Spanish Trade Industrial Cooperation Centre To Be Opened

Spanish Trade Industrial Cooperation Centre To Be Opened
National Assembly of RA, Armenia
March 31 2006
On March 30, in Valencia within the framework of the Fifth Forum
of World Alliance of the Cities Fighting Against Poverty Artur
Baghdasaryan, RA NA President, had several bilateral meetings.
During the meeting with Francisco Camps, President of the Valencian
Government, problems of establishing regional relations between
Valencia and Armenia were discussed. An agreement was reached on the
leave of the Valencian delegation to Armenia in future, during which
the possibilities of cooperation will be specified.
During the meeting with Rita Barbera, Mayoress of Valencia, the
problems of implementation of concrete programmes, as well as
transferring ambulance cars to Armenia between Valencia and cities
of Armenia were discussed.
During the meeting with Justo Nieto, Industry Minister of Valencia, an
agreement was reached on opening joint offices in Armenia and Spain,
the activity of which will have two directions: increase of trade
turnover and study of market, also study of goods consuming markets and
advertisement, establishment of joint fund, the goal of which will be
the implementation of scientific-educational programmes. The activity
of this office will boost the development of the Armenian-Spanish
trade-industrial and scientific-cultural development, establishment
of new possibilities and new jobs.
Other meetings are also envisaged during the day.
NA President Artur Baghdasaryan gave interviews to the central
newspapers, and the works of the forum are widely illustrated on TV.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Embassy Row: Recall from Armenia?

Washington Times, DC
March 31 2006
Embassy Row
By James Morrison
March 30, 2006
Recall from Armenia?
Armenian-Americans and their allies in Congress are angered over
reports that the U.S. ambassador to Armenia will be recalled or fired
for referring to the killings of Armenians in 1915 as genocide and
upsetting established U.S. policy that avoids using that word.
Ambassador John Evans, a career Foreign Service officer,
deliberately referred to the “Armenian genocide” in a speech last
year in San Francisco, and rumors of official retaliation have
persisted for the past 12 months.
The State Department officially refers to the “massacre” of
Armenians under the Ottoman Turkish Empire but has never described
the conflict as a deliberate attempt to eliminate an entire race of
people. The delicate subject also complicates U.S. relations with
Turkey, a key NATO ally that insists no genocide occurred. Turkey
says Armenians were killed in an uprising against the Ottomans and
rejects demands for an apology from the modern Turkish state.
Reps. Frank Pallone Jr., New Jersey Democrat and co-chairman of
the Congressional Caucus on Armenia, Grace F. Napolitano and Adam B.
Schiff, both California Democrats, have demanded an answer about Mr.
Evans’ future from Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice.
In a March 11 letter to Miss Rice, Mr. Pallone expressed his
“outrage that the State Department is recalling Ambassador Evans as
retaliation for statements he made in recognition of the Armenian
genocide. It is simply wrong for the State Department to punish
Ambassador Evans for statements he made that are factually correct.”
Mrs. Napolitano, a senior member of the House International
Relations Committee, asked, “Have State Department employees been
directed not to use the word ‘genocide’ when discussing the
extermination of 1.5 million Armenians starting in 1915?”
Earlier this month, State Department spokesman Sean McCormack
said he has no information about Mr. Evans’ future. The ambassador
has been in Armenia for nearly two years.
“I’m not aware that we have recalled anybody,” he said. “I
believe that he’s still serving as ambassador in Armenia.”
The Armenian National Committee of America also pressed Miss
Rice.
“The prospect that a U.S. envoy’s posting — and possibly his
career — has been cut short due to his honest and accurate
description of a genocide is profoundly offensive to American
values,” committee Chairman Ken Hachikian said in a March 8 letter to
Miss Rice.
In his Feb. 19, 2005, speech, Mr. Evans told the Bay Area
Armenian-American Community, “I will today call it the Armenian
genocide. I think we, the U.S. government, owe you, our fellow
citizens, a more frank and honest way of discussing the problem.
Embassy Row
By James Morrison
March 30, 2006
Recall from Armenia?
Armenian-Americans and their allies in Congress are angered over
reports that the U.S. ambassador to Armenia will be recalled or fired
for referring to the killings of Armenians in 1915 as genocide and
upsetting established U.S. policy that avoids using that word.
Ambassador John Evans, a career Foreign Service officer,
deliberately referred to the “Armenian genocide” in a speech last
year in San Francisco, and rumors of official retaliation have
persisted for the past 12 months.
The State Department officially refers to the “massacre” of
Armenians under the Ottoman Turkish Empire but has never described
the conflict as a deliberate attempt to eliminate an entire race of
people. The delicate subject also complicates U.S. relations with
Turkey, a key NATO ally that insists no genocide occurred. Turkey
says Armenians were killed in an uprising against the Ottomans and
rejects demands for an apology from the modern Turkish state.
Reps. Frank Pallone Jr., New Jersey Democrat and co-chairman of
the Congressional Caucus on Armenia, Grace F. Napolitano and Adam B.
Schiff, both California Democrats, have demanded an answer about Mr.
Evans’ future from Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice.
In a March 11 letter to Miss Rice, Mr. Pallone expressed his
“outrage that the State Department is recalling Ambassador Evans as
retaliation for statements he made in recognition of the Armenian
genocide. It is simply wrong for the State Department to punish
Ambassador Evans for statements he made that are factually correct.”
Mrs. Napolitano, a senior member of the House International
Relations Committee, asked, “Have State Department employees been
directed not to use the word ‘genocide’ when discussing the
extermination of 1.5 million Armenians starting in 1915?”
Earlier this month, State Department spokesman Sean McCormack
said he has no information about Mr. Evans’ future. The ambassador
has been in Armenia for nearly two years.
“I’m not aware that we have recalled anybody,” he said. “I
believe that he’s still serving as ambassador in Armenia.”
The Armenian National Committee of America also pressed Miss
Rice.
“The prospect that a U.S. envoy’s posting — and possibly his
career — has been cut short due to his honest and accurate
description of a genocide is profoundly offensive to American
values,” committee Chairman Ken Hachikian said in a March 8 letter to
Miss Rice.
In his Feb. 19, 2005, speech, Mr. Evans told the Bay Area
Armenian-American Community, “I will today call it the Armenian
genocide. I think we, the U.S. government, owe you, our fellow
citizens, a more frank and honest way of discussing the problem.
“Today, as someone who has studied it, there’s no doubt in my mind
what happened. I think it is unbecoming of us, as Americans, to play
word games here. I believe in calling things by their name.”
Upon his return to the U.S. Embassy in Armenia, Mr. Evans issued
a correction that led many observers to speculate that he was under
pressure from Washington.
“Although I told my audience that the United States policy on the
Armenian tragedy has not changed, I used the term ‘genocide,’
speaking in what I characterized as my personal capacity,” he said.
“That was inappropriate.”

Commemoration of Armenian Genocide

Commemoration of Armenian Genocide
Watertown TAB & Press, MA
March 31 2006
Friday, March 31, 2006
Rep. Rachel Kaprielian, Rep. Peter Koutoujian and Sen. Steven Tolman,
in conjunction with the State House Commemoration Planning Committee,
will host the 91st Anniversary Commemoration of the Armenian Genocide
on Friday, April 21, at 11 a.m., in the chamber of the House of
Representatives at the Massachusetts State House. The ceremony will
be followed by an informal reception in the Great Hall.
Buses will leave for the State House from St. James and St.
Stephen’s churches to transport participants and guests to the State
House. Participants should note that due to current increased security
measures, the process of entering the State House is slower than in
previous years. All visitors will be required to pass through metal
detectors, so extra time may be required to enter the building.
All are welcome to attend.
This year’s keynote address will be given by Dr. Henry Theriault,
associate professor of philosophy and coordinator of the Center for
Study of Human Rights at Worcester State College. His research focuses
on genocide and human rights, with specific emphasis on genocide denial
and its epistemological dimensions; the long-term impact of genocide
and other mass violence and their ethical and political implications;
and mass violence against women. Theriault has presented his work
on the Armenian Genocide around the globe, including California,
Tokyo and Beirut.
For more information, call Kaprielian at 617-722-2400.

Azerbaijan: Opposition Youth Activists on Trial

Azerbaijan: Opposition Youth Activists on Trial
Reuters, UK
March 31 2006
30 Mar 2006 21:38:18 GMT
Source: Human Rights Watch
(New York, March 31, 2006) – The Azerbaijani government must ensure a
fair trial for three opposition youth leaders whose trial begins
today in Baku, Human Rights Watch said today. The case against the
youth leaders originated with their arrest before the November 2005
parliamentary polls that the Organization for Security and
Cooperation in Europe, the European Union and others declared to have
fallen well short of international standards. Ruslan Bashirli, head
of the Yeni Fikir (New Thinking) youth group, is charged with
attempting to forcefully overthrow the government and of engaging in
illegal business activities. Yeni Fikir deputy heads Said Nuri and
Ramin Tagiev face identical charges.
“The context and timing of the arrest of the Yeni Fikir leaders
suggests that the case is politically motivated,” said Holly Cartner,
executive director of Human Rights Watch’s Europe and Central Asia
division. “It also casts an even darker shadow on the 2005
parliamentary elections, which were blatantly fraudulent.”
Azerbaijani authorities arrested the three Yeni Fikir leaders in
August and September 2005, in the run-up to the November
parliamentary elections. Yeni Fikir is closely aligned to the
opposition Popular Front Party. Prior to the elections, authorities
arrested dozens of other individuals, including many former
government officials and prominent business leaders, who are alleged
to have ties to opposition parties. These individuals similarly face
charges of attempting to overthrow the government and committing
other crimes against the state.
On August 6, law enforcement officers in camouflage uniforms and
black masks arrested Ruslan Bashirli. The next day the Prosecutor
General’s Office charged Bashirli with attempting to forcefully
overthrow the government and accused him of meeting with Armenian
security service officers in Georgia in July and accepting U.S.$2,000
from them. Bashirli was then questioned for two days in the presence
of a state-appointed lawyer instead of the lawyer he had explicitly
chosen at the time as defense counsel. Bashirli informed his own
lawyer that during this questioning, law enforcement officers
pressured Bashirli to give evidence against Ali Keremli, leader of
the Popular Front Party, suggesting that if he made a statement on
television implicating Keremli, he would be released within 24 hours.
Bashirli refused to make such a statement.
Human Rights Watch has spoken with Bashirli’s lawyer, who states that
Bashirli maintains that the meeting in Georgia indeed took place, but
he believed that his counterparts were members of civil society
organizations and that the funds were intended to support
democratization activities. On September 12, police arrested Said
Nuri and charged him also with attempting to violently overthrow the
government. The authorities accused him of organizing weapons and
equipment for a coup in Azerbaijan while he was in Poland in late
July and early August. Nuri was in Poland during this period for a
conference sponsored by the European Institute for the Furtherance of
Democracy, a Vienna-based organization that supports individuals and
organizations working to promote democracy in Southern and Eastern
Europe. On September 14, police arrested Ramin Tagiev on the same
charge and accused him of “molding opinion about the falsity of
elections among the population.”
Since these arrests, prosecutors have also charged the three men with
illegal business activity.
For days after Bashirli’s arrest, state-controlled Azerbaijani
television showed video footage of him drinking at a table with two
men who the government alleges are Armenian agents, and another
member of Yeni Fikir, Osman Alimuradov. The prosecuting authorities
claimed that the men alleged to be Armenian agents filmed the meeting
and then gave the video cassette to Alimuradov, threatening to use it
against the Yeni Fikir members should they change their minds about
cooperation.
The government further alleges that it was Alimuradov who began to
have second thoughts and decided to inform the Azerbaijani
authorities about Bashirli and handed over the tape as evidence. It
is not clear how the television station received copies of the video
tape.
Posters showing still photographs from this video, alongside graphic
photographs allegedly depicting bodies of Azerbaijanis killed and
mutilated by Armenian forces during the Nagorno-Karabakh war,
implicating Bashirli in collusion with Armenian security agents, were
displayed in public places widely throughout Baku. It is not clear
who created or distributed these posters.
“Azerbaijan’s government is known for pressing charges against
opposition figures for what appear to be political reasons, and the
Yeni Fikir case fits this pattern,” said Cartner. “We are deeply
concerned that the three men will not get a fair trial.”
Azerbaijan has a history of arresting opposition figures during
election periods and convicting them without guaranteeing basic fair
trial standards. In October 2003, following fraudulent presidential
elections and post-election violence, seven opposition leaders were
convicted on charges of organizing or participating in mass
disturbances and resisting or committing violence against a state
representative. Human Rights Watch documented torture in the
pre-trial detention of four of the seven defendants. Prosecution
witnesses in this case also told the court that police and
prosecutors had coerced and tortured them to make statements
incriminating the opposition leaders. It is widely considered that
the convicted opposition leaders are political prisoners.
HRW news

Nuclear energy allows Armenia export energy

NUCLEAR ENERGY ALLOWS ARMENIA EXPORT ENERGY
ARKA News Agency, Armenia
March 31 2006
Yerevan, May 31. /ARKA/. By means of nuclear power Armenia is supposed
not only to satisfy its own energy needs, but also export energy,
Chairman of the Parliamentary Commission for Finance, Credit, Budget
and Economic Affairs Gagik Minasyan told reporters.
According to him, the construction of a new nuclear-power plant will
pursue this goal. “These prospects became possible after the European
Union somewhat moderated its policy toward Armenia’s nuclear-power
sector, and international experts arrived at the conclusion that
Armenia needs an NPP,” he said.
The Armenian NPP was put into operation in 1980. Specialists say that
it the NPP can operate until 2016.
In mid-April, 2006, the RA Parliament is to discuss amendments to
the RA Law “On energy”, which abolish government monopoly of atomic
energy. The amendments are aimed at the attraction of foreign private
capital to the construction of a new NPP in Armenia.
The construction of the new NPP with a capacity of 1,000 megawatt is
estimated at $1bln. P.T. -0–

Newsletter of the Armenian National Committee – Middle East chapter

Middle East Armenians (General) > Newsletter of the Armenian National Committee – Middle East chapter
Azad Hye, United Arab Emirates
March 29 2006
Azad-Hye, Dubai, 29 March 2006: After starting a website earlier this
year, the Middle East chapter of the Armenian National Committee
started to circulate a newsletter in Arabic language.
The first issue of the newsletter, dated 21 March 2006, has already
reached the mailbox of thousands of individuals in Arabic countries.
It aims at updating Arabic language speakers about the developments
related to Armenia and the Armenians, especially the course of the
Genocide recognition worldwide. The publication is important also for
certain number of Armenians living in the Middle East, who use Arabic
as mode of communication.
The Arab public who has witnessed the arrival of the Armenians into
the Middle East and has shared with them decades of political, social
and economic experience, needs to know more about this group of
people, who are struggling for full acknowledgment of their plight.
The Arabs, who are in majority Muslims, have welcomed the Armenian
refugees during WWI. This is an important indication that the
Genocide against the Armenians did not have religious motivation.
The first issue of the newsletter has 4 pages, half of which is
devoted to the unfortunate news of the destruction of the Julfa
Armenian historical cemetery in Nakhichevan (Azerbaijan).
Other subjects in the newsletter:
– Turks organize anti-Armenian demonstrations in Paris
– Turkey has only two years ahead to comply with the political
criteria of the European Union.
– Request for equal US military aid to Armenia and Azerbaijan.
– The Committee for Defending the Armenian Cause meets the Ambassador
of the United Arab Emirates in Lebanon
Below is the complete text of this last piece of news related to the
UAE:
“Beirut: 17/3/2006 – A delegation of the Committee for Defending the
Armenian Cause meets the Ambassador of UAE in Lebanon His Excellency
Mohammad Sultan Seif Sweidi.
During the meeting the anti-Armenian policy of Azerbaijan was
exposed, a policy that reached to an extreme point through the
destruction of the Armenian archaeological and cultural monuments
in Julfa (Nakhichevan). The Karabag problem was another topic of
discussion. The delegation pointed to the anti-Armenian policy of
both Azerbaijan and Turkey regarding this issue, which is manifested
through the rejection of any peaceful solution in the area, which
gives the Armenians the right for self-determination.
The UAE Ambassador promised to follow up this issue with
his government. He referred to the friendly Armenian – Emirati
relations and the policy of openness adopted by his country, without
discrimination towards nations and religions.
The Committee had paid similar visits in the past to the Ambassadors
of the United Kingdom, Russia, Italy, the European Union, Netherlands,
Vatican and Egypt.”
Website of the Committee:

www.ancme.org

Official of the presidential administration in Georgia arrested fore

Agency WPS
DEFENSE and SECURITY (Russia)
March 31, 2006 Friday
MOLE CLOSE TO SAAKASHVILI;
Official of the presidential administration in Georgia arrested for
espionage and treason against the state
by Yuri Simonjan
A SPY SCANDAL IN GEORGIA; An update on the spy scandal in Georgia.
Simon Kiladze, official of the PR Service of the Presidential
Administration, was arrested in his office on the premises of the
Georgian State Chancellery yesterday on charges of espionage and
treason against the state. Kiladze’s duties included monitoring of
foreign, mostly Russian, media. Georgian TV channels ran the tape
showing arrest of a mole supplying sensitive information to secret
services of “a foreign state” on Tuesday morning.
Interior Minister Vano Merabishvili announced at a special briefing
yesterday that since 2004, Kiladze had “systematically updated
secret services of a foreign state on the president of Georgia;
senior officials of the legislative and executive branches of the
government, visits of state delegations, consultations and matters
discussed in the course of these visits, and provided information
of strategic importance for the country.” “This man used e-mail
or international mail depending on the value of the data. He even
brought sensitive information to the foreign country in person every
now and then,” Merabishvili said. By the minister’s rough estimate,
Kiladze was paid at least $20,000 for the information (just the money
transacted via Georgian banks). “The Interior Ministry knows for a
fact that Kiladze has leaked information to his spy runners since
2004. Identities of his handlers will be revealed in the course of
the trial,” Merabishvili said.
Director of the Presidential Administration, Georgy Arveladze,
arranged another briefing. He announced that “agents of a foreign
state” had operated in Georgia and even in its upper echelons of
power with impunity until recently but “no more”. Arveladze assured
journalists that it will be different now. “Nobody will be permitted
to trade interests of the state for money from foreign intelligence,”
he said.
Journalists were never told what country the spy had been working
for. Neither was President Mikhail Saakashvili any more specific. He
only told journalists yesterday that “Georgia has a lot of enemies”
who want to split it “but they will be frustrated.” As for the
likes of Kiladze, the people “working against their own country”,
Saakashvili advised them to surrender to counterintelligence before
May 1, in return for guarantees that no steps would be taken.
As a matter of fact, the circle of potential enemies hungry for
sensitive information on Georgia is not broad at all. Popular
Tbilisi weekly Kviris Palitra or Palitra Nedeli featured results
of an interesting opinion poll not so long ago. Its readers were
asked to name two particularly hostile countries. Almost 700 readers
responded and 94.4% of them named Russia. Belarus was named the second
hostile country (33.7%). No wonder – what with all the latest scandals
between Tbilisi and Minsk. Armenia became the third hostile country
with 28.1%. One of these three countries will probably be identified
as having recruited Kiladze.
Source: Nezavisimaya Gazeta, March 29, 2006, p. 4

“Moscow’s hand” discovered in Djavakhetia

Agency WPS
DEFENSE and SECURITY (Russia)
March 31, 2006 Friday
“MOSCOW’S HAND” DISCOVERED IN DJAVAKHETIA
by Yuri Simonjan
TBILISI IS CONVINCED THAT THE RUSSIANS ENCOURAGE ARMENIAN SEPARATISTS
IN SOUTH GEORGIA; Official Tbilisi found another pretext to pin the
blame on Russia.
The forecasts that without a solution to the problems of Abkhazia and
Tskhinvali found, Georgia may encounter a similar problem with
Armenian-populated Djavakhetia seem to be coming to pass. Mass
rallies took place in the district center of Akhalkalaki last week.
Demands of the autonomous status for the region were made in the
presence of several emissaries from Yerevan.
The latest protest actions were sparked by the murder of Gevork
Gevorkjan, 25, an Armenian from the town of Tsalka (his two friends
were injured). Some media outlets including Russian ones immediately
branded the murder as ethnic (allegedly the Svans, a Georgian ethnic
group, were after the Armenians). The same opinion was aired at the
rallies in Akhalkalaki. In the meantime, everything was more banal
than that. Gevorkjan was killed in a drunken scuffle with the ethnic
Svans moved to the Tsalka district several years ago after an
ecological catastrophe on their native land. A bar brawl rapidly
developed into a stabbing outside.
Armenian politicians in Djavakhetia and Armenia itself have a
different opinion. Albert Bazejan, National Revival Party leader,
said in Yerevan that the Armenian authorities should take an active
part in what he termed as “Akhalkalaki processes”. “We do not need
another hostile neighbor,” Bazejan was quoted as saying. “Along with
the social problems of the Armenian population, there are also some
political matters that have to be addressed and the questions of
survival of ethnic identity. I’d say it’s time we discussed the
status of cultural autonomy for the region.”
“Statements like that encourage separatism in Djavakhetia and have a
thoroughly negative effect on the Georgian-Armenian relations,” said
Van Vaiburt, a deputy in the parliament of Georgia and one of the
chairmen of the Union of Georgian Armenians. The lawmaker is
convinced that most Armenians in Djavakhetia do not care about
“autonomization”.
Another lawmaker, Gamlet Movsesjan, believes that social problems may
deteriorate into political even without deliberate provocations. He
says that abatement of tension in the area requires new jobs for the
locals and help in selling the harvest. “The Russian military base in
Akhalkalaki will be closed in 2007. The president promised that all
citizens of Georgia employed there will be offered jobs with similar
salaries but nothing at all has been done to this end so far,”
Movsesjan said.
Several non-government organizations of Djavakhetia put forth a
demand to make Armenian the state language. The petition will soon be
forwarded to the Armenian deputies of the parliament of Georgia. What
will come of the idea is easy to predict.
For the time being, official Tbilisi does not overestimate the danger
the rallies in Akhalkalaki pose. Some representatives of the
political establishment commented – traditionally – that the rallies
in Djavakhetia were probably incited from abroad, i.e. from Moscow.
Nino Burdzhanadze of the parliament said, “Certain forces are trying
to drive a wedge between the Armenian and Georgian population of the
Akhalkalaki district of Georgia.” She hinted as well that the rallies
could be provoked by the Russian military base command. Base
Second-in-Command, Colonel Igor Luzhnikov, denied involvement. “We
have nothing to do with the protests,” he said.
Even some political circles in Armenia do not rule out the
possibility of involvement of “a certain third force” in the rallies
in Akhalkalaki. Stepan Gregorian, Director of the Analytical Center
for Globalization and Regional Cooperation, believes that Moscow may
be indirectly interested in deterioration of the Georgian-Armenian
relations. “The scope of the Armenia-NATO cooperation plans worries
Moscow. The two signed the IPAP now long ago. A crisis in the
relations with Georgia will leave Armenia in a ring of hostile
countries – Turkey, Azerbaijan… Moscow will then be all it will be
able to turn to for assistance,” the analyst said.
Source: Nezavisimaya Gazeta, March 28, 2006, p. 5
Translated by A. Ignatkin

A mini-marshall plan for the trans-caucasus

Agency WPS
What the Papers Say Part A (Russia)
March 31, 2006 Friday
A MINI-MARSHALL PLAN FOR THE TRANS-CAUCASUS
by Vladimir Ivanov
Different visions for the conflict zones of the South Caucasus; The
Washington Post recently published an article that accuses Moscow
of establishing a “shadow empire” in the South Caucasus and calls
on the West to take action. Russian analysts Stanislav Lekarev and
Pavel Zolotarev comment on the article and its assumptions.
On March 11, the Washington Post published an article by Ana Palacio,
former Spanish foreign minister, and Daniel Twining, Oxford University
academic and consultant to the Marshall Fund. They set out their
vision of security problems in the Trans-Caucasus and proposed their
own scenario for pushing Russia out of that region.
First of all, the authors accuse Moscow of having imperial ambitions
and striving to reconstitute the Soviet empire by keeping Russia’s
former Soviet neighbors dependent on Russia in military and political
terms. However, according to the article, Russia is unable to turn
these intentions into reality as yet.
Citing calls by the Georgian and Ukrainian presidents for “a united
Europe stretching from the Atlantic to the Caspian,” Palacio and
Twining maintain that such declarations ought to prompt Europe and
America to help “people aspiring to freedom in other post-Soviet
states” rid themselves of Russia’s dominion and “the corrupting
influence of Russian power in regions beyond its borders.”
According to the authors, Moscow has managed to establish some sort of
“shadow empire” on the territories of former Soviet republics that are
now sovereign states, and uses its financial and military resources to
sponsor “frozen conflicts” in the Trans-Dniester region and the South
Caucasus. Such a policy, according to the authors, poses a serious
threat to the national security of European Union countries and the
United States, since they might be drawn into a regional military
conflict that is very likely to break out.
Palacio and Twining maintain that the situation taking shape in the
Trans-Dniester region, Abkhazia, and South Ossetia could have serious
consequences. The Russian military plays an active role in training
the armies of the separatist regimes and is very influential in the
unrecognized states. Their leaders, who support unification with the
Russian Federation, are Russian citizens and “enjoy the sponsorship of
powerful criminal elites in Russia, which profit from the unregulated
smuggling trade – in consumer goods, drugs, weapons and women –
in the conflict zones.”
Therefore, Palacio and Twining strongly advise Western Europe
and America to put pressure on Moscow, compelling it to withdraw
its troops from Abkhazia and South Ossetia: this would allegedly
facilitate preserving Georgia’s territorial integrity, following
multilateral negotiations involving the EU and the United States.
“Internationalized” peacekeeping forces should be stationed in
these hot-spots to guarantee stability. The same plan is proposed
for solving the Trans-Dniester problem, where Ukraine is nominated
for the role of Moldova’s chief assistant.
Moreover, say Palacio and Twining, “the West should require closure
of the Russian bases on Armenian territory.” They maintain that the
presence of Russian military contingents in Armenia only exacerbates
the Nagorno-Karabakh situation and makes it more difficult to
resolve. The EU and NATO, rather than Russia, are positioned as
realistic guarantors there. Palacio and Twining maintain that
the civilized West ought to support a settlement in which Armenia
returns the occupied territories to Azerbaijan and Nagorno-Karabakh
has autonomy status until a referendum is held.
In return, the West should ensure a prosperous future for the states
of the Trans-Caucasus and “put these countries on a path to Europe.”
In the South Caucasus states, for example, some sort of “mini-Marshall
Plan” is proposed. Then again, proposals for reviving that plan, once
used to rebuild the countries of Western and Southern Europe after
World War II, started appearing in the press as far back as the period
when NATO was bombing Yugoslavia. NATO and the EU, concerned about the
large number of refugees on the territories of their member states,
promised to provide help of this kind to the peoples of the Balkans,
enmeshed in bloody internecine conflicts.
The Washington Post is a prominent publication that reflects the
opinion of fairly influential circles in the West. That seems to be
why its pages have been used to test international public opinion
about the possibility of using the Balkans scenario for regulating
conflicts in the South Caucasus.
Experts take different views of the proposal set out by Ana Palacio
and Daniel Twining.
Stanislav Lekarev, former FSB officer, now at the Security, Defense,
and Law Enforcement Academy:
It’s no coincidence that the Marshall Plan is being mentioned at a
time when a sequence of color revolutions is taking place across the
former Soviet Union. It’s worth noting that General John Marshall, who
headed the Joint Chiefs of Staff and then the US State Department, was
skilled at various methods of causing conflict between his country’s
opponents, in the interests of furthering American policy. All this
was done beneath the banner of humanitarian actions aimed at fighting
“evil” and ensuring economic prosperity.
Using those kind of techniques, General Marshall was an active link
in realizing many vital US interests in various locations around the
world. During World War II he took part in many of America’s political
actions aimed at ensuring global dominance for the United States.
The plan for providing economic aid to Europe was proposed by
General Marshall in July 1947. This aid was offered to all European
countries affected by the war. The USSR refused the American money,
since Soviet leaders regarded the Marshall Plan’s basic provisions
as infringing state sovereignty, and no other country under Soviet
control was allowed to accept Washington’s offer. The Marshall Plan
was in effect for four years and cost America $13 billion; equivalent
to $130 billion in 2006 prices. This amounted to 5% of GDP for the
United States at the time.
Any such plan now would have to be approved by the US Congress,
signed by the US President, coordinated with the relevant European
Union bodies, and set down in the form of legislation according to
established procedures. In the Marshall Plan era, the United States
passed a special law on helping European countries.
The Marshall Plan served as the foundation for establishing NATO as a
counterweight to the USSR. This was a mechanism for resisting Stalin’s
attempts to extend Moscow’s influence across the whole of Europe.
And a very convenient situation for similar actions has arisen now.
All kinds of color revolutions and velvet revolutions are under way.
Such a plan could be a component in safeguarding the political and
economic interests of Europe and America. Undoubtedly, this does pose
a certain threat to Russia’s national interests. If Russian troops are
starting to be pushed out of regions where Moscow has traditionally
exerted political and economic influence, there are obviously
some far-reaching intentions behind that. We can’t rule out the
possibility that the basic strategy of the US and NATO, which entails
establishing mobile forces equipped with the very latest weaponry,
might be extended to the Caucasus. There wouldn’t be any American or
NATO bases there in the full sense of the term, but there might be
some kind of bridge-heads for deploying groups capable of ensuring
the achievement of political, economic, and military objectives.
The Washington Post article is clearly intended to test the
international community’s reaction. American strategy analysts will
use the results to develop evaluations and proposals.
Major-General Pavel Zolotarev, deputy director of the United States
and Canada Insitute:
Economic reconstruction of the Caucasus region and the implementation
of a Marshall Plan or any other programs wouldn’t necessarily lead
to NATO bases being established there. That scenario was essentially
inevitable, and logical, after World War II. But we can’t say for
sure that it would happen now. On the other hand, the proposals to
shut down Russian military bases and reform the peacekeeping forces
aren’t logically consistent with the European Union’s concern about
the prosperity of the Caucasus.
The European Union has failed to cope with the problems that have
existed, still exist, and will continue to exist in the Balkans – in
Kosovo, where the EU isn’t implementing any Marshall Plans. That area
retains all the negative charateristics of hot-spots: criminality,
terrorism, trafficking, and all the other negative aspects of such
locations. But Russia did warn the United States against establishing
an independent Muslim state in the center of Europe. These days,
no one talks of rebuilding democratic values there. The West is now
saying that everyone in the Balkans should be granted independence,
and the peoples will sort out their own problems. NATO and EU policy
has failed completely. No one’s trying to bring back refugees, no
talks are under way to preserve the state integrity of what remains
of Yugoslavia, and many other problems aren’t being addressed either.
And suddenly we’re seeing such tender concern for the Caucasus. A
clear trend is entirely obvious here: NATO and its leader, America,
obviously still take the same approach to determining political
dominance areas. This pays no regard to all of Russia’s proposals for
cooperating with the EU and the US in hot-spots across the former
Soviet Union, or the need to maintain the principle of dividing
spheres of influence.
All the same, the United States is taking a more sober-minded approach
to Russia. Sometimes it even reprimands Saakashvili, who doesn’t
always express himself appropriately. But Europe, unfortunately, is
too often forced to comply with the wished of NATO’s newest members,
who have anti-Russian attitudes in their blood. This is what seems to
be behind the statements and proposals in the Washington Post article.
In principle, it is necessary to invest in the South Caucasus. It is
necessary to create jobs there and solve all the problems commonly
encountered by underdeveloped countries worldwide. But I don’t think
Europe is capable of allocating any substantial sums to ensure economic
prosperity for the Trans-Caucasus. The integration of new member
states into the EU and NATO involves considerable economic costs –
not to mention the Balkans. Besides, the Europeans aren’t so generous
as to throw their money away. Any financial aid sent to the problem
regions is likely to be misspent, and the West is well aware of that.
Source: Nezavisimoe Voennoe Obozrenie, No. 9, March 2006, p. 2
Translated by Daria Smirnova

Azerbaijan says soldier killed on Armenian border

Azerbaijan says soldier killed on Armenian border
Agence France Presse — English
March 30, 2006 Thursday 1:28 PM GMT
BAKU, March 30 2006 — Azerbaijan accused Armenia Thursday of breaking
a ceasefire and responsibility for the death of one of its soldiers
on their common border.
“An Azeri soldier was killed during the habitual violations of the
ceasefire by the Armenian side,” the defence ministry said in Baku.
“Azerbaijan’s positions in the Tovuz region were targeted by Armenian
military units from the Berd area,” it said.
The two neighbours, which fought a war in the early 1990s over
Azerbaijan’s Armenian-populated enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh, regularly
charge each other with ceasefire violations.
Azerbaijan accused Armenia on March 7 of causing the death of an
Azeri soldier in the Karabakh region. Armenia quickly denied the
charge and responded with counter-accusations that Azeri troops had
killed an Armenian soldier the previous week.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress