CoE: Hearing on the merits

ceHearingsSeptember2005.htm
Tuesday 20 September 2005
Chamber
Hearing on the merits
9 a.m. Fener Rum Erkek Lisesi Vakfi v.Turkey (no. 34478/97) and
Yedikule Surp Pirgic Ermeni Hastanesi Vakfi v. Turkey (nos. 50147/99 and
51207/99)
Both applicants are foundations under Turkish law that were established at
the time of the Ottoman Empire. Fener Rum Erkek Lisesi Vakfi was set up to
provide educational facilities at the Greek Higher Secondary School in Fener
(Istanbul). Yedikule Surp P?rgic Ermeni Hastanesi Vakf? is the foundation
for the Armenian hospital Surp P?rgic in Yedikule. The status of both
foundations complies with the provisions of the Lausanne Treaty of 1923
affording protection to foundations that provide public services for
religious minorities.
In accordance with Law no. 2762 of 13 June 1935, by virtue of which they
obtained legal personality, the applicant foundations filed a declaration in
1936 of their aims and of their immovable property.
In 1952 the Fener Rum Erkek Lisesi Vakfi Foundation received a gift of part
of a building in Istanbul. It purchased another part of the building in
1958. The Yedikule Surp P?rgic Ermeni Hastanesi Vakf? Foundation received
gifts of two properties in Istanbul in 1943 and 1967, one in Beyoglu, the
other in Kad?koy.
In 1992 the Treasury applied to the Turkish courts for an order setting
aside the applicants’ title to the properties and deleting their names from
the land register. In three judgments (on 7 March 1996 in the case of Fener
Rum Erkek Lisesi Vakfi and on 30 October 1997 and 24 February 1998 in the
case of Yedikule Surp P?rgic Ermeni Hastanesi Vakf?), the Istanbul High
Court granted the Treasury’s applications. Referring to a decision of the
Court of Cassation of 8 May 1974, it held that the foundations, whose
membership was made up of religious minorities as defined by the Treaty of
Lausanne and whose constitutive documents did not contain a statement that
they had capacity to acquire immovable property, were precluded from
purchasing or accepting a gift of such property. Accordingly, their
immovable property was restricted to that set out in their constitutive
documents and finalised in the declaration made in 1936, so that they were
precluded from acquiring immovable property.
On appeals on points of law by the applicants, the Court of Cassation upheld
the judgments of the Istanbul High Court in decisions of 9 December 1996, 22
September 1998 and 20 October 1998.
In October 2000 Fener Rum Erkek Lisesi Vakfi applied to the Foundation
Commissioners for permission to amend its status to permit it to acquire
immovable property. However, its application was turned down.
In both cases, the applicants complain of the orders setting aside their
title to the properties. They argue that the Turkish legislation as
interpreted by the domestic courts deprives foundations established by
religious minorities within the meaning of the Lausanne Treaty of all
capacity to acquire immovable property. In their submission, that incapacity
amounts to discrimination when their position is compared to that of other
foundations. The applicants rely on Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 (protection
of property), and Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) taken together
with Article 1 of Protocol No. 1. Yedikule Surp P?rgic Ermeni Hastanesi
Vakf? further complains under Article 6 (right to a fair hearing) that it
did not receive a fair hearing in the Turkish courts.
Decisions, judgments and further information about the Court can be found on its Internet site ().

Registry of the European Court of Human Rights
F – 67075 Strasbourg Cedex
Press contacts: Roderick Liddell (telephone: +00 33 (0)3 88 41 24 92)
Emma Hellyer (telephone: +00 33 (0)3 90 21 42 15)
Stephanie Klein (telephone: +00 33 (0)3 88 41 21 54)
Fax: +00 33 (0)3 88 41 27 91
The European Court of Human Rights was set up in Strasbourg by the
Council of Europe Member States in 1959 to deal with alleged
violations of the 1950 European Convention on Human Rights. Since 1
November 1998 it has sat as a full-time Court composed of an equal
number of judges to that of the States party to the Convention. The
Court examines the admissibility and merits of applications submitted
to it. It sits in Chambers of 7 judges or, in exceptional cases, as a
Grand Chamber of 17 judges. The Committee of Ministers of the Council
of Europe supervises the execution of the s judgments.
[1] Under Article 43 of the European Convention on Human Rights,
within three months from the date of a Chamber judgment, any party to
the case may, in exceptional cases, request that the case be referred
to the member Grand Chamber of the Court. In that event, a panel of
five judges considers whether the case raises a serious question
affecting the interpretation or application of the Convention or its
protocols, or a serious issue of general importance, in which case the
Grand Chamber will deliver a final judgment. If no such question or
issue arises, the panel will reject the request, at which point the
judgment becomes final. Otherwise Chamber judgments become final on
the expiry of the three-month period or earlier if the parties declare
that they do not intend to make a request to refer.

Russian-Armenian School Opened In Sochi

RUSSIAN-ARMENIAN SCHOOL OPENED IN SOCHI
Pan Armenian News
06.09.2005 04:32
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ In Chereshnya village of Adler region of Sochi
a ceremony of opening a new school was held, reported the Yerkramas
newspaper of Armenians of Russia. The school is a national one and has
bilingual instruction – in Russian and Armenian. The school building,
designed for 550 pupils, was built in the course of 3 years. Head of
the resort town Victor Kolodyazhny took part in the opening ceremony of
the Russian-Armenian school. He noted in his speech that “the opening
of the school should make the village residents believe in tomorrow,
the deserving future of their children and their village.”
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armentel Wants To Revise Fixed Telephones Tariffs

ARMENTEL WANTS TO REVISE FIXED TELEPHONES TARIFFS
Armenpress
Sept 5, 2005
YEREVAN, SEPTEMBER 5, ARMENPRESS: ArmenTel telephone operator that
holds legal monopoly on fixed telephones and Internet services in
Armenia, has confirmed today it has sent a package of proposals to
transport and communication ministry calling for revision of tariffs
for fixed telephones.
A spokeswoman for ArmenTel said a state commission for protection of
economic competition has to examine the company’s proposals and make
a decision within next 45 days.
The commission in turn has said that ArmenTel paid a $400,000 fine
levied on it for the more than month-long breakdown of its network
that caused widespread anger among its nearly 300,000 subscribers
from June 30 to July 10.

UK Government: Change Of Ambassador To The Republic Of Armenia

UK GOVERNMENT: CHANGE OF AMBASSADOR TO THE REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA
M2 Presswire
September 5, 2005
Mr Anthony Cantor has been appointed Her Majesty’s Ambassador to the
Republic of Armenia in succession to Miss Thorhilda Abbott-Watt who
will be transferring to another Diplomatic Service appointment.
Mr Cantor will take up his appointment in January 2006.
CURRICULUM VITAE
Full Name: Mr Anthony John James Cantor Date of Birth: 1 February 1946
Family Status: Married to Patricia Children: Two daughters (1969) &
(1972) and one son (1980)
2001-2005 Asuncion, Ambassador
2000-2001 FCO: Public Diplomacy Department, Head of Expo Section
2000- Hanover, Deputy Commissioner General, Expo 2000
1999-2000 FCO: European Union Department (Bilateral), Desk Officer
1995-1998 Osaka, Deputy Consul General
1994-1995 Tokyo, 1st Secretary Commercial
1992-1994 On loan to Department of Trade and Industry
1990-1992 Hanoi, Deputy Head of Mission
1983-1989 Osaka, Consul Commercial
1982-1983 FCO: West Indian Atlantic Department, Desk Officer
1980-1982 FCO: Aid Policy Department, Desk Officer
1977-1980 Accra, 2nd Secretary Consular
1972-1976 Tokyo, 3rd & later 2nd Secretary Commercial
1968-1971 Rangoon, 3rd Secretary
1966-1968 FCO: Finance Department, Desk Officer

Open Discussion Of The Conflict

OPEN DISCUSSION OF THE CONFLICT
A1+
| 15:07:51 | 05-09-2005 | Official |
Today the OSCE Chairman-in-Office, the Slovenia Foreign Minister
Dimitrij Rupel who has arrived in Armenia on a 2-day official visit
will meet the President of the Nagorno Karabakh republic Arkadi
Ghoukasyan. The meeting will take place at 09:00 p.m. by local time
in the hotel Yerevan.
It is noteworthy that the meeting is not closed as journalists have
been invited to highlight the meeting.
The NGR President has already arrived in Armenia.

Nistelroy Saved Holland

NISTELROY SAVED HOLLAND
A1+
| 15:00:27 | 05-09-2005 | Sports |
After the 1-0 win over the Armenian National Football team in Yerevan,
the Holland team practically secured their place in the 2006 World
Championship.
The win was not an easy one for the Netherlands National team, although
before the match no one doubted their winning. Our team had chosen
a defense tactics, besides, goalkeeper Roman Berezovsky was quick
enough to capture dangerous moments and save our team. Nevertheless,
the guests managed to break the defense, and at the 67th minute Ruud
van Nistelroy scored.
In the press conference after the match the Holland team coach Marco
van Basten said, “I never thought the Armenian team could create so
many problems for us and that it would be so difficult to win”.

Armenian And Azeri Foreign Ministers May Meet In October

ARMENIAN AND AZERI FOREIGN MINISTERS MAY MEET IN OCTOBER
DeFacto, Armenia
Sept 5 2005
Armenian and Azeri Foreign Ministers’ recurrent meeting may take
place in October. “We’ll try to organize the meeting”, stated the OSCE
Minsk group Russian Co – Chair Yuri Merzlyakov during the interview
for Freedom Radio Station. According to the Russian mediator, the two
countries’ Presidents’ August meeting was useful. In his words, the
negotiations proceeded in very favorable atmosphere. “They discussed
what we had proposed”, said Yuri Merzlyakov.

Yunusov: Karabakh Process Activation Conditioned By Increased Pressu

YUNUSOV: KARABAKH PROCESS ACTIVATION CONDITIONED BY INCREASED PRESSURE OF WEST ON YEREVAN AND BAKU
Pan Armenian News
06.09.2005 04:42
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ After Ilham Aliyev coming to power in October 2003,
a natural pause has appeared in the talks, head of the Department of
Conflictology and Migration of the Institute of Peace and Democracy
Arif Yunusov stated in an interview with PanARMENIAN.Net. In his
words, a situation has appeared that had already taken place, when
after the resignation of Levon Ter-Petrosyan new Armenian President
Robert Kocharian stated the line pursued in the talks by the Armenian
authorities was incorrect and it was necessary to review many aspects
in the negotiation process. “I. Aliyev behaved the same way, stating it
was necessary to start the talks from naught. This at first caused a
painful response of Armenia, however talks started then and they were
even called “the Prague process.” That was what I exactly meant when
stating in one of interviews in Azerbaijan that a new, recurrent and
of course not last stage has outlined in the negotiation process,”
the expert noted. In his words, “The activation is conditioned with
the increase of West pressure upon Armenian and Azeri authorities
and the domestic political situation in the two republics,” the Azeri
political scientist considers.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

“Azerbaijan Ready To Recognize Karabakh’S Right For Self-Determinati

“AZERBAIJAN READY TO RECOGNIZE KARABAKH’S RIGHT FOR SELF-DETERMINATION”
A1+
| 14:43:04 | 06-09-2005 | Politics |
Upon completion of the meeting with OSCE Chairman-in-Office Dimitrij
Rupel NKR President Arkady Ghukasyan answered reporters’ questions.
-Do you see any progress in the Karabakh conflict settlement and what
is your position on conduction of a referendum in the NKR?
-It it hard to say whether there is progress or not. Anyway there are
definitely some positive elements. I think that Azerbaijan has entered
a more constructive field. As for the referendum, in my opinion,
the fact that Azerbaijan is ready to recognize Karabakh’s right for
self-determination is positive.
-What do you think about the format of the negotiations between the
Armenian and Azerbaijani Presidents?
-These meetings cannot be referred to the OSCE Minsk Group format. I
rate the Kocharian-Aliyev talks as positive, however these talks
cannot be complete without NKR’s participation. Meanwhile the Minsk
Group has limited its activities to the format of visits.
-Taking into consideration the current situation, do you rule out
the possibility of repetition of the scenario of 1998?
-I think history is not likely to repeat, thus repetition can be
excluded.
-Your meeting with Mr. Rupel lasted longer than scheduled. What was
the reason for it?
-I suppose the meeting was interesting for both of us. We did not
complete our meeting, since it was impossible to discuss all the
issues. Anyway the fact that the Chairman-in-Office visits the region
for the second time is extraordinary in itself.
-Why extraordinary?
-He wishes to speed up the settlement of the conflict
-Do you think the conflict can be resolved till the end of the
current year?
-It’s not real
-Today Ilham Aliyev made some militaristic statements. Do you thinks
it’s a part of election campaign or a real threat?
-Aliyev is likely to be solving inner political problems, however it
impedes the process.
-Do you imagine Karabakh’s status lower than the status of
independence?
-It’s like to be “a bit pregnant”.
To note, yesterday Ankady Ghukasyan touched upon the inadmissibility
of a stepwise settlement of the conflict. “Karabakh can agree on a
stepwise settlement only in case our own issues are settled first”,
he noted.

OSCE Chief To Discuss Karabakh Peace Process, Azeri Polls

OSCE CHIEF TO DISCUSS KARABAKH PEACE PROCESS, AZERI POLLS
Itar-Tass, Russia
Sept 5 2005
BAKU, September 5 (Itar-Tass) – Dimitrij Rupel, current Chairman
of the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE),
is to meet with the leaders of this Transcaucasian republic here on
Monday to discuss matters connected with the Nagorno-Karabakh peace
process and with the talks held by the Presidents of Azerbaijan and
Armenia in Kazan on August 27.
According to diplomatic sources, the OSCE chief is to meet with Azeri
President Ilkham Aliyev, Prime Minister Artur Rasi-zade, Parliament
Speaker Murtuz Aleskerov, Foreign Minister Elmar Mamedyarov, and with
Nizami Bakhmanov, leader of the Azeri community of Nagorno-Karabakh.
During the upcoming meetings, Rupel is expected to discuss the
situation in Azerbaijan on the eve of the November 6 parliamentary
elections. He is also scheduled to meet with Gerd Arens, chief of
the OSCE mission that begins Monday to monitor preparations for the
elections to Azerbaijan’s top legislature.
According to the Baku-based office of the OSCE, the parliamentary
elections will be monitored so far by an extended mission consisting
of 28 observers. On the eve of the polling day, a short-term mission,
which is to include more than 500 international observers, is to join
in the monitoring.