Lessons started in the seminary

A1+
| 17:37:07 | 09-09-2005 | Official |
LESSONS STARTED IN THE SEMINARY
Today the opening ceremony of the 2005-2006 educational year took place in
the Gevorgyan Theological seminary of Echmiadzin.
After the Lord’s Prayer the Inspector of the seminary rendered an opening
speech. He mentioned gladly that this year the seminary will celebrate the
60th anniversary of its re-opening, and that there are no more of the
difficulties which existed in 1945.
After the entrance examinations 43 applicants have entered the seminary, and
there are on the whole 240 students in the seminary.

Ofcl: US not seeking extradition of man who threw grenade at Bush

Official: U.S is not seeking extradition of man who admitted throwing
grenade toward Bush
.c The Associated Press
TBILISI, Georgia (AP) – Georgia’s interior minister said Thursday that
a man who admitted throwing a live grenade toward U.S. President
George W. Bush during a rally in the ex-Soviet nation will face
justice at home.
Interior Minister Vano Merabishvili said that the United States had
not asked for the extradition of Vladimir Arutyunian, who was indicted
Wednesday by a U.S. grand jury on charges of trying to assassinate the
president.
“The United States trusts the Georgian justice and law enforcement
agencies, and it hasn’t made an extradition request,” Merabishvili
said at a news conference.
Arutyunian already faces terrorism and murder charges in Georgia
stemming from the May 10 incident in Tbilisi and the killing of a
policeman in a shootout before his arrest in July. Merabishvili says
that the charges carry a punishment of life imprisonment – the same
punishment that he would face in the United States.
Bush and Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili were behind a
bulletproof barrier addressing a rally of thousands in Tbilisi in May
when the grenade, wrapped in a plaid cloth, landed about 100 feet
away. It did not explode; investigators said it apparently
malfunctioned. No one was harmed.
In a video broadcast on Georgian television, Arutyunian said he
intended to spray shrapnel over the bulletproof glass.
Autyunian got a new private lawyer Thursday to replace a lawyer
provided by the state.
09/08/05 13:53 EDT

Trial of novelist ‘shows Turkey not ready for EU’

The Telegraph (UK)
Trial of novelist ‘shows Turkey not ready for EU’
By Amberin Zaman in Ankara and Tony Paterson in Berlin
(Filed: 11/09/2005)
An internationally acclaimed Turkish novelist who faces prosecution for
speaking out about the mass slaughter of Armenians last century has said
the case against him shows his country may not be ready to join the
European Union.
Orhan Pamuk, who faces up to three years in jail if convicted at his
trial in December of “denigrating Turkey”, said that reforms promised by
the Turkish government in return for a guarantee of talks on EU
membership had not materialised.
Prosecutors provoked a furore across Europe last month by announcing the
action against him under the country’s recently adopted penal code,
which is supposed to bring Turkish criminal law more closely into line
with that of EU countries.
In his first interview since the prosecution was announced, Pamuk
declared: “Unfortunately I do not believe that Turkey has come very far
in this respect. Nothing has happened over the past year. Turkey has sat
on the promises that Europe has given and taken it easy.”
Although forbidden to comment directly on his own case, the best-selling
author added: “Turkey has not changed so much. Laws have been changed,
but the thought processes, our culture and our way of seeing things…
that has not changed much.
“There have been legal and political changes in the hope of EU
membership. But the trial opened against me shows… that the state
prosecutors have not changed very much. It shows that there is not much
tolerance in society.”
Pamuk’s comments, in an interview with a German newspaper, come as
several countries, including France, have stepped up their effort to
block Turkey’s entry to the EU after public opposition to the inclusion
of such a large, predominantly Muslim, country.
The EU has long cited Turkey’s chequered record on human rights as an
obstacle to membership, and its government – led by Recep Erdogan,
Turkey’s mildly Islamist prime minister – has enacted a series of new
laws in an attempt to overcome the objection. Talks on membership are
due to start next month.
Critics maintain that Turkey’s new penal code falls short of EU
standards by proscribing free debate of the Armenian tragedy and
criticism of Turkey’s 1974 invasion of Cyprus.
Last week Jack Straw, the Foreign Secretary, singled out the Pamuk
prosecution for criticism in a speech in which he nonetheless argued for
Turkish membership of the EU. “There is still some way to go with
implementation, as the recent charges against the distinguished Turkish
novelist Orhan Pamuk show, in the context of freedom of speech,” he said.
Pamuk drew nationalist ire in Turkey and received anonymous death
threats after telling a Swiss newspaper in February that “30,000 Kurds
and 1 million Armenians were killed in these lands and nobody but me
dares to talk about it”. One Turkish official in the western town of
Sutluce ordered citizens to destroy all of his books.
Several of Pamuk’s novels, including the acclaimed My Name is Red, have
been translated into English. His most recent bestseller, Snow, explores
tensions between Turkey’s secular elite and religious conservatives.
Turkey has long denied that more than one million members of its once
thriving Armenian community were the victims of systematic annihilation
between 1915 and 1923. Armenians and many others label the campaign
genocide – a description of the events which is proscribed in Turkish law.
The Turkish government insists that a smaller number of Armenians –
several hundred thousand – died unintentionally of exposure, famine and
disease as they journeyed to Syria, after being deported for
collaborating with invading Russian forces.
Prosecutors are still deciding whether to bring further charges against
Pamuk for referring to the more recent killing of Kurds – whose
sometimes violent separatist movements in the east of the country have
been brutally suppressed by successive Turkish governments.
Mr Erdogan won strong praise from EU governments in April when he called
for a joint commission of Turkish and Armenian scholars to research the
events of 1915. It was the first time Turkish leaders had invited
international scrutiny of the deaths. This month a group of Turkish
academics who challenge the official line, saying that there was a
conspiracy to kill, will be allowed to gather in Istanbul to air their
views for the first time.

Lady screams the blues

theaustralian.news.com
Lady screams the blues
Iain Shedden
10sep05
FOR someone whose name is associated with subjects such as mortality
and genocide, Diamanda Galas has an acute sense of humour.
“I’m able to take myself beyond the parlour room of my own insanity,”
Galas declares with a deep, rasping laugh, “whether it’s sadness or
happiness or whatever.”
The 49-year-old singer – although singer hardly does her justice – is
a one-off. She has been described as a vocal terrorist, not to mention
a political animal with a stage presence (think a deeply troubled
Morticia Addams) capable of wringing any number of emotions from
herself and her audience during a performance.
Consider that the two most famous and recurring themes in her oeuvre
are AIDS and the genocide of Armenians and Assyrians at the hands of
the Turks, and it’s clear that her art stems from a lot more than her
voice and piano.
A Californian of Greek descent, Galas has spent the past 20 years
confronting her audience with death, injustice, caustic humour and a
voice that can stretch across four octaves and scare the hell out of
you in all of them. Her avant-garde style calls on blues, jazz, opera
and more. She can silence a room with a scream that sounds as though
it comes from the deep recesses of her soul.
Her latest show, Guilty Guilty Guilty, which makes its Australian
debut in Brisbane on October 13, is subtitled “a program of tragic and
homicidal love songs and death songs”, which could be seen as light
relief from her normal agenda. That’s certainly how she sees it.
“There’s a lot of humour in that concert,” she says. “Some of the
songs are very funny. I’m glad that they have that side.”
The song list includes Hank Williams’s aching I’m So Lonesome I Could
Cry, Johnny Cash’s Long Black Veil and one of the staples of her blues
repertoire, Screamin’ Jay Hawkins’s I Put a Spell on You.
The show contrasts with her scheduled performances at the Melbourne
Festival on October 7 and 10. The first show there is Defixiones:
Order From the Dead, the latest episode of her Defixiones
work-in-progress that is dedicated to the victims of Armenian,
Anatolian and Pontic Greek genocides between 1914 and 1922. She will
perform it for the first time in her adopted home city, New York,
later this month.
Her last Australian appearances four years ago included Defixiones,
Will and Testament and La Serpenta Canta, the latter an eclectic
selection of songs that included a melodramatic centrepiece, the
death-row blues 25 Minutes to Go.
Wherever she travels, her long-term dedication to the fight against
AIDS and her obsession with the genocide issue are never far
away. They are part of her.
Growing up in a Greek Orthodox household in San Diego accounts partly
for her interest in the genocide of her ancestors and others in that
region. It is a part of history that she says is little known and she
has done everything in her power to change that, both as a performer
and as an activist in the media.
“I show a tremendous amount of anger,” she says. “To articulate these
things is hard. They are difficult to explain. Things that are
happening around the world, commercialisation and invisibility that
certain people are given in some cultures. I get extremely angry about
it.”
One can sense that anger welling up inside her as we speak. “There’s
a lot of history that deals with genocide of the Greek, Armenian and
Assyrian population at the hands of the Turks,” she says. “That’s
something that is very, very remotely recognised, if at all
recognised. Many people have fought for a greater recognition of the
Armenian genocide and they have been extremely powerful fighters.”
She says that the process of writing Defixiones only heightened her
passion for the cause. “When you’re dealing with these subjects you
end up becoming absorbed by a great deal of history, a great deal of
common events. You end up working in a lot of different
languages. That takes up a lot of time.”
What also took up a lot of time before Defixiones was her work in the
battle against AIDS. She lost her brother, artist Philip-Dimitri
Galas, to the disease. She has the phrase “Everyone is HIV+” tattooed
on her hand and several of her recordings, such as the landmark Plague
Mass and her 1992 recording Vena Cava, are informed by her knowledge
of the epidemic and by her role in campaigns to help end it.
These issues are the cornerstone of her life and career, but they are
not the sum total.
Galas may not have been destined to be a political activist, but there
was every chance she was going to be a musician. Her father was a
professional musician and she began her career playing piano in his
band. She had a formal music education too and studied improvisation
and visual-art performance, but she cites her early experience with
her father as crucial to her musical development and her taste for the
blues and jazz in particular. The attraction of the blues, she
explains, goes way beyond its recurring themes of love and death.
“I’ve been playing the blues for so long, I didn’t even have a chance
to be drawn to it,” she says. “I was playing it for money in my
father’s band when I was 13. He taught me how to play and that was a
very important part of my education. He played New Orleans music for
years. That’s a pretty basic grounding.”
That grounding wasn’t going to be enough, however. Even while she was
becoming an accomplished pianist as a teenager, her sights were set on
being a singer, though her father was against it.
“That was something that filled my father with trepidation,” she says,
“and he was right. He considered singers to have insane
lifestyles. It’s a difficult profession because people encourage
singers to sound like idiots and push them to present themselves and
to make a show and take credit for doing things they don’t do: like
music written by other artists. Plus my father didn’t want me to be
thought of as a sub-par musician, which in many cases singers are.
“But I wanted to do it because I wanted to be the leader of a band. I
wanted to do it because I had been inspired by people like Ornette
Coleman and by instrumentalists like that who were doing interesting
things. So I started studying voice a lot and going to teachers and
doing improvisation because I wanted to learn the instrument in a way
where I could master the musical aggression.”
There is no question that she has succeeded. The combination of her
emotional and musical ranges makes for rare and spectacular
theatre. The subject matter often fans the flames.
“Some people say that I’m fascinated by things that I am afraid of,
but many people do that,” she says. “Some of them go into the
military. Some of them go into the movies, some of them go into
deep-sea diving and some of them go into music. I have the opportunity
through my work to address things that keep me awake at night.
“What I’m talking about are timeless subjects like mortality. I can’t
seem to come to terms with that very well like some people. It’s
something that makes singing and performing and composing a great
gift.”
Subjecting your mind and your lungs to such an emotional kicking night
after night must take its toll, one would think. If it leaves
audiences exhausted and exhilarated, isn’t it even more confronting
for her? She says that when she gets on stage she is hoping “to be as
honest as possible, and I hope that I’m going to be able to discover
something new on stage every night and be at one with my
material. That’s why a performer prays and hangs around the
material. So that she can be free on stage and be able to feel the
things that are severe and such important subjects to (her) craft.
“You certainly don’t want to feel as you do when you’re sitting in
your living room having a coffee or something. You want to feel as if
you know as much about life in that moment and convey that in the
limited time that people have come to see you.”
If her music defines her as an artist, her appearance has led to less
sophisticated assessments of her as a celebrity. Terms such as
“daughter of darkness”, “gothic diva” and – a particular pet hate of
hers – “bride of Satan” paint a superficial picture at best.
Of the latter, she says she is “absolutely appalled. It’s so old. That
is the oldest quote in the book. They keep putting that out. It’s 20
years old. I just laugh at it. If they want to think that, then
fine. But as years go on, it gets so tiresome.”
She finds it particularly galling when such perfunctory descriptions
blur her art. “It matters to me when they say that and I’m doing
something to do with genocide or something, because it dismisses the
seriousness of its intent and the research that has gone into it.”
Her music is not for the faint-hearted, then, nor could it be
described as mainstream. She has been conspicuously absent from the
pop charts throughout her career. “A lot of today’s pop music is so
simple-minded, it would be impossible for me to play it,” she says. “I
would be asleep. I would say I have wasted my life.”
Nor does she subscribe to the conventional methods of the mainstream
recording industry.
“I’m not in the studio 24 hours a day the way people in pop music
(are),” she says. “I go in for a limited time and I do a lot of really
weird shit, and I have a record company that puts it out anyway. I
don’t get paid a lot for it, either. I sell records at concerts and
that helps me. I decided to make the money while I was alive rather
than when I’m dead.”
Diamanda Galas performs at the Melbourne Festival on October 7 and 10,
in Brisbane on October 13, in Adelaide on October 16 and in Sydney on
October 21.

The Turkish Identity

September 10, 2005
The Turkish Identity
Next week, the Turkish prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, will
address the United Nations here on one of the issues threatening to
slow down negotiations to admit Turkey into the European Union –
recognizing Cyprus. But he should also address the question of Orhan
Pamuk, the pre-eminent Turkish novelist who has been charged with
“public denigration” of Turkish identity.
In February, a Swiss newspaper quoted Mr. Pamuk on Turkey’s
longstanding refusal to discuss the Armenian genocide and the deaths
of some 30,000 separatist Kurds more recently. Mr. Pamuk’s remarks
inflamed Turkish nationalists, and he left the country. He faces the
possibility of three years in jail.
The charges against Mr. Pamuk violate the standards of free speech,
one of the prerequisites to Turkey’s admission to the European
Union. The charges also cut to the heart of Mr. Pamuk’s writing. The
question of Turkish identity informs his work. In “My Name Is Red,”
Mr. Pamuk never lets the reader forget the ethnic and cultural
diversity of Turkey’s past. Nor does he flinch, in “Istanbul,” from
reminding readers of the “deliberately provoked” 1955 riots that
destroyed several non-Muslim neighborhoods in that city. Beneath the
notion of a Turkish identity lies a tension, still noticeable today,
that has nourished Mr. Pamuk’s writing.
It has been about six months since Mr. Pamuk’s comments were
published, so it is unclear why the charges are being brought just
now. Whatever the motive, they are a reminder that one of Turkey’s
biggest obstacles in dealing with the West is the way it chooses to
patrol its own history.

Armenians choose independent path

Source: Institute for War and Peace Reporting (IWPR)
Date: 08 Sep 2005
Armenians choose independent path
Delegates at a conference on Armenia’s future voted for an independent
development, rather than placing too much reliance on Russia or Europe.
By Ara Tadevosian in Yerevan (CRS No. 303, 08-Sep-05)
Armenians meeting to discuss their country’s future have rejected the idea
that they should place all their hopes in Europe — and, more surprisingly,
Russia.
The 500 delegates at the unique conference held in Yerevan came from all
walks of life – teachers, students, small business owners, manual workers
and the unemployed – concluded Armenia should instead pursue its own path,
increasing economic activity and productivity, fighting corruption, and
ensuring the 2008 presidential election is free and fair.
“I think it isn’t right to go with one country,” said college student Gevorg
Stepanian. “You have to be more cunning and be able to manoeuvre in a number
of directions.”
The event was part of “Armenia 2020” — a campaign led by several prominent
figures from the Armenian diaspora, including businessman Ruben Vardanian,
who is president of the Russian Troika-Dialog group of companies, and Nubar
Afeyan, general director of the American group Flagship Ventures.
The results may come as a surprise to some western observers who think of
Armenia as primarily pro-Russian in orientation. However, organisers said
the results of the Yerevan gathering, held at the capital’s main stadium,
mirrored those at similar events in Idzhevan and Ekhagnadzor, where the idea
forging stronger links with Russia was also rejected.
As one participant said, “Because of its geopolitical situation, Russia will
always be interested in a weak Armenia and will keep us in slave-like
dependence.”
“Historically, Russia has betrayed Armenia repeatedly and that likelihood
exists today too,” said another.
A third person added, “Do you know of any other nation, other than the
Armenians, who have such a strange attachment to Russia? I think not – this
is just another example of our national irrationalism.”
Full integration into Europe also received the thumbs down from many of the
delegates, with that option getting only 120 votes compared with 136 for
preserving the Russian alliance and 210 in favour of a dynamic independent
path, the so-called Singapore model which organisers dubbed “Dare to Excel”.
Those unconvinced of Armenia’s need to integrate more fully with Europe gave
various reasons, with one person expressing fears the country would be
forced to change its constitution, and another saying, “We’re Armenians, and
Europe is not our home.”
A third participant put this view more pithily,”Europe is an old woman in
civilised make-up. There’s no need for us to fall for her charms.”
Sociologist Lilit Arutyunian said the conference showed that the
government’s talk of integration with Europe had been ineffective.
“It’s been 10 years now that the government has been talking almost daily
about its enthusiasm for European integration,” said Arutyunian. “But these
are just empty words. The government, intentionally or unintentionally,
places no emphasis on the fact that the principal European value is human
life, which now as before is worth little in our country.”
Many participants said Armenia’s relations with neighbours like Georgia and
historical enemy Turkey was more important than European integration. This
despite the fact that Turkey, with which Armenia has no diplomatic
relations, was not included in any of the possible development options
offered by the organisers.
“Today the question of Turkey’s entry into the Europe Union is being
discussed. But do we want to enter the European Union with Turkey? Just
imagine, the Armenian border opens and three million Turks rush in. What
would happen then?” asked one participant.
But another took a different view, said, “We must strive to normalise
relations with Turkey, as this will be extremely useful to us on the path of
independent development.”
Armenian relations with Azerbaijan, which are still hostile because of the
unresolved dispute over Nagorny Karabakh, remain too sensitive an issue for
conference participants even to discuss them as part of a picture of
shifting regional alliances.
The country’s other near neighbour Georgia, however, was viewed as a partner
by many participants. Rather than Europe, one person suggested that Armenia
focus on Georgia in order to gain access to that country’s ports. The two
have been trying to forge closer ties, and this summer tens of thousands of
Armenians took holidays in Georgia’s Black Sea resorts for the first time in
many years.
While the conference organisers admitted the current Armenian government was
unlikely to pay attention to many of the findings, the strong emphasis
placed on fair elections and the war on corruption may yet be reflected in
future voting patterns.
Even in the best-case scenario, Armenia has a long way to go to meet the
aspirations articulated by conference participants. According to Artashes
Kazakhetsian, manager of the Armenia 2020 project, if the ideas behind the
Singapore model were implemented in full, the country would take the next 15
years to attain the same level of development that another former Soviet
republic, Estonia, is at today.
Ara Tadevosian is the director of Mediamax, an independent news agency in
Yerevan.

Booker novelists denounce Turkey for charging author

The Sunday Times (UK)
September 11, 2005
Booker novelists denounce Turkey for charging author
Tom Pattinson and Alice Jones
TURKEY has been condemned by Kazuo Ishiguro, the novelist, and fellow
Man Booker prize nominees over a threat to imprison one of its leading
writers for highlighting his country’s role in the 1915 Armenian genocide.
Orhan Pamuk, 53, who has written several award-winning books, was
charged last week with `denigrating national identity’ with comments in
a Swiss newspaper. If found guilty at his trial, set for December 16, he
could be jailed for up to three years.
Publicity surrounding the case has thrown the spotlight on Turkey’s
human rights record as it prepares to begin negotiations next month on
joining the European Union.
Ishiguro, who won the Booker prize in 1989 for The Remains of the Day
and is on this year’s shortlist for Never Let Me Go, said: `I’m
astonished and horrified to discover such a situation can arise in
Turkey today – and to a writer who has done so much to enhance his
country’s reputation. I hope the Turkish government does all in its
power to bring this misguided prosecution to an end.’
John Banville, nominated this year for The Sea, said Pamuk was right to
remind compatriots of past crimes committed in their name. `It will be a
disgrace if Pamuk is jailed, and Turkey should realise the damage that
will be done to its reputation if it goes ahead with this injustice,’ he
said.
Sebastian Barry, shortlisted for A Long Long Way, agreed. `A grown-up
country like Turkey can afford to open the book fully on every aspect of
its interesting and challenging history,’ he said.
John Sutherland, chairman of the Man Booker judges, said: `It seems
wholly inappropriate that statements of political opinion should be
regarded like that. You can deny it (Pamuk’s comment) but you should not
deny their freedom.’
The charges against Pamuk followed remarks made in February to a Zurich
newspaper. `Thirty thousand Kurds and a million Armenians were killed in
these lands and no one dares to speak out on this but me,’ he said.
Turkey is extremely sensitive over its role in what is known as the
Armenian genocide. Between 600,000 and 1.2m Armenians are thought to
have been killed between 1915 and 1917 during a forced evacuation. The
Turks say the figure is much lower and was the result of ethnic
conflict, the first world war, disease and famine.
Pamuk’s case has been an embarrassment for the Turkish government, which
is fighting opposition, especially in France and Germany, to its
attempts to join the EU.
Abdullah Gul, the foreign minister, said of the charges: `There is no
decision yet. I would like to announce to the world that there is
freedom of expression in Turkey. People voice their opinions comfortably
as long as they do not promote violence.’
Additional reporting: Gareth Jenkins, Istanbul

NKR: Time Out in Karabakh Resolution

TIME OUT IN KARABAKH RESOLUTION

Azat Artsakh Nagorno Karabakh Republic [NKR]
08 Sept 05
The CIS summit in Kazan, Russia, and the longed-for meeting of the
presidents of Armenia and Azerbaijan marked the end of the summer
holiday in the diplomatic camp of Armenia. One thing is obvious
today. The opinion of the political scientists who insisted that the
meeting in Kazan would be a turning point in the resolution was, to
put it mildly, exaggerated. However, as the foreign minister of
Armenia states, although the longed-for turning point did not occur,
the meeting was useful to the process. Remaining faithful to the
principle of confidentiality of the process, the foreign minister did
not give any detail of the meeting, mentioning only that there is
always the danger of reaching a deadlock which did not happen in
Kazan: `We are not deadlocked.’ Most probably, the Azerbaijani side
is not discontent with the meeting in Kazan either. Moreover,
according to the foreign minister of Azerbaijan E. Mamedyarov, the
talks in Kazan are a step ahead; however it is early to consider real
progress. By the way, if after the meeting in Kazan the Armenian
foreign minister mentioned that the present stage in the resolution of
the conflict does not allow giving more detail about it to the people
of Armenia and Azerbaijan and though the meeting of Kocharian and
Aliev was not a turning point, the talks were positive, the
Azerbaijani side was of a different opinion. Following the tradition,
the Azerbaijani side again neglected the confidentiality of the talks,
and the Foreign Ministry announced that the parties allegedly
discussed 7 ` 9 elements of the resolution, namely `the liberation of
occupied areas, the return of refugees and restoration of
communication between Azerbaijan and Nakhijevan’ and there is progress
in reference to certain elements too. According to the foreign
minister of Armenia, there was progress for the Armenian side as well,
however, unlike his Azerbaijani colleague, Vartan Oskanian does not
give details except that the concern that the sides may reach a
deadlock rising before each meeting of the presidents, did not come
true. And, most probably, the next meeting of the ministers will take
place no sooner than in a month because Yerevan and Armenia need time
to analyze the results of the meeting in Kazan. Before this the
foreign ministers of the two countries will share their opinions with
the OSCE Chairman-in-Office, the foreign Minister of Slovenia Dimitrij
Rupel who is visiting Armenia on these days. The department of press
of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Armenia informed that the OSCE
Chairman-in-Office is to meet with the presidents of the Republic of
Armenia and NKR, the prime minister of Armenia, as well as the foreign
minister of Armenia. The results of the meetings are to be summed up
at the press conference on September 6. After the visit of the OSCE
Chairman-in-Office to Yerevan and Baku the co-chairmen will prepare
the recurrent meeting of the foreign ministers of Armenia and
Azerbaijan, which may take place at the end of September or at the
beginning of October.
CHRISTINE MNATSAKANIAN.
08-09-2005

NKR: Resolution Coming Nearer

RESOLUTION COMING NEARER

Azat Artsakh Nagorno Karabakh Republic [NKR]
09 Sept 05
At the meeting with NKR President Arkady Ghukassian the OSCE
Chairman-in-Office, the foreign minister of Slovenia Dimitrij Rupel
visiting Baku and Yerevan on September 5 and 6 said the resolution of
the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict may be reached by the end of the
year. According to the president of NKR, during the meeting which
lasted longer than it had been scheduled, not all the questions were
discussed because they were very many. Dwelling on the details of the
meeting, President Ghukassian commended the work of the OSCE Minsk
Group and mentioned that two visits of the OSCE Chairman-in-Office
Dimitrij Rupel in a year show that the process will be accelerated.
However, it will not be over by the end of the year. The foreign
minister of Slovenia shared his opinion. According to him, the
resolution of the Nagorno-Karabakh issue is probable this year despite
the parliamentary election in Azerbaijan in November, and the
referendum on the Constitution of Armenia, and it is obvious that the
elections are not a good motive, said Dimitrij Rupel. Nevertheless,
he said, the election will not affect the talks. The NKR president
also discussed the boldness of the Armenian party to make compromises,
which is not the case with Azerbaijan. Arkady Ghukassian mentioned
that the Armenian party is aware of the fact that during the talks one
does not get what they want. Of course, it is necessary to sacrifice
something to attain another thing. As to the president, he cannot see
that the Azerbaijanis are brave enough to accept compromise. According
to Arkady Ghukassian, he is interested in the results of the talks
rather than the talks itself. `We always take into account the problem
of security of Nagorno Karabakh, and any decision, any process is
first of all to be determined by the problems of security of Nagorno
Karabakh for us,’ said the president of NKR. As to the variants of
resolution, be it a package or a stage by stage resolution, according
to the president, they are not important. `We agree to the stage by
stage resolution if Azerbaijan agrees to settle first the issue of the
status of Artsakh and only then solve its own problems. This is
acceptable for us. ‘ Arkady Ghukassian was quite brief on the new
model of status which consists in partial independence of Karabakh:
`It is like being partly pregnant. I cannot imagine such a status.’
The NKR president said he drew the attention of the OSCE
Chairman-in-Office to the fact that while the Armenian party views the
issue in the light of the peace process, the Azerbaijani party does
the opposite. Azerbaijan regularly considers the militaristic
resolution of the conflict and increasing the budget of the army.
Arkady Ghukassian explains Aliev’s statement by the fact that the
latter is trying to solve domestic problems but, on the other hand,
the president is anxious because by solving domestic problems Aliev
becomes the slave of his statements and thereby hinders the general
process. According to the NKR president, the resolution is also
delayed because Nagorno Karabakh does not take part in it. In his turn
the foreign minister of Armenia did not forget to mention that this
gap will be filled in very soon `when we arrive at a certain level in
discussing the details.’ In this case, according to him, it will be
necessary to restore the Minsk process, and the government of Nagorno
Karabakh will be automatically involved in the process. After the
meeting with the NKR president the foreign minister of Slovenia
Dimitrij Rupel met with the president of Armenia Robert Kocharian and
the prime minister of Armenia Anoushavan Danielian. President
Kocharian and D. Rupel discussed the talks for the resolution of the
conflict and its present stage. Here is one more interesting detail;
Dimitrij Rupel extended the message of Ilham Aliev to the president of
Armenia. Despite the curiosity of the journalists, the OSCE
Chairman-in-Office did not say anything about the content of the
message. He merely said that hopefully the meetings of the foreign
ministers of the two countries will go on.
CHRISTINE MNATSAKANIAN.
09-09-2005

NKR: Minsk Group Is Not Dead

MINSK GROUP IS NOT DEAD

Azat Artsakh Nagorno Karabakh Republic [NKR]
09 Sept 05
According to him, it is waiting for the instructions of the presidents
of Armenia and Azerbajan. After the meetings with the presidents of RA
and NKR on September 6 the chairman of the OSCE Minsk Group met with
the foreign minister of Armenia Vartan Oskanian. As Mr. Rupel said he
had a lot of questions to discuss with his old friend Vartan Oskanian.
Certainly, the issue of resolution of the Nagorno-Karbakh conflict was
the most interesting of all. According to the OSCE Chairman-in-Office,
there are already points in common in the standpoints of the both
parties, which is commendable. Dimitrij Rupel said he is not partial
and tries to understand and support the process. Accoding to the
European diplomat, to assist to the process he is ready to meet with
all the parties, be it Armenia, Azerbaijan or Nagorno Karabakh. He
described the position of the chairman-in-action as an administrative
official whose task is to listen to the parties and his visit to the
region is the evidence to this. I visited the region to listen rather
than to speak, he mentioned. In fact, In Baku and Yerevan D. Rupel
listened to many, and relying on what he had heard, told the journalists
that there are more points in common between the standpoints of the
parties concerning the Karabakh resolution. However, he noticed that
the similarities are only in principle issues, whereas problems occur
connected with the details. The foreign minister of Armenia Vartan
Oscanian also asserted this idea. `If we start to open these
ideantical principles and go into detail, we shall face serious
difficulties. We cannot discuss any variant of resolution which does
not provide for the right of self-determination of the people of
Nagorno Karabakh,’ stated V. Oskanian. As to the weakening of the
Minsk Group and the rumours about taking away the issue of resolution
from the Minsk Group and solving it under the auspices of another
organization, the OSCE Chairman-in-Office denied these. According to
him, the Minsk group is not dead. What is more, Dimitrij Rupel is
convinced that the meetings of the conflict sides in the framework of
the OSCE Minsk Group will resume. The chairman explained the silence
of the Minsk group by the lack of instructions on the part of the
presidents of Armenia and Azerbaijan. Vartan Oscanian added that when
we reach some level in discussing the details, it will be necessary to
resume the Minsk process in which the Karabakh government will be
involved automatically. In the end the foreign minister of Armenia
touched upon the recent militaristic statements of Azerbaijan (which,
by the way, the OSCE Chairman said not to have ever heard), once again
warned the present government of Azerbaijan and the authors of the
statements. Even if Azerbaijan increases its military budget, it will
not be able to bias the balance with Armenia. We are not afraid of
this way because we have once won already.
CHRISTINE MNATSAKANIAN.
09-09-2005