Despite The Chorus Of Pious Hope, Turkey Is Not Going To Join The EU

DESPITE THE CHORUS OF PIOUS HOPE, TURKEY IS NOT GOING TO JOIN THE EU
Geoffrey Wheatcroft

The Guardian , UK
Dec 18 2006

There will be no place at the table for Ankara in any foreseeable
future, and the most profound reason is geographical

Of all the temptations of journalism, prediction is the most
dangerous. Soothsayers in our trade are usually made to look foolish by
events. The best answer was given by the fabled correspondent in some
distant spot who, asked by an importunate foreign desk (in the days
of abbreviated cablese) to file "soonest,fullest,whatnext happens",
responded succinctly: "Myballs uncrystal."

After that, let me say something simply and confidently: Turkey is
not going to join the EU. "Not" does not mean "never" but in any
foreseeable future, although you wouldn’t know that from Tony Blair.

He visited Turkey last Friday at the beginning of his latest forlorn,
not to say fantastical, mission to bring peace to the Middle East,
intoning the words: "It is important that we continue the process of
accession with Turkey."

Nor would you know it from other exalted Euro-personages. Chancellor
Angela Merkel has just joined the Social Democrats, her German
coalition partners, in saying that full membership "would be
worthwhile", one fine day. Erkki Tuomioja, the Finnish foreign
minister, whose country’s EU presidency is just coming to an end,
says that "the door is still open", while Carl Bildt, the foreign
minister, continues ardently to favour Turkish membership.

All these pious hopes are expressed at the very moment negotiations
between Turkey and the EU have just hit one more pothole, with
Brussels suspending talks as a punishment for Ankara’s refusal to
open its ports and airports to Greek Cyprus. This suspension was a
"serious mistake", Blair says, and Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the Turkish
prime minister calls it "unacceptable".

By now the Turks should have learned that there is much they must
accept whether they like it or not, and they have come to feel, not
without reason, that when one obstacle is surmounted Europe will
always find another. Turkey became an associate member of the EEC
or Common Market as long ago as 1963, and in 1987 Ankara applied for
full membership of the EU.

During the lengthy interlude came the Turkish invasion of Cyprus in
1974 and in 1983 the creation of a Turkish Cypriot state, which no
one but Ankara recognises. Turkey has a much better case over Cyprus
than in other matters, and the despicable behaviour of the Greek
Cypriot government – and electorate, when they voted against the
reunification of the island once EU membership could not be revoked –
has made Cyprus the least loved member state of the EU.

More serious objections are the patchy Turkish record (to put it
mildly) on human rights. Turkey still does not enjoy what European
countries consider a true rule of law or freedom of speech, and has
not come to terms with its history, notably the fate of the Armenians.

Even then, the continual European hesitancy and changing of the tune
might suggest bad faith. But that is not really so, and a better way
of seeing it is as a kind of social embarrassment. Far from having
embarked on an elaborate deception, Europe said something with good
intentions but without really thinking it through, only to recognise
slowly how grave the practical difficulties are. As a result, Turkey
waits for church bells that never ring, while Europe, as one French
diplomat puts it, is like a man with a mistress he doesn’t want to
lose, but doesn’t want to marry, either. The trouble is that a moment
passes, after which it’s no longer easy or even possible to say this
thing can work without causing pain.

For their part, the worst mistake the Turks have made is invoking US
support. During yet another crisis between Ankara and Brussels a little
more than a year ago, Erdogan rang Condoleezza Rice and asked for her
help, to which the secretary of state duly responded by expressing yet
again Washington’s ardent support for Turkish admission to the EU –
and thereby further enraging the Europeans.

As usual Blair takes the American line, arguing for Turkish admission
on strategic grounds: it "has an importance not just in respect to
Turkey but with wider relationships between the west and the Muslim
world". Shutting the door will alienate Muslims everywhere, letting
Turkey in will build a bridge between the west and the Islamic world.

But another way of putting it is that Europe is being asked to make
a huge sacrifice to gratify American strategic interests. Whatever
Blair may think, this doesn’t meet with universal favour. As the
former European commissioner Chris Patten has sarcastically said,
it is very good of the Americans to keep offering Turkey admission
to the EU, but this is a question on which Europeans might want to
have some say themselves.

Neither Blair nor his American friends have noticed that there has
scarcely been a less propitious moment for Turkish admission in these
40 years. Turkish sensitivity about being excluded from a "Christian
club" is quite misplaced: Europe today isn’t a Christian anything, and
even fear of radical Islamism is not the main factor. More important
is the hangover from previous EU expansion – and the Turkish question
also illustrates the gulf between "the soi-disant elites", as that
contrarian French politician Jean-Pierre Chevènement calls them,
personified by Blair, Tuomioja and Bildt, and the actual peoples
of Europe.

In May 2004, eastern European countries that had been sundered from
their neighbours by 60 years of war and cold war were admitted to
"our common European home" and very moving it was. After the elation,
Europe woke up to realise that its 10 new member states now comprised
a quarter of its population while providing a 20th of its economic
product, and that’s before Romania and Bulgaria join in the new year,
let alone Turkey, with a per-capita income one-tenth of the British,
and a child mortality rate 10 times the French.

A year later, the French and Dutch referendums, which turned down the
new EU constitution, were a hostile response to that expansion, and
by implication to Turkish admission. For all Blair’s high-sounding
platitudes, that new mood has been caught by other European
politicians. Nicolas Sarkozy, the French interior minister who is
almost certain to be the conservative candidate – and favourite –
in May’s presidential elections, is an open opponent of Turkish
membership, and is "happy to see that these ideas are gaining
ground". As he might say, building bridges between the west and Islam,
and sapping the roots of terrorism, are doubtless worthy objectives,
but since when did they become the purpose of the EU?

In the end, the problem is less cultural or economic or religious than
simply geographical. This is something we have only slowly woken up
to, but it explains why Turkey will not join for a very long time,
if ever. Bildt says, solemnly and dubiously, that "there is no doubt
that Turkey is a part of Europe", but a French politician has put it
another way: can we really have a Europe that extends to the borders
of Iraq? Many ordinary Europeans seem to know the answer to that
better than their rulers.

–Boundary_(ID_AKVHL26DKxC+K4dzkPCO5A)–

Psychology That Is Stronger Than Mind

PSYCHOLOGY THAT IS STRONGER THAN MIND
James Hakobyan

Lragir, Armenia
Dec 18 2006

The diminishing activity of Armenia in the talks over Karabakh had
been expected before the recent interview with Robert Kocharyan when
different officials in Karabakh and Armenia, including the speaker of
the Armenian parliament, started developing the theory of "not a patch
of land". Hence, Robert Kocharyan only summed up these statements. And
these statements were rather interesting. First of all, it is evident
that Armenia’s standpoint contains certain threat.

Robert Kocharyan’s words on avoiding active talks, i.e. signing of an
agreement, was addressed to the opposition, and maybe also the part
of the government who were thinking about coercing Robert Kocharyan
using the agreement and making him accept their rules of the game.

Meanwhile, Robert Kocharyan’s statement contained elements of coercion
which are evidently directed against the mediators in the talks for the
settlement of the Karabakh issue. They are known to have stated several
weeks ago that the Armenian parliamentary election cannot obstruct the
negotiations. In fact, Robert Kocharyan shows that it can obstruct. And
the purpose is clear. By questioning the talks the Armenian president,
in fact, wants to extort guarantees of reproduction of government from
the mediators to have them shut an eye on the quality of the election
in 2007. Therefore, Robert Kocharyan is stating that he will not sign
anything until the election in 2007. At the same time, an atmosphere
of not returning the territories is being created in Armenia to boost
the value of the government who return the territories and convince
the mediators that eventually the reproduction of this government is
the right thing.

However, the intention of the Armenian president has another nuance.

After the recent negotiations the co-chairs and Azerbaijan became
more optimistic, and Mammedyarov even stated that Lachin and the
status are not a reason for disagreement. This shows that Azerbaijan
may have finally adopted a milder standpoint. And the standpoing of
the Armenian side over these years has been based on one thing – the
intolerance of Azerbaijan. Yerevan, which was ready to return these
territories for the sake of a status, perhaps does not have a vision
of bringing this formula into being, but is saying that hopefully
Azerbaijan will never accept it. Hence, the optimism of the mediators
and Azerbaijan allows supposing that Azerbaijan has become milder in
its standpoint. In this case, the Armenian side would have to replace
words with actions, and shift the issue of returning territories
to a more practical level. And it would mean sentencing the present
regime led by Robert Kocharyan without pardon. The regime which is
almighty in all the questions does not have hegemony over the issue
of the territories. All Yerevan can do is coercion. And it means a
new promise. In other words, the mediators approve reproduction but
they stipulate that an agreement must be signed after the election in
2007. In this case, the question occurs what’s the difference when
the "sword" of signing will hang above Robert Kocharyan, after the
election or before the election.

The difference is significant. Kocharyan is rather weak before the
election so that he has to "shout" regularly that everything happens
with his approval to overcome his fear. It is not a secret that the
Armenian opposition expects assistance from the outside without
having an idea what he should do for victory, and when it is not
there, 150 thousand people are sent home. Hence, the election is
vital energy for Robert Kocharyan if he can prevent the West from
interferening. After getting this energy he can carry on the tactics
in the talks over Karabakh used since 1998 for both the inside and the
outside. This is a situational solution and does not seem to contain
any prospects. But the problem is that Robert Kocharyan does not have
opponents who work out and pursue far-reaching problems.

There is competition in situational solutions, and here Robert
Kocharyan has not only a psychological advantage over his opponents,
which makes mental exercise obsolete.

Is Revolution Possible?

IS REVOLUTION POSSIBLE?

Lragir, Armenia
Dec 18 2006

The leader of the Liberal Progressive Party of Armenia Hovanes
Hovanisyan stated December 18 at the Pastark Club that although they
are against major quakes, "there is too much trash in the country
and evolutionary development would take 50 years. Consequently, we
need a movement and a shake-up to clean up this trash. Trash cannot
foster stability." Hovanes Hovanisyan had one impression from Robert
Kocharyan’s recent interview. "He did not say a new thing. He said
they will do everything to hold power."

According to the leader of the LPP, if this logic of the government
persists, the parliament as a political institution will become
obsolete, the end of parliamentarism will come. "The government does
not pursue progress and change in this country, and the principle is
who will give out more. The government is seeking for a miscarriage
of the political thought and removing political struggle from the
political sphere. They do their best to eliminate political dialogue
and ideas." In addition, the electoral campaign started too early,
the entire political sphere was monopolized, the media are crammed
with PR campaigns, "however, these campaigns are not always effective,
very often these campaigns bring evidence against themselves."

According to the LPP leader, the government is waging an internal
struggle and a struggle with the opposition, and the second is not
adequate to the steps of the competitor, "we have no political
opponents, the government responds to our ideals with gossip,
distortion, rejects a political dialogue, acts boyishly in this
process." If the government carries out this policy successfully,
it will eventually reach the degradation of the society, the society
will become a dull, castrated mass unable to make any decisions. At
the same time, Hovanes Hovanisyan does not exclude that electoral
fraud in 2007 will make the society rise, "and a process may start
which is called a revolution."

Hovanes Hovanisyan denounces only the Republican Party. According to
him, the Republican Party gave no new ideas to the Armenian nation in
the 21st century except the ideas of Garegin Nezhdeh. But the ideas
of Nezhdeh are formal for the Republicans. Moreover, in connection
with shaping the structure of the parliament in 2007 by government’s
scenario Hovanes Hovanisyan said, "the Republican Party has become
an errand political party. There are people who have not uttered a
word at the National Assembly over the past decade but are likely to
run for parliament." By the way, Hovanes Hovanisyan thinks that no
one in Armenia can mention a definite rating of one political party
or another because "the elections have been falsified since 1995."

New Statement On Arrest Of Sefilyan And Malkhasyan

NEW STATEMENT ON ARREST OF SEFILYAN AND MALKHASYAN

Lragir, Armenia
Dec 18 2006

The arrest of Jirair Sefilyan and Vardan Malkhasyan cannot be
considered as the start of persecutions before the election. The
reason is that the persecutions started when the Bolshevists were
in power, and continue in independent Armenia. Paruir Hairikyan,
the leader of the National Self-Determination Union, described the
arrest of Sefilyan and Malkhasyan on December 18 at the Friday Club.

According to him, the government is afraid of polarization and took
this step to prevent the danger that threatened it. Even if we admit
that Jirair Sefilyan made an appeal for a coup, the punishment is
a fine, not arrest and charges, Paruir Hairikyan says. He disagrees
with Member of Parliament Manuk Gasparyan that Sefilyan was arrested
in connection with the problem of Akhalkalaki. Hairikyan says it is
an opinion which has the right to exist, but he thinks that Sefilyan’s
arrest is related to home problems.

Paruir Hairikyan also informed that the anti-criminal movement is
preparing a new statement on the arrest of Jirair Sefilyan and Vardan
Malkasyan, which runs that the government arrested Sefilyan to flatter
the West, namely the forces who support an agreement on settlement
of the Karabakh conflict to show that there are militaristic forces
in Armenia which may try to obstruct a peace settlement. Hence,
according to the new statement of the anti-criminal movement, the
government is trying to aggravate the situation and gain the support
of the West for reelection by means of manipulation.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Peter Semneby: The Reaction Of International Structures Not Directed

PETER SEMNEBY: THE REACTION OF INTERNATIONAL STRUCTURES NOT DIRECTED AGAINST DEMOCRATIC PROCESSES

ArmRadio.am
18.12.2006 11:34

One should not conceive the reaction of international structures to the
Constitutional referendum in Nagorno Karabakh as a negative reaction
towards democratization processes, EU Special Envoy for the South
Caucasus Peter Semneby told the journalists after the meeting with
the President of Nagorno Karabakh in the NKR Permanent Representation
in Yerevan.

"We recognize that there is a high level of democratic culture
in Nagorno Karabakh, and it is positive. As for the referendum, it
includes other questions of principle, which we cannot agree to, since
it predicts the questions due to be resolved during the negotiations,
including the issue of the status of Nagorno Karabakh," Semneby noted.

Peter Semneby: The Right For Self-Determination Should One Of The Ba

PETER SEMNEBY: THE RIGHT FOR SELF-DETERMINATION SHOULD ONE OF THE BASIC PRINCIPLES

ArmRadio.am
18.12.2006 11:46

The right for self-determination of peoples is one of the principles
that should be basic for the settlement of the Karabakh issue and
other conflicts, EU Special Envoy for the South Caucasus Peter Semneby
told the journalists after the meeting with the President of Nagorno
Karabakh in the NKR Permanent Representation in Yerevan.

At the same time he underlined that it is not the only principle,
referring to the Helsinki Final Act, which includes also
other principles, among which is the territorial integrity of
states. "However, the principle you mentioned should be one of the
basis ones," Peter Semneby added.

Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian Visited Iran

FOREIGN MINISTER VARTAN OSKANIAN VISITED IRAN

ArmRadio.am
18.12.2006 12:21

At the Invitation of the Iranian Foreign Minister Manouchehr Mottaki
December 17 the delegation headed by RA Foreign Minister Vartan
Oskanian was in the Islamic Republic of Iran.

The Foreign Ministers of the two countries noted with appreciation
that the bilateral agreements have been consistently accomplished
after President Robert Kocharyan’s visit to Iran in July.

The interlocutors discussed a broad circle of bilateral and regional
issues, appreciating the active development of relations, the bilateral
contacts on different levels.

Attaching importance to the activity of the intergovernmental
commission, the interlocutors turned to the existing trade and economic
relations. It was noted that the diverse cooperation between Armenian
and Iran stems not only from the interests of the two countries,
but also benefits the region as a whole.

The Ministers also turned to regional problems, exchanging views on
the developments in Iraq, Afghanistan and the Middle East. Minister
Oskanian presented the latest developments in the talks on the Karabakh
conflict settlement.

Vartan Oskanian was receied also by the Presidnet of Iran Mahmoud
Ahmadinejad. Highly assessing the cooperation between Armenia and Iran,
issues related to the bilateral agenda were discussed.

During Minister Oskanian’s meeting with the Secretary of the Supreme
Council of National Security Ali Larijani the latter presented the
latest developments in international organizations connected with
the nuclear programs of Iran, emphasizing the right of the Islamic
Republic of Iran to use nuclear energy for peaceful objectives. At
the request of Ali Larijani, Minister Oskanian presented the current
stage of the talks on Nagorno Karabakh.

Vartan Oskanian met also with the Iranian Armenian delegation of the
Armenian-Diaspora Third Forum and representatives of the Armenian
community.

Arkady Ghukasyan: Solution Impossible Without Karabakh’s Involvement

ARKADY GHUKASYAN: SOLUTION IMPOSSIBLE WITHOUT KARABAKH’S INVOLVEMENT

ArmRadio.am
18.12.2006 13:02

Settlement of the Karabakh conflict is impossible without the
participation of Nagorno Karabakh, NKR President Arkady Ghukasyan told
the journalists yesterday. "I do believe that the negotiation process
is necessary, the contacts should continue. The meetings between
Armenian and Azerbaijani leaders are also important. However, I want
to repeat the formula which I have been talking about many times: the
solution of the question is impossible without Nagorno Karabakh. No
matter how much Armenia and Azerbaijan negotiate, the participation
of Nagorno Karabakh is necessary. There is simply no other way,"
Arkady Ghukasyan underlined. He added that this has peen emphasized
also by the leadership of Armenia and the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs.

Turkish MFA Dissatisfied With The Argentinean Law On The Armenian Ge

TURKISH MFA DISSATISFIED WITH THE ARGENTINEAN LAW ON THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE

ArmRadio.am
18.12.2006 14:00

Turkish MFA has issued a statement, in which it condemns the adoption
of the law on Armenian Genocide during December 13th sitting in
the Argentinean Senate. The statement notes that Turkey condemns
and denies all the groundless accusations from legal and historical
perspectives, Azeri "Trend" agency informs. It is noted that this
decision will damage the bilateral relations and hope is voiced that
the President of Argentina will be reasonable enough not to ratify
the Senate’s decision.

Let us remind that according to the decision of the Argentinean
Parliament, April 24 has been declared "The day for tolerance and
respect between peoples" and a day off for Armenian students and
workers.

Armenian President’s Statement Causes The Irritation Of Baku

ARMENIAN PRESIDENT’S STATEMENT CAUSES THE IRRITATION OF BAKU

ArmRadio.am
18.12.2006 17:45

Baku has assessed the recent statement by Ra president Robert Kocharyan
on the negotiation process on the Karabakh conflict settlement as "the
intention of the Armenian side to use the issue for its own interests."

"This statement proves once again that the Armenian side is not
sincere," Head of the Foreign Relations Department of the Office to
the Azerbaijani President Novruz Mamedov told the journalists.

"It seems that the Armenian side is trying to save time, and the
Armenian President is willing to have these talks serve his political
interests and is trying to gain points connected with the parliamentary
and presidential elections in Armenia," the representative of the
Azeri President noted.