ARMENIA: BACKDOOR CENSORSHIP FEARS
By Arpi Harutunian in Yerevan
Institute for War and Peace Reporting (IWPR), UK
March 16, 2006
Newspaper distribution law could severely restrict circulation of
opposition titles.
Armenian journalists are sounding the alarm over legislation that
requires newspaper delivery companies for the first time to apply
for licenses.
Local activists say that the legislation, introduced by Armenia’s
parliament last year in the form of an amendment to existing laws
on mail service and tax regulations, is in fact a hidden form of
state censorship.
“The journalistic community and public organisations of Armenia are
trying to stop this law,” Boris Navasardian, chairman of the Yerevan
Press Club, told IWPR. “Otherwise, we will have to admit that it is
one more mechanism for secret censorship.”
The legislation stipulates that firms pay 11,000 US dollars per year
in order to receive licenses for the right to deliver newspapers.
This requirement will bankrupt many small independent delivery
companies, say observers, and place the country’s newspaper
distribution service firmly in the hands of two state-connected
enterprises, Haipost, Armenia’s postal service, and Haimamul, the
main kiosk vendor.
Haipost, as a self-financing closed joint-stock company, is nominally
independent. However, since all of its shares belong to the state,
it is considered to be closely linked to the government.
Haimamul for its part is fully independent, though its origins indicate
close state ties. The firm was established in 1939 as Soviet Armenia’s
sole concern handling newspaper subscriptions and delivery.
Today it is the largest single distributor, and with about 400 kiosks
and 7,223 subscribers, one of the few that reaches all the country’s
regions.
Rather than censoring the newspapers outright, say media professionals,
government officials can instead pressure these two companies to
prevent publications with offending content from reaching the public,
especially in rural areas.
“I have the impression that the Armenian government is doing
all it can, and even what it cannot, in order to reduce newspaper
dissemination as much as possible,” said Hakob Avetikian, editor in
chief of the daily Azg. “They want to reduce the amount of undesirable
information to the public.”
The critics point to a number of incidents where Haimaimul failed
to distribute certain publications. In October, 2002, for example,
4,600 copies of the Aravot opposition newspapers disappeared from
Haimamul’s kiosks.
Aravot editors’ say that the incident was tied to an article which
was critical of Hrach Abgarian, former adviser to Armenian prime
minister Andranik Margarian.
Members of the Yerevan Press Club and other public organisations say
the new legislation violates human rights and have sent a letter
to parliament demanding the law be changed. IWPR has learned that
the opposition United Labour Party has thrown its weight behind
the initiative.
Press club officials say that the laws violate Article 10 of European
Convention of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, Article 19 of
Universal Declaration of Human Rights as well as Article 24 of the
Armenian constitution, guaranteeing the right to free expression.
“If we are members of the Council of Europe and if we speak about
European integration, freedom of speech, and freedom of the press,
then we should reject licensing of the media,” said Armen Davtian,
director of the Blitz independent media distribution company, who
compared the situation with licensing of press distribution in Armenia
to that in authoritarian Belarus.
The new legislation comes into force just as a number of small,
independent companies have sprung up to challenge Haipost and
Haimamul’s near-monopoly over distribution.
Last year, for example, the US-funded Eurasia Foundation and George
Soros’ Open Society Institute awarded grants to five companies under
a programme to support alternative distribution channels and improve
delivery to rural areas.
Eurasia officials say that very few of Armenia’s daily newspapers
reach the country’s villages, where much of the population resides.
Some remote towns do not receive a single newspaper, they say.
“Our aim was to create stable companies that would lead to the
weakening of the monopoly of Haipost and Haimamul and become
alternative companies in the newspaper market,” Alisa Alaverdian,
Eurasia’s external relations coordinator, told IWPR.
Now, however, because of the new legislation, these enterprises are
under threat of closure.
Tax officials have paid several visits to the heads of the Blitz
Media Company, one of the new distributors, demanding that they either
suspend their activities or pay for a license.
“I pay annual 1,500 dollars in income tax, and according to what
I know, other small organisations that work in this sphere pay
approximately the same amount,” said Blitz director Davtian. “There
is no logic in this fixed sum of 11 thousand dollars for the license.”
Haikaz Simikian, head of the Simikian distribution company in
Vanadzor with 700 subscribers, one of the five firms to receive
Eurasia Foundation and OSI’s grants, said it’s likely to close if
they pay the license fee.
“This amount is absurd,” said Simikian. “We won’t have any income
under such conditions.”
Eurasia Foundation officials agree that the law comes at a very
untimely moment. “As a result of [our] programme, the circulation of
some newspapers grew significantly,” said Marina Mkhitarian, Eurasia’s
programme coordinator. “[This continued] until the distribution
companies encountered problems with taxation bodies because of their
lack of licenses.”
Government officials for their part defend the legislation by saying
that it in no way restricts the dissemination of the news. Delivery
is being licensed, not subscription, they say, and the law will
strengthen the distribution system and regulate deliveries, especially
to rural areas.
Tamara Ghalechian, spokesperson for the ministry of transport and
communications, said that the high license fee will help weed out
the field and assure that only companies that can provide the best
services will be involved in newspaper delivery.
“The state is establishing a regulating mechanism for companies which
are responsible for organising subscriptions, Ghalechian told IWPR.
Many do not buy this explanation, however. “What sense is there in
subscription, if there is no delivery?” asked Blitz distribution
company head Davtian.
Haipost officials guarantees that the company’s 904 post offices will
deliver all newspapers in a timely manner, even those to far-flung
regions. “We deliver newspapers to subscribers even in the most remote
villages,” said Haipost spokesperson Astghik Martirosian.
Martirosian supports the new legislation whole-heartedly. “If the state
believes that we need such a law, this means that we indeed need it,”
he said.
Interestingly, despite the benefits that their company will allegedly
reap, Haimamul officials say that they are opposed to the law. “The
number of newspapers is already very small and they do not reach
residents in the regions,” said Haimamul executive director Arshaluis
Manukian.
“Laws like this will lead to the total isolation of rural residents
from any information, since companies with small budgets will be
unable to pay and will have to halt their activities,” he said,
calling the legislation “the product of a morbid imagination”.
Arpi Harutunian is a reporter with weekly in
Yerevan. Seda Muradyan, IWPR’s Armenia coordinator, also contributed
to this article.
;s=f&o =260381&apc_state=henh
Alexan Harutyunyan: Armenia Has Chosen The Correct Song And TheCorre
ALEXAN HARUTYUNYAN: ARMENIA HAS CHOSEN THE CORRECT SONG AND THE CORRECT SINGER
ArmRadio
16.03.2006 16:05
Armenia has chosen the correct song to present at the “Eurovision,”
President of the Public Television and Radio Company of Armenia Alexan
Harutyunyan has received the first foreign response from the experts
of this most popular European song contest.
The song (“Without your love”), which was presented to the attention
of the Armenian pubic yesterday, has already managed to become a
subject of controversial views and criticism in Armenia.
“Some complain that Andre is going to present an English song at
the ” Eurovision,” some have found Eastern tunes in the song. The
“Eurovision” is a special song festival, and I have to disappoint all
those who were anticipating that we would present Komitas there. And
let’s not forget that the song has been written by one of out best
composers Armen Martirosyan, and has been instrumented by Murzik,
one of our best arrangers. Besides, national musical instruments have
been used,” Alexan Harutyunyan said in his interview to ” Radiolur”
correspondent.
As for the Eastern tunes, Alexan Harutyunyan noted, “Eastern tunes
exist also in Sayat-Nova’s music.”
Final Act – Jugha Cemetery A Firing Range
FINAL ACT – JUGHA CEMETERY A FIRING RANGE
AZG Armenian Daily
17/03/2006
The photo accompanying this article was made only 5 days ago by very
rev. Topuzian, and depicts the Armenian cemetery that only 15 years
ago had 10.000 khachkars but due to Azerbaijani barbarism this number
was reduced to 3.500. A caption by very rev. Topuzian underneath
the photo reads: “As an eyewitness to this sacrilege I can say this
is the evidence of ‘final act’ (Friday, 10 March 2006) when we saw
the great territory of Old Jugha cemetery completely destroyed…
wiped away… transformed into a firing range.”
It goes without saying that other monuments of Armenian history
and culture invisible from the Iranian border were eliminated long
ago. The Azeri state has one goal: to demolish all traces of Armenian
presence to avoid another headache in future.
Punishing A Criminal And Murderer Is No Crime
PUNISHING A CRIMINAL AND MURDERER IS NO CRIME
By Tamar Minasian
AZG Armenian Daily #048
17/03/2006
On March 15, we celebrated the 85th anniversary of Tallat Pasha
assassination, who was one of masterminds and accomplisher of
the Armenian Genocide. On this occasion, the youth branch of ARF
Dashnaktsiutiun held a rally in front of the monument to Soghomon
Tehlerian, the assassin of Tallat. Armen Rustamian, member of ARFD
Supreme Body, stated that the events of the past helped us preserve
our national dignity. He added that we strengthened the spirit of
our people in the fair struggle against our enemies. Rustamian is
confident that many new generations of Armenians will be educated on
the example of Soghomon Tehlerian.
He added that punishing the murderer is no crime.
Rustamian stated that the Turks learnt no lesson from the history
and still try to make falsifications and deny the reality.
The members of Dshnaktsiutiun’s youth branch said that there are
still young people that follow the path of Tehlerian. 17 years old
Dvin who came to Armenia from Canada said that the patriotic feeling
of the Armenians from Diaspora differ from those who live in Armenia.
“There they feel patriotism mixed with homesickness, while in
Armenia patriotism means to preserve and develop the motherland,”
he said. “Tehlerian was 25 when he killed Tallat. He should be a
lofty ideal for us, as he could show to the world that we will not
be silent,” Dvin underscored.
Roger Robinson: Increase In Price For Gas Will Have No Big NegativeI
ROGER ROBINSON: INCREASE IN PRICE FOR GAS WILL HAVE NO BIG NEGATIVE IMPACT ON ARMENIA’S ECONOMY
By Ara Martirosian
AZG Armenian Daily
17/03/2006
Roger Robinson, head of the World Bank Office in Armenia, expressed an
opinion that the increase in price for gas will have no big negative
impact on Armenia’s economy. The WB experts haven’t completed
the researches on the issue yet and the final conclusion will be
represented soon. Robinson stated that notwithstanding the increase
in oil price, the progress is still fixed in the economy of Armenia.
They also stated that RA Central Bank will manage to preserve the
inflation indicator within the framework of envisaged 3%.
Azeri Paper Closes Down For Nationalism
AZERI PAPER CLOSES DOWN FOR NATIONALISM
AZG Armenian Daily
17/03/2006
According to “Kar” news agency of Iran and “Armenia” newspaper of
Athens, on March 12 the press supervision department of the Iran’s
Culture Ministry closed down Azeri “Navide Azerbaijan” Turkish-language
newspaper that had existed for 8 years. The reason for banning the
paper was the violation of articles 4 and 5 of the law on press that
prohibits inciting citizens to acts threatening national security
and expression of nationalistic attitude.
Heating Strategy Is A Priority For Armenia
HEATING STRATEGY IS A PRIORITY FOR ARMENIA
AZG Armenian Daily
17/03/2006
RA Government and USAID initiated an exhibition of new heating systems
that will last from March 15 to 17.
Holding his speech at the opening ceremony of the exhibition,
Gagik Martirosian, chief councilor of RA Prime Minister, stated
that the exhibition is meant to develop heating market of Armenia,
familiarizing the larger circles of society, the consumers with the
newest technologies. Robin Phillips director of USAID in Yerevan,
said that the given exhibition will help various companies represent
their capacities and production. 27 organizations, including ACBA
bank, AH Building Technologies, AIB BEN GIM Engineering Anergo-2,
R&R, Arazen, Artstorm, GAS AMA, Euroterm, Termoros-AR and others
participate in the exhibition.
3 Thousand Take Part In Burial Of Gevorgyan Killed In Tsalka
3 THOUSAND TAKE PART IN BURIAL OF GEVORGYAN KILLED IN TSALKA
PanARMENIAN.Net
16.03.2006 22:56 GMT+04:00
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ March 14 burial of Gevorg Gevorgyan, 23, brutally
killed in the regional center a few days ago, was held in Ghushchi
Armenian village of Tsalka region, Georgia. Some 3 thousand people
took part in the ceremony. In spite of hard road conditions, some
500 persons arrived from Akhalkalaki and Ninotsminda.
During the mourning ceremony public figures, citizens demanded
just verdict regarding the murderer from Georgia. Three persons are
arrested on suspicion of committing the murder of Gevorg Gevorgyan
and attacking his friends, though the number of those attacking is
some 15, reports A-Info.
Armenian MOD Head Thanked US For Efforts To Solve Karabakh Dispute
ARMENIAN MOD HEAD THANKED US FOR EFFORTS TO SOLVE KARABAKH DISPUTE
PanARMENIAN.Net
16.03.2006 23:04 GMT+04:00
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Armenian Defense Minister Serge Sargsyan suggested
monitoring contact line between Armenian and Azeri Armed Forces more
frequently and openly publishing the results. As Spokesperson of
the Armenian MOD Head Seyran Shahsuvaryan told PanARMENIAN.Net, the
Defense Minister proposed it at a meeting with US Assistant Secretary
of State Daniel Fried and US Co-Chair of the OSCE MG Steven Mann.
Sargsyan said the measures will allow to prevent breaks of the
cease-fire. He thanked the US for efforts to settle the Nagorno
Karabakh issue, made within the OSCE MG. Sargsyan was optimistic and
believed the efforts will be a success.
Armenia-NATO Relations Develop Fast
ARMENIA-NATO RELATIONS DEVELOP FAST
PanARMENIAN.Net
16.03.2006 23:09 GMT+04:00
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Armenian Defense Minister Serge Sargsyan believes
Armenia-NATO relations are developing fast. As Spokesperson of the
Armenian MOD Head Seyran Shahsuvaryan told PanARMENIAN.Net, the
Defense Minister stated it at a meeting with colonel Mike Anderson,
a representative of the US European Command, who accompanied US
Assistant Secretary of State Daniel Fried. On behalf of the US European
Command Mike Anderson thanked the Minister for Armenian peacekeepers’
service in Iraq, noting their professionalism. He also thanked the
MOD leadership for cooperation and openness during the work of a US
evaluation mission in Armenia. Speaking of reforms in the Armenian
Army, S. Sargsyan said that in 10 years Armenia will have Armed Forces
that are more compatible and that meet international standards.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress