TURKISH press: Senior Turkish officials, minority communities discuss minority rights, steps against hate crimes

Justice Minister Abdulhamit Gül and Presidential Spokesperson Ibrahim Kalın chair a meeting with the representatives of minority communities in Turkey at the Dolmabahçe Presidential Office in Istanbul, Nov. 29, 2020. (AA Photo)

Senior Turkish officials discussed minority rights and steps that can be taken against hate crimes in a meeting Sunday with the spiritual leaders of minority communities and representatives from minority foundations.

Fener Greek Orthodox Patriarch Bartholomew; Archbishop Sahak Maşalyan, the 85th Armenian patriarch of Turkey; Yusuf Çetin, the metropolitan bishop of the Istanbul-Syriac Church, and Ishak Haleva, chief rabbi of the Jewish community in Turkey, were present at the meeting held in the Dolmabahçe presidential working office in Istanbul.

Yusuf Çetin (L), the metropolitan bishop of the Istanbul-Syriac Church, and Ishak Haleva, chief rabbi of the Jewish community in Turkey, are seen attending to a meeting with the representatives of minority communities in Turkey at the Dolmabahçe Presidential Office in Istanbul, Nov. 29, 2020. (AA Photo)

Following the three-hour session, Justice Minister Abdulhamit Gül and Presidential Spokesperson Ibrahim Kalın spoke to Turkish media.

Gül said they had an important and efficient consultation with the representatives, adding that decisive steps have been taken over the last 18 years under the leadership of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party).

"Since 2008, we have seen once again that the steps we took regulating foundations yielded very important results in removing obstacles from minorities," Gül said.

He went on to say that suggestions regarding property rights, the right to education and the right to organize were discussed.

Noting that the ruling AK Party has demonstrated its desire to increase freedom for all citizens, Gül said they also addressed further steps that can be taken against hate crimes.

Kalın also said the meeting was very productive.

He said minority community members who were unable to address the state before are now accepted and have a voice.

"As you know, with the Endowments Law enacted in 2008, a historical, revolutionary change took place and the properties and immovables that belonged to the foundations were returned."

He added that some specific issues related to churches, schools and properties that were on the minority representatives' agenda were also discussed at the meeting.

"It is extremely important that we fight against hate crimes and discrimination with a single voice, especially at a time when anti-Islamism, anti-Semitism and anti-Christianity are on the rise all over the world," he said. "We have stated here once again that there is no legal or humanitarian basis to condemn, accuse or make anyone an object of hate, regardless of their religious identity, because of their religion, ethnic identity or belief."

The meeting came amid recent reform efforts in the areas of law, the economy and democracy. Representatives of minority communities relayed their problems and expectations, describing the meeting as "positive, hopeful and solution-oriented."

In a written statement released by the Armenian patriarch, Maşalyan said that one of the consensuses that representatives of minority communities reached was the displeasure with the exploitation of issues related to minority communities in Turkey by international actors as a political tool.

“It was emphasized that there is a state structure in Turkey which is willing to listen to these problems and ready to take steps for producing solutions,” he said.

Sait Susin, the chairperson of the executive board for the Virgin Mary Assyrian Church Foundation located in Istanbul's Beyoğlu district, also said that it is very important and thoughtful that authorities noted their opinions and expectations for the planned democratic reform efforts.

In the past decades, Turkey has moved to reinstate the rights of minorities and help their survival as their numbers have dwindled over time. Long treated as second-class citizens, the Greek, Jewish, Armenian and Syrian communities have praised the return of their rights, though they have complained about it being a slow process.

TURKISH press: Young couple explores unknown gems of Turkey

For four years now a pair of enthusiastic young travelers has been exploring lesser-known sites in Turkey, a country they call “one of the historically and culturally richest lands in the world.”

Ayesha Bilal and Argun Konuk’s story is a unique one, as they like to seek out places that are far from the beaten path.

They promote these hidden gems online, writing in English for future visitors “with the hopes of giving these places some of the spotlight.”

Instead of drawing up an itinerary by looking at brochures or asking a travel agent, they try to discover places that are worth visiting but not commonly appreciated.

Konuk, 25, said he spends a lot of time on Google Maps exploring areas one by one, and going to websites of cities or archeological research papers to find new spots to explore.

For Bilal, also 25, a Pakistani-American, she loves tasting the culture.

“As a foreigner in Turkey, one of my strongest motivations is food,” she explained.

“Wherever we go, I like to research the unique cuisine of that area. Sometimes it’s the other way around. I discover a certain food or dessert and want to go to the city it’s famous for.”

However, the lack of appreciation that some places suffer from receive saddens the couple. While having fun, they also hope that their travels will spur beneficial consequences.

Travel through history, travel through time

“A considerable majority of the attractions in Turkey we visit do not get the attention they rightfully deserve,” said Konuk.

“Tourists visiting Turkey are largely unaware of the less popular historical and natural attractions that lie right under their noses. This is mainly due to the lack of promotion of these spots.”

He said he believes that if the locales draw enough attention, they will be protected by locals or national officials from treasure hunters or the ravages of nature.

“It saddens me that these places have so much history, people built them with their own hands and they were once people’s homes, and now they’re endangered,” he explained.

Bilal agreed.

“The memories of the people who once inhabited these places should never be allowed to fade away,” she said.

“These places are a testament to the unique history of humankind, and they deserve protection and are certainly worth seeing for those who are interested in going off-path a bit.”

Scholars and archeological bodies will also help protect such sites, she added.

“Most of these sites have only been partially discovered, and the large majority of the places still remain buried underground. After all, Gobeklitepe was only a mere hill, under which lay something that changed our entire timeline of human history in a way,” she explained, referring to the UNSECO site widely hailed as the world’s oldest temple.

“So with the promotion of these places, they may catch the eye of archeologists somewhere who may decide to look into them further.”

The couple’s love of history is another motivation. Awed by the historical, cultural, and natural diversity of Turkey, they set a goal to explore the highlights and hidden gems it holds.

“Turkey is called the ‘cradle of civilizations’ for a good reason. Every nook and corner of the country is thriving with ancient cities, historical places, and remnants of archaic peoples who had inhabited these lands,” according to Konuk.

One of his main goals one day is to see the places gain popularity not only within Turkey but with a global audience.

“For me, it’s a lot about the amazing feeling of walking on the same path and entering through the same doorways as people did hundreds or thousands of years ago. I enjoy being inside history itself,” said Bilal.

Endless places to visit

The couple has lost count of how many places they have visited.

“We visit a lot of small, obscure places sometimes. A single dilapidated church dating back to Roman times in the middle of nowhere, or a small underground city in the center of an otherwise unremarkable village,” said Bilal. “It gets hard to keep count of then.”

Saying that they have been to every geographical region of the country multiple times, they add there are still many places they would like to visit, especially in eastern and southeastern Turkey.

Among Konuk’s favorite sites in Turkey is the city of Ani, a medieval Armenian city that is often called “the City of 1,001 Churches,” situated in the eastern Kars province on the Armenian border.

He also loves the eastern Black Sea region for its astounding nature and hospitable people.

Bilal is particularly interested in ancient Greek and Roman history and finds cities along and near the Mediterranean coast most exciting.

“There are so many small, hidden ruins of castles, cities, churches, that you keep stumbling on more and more,” she said.

Yet the region that fascinates her the most is the southeast. “They have delicious food, needless to say, and that region is the cradle of civilizations. The history there is some of the oldest in the world,” she said.

Traveling during the pandemic

Setting out on the road at every chance they find, the couple did not allow the coronavirus pandemic to hold them back.

Stressing that they work hard to avoiding crowds, Konuk said: “Since we’re usually visiting open-air places and luckily, these are very uncrowded during the pandemic, wearing a mask and keeping socially distant suffices.”

Ayesha said they are also careful about the places where they eat to protect against the risk of infection. “But I think it’s almost been easier to travel during a pandemic. Working from home has allowed me to find more time for traveling out of the city, and it’s sometimes great to have the whole place to yourself,” she said.

During their travels, they prioritize taking proper photos and shooting videos for their audience.

Apart from social media and a personal blog at fellowprimo.com, they are also starting a YouTube channel where they will provide further information about interesting historical events.

Their main sources of information are research by archeologists and historians at various universities in Turkey and abroad, websites of municipalities, and talking to locals.

“Locals, who also help protect and secure the places, often have the richest information, not only about the history of the place, but also hidden features and parts that have not been opened for the public. They can also help by directing us to other nearby places that aren’t on maps or any website,” said Konuk.

Ayesha urged other young people to save money for traveling by making “easy sacrifices” like not eating out or splurging on new things.

“Turkey is one of those countries where no matter where you go, you’ll find something to see, eat, and do. So be a little adventurous, and let the world decide where your next destination will be,” she said.