Danger Of Zhirayr Sefilian’s Deportation Preserves

DANGER OF ZHIRAYR SEFILIAN’S DEPORTATION PRESERVES

Noyan Tapan
Dec 13 2006

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 13, NOYAN TAPAN. The danger of deportation of Zhirayr
Sefilian, the Coordinator of the Defence of Liberated Territories
public initiative, the Commander of the Shoushi special battalion,
preserves. Armen Aghayan, the organization’s Political Secretary,
informed journalists about it on December 13. In his words, though
against spread rumors Zh.Sefilian was not deported to Lebanon
late in the evening of December 10 by a plane flying from Yerevan
to Beirut, leakage of information about possible deportation of
Zh.Sefilian continues from the National Security Service. Mentioning
that everything will be done to prevent Zh.Sefilian’s deportation,
A.Aghayan at the same time did not disclose the steps to be done in
this direction. Zh.Sefilian who was arrested on December 10 by RA
National Security Service employees is charged with making public
appeals for changing RA constitutional order by force (Article 301,
RA Criminal Code). As A.Aghayan said, his arrest, as well as search
of his flat that followed the arrest were done for show. Thus,
Zh.Sefilian’s arrest took place at a restaurant where he was with
his family and friends.

VivaCell company’s Director, Lebanese Armenian Ralph Yirikian was also
among the latters (he was Sefilian’s classmate). By the way, he was
also arrested, but was released some minutes later. In A.Aghayan’s
words, the arms discovered at Zh.Sefilian’s apartment was a martial
award given to him by former Commander of NKR defence army, Samvel
Babayan. As regards ammunition, only some bullets not fit for use were
discovered. A.Aghayan said that such "ammunition" can be found at home
of any participant of Karabakh liberation war. Arrest of 2 months was
chosen as a preventive punishment towards Zh.Sefilian at the December
12 closed trial of first instance court of Yerevan’s Kentron and
Nork-Marash communities that lasted for seven hours and ended only
late in the evening. According to information provided by A.Aghayan,
Sefilian refused to testify at the court declaring that the accusations
brought to him are fake and have political motives. According to the
report spread by the National Security Service, the Consolidation of
Armenian Volunteers organization initiated by Zhirayr Sefilian and
some of his supporters having no registration by RA law pursued the
goal to make illegal, force intervention into the coming political
processes in RA, in particular, into the process of the 2007 elections
by undertaking extremist actions. In A.Aghayan’s words, there are some
versions about the real reasons of Zh.Sefilian’s arrest. A.Aghayan
considers improbable one of them concerning his activity aimed
against return of liberated territories, as it seems that no return
of territories is expected in the coming period. In his words, the
authorities try to impede the activity of the Defence of Liberated
Territories public initiative in the direction of taking control of the
process of parliamentary elections. A.Aghayan said that the volunteers
involved in the Consolidation of Armenian Volunteers are ready to
exercise such control without striving for receiving mandates. He
also assured that as a result of Zh.Sefilian’s arrest the organization
will not stop its activity and possibly, will extend it for even more.

IMF Provides About 5 Million Dollar Credit To Armenia

IMF PROVIDES ABOUT 5 MILLION DOLLAR CREDIT TO ARMENIA

Noyan Tapan
Dec 13 2006

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 13, NOYAN TAPAN. The International Monetary Fund
(IMF) provided an about 4.9 mln dollar credit to Armenia within the
framework of the Poverty Reduction and Economic Growth Program. Nienke
Oomes, IMF Yerevan Office Resident Representative, said at the
December 13 press conference that by this 19.5 mln USD out of the
34.3 mln USD envisaged by the three-year program have already ben
provided to Armenia. The program will finish in 2008.

According to N. Oomes, the IMF Executive Board assessed positively
the "reasonable monetary-credit and fiscal policies" of the Armenian
authorities that promoted the two-digit economic growth, poverty and
unemployment reduction and low inflation. The IMF Executive Board
approved the 2006 fiscal policy as well. It qualified the 2007 state
budget as a document consistent with economic stability. At the same
time, according to the board, although in recent years the GDP/taxes
ratio has notably improved in Armenia, it is still lower than the
indices of other regional countries. For this reason the IMF Executive
Board calls on the Armenian authorities to abolish tax privileges
of foreign investors in accordance with the envisaged schedule and
to increase the tax bodies’ powers of checking transactions and
tax-payers.

IMF Welcomes Prudent Monetary-Credit Policy Of CBA

IMF WELCOMES PRUDENT MONETARY-CREDIT POLICY OF CBA

Noyan Tapan
Dec 13 2006

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 13, NOYAN TAPAN. The IMF Executive Board welcomed
the prudent monetary-credit policy of the Central Bank of Armenia (CBA)
that aims to maintain price stability. Nienke Oomes, IMF Yerevan Office
Resident Representative, stated this during the December 13 press
conference. According to her, the IMF Executive Board also approved
the floating exchange rate policy that the CBA has conducted for the
same purpose. N. Oomes said that the CBA’s intervention in the foreign
currency market to smoothen sharp fluctuations without setting a target
level of exchange rate was also assessed positively. The IMF Executive
Board takes the view that resisting nominal appreciation pressures
may lead to high inflation, which may have a negative impact on the
vulnerable groups of the population and the economic growth. According
to the IMF, there is no definite evidence of the Armenian dram’s
being overvalued, while the best way to resist the danger posed to
competition is to conduct a policy of promoting productivity growth,
including improvement of the business environment and encouragement
of competition.

Armenian President Signs Law On 2007 State Budget

ARMENIAN PRESIDENT SIGNS LAW ON 2007 STATE BUDGET

Noyan Tapan
Dec 13 2006

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 13, NOYAN TAPAN. The Armenian President Robert
Kocharian on December 12 signed the RA Law on the 2007 State Budget
of the Republic of Armenia and the RA Law on Property Alienation for
Public and State Needs. NT was informed from the RA President’s press
service that on the same day the Armenian president signed the laws
on making amendments to the RA Civil Code and the RA Land Code.

Kindergarten Of Syunik Region’S Village Of Verishen Repaired Within

KINDERGARTEN OF SYUNIK REGION’S VILLAGE OF VERISHEN REPAIRED WITHIN FRAMEWORK OF COMMUNAL SELF-ASSISTANCE FUND’S PROGRAM

Noyan Tapan
Dec 13 2006

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 13, NOYAN TAPAN. The kindergarten of the Syunik
region’s village of Verishen was repaired within the framework of the
Communal Self-assistance Fund’s program financed by the U.S. Embassy
and the International Development Agency, implemented by the Save
the Children organization. The kindergarten’s official opening will
take place on December 14. According to the report submitted to Noyan
Tapan, the kindergarten is a two-storeyed building built in 1974. The
kindergarten’s kitchen, laundry, first-aid post, hall, playrooms,
bedrooms, heating system were repaired, a boiling-house was built
by the grant of the Communal Self-assistance Fund’s program. After
the repairs 90 children of Verishen and neighboring village of Akner
can attend the kindergarten. Besides, 18 jobs will be created. The
program’s total cost is 26599 USD, 18199 out of which was given by
the Fund and 8400 in the form of labor and building materials by the
communities of Verishen and Akner.

Baku Banks On Independent Energy Policy

BAKU BANKS ON INDEPENDENT ENERGY POLICY
Rovshan Ismayilov

EurasiaNet, NY
Dec 13 2006

As winter approaches, Azerbaijan appears to be strengthening its
support for Georgia in the South Caucasus’ ongoing chess game of energy
alliances, despite a reported earlier overture by the Kremlin for
cooperation. A December 1 order by Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev
that the Azerbaijani government consider suspending the country’s use
of a Russian-run pipeline to transport Azerbaijani oil to overseas
markets – a sign Baku wants to be an independent energy player.

The order came in response to an announcement by Gazprom that it would
increase gas prices for Azerbaijan in 2007 from $110 to $230 per
1,000 cubic meters. The Russian supplier would also cut the volume
of supplies exported to the South Caucasus state from 4.5 billion
cubic meters (bcm) to 1.5 bcm. Azerbaijani officials have indicated
that Baku is disinclined to buy any gas at all from Russia in 2007
at Moscow’s proposed price.

Gazprom representative Sergei Kupriyanov stated that the 1.5 billion
cubic meters "will fully meet Azerbaijan’s needs because the country
will increase its own gas production next year." Kupriyanov said that
Azerbaijan is getting ready to become a gas exporter. "We are not
against competition with Azerbaijan, but we are not going to support
this competition. It does not make sense," he said.

Aliyev directly linked his decision with Gazprom’s plans. Gazprom’s
price hike and its reduction in gas exports to Azerbaijan will require
the Caspian Sea state to make use of additional energy supplies to
keep its electric power stations running this winter, he said.

While the economic loss to Russia from Baku severing this relationship
would not be large – about $25 million per year in transit fees
are collected from the 1.5 million tons of Azerbaijani oil that
pass through Russian territory — the diplomatic fallout could be
more severe.

The fact that the order came on the eve of Russian Prime Minister
Mikhail Fradkov’s December 4 visit to Baku was interpreted as a
sign that Azerbaijan is priming for a long-term deterioration in
its relations with Moscow, local experts believe. In early November,
President Aliyev reportedly rejected a proposal by Russian President
Vladimir Putin to take part in a "coordinated policy" for energy
exports to the West, emphasizing that Baku wanted an independent
policy line, according to the influential Russian newspaper Kommersant.

The proposal has been widely interpreted as a request for Azerbaijan to
side with Russia in its dispute with Georgia, Ukraine and Belarus over
Gazprom’s efforts to increase gas prices. In this game of strategy,
commented one analyst, Azerbaijan’s state interests would be better
served if Baku aligned itself with Georgia.

"Ilham Aliyev has shown that he is unhappy with Russia’s pressure
and he does not have plans to coordinate Azerbaijan’s energy policy
with Moscow," commented Rasim Musabekov, an independent Baku-based
political analyst. "And this is a justified decision: [any] energy
blockade and crisis in Georgia will have a negative impact on the
national interests of Azerbaijan."

By damaging its relations with Georgia, Azerbaijan would lose its
only non-Russian-controlled energy transport corridor to the West,
Musabekov said. "All of Azerbaijan’s strategic energy projects such as
BTC [Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline], Baku-Supsa [oil pipeline] and
the South Caucasus [gas] pipeline run through Georgia. Another large
regional project, the Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku railroad, is in
the works," he said. "Therefore, stability in Georgia and relations
with this ally are of even greater importance for Azerbaijan than
relations with Russia."

After meeting with President Aliyev on November 28 at the Commonwealth
of Independent States summit in Minsk, Georgian President Mikheil
Saakashvili announced that Azerbaijan will render "brotherly
assistance to Georgia in the winter." Georgia has refused to pay
increased prices for Russian gas – $230 per 1,000 cubic meters, up
from $110 per cubic meter – saying that the price hike is politically
motivated. Georgia’s arrest of Russian military officers on charges of
espionage this September led to a complete shut-down of transportation
and communication links between Georgia and Russia, the withdrawal of
Russian embassy staff from Tbilisi, and the deportation of hundreds
of Georgian citizens from Russia. [For background see the Eurasia
Insight archive].

How Russia will respond to Aliyev’s order is uncertain, although
analyst Musabekov dismissed the possibility that sanctions similar
to those imposed against Georgia could come into force. Baku’s
negotiations with Armenia over the breakaway Azerbaijani region of
Nagorno-Karabakh are a more likely area for pressure, he added. [For
background see the Eurasia Insight archive].

Whether Azerbaijan will be able to cope with reduced gas supplies from
Russia and still supply Georgia with increased Azerbaijani gas for
2007 remains unclear. Russia provides gas for thermoelectric power
stations that meet up to 90 percent of the country’s power needs. By
buying gas from Russia at relatively cheap prices, Azerbaijan has
been able to export its natural resources at market prices and make
a good profit. A deficit in the country’s energy balance will mean
that that it will have to reconsider this strategy.

"Azerbaijan itself will need additional volumes of gas in 2007.

Besides, Baku has to buy Russian gas for $230 per 1,000 cubic meters,"
commented Ilham Shaban, editor of the Turan-Energy daily bulletin. "It
means that the export of its own gas to Georgia for a lesser price
will mean a straight loss for Azerbaijan." Although the precise
proposed price has not yet been specified, Georgia hopes to buy gas
from Azerbaijan at less than the $230 charged by Gazprom.

To sort out the muddle of gas supplies and demand, the energy
ministers of Georgia, Azerbaijan and Turkey met in Tbilisi on December
8. Georgian Energy Minister Nika Gelauri told reporters after the
talks that "[a] great step forward" had occurred. "[T]he ministers
have agreed that part of Turkey’s share in the Shah Deniz gas will be
divided between Georgia and Azerbaijan," Black Sea Press news agency
reported Gelauri as saying. The timing of deliveries and the volume
of gas supplies from Azerbaijan to Georgia in 2007 are expected to
be negotiated in a meeting in Baku the week of December 17.

How much gas Georgia will actually seek from Azerbaijan is a critical
factor. Tbilisi is also negotiating with Iran for gas supplies to
Georgia in 2007 to make up for any loss of Russian gas, if price
talks between Georgian energy distributors and Gazprom fail.

Technical problems connected with transporting large volumes of
Iranian gas via Azerbaijan are one obstacle for this gas source,
however. Strong misgivings expressed by the US ambassador to Georgia
recently about a Georgia-Iran energy pact could pose a more difficult
problem. If an agreement cannot be reached with Tehran, Tbilisi could
turn to Baku and Turkey to make up the difference via Shah Deniz,
an option favored by Washington.

For now, though, the start date for exports from the Shah Deniz gas
field remains a riddle. British Petroleum, the project’s operator,
began gas production at Shah Deniz in early November, and has stated
that it is ready to start exports at any time. The Azerbaijani
government has not commented on a start date. The South Caucasus
Pipeline, which will carry the gas to Turkey via Georgia, remains
incomplete on Turkish territory, though it is already able to transfer
supplies to Georgia. [For background see the Eurasia Insight archive].

Regardless of the outcome, energy analyst Shaban believes that
Azerbaijan itself will not suffer an energy crisis this winter. The
State Oil Company of Azerbaijan (SOCAR) has promised to increase its
own gas production in 2007 up to 2 billion cubic meters, he noted.

The company has stated that Azerbaijan could also buy an additional
1.5 to 2 billion cubic meters of gas from the Shah Deniz gas project
that Turkey has said it is unable to accept in 2007.

"That means that Azerbaijan might receive up to 4 billion cubic
meters of gas additionally in 2007, and this volume would cover the
3-billion-cubic-meters reduction in the gas supply from Gazprom,"
Shaban commented.

Nonetheless, reduced gas supplies from Russia and an increase in
Russian gas prices could pose a burden for Azerbaijan’s residential
and commercial consumers. As of January 1, 2007, residential gas
prices could double, the pro-opposition news agency Turan reported
an unnamed government source as saying.

"It is already clear that Russia will double the gas price for
Azerbaijan next year. Before we [the government] supplied part of the
gas imported from Russia to the population for $55 for 1,000 cubic
meters. But now we have to reconsider the price and increase it,"
said the source, the agency reported on November 29.

Editor’s Note: Rovshan Ismayilov is a freelance reporter based in Baku.
From: Baghdasarian

Armenian Patriarch Writes To The EU Leaders

ARMENIAN PATRIARCH WRITES TO THE EU LEADERS

AB Haber, Belgium
EU-Turkey News Network
Dec 13 2006

His Beatitude Mesrob II, Armenian Patriarch of Istanbul and All Turkey,
wrote a letter, dated 12 December 2006, to the Queens and Kings,
Presidents and Prime Ministers, and the Foreign Ministers, wherever
applicable, of Austria, Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia,
Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania,
Luxembourg, Malta, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden,
the Netherlands and the United Kingdom concerning his views on the
accession process of the Republic of Turkey to the European Union.

The content of the Patriarch’s letter is as follows:

"In view of the upcoming European Council, as the religious minority
leader of the Armenian Orthodox community, I wish to bring to your
kind attention some of my thoughts and concerns on Turkey’s accession
process.

The European Union is going to take a decision on 14 December which
will have crucial significance in terms of Turkey-EU relations.

Certainly, the impact of this decision will be felt in a much wider
context.

My primary concern, in this regard, is that the current impasse
seriously puts at risk Turkey’s accession process and Turkey-EU
relations at large. I think that this critical period should be
handled with a sense of utmost responsibility.

Turkey’s accession process is first and foremost important for the
Turkish people. The commitment of Turkey to be a member of the EU has
encouraged the political and economic reforms in our country. The
comprehensive reforms which were carried out in the last years are
also named as a silent revolution by outside observers. These have
tremendously improved the fundamental rights of all Turkish citizens,
including the religious minorities, and will certainly continue to
do so.

I also believe that Turkey’s accession process is significant for
the future of Europe. One of the major consequences of the accession
process will be a modern and economically prosperous Turkey which is
to the well-being of the EU and a wider geography.

It was the founder of the Republic of Turkey, Mustafa Kemal Ataturk,
of blessed memory, who, in the 1920’s, decidedly turned the face of
Turkey to Europe. Turkish people made their choice long ago to follow
the path of political and economic modernization. We are at a time
where we should highlight our shared values. That’s the only way to
realize that our diversities are nothing but a source of wealth for
all of us.

In this respect, it is so important that the EU should not
take decisions that would derail the negotiation process through
pressuring Turkey to fulfill unilateral conditions, while ignoring
other obligations.

Your Excellency, your leadership at this moment will be important in
preventing a negative decision to be taken by the European Council.

It is my sincere hope that your strategic vision will be instrumental
to put the process back on the right track.

Prayerfully, MESROB II, Armenian Patriarch of Istanbul & All Turkey"

.asp?id=15092

http://www.abhaber.com/haber_sayfasi

Baskin Oran: It Is Down To Secular Turkey To Foot The Bill For ‘Isla

BASKIN ORAN: ‘IT IS DOWN TO SECULAR TURKEY TO FOOT THE BILL FOR ‘ISLAMIC TERRORISM"

Cafe Babel, France
Dec 13 2006

‘Dialogue of the deaf’ between Ankara and Brussels – Turkish political
scientist, Baskin Oran shares his criticisms

‘Although both the EU and Turkey make mistakes, the latter is more
fragile’ – Oran (Photo: Berrin Cerrahoglu) Baskin Oran is a Turkish
political scientist and member of the Human Rights Committee in
Ankara. In 2004, he published a work on the concept of citizenship and
minorities in Turkey. Also a columnist for the weekly Turco-Armenian
magazine ‘Agos’, he is currently on trial for ‘insulting Turkish
justice’ and ‘incitement to hatred’. Whilst Ankara has made mistakes
in the membership process, European leaders are themselves behaving
irresponsibly, he says.

Why does Turkey refuse to open her ports and airports to Cypriot
boats and planes?

Following the last enlargement in 2004, Turkey decided to widen the
application of the 1963 Ankara Agreement [linking it to the EU], to
nine of the new member states. The list did not mention the ‘Republic
of Cyprus’. Protests from Brussels and Ankara’s obstinacy then led to
a protocol, signed in July 2005, which also caused problems. On the
Turkish side, ratifying the text implies recognition of the south of
Cyprus (Greek), and the abandonment of the north, denying the existence
of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC). On the European
side, the diplomats are embarrassed because Turkey has always said that
this protocol did not mean recognising Cyprus. By not mentioning the
‘Republic of Cyprus’ in its first decree, Turkey is today forced to
ratify a protocol that it cannot ratify. As in December 2004, the EU
is making Cyprus a ‘de facto’ membership condition, meaning that we
are today facing deadlock in the process.

It really is nothing more than a dialogue of the deaf.

Why has the situation become so unsolvable?

2007 is an electoral year in Turkey and boldness is not a value of
any of the candidates. More fundamentally, the Cypriot question has
always been a national issue. The Greek massacre of Turkish Cypriots
in 1964 caused such heartfelt reactions that leaving Cyprus has become
synonymous with treason. Moreover, in Turkey today, there is a sort
of ‘paranoia of the Treaty of Sèvres’, after the destruction of the
Ottoman Empire in 1920. Abandoning Cyprus is part of this phenomenon
and also contributes to worsening it. The reaction is exacerbated by
other factors, such as opposition to globalisation, as represented
by the EU. Many Turks fear that joining the EU will affect their
independence and culture. In addition, Turks are reacting against
the EU’s mistakes.

What do you mean by ‘mistakes’?

I mean the irresponsible acts and speeches made by European politicians
and statesmen – the fact that every new European document lists
new conditions for membership. Today, it is Cyprus; tomorrow it
will be genocide. The day after that, it will be something else
again. Moreover, the concept of ‘absorption capacity’ is enough in
itself. It creates a permanent impression of humiliation – it is the
idea of Turks always being unable to eat the carrot, however much they
are hit with the stick. There is no other way for it to be interpreted.

Why is the EU behaving in such a way?

In the past, only the elite would talk rationally about membership.

Since September 11, it is the emotional feelings of the masses that
hold sway. Politicians fear being caught on the wrong side of them.

It seems that secular Turkey must foot the bill for Islamic
terrorism. Then, we have the hasty integration of Eastern countries:
the rules have been swept away and the money is not there. Now, they
are trying to palliate the impact by using Turkey. In addition, the
Cypriot President, Tassos Papadopoulos, is a man whose nationalism
and carelessness are legendary. Brussels knows how to make use of
him. However, once appeased, the EU will put Cyprus in its real place.

What will the consequences of these arguments be?

Let’s be fearless. Diplomacy will soon find a middle way. However,
the problem remains that this nationalism throughout Europe is
feeding Turkish nationalists who, in return, feed their European
counterparts through their anti-democratic behaviour. The world is
undergoing a fundamental change in its socio-economic structures,
moving from national to international capitalism. This is reflected
in culture, politics and the law. This enormous change is frightening
everyone. However, let us not forget this – it is affecting Turkey
much more than Europe, due to its relative weakness. Turkey is making
a lot of mistakes but we must bear in mind its fragility.

p?T=T&Id=9182

–Boundary_(ID_bCLJbl4E7C3m7U3E Bzj+kA)–

http://www.cafebabel.com/en/article.as

U. S. Congressmen Congratulated NKR On Adoption Of Pro-Independence

U. S. CONGRESSMEN CONGRATULATED NKR ON ADOPTION OF PRO-INDEPENDENCE CONSTITUTION

DeFacto Agency, Armenia
Dec 13 2006

December 12 the Co-Chairmen of the Congressional Armenian Caucus,
Frank Pallone (D-NJ) and Joe Knollenberg (R-MI), were joined by
Representatives Adam Schiff (D-CA) and George Radanovich (R-CA)
in congratulating the citizens of the Republic of Nagorno-Karabagh
(Artsakh) on overwhelmingly approving a pro-independence constitution
in a popular referendum held on December 10th.

According to the information DE FACTO got at the Armenian National
Committee of America (ANCA), in a December 11th letter to Artsakh
President Arkady Ghoukassian, the two Caucus leaders had welcomed
the adoption of the first-ever constitution as a key milestone in
Nagorno Karabagh’s political and democratic progress. They stressed,
"Artsakh’s Constitution embodies your nation’s values to live in a free
and fair society, where human rights and economic opportunities are
enjoyed by all," adding that "societies that are fundamentally free and
fair are most successful, contributing to international security and
progress along the way." They closed their letter to the President by
reaffirming that they "will remain by your side, as Nagorno Karabagh,
Artsakh, continues to pursue its freedom, security and development."

Commenting on the referendum, Congressman Adam Schiff (D-CA) stated,
"I congratulate the people of the Republic of Nagorno Karabagh for
reaffirming their commitment to freedom, peace, economic development,
and regional stability by democratically adopting a new constitution.

By establishing a market economy, holding free and fair elections,
and promoting human rights, the people of Nagorno Karabagh have
shown that they deserve an independent state free from the oppressive
Azerbaijani regime."

Rep. Radanovich noted, "The adoption of Nagorno Karabagh’s first ever
democratic Constitution is a landmark achievement; advancing democracy
breeds a free and open society, while promoting human rights. The
adoption of the Constitution proves the desire of the people of
Nagorno Karabagh to live in such a free society. I commend this
great achievement and pledge my continuing support for the Nagorno
Karabagh Republic."

In letters sent December 11 to every member of Congress, the ANCA
underscored that "the approval of the Nagorno Karabagh constitution
reaffirms its citizens’ collective commitment to freedom and marks
a major milestone in this new democracy’s contribution to peace,
economic development, and regional stability." Each ANCA letter was
accompanied by a three-page briefing document (attached) addressing
key points concerning Nagorno Karabagh, Azerbaijan, the peace process,
and prospects for regional stability.

The Nagorno Karabagh Republic Central Electoral Commission has
reported, based on preliminary results, that the people of Nagorno
Karabagh overwhelmingly approved their first-ever constitution by a
majority in excess of 98% of those casting ballots. Early estimates
point to a voter turnout of over 87% of eligible voters.

The new Constitution affirms that the Nagorno Karabagh Republic is
a sovereign state based upon democracy and the rule of law, as well
as the protection of human rights and civil liberties. The state’s
authority is derived from popular consent, as expressed through
elections and referendums, and the governmental system is based
on the principle of separation of the executive, legislative and
judiciary branches.

Kocharian Rejects Karabakh Vote Criticism

KOCHARIAN REJECTS KARABAKH VOTE CRITICISM
By Emil Danielyan

Radio Liberty, Czech Rep.
Dec 13 2006

President Robert Kocharian condemned international mediators
and European officials through a spokesman on Wednesday for their
strong criticism of the weekend referendum in Nagorno-Karabakh on a
constitution declaring the disputed region an independent state.

The Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, the Council
of Europe and the European Union joined the Azerbaijani government
in rejecting the legitimacy of the vote that reaffirmed Karabakh’s
de facto secession from Soviet Azerbaijan.

The OSCE chairman-in-office, Belgian Foreign Minister Karel De Gucht,
said it is "counter-productive to the ongoing conflict settlement
process." In a separate statement, French, Russian and U.S. diplomats
co-heading the OSCE’s Minsk Group on Karabakh likewise called it
"unhelpful." A similar statement issued by Terry Davis, the Council
of Europe secretary general, said the international community will
not recognize the referendum outcome.

"This is an overt display of disrespect for an event of historic
significance for the people of the Nagorno-Karabakh Republic,"
Kocharian’s press secretary, Victor Soghomonian, was quoted by the
Regnum news agency as saying.

"Such an attitude can only undermine the trust in the OSCE and the
group of mediators. I believe the best thing these gentlemen — as
well as ‘commentators’ from the Council of Europe — could have done
was to keep silent," Soghomonian snapped.

Kocharian on Monday welcomed the official referendum results that
showed the overwhelming majority of voters in Karabakh approving
the constitution drafted by their government. He described the vote
as "another milestone in the establishment of Nagorno-Karabakh’s
independence."

The authorities in Stepanakert also received a congratulatory message
from the two U.S. congressmen co-chairing the 142-strong Armenian
Caucasus in the House of Representatives.