The death of an Armenian opposition politician in detention has brought renewed scrutiny to the country’s justice system.
On November 10th, Arsen Gevorgyan, a member of the opposition Strong Armenia party who was running for mayor in Stepanavan, died at Yerevan’s Nubarashen prison, where he had been held since his arrest on October 21st, just four days before the local elections, on voter bribery charges that he denied. The following day, protesters gathered outside the EU Delegation in Yerevan, demanding answers and calling on European institutions to respond.
Armenian authorities have launched a criminal investigation into Gevorgyan’s death and ordered a forensic examination. Justice Minister Srbuhi Galyan has said that Gevorgyan had not previously reported health problems, while his lawyers have questioned the adequacy of the medical response, allegations the prison authorities deny. Armenia’s Human Rights Defender has also initiated an inquiry into the circumstances. His cause of death has yet to be conclusively established, but the case has revived concerns about the use of pretrial detention and the treatment of defendants in politically sensitive proceedings.
Gevorgyan’s death comes amid mounting warnings from human rights organisations and international institutions about Armenia’s commitment to the rule of law. For the European Union, which has invested considerable political capital in bringing Yerevan closer to the West, those warnings now present an uncomfortable dilemma. How far can Brussels continue supporting Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan without demanding greater accountability for the conduct of his government?
Warnings that can no longer be ignored
Concerns about Armenia’s justice system have been accumulating for some time. In its 2026 World Report, Human Rights Watch highlighted warnings from Armenian civil society organisations about judicial independence, ineffective investigations into police abuse and excessive pretrial detention. The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe likewise raised concerns following June’s parliamentary election, documenting criminal proceedings against opposition candidates and activists that discouraged political participation and raised questions about selective enforcement of the law.
The widespread use of pretrial detention is particularly troubling. According to judicial statistics reported by CivilNet, the number of prosecution motions for detention increased from 2,913 in 2023 to 3,530 in 2025, even as the proportion approved by courts declined from 72.7% to 60.9%. While these figures alone cannot establish whether individual detention requests were justified, they point to a growing reliance on a measure intended to be exceptional. Detention should protect the integrity of judicial proceedings, not serve as punishment before a defendant has been convicted.
Brussels is well aware of these concerns. During the EU-Armenia Human Rights Dialogue in July, European officials urged Armenia to improve detention conditions, address prison overcrowding and expand alternatives to pretrial detention. Yet four months later, the death of an opposition politician in custody has brought renewed attention to precisely those issues. In an interview with CivilNet, legal expert Varazdat Harutyunyan criticised systemic deficiencies in prison medical care and argued that detention was being used to exert pressure on political opponents.
The warnings extend beyond the country’s prisons. A recent Deutsche Welle investigation reported growing concern among Armenian civil society organisations about prosecutions targeting government critics, including cases arising from social media posts. Taken together, these developments raise serious questions about the independence of institutions that should protect citizens from the arbitrary exercise of state power.
When judicial decisions fail to protect businesses
The treatment of businesses associated with political opponents has added another dimension to these concerns. In July, Armenian investigators searched and sealed numerous premises linked to opposition politician and businessman Gagik Tsarukyan, disrupting operations across his Multi Group conglomerate. Tsarukyan faces fraud and money-laundering allegations, which authorities are entitled to investigate. But the legitimacy of an investigation does not automatically justify the prolonged closure of businesses, particularly when employees and commercial partners bear the consequences.
Among those affected was Euromotors, the official Armenian distributor of BMW and MINI, whose showrooms and service centre were temporarily shut before reopening in September. According to a report published on November 5, courts had found investigative measures against four companies, including Euromotors, Multi Tabak, Olympavan and Multi Stone, unlawful. Prosecutorial appeals were reportedly rejected in three cases, yet lawyers representing the businesses maintained that several operations had still not resumed.
Such allegations strike at the heart of judicial independence. Investigators cannot be permitted to treat court decisions as optional simply because they interfere with an ongoing prosecution. Nor should legitimate commercial activity be suspended indefinitely without adequate legal grounds. If businesses remain closed despite binding judicial decisions requiring restrictions to be lifted, the problem goes far beyond the immediate financial damage. It calls into question whether Armenia’s courts can exercise meaningful authority over the state, while European commercial interests are also exposed to these uncertainties.
The human cost of political prosecutions
Beyond their economic consequences, these proceedings have also raised troubling questions about the treatment of defendants. The case of Gagik Khachatryan offers a particularly disturbing example. In September, the 71-year-old former finance minister, who suffers from serious spinal health problems, was brought to court on a stretcher before being remanded in custody. Footage released by his lawyers showed him being carried from his home by security officers, prompting allegations of inhumane treatment.
His lawyers subsequently sought urgent intervention from the European Court of Human Rights over his detention and access to medical care, although the request for interim measures was rejected, with a decision on the merits of the case still pending. Armenian prosecutors have disputed the defence’s assessment of his medical condition. Whatever the eventual findings, the images should serve as a reminder that the protection of fundamental rights cannot depend on a defendant’s political history, public reputation or the seriousness of the allegations against him.
Gevorgyan’s death has now made that principle impossible to ignore. The circumstances of the two cases differ, and neither should be prejudged. But the combination of an elderly defendant transported to court on a stretcher and an opposition politician dying barely three weeks into his detention demands serious scrutiny of how the Armenian state exercises its powers over people who have not been convicted.
An appeal to Europe, not a rejection of it
The demonstrations following Gevorgyan’s death are particularly revealing. Protesters gathered outside the EU Delegation not to condemn Europe, but to appeal to it for help. Harutyun Harutyunyan, a Strong Armenia lawmaker, made clear that the demonstration was not directed against the EU ambassador or his delegation, adding that the party intended to submit further information to European partners. Their message was that European institutions should not remain passive in the face of the concerns being raised.
The appeal places Brussels in an increasingly uncomfortable position. Armenia has become an important strategic partner as Pashinyan seeks to reduce the country’s dependence on Russia and strengthen relations with Western institutions. The EU has actively encouraged this realignment, deepening cooperation on economic development, connectivity and security, most recently through the first EU-Armenia summit in May.
Supporting Armenia’s Western aspirations is both legitimate and necessary. The country’s closer integration into European political and economic structures deserves encouragement, particularly given its difficult geopolitical circumstances. Equally, fighting corruption and holding former officials accountable are essential democratic objectives. No politician or businessman should be above the law, and efforts to investigate credible allegations of wrongdoing should not be dismissed simply because the defendants belong to the opposition.
But there must be limits to what Europe is prepared to tolerate in pursuit of those goals. As Deutsche Welle reported, Armenian analysts and civil society representatives have questioned whether Brussels’ geopolitical priorities have made it excessively accommodating of Pashinyan’s treatment of his critics. The EU has publicly affirmed the importance of impartial investigations, yet concerns persist that its desire to strengthen Armenia’s Western orientation has tempered its response to politically sensitive prosecutions.
The danger is that a government’s geopolitical allegiance becomes a substitute for scrutiny of its domestic conduct. Armenia’s democratic future cannot be reduced to a choice between Pashinyan and Moscow, nor should criticism of the prime minister automatically be treated as support for Russia. If the EU demands judicial independence and fundamental rights from governments it regards as adversaries, it must be equally prepared to defend those principles when its strategic partners fall short.
Europe must live up to its own standards
The death of Arsen Gevorgyan represents a deeply troubling development in a country where warnings about excessive detention, selective prosecution and judicial independence have already been accumulating. His death must be independently investigated, but the wider concerns deserve more than another round of diplomatic reassurances. The treatment of Gagik Khachatryan, the reported failure to give effect to judicial decisions concerning business closures, and the potential repercussions for European commercial partners all warrant serious examination.
Brussels must now be prepared to challenge Pashinyan’s government directly, insisting on independent investigations, respect for judicial decisions, effective safeguards against excessive pretrial detention and the protection of detainees’ fundamental rights. Such pressure would not undermine Armenia’s Western aspirations or weaken the fight against corruption. On the contrary, the credibility of both depends on ensuring that the law applies equally, regardless of who stands accused.
The demonstrators outside the EU Delegation were asking Europe to uphold the principles it claims to represent. With an opposition politician now dead in custody, their appeal deserves an answer. Europe’s commitment to the rule of law will ring hollow if it demands accountability from its adversaries while looking the other way when its partners fall short of the same standard.
https://eutoday.net/a-death-in-armenian-custody-raises-questions-europe-cannot-ignore/
—
Disclaimer: This article was contributed and translated into English by Tambiyan Samvel. While we strive for quality, the views and accuracy of the content remain the responsibility of the contributor. Please verify all facts independently before reposting or citing.
Direct link to this article: https://www.armenianclub.com/2026/11/20/a-death-in-armenian-custody-raises-questions-europe-cannot-ignore/