BAKU: Hungarian Appeals Court to consider complaints on R. Seferov

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Dec 15 2006

Hungarian Appeals Court to consider complaints on Ramil Seferov’s
case on Feb 22, 2007

[ 15 Dec. 2006 13:50 ]

The date of Appeals Court on complaints of Azerbaijani Army officer
Ramil Seferov, sentenced to life imprisonment on accusation of
killing Armenian officer Gurgen Markaryan in Hungary, is set,
Ministry of Justice, International Law Cooperation Department chief
Zafer Gafarov told APA.

Advocate Ikram Shirinov said that they have not received a summons
concerning the court date.
`So, the date is not precise’, he noted. The advocate will visit
Hungary on Jan 15 to meet with Ramil Seferov. /APA/

ANKARA: Armenian Patriarch backs Turkey’s EU bid

NTV MSNBC, Turkey
Dec 15 2006

Armenian Patriarch backs Turkey’s EU bid
The EU’s leaders should not impose unilateral conditions on Turkey.
Mesrob said.

Güncelleme: 03:45 ET 15 Aralık 2006 Cuma
ISTANBUL – The head of the Armenian church in Turkey has called on
the leaders of the European Union not to undermine Ankara’s bid for
membership of the bloc.

A letter released by the office of Armenian Patriarch Mesrob II late
Thursday, sent to the leaders of the EU’s 25 member states, said that
efforts should be made to overcome a critical period in Turkey’s
accession process.

The letter was made public on the day that the EU leaders endorsed a
recommendation by the European Commission to partially suspend
Turkey’s membership negotiations in response to Ankara’s refusal to
open its ports and airports to Greek Cypriot trade. `The EU’s leaders
will make a critical decision in Turkey-EU relations, which will have
broad consequences,’ Mesrob II said in his letter. `My concern about
this decision is that current unsolved problems could jeopardise the
country’s membership process and Turkey-EU relations in general.’

Turkey was committed to becoming a member of the EU and was enacting
the political and economic reforms required under the accession
criteria, the Patriarch said. `These reforms have improved the basic
rights of Turkish citizens including religious minorities,’ wrote
Mesrob. `This positive process will of course continue.’ The EU
should not derail Turkey’s membership negotiations by imposing
unilateral conditions without taking into account Turkey’s other
commitments, he said. `Your leadership is of utmost importance in
preventing the European Council from taking a negative decision,’
Mesrob wrote. `I hope that your strategic vision would mediate
putting the process back on track.’

OSCE presents publication on main aspects of cyber security in ROA

Organization for Security and Co-Operation in Europe (OSCE)

Dec 15 2006

OSCE Office presents publication on main aspects of cyber security in
Armenia

YEREVAN, 14 December 2006 – Cyber security and cyber crime, including
the global threats in this respect and their relevance for Armenia,
international standards and Armenian efforts to combat it are the
focus of a publication, presented in Yerevan today.

Supported by the OSCE Office, it included the conclusions of a recent
roundtable discussion on cyber security, as well as recommendations
from an OSCE-supported cyber security task force.

"The importance of cyber security management continues to grow as the
global digital economy develops. The inadequate protection of
information technology could hinder the development of Armenia and
not only in the information and communication sectors," said
Ambassador Vladimir Pryakhin, the Head of the OSCE Office.

"Best international practices offer Armenia models that can be
applied to fill in the practical gaps. An important step in this
respect was the ratification by Armenia in March 2006 of the Council
of Europe Convention against Cyber Crime. The publication presented
today can help Armenia in its efforts to safeguard cyber security,
combat cyber crime and adopt policies to foster technological
innovation."

Ara Yeremyan, Head of the Criminal and Administrative Law Unit of the
Legislative and Analytical Department at the National Assembly,
added:

"It is crucial for Armenia to create a comprehensive approach, taking
into account international standards and other countries’ experience.
This publication is a useful tool in that work."

The Task Force on Cyber Crime and Cyber Security was created at the
initiative of the OSCE Office in Yerevan and includes members from
the Police, the National Security Service, the National Assembly and
the Presidential Administration. It was designed to co-ordinate
efforts in this area, raise awareness on the issue and propose
concrete steps to improve the situation.

Limited copies limited copies are available at the OSCE Office in
Yerevan.

http://www.osce.org/

Yerevan Medical Uni. Merged With Environmental Hygiene Institute

YEREVAN MEDICAL UNIVERSITY MERGED WITH ENVIRONMENTAL HYGIENE INSTITUTE
BY DECISION OF ARMENIAN GOVERNMENT

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 16, NOYAN TAPAN. At the Deember 14 sitting, the
Armenian government made a decision to merge Yerevan State Medical
University after Mkhitar Heratsi and Yerevan Scientific and Research
Institute of Environmental Hygiene and Preventive Toxicology into
Yerevan State Medical University after Mkhitar Heratsi. According to
the RA Government Information and PR Department, the reorganization of
the indicated organizations through a merger will become a stimulus
for the development of the country’s sanitary and preventive medicine
and the preparation and training of medical personnel.

ANKARA: Armenian Patriarch Urges EU to Continue with Turkey

Zaman, Turkey
Dec 15 2006

Armenian Patriarch Urges EU to Continue with Turkey
By Sezai Kalayci, Istanbul
Friday, December 15, 2006
zaman.com

Patriarch Mesrob II, the head of the Armenian Orthodox Church in
Turkey, sent out a letter to the leaders of all European countries
asking them to support Turkey’s EU bid during the European Council
meeting.

The letter was sent on Dec. 12 to 23 EU leaders, except Greek and
Greek Cypriot leaders.

Mesrob Mutafian reminded EU leaders the obligations of the union and
asked them to fulfill their promises.

The Armenian patriarch said Mustafa Kemal urged Turkey in the 1920s
to turn to the West, adding: `It is of utmost significance that the
EU should not force Turkey to fulfill multifaceted conditions and
derail negotiations, while ignoring its obligations.’

Mutafian said as the leader of the Armenian Orthodox community he
wanted to convey his opinions and concerns ahead of the council
meeting started the previous day, and indicated that EU leaders’
decision regarding Turkey would have impacts in a wide context.

The current impasse over Turkey-EU relations would put Turkey’s
accession process to the union in a risky position, the Patriarch
said, adding: `This critical period should be handled with
responsibility.’

Parochial elections in the United Arab Emirates

Azad Hye
December 15, 2006

In 1994 the Parochial system was introduced into the life of the Armenians
residing in Kuwait and the Arab Gulf countries. Since then three consecutive
elections took place (1994, 1998, 2002). Time has come for the fourth
elections. Besides our best wishes we would like to take the opportunity to
point out to the following:

– It is expected that, after having three previous experiences, the
forthcoming elections would go ahead smoothly enough. Thus we expect that
the election date would be announced very soon and proper circular would be
sent to the Armenians. On the other hand enough time should be given to the
candidates to orient themselves and take this task seriously. The collection
of the national taxes should not be left to the last one or two weeks, etc.
It is recommended to take advantage of this occasion to organize a series of
informative activities emphasizing the importance of the participation in
the public life and highlighting the meaning of the elections and their
influence in our life.

– It is recommended that the candidates provide a written accord regarding
the policies they intend to follow in the coming period (in case they are
elected), making it clear, in the first place, why they want to be elected.
The electors have the right to know about the priorities of the candidates,
their plans and concerns. It would be a good idea if candidates publicize
their pre-election declarations at least two weeks in advance.

– The official parochial report on the activities of the last four years
should be availed to the electors. It is not logical to ask the public to
take part in the elections if the majority is not aware about what has been
going on in the last four years. The elector should have an idea about the
existing difficulties, how effective were the implemented plans, what parts
were not materialized, what ideas were suggested in the course of action.
Only with such an approach an elector would really know the value of his
vote and will understand that he is part of a larger community.

– Meeting people: Of course it is a very healthy phenomenon to do the
elections, but officials should meet with the public not only during the
election time. The UAE Armenian community is getting larger and larger every
day. There are several hundred newly arrived Armenians who live scattered in
many cities in the Emirates without having any record about them. It is a
great challenge to find them and communicate with them. But why not accept
the challenge and proceed to do what is necessary to establish contact with
them, using all advanced technology in this context? Of course this step
means to alter the type and nature of the activities that we are used to
offer to the audience. Not doing so, the newly added members will feel that
they are wasting their time.

– It is very much appreciated if an Armenian networking event takes place at
least once a month in any suitable location in the city. We should invite
all the members of the community to such meetings, especially those who have
settled in the Emirates in the last few years. Our community has a different
structure than the traditionally known Armenian communities: the percentage
of the bachelor professionals (or those who live away from their families)
is big compared to the other Middle Eastern societies. Only by getting to
know each other we can achieve progress.

– The daily school: Behind the curtains there is much talk nowadays about
the school. For 25 years the weekly Armenian school served and continues to
serve the community. The new challenge is to change the school to a daily
one. What is lacking to materialize this project? Willingness! It is a fact
that establishing a school requires sacrifices, but when was the Armenian
hesitant to go ahead with opening a school, especially that the financial
means are almost secured and the number of the students is sufficient? It is
totally different thing that some of those who are occupying positions in
the Armenian community are not convinced about this step. If – in principle
– they have suspicions about the mission of the school, they should tender
their resignations. Preserving the Armenian identity was not always related
to "practical considerations". The elections will enable the emergence of
those who believe in the idea of the daily school.

– Embassy of Armenia: It is a fact that since the year 2000 the Embassy of
Armenia is operating in Abu Dhabi. Supporting an Embassy is a very noble
act. The Armenians of the UAE have assisted the Embassy from the first
moment. In about one year time the new building of the Embassy will be
completed. We must be happy for this achievement, but we should not think
about it as our direct mission. An Embassy before anything else needs
respect. For example, a new website has been recently introduced dedicated
to the monitoring of the construction of the Embassy building, but the
Ambassador was not counseled about it. Patriotism should not take the form
of show-off. Embassy – community relationships should be clear and
transparent, in order to avoid some of the bitter experiences recorded in
other communities.

– Other challenges: In the future we will refer to other issues such as how
involved are the citizens of Armenia in the community life, what are the
cooperation prospects between people of different ideological backgrounds
and sympathies in our community, what are the opportunities for propagating
the Armenian cause in the Gulf countries, etc. It is pity to confirm that we
are going to the elections without having the slightest idea about the above
mentioned issues.

See Armenian text at:
Id=621dzk41

http://www.azad-hye.net/news/viewnews.asp?news

Azeri party ignores Armenian refugees’ just dreams

DeFacto Agency, Armenia
Dec 15 2006

AZERI PARTY IGNORES ARMENIAN REFUGEES’ JUST DEMANDS

A network of the civil society `’Refugees and International Law” has
circulated a statement in connection with the NKR Constitution’s
adoption.
The statement runs, in part:
`’A network of the civil society `’Refugees and International Law”
on behalf of hundreds of thousands refugees from the Azerbaijani SSR
and Nakhijevan states that the adoption of the Main Law – the NKR
Constitution – corresponds to the fundamental interests of Artsakh
people, refugees and will become an important incentive for the
negotiation process to proceed in the rational channel. The next step
of the NKR people and leadership should be adoption of a law on the
NKR citizenship, which would enable the refugees to again find a
country of their citizenship in the NKR. The network of the civil
society `’Refugees and International Law” believes the OSCE Minsk
group Co-Chairs Matthew Bryza, Yuri Merzlyakov and Bernard Fassier,
as well as all officials, who ignore and hush up the issue of half a
million refugees from the Azerbaijani SSR and Nakhijevan one way or
another, bear personal responsibility for the non-productiveness of
the bilateral talks being held. Since the Azeri party ignores a just
demand of the refugees from the Azerbaijani SSR and Nakhijevan to
compensate material and moral damage incurred by the Azerbaijani
authorities, the network of the civil society `’Refugees and
International Law” again reaffirms its determination to achieve the
aim: the territories of the former Aghdam, Fizuli, Jebrail and other
regions of the former Azerbaijani SSR should be turned over to the
refugees from the Azerbaijani SSR as a partial compensation of the
damage they have suffered”, KarabakhOpen reports.

Armenian press grappling with newsprint shortage

EurasiaNet, NY
Dec 15 2006

ARMENIAN PRESS GRAPPLING WITH NEWSPRINT SHORTAGE
Emil Danielyan 12/15/06

Armenia’s vibrant print media are struggling to remain afloat due to
a serious shortage of newsprint which government officials and
private publishers blame on external factors such as Russia’s
continuing transport blockade of Georgia. Some newspaper editors,
however, wonder whether the shortage is, in fact, politically
motivated.

The country’s largest printing house, which publishes some 30 local
periodicals, claims to have been unable to ship paper since the
closure of the main Russian-Georgian border crossing last summer. The
privately owned company, Tigran Mets, announced late last week that
it has run out of stock and will not accept printing orders from
clients until further notice.

Virtually none of the affected publications has suspended publication
so far, however. Some have temporarily switched to other, smaller
printing houses. Others continue to be produced by Tigran Mets on
thicker and more expensive paper which is normally used for books.
They have had to reduce their already small printing runs to offset
the extra publishing costs involved.

Tigran Mets owner and Chief Executive Officer Vrezh Markosian told
EurasiaNet on November 12 that the crisis will likely end by the
December 16-17 weekend. "We expect to get a fresh batch of newsprint
on Friday or Sunday at the latest," he said. "It is on its way to
Armenia."

Tigran Mets has for years imported Russian-made newsprint to Armenia
via neighboring Georgia, usually by trucks. The company says the
Russian government’s decision in June to "temporarily" shut down the
sole functioning Russian-Georgian border crossing at Upper Lars left
more than 200 tons of its newly purchased paper stranded in southern
Russia. The all-out Russian transport blockade subsequently imposed
on Georgia forced it to divert the cargo consignment to the Ukrainian
Black Sea port of Ilyichevsk, which operates a regular rail ferry
service with Poti, Georgia.

Markosian and government officials in Yerevan say the ferry link,
heavily used by Armenia in its external trade, was not operational
during most of November because of stormy weather. The explanation
seems less than convincing to Armenian newspaper editors and leaders
of media associations. In particular, they wonder why Markosian took
six months to reroute the newsprint deliveries and why he warned
customers of the problem at short notice.

"I can’t say for certain that there is no politics involved here,"
said Aram Abrahamian, editor of the independent daily Aravot. "I can
only hope that the reasons [for the shortage] are really economic."

Boris Navasardian, chairman of the Yerevan Press Club, voiced similar
suspicions, arguing that imports of other commodities have barely
been affected by the Russian-Georgian confrontation and other
problems complicating landlocked Armenia’s transport communication
with the outside world. "In countries like ours, the authorities can
take any step to restrict freedom of speech and dissemination of
information," he told a November 6 roundtable discussion in Yerevan.

The Armenian print media have not faced serious government
restrictions until now, with many newspapers routinely making harsh
attacks on President Robert Kocharian and other top officials. Most
of the country’s five national dailies and a dozen other major
publications are highly critical of the authorities. They are
tolerated by the latter not least because of their small circulation
and the resulting limited impact on public opinion. The best-selling
local daily, Haykakan Zhamanak, sells less than 6,000 copies a day
and is only eight pages long.

Instead, Kocharian maintains a tight grip on the far more accessible
electronic media. The presidential administration is believed to
control the news coverage of dozens of big and small television
stations operating in Yerevan and across the country. The only TV
channel that regularly aired criticism of the Armenian president and
his cabinet was controversially pulled off the air in April 2002. The
de facto closure of the popular A1+ station was condemned by local
and international media watchdogs. One of them, the Washington,
DC-based Freedom House, has described the Armenian media as "not
free" in its annual reports released since the closure.

Another watchdog, Reporters Without Borders (RSF), put Armenia in a
lowly 101st place in its latest list of 168 nations ranked in terms
of press freedom protection. The Paris-based group pointed not only
to the de facto government control of Armenian broadcasters, but also
to periodical physical attacks on local print journalists. In the
most recent of such cases reported in September, unknown men ambushed
and beat up Hovannes Galajian, editor of the opposition-linked
Iravunk weekly. Also in September, another newspaper editor critical
of the government, Arman Babajanian, was sentenced to four years in
prison for dodging military service. While Babajanian pleaded guilty
to the charge, the sentence was unusually harsh by Armenian
standards.

The newsprint shortage, coupled with Babajanian’s imprisonment and
violence against other journalists, is raising fears among media
professionals that the authorities have decided to get tougher on the
defiant print press ahead of parliamentary elections next spring.

"We will somehow overcome this crisis, but what is going to happen
next?" asked Hagop Avedikian, the veteran editor-in-chief of another
daily, Azg. Avedikian is particularly worried about newspaper
distribution in Armenia, which he believes could become an even more
serious problem. Private distribution agencies that owe considerable
sums to Azg and other papers, he explained, are increasingly facing
bankruptcy.

"What is happening now is extremely dangerous," said Nune Sargsian,
head of the Yerevan office of the US media support group Internews.
"What will we do if the same situation arises during the election
period? That may happen and we must be prepared for that."

Editor’s Note: Emil Danielyan is a Yerevan-based journalist and
political analyst.

The Consequences For Discussing The Armenian Genocide

RAGIP ZARAKOLU
TURKISH PUBLISHER AND HUMAN RIGHTS CHAMPION SPEAKS IN LONDON
ON 13TH DECEMBER

THE CONSEQUENCES FOR DISCUSSING THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE

Ragip Zarakolu*

(*) President of the Turkish Publishers Unions Committee for Freedom
to Publish and IPA’s IFTC Member

The events that took place in the year 1915, namely the Armenian
Genocide, continue to be the most sensitive and taboo topics in the
history of the Turkish Republic. The prohibitions concerning the
discussion of the events that took place in 1915 have escalated to
such a degree as to question Armenian identity itself. Such
prohibitions have endeavored to erase Armenian identity from
historical atlases and encyclopedias, and have even encouraged the
destruction of graves and historical sites. I have labeled this the
final stage of the genocide.

The chief endeavor of these prohibitions was to erase all
consciousness of this incident from public memory. Up until 1965,
which happened to be the 50th anniversary of the Genocide, it is
plausible to argue that this was successfully achieved. During that
time, aside from the dispersed Diaspora circles, the event had been
forgotten.

THE PROHIBITION OF THE ARMENIAN PROBLEM

Starting with the 1990’s, when the problem was initially discussed in
the courts, we may divide the prohibition process into three stages.

1. 1923-1945. Orders for prohibition during this period were issued
directly by the Council of Ministers (OPCM). In addition to Armenian
publications, Kurdish, Greek, Laz, Circassian books and reviews,
publications by intellectuals, leftist and Islamic circles which had
been driven out of Turkey were also closely monitored. The issuing of
prohibition orders based on the flow of these reports constituted a
very important aspect of the government’s duties.

a) In 1925 after the issuing of the Takrir-i Sükun Law (Law for
Peace or Silence), which encompassed both the press and political
activity, the Armenian press in Istanbul saw its fair share of
difficulties. The Hahtanak newspaper was shut down because it was
argued that `it attempted to popularize bolshevism amongst Armenians.’
In the 30’s the Aztarar newspaper, which was also published in
Istanbul, was shut down because of the prohibition by Council of
Ministers.

b) During the time period in question publications outside Turkey were
prohibited and denied circulation in Turkey because it was argued that
`they might incite hostility amongst the citizens once again.’ Another
reason given for this prohibition was `to protect Armenians from
harmful influences.’ Yet another reason given was the alleged ties
between these publications and the Tashnak Party. An interesting fact
worthy of mention is that the Tashnak Party was seen as `a committee,
which has important organizational links inside the country.’

With that said, in 1928 the newspaper Harac published in
Paris, Aztak published in Syria, Noror published in Athens, Husaper
published in Cairo and Misak magazine published in California were all
denied circulation in the country. In the following years Armenian
publications that were prohibited are as follows: Hayrenik and Baykar
(Boston), Mardigoz (Paris), Arev (Cairo), Zartonk and Ararat (Beirut),
Aramatz (Athens), Aras (Bucharest),Yeprat and Hayastan Gacnak (USA),
Azad Hosk (Sofya), The Armenian and His Works (Yerevan). In the
decisions for outlawing these publications other reasons that were
often given were that these were `inciting Armenians within the
country’ and ` catering to the Armenian cause.’ It was claimed that
the article which led to the closing of Mardigos in 1933 defended the
position that the `Armenian revolution was in fact righteous and not
working together with the Kurds was a very important tactical
mistake.’ The article that was given as the reason for closing Arev,
which was published in Cairo, is one of he first examples of memories
from 1915 being revitalized: `Due to the 20th Anniversary of the Mush
Plain tragedy.’

c) Books during this period also received prohibitions. Examples of
these are `Today’s Armenia’ and `Gardens and Orchards’ published in
Cairo, `Emma’ and `Longings for Life’ published in Yerevan.

d) In 1933 for the first time the entry of an encyclopedic publication
was denied. The famous German dictionary/encyclopedia Brochaus’ Atlas
was prohibited because it was argued that it `had a splintering effect
on Turkish Cultural Unity.’ The prohibition concerning encyclopedias
would once again resurface after the September 12th military coup
d’etat in 1980. The reason given for this was the incorporation of
`Historical Armenia.’

e) An event that left its mark on this period was the attention
Austrian writer Franz Werfel’s Forty Days on Musa Dagh received. It
was a novel that served as a reminder of the events that took place in
1915. The Turkish diplomatic effort for the banning of this book was
successful and the campaign served as an example for campaigns against
1915 memorials in the world and the movie `Midnight Express’. The book
was first published during the beginning of Nazi rule and with the
OPCM its entry in to Turkey was immediately prohibited.

A treaty with only a single condition was signed between Turkey and
Nazi Germany concerning the prohibition of the book. This must have
been one of the first international treaties the new German regime had
signed. In any case Werfel’s book in addition to many other authors’
books was burned in campaigns organized by the Nazis through out
Germany on May 10. In 1935 the book along with a photograph of Werfel
was burned in the garden of the Armenian school in Pangalti. In 1934
the book was published in French. France refused to prohibit its
distribution. The American edition became a best-seller with over one
million copies sold. The American company MGM expressed interest in
making a movie based on the book. However, when faced with Turkish
diplomats threatening to close Turkey’s doors to the American film
industry they gave up the idea. (The detailed story of this diplomatic
campaign that spanned a time period of five years may be found in
Rifat Bali’s article in the magazine Tarih ve Toplum).

f) Armenian graves were removed; most churches were either legally
expropriated or simply left to collapse. These practices were once
again employed after 1960 with the help of the secret Subcommittee for
Minorities (Azınlıklar Tali Komisyonu) initiated by
Prime Minister Ismet Inonu. This Committee were dissolved again
secretly in 2005, by Government’s Decree, as a part EU reforms.

2) We may label the second phase of this process as the stage of
amnesia or that of forgetting. In 1948, despite being one of the first
nations to sign the UN’s genocide treatise, it is safe to say that a
general amnesia played an important role for Turkey in this decision.
While the Turkish Republic signed this treaty with out giving any
thought to the hardships it would cause later on, the United States
waited until 1986 to sign it. The period between 1945 and 1990 marks a
tumultuous democratization period for Turkey. In 1950 the founding
party of the Republic, CHP, lost the elections and was removed from
power. However, in 1960, 1971 and 1980 respectively military coup
d’etats would take place. Despite all these changes the prohibition
on foreign publications entering into the country as arranged by the
Council of Ministers continued. Interestingly enough tourist guide
books also suffered as a consequence of this because of mentioning
`Historical Armenia.’ Those who guide books on them or anyone who was
found carrying books about Armenians at borders were detained. One of
the most memorable demonstrations of the 1980 coup was the bombing of
the resistance memorial at Musa Dagh by canons.

During the militaristic rule of General Kenan Evren the French
encyclopedia Larousse was prohibited from being imported due to the
fact that it included an entry on the Armenian Genocide and its
history. The editor of the Turkish edition of the British encyclopedia
Britannica was tried in court for allowing an entry on `Historical
Armenia.’ The Britannica fascicle in question was taken out of
circulation. During this time a Turkish encyclopedia which gave
detailed accounts of all the provinces, Yurt Ansiklopedisi was
published under strict censorship, cleaned from the pages about
Armenia and Armenians.

3) The third phase constitutes a kind of civil disobedience where
books on the Armenian issue began to get published and discussion of
the issue itself began to be carried out in the courts.

The 1980 coup had a detrimental effect on human rights, this lead to a
large scale human rights movement. The escalation of the Kurdish issue
caused a continuation of these problems on the one hand and on the
other intensified the search for civil liberties and rights.

Ayse Nur Zarakolu, one of the leading figures in this human rights
movement, published books on the Kurdish issue in 1990 and also
published sociologist Dr. Ismail Besikci’s books which had been banned
from publication since 1971.
By doing so Ayse Nur Zarakolu initiated the discussion of the Kurdish
problem. In 1990 while being tried for the book Kurdistan: An
Inter-states Colony in her defense Ayse Nur Zarakolu mentioned for the
first time in addition to all the international human rights documents
the Genocide Treatise. She stated that `It is the committers of
genocide that should be tried not those who discuss it.’

The 142nd Article of the Turkish Penal Code, which had been borrowed
from the Italian Penal Code in 1930 and was removed in 1990, in
addition to socialist publications had become the standard article
with which books on the Armenian and Kurdish issue were handled. The
article was used for prosecuting crimes that endeavored to incite
hostility amongst social groups based on class, religion, ethnicity,
race and nation.

After the removal of the 142nd article from the penal code there was a
significant increase in the number of publications concerning the
Kurdish issue.

But this also translated into an increase in the number of trials
taking place. Med/Zel/Peri Publications’ editor Ahmet Onal, in 1992,
published Armenian researcher Garo Sasuni’s The Kurdish National
Movement and Kurdish- Armenian relations beginning with the 15th
Century up until The Present the original of which was first
published in Beirut and later in Stockholm. The book was tried and
banned. ‘The same publisher in 1994 published Western Armenia and
Genocide by Kurdish researcher K.Kalman. The book was also tried and
banned. In 1996 a book published by Ahmet Onal was banned: The novel
Longing/Garod written by Hracya Kocar who had been exiled during the
Stalinist rule in the Soviet Union, had its second edition banned,
because of the cover.

Despite the removal of article 142 from the Turkish Penal Code the
State Security Courts began using article 8 of the Struggle on Terror
Law and the Penal Codes 321st article in place of it, essentially
employing these alterations for the same purposes as before.

In accordance with changes taking place since the 2004 reforms for EU
membership the 8th article of the Struggle on Terror Law has been
dropped and the 312th article of the TPC has been `softened’. However,
since these changes, cases dealing with the Armenians and Kurds are
now tried under the 7th article of the Struggle on Terror Law and the
old TPC’s 159th article (301st under the new penal code). `Publishing
materials contrary to the national interest of Turkey with the help of
foreign aid’ has been added on to this as a new article, article
305. It is this article that permits for Armenian Genocide
Publications to be prosecuted directly as offenses. So far no
prosecution has made use of this article.

While the 305th article has yet to be employed in such matters, cases
that are taking place frequently prosecute under the law which
prohibits insulting and making accusations against the Turkish State
or its armed forces. In addition to this a special law that came into
effect in 1951 which strives to protect the honor of Ataturk is also
resorted to i.e. Dora Sakaryan’s and George Jerjian’s cases in 2005.
Journalists who have made a point of discussing this kind of trials
have found themselves in court houses being charged with `attempting
to affect the Turkish Justice System’. Even the Administrative Court
System has been included in trying to prevent the Armenian Genocide
from being discussed in the Turkish Universities. This demonstrates
just what kind of a political and ideological tool the legal system is
becoming.

WHY IT WAS NECESSARY TO DISCUSS THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE IN 1993

With the threat of genocides in Bosnia and Yugoslavia and with the
Kurdish problem not making any progress, with the process of a forced
migration being reinstated we feel that it was time to once again to
begin discussing the Armenian Genocide. Over the course of two years
we worked on Yves Ternon’s ` History of The Armenian Genocide’ and
published it in 1993 under the title `The Armenian Taboo’. The Rwanda
genocide which was taking place at the time only confirmed our fears
that history would have to be faced sooner or later.

The same year Taner Akcam as part of the civil liberties and rights
search, though not settling for the term `Genocide’, concentrated his
studies of the tradition of the oppressive Turkish State around the
Armenian question and published his first book relating to the matter
under the title `The Armenian Problem and Turkish Identity’.

While the Ternon case continued in order to solidify our position and
to broaden our argument we published a translation of Professor Vahakn
N. Dadrian’s `Genocide According to International and National Law:
The Armenian Example’ published by Yale University. This book too was
immediately banned and a case was set up against it. While the Ternon
case resulted in conviction and a two year prison sentence, the
Dadrian case was dismissed and this in turn opened the door for
further study of the matter. Because of the importance that rests on
the shoulders of these two cases for having paved the way for further
discussion of the Armenian Genocide we will talk about them in greater
detail later on.

Yves Ternon’s Case, the Accusation, the Defense and the Conviction

In November of 1993 we had given the following reason for publishing
Ternon’ s `The Armenian Taboo’: `The Turkish public knows of only one
story when it comes to the Armenian issue and that is the official
position the government has taken. What is the other side of the
story? This was never found out by the Turkish public. The prevention
of future problems such as international hardships, more genocides and
new dangers is only achievable through facing our own history in a
bold manner. It seems unlikely that any Turkish Prime minister will
ever kneel before a genocide memorial the way German Prime minister
Willy Brand did. But they must.’
In order to prevent discussion of the Armenian Genocide the first law
that was put into action was the law concerning the struggle against
terror and more specifically its 8th article. Therefore, Ayse Nur
Zarakolu was tried as a ` perpetrator of terror’ at the 4 State
Security Court 4th in Istanbul. While the book on the Armenian
Genocide was being prosecuted in Istanbul, in Paris, Historian Bernard
Lewis was being prosecuted for arguing in one of his articles for Le
Monde the inapplicability of the term `Genocide’ for the Armenian
issue. The case against Lewis had been brought on by Yves Ternon and
the Armenian community. These two cases, which concentrated on the
acceptance and the denial of the Armenian Genocide, affected each
other and both resulted in convictions. Lewis was sentenced to pay a
symbolic one Franc compensation in Paris, while Ayse Nur Zarakolu was
sentenced to two years in prison along with a 250 million Lira
fine. The prosecutor instead of grounding his charges in the 312th
article of the TPC decided to prosecute under the struggle against
terror law. Turkish media focused its attention mainly on the Lewis
case in Paris and therefore paid little attention to the Ternon case
in Istanbul, this resulted in no discussion taking place at all
amongst the Turkish public concerning the Armenian Genocide.
On December 4th 1994 the publishing house was bombed and in the case
which was held shortly after the Government was on the losing side. It
has been 12 years and the case still has not been recognized by the
Court of Appeals.

The Prosecutions primary argument:

It was argued that the book `on 29 separate occasions claimed that at
various times genocide had been committed against the Armenians, and
it did so in a manner that openly provoked hostility amongst citizens
based on racial differences. It labeled certain regions of the
Republic of Turkey, Kurdistan and Turkish Armenia which is an argument
in favor of the divisibility between the countries people and its
lands.’

Publisher Ms. A. N. Zarakolu’s Defense:

`As I stated from the very beginning, I am a human rights activists
and it because of my beliefs as a human rights activist that I am
opposed to all types of genocide. The only way of preventing genocide
today is by unearthing past ones and discussing them.’

The Decision:

`While the book, which goes on to discuss the Ottoman Empires role in
subjecting the Armenians to genocide and the massacres committed by
the Kemalists during the Turkish independence movement, claims in 29
separate pages the occurrence of an `Armenian Genocide’ it is noted
that the borders which are said to belong to Armenia overlap with
regions claimed by the PKK to be Kurdistan’ the decision then
continues as follows:
`The book is accurate in so far as the Armenian people living under
the Ottoman Empire were over the course of history harassed, had their
villages plumaged, and were killed by the Empires Kurdish subjects
living in the same region. However, the portrayal of these two groups
as currently friendly with one another, as two suffering nations,
reflects a future interest in the sharing of lands.’

A book which studied a period of history 80 years ago was being
convicted for its involvement with a contemporary issue, the Kurdish
issue. The decision which is full of all sorts of conspiracies
continues like this:
`From the books entirety it is understood that the requests of these
two ethnic groups, both of which have never been able to achieve
statehood, include territories of the Republic of Turkey. It is agreed
that the defendant, therefore, has argued in favor of the idea of
divisibility in relation to future times. The map in this book matches
the map drawn by the PKK, and the victimization of both these groups
is discussed at length. It is understood by these stated facts that
the book is arguing in favor of the division of Anatolian territories
into two separate states by the afore mentioned two groups. The State
Security Court despite understanding the reasons for the books
publication, which were stated to be `facing history and preventing
future genocides’, chose to ignore this. Instead, choosing to
fabricate certain theories which have nothing to so with the contents
of the book in question, they decided to convict based on
fabrications. In 1997, twenty years after the publication of the books
original edition in French, this conviction was approved by the
Supreme Court of Appeals.***

** Because the court recognized ANZ as the author of the book she was
given the maximum sentence. They noted that Dr. Ternon was `some
unidentifiable person who was narrow minded and full of hate.’ Once
information concerning Dr. Ternon’s status as a researcher and
scholar, who at the time was delivering a paper on the Rwanda genocide
in Paris, was established the Court of Appeals asked that her sentence
be reduced to six months as the publisher of the book not the
author. The court agreed to this only not changing their minds about
the following: they stated that `considering the defendants past and
her tendency to commit such offenses it is believed that with the
reduction of the sentence will not prevent her from committing future
offenses.’

***The following Press Statement was released by Belge Publishing on
the 27th of April 1997 as a response to the decision:

`This decision is not based on any judicial truth. The reasons they
have given are purely stereotypical. The only thing that is accurate
about the conviction is that the term `Western Armenia’ is mentioned
in the book. According to the court this same region is claimed by
the PKK to be a Kurdish region and therefore this book in some way
serves their cause. This decision is perhaps the strangest one ever to
be issued. Because of the ambiguity concerning the language that was
used in the statement we wonder whether or not the committee
responsible for reading and analyzing the book even did so. It has
even led us to believe that perhaps the case was confused with another
one! The statement mentions certain things that have nothing to with
the contents of the book. They argue that this book, which was written
in 1977 by a French researcher, serves the PKK’s cause. The PKK was
founded in 1978 which would make Dr. Ternon one of the world’s
foremost prognosticators! He discovered a separatist group before it
had actually formed and had devised certain evil plans for Turkey
through them! This scenario can only be described as paranoia. The
map in the book is said to overlap with a map drawn by the PKK. If
that is the case where is this map that was drawn by the PKK!? What
does the PKK have anything to do with the issue at hand anyway!? In
fact there is no map in the book. In all honesty this is an
embarrassment for the legal process. We believe that it will suffice
to say that Dr. Ternon’s book is a study of a specific historical and
tragic period in time and that its sole purpose is to aid in the
prevention of future tragedies by allowing for honest and open
discussion of history.’

THE IMPORTANCE OF VAHAKN N. DADRIAN’S 1995 ACQUITTAL

The acquittal of Prof. Dadrian’s book, entitled `Genocide’, on
December 29 1995 by the No: 5 State Security Court of Istanbul was a
decision of historical significance. This caused a significant
increase in awareness and up until the wave of nationalism that came
about as a result EU membership talk in 2005, not a single publication
concerning genocide was prosecuted. We saw this decision as a victory
in our struggle for truth.

After the decision we issued the following statement:

`Despite the courts reasons for the acquittal which were strange and
somewhat offensive, we see this as a step towards forming a bridge
between the two communities in an environment that uses the term
`Armenian’ as an insult, many times by high ranking officials to
degrade their opponents. We see this as a step in the right
direction.’

The decision caused certain political debates. In 2000 the Islamic
press drew attention to the issue by releasing the headline:
`Acquittal for the Armenian, Conviction for the Hoca.’ The reason for
this was because of the convictions that were approved by the Supreme
Court against former Prime Minister Erbakan and Istanbul’s mayor
Tayyip Erdogan. How is it that a book arguing in favor of the genocide
could be acquitted (Akit, Oct. 6, 2000)

The Prime Minister at the time, Bulent Ecevit, sent an official letter
to the Supreme Court asking how such an acquittal could be issued. The
court in its response stated that they did not accept the term
genocide; however, in the TPC there was no article that was applicable
to the case. The prosecution could not argue the 312th article.

Ecevit during this time established a Committee that would be
responsible for Struggle against the Accusations concerning the
so-called Armenian Genocide (CSAAG). As the president of this
committee he appointed Asst. Prime Minister and head of the
Nationalist Movement Party Devlet Bahceli. The Committee would involve
representatives from the General Staff, bureau of Internal Affairs,
bureau of International Affairs, also from the ministry of culture
along side MIT (National Intelligence Agency) and YOK (Council for
University Education) and other representatives who would make a joint
effort against the theory of genocide being committed against the
Armenians.

This development involved reaching out to teacher and other government
employees through out the country, editing text books with the
inclusion of appropriate materials, composition assignments for
students about the Armenian genocide, symposiums at universities
concerning the issue. And anti-Genocide studies would be supported.

During the same period the new draft for the TPC including drafts of
the 301st and 305th articles were penned in a manner that aided this
campaign. Erdogan and his cabinet have not altered these changes to
cause a significant effect.

ANALYSIS OF THE DADRIAN CASE’S DECISION:

The Dadrian acquittal is also interesting as it serves as an outline
of the official denialist view on the Genocide. The Supreme Court paid
special attention to the denial of the Genocide in its acquittal
statement.

`The claim that at various times through out the 17th, 18th and 19th
centuries (?) Genocide was committed against the Ottoman Empires
subjects in the Caucuses is a well known Armenian accusation. Because
this accusation is known by both Turks and Armenians it carries no
legitimacy as a new development. The author has written this work with
a very narrow frame of mind not making room for any opposing or
comparative views and has endeavored to document it.
During wars with large states a certain Nationalistic sentiment came
about and the Empires Armenian subjects were affected by this. As a
result of outside influences by neighboring states the Armenians
actively jeopardized the safety of Ottoman forces, disrupted life for
the local people and attempted to kill many of them in the process.
Faced with these conditions the Ottoman government was forced to make
certain decisions to try and stop these acts. The relocation of the
Armenians to the Eastern regions of the Empire was a seen as a
solution; however, certain losses were suffered in the process. The
term genocide is not applicable to the losses that were suffered nor
is it possible to hold the Turkish people responsible for what
happened during the relocation.

In addition to this it is noted that there is not a significant amount
of the aforementioned people to incite. According to the TPC’s 312t h
Article the crime must endeavor to incite a large group of citizens.

Because of these reasons stated the book must not be taken
seriously. In addition to this because of the lack of scientific
comparison it is not possible to qualify this book as scholarly in
nature.

Despite distorting historical facts the book does not satisfy the
conditions set forth by the TPC’s 2nd article which states that a work
must, in order for the article to apply, try to `incite the public
based on racial, religious and regional differences.’ Therefore it
cannot be convicted.

Out of the 5 presiding judges two were opposed to the acquittal and
their reasons for the opposition are as follows:

`When considering the book in question it was recognized to be a study
that was not scholarly in nature and presented a single view point
which was limited. From the book the following claim appears to be
made `that Armenian’s in Anatolia were systematically massacred in a
genocide committed by the Ottoman Turks and the reasons for the
Ottomans denying it are that they plan on committing such crimes again
in the future and this has resulted in the emergence of a dangerous
situation for Armenian citizens in the country.’ This is a one sided
argument that has been embellished and it does satisfy the conditions
set forth by the 312th Article’s last condition trying to `incite the
public based on racial, religious and regional differences.’ Because
of this we do not agree with the opinion of the other judges in this
matter.

In a way the accused in this case, the publisher, became the plaintiff
and the court was left to defend itself.

As Ms. A. N. Zarakolu said once, `It is our belief as publishers, that
such discussions do not belong in the courtroom, but should rather be
the subject of articles, reviews, books and conferences’.

Turkey’s Killing Fields

Turkey’s Killing Fields
By GARY J. BASS

New York Times Book Review
December 17, 2006

A SHAMEFUL ACT
The Armenian Genocide and the Question of Turkish Responsibility.
By Taner Akcam. Translated by Paul Bessemer.
483 pp. Metropolitan Books/Henry Holt & Company. $30.

In July 1915, the American ambassador to the Ottoman Empire sent Washington
a harrowing report about the Turks’ `systematic attempt to uproot peaceful
Armenian populations.’ He described `terrible tortures, wholesale expulsions
and deportations from one end of the Empire to the other accompanied by
frequent instances of rape, pillage and murder, turning into massacre.’ A
month later, the ambassador, Henry Morgenthau – the grandfather of the
Manhattan district attorney, Robert M. Morgenthau – warned of an `attempt to
exterminate a race.’

The Young Turk nationalist campaign against the empire’s Armenian subjects
was far too enormous to be ignored at the time. But decades of
government-backed denial have created what amounts to a taboo in Turkey
today. Instead of admitting genocide, Turkish officials contend the
Armenians were a dangerous fifth column that colluded with Russia in World
War I; many Armenians may have died, they say, but there was no organized
slaughter. Turkish writers who challenge this line, like the novelists Orhan
Pamuk and Elif Shafak, have risked prosecution for insulting Turkish
identity. And on the diplomatic front, when Turkey should be polishing its
credentials for eventual European Union membership, it is mired in
historical fights; this May, for instance, it pulled out of a NATO military
exercise to protest the Canadian prime minister’s acknowledgment of the
genocide.

`A Shameful Act: The Armenian Genocide and the Question of Turkish
Responsibility,’ by Taner Akcam, is a Turkish blast against this national
denial. A historian and former leftist activist now teaching at the Center
for Holocaust and Genocide Studies at the University of Minnesota, Akcam is
often described as the first Turkish scholar to call the massacres genocide,
and his impressive achievement here is to shine fresh light on exactly why
and how the Ottoman Empire deported and slaughtered the Armenians. He
directly challenges the doubters back home, basing his powerful book on
Turkish sources in the old Ottoman script – including the failed Ottoman war
crimes tribunals held after World War I. Although he bolsters his case with
material from the American, British and German archives, he writes that the
remaining Ottoman records are enough to show that the ruling party’s central
committee `did deliberately attempt to destroy the Armenian population.’

Akcam closely links the 1915 genocide with World War I. The Unionists, as
the nationalist leaders were known, dreaded the partition of their empire by
the European great powers. Not only did they suspect the Armenians of
dangerous disloyalty, Akcam writes, but massacres of Muslims in Christian
regions of the faltering empire before World War I had fostered a desire for
vengeance.

While never excusing the atrocities, Akcam does argue that the Turkish
leaders chose genocide in a mood of stark desperation. Staggered by a series
of early military defeats, and by the Allied onslaught at Gallipoli, they
fully expected their empire – driven out of so much of its vast territories
over the past two centuries – to collapse. The Turkish heartland of Anatolia
was threatened – as was Constantinople.

The fiercest Ottoman enemy was Russia, which had nearly seized
Constantinople in a bloody 1877-78 war and had a storied history of trying
to foment uprisings against Ottoman rule. The Turkish nationalist line puts
great weight on the internal menace of pro-Russian Armenians. But Akcam
argues that there was little real danger from the Armenian uprisings, which
were limited and directed mostly against the deportations. (British
officials considered the Armenians militarily useless and thus refused to
encourage the uprisings.) Akcam allows that the evacuation of Armenians may
have been justified by military necessity in areas where the Armenian
revolutionaries were strong – but not throughout the empire.

The killings were a colossal undertaking. Paramilitaries and Interior
Ministry gendarmes slaughtered Armenians en masse, while the Interior
Ministry under Talat Pasha, who coordinated the campaign, arranged for the
deportation of untold thousands more to the blazing Syrian deserts. Many of
the deportees were massacred along the way, and those who survived were left
without food, shelter or medicine, in what Akcam calls `deliberate
extermination.’ Akcam cites Ottoman Interior Ministry papers that chillingly
call for keeping Armenians to less than 5 or 10 percent of the population. A
postwar Turkish investigation found that some 800,000 Armenians perished.

After the war, Britain pressured the defeated Ottoman government into
setting up its own war crimes tribunals. Mustafa Kemal Ataturk himself, the
founder of the present Turkish republic, once said that the Unionist leaders
`should have been brought to account for the lives of millions of our
Christian subjects ruthlessly driven en masse from their homes and
massacred.’ Today, those who deny the genocide have to dismiss these trial
records as mere victor’s justice. Akcam uses the records as important
evidence, though he frowns on Britain’s imperialist ambitions and cultural
biases.

This dense, measured and footnote-heavy book poses a stern challenge to
modern Turkish polemicists, and if there is any response to be made, it can
be done only with additional primary research in the archival records. In
1919, a British general hoped the Ottoman war crimes trials would `dispel
the fog of illusions prevailing throughout the country.’ Eighty-seven years
later, the murk still lingers.

Gary J. Bass, the author of `Stay the Hand of Vengeance: The Politics of War
Crimes Tribunals,’ is writing a book on humanitarian intervention.

Copyright 2006 The New York Times Company