NO POLITICAL PROBLEMS BETWEEN ARMENIA, IRAN
ARKA News Agency, Armenia
Sept 16 2005
YEREVAN, September 16. /ARKA/. Armenia and Iran have no political
problems, RA Premier Andranik Margaryan stated at his meeting with
Iranian President Mahmud Ahmadinejan in New York, USA. According
to him, the bilataeral economic relations are developing, which is
confirmed by increase in bilateral trade. Margaryan pointed out the
importance of successful implementation of Armenian-Iranian programs,
which will promote the development of bilateral; relations. He stressed
that Iran’s balanced policy played an essential role in the maintenance
of stability in the South Caucasus. He pointed out paramount importance
of this policy being continued. Margaryan expressed gratitude for the
Iranian Government’s attitude to the Armenian community, pointing out
communities’ important role in the development of bilateral relations.
In his turn, the Iranian President pointed out that the development
of friendly relations with its neighbors, particularly, with Armenia,
is in conformity with Iran’s policy. He also pointed out the importance
of consistent implementation of economic programs.
According to the RA National Statistical Service, in January-July
2005, Armenian-Iranian trade turnover totaled $63,335.2ths (exports
$17,884.1ths and imports 45,541.1ths) against $53,689 ths in
the corresponding period of last year ($17,989ths and $35,700ths
respectively). P.t. -0–
Armenian NA Speaker Meets With Secretary General Of InternationalEur
ARMENIAN NA SPEAKER MEETS WITH SECRETARY GEENRAL OF INTERNATIONAL EUROPEAN MOVEMENT
ARKA News Agency, Armenia
Sept 16 2005
YEREVAN, September 16. /ARKA/. Speaker of the RA parliament Artur
Baghdasaryan held a meeting with Secretary General of the International
European Movement (IEM) Henry Kroner. During the meeting, Kroner
told the IEM’s history, pointing out that the organization was at
the outset of the formation of the European Parliament and EU. Kroner
proposed that Speaker Baghdasaryan that he join IEM. Among IEM members
are president of the European Commission Jose Manuel Barosso, French
ex-president Valery giscar de Sten, German ex-Chancellor Helmut Col,
Baghdasaryan expressed his support to Kroner and wished his successful
activities in Armenia. The sided reached an arrangement on further
cooperation.
The 42nd branch of IEM has been opened in Yerevan today. P.T. -0–
EU, Turkey: New Talks, Old Hindrances
EU, TURKEY: NEW TALKS, OLD HINDRANCES
By Federico Bordonaro for ISN Security Watch
ISN, Switzerland
Sept 19 2005
With talks set for next week on Turkey’s EU accession negotiations,
all major EU states appear eager to staff for time.
EU governments on 14 September failed to approve a declaration to
surmount divisions over Ankara’s refusal to recognize Cyprus, a move
considered necessary by continental states to proceed to Turkey’s
membership talks on 3 October. A negotiating mandate for Turkish
entry talks will be discussed once again on 21 September. In a joint
declaration, EU member states have stated that “recognition of all the
member states is a component necessary to the process of adhesion”,
the French daily Le Figaro reported.
However, the Cyprus issue is not the only trouble the Turkish
government will face on its way to Brussels. The EU is split over
further enlargements and more than ever over Turkey’s integration into
the union. After more than 40 years since Europe’s first openings to
the prospect of membership, Turkish accession still appears to be a
long and difficult journey.
Cyprus’ protests and Ankara’s gaffe The current crisis, which broke
just a few weeks before membership talks begin, was originated
by two concomitant events. One is Cyprus’ protest against Ankara’s
unwillingness to fully recognize Cypriot national unity and sovereignty
before the talks start. Evidently, the Turkish government cannot act
in a hurry in this respect, because of the 30,000 ethnic Turks still
living in the island, whose possible departure from Cyprus must be
carefully negotiated to obtain guarantees.
EU member states like France – sceptical about Turkey’s full
integration into the bloc – immediately pointed out that membership
could be given to those who did not fully recognize other member’s
sovereignty. Then this week, Paris accepted a diplomatic draft that
makes it possible for the membership talks to start before Turkey
officially recognizes Cyprus. France thus accepts the talks to begin
as planned on October 3. But the issue is far from over.
September’s other spiky issue was the EU members’ annoyance with
Ankara’s allegedly repressive policy against Orhan Pamuk, a novelist
who is being accused of insulting the Turkish national character for
telling a Swiss journal that “30,000 Kurds and one million Armenians
were killed in these lands and nobody but me dares to talk about it”.
The new Turkish penal code makes it a crime to denigrate the national
identity, and Turkey’s determination to force Pamuk to stand trial
is viewed by many in Western Europe as a “provocation”.
Both these facts highlight underlying European tensions about the
Turkish accession to the EU. However, the impression is that some
governments in Western Europe are using such events to further
complicate the membership talks, thus gaining time and appeasing
recalcitrant and increasingly “euro-sceptic” public opinion at home.
Moreover, Europe is once again divided over the issue, augmenting
Turkey’s frustration and possibly paving the way for further political
manoeuvring.
Europe’s divisions and Turkey’s irritation The real matter behind the
Turkish accession troubles is the EU enlargement process itself. It’s
no secret that EU members are divided over the very nature of Europe’s
political unification. Last year’s big eastward enlargement left many
wondering what kind of union they were getting.
The real issue at hand is the viability of a 25-states federation as a
geopolitical unit – whereas sovereignty in Europe remains split between
a cumbersome supranational decision-level and a weakened national one.
In this respect, Bulgaria’s and Romania’s applications for EU
membership also appear to have become more complicated following the
EU Constitutional Treaty’s failure and the new wave of euro-scepticism
in Western Europe.
Moreover, Ankara’s integration would challenge the European cultural
identity because of its almost totally Muslim population and modify
the demographic balance in the Old Continent. By 2015, Turkey should
have surpassed Germany as the most populous EU country, which – given
the EU voting system – could have important political consequences
on the European parliament, which Paris and Berlin have perhaps
not anticipated.
Paradoxically, the traditionally more Europeanist states like France,
Germany, the Netherlands, or Italy, are disappointed with the EU
political integration process, which they had so strenuously advocated
during the 1990s. This is due to the difficulties in management the
single currency and to the “identity crisis” that has overcome the
“New Europe” – which quickly looked after its own security and
geopolitical goals by aligning with Washington and not with the
Franco-German combine on Iraq.
In addition, both the 2004 enlargement and (especially) the Turkish
membership issue are often perceived by Paris and Berlin as US and
British priorities, and that such processes are being managed according
to the Anglo-American agenda and timing.
All these elements are the driving forces behind recently conceived
proposals of an enhanced partnership between the EU and Turkey, to
be offered Ankara in place of a full membership – a proposal that
has been categorically rejected by Ankara.
In fact, as Italian ambassador Luigi V. Ferraris told to ISN-Security
Watch this week, it is now impossible to keep saying “no” to Ankara
– unless the latter did something so serious to become unacceptable
for the EU.
Turkey is a full member of NATO and is already part of the European
Council, and as such there is no solid basis upon which EU member
states could set up a coherently obstructionist position. Besides,
Ankara could easily perceive its real “fault” being its Muslim identity
– which would only fuel the fires of a “clash of civilizations”
that EU members want to avoid.
Apart from Turkey’s obvious geopolitical and geostrategic importance,
as a land directly connecting the Balkan regions and the Black Sea
regions of Georgia, Armenia, and Azerbaijan, as well as the Syria,
Iraq, and Iran in the Middle East, some observers have highlighted
that Ankara’s role in Europe could be that of epitomizing a modern
Muslim democracy to other influential Muslim states. Since it is often
repeated that one of the keys in tackling Islamist terror is to enhance
moderate Islam, such a “geo-cultural” function could be one of Turkey’s
most attractive features to offer to its diffident EU partners.
On the contrary, should Turkey be eventually refused EU membership, its
ruling classes might turn towards enhanced strategic partnerships with
Syria and Iran from an anti-European perspective, thus complicating EU
efforts to make the East Mediterranean region a secure and stable area.
What is more, in recent years Turkey has worked hard to catch up with
European social and political standards, abolishing the death penalty,
accepting Kurdish as a language in schools, scrapping state security
courts, changing the penal code, and increasing civilian control over
the army.
Can London succeed?
According to Ambassador Ferraris, the current British EU Presidency
has an overtly different position from France, Germany, and the
Netherlands on Turkish membership. London is trying to smooth the
progress of Turkey’s accession, but it is doubtful whether it will
have the strength to impose a decisive acceleration.
The Turkish issue was a central topic during recent French and Dutch
referendums on the EU Constitutional Treaty, and large parts of the
French public are unconvinced that welcoming Ankara into the EU is
in Paris’ interests, Ferraris said.
In Germany, Christian Democratic Union (CDU) candidate Angela Merkel
has taken an anti-integrationist position during the election
campaign, but she is likely to mitigate her position should she
become chancellor, replacing Gerhard Schroder who has lobbied for
full Turkish membership in the EU.
Germany’s Social Democratic Party (SPD), on the contrary, keeps a
more cautious stand on the issue, also because of the large Turkish
community in Germany, whose votes are traditionally social-democrat.
However, German (but also French) decision-makers are still in need
of a clear strategy towards Turkey, whereas Italy appears, for the
moment, decidedly more aligned with London than with Paris and Berlin.
German federal elections, which took place on Sunday, proved to be a
tight race, with both Merkel and Schroder claiming victory on Monday
and the chancellor’s post still up for grabs.
Stalling for time Independent of next week’s talks, all major EU
states appear eager to stall for time. The Turkish membership issue
– already complicated if seen as a EU-Turkey bilateral affair –
is being made increasingly thorny by the French, German, Dutch and
other domestic political contexts.
With public opinion undecided – if not, sometimes, overtly hostile to
Ankara’s accession – it is likely that both the new German government
and its French and Dutch homologues will start the negotiations knowing
that the latter will be very long, so that current governments will
hardly be the ones to resolve the matter.
In fact, according to Ambassador Ferraris, a sort of buck-passing from
present to future European administrations is not to be ruled-out,
even though sharp rhetoric against Turkish integration could be surface
when election campaigns in Western countries enter the decisive stage.
Federico Bordonaro, based in Italy, is an analyst of International
Relations and Geopolitics with the Power and Interest News Report
and Stategic-Road.com. His expertise is concentrated in the new
structure of the international system after the Cold War, the
European integration process, Security and Defense issues, and
political realism.
Armenian FM Holds Working Meeting With OSCE MF Co-Chairman Steven Ma
ARMENIAN FM HOLDS WORKING MEETING WITH OSCE MF CO-CHAIRMAN STEVEN MANN
ARKA News Agency, Armenia
Sept 16 2005
YEREVAN, September 16. /ARKA/. RA Foreign Minister Vardan Oskanyan
has held a working meeting with OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairman, US
representative Steven Mann. The Minister also held meetings with
Belgian Special Representative to the OSCE Pierre Chevalier. The
RA Foreign Minister presented to chevalier various aspects of the
Armenia-OSCe cooperation, regional and economic developments, as well
as the process and prospects of the Nagorno-Karabakh settlement. P.T.
ANKARA: TPB Chairman Sends Letter To Members Of US House OfRepresent
TPB CHAIRMAN SENDS LETTER TO MEMBERS OF US HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
Turkish Press
Sept 16 2005
ANKARA – Turkish Parliamentarians Union (TPB) Chairman Hasan Korkmazcan
sent a letter to members of U.S. House of Representatives, calling
them to act with commonsense and without prejudice regarding the
draft resolution on the so-called Armenian genocide, it was reported
on Friday.
The letter stressed that the provocation carried out by fanatic
organizations within the framework of biased, racist and unreal
allegations, would affect negatively friendly relations of Turkey
with its neighbors.
Korkmazcan indicated that reflecting historical incidents through a
biased point of view which is far from being scientific, and turning
them into campaigns targeting Turkey`s social values, was unfortunate.
Korkmazcan said, “it is an absolute necessity to remember (today)
terrorist groups of Armenian origin, claiming lives of many civilians
and leaving its mark on 70`s and 80`s.”
Committee on International Relations of the U.S. House of
Representatives Thursday passed two resolutions acknowledging the
so-called Armenian genocide, although the U.S. Department of State
sent the committee a letter opposing this move.
ANKARA: A Familiar Strategem
A FAMILIAR STRATEGEM
By Sami Kohen
Turkish Press
Sept 16 2005
MILLIYET- The Armenian lobby has been doing this for years. The
lobby and its supporters always wait for an opportunity to enact
a law justifying the claims on the so-called Armenian genocide in
the US Congress. First of all, it receives support and interest
with a bill it presents to the relevant committees of the House of
Representatives. However, when the bill is brought to the House floor,
the White House and various branches of the administration become
involved in the issue. Finally, the bill is never brought to the floor
or fails to get approval. Then a period of silence follows until the
lobby and its supporters find a new opportunity and go through the
same process.
The US House of Representatives International Relations Committee
this week considered a bill holding the Ottoman Empire responsible
for the Armenian genocide and requesting that the Turkish Republic
accept this crime. Actually, it seems unlikely that this bill will
be presented to the full House or even approved. However, even if the
bill is discussed by the committee and gets great support and interest,
this would be a success for the Armenian lobby. If Congress doesn’t
make such a final decision, it will be necessary to evaluate the
reasons for the Armenian lobby’s success on the US political platform.
Generally, people’s reasons for supporting the claims on the
so-called Armenian genocide in the US, as in other countries,
depends on Turkey’s incompetence in promotion — in conveying
its ideas and influencing public opinion — against the Armenian
diaspora’s advantage of propaganda and influence. It’s a shame that
for years we haven’t overcome this. Unfortunately, Turkey is still
ineffectual against the propaganda of counter-lobbies in the US. We
can’t say that the professional lobbyists working for Turkey are very
successful. Likewise, promotion isn’t the only way of getting results
in the US and the world generally. The political dimensions of this
question are very important. The Armenian lobby’s success in the
Congress is related with the atmosphere of the US public’s feelings
concerning Turkey, in Turkish-US relations, and among politicians
in Washington, and this atmosphere isn’t so bright. Actually, the
US Congress has never really gotten over Turkey’s rejection of the
deployment of US soldiers before the Iraq invasion in March 2003. As
for the political dimensions of the problem, Turkey has to establish
new strategies to counter claims on the so-called Armenian genocide.
ANKARA: US Committee Approves Armenian Resolutions
US COMMITTEE APPROVES ARMENIAN RESOLUTIONS
Turkish Press
Sept 16 2005
Press Review
TURKIYE
The International Relations Committee of the US House of
Representatives yesterday passed two resolutions affirming the
so-called Armenian genocide allegations. The resolutions, which
are expected to reach the House floor, urge commemoration of the
anniversaries of the so-called genocide by the US and call on the
president to take into consideration the Armenian genocide allegations
in setting foreign policy. Supporting the resolutions, committee head
Rep. Henry Hyde stated that he didn’t believe that the resolutions
would harm relations with Turkey. /Turkiye/
Russian-Armenian Military Exercise Anachronostic
RUSSIAN-ARMENIAN MILITARY EXERCISE ANACHRONISTIC
By Vladimir Socor
Eurasia Daily Monitor,
Jamestown Foundation
Sept 16 2005
On September 10-13, Russia and Armenia conducted a tactical
military exercise at the Marshal Bagramian training grounds, close
to the Armenian-Turkish border. President Robert Kocharian and other
Armenian officials attended the final, live-fire stage of the joint
exercise. Each side committed a motor-rifle regiment, artillery, and
tank company, for a total of 1,300 ground troops, to the four-day
exercise. In addition, four Su-25 and four MiG-24 planes from the
Armenian side, S-300 air defense systems, and four MiG-29 planes from
the Russian side, and combat helicopters from both sides took part.
Armenia’s Deputy Defense Minister, Lt.-General Mikael Grigorian, acted
as coordinator of the exercise in the presence of Maj.-General Andrei
Popov, commander of Russia’s Group of Forces in the Transcaucasus
(GRVZ), to which the Russian forces stationed in Armenia are
subordinated. The GRVZ command headquarters has yet to be moved out
of Tbilisi by Russia’s Defense Ministry, presumably to the Russian
base at Gyumri in Armenia. Russia stations an estimated 5,000 troops
of all types in Armenia, including 3,000 officially reported to be
based at Gyumri.
The exercise aimed to test the interoperability of Russian and
Armenian forces. It rehearsed a defensive battle against “aggressor
forces from the direction of Turkey” that attacked on the ground
and in the air, advancing into Armenia during the first stage of
the battle. In the follow-up stages, Russian and Armenian forces
counterattacked and destroyed the invader’s forward elements, then
encircled and attacked the main invasion grouping, forcing it to
surrender. This type of scenario is traditional at Armenian-Russian
annual tactical exercises, but it now seems out of step with the
bilateral rapprochement between Russia and Turkey on all levels,
including that of regional security. This year’s exercise scenario
added for the first time an “anti-terrorist operation” to suppress
a diversionary terror attack by the invading force.
Armenia’s Su-25 planes made their first public appearance in the
country on this occasion. Armenia took delivery of 10 planes of
that obsolescent type from Slovakia’s air force last year. They are
co-located with the Russian base in Gyumri.
Addressing all troops in Russian after the exercise, Kocharian
characterized Armenia-Russia relations overall as “brotherhood…thanks
to which the Russian military base exists and we conduct joint
exercises to ensure our countries’ security.” If viewed in those terms,
however, the exercise scenario of battling Turkey seems anachronistic
and unrealistic. For his part, Defense Minister Serge Sarkisian cited
Azerbaijan as a source of threats to Armenia’s security; he expressed
confidence in the Armenian army’s readiness to face that challenge.
While Yerevan portrayed the exercise accurately as a bilateral
event, Moscow billed it as an undertaking of the CIS Collective
Security Treaty Organization (CSTO). Russia’s Security Council
Secretary Nikolai Bordyuzha, also attending the event, listed the
Russia-Armenia “group of forces” as a CSTO component, together with
a Russia-Belarus group of forces and the Collective Rapid Deployment
Forces in Central Asia. However, those two “groups of forces” exist
only virtually, in Russian planning for wartime operations, and remain
at any time a matter of Russia’s bilateral relations with Armenia or
Belarus. Armenia’s participation in CSTO exercises remains confined
to the annual air defense practice.
Moscow traditionally relies on bilateral relations for alliance
management. However, Russia is interested in advertising the CSTO in
order to enhance Russia’s own status vis-a-vis NATO. Attending the
NATO-Russia meeting of Defense Ministers on September 13 in Berlin,
Russia’s Defense Minister Sergei Ivanov cited the Russian-Armenian
exercise as part of ongoing CSTO activities. He sought to portray the
CSTO as an operational reality and urged NATO to establish cooperation
with this Russian-led organization. Armenia, however, is interested
in developing its own ties with NATO through an Individual Partnership
Action Plan.
(Interfax, Regnum, Arminfo, Armenian Public Television, September
12-14; Air Force Monthly, August 2005)
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
BAKU: Council Of Europe Not To Assist In Holding Vote At KarabakhCon
COUNCIL OF EUROPE NOT TO ASSIST IN HOLDING VOTE AT KARABAKH CONSTITUENCY
Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
Sept 16 2005
The Council of Europe will not assist in the organization of voting
at the Khankandi district constituency in Nagorny Karabakh, which
allows ethnic Armenian citizens of Azerbaijan to vote in the November
parliament elections.
Azerbaijan’s central election commission (CEC) earlier requested CE
to assist in preparation of voter lists and other technical matters
related to the constituency, head of the CE office in Azerbaijan Mats
Lindberg said.
Lindberg told reporters on Thursday that the organization will not
be able to provide assistance, as the CEC appealed to the CE ‘at
the last moment’ and there is not enough time for this. However,
the Council of Europe office in Baku will try to provide a precise
response to the commission’s appeal, he added.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Committee: Armenians Endured Genocide
COMMITTEE: ARMENIANS ENDURED GENOCIDE
By Lisa Friedman, WASHINGTON BUREAU
The Argus, CA
Sept 16 2005
State Department, House speaker fear resolution could hurt
U.S.-Turkish relations
WASHINGTON – In a momentous victory for California’s sizable Armenian
communities, the House International Relations Committee voted
overwhelmingly Thursday to declare the massacre of Armenians in the
Ottoman Empire a genocide.
In a surprise move, Rep. Tom Lantos, D-San Mateo, declared that after
years of opposing the genocide resolution, he now would support it.
The only Holocaust survivor in Congress and the founder of the
Congressional Human Rights Caucus, Lantos had long cited Washington’s
close relationship with Ankara as a key reason for objecting to
the resolution.
The separate resolutions by Reps. Adam Schiff, D-Pasadena, and George
Radanovich, R-Fresno, still must pass several hurdles. The State
Department and House Speaker Dennis Hastert fiercely oppose recognition
of the Armenian genocide, arguing its passage will rupture U.S.-Turkish
relations. Both are expected to try to block a full House vote.
Nevertheless, Armenians on Thursday said by voting 35-11 for Schiff’s
bill and 40-7 for Radanovich’s, the panel sent a strong message that
Congress should not equivocate when it comes to recognizing crimes
against humanity.
“If the United States does not step up and acknowledge this history
and show moral backbone and clarity on these sorts of issues, people
are going to be disappointed in us. We believe in this country because
it does the right thing,” said Armen Carapetian, spokesman for the
Armenian National Committee of America.
The panel voted after more than three hours of tense debate, in
which lawmakers invoked the Holocaust, slavery, Darfur and the fate
of American Indians.
Every Californian on the panel voted in favor of the resolutions.
In 2000, when the issue came before the same committee, Lantos told
his colleagues, “There is a long list of reasons why our NATO ally,
at this point, should not be humiliated.”
On Thursday, Lantos said that while he was “profoundly moved and
anguished by the Armenian people’s horrendous suffering” he remained
unconvinced that the massacres they endured technically constitute
genocide.
Instead, he cited Turkey’s unwillingness to allow U.S. troops to
use its territory to launch an invasion into northern Iraq as well
as the country’s growing closeness with Syria even in the wake of
former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri’s assassination.
“Turkey ignored our interests,” Lantos said. “Our allies must
understand that if they expect the U.S. to support matters of great
interest to them, we expect them to support the things that are
important to the United States.”
Armenians estimate more than 1.5 million died and hundreds of thousands
of others displaced in a planned genocide campaign between 1915 and
1923. Turkey maintains there was no systematic extermination plan,
that only about 300,000 Armenians were killed, and that Armenians
also killed thousands of Turks in the tumultuous last years of the
Ottoman Empire.