9, amid what appeared to be a series of military defeats suffered by Armenia-backed ethnic Armenian forces in Nagorno-Karabakh fighting against Azerbaijan, a group of Armenian opposition parties issued a joint statement demanding Pashinian’s resignation. Among the 17 parties that signed the statement were the main parliamentary opposition party, Prosperous Armenia, led by tycoon Gagik Tsarukian, the former ruling Republican Party of Armenia of former President Serzh Sarkisian, the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaktsutyun) and others. In earlier remarks Pashinian implied that corruption in previous governments was also to blame for the current situation. “All those who are responsible, including myself if I am responsible, will be held to account,” he said. Angry Mob Attacks RFE/RL’s Armenia Office Amid Unrest Following Nagorno-Karabakh Deal Logo of RFE/RL Armenian Service (Azatutyun) Around 40 men have attacked the office of RFE/RL’s Armenian Service (Azatutyun) in Yerevan amid unrest triggered by Armenia’s signing of a Russian-brokered agreement with Azerbaijan to end fighting over the breakaway region of Nagorno-Karabakh. The mob tried to break into RFE/RL’s office early on the morning of November 10, calling the Armenian Service “traitors” and “Turks” while in a tirade against the government over what they perceive as a surrender in Nagorno-Karabakh. “You are responsible for the deaths of my friends [in Nagorno-Karabakh],” one of the attackers charged. Others said they wanted to destroy Azatutyun’s computer servers to force journalists from going on air. RFE/RL Armenian Service Executive Producer Artak Hambardzumian said he personally identified one of the men as Gerasim Vardanian, a member of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaktsutiun), one of nearly two dozen political parties that are demanding Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian’s resignation. Hambardzumian said the men tried to break the door to the office and attack him and a cameraman. RFE/RL Acting President Daisy Sindelar condemned the attack on Azatutyun in a statement issued today. “The attack on RFE/RL’s Yerevan bureau is a reprehensible assault on the essential duty of journalists to serve as impartial witnesses during major news events,” said Sindelar. “Our Armenian Service, Azatutyun, is one of the few media outlets in Armenia that has aimed to present all sides of a deeply divisive conflict. We call on the police and public alike to support the right of Azatutyun and all independent journalists to report the news, objectively and in full, without threat of violence or scapegoating.” The Union of Journalists of Armenia, other leading media organizations and Armenian Ombudsman Arman Tatoyan also condemned the attack against Azatutyun. In chaotic scenes in Yerevan, protesters in the early hours of the morning also stormed government buildings and parliament. Armenia, Azerbaijan Agree To Russia-Brokered End To Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian, 10Nov, 2020 The leaders of Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Russia have signed an agreement to end fighting over Nagorno-Karabakh starting on November 10, triggering unrest in the Armenian capital as protesters stormed government buildings. Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian first announced the agreement in an early morning social media post, saying he had signed a statement with the presidents of Russia and Azerbaijan on the “termination” of the war over Nagorno-Karabakh war as of 1:00 a.m. local time. Russian President Vladimir Putin and Azerbaijan President Ilham Aliyev later confirmed the agreement, which will include the long-term deployment of Russian peacekeepers. "We believe that the achieved agreements will create [the] necessary conditions for a long-term and full-fledged settlement of the crisis around Nagorno-Karabakh on a fair basis and in the interests of the Armenian and Azerbaijani people," Putin said of the agreement. The early morning announcement on November 10 comes as Azerbaijani forces have made major battlefield gains in the six-week flare up in the decades-long conflict, including reports they were approaching the region’s capital, Stepanakert. “I made a very difficult decision for myself and for all of us,” Pashinian said on Facebook. “I made this decision as a result of an in-depth analysis of the military situation and an assessment of the people who know it best.” Pashinian said he would provide more information in the coming days, adding that the agreement was “the best possible solution for the current situation.” Nagorno-Karabakh’s de facto ethnic Armenian leader, Arayik Harutiunian, said he had agreed with Pashinian to end hostilities with Azerbaijan “given the current dire situation” and to avoid completely losing the region. The backlash from the announcement in Yerevan was swift as several thousand protesters angry over the agreement stormed government buildings and the opposition called on Pashinian to resign. Aliyev said in a televised online meeting with Putin that the trilateral agreement would be a crucial point in the settlement of the conflict. He also said that Turkey, a close ally of Baku, would take part in the peacekeeping center to monitor the cease-fire. Under the deal, Azerbaijan will keep territory in Nagorno-Karabakh and surrounding areas captured during the conflict. It also calls for Armenian forces to hand over some areas it held outside the borders of Nagorno-Karabakh, including the eastern district of Aghdam and western area of Kelbajar (Kalbacar). Armenians will also forfeit the Lachin region, where a crucial road connects Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia. The agreement calls for a 5-kilometer wide area in the so-called Lachin Corridor to remain open and be protected by around 2,000 Russian peacekeepers. The agreement also calls for Russian border services to monitor a new transport corridor through Armenia connecting Azerbaijan to its western exclave of Nakhijevan (Naxcivan), which is surrounded by Armenia, Iran, and Turkey. Since fighting erupted on September 27, several thousand people are believed to have been killed as three cease-fires failed to halt fighting between ethnic Armenian forces and the Azerbaijani military. Aliyev on November 8 said that his country’s forces had taken Shushi (known as Susa in Azeri), offering strategic heights over Stepanakert just 10 kilometers away. Shushi also lies along the main road connecting Stepanakert with Armenia. Thousands of people have fled Nagorno-Karabakh in recent days to Armenia, with lines of vehicles clogging the main road connecting the enclave to Armenia. Azerbaijan's forces in recent weeks have also retaken several regions outside Nagorno-Karabakh. Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL Copyright (c) 2020 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc. 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
Author: Ani Kharatian
CivilNet: A British Journalist Recaps His Time on the Karabakh Frontline and His Interview with Pashinyan
Azerbaijan-Armenian Conflict Plays Out as War of Words on San Francisco Peninsula
SAN FRANCISCO (KPIX) — On September 27, a long-running dispute between Armenians and the nation of Azerbaijan exploded into violent conflict. Now supporters on both sides are fighting a public relations battle here in the Bay Area.
Violence has flared up half a world away in a small region of Azerbaijan called Nagorno-Karabakh. Many ethnic Armenians live there and have claimed it as their own Artsakh Republic, which has drawn the ire of Azerbaijanis. Their weapons are rockets and bombs but Sunday, in dueling protest rallies in the Bay Area, it remained a war of words.
“Fair media coverage! Fair media coverage!” chanted Azerbaijani protesters. They marched in San Francisco to gain exposure and protest what they feel is one-sided coverage.
“Media is covering their protests, everything,” said organizer Narmin Babayeva, “but when we are going out, it’s hard for us to get any coverage.”
They said that, since 1991, the Armenians have been “ethnic cleansing” the region, forcing Azerbaijanis out.
“Peace is through co-existence,” said Azerbaijani protester Ayka Agayeva. “What we want is Armenian army, the occupying Armenian army, to vacate the land so the Azerbaijani people who used to live there can come back to their homes.”
Down the peninsula in San Mateo, Armenians said that part of the world has been their homeland for hundreds of years and declaring it an independent state is an act of self-rule equivalent to the American Revolution.
“This is a war that very much reflects the ideals of America,” said protest organizer Raffi Samurkashian. “The Armenian people living there very much reflect the ideals of the American people living here.”
Each side said their civilians are being killed and each denies being the aggressor.
“If there is a reaction, if there is violence, I mean, you can’t expect people living in Artsakh to sit back and take that violence,” said Armenian protester David Iskikian.
When the conflict reignited in September, it ended a cease-fire lasting more than 20 years. No one KPIX spoke to Sunday knew exactly what happened that caused the fighting to resume. The Armenians are getting support from the Russians while the U.S. financially supports Turkey, which is helping Azerbaijan. The geo-politics can be dizzying but people on each side of the dispute in this country share the same goal: to convince the American public that their side is in the right.
CivilNet: We’ll Always Have Stepanakert
By Michael Krikorian
“Riding high in April, Shot down in May” – Frank Sinatra line from “That’s Life”.
April to May? Hell, at least it took Frank a month to do what Angelika Zakaryan heartbreakingly did right before my eyes in a 15-minute journey from ecstasy to agony.
Angelika, also known as Lika, 26, is a journalist from Yerevan-based CIVILNET news agency who has been writing a personal daily diary of the war in her native Nagorno Karabakh for the last month. Her columns are brutally raw, innocent and heartfelt.
I met her on Day 27 of the war in what has become her new home: a school with a sturdy basement that has been converted into a bomb shelter. Our meeting had been prearranged by Salpi Ghazarian, the director of the Institute of Armenian Studies at the University of Southern. Before I left Los Angeles, Salpi said “You’ll like Lika.” I said nothing, but thought to myself “No, I won’t.” I almost never like anyone who someone else says I will. But, in this case, I was wrong and Salpi was right.
Angelika has this engagingly bright smile, the kind that nearly closes the eyes, that now often masquerades her sadness and anger. But, that smile also makes her darker thoughts all the more powerful when they break past her inherent goodness. When a kind person wishes ill will on someone, it hits much harder than when a commando says he will slaughter the enemy.
We engage in some small talk before we hit the streets of Stepanakert. It’s no surprise – if you know me even a little – that “Casablanca” comes up. And Lika loves that movie, too, and even quotes one of the lines from Ilsa, aka Ingrid Bergman. “I hate this war so much.”
She also says the war has introduced her to Joan Baez and the song “Donna Donna”, which I’ve never heard.
Our first stop is another school converted to a bomb shelter. There are children here. After an hour or so, we leave to get some lunch.
On the way, in our van driven by Arshak, a veteran of the war here in the 1990s, Angelika gets news that sends her spirits soaring, sends her “riding high”. Her brother is home from the front. Arshak speeds the Honda van to her house. As we get near, another car is pulling up and a man is getting out. It’s her brother.
“Stop! Stop!” she screams . “That’s my brother.” I slide open the van’s side door and before I can even get out, Lika is climbing over me and onto the street. She rushes to her brother and they embrace for a long, silent time.
Lika’s brother has been on the front since the beginning. His closest friends, all volunteers, have previous army experience. They have all survived so far, though several other young men they fought alongside, near Martakert, have been killed. Angelika hardly says a word as he and I talk briefly. She’s beaming, bouncing on her toes, hands either clasped behind her back or touching his shoulders.
She says we will go to the best store open and bring back some things to eat. Less than 15 minutes later, we are at a store called Gurman, a corner market type of place the size of a Seven-Eleven. I wander around, grab some chocolate bars and notice that Lika is off by herself near the toothpaste shelves. She’s on the phone.
When she approaches me a minute later, she’s not the same jubilant young woman I was just with. She looks like another person. I’ve never seen anyone “shell-shocked”, but I’m guessing they look like Angelika now. Her mother just called to tell her that her favorite cousin has been captured by the Azerbaijani military.
“I don’t know what to think,” Lika says. “I can’t even cry.”
She stands numb in the little market as men in army uniforms pass by. “I’m so afraid. He has a heart of gold. I’m so afraid of what they will do to him. Beat him. Or worse.”
I don’t know what to say. What can I say?
##
Yesterday, I left Stepanakert. I had to say goodbye to Lika, so I go to the school-turned-bomb shelter, three-blocks from my room at the Park Hotel.
At the school, two metal doors are locked with thick iron chains. My phone doesn’t work. I call out her name. Then loudly. Then I yell. Nothing. Then, I think, hell I’m in a war zone, so I scream, big deal. And from the ceiling of my lungs, I roar out “Angelika! Lika! Angelika.” Still no reply. Then I see her appear through the dirty windows. She is so relieved to see me. “I thought they were yelling for me because the Azeris were coming to get me.”
That is her worst fear, she tells me as we go downstairs into a converted classroom where she sleeps.
“I would be more afraid of Azeri hands than Azeri bombs. If a bomb fell on me, I wouldn’t be afraid. I wouldn’t have time to be. But if they got their hands on me? The things they would do to a woman. It’s not that I don’t fear the bombs. If you are a human being you have to be afraid of bombs. But, I think they would do the most horrible things to me. But, still, as much as I hate this war, I am here.”
Lika reports her brother is back at the front. There is no further word about her cousin, although the International Red Cross has been alerted.
She drifts off in thought and comes back.
“Do you remember the fires in Australia a little while ago? The world was so worried about the koala bears that were hurt and killed in the fire. I love koalas. But I wish people would care about Armenians like they care abut koala bears.”
Soon, we say our goodbyes. I go sentimental and steal a line from Casablanca. Swapping out Paris for Stepanakert. She walks back to her new home.
That night, in the calmness of a Yerevan hotel room, I look up the Joan Baez song “Donna Donna” and I understand why Angelika Zakaryan loves it so much.
Calves are easily bound and slaughtered
Never knowing the reason why.
But whoever treasures freedom,
Like the swallow has learned to fly.
##
Michael Krikorian is a writer from Los Angeles. He was previously a reporter for the Los Angeles Times and for the Fresno Bee. He writes under the pseudonym “Jimmy Dolan” for the Mozza Tribune. His website is and his first novel is called “Southside”.
Offices of 1st, 2nd Presidents of Armenia comment on their readiness to go to Moscow
20:13,
YEREVAN, OCTOBER 30, ARMENPRESS. The Offices of the 1st and 2nd Presidents of Armenia, Levon Ter-Petrosyan and Robert Kocharyan have commented on the information of their willingness to leave for Moscow.
ARMENPRESS reports, citing ‘’Ilur’’ news website, the spokesperson of the 1st President of Armenia Arman Musinyan said,
‘’Now our country is in complicated war situation and for avoiding misunderstanding and speculations, we will give detailed clarification over this issue only after the end of the crisis’’.
The statement of the Office of the 2nd President of Armenia says that 2nd and 3rd Presidents of Nagorno Karabakh Republic offered Robert Kocharyan to leave for Moscow, but he is unable to go because of being infected with coronavirus.
”The President accepted the reasonability of the offer, but his exit from the country was closed for the well-known reason. Following the conversation between the Prime Minster and Arkadi Ghukasyan and Bako Sahakyan (former NKR Presidents – edit.), the court allowed President Kocharyan to leave the country/with the limitation of exit permit until November 7/ and returned his passport.
Robert Kocharyan was planning to leave for Moscow in the nearest days and passed COVID-19 test for that, which is mandatory for the entry to the Russian Federation.
The result of the test was positive, which was very unexpected, since he had and now has no symptoms.
Unfortunately, in this situation departure to Moscow and holding different meetings becomes temporarily impossible.
Now President Kocharyan is in self-isolation, but makes all efforts to contribute to the cessation of hostilities in Artsakh”, reads the statement of the Office of the former President of Armenia Robert Kocharyan.
Earlier today, Mane Gevorgyan, the spokesperson of the Prime Minister, wrote on her Facebook page that first and second Presidents of Armenia Levon Ter-Petrosyan and Robert Kocharyan want to leave for Moscow to discuss with the Russian elites the situation over Nagorno Karabakh and offer concrete solutions to the Armenian Government based on the discussions.
Azerbaijani armed forces bomb Syunik Province of the Republic of Armenia
22:19,
YEREVAN, OCTOBER 30, ARMENPRESS. The Azerbaijani armed forces used artillery against Davit Bek village of Syunik Province of the Republic of Armenia, ARMENPRESS reports representative of the MoD Armenia Artsrun Hovhannisyan said in a press conference.
”In this direction military operations took place and the Azerbaijani artillery fired, resulting in concrete consequences’’, Hovhannisyan said.
Artsakh downs two more Azerbaijani UAVs
22:59,
YEREVAN, OCTOBER 26, ARMENPRESS. The Defense Army of Artsakh has destroyed two more Azerbaijani UAVs, ARMENPRESS reports spokesperson of Artsakh’s President Vahram Poghosyan wrote on his Facebook page.
”Two hostile unlucky UAVs fell down a while ago due to the skillfulness of our soldiers”, Poghosyan wrote.
Since September 27 the Armenian side has downed at least 222 UAVs.
U.S. Embassy in Azerbaijan warns its citizens of kidnapping and terrorism risks
22:35,
YEREVAN, OCTOBER 24, ARMENPRESS. The U.S. Embassy in Baku has warned its citizens and foreigners about kidnapping and terrorism risks, ARMENPRESS was informed from the official website of the Embassy.
”The U.S. Embassy in Baku has received credible reports of potential terrorist attacks and kidnappings against U.S. citizens and foreign nationals in Baku, including against hotels such as the J.W. Marriott Absheron, as well as potentially other locations in Baku. U.S. citizens are advised to exercise heightened caution in locations where Americans or foreigners may gather.
Actions to Take:
- Exercise caution and remain vigilant.
- Avoid crowds.
- Keep a low profile.
- Be aware of your surroundings.
- Stay alert in locations frequented by foreigners.
- Monitor local media for updates”.
On October 23 the U.S. Embassy in Turkey issued a similar statement.
RFE/RL Armenian Report – 10/20/2020
Tuesday,
Russia, France Vow More Joint Efforts For Karabakh Peace
France - French President Emmanuel Macron, right, welcomes Russian President
Vladimir Putin at the Elysee Palace in Paris, December 9, 2019
Russian President Vladimir Putin and his French counterpart Emmanuel Macron
pledged on Tuesday to continue coordinating their efforts to stop the war in
Nagorno-Karabakh and restart Armenian-Azerbaijani peace talks.
In a statement, the Kremlin reported that during a phone conversation they
discussed “in detail” the latest developments in the Karabakh conflict zone.
It said Putin briefed Macron on Russia’s efforts to “prevent a further
escalation of hostilities and quickly resume negotiations aimed at a
politico-diplomatic settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh problem.”
They “emphasized the importance” of the conflicting parties’ compliance with
ceasefire agreements that were brokered by Russia and France on October 10 and
October 17 respectively, read the statement. It added that the two leaders also
pledged to continue the “close coordination” of their peace efforts.
France, Russia as well as the United States lead the OSCE Minsk Group tasked
with helping to find a solution to the Karabakh conflict.
The conflicting parties accuse each other of not respecting the ceasefire
agreements. They both reported on Tuesday continued heavy fighting between
Armenian and Azerbaijani forces at frontline sections south of Karabakh.
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov spoke, meanwhile, of continuing international
efforts to stop the fighting and kick-start the peace process. He did not go
into details.
Speaking to journalists in Moscow, Peskov refused to comment on speculation that
Moscow is trying to organize a meeting of Armenian Prime Minister Nikol
Pashinian and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev.
In interviews with the official Russian TASS news agency, both Pashinian and
Aliyev expressed readiness on Monday to hold face-to-face talks in Moscow.
Pompeo To Meet Armenian, Azeri FMs
• Tatevik Lazarian
U.S. -- U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo speaks during a news conference at
the State Department, in Washington, October 14, 2020
Armenia and Azerbaijan confirmed on Tuesday that their foreign ministers will
separately meet with U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo in Washington later
this week for talks on the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.
Citing “U.S. government documents,” Politico.com reported that Pompeo’s meetings
with Armenian Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanian and his Azerbaijani
counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov are scheduled for Friday.
The Armenian Foreign Ministry confirmed the information. The ministry
spokeswoman, Anna Naghdalian, said preparations for Mnatsakanian’s visit to
Washington are already underway.
Naghdalian would not say whether Mnatsakanian and Bayramov could also meet with
each other in the U.S. capital.
“I have no information about a meeting in a different format or preparations for
it,” she told RFE/RL’s Armenian service.
According to Politico.com, Azerbaijan’s ambassador to the United States did not
rule out the possibility of face-to-face talks between the two ministers.
Bayramov and Mnatsakanian most recently met in Moscow on October 9-10. The
11-hour talks mediated by Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov resulted in an
Armenian-Azerbaijani agreement to stop fighting around Karabakh and resume
“substantive” peace talks.
The hostilities have continued since then, however, with the conflicting parties
accusing each of not respecting the ceasefire deal.
Joe Biden, President Donald Trump’s Democratic rival in the November 3
presidential election, last week expressed deep concern over the “collapse” of
the ceasefire and accused the Trump administration of being “largely passive and
disengaged.”
Pompeo has repeatedly called for an end to the Armenian-Azerbaijani war that
broke out on September 27. He has also criticized Turkey’s military support for
Azerbaijan in the conflict.
The United States, Russia and France have long been leading international
efforts to end the Karabakh conflict in their capacity as co-chairs of the Minsk
Group of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe.
Armenia Calls For Wider Ban On Drone Technology Sales To Turkey
Nagorno-Karabakh -- An Armenian Defense Ministry photo that purportedly shows a
fragment of a Turkish-manufactured combat drone shot down in Nagorno-Karabakh,
.
Armenia on Tuesday urged more Western nations to suspend the export of drone
technology to Turkey as it publicized purported evidence of Turkish unmanned
aerial vehicles (UAVs) used by Azerbaijan in the ongoing war over
Nagorno-Karabakh.
The Armenian Defense Ministry released photographs of what it described as
fragments of a Turkish-made combat drone Bayraktar TB2 allegedly shot down by
Karabakh Armenian forces on Monday.
The ministry spokeswoman, Shushan Stepanian, said one of the photos depicts the
drone’s largely intact imaging and targeting system manufactured by a
Canadian-based firm, L3Harris Wescam.
“It was manufactured by the Canadian company Wescam in June 2020 and installed
on Bayraktar TB2 in September 2020,” she said.
The Canadian government temporarily banned the sale of such equipment to Turkey
October 5 just over a week after the outbreak of the worst hostilities in the
Karabakh conflict zone since the early 1990s.
Nagorno-Karabakh -- An Armenian Defense Ministry photo that purportedly shows a
fragment of a Turkish-manufactured combat drone shot down in Nagorno-Karabakh,
.
The move was hailed by Yerevan but criticized by Ankara. It followed a statement
by Canadian arms control group Project Ploughshares saying that video of air
strikes carried out by Azerbaijani army drones indicates that they are equipped
with imaging and targeting systems manufactured by L3Harris Wescam.
A Turkish company manufacturing Bayraktar reportedly also buys components from
other Western countries.
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian claimed that Karabakh’s Armenian-backed
Defense Army has shot down about a dozen such UAVs so far.
“None of the destroyed drones fell on territory controlled by the Defense Army
[until Monday.] We now seem to finally possess fragments of Bayraktar,” he wrote
on Facebook.
UKRAINE – A Turkish-made Bayraktar combat drone purchased for Ukraine's Armed
Forces, March 20, 2019
Pashinian described the publicized photos as further proof of Turkey’s “direct
involvement” in the war. “Based on this fact, those countries that supply Turkey
with necessary parts of Bayraktar should follow Canada’s example and suspend
further supplies,” he said.
Armenia has also accused Turkey of deploying Turkish military personnel and
Syrian mercenaries to Azerbaijan ahead of the war. The Turkish and Azerbaijani
governments deny that.
Baku has admitted heavily using Turkish as well as Israeli drones against
Armenian targets. But it insists that they belong to and are operated by the
Azerbaijani army.
According to exports data cited by the Reuters news agency, Turkey’s military
exports to Azerbaijan have risen six-fold this year, with sales of drones and
other military equipment rising to $77 million last month alone. Most of the
purchased drones, rocket launchers, ammunition and other weapons were delivered
after July.
UN Security Council Again Discusses Karabakh
• Armen Koloyan
The United Nations Security Council meets at UN headquarters in New York,
February 28, 2020.
The United Nations Security Council again discussed the continuing war over
Nagorno-Karabakh late on Monday at a meeting initiated by France, Russia and the
United States and, the three world powers trying to end the Armenian-Azerbaijani
conflict.
Vasily Nebenzya, the Russian ambassador to the UN who chaired the closed-door
meeting, said it discussed ways of ensuring the conflicting parties’ compliance
with ceasefire agreements.
“It is now necessary to ensure the implementation, this is the most pressing
issue because a relevant agreement was reached but not respected,” the TASS news
agency quoted Nebenzya as saying. “The main question remains how to ensure a
verification of its implementation.”
“This issue was certainly discussed during the consultations, and the council
was quite unanimous in its approach,” he told reporters in New York.
Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said earlier on Monday that Moscow keeps
pressing Armenia and Azerbaijan to work out a ceasefire “verification
mechanism.” He said the Russian Defense Ministry is also involved in these
efforts.
Lavrov suggested last week that such a mechanism would involve the deployment of
“military observers” to the conflict zone.
Nebenzya did not exclude that the observers would be deployed by and operate
under the aegis of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe
(OSCE). “The questions of who will be there and in what capacity remain open and
under discussion,” said the Russian diplomat.
The OSCE’s Minsk Group co-headed by Russia, France and the U.S. has long been
the main international body trying to broker a solution to the Karabakh
conflict. All three co-chair nations are permanent members of the UN Security
Council.
The council already discussed the situation in the Karabakh conflict zone on
September 29 two days after the outbreak of the war. It called for an immediate
end to the fighting.
The fighting in and around Karabakh reportedly continued on Monday night and on
Tuesday. The Armenian Defense Ministry said in the morning that Karabakh’s
Armenian-backed army is trying to repel a continuing Azerbaijani offensive at a
frontline section south of Karabakh.
The Azerbaijani military said, for its part, that Armenian forces shelled its
frontline positions overnight.
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2020 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
CivilNet: Day 18, Diary of War, Artsakh | Don’t lose hope, believe in magic
There has been no phone call from my brother since yesterday. Dad was trying to reach him every 10 minutes. “Did he call? No? He did not call me either. I thought, maybe he called you? Ah.. okay. Let me know when he does.” Every 10 minutes! We were terrified to think of possible reasons for his silence. He knows, life stops in this part of the world, when there is no call.
Mom, dad and I went to our home today, for an hour. Mom started cooking french fries, dad was watching the statements of Harutyunyan and Pashinyan on TV and I went to my room. I looked around and thought – is there anything in this room I won’t be able to live without? If my home disappears tomorrow what I will miss the most? Maybe “Fahrenheit 451,” my favorite book? Or acrylic dye? Or maybe a photo album? Oh, this one- my favorite dress! No, wait.. maybe earrings I bought in Würzburg, my favorite city… or mom’s scarf.. or maybe my sister’s favorite jacket? I could not make up my mind…
Eventually, I decided not to take anything. Because it would have meant that there is a chance (which, in fact is real) that my house might not exist.
We have been building our house all our lives, have been changing it, improving, adding more and more to make it special. And to lose it within seconds, to end up without your own hearth, without our little corner in a big and strange world – such thoughts break our hearts. And I am not ready to put up with it! So, I did not take anything from my home. If there is a choice- my choice is to keep it all.
And you know what? The phone rang. it was him, my brother! Filled with emotions and excitement, I could not help crying, I was talking and laughing and crying. “All is okay”- this is what they usually say to us. A few months ago, I lent some money to him for his education. We are very close to each other. And today I told him ” You know what – I remove your debt. You just come back safe as soon as possible. And he said ” Oh, realy? If I only knew, I would have taken more!” We laughed for 7 minutes.
Then I asked my dad to give me a lift to my office. On September 22, it was my cameraman’s birthday. My cameraman, my best friend, my boyfriend. I made a present for him- fish. I wanted these fish to share our space. When the war broke out, we still were going there, to feed them, under shellfire. But when my friend had been drafted, there was no chance to go by, ( the city had been bombed heavily and I was alone) and I thought our fish had gone. That though hurt a lot. So, I went into the office, to the aquarium. The fish were there, but they didn’t move. I kept saying in my mind “Be alive, please, be alive!”
They did not move. And I thought- this is it, so many days, without food. How will I live with such a sin in my heart? I mean, they only recently became members of our office, our second home. I sat next to them, almost crying and suddenly, I saw them move. One fish moved, then another… I jumped up, hugged the aquarium and started crying. I hurried to give them their food and was begging them to see the food and eat it. They saw, they ate. I decided not to leave them alone any more and took them. They are in my shelter now, until their owner returns.
I changed the water, added more feed and have been checking on them every five minutes.
This fish story is a true sign for me today, that we should not lose hope. Even when it seems there is no one, life can reward us a surprise and give us strength to live.