TURKISH COURT ORDERS CANCELLATION OF ACADEMIC CONFERENCE ON ARMENIAN MASSACRE
By Benjamin Harvey
The Associated Press
09/22/05 13:45 EDT
ISTANBUL, Turkey (AP) – An Istanbul court on Thursday ordered the
cancellation of an academic conference on the massacre of Armenians
during the Ottoman Empire, casting greater doubt on whether Turkey
is prepared to accept open discussion of controversial subjects.
The conference was originally scheduled for May but was postponed
after Justice Minister Cemil Cicek severely criticized it, saying it
went against government efforts to counter an Armenian campaign to
have the killings recognized as genocide.
The case to close the conference was brought by the Turkish Lawyers
Union and other lawyers.
The conference was scheduled to deal with one of the most sensitive
issues in Turkish politics – the killings of Armenians during
the collapse of the Ottoman Empire around the time of World War I,
which an increasing number of governments have officially recognized
as genocide.
Turkey says the killings took place during civil unrest and backing
the genocide claim in Turkey can be a cause for prosecution.
There was no immediate word from court officials on why the conference
was canceled.
The Anatolia news agency reported that the court said the hosts could
appeal, but demanded a number of documents including the academic
backgrounds of the participants, proof that invitees were of varying
viewpoints and documents listing the financial backers of the speakers.
Turkey came under international scrutiny after the original conference
was postponed, with some critics saying it showed Turkey would not
allow freedom of expression on sensitive subjects.
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan immediately condemned the court’s
decision Thursday. Courts are independent in Turkey, however, and
the prime minister has little power to overturn their decisions.
Last month, Turkey opened a case against one of the country’s most
acclaimed contemporary writers, novelist Orhan Pamuk. Pamuk, who is
often mentioned as a candidate for the Nobel Prize in literature,
is scheduled to go before a Turkish court in December for the crime
of insulting the Turkish national identity. His offending comment was
made to a Swiss newspaper in regard to Turkey’s killings of Armenians
and Kurds.
European Union officials have said they will be watching the Pamuk
trial very closely, and some have suggested that Turkey’s refusal
to permit free expression could be a cause for halting EU membership
negotiations, which are to begin Oct. 3.
Turkish Court Blocks Armenian Genocide Conference
TURKISH COURT BLOCKS ARMENIAN GENOCIDE CONFERENCE
Deutsche Presse-Agentur
September 22, 2005, Thursday
16:59:05 Central European Time
Ankara
A Turkish court has banned an academic conference on the massacres
of Armenians in 1915 by Ottoman Turks, planned for this week, CNN
Turk reported Thursday
The Istanbul 4th Administrative Court ordered the ban on Monday
after a group from the Lawyers Union Foundation applied to have the
conference cancelled. Bogazici University, where the conference was
due to start on Friday, received news of the order on Thursday.
The circumstances surrounding the 1915 massacres of hundreds of
thousands of Armenians continue to arouse controversy in Turkey today,
with the official line being that while many died the incidents cannot
be regarded as a genocide.
More than a dozen European countries have passed resolutions
specifically stating that the events of 1915 did constitute a genocide
and that Turkey should accept this and make appropriate apologies.
The conference was to include a number of Turkish historians who
are critical of the official stance. It was originally to have taken
place on May 25 but organizers decided to postpone it after Justice
Minister Cemil Cicek described the gathering as a “stab in the back”.
Cicek’s comments came despite assurances from Prime Minister Recep
Tayyip Erdogan that Turkey has completely opened its archives and is
prepared to allow historians discuss the issue.
Erdogan said Thursday he regretted the court’s decision saying it
did not comply with democratic rights.
The court decision comes two weeks after prosecutors filed charges
against Turkey’s internationally famous author Orhan Pamuk for
“denigrating the country” when he told a Swiss news magazine that
“a million Armenians were killed”. Pamuk faces up to three years
imprisonment if found guilty.
The latest court decision is sure to embarass the government as it
attempts to convince European countries to give the go ahead for E.U.
membership talks to begin on October 3. dpa cw sr
US Envoy Says UN Discussion Won’t Hamper Karabakh Peace Talks
US ENVOY SAYS UN DISCUSSION WON’T HAMPER KARABAKH PEACE TALKS
Regnum, Moscow, in Russian
22 Sep 05
22 September: The US ambassador to Azerbaijan, Reno Harnish,
has commented on Armenia’s statement on the readiness to quit the
settlement process of the Karabakh conflict, if the UN is involved
in the discussions of the issue.
“The talks between the Armenian and Azerbaijani presidents,
including the Kazan meeting [on 27 August], have been fruitful. The
two sides have reached an agreement regarding discussions of the
Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict in the UN. That is why, the discussions
in the UN are not an obstacle to the settlement process of the
conflict,” the ambassador said.
Harnish also said that the US Congress had not adopted any document
on genocide of Armenians. This issue is being discussed at the
level of [Congress] committees for the time being, he added. “The
US administration believes that this issue should be thoroughly
examined. We call on Turkish specialists to take part in this as well,”
Harnish said.
He said that the USA will render assistance to Azerbaijan in holding
a democratic election, a Regnum news agency correspondent reported.
Asked about the election situation in Azerbaijan, Harnish stressed
that under the current circumstances, it is possible to hold an
election in compliance with international standards. “The authorities,
however, should demonstrate their will and fulfil the commitments of
the presidential decree [on improving election practices] on 11 May
this year. Candidates and voters should be active during the election
and the US government is ready to give its support to ensure that
the election is conducted in a democratic way,” he added.
BAKU: Kuwait Supports Azerbaijan In Karabakh Question
KUWAIT SUPPORTS AZERBAIJAN IN NAGORNO KARABAKH QUESTION
AzerTag, Azerbaijan
Sept 22 2005
Foreign minister of Azerbaijan Elmar Mammadyarov met the
Kuwait-Azerbaijan Inter-parliamentary Group’s delegation lead by
Kuwait’s MP Hamood Mansour El-Hajiri.
Noting that opening of the Azerbaijan embassy in Kuwait creates
favorable atmosphere for close cooperation between the two states,
Minister Mammadyarov wished Kuwait to open its embassy in Azerbaijan,
too, which, according to him, would promote significant impact on
development of bilateral links.
Minister Mammadyarov updated the guests on current situation in the
negotiations concerning the Armenia-Azerbaijan, Nagorno Karabakh
conflict and Azerbaijan’s position in these process, emphasized that
settlement of the conflict is possible only in the frame of territorial
integrity of Azerbaijan.
Underlining that the State of Kuwait supports Azerbaijan in settlement
of the conflict, Mr.
Hamood Mansour El-Hajiri expressed hope for further development of
bilateral cooperation.
Touching upon the situation in Iraq, Mr. Mammadyarov said strengthening
of territorial integrity of this country is necessary; otherwise,
it will cause threat in region.
The sides also had exchange of views on cooperation in the political,
economic, cultural and tourism fields between the two counties.
Armed Separatism Showcased In South Ossetia
ARMED SEPARATISM SHOWCASED IN SOUTH OSSETIA
By Vladimir Socor
Eurasia Daily Monitor, DC
The Jamestown Foundation
Sept 22 2005
On September 19-20 in Tskhinvali, South Ossetian authorities led
celebrations of the 15th anniversary of the declaration of secession
from Georgia. Although the September 20, 1990, declaration and some
subsequent documents speak of “independence” and a “sovereign state,”
the authorities in practice seek outright annexation to Russia via
North Ossetia. A giant billboard just outside Tskhinvali, showing
Russian President Vladimir Putin with the caption, “Our President,”
in effect advertised that program during the festivities.
Yevgeny Trofimov (chairman of the Russian Duma’s Nationalities
Committee), Konstantin Zatulin (who is also director of the
government’s Institute on CIS Affairs), and other Duma deputies
attended the celebration, along with the Abkhaz de facto leader
Sergei Bagapsh (arriving directly from Moscow) and delegations from
Transnistria and Karabakh. These delegations, as well as guests from
North Ossetia, crossed the Russia-Georgia border unlawfully through
the Roki tunnel, which is controlled by Russian troops.
Ossetian troops with some 20 tanks and other armored vehicles,
anti-aircraft installations, and 10 infantry battalions took part
in a military parade in Tskhinvali’s central Stalin Street and
Stalin Square. The “defense ministers” of South Ossetia and Abkhazia,
Maj.-Generals Anatoly Barankevich and Sultan Sosnaliev — both seconded
by the Russian military to these posts — attended the parade.
The Russian “peacekeeping” commander, Maj.-General Marat Kulakhmetov,
pre-notified Tbilisi of some of the movements of those troops and
hardware toward Tskhinvali and conceded that those movements were
unlawful. However, his troops did nothing to stop this massive
breach of multiple agreements among Russia, Georgia, South Ossetia,
and the OSCE on force-reduction and demilitarization measures in the
“security zone.”
South Ossetia’s de facto leader Eduard Kokoiti signed with Bagapsh
a “treaty” on friendship and cooperation between Abkhazia and
South Ossetia — the type of move intended to suggest that the two
territories’ secession from Georgia is irreversible: “Our celebration
will demonstrate to the world that we are full-fledged democratic
states.” However, they made no secret of the shared goal for their
territories to become eventually parts of Russia.
Kokoiti signed an agreement with Russia’s North Ossetian republic
leader, Teimuraz Mansurov, to create a commission on “special
relations” and draft a comprehensive agreement to that effect. The
document proclaims the goal of “striving to preserve the unity of
Ossetia.” “There can be no other option than unification,” Mansurov
declared. In a similar vein, Kokoiti told the press conference, “We see
our future only in a single political, economic, and cultural space
with Ossetia and Russia.” Kokoiti also made a speech on “Ossetian
self-determination” in Russian. He and others at the celebration
summarily dismissed Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili’s offer
of autonomy and devolution of powers to South Ossetia as a “publicity
exercise for international consumption,” thus avoiding discussion of
the offer on its merits.
Georgia’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs lodged a protest with Russia’s
Ministry of Foreign Affairs over Mamsurov’s actions in Tskhinvali.
“Inasmuch as the Russian side is fully responsible for actions of the
executive branch, Georgia regards the step taken by the head of North
Ossetia as an unfriendly move by Russia that encourages separatism.”
Parliament chairwoman Nino Burjanadze in turn “ask[ed] the
international community: Do we really need a peacekeeping force
under whose nose the separatist authorities are staging military
parades? A peacekeeping force that sits idly by while two separatist
presidents are proffering threats?” The parliament’s international
affairs committee chairman, Kote Gabashvili, noted that Russia is
now engaged in an ongoing annexation of South Ossetia after having
supported their secession. The Georgian parliament is now drafting a
resolution calling for basic changes to the “peacekeeping” operations
in South Ossetia and Abkhazia.
On September 21 in the evening, three projectiles were fired from
grenade-launchers into Tskhinvali, injuring seven persons, most of
whom were released from ambulatory care that same evening, Kulakhmetov
announced. Both he and Russia’s MFA statement did not blame any side
for the incident. The festivities were not affected.
Georgia’s Defense Minister Irakli Okruashvili and parliamentary
defense committee chairman Givi Targamadze — who were visiting
nearby Georgian villages that day — rejected any suggestions that
Georgians were responsible. They, as well as State Minister for
Conflict Resolution Giorgi Khaindrava, noted that only Georgia’s
adversaries were interested in provoking such incidents. Saakashvili
promised an investigation and declared that Tskhinvali residents’
safety was “a matter of honor” to him.
In his speeches on September 14 at the summit of world leaders in
New York and on September 18 in Tbilisi, Saakashvili decried the
“intensive annexation” of Abkhazia and South Ossetia “with direct
support from outside,” and vowed that Georgia would never accept such
“despicable annexations” of parts of its territory.
The Tskhinvali events demonstrated also the OSCE’s irrelevance
regarding South Ossetia. The organization has only five or six military
observers, dual-based in Tbilisi and Tskhinvali, who are pathetically
under equipped with transport and communications, and thus unable
to detect most breaches of the agreements on force-reduction and
demilitarization in the “security zone.” The OSCE interprets its
mandate as being confined to the “security zone” around Tskhinvali,
which forms only a small part of South Ossetia’s territory. The
Mission declines to monitor Java, where Ossetian troops and their
heavy weaponry are stationed for quick deployment in Tskhinvali.
Politically, the Mission failed to react to the September 19
demonstration of military force, just as it had failed in June
2004 to react to the expedition of armed “volunteers” from Kuban,
Abkhazia, and Transnistria to South Ossetia and their exercises
with Ossetian troops. As custodian of the Helsinki Final Act and the
Treaty on Conventional Forces in Europe, the OSCE would be obligated
to respond at least declaratively to the ongoing annexation of
Georgia’s territories and the parades of CFE-banned combat hardware
(“unaccounted-for treaty-limited equipment”). However, the OSCE
Mission — like the organization itself — is hostage to Moscow’s
veto in Vienna and thus unable to act unable to act in Tskhinvali.
(Rustavi-2 TV, Interfax, Russian TV Channel One, September 18-21)
Turkish Court Stops Conference On Armenian Killings
TURKISH COURT STOPS CONFERENCE ON ARMENIAN KILLINGS
Reuters
09/22/05 19:23 ET
ISTANBUL, Sept 22 (Reuters) – A Turkish court has ordered the
postponement a university conference called to debate the deaths
of Armenians in Ottoman Turkey during World War One, the state news
agency Anatolia said on Thursday.
The conference, already postponed in May after a minister accused its
organisers of treason, was meant to give a platform to intellectuals
who question Turkey’s official view of the Armenian killings. It was
due to start on Friday.
Turkey denies claims the death of 1.5 million Christian Armenians
in the dying days of the Ottoman empire was genocide, but is under
pressure to change its stance as part of its bid to become the first
Muslim country to join the European Union.
The court unanimously awarded the temporary injunction after various
lawyers and organisations filed complaints demanding the cancellation
of the conference, which was to be held at Istanbul’s Bosphorus and
Sabanci universities.
“Istanbul 4th Administrative Court suspended ‘Ottoman Armenians
during the collapse of the Empire’ conference until the defendant
Bosphorus and Sabanci universities give their defence,” Anatolia news
agency said.
The court asked the universities to provide more information on the
content of the conference and on its speakers but gave no further
details. Turkish law prohibits any comments which are considered
insulting to Turkish national identity.
Turkey’s pro-European government, breaking with past administrations,
has said it is willing to discuss historical differences with
Armenians. But official policy still rejects claims that 1.5 million
Armenians were slaughtered.
It accepts that hundreds of thousands of Armenians were killed by
Ottoman Turks, but says even more Turks died in a partisan conflict
that erupted as the Ottoman empire collapsed.
Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan said he regretted the court’s decision.
“It is not possible that I approve such a decision during a time of
steps for a more advanced democracy, and a more free Turkey.”
Turkey is due to start European Union accession talks in October,
and has taken wide-ranging political reforms to bolster freedom of
expression and improve human rights.
The EU has said Turkey should improve ties with neighbouring Armenia,
and some European leaders have said Turkey must acknowledge the deaths
of Armenians as genocide.
The conference was postponed in May after Justice Minister Cemil
Cicek accused the organisers and participants of treason.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
A Lively Discussion On Armenian Issue At Turkish Weekly
A LIVELY DISCUSSION ON ARMENIAN ISSUE AT TURKISH WEEKLY
Baris Sanli
Journal of Turkish Weekly, Turkey
Sept 22 2005
For those people looking for a lively debate about Armenian Issue,
Journal of Turkish Weekly(JTW) provided such a medium for it, thanks
to Maral Der OHANNESIAN & Sedat LACINER. After Mrs. OHANNESIAN’s call
for a duel, Sedat Laciner accepted the invitation and the duo started
a lively discussion.
The first and the second part of these letters were published on JTW’s
Comments page. The discussions cover a wide range of topics from the
claims to DNA tests. Mrs. OHANNESIAN will set an example for both
Armenian politicians and people with her courage and her willingness
to discuss this issue. This braveness and firm belief in her version
of the history will help the two nations to better understand what
has happened.
The letters can be accessed from:
System Of A Down Brings Its Subtly Satirical Self To Town
SYSTEM OF A DOWN BRINGS ITS SUBTLY SATIRICAL SELF TO TOWN
By Ross Raihala
Pioneer Press, MN
Sept 22 2005
With its innovative, complex music and surreal lyrics, System of a Down
isn’t just the most unusual band in metal (that’s the closest genre
that fits the virtually unclassifiable band). It’s quite possibly
the weirdest million-seller on the charts.
“I love that,” said vocalist Serj Tankian during a phone interview
from Manhattan. “We’ve really never approached anything from the
typical angle. We came into the music scene in L.A. from left field.
“We always did our own thing, taking everyone’s career advice and
then not following it.”
So far, the anti-plan has worked.
The Armenian-American quartet stops by the Xcel Energy Center Friday
night during its most successful year to date. The band launched
“Mezmerize” in the spring with an instantly sold-out guerrilla club
tour. Follow-up disc “Hypnotize” hits stores in November and is
already one of the fall’s most hotly anticipated releases.
” ‘Mezmerize’ and ‘Hypnotize’ are really one record divided into two,”
Tankian said. “It’s not a concept album in terms of completing a story,
but it is kind of like completing a circle.”
Critics have long praised System of a Down’s unbridled creativity,
which brings a Frank Zappa-esque sense of the surreal to pounding,
operatic and politically charged metal. But it’s the kids who fill
the mosh pits at SOAD shows and have snatched up more than 10 million
copies of the band’s albums worldwide.
Does Tankian ever worry his young fans might be missing some of System
of a Down’s more subtle commentary in favor of merely rocking out?
“No, no – rocking out is the reason why we’re doing this,” he said.
“I think as long as people instinctively feel our music, they don’t
have to psychologically analyze it.
“A lot of people do come up with all sorts of theories and
understandings from the lyrics. A lot of people don’t, too, and that’s
OK. We just want people to connect to our music in some way.”
Tankian points to the song “B.Y.O.B.” As far as SOAD goes, it’s a
fairly straightforward protest song with pointed lyrics: “Why don’t
presidents fight the war? Why do they always send the poor?”
“You may not be anti-war yourself,” he said, “but you will definitely
feel the power of the sarcasm in that song. You don’t have to theorize
about it – you just feel it.”
But there’s also a satirical side to System of a Down that often gets
overlooked amid all the anger.
“There has been such a focus on the political aspect of the band or
the heritage aspect of the band,” Tankian said. “But I think people
are starting to get now that humor is a huge part of what we do, too.”
Pop Music Critic Ross Raihala can be reached at
[email protected] or 651-228-5553. Read more about the local
music scene on his blog, “The Ross Who Knew Too Much,” at www.
twincities.com. What: System of a Down, with the Mars Volta and Hella
When: 7 p.m. Friday Where: Xcel Energy Center, 175 W. Kellogg Blvd.,
St. Paul Tickets: $43.25-$35.75 Call: 651-989-5151
ANKARA: Postponed Armenian Conference Put On Hold
POSTPONED ARMENIAN CONFERENCE PUT ON HOLD
Anatolian Times, Turkey
Sept 22 2005
ISTANBUL – The Istanbul Administrative Court no:4 has decided today
to put on hold a conference, titled “Ottoman Armenians During the
Empire`s Fall: Scientific Responsibility and Problems of Democracy,”
that was to take place in Istanbul tomorrow.
The conference was originally scheduled in May, 2005 but was postponed
due to reactions.
The Istanbul court`s decision came after a lawyer, member of the
Foundation of Lawyers` Union, filed an application.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Regular Sitting Of Committee On RA And NKR Inter-ParliamentaryCooper
REGULAR SITTING OF COMMITTEE ON RA AND NKR INTERPARLIAMENTARY COOPERATION TO TAKE PLACE IN SPRING, 2006, IN STEPANAKERT
Noyan Tapan News Agency
Sept 22 2005
YEREVAN, SEPTEMBER 22, NOYAN TAPAN. The regular sitting of the
Committee on Interparliamentary Cooperation of the RA and NKR National
Assemblies will take place in spring, 2006, in Stepanakert.
An agreement about this was reached at the September 20 meeting of
Artur Baghdasarian, the RA NA Chairman, and Ashot Ghulian, the NKR
NA Chairman.
Artur Baghdasarian again congratulated Ashot Ghulian on the occasion
of having been elected the NKR NA Chairman and wished productive work
to the Parliament.
As Noyan Tapan was informed by the RA NA Public Relations Department,
according to traditions established between the Parliaments,
continuation of the cooperation at the level of Committees was mutually
considered important. Agreements were reached concerning legislative
and experimental assistance, joint re-training of staffs, assisting
the NKR Parliament with technical means.