BAKU: Azerbaijan Does Not Consider EU Statement As Serious

AZERBAIJAN NOT CONSIDER EU STATEMENT AS SERIOUS
Azerbaijan News Service
Oct 7 2005
A high-ranking European Union official has warned Azerbaijan may
“fall behind” in the EU New Neighborhood Policy due to its forging
ties with the unrecognized Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus
(TRNC), Armenia media reported. The European Commissioner for
Foreign Affairs Benita Ferrero-Waldner said the international
community recognizes a united Cyprus. This country is currently
blocking the progress achieved by Baku within the mentioned program
due to the opening of direct flights with TRNC, she said. I have
informed Azeris that if they do not change their decision, we will
continue collaborating only with Georgia and Armenia within the
New Neighborhood Policy. Nonetheless, we hope Azerbaijan will find
a solution for the problem, said Ferrero-Waldner.In his turn Azeri
official do not consider the statement as serious. Tahir Taghizadeh,
head of the information of the Ministry of foreign affairs of
Azerbaijan said official Baku did not receive any letter on the
issue. In his interview with ANS TV, Mr. Taghizadeh said during his
visit to New-York within the 60th session of UN, Elmar Mammadyarov,
foreign minister of Azerbaijan met with his Cypriote (Greek Part)
Colleague and no excitement was heard from that part. In any case we
are not going to change our position. Because position of Azerbaijan
coincides with one of the United Nations, European Union and other
countries who call to eliminate problems and bring the Northern Cyprus
from isolations. Relations with Northern Cyprus are only commercial
and no need to politicize the case.

ANKARA: We Cannot Let It Happen Again

WE CANNOT LET IT HAPPEN AGAIN
Turkish Daily News
Oct 9 2005
‘How many great poets, like Nazim Hikmet, could we have had if in
the past hundred years our culture had not been suppressed,’ Yasar
Kemal had once lamented. He would know the answer better than anyone.
Himself an ethnic Kurd, Kemal has always been outspoken on issues
of human and minority rights not only via his writing but also via
his activism.
Elif ªafak “How many great poets like Nazim Hikmet could we have had
if in the past hundred years our culture had not been suppressed,”
Yasar Kemal once lamented. He would know the answer better than
anyone. Himself an ethnic Kurd, Kemal has always been outspoken on
issues of human and minority rights not only via his writing but also
via his activism. In 1995 after publishing an article in Der Spiegel,
he was given a suspended sentence of 20 months in prison. During
Kemal’s trial 1,000 intellectuals had claimed responsibility for
the book in which his article had appeared in order to stand behind
him. Among these intellectuals, 99 went on trial at the Istanbul
State Security Court (DGM).
Viewed from this perspective, it looks like nowadays an old pattern
is repeating itself. Once again an acclaimed Turkish novelist is
being put on trial for his views. Orhan Pamuk will go to court in
December for the views he expressed during an interview with a Swiss
paper. In that interview Pamuk had claimed, “Thirty thousand Kurds
and 1 million Armenians were killed in these lands and nobody but
me dares to talk about it.” Once this statement was heard in Turkey,
it triggered a huge reaction and nationalist uproar. At the same time
there was an intricate debate in the Turkish media, full of twists
and turns. The debate was not between “black” and “white” but between
“shades of gray.” Not many Western journalists have paid attention to
the nuances of this debate, and not many Turkish intellectuals have
tried to explain the nuances to foreign journalists. As a result,
civil society in Turkey has been depicted as more black-and-white
than it really is.
There is no clash of civilizations. Instead there is a clash of
opinions and values. As in many countries, in Turkey too there
is a clash between two forces. On the one hand there is the
“state oriented.” They comprise a crooked alliance: army officers,
conservative bureaucrats, some diplomats, ultranationalist groups,
some Kemalists and some groups on the far left. All these people
can act together if they suspect that “Ataturk’s legacy is being
challenged” and that the state is in danger. For them the state
machinery is above everything, above society and the individual. They
all respond with a nationalist reflex when a Turkish intellectual
voices a critical opinion outside Turkey. The desire to look “good”
in the eyes of the Western world runs deep in the subconscious of this
group. Anyone who taints Turkey’s image in the eyes of the Western
world is seen as a “traitor.” This group is strong, as it is backed
by state apparatuses. Yet, it is also problematically heterogeneous.
The second major force in Turkey today is the “civil
society-oriented.” These, too, compose an alliance: liberals,
libertarians, some social democrats, some conservative Muslims critical
of an excessively centralized regime, many Kurds and Alawis and Sufis
and all open-minded intellectuals. This second alliance is pushing
the country harder and harder towards a multicultural, cosmopolitan
regime and strongly favors Turkey’s accession to the EU.
This group is strong. The problem is, the more they gain pace, the
more the backlash against them.
Turkish media and civil society were recently stirred by a critical
conference that was held for the first time in Istanbul: a conference
on Ottoman Armenians. Over the last four years, similar workshops and
conferences had been organized by open-minded Turkish and Armenian
scholars in different parts of the United States. Yet this conference
differed from the previous ones in three aspects: It was held in
Istanbul, organized collectively by three Turkish universities and all
its keynote speakers came originally from Turkey. For the first time
critical-minded Turkish intellectuals came together to jointly explore
what had happened to the Ottoman Armenians before, during and after
1915. Though highly diverse in other ways, the participants shared one
thing in common: their belief in the need to face the atrocities of
the past, no matter how distressing or dangerous, in order to create
a better future and a more democratic society in Turkey. Despite a
last-minute legal maneuver by a lawyer to prevent it from happening,
the conference was held and openly supported by Prime Minister Recep
Tayyip Erdogan. All papers were presented without censure, and even
the taboo word “genocide” was publicly uttered. The next day Turkey’s
Milliyet said “Another Taboo Has Been Smashed.”
Though there has been an accompanying nationalist smear campaign,
the number of Turks supporting the network of intellectual solidarity
between Turkish and Armenian intellectuals is on the rise. Through
the collective efforts of academics, journalists, writers and media
correspondents, 1915 is finally being opened to discussion in Turkey
like never before. All this is accompanied by a series of important
steps that the government has taken to improve its human rights record.
Therefore, Pamuk’s case will be received within such a complicated
framework in which two forces are in conflict. We are in need of
collective efforts for the civil society-oriented to preside over
the state-oriented. Turkey is a country where in the past, social
transformation was always introduced from above, imposed by a cultural
elite on the rest of society. This time it has to be different. For
a true democracy to exist, change has to come from below and from
within. This is what we are struggling for.
Turkish intellectuals will stand by Pamuk on the day of his trial,
just like they stood by Kemal in the past. Our country has already
hurt and isolated many of its great poets and writers in the past. We
cannot let it happen again.
–Boundary_(ID_COyhDwRn5uic7+LA23/slw)–
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

EU Support For Turkey ‘Genocide’ Writer

EU SUPPORT FOR TURKEY ‘GENOCIDE’ WRITER
By Amberin Zaman in Istanbul
The Daily Telegraph, UK
Oct 10 2005
A senior European Union official has underlined concern for Turkey’s
human rights record by joining the acclaimed author, Orhan Pamuk,
for lunch in Istanbul. An Istanbul court provoked outrage last month
when it charged Mr Pamuk with violating laws that forbid description
of the mass killings of Armenians during the last days of the Ottoman
Empire as genocide.
The author, who is due to appear in court on Dec 16, could spend
up to three years in prison if found guilty of “insulting Turkey’s
national dignity”. The charges were filed after Mr Pamuk told a Swiss
newspaper in February that “a million Armenians and 30,000 Kurds were
killed in these lands and nobody but me dares talks about it”.
Olli Rehn, the EU’s enlargement commissioner who lunched with Mr Pamuk,
hinted that negotiations with Turkey over its entry to the EU might
be interrupted if the author were to be convicted.
From: Baghdasarian

Turkey Plays Down Author’s Trial

TURKEY PLAYS DOWN AUTHOR’S TRIAL
Al-Jazeera, Qatar
Oct 10 2005
Sunday 09 October 2005, 23:13 Makka Time, 20:13 GMT
Abdullah Gul (R) says Turkey’s rights record has improved
Turkey’s foreign minister says he is confident a court will dismiss
charges against a best-selling Turkish writer who faces prison for
his views on the massacres of Armenians 90 years ago.
Orhan Pamuk has been charged with insulting Turkish identity for
supporting Armenian claims that they suffered a genocide under Ottoman
Turks in 1915. He faces three years in jail if convicted.
Pamuk further upset the establishment and nationalists by saying
Turkish forces shared responsibility for the deaths of more than
30,000 Kurds in southeast Turkey during separatist fighting there in
the 1980s and 1990s.
Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul on Sunday sought to play down the
controversy, telling Canal television that he expected the case to
be dismissed because a court had thrown out similar charges against
a different person.
Rights record
“The same trial has been held before, over the same phrases, the same
words,” Gul said.
“The judge ruled that everyone has the right to express their
opinion. The same decision will be handed down, I have no doubt
about this.”
Nationalists reject any attempt to reopen the Armenian chapter
Pamuk’s prosecution has highlighted concerns over whether Turkey’s
human-rights record is compatible with EU membership. About 60% of
French voters say they do not want mainly Muslim Turkey to join the EU.
In a show of support, EU Enlargement Commissioner Olli Rehn met Pamuk
at the writer’s Istanbul home on Saturday and urged Ankara to respect
freedom of expression.
Pamuk, best known for historical novels such as My Name is Red and
The White Castle, goes on trial on 16 December.
Archives opened
Gul said that despite the case, human rights had advanced by leaps
and bounds in the past three years.
“The same trial has been held before, over the same phrases, the
same words”
Abdullah Gul, Turkish Foreign Minister
“We have a limited democracy in Turkey … but thanks to the reforms
of the past few years, its scope has widened enormously.”
Turkey had offered to open its archives to international historians
to resolve the Armenian massacre issue, which has complicated Ankara’s
bid to join the European Union.
The European Parliament last month passed a non-binding resolution
saying Ankara must recognise the Armenian massacres as a genocide
before joining the EU, and gave only grudging support to the start
of entry talks with Turkey on 3 October.

BAKU: Turkish Official Says Azerbaijan Gaining Advantage In Conflict

TURKISH OFFICIAL SAYS AZERBAIJAN GAINING ADVANTAGE IN CONFLICT SETTLEMENT
Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
posted Oct 10 2005
Baku, October 7, AssA-Irada
A high-ranking Turkish military official has said that Azerbaijan is
increasingly getting an advantage over Armenia in the settlement of
the Upper Garabagh conflict.
“Time is in favor of Azerbaijan, while Armenia is getting economically
weaker. We believe this factor will affect Azerbaijan’s political
power and create favorable conditions for the conflict settlement”,
Chief of the Turkish General Staff, General Hilmi Ozkok said.
He said in a meeting with Azeri Minister for Defense Safar Abiyev on
Friday that Turkey and Azerbaijan should continue cooperation while
ensuring that their common historical roots are not forgotten.
Abiyev said Azerbaijan wants to settle the Garabagh conflict
peacefully. “But if the efforts turn out fruitless, the national army
will definitely liberate the occupied territories”, he said.
The minister praised the expanding military collaboration between
the two countries, saying that President Ilham Aliyev is making every
effort in this area.
Views were also exchanged on prospects for further military cooperation
and the current political situation in the Caucasus and the Middle
East at the meeting, attended by the Turkish Ambassador to Azerbaijan
Turan Morali.*

2 Iranian Literary Figures In Yerevan

2 IRANIAN LITERARY FIGURES IN YEREVAN
IranMania, Iran
Oct 10 2005
LONDON, October 10 (IranMania) – The Biggest gathering of Armenian
authors will be held in Yerevan from 8 to 12 October with the presence
of 2 Iranian literary figures; Zoya Pirzad and Ahmad Nouri Zadeh,
said CHN.
The gathering is dedicated to the writers and poets who write their
works in languages other than Armenian.
Among the invited literary figures for the event, Zoya Pirzad,
an Iranian awarded female writer, is mentionable. Zoya Pirzad whose
famous ?I am the one who turns off the lights? has won several national
literary awards, is one of the few Armenian writers in Iran who writes
in Persian.
?Since Leon Analian became responsible for the directorship of Armenian
Writers Association, the association is more active.
Organizing several literary conferences are among its achievements?
said Varand, secretary general of the association.
This 2nd edition of the conference of Armenian writers is dedicated
to the review and study of Armenian writers who live outside the
country. These kinds of literary events are aimed at creating greater
kinship among Armenian literary figures from all over the world.
Beside Zoya Pirzad, Ahmad Nouri Zadeh is another Iranian literary
figure who will be present at the event. He will be awarded for his
great translations of Armenian works into Persian.

Turkey Not Fit For Membership

TURKEY NOT FIT FOR MEMBERSHIP
By Matthew Nickson
Daily Texan, TX
Oct 10 2005
Last Monday at a ministerial conference in Luxembourg, the foreign
ministers of the European Union agreed to begin membership talks with
Turkey. The decision to open “adhesion negotiations” – taken after
overcoming an Austrian counter-proposal for a “privileged partnership”
– is a blow to the democratic goals of a unified Europe.
Since joining the European Economic Community as an associate member
in 1963, Turkey has consistently professed its reformist credentials,
eager to counter the world community’s outdated image of a thinly
veiled military dictatorship. But time and again – despite progress
in certain areas outlined in the 1993 Copenhagen Criteria for EU
expansion – the Turkish government has shown it is either unwilling
or unable to fully democratize and modernize. In its own country,
Turkey continues to systematically restrict freedom of expression and
oppress its minority Kurdish population. Abroad, Turkey maintains an
ever belligerent posture toward its neighbors, particularly Armenia
and Cyprus.
The latest example of Turkish repression came last Friday, when
a Turkish administrative court convicted an Armenian journalist,
Hrant Dink, of insulting the “Turkish identity” by writing about
the Armenian genocide. During World War I, the Ottoman Army and
its guerilla auxiliaries massacred more than one million Armenians
who refused to convert from Christianity to Islam. To this day, the
Turkish government illegalizes practically any admission of Turkish
guilt and threatens or imprisons individuals who speak out.
Nationalist officials trivialize the massacres as tragic but
inevitable consequences of war, or dismiss the Armenians as pro-Russian
traitors. Although Armenia is a small, underdeveloped country, Turkey
continues to blockade it by land, cutting off road and rail traffic.
Ironically – and in a sign of the Turkish court system’s perversity
– Dink was tried and convicted for writing that Armenians should
rid themselves of anti-Turkish anger. The court implied from his
admonition that Dink – who received a suspended six month sentence –
was somehow deriding the Turkish blood.
The fact is, unlike many former European colonizers, Turkey has
made few if any efforts to atone for its imperialist past. The Turks
have been unable, notwithstanding decades of co-membership in NATO,
to arrive at a truly permanent peace with Greece. As late as 1996,
the two countries nearly fought a war over the Imia islands in the
Aegean Sea. Furthermore, the Turkish government adamantly refuses to
recognize the independence of the Greek portion of Cyprus and the
sovereignty of the government in Nicosia. Although Turkey signed
a July 29 protocol extending its customs union with the European
Union to the 10 members admitted in 2004 – among them the Republic
of Cyprus – Turkey obstinately refuses to open its ports and airports
to Cypriot commerce.
Turkey also has a bad track record with its Middle Eastern neighbors.
The country has consistently been accused by Syria and Iraq of
siphoning an inordinate amount of water from the Euphrates River,
which Turkey has diverted for a massive – and environmentally risky
– development project involving the construction of 22 dams and 19
power plants.
The Southeast Anatolia Development Project has been touted as an
economic boon for Turkey’s minority Kurdish population. Yet Turkey
has engaged in a long-standing policy of political and cultural
warfare against the Kurds who live in southeastern Turkey, near the
Iraqi border by imprisoning Kurdish political figures and limiting
classroom instruction in Kurdish. As recently as the early 1990s,
Turkey conducted a Central American-style scorched earth campaign
against Kurdish villages suspected of harboring separatist guerillas,
killing as many as 30,000 people.
All the foregoing is not to deny that Turkey has enacted reforms
in its quest for EU membership. The country has abolished the death
penalty and retreated from its once total censure of Kurdish culture.
In the economic realm, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has
repealed subsidies favoring the textile industry. If admitted to the
EU, Turkey holds out the promise of revitalizing laggard European
economies with its growing consumer market, cheap labor (an augury
of massive emigration) and increased trade.
But Turkey’s reforms are too little, and Turkish society has evolved
insufficiently since 1963. Treacherous fault lines still haunt the
political landscape, with Islamic fundamentalists on one extreme and
a military clique on the other, ever ready to intervene to defend
the ideological vision of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk.
The bottom line is that Turkey absolutely does not deserve an EU seat
alongside progressive, democratic nations like France, Great Britain,
Germany and Spain.
Nickson is a third year law student and executive editor of The Texas
International Law Journal.

Sergey Khachatryan

SERGEY KHACHATRYAN
Andante
Oct 10 2005
Sibelius, Khachaturian, violin concertos
Sergey Khachatryan was born in Yerevan, the Armenian capital, in
1985. He comes from a family of musicians. From childhood onwards,
he benefited from broad cultural horizons that favoured the musical
career of which he dreamt. He began the violin at the age of five.
The following year, he began his studies at the Sayat Nova Conservatory
in Yerevan, continuing them in Germany when his family settled
there. The exceptional qualities of this young virtuoso were revealed
at a
concert with the Orchestra of the Hessen State Theatre, Wiesbaden;
he was then nine years old. From then on, foreign trips and prizes
followed at regular intervals, with many concerts, all over Europe
– Germany, Switzerland, Finland, Portugal, Spain, Italy, France –
as well as in the USA, South America, Russia and Armenia.
The coming seasons are rich in exciting projects: with the Philharmonia
Orchestra, with the BBC Philharmonic conducted by Neeme Jarvi, with
the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra in Amsterdam, the Tokyo Philharmonic
Orchestra under Vladimir Fedoseyev. then partner Anne-Sophie Mutter
in Bach’s Double Concerto with the London Philharmonic.
When one asks Sergey Khachatryan which violinists he admires most,
he unhesitatingly speaks of the supreme genius of the Soviet school.
Above all, he evokes the magnetic tutelary figure of David Oistrakh.
Sergey Khachatryan’s first recording, released in EMI’s ‘Debut’
series in 2002, allowed us to meet a violinist blessed with a glowing
sonority and with musical intelligence rare in so young a musician.
Now he has recorded for Naïve two concertos that figure among the
jewels of the violin repertoire.
;iProductID=511
–Boundary_(ID_Sa8MVMfa6Ar2LSIQauoOrw)–

ANKARA: Nobel Committee Split Because Of Pamuk

NOBEL COMMITTEE SPLIT BECAUSE OF PAMUK
Turkish Press
Oct 10 2005
HURRIYET- It has been claimed that the Nobel committee was divided
into two because of Orhan Pamuk and couldn’t give the Nobel Literature
Prize.
The British Observer newspaper claimed that the committee which awards
the Nobel Prize for literature has delayed their decision for at
least a week amid reports of a split over honoring the controversial
Orhan Pamuk.
For the first time in at least 10 years, the literature prize was
announced neither in the run-up to, nor in the same week as the four
other main Nobel awards – medicine, physics, chemistry and peace. The
literature award is now due to be announced on Oct, 13, Thursday.
The newspaper claimed that as Pamuk has been a political figure
recently, the prize that can be given in literature to Pamuk could
be overshadowed by political debate.
GUL: PAMUK WILL WIN THE LAWSUIT FILED AGAINST HIM
ZAMAN – Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul said that author Orhan
Pamuk will win the lawsuit which was filed against him due to his
statements regarding so-called Armenian genocide.
Gul said that earlier, similar lawsuits were opened in Turkey,
but courts decided that everybody has the right to express his/her
opinion. Gul noted that he did not have any doubt that the court’s
decision will be in favor of Pamuk.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

The President Of Latvia In National Assembly Of Armenia

THE PRESIDENT OF LATVIA IN NATIONAL ASSEMBLY
National Assembly of RA, Armenia
Oct 10 2005
On October 8 Vaira Vike-Freiberg, President of the Republic of Latvia
was hosted in the Nat ional Assembly. The problems of the development
of the Armenian-Latvian relations were in the center of discussions
with NA President Artur Baghdasaryan, representatives of the standing
committees of the National Assembly, factions and grouping. Welcoming
the high-ranking guest, NA President Artur Baghdasaryan highlighted
the experience of Latvia on the road of European Integration,
strengthening of inter-parliamentary cooperation (during the
visit of the President of the Republic of Latvia a memorandum of
inter-parliamentary cooperation was signed) and regional ties with
the establishment of direct ties between the marzes and cities. The
sides also elaborated on the trade-economic and scientific-cultural
ties, discussed the possibility of the establishment of a direct
flight between two countries, which can become an impetus for the
development of trade-economic ties.
Vaira Vike-Freiberg, President of the Republic of Latvia highlighted
the success of the constitutional reforms in Armenia, noting that the
parliaments are always basic pillars of democracy, and the cooperation
of the legislative bodies of two countries has an important role in
the inter-state relations. He expressed confidence to continue the
cooperation in all directions with Armenia.
Hrair karapetyan, Secretary of ARF faction, expressed gratitude for
adopting the bill on recognition of the Armenian Genocide in the
first reading in the Parliament of Latvia. In response Mrs. Freiberg
mentioned that during her visit to Turkey she elaborated on the
necessity of recognizing the Armenian Genocide during the meeting
with the President and Prime Minister of Turkey, highlighting not
to have dark pages in the history of the country before joining the
European family.
During the meeting other issues were also discussed.