Armenian van transporting bodies of the dead comes under Azerbaijani stone attack

Public Radio of Armenia
March 29 2021

An Armenian van transporting bodies of the dead came under Azerbaijani stone attack on March 28, deputy head of Goris community Irina Yolyan informs.

“The driver says that he left Stepanakert for Goris at night amid thick fog, he felt that the car was being hit by stones. The incident took place at 01:30 am. The driver did not stop, continued driving, and took the bodies to Goris.

Last week the Azerbaijani military threw stones at cars with Armenian license plates on the way to Karmir Shuka village of Karmir village in Artsakh’s Askeran region.

Sanitek Submits investment claim against Armenia

Aysor, Armenia
March 29 2021

Sanitek and its shareholders, all foreign investors have completed the next step in their international arbitration claim against the Republic of Armenia. The foreign investors have now submitted a Request for Arbitration in accordance with Article 36 of the Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States under Article 9 of the Agreement Between the Government of the Republic of Armenia and the Government of the Lebanese Republic on the Promotion and Reciprocal Protection of Investments (the “Lebanon-Armenia BIT”) and Article XIII of the Agreement Between the Government of Canada and the Government of the Republic of Armenia for the Promotion and Protection of Investments (the “Canada-Armenia BIT”). The Request for Arbitration has been filed with the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes in Washington D.C., USA which is a part of the World Bank Group.

The dispute has arisen out of both the Government’s and Yerevan Municipality’s continuing breaches of the Lebanon-Armenia BIT and the Canada-Armenia BIT in relation to Sanitek’s investments in the waste management of the city of Yerevan. More specifically, the dispute stems from the Republic of Armenia’s discriminatory and expropriatory actions, namely the illegal acts of the Yerevan Municipality and other state authorities. Although Sanitek’s work initially achieved high approval ratings from Yerevan residents, the Municipality of Yerevan failed to perform its end of the bargain, and ultimately decided to oust Sanitek and replace it with a government-owned waste collection company while the concession contracts were still in effect. This policy was politically motivated, designed to scapegoat Sanitek for political advantage by blaming the Municipality’s shortcomings in waste management strategy and oversight of the landfill on Sanitek. Indeed, the new state-owned company has benefited from much more favorable conditions than those granted to Sanitek, showing that the Government of Armenia’s treatment of the investors was arbitrary and discriminatory.

Sanitek’s losses as a consequence of both the Government’s and Yerevan Municipality’s illegal acts and omissions are in excess of USD 25 million.

The announcement of Sanitek’s filing of a Request for Arbitration follows the widely reported news in October 2019 that Sanitek had filed a Notice of Intent to Submit a Claim to Arbitration to the Armenian authorities. This Notice of Intent remained unanswered by any state institutions.

The Government of Armenia has shown a hostility to foreign investment, and in particular the new municipal government in Yerevan escalated tensions with Sanitek, pursuing a determined policy to replace it with a municipal company in order to gain political advantage.

In sum, Armenia failed to protect Sanitek’s investments from unreasonable or discriminatory measures and to accord it fair and equitable treatment. Armenia unlawfully expropriated the Claimants’ investments without a legitimate public interest, without due process, on a discriminatory basis, and without paying prompt, adequate, and effective compensation. Sanitek and its investors intend to fully vindicate their rights through arbitration before ICSID.

The Armenian visionaries fighting to create a new contemporary culture for Yerevan

Calvert Journal
March 29 2021

<img height="1" width="1" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=132505190651897&ev=PageView&noscript=1"/>

<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1534116563569885&ev=PageView&noscript=1" />

<img src=”"https://vk.com/rtrg?p=VK-RTRG-254200-hlQp6" style="position:fixed; left:-999px;" alt=""/>

Creative cities: Yerevan

Text: Lucía de la Torre
Images: Hrant Khachatrian

Yerevan’s young creative generation are tireless, resilient, and unafraid of pushing boundaries. Whether their work means creating inclusive art spaces, putting Armenia on the international fashion scene, or encouraging new generations of photographers, they are all united in one mission: pushing the city’s cultural scene to the cutting edge to keep it both alive and thriving.

<img height="1" width="1" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=132505190651897&ev=PageView&noscript=1"/>

<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1534116563569885&ev=PageView&noscript=1" />

<img src=”"https://vk.com/rtrg?p=VK-RTRG-254200-hlQp6" style="position:fixed; left:-999px;" alt=""/>

Anush Babajanyan
<img height="1" width="1" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=132505190651897&ev=PageView&noscript=1"/>

<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1534116563569885&ev=PageView&noscript=1" />

<img src=”"https://vk.com/rtrg?p=VK-RTRG-254200-hlQp6" style="position:fixed; left:-999px;" alt=""/>

Born and bred in Yerevan, Anush Babajanyan believes in photography’s power for social change. Starting with her degree in journalism at the American University in Bulgaria, Babajanyan says “the visual _expression_ pulled me, I loved it. I wanted to photograph way more than I wanted anything else.” It took her ten years to make documentary photography a viable, successful career, but she now boasts collaborations with prestigious publications such as The New York Times and The Washington Post, and a contract with agency VII.

Among her recent reports, Babajanyan’s photographs from Nagorno-Karabakh spotlight the human stories lost between the headlines of the 2020 war that tore through the region, as Armenia and Azerbaijan fought for control of the mountainous land. Babajanyan has been photographing Nagorno-Karabakh for years — always searching to balance out everyday moments of joy and sorrow with the pain and destruction that political conflict has brought to the region. “Documenting what has been going on in Nagorno-Karabakh has brought me closer to understanding why I do what I do,” she told The Calvert Journal. “It’s the question that keeps me searching.” 

Outside of her news reports, one of Babajanyan’s most original photo series, Inlandish, focuses on gender and womanhood. The title is a pun on the outlandish women with bold outfits that she captured in Yerevan. “The women I photograph never consider themselves to be outside the norms of society,” the photographer explained. “Yet every time they walk along the streets of Yerevan, people look at them with amazement. In an environment that is often conservative and controlled by men, these women separate themselves by dressing differently or wearing bright makeup.”

Babajanyan’s impact on Armenian photography goes beyond what she captures on camera. In 2016, a year after the centenary of the Armenian genocide, the photographer co-founded the #BridgingStories project, which brought together dozens of young photographers from Turkey and Armenia to take shots of their own villages and communities, in an effort to promote peace between the two countries.

Three years earlier, she also co-founded women’s photography collective 4Plus, to support the development of professional photographers in Armenia through courses, talks, and exhibitions. 4Plus has since evolved to become a visual media centre focused on promoting documentary photography by photographers of all genders. 

Victoria Aleksanyan

Victoria Aleksanyan is a filmmaker, photographer, and activist. As a director, her work has always been closely tied to Armenia, from Caregivers, her graduation film for Columbia University, to Flights, exploring the themes of migration, After years of working in the Manhattan film scene, Aleksanyan swapped New York for her home city of Yerevan — right on the brink of the 2018 Velvet Revolution, which would overthrow Armenia’s government. “I decided that it was time to go back and make a film in Armenia, to get its stories and narratives out to the world,” she told The Calvert Journal. “But when I started working on my short, I realised many problems were stopping local filmmakers from succeeding, and jumping into the international scene. The state system for film funding, inherited from the Soviet Union, has not been reformed at all. Can you imagine? State funding has such strict budget and time constraints that it is dangerous for the arts. Many filmmakers tried their best, struggled, and failed.”

This sparked the beginning of Aleksanyan’s activism journey. Alongside fellow filmmakers, she founded the IFCA (International Filmmakers Community of Armenia): a non-profit organisation that advocates for effective policy making to boost the local film industry. Two years into their work, after tireless legal research and lobbying, they have almost achieved their main goal: drafting a law that will cut down on bureaucracy and create a new framework for officials and artists to cooperate in order to build the local film industry. Although the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh war put the process on a halt, Aleksanyan is confident that the bill will be implemented soon — and pave the way for other creative industries to follow. “This should have happened decades ago, but it’s never too late. Give it a few years, and the local film industry will be booming with new talent.”

Karen Mirzoyan

<img height="1" width="1" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=132505190651897&ev=PageView&noscript=1"/>

<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1534116563569885&ev=PageView&noscript=1" />

<img src=”"https://vk.com/rtrg?p=VK-RTRG-254200-hlQp6" style="position:fixed; left:-999px;" alt=""/>

Since 2003, Karen Mirzoyan, a Tbilisi-born Armenian photographer, has been on the road, developing his photography career and winning multiple awards for his work. Hovering between photojournalism and art photography, his projects often span several years of research into the cultural and sociopolitical context of a story, and the development of personal relationships. Mirzoyan is a member of the Magnum Photography Foundation, from which he has received several awards for his photo stories Underground Culture in Iran, Illegal Weapons in South Ossetia, and Daily Life in Nagorno-Karabakh Republic. At the heart of his practice are human rights and unseen stories. 

In 2014, the photographer opened the first photographic library in the Caucasus, the Mirzoyan Library. From its inception as a depository for his personal collection of photobooks, Mirzoyan Library has expanded into a bohemian café, bar, and working space, hosting a myriad events and competitions, and becoming the birthplace for collaborations between local creatives.

“Our goal is not to make money through the library, but to have more young people interested in photography coming to the library, and finding everything they need,” explains Mirzoyan. “Books are what made me want to be a photojournalist. I want for new generations of Armenian photographers to have the same opportunity”. 

<img height="1" width="1" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=132505190651897&ev=PageView&noscript=1"/>

<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1534116563569885&ev=PageView&noscript=1" />

<img src=”"https://vk.com/rtrg?p=VK-RTRG-254200-hlQp6" style="position:fixed; left:-999px;" alt=""/>

Anna Mikaelian Meschian <img height="1" width="1" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=132505190651897&ev=PageView&noscript=1"/> <img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1534116563569885&ev=PageView&noscript=1" /> <img src=”"https://vk.com/rtrg?p=VK-RTRG-254200-hlQp6" style="position:fixed; left:-999px;" alt=""/>

A musician, educator, and social entrepreneur, Anna Mikaelian Meschian, a US-raised and Yerevan-based pianist, is one of the driving forces behind the next generation of Armenian musicians. Inspired by El Sistema, a music education programme founded in Venezuela in the 70s, Mikaelian established the Armenian chapter of the movement in 2013. The project slowly evolved from a series of after-school music lessons for children into what it is today: the Nexus Center for the Arts, a music school, “where people who love making music and art can come together and learn from each other,” explains Mikaelian. Today, Nexus’ students range from preschoolers to adults, and the emphasis is clear: “learn to play, compose, sing, bang on a can, whatever you want, but you must be ready to share the joy.”

Although music in all its forms is the beating heart of the project, Nexus is also a deeper community experience — teaching students to learn on their own, work in a team, and produce art that makes them better individuals. “For us, it’s important to give children something they don’t get elsewhere, an environment that is rigorous, but also fun,” Mikaelian tells The Calvert Journal. “It is important for students to learn to make music in ensemble with others, because that develops their listening and empathy skills to those around them.”

Beyond Nexus, Mikaelian also organises events, gives talks, and plays in her own band. When the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh War broke out, Mikaelian, alongside her colleague Sevana Tchakerian, founded the “Nexus for Artsakh” programme, which provided temporarily-displaced children with music and art education in a bid to bring a sense of normality to their lives — an emergency project that reflects the core of her mission to using music as an educational tool.

<img height="1" width="1" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=132505190651897&ev=PageView&noscript=1"/>

<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1534116563569885&ev=PageView&noscript=1" />

<img src=”"https://vk.com/rtrg?p=VK-RTRG-254200-hlQp6" style="position:fixed; left:-999px;" alt=""/>

Vahan Badalyan <img height="1" width="1" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=132505190651897&ev=PageView&noscript=1"/> <img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1534116563569885&ev=PageView&noscript=1" /> <img src=”"https://vk.com/rtrg?p=VK-RTRG-254200-hlQp6" style="position:fixed; left:-999px;" alt=""/>

After graduating from Yerevan’s State University of Theatre and Cinema and working in drama projects in France and Italy, Vahan Badalyan came back to Yerevan in the early 2000s with a clear idea: Armenia needed free, independent theatres, otherwise, contemporary playwriting would die. As a result, he founded the NCA Small Theater: a company championing artistic independence, innovation, and youth drama education.

Twenty years since opening, Badalyan looks back on his journey with pride, and rightly so. Since its inauguration, the Small Theater has produced hundreds of plays, revolutionising traditional performance with contemporary dance, video, photography, and other art forms.

Due to the outdated and stagnating state funding system, very few freelancers get a chance and a platform, and the only opportunities for young artists are to participate in international projects

In 2013, the Small Theater also decided to create the first country’s first dance ensemble with disabled and able-bodied performers. Since then, Badalyan’s inclusive performances have travelled both in and outside of Yerevan, promoting inclusivity in Armenian regions, where disabled people still face major physical and societal obstacles.

There is still a long way ahead for the Armenian theatre scene. “Over the past years, there have been great changes, but our scene still lags behind the contemporary art world. Due to the outdated and stagnating state funding system, very few freelancers get a chance and a platform, and the only opportunities for young artists are to participate in international projects,” explains Badalyan. “We need sustainability for our inclusive work in Armenia, but that cannot happen without government support — although discussions about these topics have begun in recent years.” Badalyan’s latest project, opening a inclusive dance training centre in Yerevan, recently received a green light — another step in the right direction to broaden the Armenian arts scene.

<img height="1" width="1" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=132505190651897&ev=PageView&noscript=1"/>

<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1534116563569885&ev=PageView&noscript=1" />

<img src=”"https://vk.com/rtrg?p=VK-RTRG-254200-hlQp6" style="position:fixed; left:-999px;" alt=""/>

Armine Harutyunyan <img height="1" width="1" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=132505190651897&ev=PageView&noscript=1"/> <img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src=”"https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1534116563569885&ev=PageView&noscript=1" /> <img src=”"https://vk.com/rtrg?p=VK-RTRG-254200-hlQp6" style="position:fixed; left:-999px;" alt=""/>

When artist Armine Harutyunyan walked down the Gucci catwalk during Milan Fashion Week in September 2019 — after being scouted in a Berlin mall — she made history as the first Armenian model to do so. Yet Harutunyan, who was born and bred in Yerevan, is used to being on stage for other reasons. After studying fine art, scenography, and theatre design in Yerevan, she started out her career as a graphic designer, illustrator, and set designer.

“I have been on stage from a young age, first as a ballerina, and then I’ve made a career out of being a set and stage designer. As far as modelling goes, it was just another way for me to be on stage; it all ties together. These are all parts of my life I don’t see myself giving up,” explains Harutyunyan. Creativity runs in the family: she is the granddaughter of Khachatur Azizyan, one of Armenia’s most celebrated living painters, and her grandmother and great-grandfather are also renowned Armenian artists. After her brief modelling stint, she was the target of both sexist hate and xenophobia for her unusual looks. Her advice, as she remarked in an interview to Italian newspaper La Repubblica, “is to concentrate on yourself, on who you are and what you really love”. For her, that is all things arts-related, and Yerevan’s creative atmosphere — which Harutunyan, who is much-loved by locals for her international recognition in the fashion world, proudly praises for its rich cultural heritage, buzzing exhibition schedule and skillful, innovative young artists.

 

Landmines and Hostages are Hindering Peace in Karabakh

The National Interest
March 29 2021
| The National Interest

Serious difficulties remain in implementing the November peace agreement.

by Shahmar Hajiyev

The Second Karabakh War between Armenia and Azerbaijan changed the status quo in a protracted conflict that has lasted for decades. As a result of successful military operations, the Azerbaijani army liberated several districts and villages, including the cultural capital of Azerbaijan, Shusha city. It is worth noting that, during the Second Karabakh War, the Azerbaijani and Armenian armed forces used all types of heavy weapons, including long-range missiles such as the Tochka-U, Scud-B, and Polonez. Some experts also claim that Armenia used Iskander-E missiles against Azerbaijan during the war.

However, the major turning point in the war was the effective use of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV), such as the Turkish-made Bayraktar TB2 and Israeli Harops, by the Azerbaijani army. As a result, the Armenian armed forces suffered heavy losses, both in manpower and weapons. The military operations were stopped owing to Russian intervention on November 10, 2020, when Azerbaijan, Armenia, and Russia signed the Trilateral Agreement. With the November ceasefire agreement, Moscow became a key guarantor for the ceasefire and peace in the region. In accordance with the November Agreement, 1,960 armed troops, ninety armored vehicles, and 380 motor vehicles and special equipment units have been deployed to the Karabakh region. Moreover, the “Joint Russian-Turkish Center for Monitoring the Ceasefire” was opened in the Agdam region to monitor the implementation of the ceasefire.

Thus, the November ceasefire agreement became an important document that ended military operations. According to the agreement, Armenia pledged to return Agdam, Kalbajar, and Lachin districts to Azerbaijani control, while Azerbaijan guaranteed the security of the Lachin Corridor, to be used as a humanitarian connection between Armenia and Armenians in Karabakh.

One could argue that the main impulse for the normalization process during the post-conflict period is economic integration by opening all transport links as envisaged in the November peace agreement. This should be an efficient means for achieving durable peace and stability. Towards this end, a positive signal came on January 11, 2021, when the deputy prime ministers of Azerbaijan, Russia, and Armenia met in Moscow to discuss implementing the November deal’s clauses. This was the first trilateral meeting to discuss future peace in the region. They agreed to establish expert subgroups to deal with the provision of transport, including security, border, customs, sanitary, veterinary, and other types of control relating to rail, road, and combined transport.

Despite these positive dynamics, there are still challenges and difficulties in implementing all clauses of the November deal. The transit of Armenian armed forces and weapons through the Lachin corridor to Karabakh, as well as the Armenian armed forces’ withdrawal from Azerbaijani territories, are among the worrying signals. In addition, there are two main issues that Armenia and Azerbaijan have so far been unable to resolve. The first is the status of the sixty-two Armenian soldiers that Azerbaijani military forces captured in mid-December, a month after the signing of the peace deal. Those soldiers refused to accept the peace deal, continued military operations against the Azerbaijani army, and killed three servicemen and one civilian. In this regard, Baku accuses these soldiers of terrorism and, unlike the POWs who were returned home, has refused to hand them back to Armenia.

However, Azerbaijan recently released a Lebanese citizen, Maral Najaryan, who was previously detained in Karabakh. She entered Azerbaijani territory illegally, thereby violating Azerbaijan law. In addition, Baku has already returned the bodies of 1,400 Armenian military servicemen, facilitated humanitarian aid to the Armenian community of Karabakh, permitted Armenians to visit the Khudavang Monastery in the Kalbajar region of Azerbaijan, and, last but not least, allowed the transportation of Russian natural gas to Armenia via Azerbaijan. By these acts, Baku has shown its goodwill and readiness for future reconciliation. In the meantime, Azerbaijan is demanding that Armenia provide maps of minefields.

It should be highlighted that, after the end of the war, the landmine legacy is a significant challenge in the post-conflict period. The Karabakh region has one of the largest mine contamination problems in the post-Soviet space, and it is very difficult to remove all landmines without maps of the minefields. The Armenian refusal to provide maps of the minefields to Azerbaijan could undermine future peace efforts.

Azerbaijan has already started demining operations throughout the region. According to the Azerbaijan National Agency for Mine Action (ANAMA), since the forty-four-day war, at least 750 unexploded missiles and rockets, 4,500 anti-personnel mines, and 2,000 anti-tank mines have been found and destroyed. It should be noted that demining operations are carried out manually, through demining machines, and with the help of mine detection dogs. In order to improve demining performance and to enhance the safety of de-mining personnel, Azerbaijan has received twenty new, modern MEMATTs (Mechanical Mine Clearing Equipment) from Turkey. Additionally, Turkish mine-clearance experts are training their Azerbaijani counterparts as well as taking part in demining operations.

It is clear that demining efforts in the liberated areas are highly important for Azerbaijan to develop infrastructure and start the settlement plan. Anti-personal landmines continue to pose a major threat to human life in the liberated territories. According to Azerbaijan’s Prosecutor General’s Office, mine explosions have killed fourteen Azerbaijanis, including five Azerbaijani soldiers, since the November deal. Moreover, fifty-two soldiers and eight civilians have been injured as a result of mine explosions. It is clear that many civilians have been falling victim to anti-personal mines during the post-conflict period.

It should be noted that a complete mine clearance of the liberated territories is crucial for sustainable development and the region’s revival. It is exactly this process that will affect the settlement of Azerbaijani internally displaced persons (IDPs) and the region’s economic integration process. Therefore, Azerbaijan is cooperating with the United Nations and other international organizations to accelerate de-mining operations. The UN has provided $2 million to support the emergency humanitarian response in conflict-affected areas of Azerbaijan. With an additional $1 million from United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) Crisis Response and the UN’s Central Emergency Response Fund, UNDP will provide support to ANAMA to train, equip, and deploy emergency response teams to clear mines and unexploded bombs that pose risks to local communities living in conflict-affected areas.

The scale of the contamination by landmines and other types of unexploded ordnance is large; it will, therefore, take several years to completely clear the territory and, without access to maps of the minefields, demining operations become very difficult. Armenia should provide minefield maps to Azerbaijan and to peacekeepers as an indication of its intention for peace. Such action will accelerate demining operations and enhance mutual trust between the parties.

In the end, strengthening the post-conflict demining efforts is significant, and Armenia can help Azerbaijan by providing minefield maps. That is the most effective way to support peaceful coexistence as well as to address humanitarian concerns in the region. Additionally, Azerbaijan should support mine-risk education and capacity building across the region in order to reduce risks of future human casualties as well as increase the share of land used for agriculture and housing.

Shahmar Hajiyev is a leading advisor in the Center of Analysis of International Relations, (AIR Center), in Baku, Azerbaijan.

Image: Reuters.

https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/landmines-and-hostages-are-hindering-peace-karabakh-181429

ARF’s Ishkhan Saghatelyan says police used force to detain his three relatives after Sunday’s rally

Panorama, Armenia
March 29 2021
    

The Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF, Dashnaktsutyun) party’s Supreme Council of Armenia member Ishkhan Saghatelyan, who coordinates the activities of the opposition Homeland Salvation Movement, said police used force to detain his three relatives after the opposition rally in downtown Yerevan on Sunday.

“The Turks [referring to police officers] attacked my aunt, brother and nephew in central Yerevan and detained them,” he wrote on .

The opposition leader warned Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan against attempts to pressure the opposition, adding they will continue to take every effort to remove him from office.

https://www.panorama.am/en/news/2021/03/29/Ishkhan-Saghatelyan/2477029 

65th session of UN commission held under Armenia’s chairmanship concludes with adoption of outcome document urging equality for women

Panorama, Armenia
March 29 2021

On 26 March, the 65th session of the UN Commission on the Status of Women (CSW) held under the chairmanship of Permanent Representative of Armenia to the United Nations Mher Margaryan drew to a close with the unanimous adoption of the Agreed Conclusions on “Women's full and effective participation and decision-making in public life, as well as the elimination of violence, for achieving gender equality and the empowerment of all women and girls”.

Addressing the delegates in the UN General Assembly hall before the adoption of the document, Mher Margaryan emphasized the importance of achieving an agreed outcome under the challenging circumstances posed by the COVID-19 pandemic. He expressed appreciation for the efforts of the delegations involved in the extensive negotiations that lasted several weeks, stressing the importance of the adopted document for the promotion of full and effective participation of women and girls in all aspects of public life and elimination of violence against them, Armenia’s Permanent Mission to the UN reported. 

The Agreed Conclusions set recommendations on the measures for full and equal participation of women in all areas of public life, including in the government and public sector. The document calls for legislative changes to eliminate discrimination against women, development of innovative measures, respective targets and timelines to ensure equal participation of women in the executive, legislative and judicial branches of government. The document also reaffirms the importance of engaging women in peace processes and outlines recommendations for the elimination of all forms of violence against women and girls.

One of the most substantive deliberative events of the the UN calendar, the session of the Commission on the Status of Women featured statements by high-ranking officials from more than 100 countries, with thousands of representatives of more than 800 civil society organizations from various countries following the session. The session also featured multiple virtual side events on various aspects of gender equality and women empowerment.

“Slaves to Turkey”: A former child soldier on Turkey’s teenaged Syrian mercenaries

Panorama, Armenia
March 29 2021
Politics 13:01 29/03/2021Region

American reporter Lindsey Snell published another article about the use of mercenaries by Turkey in various wars. In the article on North Press Agency, the journalist reveals that Turkey has recruited young children and made them mercenaries. The full article is below. 

In 2012, as the revolution in Syria exploded, Fajr Maaliki (a pseudonym) was 12 years old and in the 6th grade. Maaliki’s large extended family stretched across the Idlib countryside, and when the Free Syrian Army (FSA) formed to fight against the Syrian government, many of his relatives joined. “Around 40 of the men in my family became FSA fighters. My father didn’t join the FSA, but he supported them.”

Maaliki was 13 years old when pro-government militias neared the outskirts of his village and he first took up arms. “I went with my cousins,” he recalled. “At this point, none of us had really had any training. It didn’t matter. We went and we fought.”

Maaliki was supposed to take an Arabic exam at school the day he went to his first battle. “I missed that exam and didn’t go back to school again,” he said. “When I got home that night, my mother cried and begged me not to fight again, but of course, I did.” Maaliki’s male relatives had no issue with his young age. Neither did his first FSA commander, who praised him for leaving school to join the fight.

Much of Maaliki’s teen years unfolded on Syrian battlefields. “There were some dangerous times. When I was 14 years old, I was fighting in a battle in the northern countryside of Aleppo. My faction was besieged by the Assad regime, and many of them were killed. I was stuck in one place for three days with one other boy my age. We ate from the garbage. When the siege was finally broken, I think we were both surprised to get out alive.”

Maaliki says roughly a dozen teenagers from his village joined the FSA in the first two years of the war. “Fighting seemed more important than anything else. Back then, there weren’t as many child soldiers in the Syrian opposition as there are now, but it wasn’t uncommon,” he said.

In September 2014, ISIS was approaching the peak of its power in Syria. The group had started to fight against the Free Syrian Army and Al-Nusra Front, Syria’s al-Qaeda affiliate, despite having previously allied with both in the fight against Syrian government forces. While embedded with the FSA on a reporting trip, I visited the frontlines against ISIS in the northern countryside of Aleppo for an MSNBC documentary. As I filmed the fighters preparing for battle, I saw a boy who looked no older than 13 years old carrying an AK-47. “Can you ask him how old he is?” I asked one of the English-speaking fighters.

“This is my brother,” he replied. “He’s 17. He just looks younger.”

In 2014, the United States launched the Train and Equip Program, which aimed to provide training and weaponry to select “moderate” factions of the FSA to enable them to fight ISIS. One of the key factions selected was Harakat Hazm, which had thousands of fighters in and around Aleppo and Idlib.

In March 2015, Al-Nusra Front attacked Harakat Hazm, effectively dissolving the faction. The weapons and other aid given to Hazm by the US government were stolen by Nusra. Nusra became more powerful in Idlib and Aleppo, erecting checkpoints outside of their own territories and exerting more control over FSA factions.

While ISIS’ brutality became universally known, both through its actions in Syria and Iraq and in the slickly-produced propaganda films it proudly disseminated, Al-Nusra Front, Syria’s al-Qaeda affiliate, seemed almost gentle by comparison. “Nusra was kinder to the civilians than ISIS, and they offered higher salaries and better training for fighters than the Free Syrian Army, so they became more popular. Many FSA fighters left to join Nusra,” Fajr Maaliki said. “And then, Nusra started to recruit children.”

Maaliki said that Abdullah al-Muhaysini, a Saudi Arabian salafist cleric who served as a leader in Al-Nusra Front, became a fixture at mosques in Maaliki’s area. “He would come with Nusra fighters from each neighborhood, and they would meet with men to encourage them to join Nusra. They held camps to preach to local children and recruit them to fight, too.”

In a video filmed at a youth indoctrination event in Idlib, Muhaysini said that boys joining Nusra should be at least 15 years old. Maaliki says he personally knew several boys who began fighting for Nusra when they were 13 or 14. “In 2016, when the major battle between the Assad regime and the Syrian opposition for Aleppo started, my FSA faction went there to fight. We were fighting alongside Al-Nusra Front, and I ran into a Nusra member I’d met before. His name was Mustafa Waasel. He was killed by shelling in that battle, in the first week of June 2016. He was 14 years old when he died.”

Maaliki continued to fight for the Syrian opposition as the years dragged on. “2016 and 2017 were the hardest years for me. The Syrian opposition factions were not paying fighters consistently. I couldn’t buy shoes. I could barely buy food. I was 16 and 17 years old at the time,” he said.

Then, in December 2017, most factions of the Free Syrian Army were merged into the so-called Syrian National Army (SNA), which was under the direct supervision and support of the Turkish government. “After this, the payments to fighters were made more consistently. We were hopeful that things would improve for the Syrian opposition. But then, the Afrin operation began,” Maaliki said.

In January 2018, Turkey launched Operation “Olive Branch,” attacking the predominantly Kurdish city of Afrin in northern Syria. The Turkish Air Force bombed the city, and the Turkish-backed SNA factions unleashed a ground offensive. “As Turkey started recruiting more men to fill these SNA factions for their Afrin operation, they started recruiting more children, too,” Maaliki said. “And that continues to this day. There are so many children among the SNA factions now.”

Maaliki says the SNA fighters were misled about the true purpose of the operation in Afrin. “The Turks told us the YPG [a predominantly Kurdish, US-allied militia] and ISIS were working together to fight us from Afrin. They said the YPG wanted to do what Israel has done; to create a state within Syria just for the Kurds, and that they would try to occupy Idlib, and the Aleppo countryside, all the way to Latakia.

“But when I was in Afrin after the invasion began, I saw how the SNA factions robbed the civilians, and kidnapped them, and raped women,” Maaliki continued. “I saw Turkey occupy Afrin. We were not fighting Assad in Afrin. The battle had nothing to do with our revolution against the Syrian regime.”

Eventually, Maaliki was assigned to work as a prison guard in Afrin. “There was a very old man arrested by the Hamza Division [faction of the SNA],” he recalled. “He was too old to even walk properly. I asked one of the commanders why he had been arrested, and he said the man planned to plant a bomb in one of our military points. I knew this wasn’t true. I could tell by looking at the old man that he wouldn’t be able to do anything like this.

“When I was left alone with the man, I asked him what really happened,” Maaliki continued. “He told me the Hamza Division men had stormed his home for the purpose of stealing it. They arrested him, but before they brought him to the prison, they raped his daughter in the next room.”

The prisoner gave Maaliki the exact location of his home in the Ashrafieh neighborhood or Afrin. “Go there,” the prisoner told him. “You will see that there are soldiers in my home. You will know I am telling the truth.”

A short time later, Maaliki left the SNA, returned to Idlib. He considers himself an activist now, and he closely monitors the situation in his and other opposition-held areas. “Right now, I have estimated that there are more than 500 children between the different factions,” Maaliki said. “It is because of their extreme poverty. They aren’t fighting for a cause. They are just trying to survive. Turkey is preying on all of them.”

Maaliki began collecting photos and information on child militants in the SNA. “I felt bad for them, because I was a child who fought, and I don’t want them to have the experiences I did. But they’re in a worse situation than I was. When the war started, I could read. Most of the child fighters today cannot read. Many of their fathers have died fighting. They are being taken advantage of by Turkey and the corrupt SNA commanders.”

Before Maaliki left Afrin in 2018, he recalls walking by a headquarters for the Sultan Murad faction of the SNA. “I heard music and laughing, so I stopped to look in the windows,” he said. “I thought I saw two women dancing in front of three Sultan Murad commanders. But once I looked more closely, I saw that they were young boys dressed in women’s clothing.” Maaliki said that once the men began raping the two boys, he could no longer bear to watch and fled the scene.

Maaliki says the practice of Syrian opposition commanders sexually abusing male children has existed since the beginning of the war in Syria, but that it is more common now than ever before. He cites Turkey’s involvement in the Libyan conflict as a major factor.

In December 2019, Turkey struck a deal with the Tripoli-based Government of National Accord (GNA) and began deploying thousands of Syrian National Army militants to Tripoli and Misrata. In interviews conducted with Libya-based SNA members, they revealed that the GNA forces have gone to great lengths to keep the majority of them apart from the local civilian population.

“Now that Turkey has sent the SNA factions to Libya, there are SNA commanders who don’t have access to women,” Maaliki said. “They are away from their wives. And they have brought young boys to Libya who are there for the sole purpose of being sexually used by them. They call them al-firakh [baby birds]. The practice is completely accepted among the SNA, and the young boys don’t know any better.”

In March 2020, a report by human rights organization Syrians for Truth and Justice alleged that Turkey recruited child soldiers to send them to Libya. Maaliki bristles at its mention. “Each SNA faction that sent men Libya had a quota of fighters to fill. So naturally, child soldiers ended up among the militants in Libya,” he said.

“It is not that Turkey recruited the children for Libya. It is that for years, there have been child soldiers in the SNA and the FSA. This issue existed long before Turkey sent the first Syrian to Libya, and it will exist long after the last Syrian leaves Libya,” Maaliki said. “Do the Syrian children who are fighting only matter when they leave Syria? Because it should be clear that when Turkey sent SNA to Azerbaijan [to support Azerbaijani forces in their attack on Nagorno-Karabakh in September 2020], there were children among them, as well.”

Fajr Maaliki doesn’t have high hopes for the future of Syria or its youth. “Our revolution is dead. The Syrian National Army are just mercenaries for Turkey. Erdogan has sent us to Libya, to Azerbaijan. There are many rumors about where the SNA will be sent next. The young generation, those who were babies when the war started, are illiterate, uneducated, and naive. I think they will remain slaves to Turkey.” 

MP: Constitutional Court ruling came as a ‘cold shower’ for Pashinyan

Panorama, Armenia
March 29 2021

Independent MP Gevorg Petrosyan on Monday praised the ruling of Armenia’s Constitutional Court that found Article 300․1 of the Criminal Code unconstitutional and invalid.

The ruling issued by the top court on Friday says that Article 300.1 concerning the “overthrowing the constitutional order”, under which former President Robert Kocharyan and three other former senior officials are being prosecuted, runs counter to Articles 78 and 79 of the Constitution. The articles deal with the principles of proportionality and certainty.

"Indeed, the Constitutional Court was at the height,” Petrosyan told a news conference, adding such a ruling was probably not expected given the pressures on the court.

The lawmaker stated the premier had been taking every effort to take full control of the court and assumed that he had already succeeded by declaring that “the problem with the Constitutional Court has already been resolved.”

However, the MP said, the ruling of the Constitutional Court came as a “cold shower” for Pashinyan.

“The Constitutional Court gave him a cold shower. That's why he has fallen into a panic, making strange statements. The decision of the Constitutional Court was exclusively in line with the Constitution and other legal acts of Armenia’s current legislation,” Petrosyan stated.

He also congratulated the attorneys of Robert Kocharyan for achieving success as a result of huge and competent efforts.

He highlighted the ruling as victory of justice in Armenia.

"There is still hope that not everything is destroyed in our country," Petrosyan added.

Ombudsman: The president of Azerbaijan continues implementing a policy of hatred and enmity against Armenians

Panorama, Armenia
March 29 2021

The President of Azerbaijan, authorities of this country have been implementing a policy of hatred, enmity, ethnic cleansing and genocide against Armenia, citizens of Armenia and the Armenian people for years," the Human Rights Defender of Armenia Arman Tatoyan wrote on facebook adding, the Turkish authorities have done the same or have openly encouraged the same policy.

Tatoyan shared three examples of the anti-Armenian hatred spread at the highest level of the Azerbaijani leadership. 

"In his remarks at the congress of the “New Azerbaijan Party (March 5-7, 2021), the President of Azerbaijan proudly stated, “the younger generation has grown up with a hatred of the enemy." By enemy, he means Armenia and the entire Armenian people, who are hated by a whole generation.

During the military event in Baku on the 10th of December, in 2020, the President of Turkey compared the war in Artsakh with the Armenian Genocide in the Ottoman Empire and the massacre of Armenians in Baku in September of 1918. According to him, that day was a day of glorification of the souls of Ahmed Jevat Bey, Nuri Pasha, Enver Pasha, and members of the Caucasus Islamic Army.

The ECHR judgments have confirmed that killing of Armenian in Azerbaijan has ethnic motivations and is encouraged by authorities. Therefore, no matter what process, program or words are used, these foundational facts cannot be overlooked.

This means that no one-sided process can develop at the expense of the life, physical security, or any other right of the citizen of the Republic of Armenia, or the normal life and peace of the Armenian population; and, the hatred and enmity towards Armenia and the Armenian people with state support has not only not diminished in Azerbaijan or Turkey, but due to lack of any responsibility, is taking on new manifestations," wrote Tatoyan.

In the words of the Ombudsman, his statement is directly based upon and conditioned on the gross human rights violations recorded and continuing during and after the September-November 2020 armed attacks; and, it takes it into account that the issue has become the subject of widespread public debate.

Pashinyan’s upcoming resignation does not require immediate conversation with Putin, Peskov says

Panorama, Armenia
March 29 2021

"The decision of the Prime Minister of Armenia Nikola Pashinyan to resign in April does not require an immediate conversation with Russian President Vladimir Putin," The Kremlin Spokesperson Dmitry Peskov told TASS news agency when asked to comment on the matter. 

To remind, Pashinyan announced about upcoming resignation on Sunday, saying he would resign next month while staying in office until snap parliamentary elections. 

"He [Pashinyan] would stay in charge of the Prime Minister's duties, so the decision that was announced does not require an immediate discussion," said Peskov, as quoted by the source. 

He added that the leaders of the two countries “communicated quite recently, and the contacts continue."