Russia Stance on Karabakh Referendum Expressed in OSCE MG Statement

PanARMENIAN.Net

Russia’s Stance on Karabakh Referendum Expressed in OSCE MG Statement
16.12.2006 15:12 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Russia’s stance on the Constitutional referendum in
Nagorno Karabakh found its reflection in the statement, which also was
signed by Yuri Merzlyakov, Russian Co-Chair of OSCE Minsk Group,
stated in Baku Vasili Istratov , the Russian Ambassador in the Azeri
Republic. `I am not sure that the referendum in Nagorno Karabakh will
have positive impact on the Nagorno Karabakh conflict settlement,’
underlined Istratov, reports Analitika.az

Gyumri American Corner, in Partnership with US Emb, Launches Website

EMBASSY OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
1 AMERICAN AVENUE
YEREVAN, ARMENIA
TELEPHONE (+374 10) 464700
FAX (+374 10) 464742
E-MAIL: [email protected]

December 15, 2006
Gyumri American Corner, in Partnership with U.S. Embassy, Launches Website
On December 15, the Gyumri American Corner, in partnership with the U.S.
Embassy in Armenia, launched its first website:
The bilingual English-Armenian webpage
provides information about the American Corner’s mission, services, and
upcoming events. It also includes an electronic database of the resources
available at the American Corners in Armenia, allowing patrons to search for
materials on the web.
American Corners are small American-style libraries located throughout the
world that help increase mutual understanding between the United States and
the host country. A network of over 360 American Corners is operating
globally through partnerships between the U.S. Department of State and local
host organizations. American Corners provide information about America in a
variety of formats, including reference books, works of fiction, journals,
and videos. These resources focus on such topics as studying in the United
States, American society, U.S. history, conducting business in the United
States, and English as a Second Language. The Corners also provide computers
with Internet access, and offer a variety of public programs including
speakers and workshops. The American Corners are open to the general public
and access is free of charge.
There are currently two American Corners in Armenia–one in the Gyumri
Branch of the Armenian Center for Scientific and Technological Information,
and one in Yerevan City Central Library. The U.S. Embassy hopes to open
additional Corners in Armenia in the future. American Corner Gyumri
officially opened on June 28, 2005. This Corner currently houses four
computers with Internet access and over 500 books. The Corner also holds a
variety of public events, including movie showings, presentations by
Armenians who have lived or studied in the United States as part of the
"Armenian at the American Corner" series, and lectures by an American every
third Wednesday of the month as part of the "American at the American
Corner" series.
For more information, please visit

http://www.americancorners.am.
http://gyumri.americancorners.am.

National Revival Party Leader Will Not Run in Parl. Elections 2007

NATIONAL REVIVAL PARTY LEADER WILL NOT RUN IN PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS 2007

Yerevan, December 15. ArmInfo. The leader of the National Revival
party, MP Albert Bazeyan will most probably not run in the
parliamentary elections 2007.

To remind, formerly Bazeyan was mayor of Yerevan and the leader of the
Republic party, which he left because of conflict with Aram Sargsyan.

In an interview to Haykakan Zhamanak Bazeyan says that he may dissolve
is party. Everything is possible if the opposition fails to
unite. Bazeyan says that his party is not going to take part in
half-way measures like Anti-Criminal Movement. "Somebody says some
stupidity and then asks to support it. We are not going to take part
in stupid things," says Bazeyan.

European Regional Academy Fund Applies to Appeal Court

EUROPEAN REGIONAL ACADEMY FUND APPLIES TO APPEAL COURT AGAINST
DECISION OF FIRST INSTANCE COURT

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 16, NOYAN TAPAN. The European Regional Academy Fund
on December 14 applied to the RA Court of Appeal against the December
1 decision of the court of first instance, which satisfied the lawsuit
of the RA Ministry of Education and Science. The academy rector,
member of the Orinats Yerkir Party Victor Martirosian told NT
correspondent about it. To recap, the RA Ministry of Education and
Science applied to the court, contesting the legality of the current
board of the academy and the legality of election of the board rector.
The ministry considers the grounds for the academy’s creation as
false.

The minister Levon Mkrtchian said at a recent press conference that
all the foreign organizations presented as members of the academy’s
founding board have denied this fact. According to V. Martirosian, the
further stepts of the academy will depend on the decision of the RA
Court of Appeal. "I look at all this with a smile and I am sure
justice will triumph," he noted.

Trainings of heads of staffs of NKR defense army divisions

Trainings of heads of staffs of NKR defense army divisions

ArmRadio.am
16.12.2006 14:40

Meeting of heads of staffs of NKR defense army divisions was held in
Nagorno Karabakh, during which reference was made to issues of troops
command.

ArmInfo correspondent informs from Stepanakert that the trainings were
conducted with the application of theoretic and practical
methods. Great attention was paid to the operative and combatant
preparedness. When summing up the results, it was noted that the
preparedness of the staffs is on a proper level.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

NKR: Azerbaijani Side Hampered OSCE Monitoring

AZERBAIJANI SIDE HAMPERED OSCE MONITORING

Azat Artsakh, Republic of Nagorno Karabakh [NKR]
16 Dec 2006

On December 13, in accordance with an arrangement with the governments
of the sides, the OSCE mission was to hold monitoring of the front
line between the armed forces of Nagorno Karabakh and Azerbaijan near
the Karakhanbeyli area, Fizuli. The monitoring mission and the
representatives of the ministries of foreign affairs and defense
arrived at the place of monitoring, however, considering that the
Azerbaijani side, like in the previous cases, did not take the
observers to the agreed place, the OSCE mission members decided to
postpone the monitoring for security.

NKR MFA PRESS SERVICE
16-12-2006

NKR: NKR Ministry of Foreign Affairs Statement

NKR MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS STATEMENT

Azat Artsakh, Republic of Nagorno Karabakh [NKR]
16 Dec 2006

On December 10 the NKR Constitution was adopted by a referendum. The
Ministry of Foreign Affairs is concerned about the attitude of the
international European organizations towards the referendum held in
NKR, who make statements doubting that the people of Nagorno Karabakh
are in the legal sphere. The ministry notes that the referendum set
down the principles of democracy in the basic law of the country and
was another stage in shaping the legislation, and is intended to
promote new, more progressive principles in public administration, as
well as establish a civil society. In this connection, the attempts of
the European organizations, which have adopted democracy and the rule
of law, to neglect and reject the democratic and legislative process
in Nagorno Karabakh appear strange. At the same time, the ministry
believes that the adoption of the Constitution cannot obstruct the
constructive efforts of the international observers to facilitate a
peace settlement of the conflict over Karabakh. The recent statements,
which hint that the referendum on the NKR Constitution will hinder the
talks, imply that by adopting the Constitution of the Republic of
Azerbaijan by a referendum in 1995 and the amendments in 2002 official
Baku intended to obstruct the talks. So why did the European
organizations fail to criticize the policy of Azerbaijan at that time?
Over the past 15 years separate representatives of international
organizations have displayed an inconsistent reaction to similar
procedures in Nagorno-Karabakh Republic and Azerbaijan. The
international community has always had an important role in
influencing the nature of processes in conflict areas. Only the fact
that the international community recognized the outcome of the
referendum on the independence of Azerbaijan in 1991 but refused to
recognize a similar referendum held in Nagorno Karabakh encouraged
Azerbaijan to claim to Karabakh, which resulted in the Azerbaijani
aggression against Nagorno Karabakh. The referendum on the NKR
Constitution cannot determine the outcome of the consultations on the
settlement of the conflict under the aegis of the OSCE Minsk Group.
Moreover, a question occurs whether the permanent stance of Azerbaijan
on territorial integrity, as well as the provision in the Azerbaijani
Constitution that Azerbaijan is a unitary state are not factors which
determine and disrupt the logic of the Minsk process, based on the
right for self-determination along with other principles. The NKR
Ministry of Foreign Affairs hopes that the European organizations will
be guided by the democratic principles they had declared and will
reconsider their biased attitude towards the democratic process in
Nagorno Karabakh. December 13, 2006

16-12-2006

BAKU: Semneby: Parties couldn’t seize chance in 2006 for NK Peace

Azeri Press Agency
Dec 16 2006

Peter Semneby: Parties couldn’t seize chance in 2006 for Nagorno
Karabakh conflict solution

[ 16 Dec. 2006 17:16 ]

`There has been a great opportunity for the settlement of Nagorno
Karabakh conflict. Unfortunately, the parties couldn’t seize this
chance to reach agreement,’ said Peter Semneby, EU Special
Representative for the South Caucasus, APA reports.

Expressing support for the efforts of the OSCE MG in the settlement
of the conflict, Peter Semneby said that he hopes the negotiations
will yield good results.
Touching on the `referendum’ held in Nagorno Karabakh, he said they
don’t recognize the results of that `referendum’ and the EU expressed
its position in its statement.
He said that cooperation between Azerbaijan and EU will further
develop after implementation of the EU/Azerbaijan Action Plan.
Besides, the EU will carry out a project on civil society and freedom
of speech in Azerbaijan next year. /APA/

OSCE’s Chairmanship Yielding to Russia on Istanbul Commitments

OSCE’S CHAIRMANSHIP YIELDING TO RUSSIA ON ISTANBUL COMMITMENTS

Eurasia Daily Monitor

Monday, November 27, 2006 — Volume 3, Issue 218

OSCE’S CHAIR YIELDING TO RUSSIA ON ISTANBUL COMMITMENTS

by Vladimir Socor

With barely ten days remaining until the OSCE’s year-end conference in
Brussels, the draft ministerial declaration (centerpiece of the conference
documents) would weaken the West’s hand and strengthen Moscow’s on the most
salient hard-security issue in Europe: Russia’s 1999 commitments to
withdraw its forces from Georgia and Moldova. Moscow has repeatedly tried to
decouple this issue from the 1999-adapted Treaty on Conventional Forces in
Europe (CFE), so as to bring this treaty into force on the territories of
the three Baltic states and to place the Baltic states under treaty
limitations.

Those commitments, as well as that treaty, were approved as a package
at the OSCE’s Istanbul summit in 1999. Consequently, the NATO and European
Union member countries have taken the position all along that the
Russia-desired ratification of the adapted CFE treaty is `linked with’ (that
is, conditional on) Russia’s complete fulfillment of its Istanbul
Commitments. In 2005-2006 Russia made significant progress toward
withdrawing its forces from the Batumi and Akhalkalaki bases in Georgia on a
timetable running until 2008 — a fact welcomed in the 2006 draft
ministerial declaration. Apart from that promising step, however, Moscow has
continued to breach its 1999 Commitments and CFE treaty principles on
multiple counts during 2006.

The relevant text in the OSCE’s 2006 year-end draft declaration
would — if adopted — loosen the linkage policy, relegate major elements in
Russia’s Istanbul Commitments to oblivion, and bring the adapted CFE treaty’
s ratification much closer. The treaty’s entry into force would in turn
trigger a procedure to extend its applicability to the three Baltic states’
territories and negotiate with Russia about setting limits to any possible
allied deployments there.

Drafted largely by this year’s Belgian chairmanship and reflecting
some of Belgian Minister of Foreign Affairs Karel de Gucht’s publicly stated
views, the OSCE declaration’s relevant text reads:

`We urge State Parties to the CFE Treaty to fulfill the outstanding
commitments undertaken at the 1999 Istanbul Summit. We welcome the
[Russia-Georgia] agreements that have led to substantial progress on the
ground. We call for completion of this process. As regards Moldova, no
progress could be registered in 2006. We call on the Russian Federation and
parties concerned to allow the process of withdrawal of ammunition and
related military personnel to resume expeditiously. We reaffirm our shared
determination to promote the entry into force of the Adapted CFE Treaty’
(OSCE Ministerial Council, Belgian Chairmanship, MC.DD/2306, November 23).

The paragraph on Moldova is phrased in a way that could all but
liquidate the remaining Istanbul Commitments there. It only mentions
withdrawal of ammunition, omitting the troops, although the Istanbul
Commitments require the complete withdrawal of Russian forces, a term that
focuses on the troops. From 2002 to date, the United States and European
allies as well as Moldova have consistently focused on the Russian troops
when calling for fulfillment of Russia’s Istanbul Commitments. Earlier this
year, however, De Gucht repeatedly called for withdrawal of Russian
ammunition only, omitting the troops. And earlier this month, Belgium’s
ambassador to the OSCE in Vienna, Bertrand de Combrugghe, heading a
fact-finding delegation to Chisinau and Tiraspol, similarly declared in both
places that the OSCE sought the withdrawal of ammunition, failing to mention
the troops (Basapress, Infotag, Regnum, November 12-14).

The draft’s reference to `ammunition-related personnel’ is an
innovation to allow Russia’s troops to stay. In the course of that visit to
Transnistria, the OSCE group was told by the Russian command that only about
100 Russian `personnel’ (sotrudniki), not army troops but a `militarized
protection service" (voyennizirovanaya okhrana), are guarding the massive
Russian ammunition stockpile there (Regnum, Infotag, November 13). Thus, it
appears that the ministerial declaration’s drafters would be content to see
just those 100 Russian personnel withdraw along with the ammunition. While
de Combrugghe did mention in Tiraspol the known fact that `one of the sides’
(Chisinau) does not accept the Russian `peacekeeping’ operation, that point
remains academic if the OSCE releases Russia from the Istanbul Commitments
on troop withdrawal.

The document calls on Russia "and parties concerned to allow’
ammunition withdrawal to proceed, the other "parties" being Tiraspol. This
is a further innovation to provide excuses for Moscow. Responsibility for
the unlawful stationing of Russian forces in Moldova has all along been
Russia’s liability and no one else’s. The Istanbul Commitments also hold
Russia alone liable for the unconditional withdrawal of its forces. However,
Moscow has attempted to offload those responsibilities onto other `parties,’
thereby dividing its own political liability and setting third-party
preconditions to fulfilling what are Moscow’s unconditional obligations. In
the last few years, Moscow has falsely claimed that Tiraspol’s authorities
`do not allow’ Moscow to withdraw the ammunition, let alone the troops.
Occasionally, Moscow has also alleged difficulties with Moldovan railroads
and rolling stock or Ukrainian safety concerns about the transport of old
and dangerous ammunition. However, the Tiraspol authorities (its appointees)
provide Moscow with the main alibi for blocking the troop withdrawal. The
OSCE’s draft declaration plays along with Moscow’s tactics by asking unnamed
other parties to unblock Russia’s withdrawal.

In its finely nuanced, trademark OSCE phrasing, the document calls for
the ammunition withdrawal merely to `resume," as an open-ended `process,’
rather than asking for it to be completed within a certain timeline. With
Russia having breached several actual deadlines in succession, the OSCE at
its year-end 2003 Maastricht conference gave up setting any deadlines or
timelines, realizing that Russia’s persistent noncompliance was exposing the
organization’s ineffectiveness.

The document’s pledge to promote the adapted CFE treaty’s ratification
is not accompanied by a conditional clause that would have referenced a
linkage with Russia’s Istanbul Commitments. Nor is any reference made to
Moscow’s breaches of both the original 1990 and the 1999-adapted treaties.
The unfulfilled commitments and ongoing treaty breaches include: Russia’s
retention of the Gudauta base in Georgia, which was due for closure in 2001;
deployment of treaty-banned combat hardware with secessionist forces in
Abkhazia, Karabakh, and Transnistria; and stationing of `peacekeeping’ and
other Russian troops in conflict areas without host-country-consent,
although such consent is a central principle of both the existing and the
unratified CFE treaties.

Adopting this section of the OSCE’s ministerial declaration for 2006
in this form could at one stroke erase most of Russia’s outstanding Istanbul
Commitments by the custodial organization itself. Such a development, should
it come to pass, would mark a high point of Russian clout within the OSCE.

–Vladimir Socor

German Public TV screens film criticizing current reality in Azerb.

German Public TV screens a film criticizing the current reality in
Azerbaijan

ArmRadio.am
16.12.2006 13:25

MDR ` the Public Television of Germany ` screened a documentary titled
`The History of Baku,’ where the current reality of Azerbaijan is
severely criticized. According to the Azeri Day.Az., the film
particularly criticizes corruption, poverty, and the terrible
situation in oil wells. Te film pictures Azerbaijan as a backward
state full of corruption. It is said that the journalists who shot the
film were arrested by the Police at the moment they were interviewing
the local residents protesting against the construction of an oil
pipeline. They were asserting that the documents on their agreement to
the construction were forged by local officials. The film met great
reaction in Germany, which seriously damaged Azerbaijan’s reputation.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress