Turkey Rejects EU Pressure On Genocide

TURKEY REJECTS EU PRESSURE ON GENOCIDE
Al-Jazeera, Qatar
Sept 29 2005
Turkey’s prime minister has rejected a European Parliament resolution
calling on Ankara to recognise the mass killings of Armenians during
the first world war as genocide.
“That resolution is not binding. It does not matter whether they
took such a decision or not. We will continue on our way,” private
CNN-Turk television quoted Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan as
saying during a visit to Abu Dhabi.
Turkey is scheduled to open accession talks with the EU on Monday.
The EU lawmakers said in their resolution that recognition of the
1915-1923 killings as genocide should be a prerequisite for Turkey
to join the European Union.
Armenians across the world have been commemorating the anniversary
of what they brand as genocide on 24 April each year.
Ottoman Turks
Armenians say that 1.5 million Armenians were killed by
Ottoman Turks around the time of the second world war, which Armenians
and several nations around the world recognise as the first genocide
of the 20th century.
Turkey denies that the killings were genocide, saying the toll is
inflated and that Armenians were killed in civil unrest as the Ottoman
Empire collapsed.
Speaking to Turkish reporters in Abu Dhabi, Erdogan also reiterated
his view that the EU has to admit Turkey or risk being branded a
“Christian club”.
“The EU … has to prove that it is not a Christian club. To say
‘the EU is not a Christian club’ will not save it from becoming a
Christian club,” he said.
“What will the EU achieve by admitting Turkey? It will become a bridge
between the 1.5-billion strong Muslim world and the EU. It will start
an alliance of civilisations,” he added.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Turkey Must Recognize Armenian Genocide To Join EU

TURKEY MUST RECOGNIZE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE TO JOIN EU
BBC News, UK
Sept 28 2005
The European Union parliament has backed plans to start talks on
Turkish accession, but insisted on a number of provisos before it is
allowed entry.
MPs insisted Ankara recognise the killings of thousands of Armenians
in 1915 as genocide. Turkey denies that the killings were systematic.
MPs also postponed a vote on ratifying Turkey’s customs arrangements
because of its refusal to recognise Cyprus.
Neither decision affects entry talks which are due to start on
3 October.
The negotiations, once started, are expected to take about 10 years.
The European Commission said the postponement of the vote was an
“own goal” by the parliament.
The Armenian killings have long been a taboo subject in Turkey.
Armenians, supported by 15 countries, including France, Switzerland,
Russia and Argentina, accuses the then Ottoman rulers of carrying out a
“genocide”.
Turkey disputes the charge, saying that a few hundred thousand died
and that the deaths occurred in a civil war in which many Turks were
also killed.
But Turkey’s Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan did condemn a Turkish
court’s decision to order the cancellation of a conference about the
killings which was due to have been held last week.
Vetoes await
Further talks about Turkey’s accession are set for Thursday to try
to resolve a deadlock over the question of the negotiating framework
for Turkish membership.
Turkey has been clear that it will not accept the option of privileged
partnership, which Austria is pushing to be inserted into the
negotiating framework; only full membership will do.
The BBC’s Jonny Dymond says that even if they get the framework they
want, the membership process will be a long and painful one.
This is partly because so much needs to be done by Turkey to adapt
itself to EU rules. It needs to absorb the 80,000 page long EU rule
book into its domestic law.
One member state has already boasted about the number of potential
vetoes it has during the negotiations process. There is also the
question of Turkey’s continuing human rights reform process.
Expectations
The European Commission has promised to monitor closely how Turkey
proceeds. If it is deemed to be slipping backwards in theory or
practice, then the commission will not hesitate to make its misgivings
public.
To add to all the difficulties, there is the question of public
expectations in Turkey.
Our correspondent says many Turks see the membership process as a
genuine negotiation, a process of give and take. But by and large,
Turkey has simply to do what it is told if it wants to join the club –
which for many is a sharp change in culture, he adds.

Crushing Turkey’s Hopes For EU Entry Is A Death Sentence For ItsRefo

CRUSHING TURKEY’S HOPES FOR EU ENTRY IS A DEATH SENTENCE FOR ITS REFORM DRIVE
The Daily Star, Lebanon
Sept 29 2005
Editorial
Although the European Parliament’s resolution to add new conditions
to Turkey’s accession to the European Union will not affect the start
of negotiations toward this end, the move was yet another example
of Europe’s deep reluctance to welcome Turkey into the union. It has
been over 40 years since Turkey first applied to be a member of what
was then the ECC, and during the course of a long and tedious journey
toward membership, Turkey has patiently waited for a sign that the
desired outcome is within reach.
The Turkish government has now made it clear that its patience
is running out. Yesterday, the Foreign Ministry reiterated that
Turkey will reject an offer of “privileged partnership” and will only
participate in negotiations that are geared toward full membership. A
failure on the part of the EU to offer membership will likely disrupt
the process of engagement that Europe has maintained with Turkey in
recent years.
We have already seen the benefits of Europe’s engagement with the
Turkey. To get this far in the process, Turkey has made great strides
in implementing a number of wide-ranging political reforms. The
government has abolished state security courts, reformed the penal
code, scrapped the death penalty and allowed Kurdish to be taught and
spoken in schools. There is still much more that needs to be done
in terms of political reform, improving human rights, protecting
minorities, recognizing Cyprus and acknowledging the Armenian
genocide. But keeping the process of negotiations alive will ensure
that there is continued progress on these and other fronts.
Breaking away from this process prematurely, however, would be a
recipe for disaster. Without the goal of membership in view, there
is little motivation for Turkey to continue on its current path.
Turkey’s accession could take as long as 10 years and it stands to
reason that during the lengthy process of negotiation, there will
be ample time for Turkey to make even greater advancements toward
a democratic state. The start of membership talks should therefore
be viewed as the beginning of a prolonged dialogue in which Europe
has an opportunity to promote democracy in Turkey, and by extension,
in the entire Middle East.

Armenian Delegation Held Several Meetings In Washington

ARMENIAN DELEGATION HELD SEVERAL MEETINGS IN WASHINGTON
Pan Armenian News
28.09.2005 03:57
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ September 24-28 the Armenian governmental delegation
was in Washington for the participation in the sitting of the
Armenian-American intergovernmental working group on economic affairs
and the annual sitting of the World Bank and the International Monetary
Fund. Armenian Minister of Economy and Finance Vardan Khachatrian,
RA President’s Chief Advisor on Economic affairs Vahram Nersisyants,
Minister of Trade and Economic Development Karen Chshmaritian,
Minister of Agriculture David Lokian, RA Central Bank President Tigran
Sargsian, Deputy Foreign Minister Arman Kirakosian, RA Ambassador to
the U.S. Tatul Margarian and Deputy Minister of Economy and Finance
Tigran Khachatrian served on the Armenian delegation.
Within the framework of the WB-IMF sitting the Armenian delegation
members met with the leadership of the organizations. September
27 they met with Millennium Challenge Corporation Acting Executive
Director Charles Setnes to discuss the Armenian Millennium Challenge
program. The parties agreed on proceeding with the joint activities
in order to accomplish the program. The Armenian delegates also held
meetings with Dutch Minister of Finance Gerrit Zalm and the Iranian
Minister of Finance.

ANALYSIS-Cyprus Will Hinder Not Block Turkey EU Talks

ANALYSIS-CYPRUS WILL HINDER NOT BLOCK TURKEY EU TALKS
By Michele Kambas
Reuters
09/28/05 09:56 ET
NICOSIA, Sept 28 (Reuters) – A divided Cyprus is unlikely to block
Turkey’s path in talks on joining the European Union but will attempt
to wring concessions from the big, Muslim nation every step of the way,
analysts said.
Greek Cypriots, who represent Cyprus in the EU, will be reluctant to
use their veto against Turkey in the talks, which start on Monday,
for fear of further damaging U.N. efforts to end the Mediterranean
island’s 31-year division, officials said.
But they could still create headaches for the EU in each of the 35
sections of membership negotiations, known as chapters, which require
unanimity from all 25 members. The EU is already facing objections
from members such as France and Austria.
“It is our right (to use the veto), as it is the right of other member
states, but we are not thinking about it right now,” said a senior
Cypriot official who requested anonymity.
Analysts say Cyprus is sure to constantly remind both Turkey and
the EU of any shortcomings, but Greek Cypriots know it is in their
interest to have Ankara in the EU rather than out.
“It must be very distasteful for them to allow the process to go
forward while Turkey is in occupation of part of Cyprus, but you have
to balance that by looking forward in the hope Turkey becomes more
moderate and European,” said analyst James Ker-Lindsay, director of
Civilitas Research in Nicosia.
DIVISION RUN DEEP
In divided Nicosia, Greek Cypriots can see a massive Turkish Cypriot
flag painted on the jagged mountain slopes on Cyprus’s northern rim.
Both sides are heavily militarised.
A ceasefire line laced with mines and patrolled by a U.N peacekeeping
force separates Greeks from the smaller and less wealthy Turkish
Cypriot community in the north.
“This isn’t Austria. The Austrians can have their opinions but they
are not going to suffer if the door is closed in Turkey’s face.
Cyprus will,” said Ker-Lindsay.
Cyprus, internationally recognised and Greek Cypriot-ruled, had hoped
Turkey’s EU aspirations would help re-unite the island invaded by
Turkey 1974 after a brief Greek-led coup.
But the United Nations abandoned its efforts in 2004, stung by the
rejection of its reunification plan. Another half-hearted attempt
flopped earlier this year with diplomats blaming the Greek Cypriots
for playing hard ball.
The EU would rather not get involved. It is likely to try to skirt
around sensitive issues in the talks but it remains to be seen whether
this will be possible, said Phedon Nicolaides of the European Institute
of Public Administration at Maastricht.
“I think everyone will play for time. The Commission will play for
time, the Turks will play for time. Everyone is hoping for a solution,
but there is nothing suggesting the U.N. are undertaking any new
initiative,” he said.
In a foretaste of what is to come, EU envoys spent much of September
haggling over how to formulate a response to Ankara’s refusal to
recognise Cyprus without a peace deal first.
And Cyprus has made clear it will fight hard on specific points,
such as Turkey lifting a financially damaging blockade on Cypriot
aircraft and vessels.
Ankara has failed to fully comply with an accord extending its customs
union to Cyprus, an issue which will be up for further review in
2006. Failing implementation, Cyprus will want its EU partners to
throw the book at Turkey.
Among its own options are a recourse to the European Court and to
report Turkey to the World Trade Organisation and GATT.
“Turkey fully understands that if talks are to get off to a positive
rhythmn then issues related to the customs union will be a priority,”
said John Palmer, director at the European Policy Centre in Brussels.
Analysts warn that the EU and Cyprus should be careful not to push
too hard a country that has had its pride pricked by criticism of
its human rights record and Europeans openly cautious of admitting
it into a largely Christian club.
The European Parliament, in a non-binding resolution, said on Wednesday
Turkey had to recognise the killing of Armenians under Ottoman rule
in 1915 as genocide before it could join.
“The difficulty for Cyprus is that Turkey is beginning to realise that
they can get on without being a full member of the EU. It is not EU
accession at all costs,” said Tim Ash, emerging markets strategist
at Bear Stearns in London.
“They will want to push Turkey for concessions on Cyprus, but not
too hard.”

Armenian Parliament, Minus Opposition,Approves Constitutional Amendm

ARMENIAN PARLIAMENT, MINUS OPPOSITION, APPROVES CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
The Associated Press
09/28/05 08:59 EDT
YEREVAN, Armenia (AP) – The Armenian parliament on Wednesday gave
final approval to constitutional amendments intended to impose a
more strict separation of powers between the judicial, executive and
legislative branches.
The proposed changes also include removal of a clause outlawing dual
citizenship for members of Armenia’s large foreign Diaspora.
The package of changes passed by a vote of 89-0, with one abstention.
The 24 opposition deputies, however, boycotted the vote, just as they
have boycotted most sessions of parliament on the grounds that their
proposals were not taken into account.
The opposition has called on Armenians to reject the amendments in
a late November referendum.

A New Film On Armenian Genocde At ‘Moscow’ Cinema

A NEW FILM ON ARMENIAN GENOCIDE AT ‘MOSCOW’ CINEMA
By Tamar Minasian
AZG Armenian Daily #173
28/09/2005
Cinema
On October 16, “Moscow” cinema will show the premiere of “Arakel”,
film director Zohrap Bek-Gasparents told journalists yesterday. The
movie depicts events of 1910-15 in Eastern Armenia. It is a story
of a frustrated love that continues and gains momentum as deported
Armenian workers and intellectuals carry out their exile. “This is
a real story that happened to my grandpa’s brother. On this road it
is love that saves them, love that is peculiar only to Armenians and
their faith in God”, the filmmaker said.
The preparatory works of the film began in December of the last
year. The film was shot in Lori, Gyumri, in the surroundings of
the Lake Sevan and Yerevan. The budget of “Arakel” amounted to
$100.000. The film director thinks that this is a very small sum for
a fiction but it’s more important that one has a wish to shoot. Zohrap
Bek-Gasparents thinks that everybody should work hardly in his sphere
to gradually approach the day of Armenian Genocide’s international
recognition.
The film is currently being translated into Russian, English and
French. The authors of the film will make every effort to show it
in Turkey. They also work to represent the film at international
festivals and have so far made several arrangements.
“We have to go back to our faith. We can only pin our hopes on our
God and us. The Armenians are very forgiving. If someone apologizes
for a crime he committed he is sure to be forgiven. As far as our
neighbor lacks nobility to say sorry, we have to present as many
films and books as needed to make them understand”.

EU Parliament Deals Setback To Turkey

EU PARLIAMENT DEALS SETBACK TO TURKEY
By Jeremy Smith
Reuters
09/28/05 14:27 ET
STRASBOURG, France, Sept 28 (Reuters) – European Union lawmakers
chided Turkey on Wednesday, five days before it is due to open EU
membership talks, demanding that Ankara recognise the 1915 killing
of Armenians as genocide before it joins the bloc.
The European Parliament gave grudging blessing to the start of
negotiations next Monday after a heated debate that vented strong
criticism of Turkey’s human rights record.
But it postponed a vote to ratify Turkey’s extended customs union
with the EU in a bid to put pressure on Ankara to open its ports and
airports to traffic from EU member Cyprus.
The non-binding resolution was a political slap in the face for Turkey,
which insists there was no genocide.
The Turkish lira and stock market lost ground on the news, although
traders said they did not believe the Oct. 3 opening of talks was
at risk.
Former Turkish foreign minister Yasar Yakis from the ruling AK party
told NTV television: “These decisions of the European parliament make
things more difficult for Turkey.”
EU governments remain deadlocked on a negotiating mandate for the
talks, with Austria holding out for a more explicit mention of an
alternative to membership.
Ankara reaffirmed on Wednesday it would accept nothing less than
full membership.
Diplomats said the 25 EU foreign ministers would probably hold
an emergency meeting on Sunday night in Luxembourg, hours before
negotiations are meant to start, to seek an agreement.
British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw, whose country holds the revolving
EU presidency, told his Labour Party conference in Brighton, England,
the decision was a test for the EU.
“It would now be a huge betrayal of the hopes and expectations of the
Turkish people and of Prime Minister (Tayyip) Erdogan’s programme of
reform if, at the crucial time, we turned our back on Turkey,” he said.
“For Turkey would lose from a ‘no’ decision. But Europe and its people
would lose even more.”
RECOGNISE CYPRUS
The EU legislature demanded that Turkey recognise Cyprus soon and
said negotiations could be suspended unless it granted access to
Cypriot aircraft and shipping by next year.
The vote followed an emotional debate in which many deputies attacked
Turkey’s record on human rights, religious freedom and minorities,
reflecting widespread public hostility to the poor, populous, mostly
Muslim nation ever joining the EU.
EU Enlargement Commissioner Olli Rehn regretted the decision to delay
ratification of the extended customs union, saying it would weaken
Brussels’ hand with the Turks, but stressed it would have no impact
on the start of negotiations.
Rehn warned Turkey it would have to amend its new penal code, adopted
to meet EU criteria, if hardline judges were still able to prosecute
the country’s leading novelist for expressing his views on the killings
of Armenians under Ottoman rule.
“The case of author Orhan Pamuk is emblematic of the difficulties
to ensure effective and uniform implementation of these reforms, and
also of the struggle between reformers and conservatives in Turkey,”
Rehn told the European Parliament.
An Istanbul judge is prosecuting the writer for “denigrating Turkish
identity” by endorsing the term genocide. He faces up to three years
in jail if convicted.
Other judges tried in vain to halt an academic conference in Istanbul
on the Armenian issue last week.
EU lawmakers demanded an undertaking that when the Turkish parliament
ratifies a protocol extending the customs union to new EU member
states, it will not attach a government declaration refusing to
recognise Cyprus.
Rehn had warned parliament it would be scoring “an own goal” if it
refused to approve the extended customs union.
Many lawmakers questioned the EU’s ability to absorb Turkey financially
and politically, especially after French and Dutch voters’ rejected
a draft EU constitution designed to streamline the bloc’s creaking
institutions to cope with enlargement.
Greens party leader Daniel Cohn-Bendit caused uproar by accusing some
right-wing critics of Turkey of “surfing on a wave of racism.”
Rehn said that on balance, Turkey had made sufficient progress on
human rights to justify opening talks, saying the negotiations would
give the EU crucial leverage over the direction of Turkish reforms.
Opinion polls show a majority of EU citizens, especially in France,
Germany and Austria, oppose Turkish membership.
Hans-Gert Poettering, leader of the conservative European People’s
Party, said if Turkey did not improve its human rights record within
a period after starting talks, “then we should be prepared to suspend
the negotiations.”
(Additional reporting by Marcin Grajewski in Brussels; Zerin Elci in
Ankara and Mike Peacock in Brighton, England)

U.S. Lawmakers Directing Schools To Expand History Curriculums

U.S. LAWMAKERS DIRECTING SCHOOLS TO EXPAND HISTORY CURRICULUMS
By Michael Gormley
The Associated Press
09/28/05 13:05 EDT
ALBANY, New York (AP) – State legislators across the United States
are increasingly directing their schools to teach students more about
the struggles and triumphs of different races and ethnic groups –
a move critics say amounts to politically correct meddling.
In the latest such example, a new commission in New York will examine
whether the “physical and psychological terrorism” against Africans in
the slave trade is being adequately taught in schools. The commission
is named for the slave ship Amistad, which was commandeered by slaves
who eventually won their freedom in the U.S.
Supreme Court.
The recommendations could mean rewriting textbooks, which may influence
educators in other states, according to the National Council for the
Social Studies.
A number of other U.S. states have enacted similar measures in the last
five years, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures.
Illinois also created an Amistad commission this year and added lessons
on the Holocaust, while New Mexico’s legislature required Indian
education lessons be bolstered in kindergarten through sixth grade.
In 2001, New Jersey created an Amistad commission and the Commission
on Italian and Americans of Italian Heritage Culture and Education
to advise policy makers.
California created Cesar Chavez Day – in memory of the Mexican American
labor leader – in 2000 and directed schools to include lessons about
the farm labor activist. That same year, Rhode Island directed schools
to teach about genocide and human rights violations including the
slave trade, the Irish potato famine, the Armenian genocide of the
early 1900s, the Holocaust and Italian dictator Benito Mussolini’s
fascist regime.
Virginia also directed schools that year to teach about the
accomplishments of people from different ethnic backgrounds and races,
women and disabled people.
But while most legislatures enact curriculum changes recommended by
education departments, teachers and researchers, New York’s Amistad
Commission is a case of the Legislature trying to circumvent the
state’s policy-setting Board of Regents.
“Slavery is the backbone on which this country was built,” said
Assemblyman Keith Wright, a New York City Democrat who wrote the
Amistad bill. “We haven’t even touched the tip of the iceberg in
terms of studying it … I have two children and I don’t think they
have studied the issue thoroughly.”
Critics say the goal of the commission is laudable but that teachers
already have limited time to teach American history. They also say
educators are needed on the panel to make sure its recommendations
are feasible.
The commission will include 19 unpaid members. Eight will be appointed
by the governor, and the rest will be picked by the state secretary
of state, the state education commissioner and the majority leaders
of the Legislature. Panelists need not be academics.
On the Net:
New York Assembly:
National Council for the Social Studies:

Integration But Not Assimilation

INTEGRATION BUT NOT ASSIMILATION
By Tatoul Hakobian
AZG Armenian Daily #173
28/09/2005
Diaspora
NGOs of Javakhk Demand Wide Autonomy Within Georgia
On September 23-24, the Armenian NGOs of Samtskhe-Javakhk region held
their 3d assembly in Akhalkalak within the frameworks of “Integration
but not Assimilation” initiative. The assembly adopted a resolution at
the end of the meeting. In a phone conversation with Azg, head of Virq
Party, Davit Rstakian, informed that a number of active organizations
of Javakhk took part in the assembly (“Javakhk” movement, JEM, Akunq,
A-Info and Virq).
The resolution they passed says that “only federally united Georgia
can secure final stability in the region as well as territorial
wholeness of the country… Unbalance approach in the state structures
to national minorities can damage Georgia’s international authority
and the democratic tendencies in the country”.
The Armenian organizations of Javakhk outlined the necessary steps for
the Georgian government to take in regard to national minorities:
“Granting Armenian-populated Samtskhe-Javakhk and Kvemo-Kartli
regions the status of an autonomous subject within Federal Georgia
with wide autonomy including the right of holding free elections
for of all autonomous bodies; granting Armenian language the status
of official along with Georgian; appropriate subsidies from state
budget for preserving and developing the national identity, culture,
language and history of the nations living in Samtskhe-Javakhk”.
The Russian and Georgia mass media widely covered the meeting. While
Moscow stresses the demand of autonomy, Tbilisi labeled the organizers
of the assembly extremists and separatists. Davit Rstakian told Azg
that “we are the owners of this land” and “we organized this assembly”
to give truthful assessment to present problems.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress