A.I. Bezzerides, 98; Novelist Became A Screenwriter Known For Film N

A.I. BEZZERIDES, 98; NOVELIST BECAME A SCREENWRITER KNOWN FOR FILM NOIR CLASSICS
By Dennis McLellan, Times Staff Writer

Los Angeles Times, CA
Jan 9 2007

A.I. Bezzerides, a novelist and short-story writer who became a
Hollywood screenwriter best known for the post-World War II film
noir classics "Kiss Me Deadly," "On Dangerous Ground" and "Thieves’
Highway," has died. He was 98.

Bezzerides died Jan. 1 at the Motion Picture & Television Hospital
in Woodland Hills after a brief illness, said his daughter, Zoe Ohl.

Bezzerides was working as a communications engineer for the Los
Angeles Department of Water and Power when his 1938 novel "Long Haul"
was turned into "They Drive by Night," a 1940 melodrama with George
Raft and Humphrey Bogart as struggling trucker brothers hauling
California produce.

It was only after Warner Bros. paid him $2,000 for the rights to his
novel and put him under contract as a $300-a-week screenwriter that
Bezzerides discovered that a script based on his book already had
been written.

"I had no idea whether it was guilt or conscience, or greed to swindle
more stories out of me, for peanuts, that motivated Warner Bros. to
offer me a seven-year contract, with options to be exercised every
six months," Bezzerides wrote in the afterword to the 1997 University
of California Press republication of his 1949 novel "Thieves’ Market."

"Whatever their reason, I grabbed their offer so I could quit my
putrid career as a communications engineer by becoming a writer,
writing scripts in an entirely new world."

Known to his friends as Buzz, Bezzerides’ first film credit was "Juke
Girl," a 1942 story of migrant farmworkers starring Ann Sheridan and
Ronald Reagan.

While under contract to Warner Bros. during World War II, he did
uncredited polishing of the scripts for the 1943 wartime drama
"Action in the North Atlantic," starring Bogart, and for other films.

"There Is a Happy Land," the second of his three novels, was published
in 1942.

After leaving Warner Bros., Bezzerides wrote or co-wrote films such
as "Beneath the 12-Mile Reef," "Desert Fury," "Sirocco" and "Track
of the Cat."

He segued into television in the 1950s, writing for such series as
"Bonanza," "DuPont Theater," "Rawhide," "77 Sunset Strip" and "The
Virginian."

He also was the co-creator of "The Big Valley," the popular 1960s
western series starring Barbara Stanwyck.

To film buffs, Bezzerides was best known for "Thieves’ Highway,"
director Jules Dassin’s thriller based on Bezzerides’ 1949 novel;
"On Dangerous Ground," Nicholas Ray’s 1952 crime drama; and "Kiss Me
Deadly," Robert Aldrich’s 1955 crime thriller loosely based on the
Mickey Spillane novel.

"Buzz was more of a pivotal figure in the development of American
film noir than he has been given credit for," said writer-publisher
Garrett White, who interviewed Bezzerides for the foreword White
wrote for the reprint of "Thieves’ Market."

In an interview with White, Bezzerides said Aldrich called him shortly
before he died in 1983.

"He wanted to tell me that he had just reread my script for ‘Kiss Me
Deadly,’ " Bezzerides recalled. When he asked why, Aldrich told him,
"I wanted to see how I could’ve shot it in three weeks. You know
what? It was all there" in the script.

White said a common thread runs through all of Bezzerides’ work, "and
that has to do with his constant meditation on human – and particularly
male – destructiveness. He thought long and hard about why people
do what they do to nature, to each other and to themselves. Hence,
he was able to write about violence, which is often key to the crime
stories that film noir tended to revolve around."

White, who knew Bezzerides for 20 years, said that "for all of his
toughness and for writing about the dark side of human nature, he
was simply one of the most gentle, big-hearted and generous people
I’ve ever known. He gave away a lot of his money trying to help drug
addicts and just people in need."

During his time at Warner Bros., Bezzerides was a close friend with
another contract writer at the studio: William Faulkner.

"Faulkner actually stayed with Buzz and his first wife [Yvonne]
in Brentwood from time to time," White said.

He said Bezzerides is quoted "in most of the Faulkner biographies,"
and he wrote the documentary "William Faulkner: A Life on Paper,"
which aired on PBS in the late 1970s.

The son of an Armenian mother and a Turkish-speaking Greek father,
Albert Isaac Bezzerides was born Aug. 9, 1908, in Samsun, Turkey. He
moved to America with his parents before he was 2, and they settled
in Fresno, where his father worked in the fields before becoming a
produce-hauling trucker.

Bezzerides, who grew up with young William Saroyan, began writing
short stories while studying at UC Berkeley. His first published story,
"Passage Into Eternity," appeared in a 1935 issue of Story magazine.

Three of his Fresno-set short stories from the 1930s will appear in
the anthology "Forgotten Bread: Armenian American Writers of the First
Generation," to be published in the fall by Heyday Books in Berkeley.

Bezzerides was the subject of two recent documentaries, "The Long
Haul of A.I. Bezzerides" (2005) and "Buzz" (2006).

A longtime Woodland Hills resident whose first marriage ended in
divorce, Bezzerides was married to film and television writer Silvia
Richards until her death in 1999.

In addition to his daughter Zoe, he is survived by a son, Peter;
daughter Rachel Morgan; a granddaughter; and four great-grandchildren.

Support Palestine’s Struggle

SUPPORT PALESTINE’S STRUGGLE

Washington Post
Jan 9 2007

Dear Mr. Ban Ki-moon,

First, allow me to congratulate you on your new post as
secretary-general of the United Nations. I am writing to you from
Syria, a country that co-founded the UN back in 1945. So determined
were the Syrians for the UN to succeed that we sent some of our finest
diplomats to its founding conference, and our late Prime Minister
Faris al-Khury even co-designed its emblem, the same one that is
printed on the UN Flag at your office desk, Mr. Moon. We really
wanted the UN to achieve its declared objectives because this meant
a better life for the Arabs in general, guaranteeing their right to
self-determination after centuries of colonial rule by the French,
the British, and before them, the Ottomans.

We do have serious reservations, however, at how the UN was
administered under your predecessors, and the outright bias it showed
towards both Israel and the United States. We will never forgive–or
forget–the UN for standing by and watching the US invade Iraq in
2003. Washington did not receive clearance from the UN but went on
with the war, caring little for the family of nations that assembled
in San Francisco in 1945 to make the world "safer for democracy." Mr.

Kofi Anan was both unable–and unwilling–to say no to the Americans.

And by no means has the world become "safer for democracy" after the
fiasco in Iraq.

Allow me to quote an open letter, written to your predecessor the late
Dag Hammarskjold when he visited Damascus in 1956. It was published
in a bygone Damascus periodical, called "al-Hadara" (Civilization)
and written by Dr. George Jabbour, a scholar, presidential advisor,
and current parliamentarian, who at the time, was a university student
in Damascus. Addressing Hammarskjold he said: "When you descend from
the airplane with a smile on your face, forgive us if no similar
smile is drawn on our faces." After all, we had welcomed the first
UN secretary-general Trygve Lie to Damascus and our late President
Hashim al-Atasi had decorated him with the Syrian Medal of Honor,
Excellence Class.

The man betrayed us and gave unconditional support for Israel. As
early as 1956, Jabbour wrote that the Arabs in general no longer have
faith in solutions that are imposed on them from an outside power. He
wrapped up saying: "When you leave, it is not a problem if you forget
our wounds and sorrows because we no longer believe in medications that
are not made out of our own hands." Fifty-one years later, Jabbour’s
words are still alarmingly true, although five secretary-generals have
rotated at the UN since 1956, including an Arab, Mr. Boutros Boutros
Ghali. One-by-one we welcomed them to the Middle East, and spilled
out our worries and agitations. And one-by-one we watched them leave,
forgetting both our "wounds and sorrows." We want you to be different
Mr. Moon.

Mr. Secretary-General, there is great injustice in the Middle East.

You started the year 2007 with a new job in New York. We started it
with a massive Israeli raid in Ramallah. Why is it that out of the
65 UN resolutions passed against Israel, not one has been implemented
since 1948? The first was UN Resolution 106 "condemning" Israel for its
raid into Gaza in 1955. The second was UN Resolution 111 "condemning"
Israel for a raid on Syria that "killed 56-people." Must we remind
the world that not a single resolution was ever passed against the
Palestinians. Allow me to make another historical parallel and
refer to an open letter sent by the late Reverend Martin Luther
King, Jr. from his prison cell in Birmingham, Alabama on April 16,
1963. It was in response to a statement made by eight white clergymen
from Alabama who argued that although injustices were taking place
against African-Americans, they should be solved in the courts not
on the streets of the United States. I do not see any difference
between the plight of Africa-Americans in the 1950s and 1960s, and
that of the Palestinians in the Occupied Territories. I will quote
passages from King’s letter, and allow you to play the mental exercise
of replacing the word "Negro" with the word "Palestinian." You will
find the similarities dangerously alarming.

King addressed the clergymen saying: "You warmly commended the
Birmingham police for keeping "order" and "preventing violence." I
doubt that you would have so warmly commended the police force if
you had seen its dogs sinking their teeth into unarmed, nonviolent
Negros. I doubt you would so quickly commend the policemen if you
were to observe their ugly and inhumane treatment of Negros here in
the city jail; if you were to watch them push and curse old Negro
women and young Negro girls." That, Mr. Moon, is what happens every
day in Palestine at checkpoints, in jails, and at border-crossings.

King adds:

For years now, I have heard the word ‘Wait!’ It rings in the ear of
every Negro with piercing familiarity. This ‘Wait’ has almost always
meant ‘Never!’ We must come to see…that justice too long delayed
is justice denied. It is unfortunate that demonstrations are taking
place in Birmingham, but it is even more unfortunate that the city’s
white power structure left the Negro community with no alternative.

That is why the civil rights movement started, he explains, "we had
no alternative except to prepare for direct action, whereby we would
present our very bodies as a means of laying our case before the
conscience of the local and national community." That is also the case
with the Palestinians. Of course their demonstrations are violent–very
violent–unlike the case with King, who was inspired by Ghandi.

The question remains: have the Palestinians achieved anything for
their cause, seven years into the intifada? The answer is no. The
first intifada of the 1980s was by far more successful because it was
nonviolent indeed, symbolized only by small boys throwing stones at
tanks and troops from the IDF. That is why it attracted the world’s
attention–and sympathy, and led to Oslo. But these people are
desperate Mr. Moon. What else except despair would let someone like
Wafa Idris, a 28-year old paramedic with the Palestinian Red Crescent,
blow herself up in Jerusalem on January 28, 2002. She was the first
"woman martyr" of the intifada and inspired another young woman,
Ayat al-Akhras, an 18-year old girl, to kill herself by denoting
a bomb at a supermarket in Jerusalem on March 29, 2002. She killed
two Israelis, one being a 17-year old Israeli girl. She had been a
straight A student, who was going to college to study journalism. She
was engaged to be married in June 2002. When a 18-year old Palestinian
girl kills a 17-year Israeli girl–a conflict that both teens are not
responsible for, then the future itself is dying in the Middle East.

The world says that negotiations are the only solution to the
Arab-Israeli conflict. That is true. The Palestinians will be unable
to destroy Israel. That is a fact. But they can create a situation,
and here again I use the words of King, "that is crisis-packed that
it will inevitably open the door to negotiation."

He adds, "We know through painful experience that freedom is never
voluntarily given by the oppressor; it must be demanded by the
oppressed." The most beautiful part of King’s great letter is the
section I will quote at length, which is filled with parallels to
the plight of the Palestinians. He says:

Perhaps it is easy for those who have never felt the stinging dark
of segregation to say, ‘Wait.’ But when you have seen vicious mobs
lynch your mothers and fathers at will and drown your sisters and
brothers at whim; when you have seen hate-filled policemen curse,
kick, and even kill your black brothers and sisters; when you see
the vast majority of your twenty million Negro brothers smothering
in a airtight cage of poverty in the midst of an affluent society;
when you suddenly find your tongue twisted and your speech stammering
as you seek to explain to your six-year old daughter why she can’t
go to the public amusement park that has just been advertised on
television, and see tears welling up in her eyes when she is told
that Funtown is closed to colored children, and see ominous clouds
of inferiority beginning to form in her little mental sky, and she
her beginning to distort her personality by developing an unconscious
bitterness towards white people, when you have concoct an answer for
a five-year-old son who is asking: "Daddy, why do white people treat
colored people so mean?"; when you are humiliated day and night by
signs reading "white" and "colored," when your first name becomes
"nigger" [in this case ‘Palestinian’], your middle name becomes "boy"
(however old you are)…and your wife and mother are never given the
respected title of "Mrs;" when you are harried by day and haunted by
night by the fact that you are a Negro, living constantly at tiptoe
stance, never quite knowing what to expect next, and are plagued by
inner fears and outer resentments…then you will understand why
we find it difficult to wait. I hope sirs, you can understand our
legitimate and unavoidable impatience.

Mr. Moon, over the past couple of years, the UN’s image has been
severely damaged in the Arab World. It has been perverted, distorted,
and tarnished –perhaps beyond repair — in the eyes of millions of
Arabs. The reasons can be found in Iraq, Lebanon, and Palestine. Very
recently, over 1,000 Lebanese were killed in the summer war of 2006,
and the UN was unable to protect them. Nearly 60,000 Iraqis have died
since 2003. Over 4,300 Palestinians have been killed since 2000, and
the UN stands in similar paralysis. Also, 31,168 have been seriously
wounded while 4,170 homes have been demolished in the Occupied
Territories. The Occupied Territories currently suffer from 30-40%
unemployment, and in Gaza alone it is over 50%. When the intifada
broke out in 2000, the poverty rate was 21%, and by December 2002 it
had increased to 60%. In Gaza, poverty today is estimated at 80%. Due
to terrible conditions, food consumption in the Occupied Territories
has dropped by 25%, and half of the population currently lives off
United Nations aid. Malnutrition among infants is 22%, the highest in
the region, matched only in the Sahara Desert. Since September 29,
2000, a total of 869 Palestinian children have been killed by the
Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). As many as 20,000 Palestinian children
were injured. Over 1,500 suffered life-long disabilities.

Killing is reciprocal, of course, and the number of Israelis killed by
Palestinians during the same period is a total of 1,084 (840 soldiers,
settlers and civilians), including about 123 Israeli children. Nearly
2,500 Israelis children were injured. Their life and safety are — or
should — be dear to all of us, because they bear no responsibility
for this bloody Middle East conflict. Israeli officials, however,
continue to deny that the IDF targets Palestinian children. Amira
Dotan, a spokeswoman for the Israeli Foreign Ministry, once told the
Doha-based al-Jazeera TV: "This sort of thing just doesn’t happen
in Israel." When asked to explain the death of Palestinian children
killed by the IDF since the outbreak of the uprising in 2000, she
said the deaths were "accidental, collateral but not deliberate. Yes,
we knew there were children, but we had to kill the terrorists." The
Israeli journalist Amira Hass once interviewed an Israeli soldier
who confessed that the IDF gives orders to kill Palestinian boys and
girls aged 12 and above. He told her: "Twelve and up, you are allowed
to shoot. That’s what they tell us."

This is the sad Middle East that you will inherit from Kofi Annan,
Mr. Moon. Every single secretary-general since Mr. Lie failed
at bringing law and order to this part of the world, due to our
conflict with Israel. We want you to be different; we need you to be
different. My generation, the third in the Arab-Israeli Conflict, is
tired of bloodshed. Although still in our 30s, we have seen many wars
in our life, starting with Lebanon in 1982, and ending with Lebanon
in 2006. We want justice for the Lebanese, freedom for Iraq, and peace
in the Holy Land. Our cause is just because for too many years we were
wronged by everybody: the Great Powers, Israel, and the United Nations.

Our cause is paralleled only by two other great injustices in the
20th century. One is that of the Armenian genocide under the Ottoman
Empire. The other is that of the Jews in the Holocaust. Both have
been compensated for their misery with states of their own. Left
alone are the Palestinians. The road to peace in the Middle East runs
through Jerusalem first, not Baghdad. Mixed feelings exist in the
Arab world toward Iraq. Some are in favor of the post-Saddam order
and American schemes, while others are overwhelmingly opposed. On the
issue of Palestine, there is more of a consensus among the 200 million
Arabs. The real problem of the Middle East, which the international
community fails to understand is not terrorism, or Osama Bin Laden,
or even Yasser Arafat, who for long was blamed for obstructing peace
with Israel. The real problem has to do with land and freedom for
the Palestinians. Sadly as I write these words the Palestinians are
behaving in a foolish and ignorant manner, killing each other off in
petty rivalries over power.

I beg you to forgive me for such a long and tedious letter. It
certainly has taken up much of your time. I am writing it, however,
while watching the news in Ramallah. And in wrapping up, I will again
quote Dr King, addressing the white clergymen in Alabama: "Never before
have I written so long a letter. I can assure you that it would have
been much shorter if I had been writing from a comfortable desk, but
what else can one do when he is alone in a narrow jail cell, other
than write long letters, think long thoughts and pray long prayers?"

Like Reverend King, the Palestinians have had long thoughts, and long
prayers indeed.

Wishing you a successful tenure at the UN.

Faithfully, Sami Moubayed

Sami Moubayed is a Syrian political analyst, journalist, and author.

Moubayed is the author of "Damascus Between Democracy and Dictatorship
(2000)" and "Steel & Silk: Men and Women Who Shaped Syria 1900-2000
(2006)." He has also authored a biography of Syria’s former President
Shukri al-Quwatli and currently teaches at the Faculty of International
Relations at al-Kalamoun University in Syria. In 2004, he created
Syrianhistory.com, the first and online museum of Syrian history. It
contains over 2,000 photographs, documents, and rare audiovisual
material on Syria during the years 1900-2000.

National Self-Determination

NATIONAL SELF-DETERMINATION
by Murray N. Rothbard

Lew Rockwell, CA
Jan 9 2007

This article first appeared in the August 1990 issue of The
Rothbard-Rockwell Report under the title "The Nationalities Question."

Upon the collapse of centralizing totalitarian Communism in Eastern
Europe and even the Soviet Union, long suppressed ethnic and
nationality questions and conflicts have come rapidly to the fore.

The crack-up of central control has revealed the hidden but still
vibrant "deep structures" of ethnicity and nationality.

To those of us who glory in ethnic diversity and yearn for national
justice, all this is a wondrous development of what has previously
lived only in fantasy or longing: it is a chance in Europe at long
last, to begin to reverse the monstrous twin injustices of Sarajevo
and Versailles. It is like being back in 1914 or 1919 again, with a
chance for the map of Europe and near Asia to be righted and redrawn.

For the first time since the end of World War II, or arguably since
Versailles, the world is in a "revolutionary situation." There are
many problems and costs to such a revolutionary situation, costs that
are well-known and need not be repeated here; but there are also many
benefits: currently, not only the collapse of Socialism-Communism,
but the sense that all things are possible, and that justice may come
at last to a long-suffering area of the world.

Most Americans, however, are puzzled and disturbed rather than
delighted at the re-emergence of the nationalities question. We
can separate the worried or hostile reactions into four groups: (a)
the average American; (b) Marxist-Leninists; (c) global democrats,
which include the liberal and neoconservative wing of the ruling
American Establishment; and (d) modal libertarians.

HOSTILES: THE AVERAGE AMERICAN

First, the average American is uncomprehending of the very problem.

Why can’t all these groups live-and-let-live, and join peacefully
together as has the United States in its "melting pot" of varied
immigrant groups? In the first place, this Pollyanna view of America
overlooks the black question, which has scarcely settled into any
melting pot, and is more mired in deep conflict now than at any
time since the late nineteenth century. But even setting that aside
no peaceful "melting pot" existed in the nineteenth century. From
the 1830s until after World War I, northern, "Yankee," mainstream
Protestants (with the exception of old-style Calvinists and high-church
Lutherans) were captured by an aggressive and militant post-millennial
pietism whose objective was to use government to stamp out "sin"
(especially liquor and the Catholic Church), and who made the lives
of Catholic and German Lutheran immigrants miserable and put them
under constant attack for nearly a century. Finally, the pietists
succeeded in imposing immigration restrictions and national origin
quotas after World War I.

But even setting all that aside, the United States of America was a
unique development in the modern world: a roughly "empty" land (with
the notable exception of American Indians), peopled by a large number
of mainly European religious, ethnic, and national immigrant groups,
within the framework of a mainly free, constitutional Republic under
the rubric of English as the common, public language.

Other nations in Europe and Asia developed very differently, often
with native nationalities conquered and dominated by "imperial"
nations. Instead of one public language, the oppressor nationalities
invariably tried to obliterate the languages and even the names of
conquered nationalities. One of the most moving cries during last
year’s implosion of Communism came from the suppressed Turkish minority
in Bulgaria and the conquered "Moldavians" (i.e., Romanians) in Soviet
Moldavia, grabbed from Romania after World War II: "give us our names
back!" The Moldavians want to shed the hated Russian names imposed by
the Soviet state, as well as the even more hated Cyrillic forced upon
them in place of their Latin alphabet. And this national obliteration
is not just a product of Communism. It is an age-old practice:
"imperial" France still forbids the Celts of Brittany to name their
children according to Celtic nomenclature; and the Turks, still not
admitting their genocidal massacre of the Armenian minority during
World War I, also refuse to acknowledge the very existence of their
Kurdish minority, referring to them contemptuously as "mountain Turks."

HOSTILES: THE MARXIST-LENINISTS

The Marxist-Leninists are a dying breed, but it is fascinating to
consider their now vanishing role on this issue. Their reputation as
"anti-imperialists" has nothing to do with classical Marxism. In fact,
Marx and Engels, consistent with their pro-modernizing approach,
aggressively favored Western imperialism (especially that of the
Prussians as against the hated Slavs). This stance accorded with
their view that the faster capitalism and "modernization" advance,
the sooner the "inevitable final stage" of history, the proletarian
communist revolution, will take place.

Lenin, however, pragmatically junked Marxism to side with the Third
World and other peasantry, which he saw perceptively as far riper
for revolution than the advanced capitalist nations. In practice,
however, Leninism, while giving lip-service to the right of national
self-determination (enshrined on paper in the Soviet Constitution but
always ignored in practice), was a centralizing universalist creed
transcending nationalities. More important, the actual Leninist cadre
in every country were deracinated intellectuals (often colonials
educated by Marxist-Leninist professors in the imperial centers
of London, Paris, and Lisbon), who were generally ignorant of, and
contemptuous or hostile toward, ethnicity, religion, and culture. The
official compulsory atheism of Marxist-Leninists was only the most
overt example of this hostility.

This riding roughshod over national cultures in the name of
universalist Leninist ideology is most starkly evident in the
regimes of Africa. The Marxist centralizing governments of Africa are
descendants of the regimes of Western imperialism established in the
late nineteenth century.

Britain, France, and Portugal marched into Africa and carved it up into
provinces totally heedless and uncaring of the realities of the varied
and highly diverse tribes which constituted the African polity. Many
tribes, most of which hated each other’s guts, and had nothing –
neither culture, language, customs, nor tradition – in common, were
coercively incorporated into "colonies" with arbitrary borders imposed
by the imperial Western powers. In addition to this forced marriage,
many of the artificial borders split tribal regions into two or more
parts, so that tribesmen seasonally migrating into age-old occupied
regions, found themselves stopped at the border and accused of being
"illegal immigrants" or "aggressors."

The tragedy of modern Africa is that the imperial powers did not
simply withdraw and allow the natural tribal formation to resume
their original occupation of the continent. Instead, the coercive
centralizing regimes of these so-called "nations" were turned over
to the deracinated Marxist intellectuals educated in the imperial
capitals, who soon became a parasitic bureaucratic class taxing and
oppressing the peaceful peasantry who constitute the bulk of the
actual producers in Africa.

HOSTILES: THE GLOBAL DEMOCRATS

The most significant negative reaction to the recent eruption
of the nationalities question is that of our "global democracy"
Establishment. Theirs is the most significant because they constitute
the dominant opinion-molding force in American life. Essentially theirs
is a far more sophisticated version of the reaction of the average
American. The concerns and demands of nationalities are dismissed as
narrow, selfish, parochial, and even dangerously hostile per se and
aggressive toward other nationalities. Above all, they interfere
with the most sanctified value in the global-democratic canon:
"the democratic process," which inherently means "majority rule,"
albeit sometimes limited by the restraints of "human" or "minority"
rights. Therefore, the ultimate curse leveled against nationalities
and their demands is that they are perforce "undemocratic" and hence
not suitable for the modern world.

Thus, there is a deeper reason than realpolitik for the seemingly
strange coolness of the Bush administration toward the heroic
national independence movement of the Lithuanians and the other Baltic
nations. It’s not just that the United States is supposed to sacrifice
them on the altar of "saving Gorby." For there was unalloyed joy at
the liberating of Officially "Acredited Nations, such as Poland,
Hungary, and Czechoslovakia, from Soviet and Communist yokes. But
the Baltic nations, after all, are different: they are "part" of the
Soviet Union, and therefore their unilateral secession, against the
will of the majority of the USSR, becomes an affront to "democracy,"
to "majority rule," and, last but far from least, to the unitary,
centralizing nation-state that allegedly embodies the democratic ideal.

The fact that the United States had never recognized the forcible
incorporation of the Baltic nations into the USSR in 1940, is now
demonstrated to be a Cold War sham to win the votes of East European
ethnics living in the United States. For when push comes to shove,
how can little parts of a great nation be permitted to secede in
opposition to the "democratic will" of the larger nation? Not only the
Bush and Establishment coolness toward the Baltics, but also their
palpable relief when Gorby sent troops in to Azerbaijan, allegedly
to stop Azeris and Armenians from killing each other, shows that far
more is at stake here than helping Gorby against the Stalinists.

For the U.S. global democrats had gotten worried that Gorby might
fail to carry out the alleged fundamental responsibility of a great
modernizing nation: to use force and violence to settle disputes
among its various regions and nationalities. That is, in fact, to
maintain the unitary force of the central "imperial" power against
the nationalities within its periphery.

The clinching argument of the global democrats in all this may be
summed up as "after all, didn’t Lincoln?" The most sanctified figure
in American historiography is, by no accident, the Great Saint of
centralizing "democracy" and the strong unitary nation-state: Abraham
Lincoln. It is fascinating and no accident, and reveals the vital
importance of history and of historical myth even in as amnesiac a
nation as the United States, that a major reason that the neocons and
their stooges have tried to read such paleocons as Mel Bradford and
Tom Fleming out of the conservative movement is that they are highly
critical of "honest Abe."

And so didn’t Lincoln use force and violence, and on a massive scale,
on behalf of the mystique of the sacred "Union," to prevent the South
from seceding? Indeed he did, and on the foundation of mass murder and
oppression, Lincoln crushed the South and outlawed the very notion of
secession (based on the highly plausible ground that since the separate
states voluntarily entered the Union they should be allowed to leave).

But not only that: for Lincoln created the monstrous unitary
nation-state from which individual and local liberties have never
recovered: e.g., the triumph of an all-powerful federal judiciary,
Supreme Court, and national army; the overriding of the ancient
Anglo-Saxon and libertarian right of habeas corpus by jailing
dissidents against the war without trial; the establishment of
martial rule; the suppression of freedom of the press; and the largely
permanent establishment of conscription, the income tax, the pietist
"sin" taxes against liquor and tobacco, the corrupt and cartelizing
"partnership of government and industry" constituting massive
subsidies to transcontinental railroads, and the protective tariff;
the establishment of fiat money inflation through the greenbacks and
getting off the gold standard; and the nationalization of the banking
system through the national Banking Acts of 1863 and 1864.

It is particularly fascinating that many conservative defenders of
Lithuania and the other Baltic nations, try themselves to preserve
the Lincoln myth and the general U.S. hostility to secession. They
argue that since the Baltic states were forcibly incorporated by
Stalin in 1940, they at least should be allowed to secede without
the punishment of Lincoln-style repression!

Let us set aside the fact that most of the other incorporations
of nations into the Soviet Union were just as compulsory albeit
more venerable: e.g., the Ukraine, Armenia, or Georgia in the
early days of the Bolshevik Revolution. Let us instead cut to the
heart of the democratic political theory that is involved in the
pervasive hostility to secession. For democratic theory, including
the theory of most "minarchist" laissez-faire libertarians, holds that
government, whether broadly social-democratic or confined to police,
defense and the judiciary, should be chosen by majority rule in free
elections. Minority secession movements are accused of violating
democratic majority rule. But the crucial and always unanswered
question is: democratic rule over what geographical area?

Let us put the problem another way: minarchist or democratic
theory says that the State should have a monopoly of force in its
territorial area. Let us agree for the sake of argument. But then
the big unasked, and unanswered, question arises: what should be
the territorial area? To paraphrase a favorite gambit of Ayn Rand’s,
the near-universal response is: Blankout!

Nationalities secessionists are implicitly challenging this
pervasive blankout as a serious response to their concerns. So far,
whether under Lincoln or, to a much lesser extent under Gorby, their
crucial question has been met only by violence and force majeure:
by the unquestioned mystique of might-makes-right and the coercive
unitary nation-state. But the inner logic of that mystique, and the
basic logic of minarchist political theory, is at once simple and
terrifying: unitary world "democratic" government. The minarchist
argument against anarcho-capitalist libertarians is that there must
be a single, overriding government agency with a monopoly force to
settle disputes by coercion. OK, but in that case and by the very
same logic shouldn’t nation-states be replaced by a one-world monopoly
government? Shouldn’t unitary world government replace what has been
properly termed our existing "international anarchy?"

Minarchist libertarians and conservatives balk at the inner logic of
world government for obvious reasons: for they fear correctly that
world taxation and world socialization would totally and irreversibly
suppress the liberty and property of Americans. But they remain
trapped in the logic of their own position. Left-liberals, on the
other hand, are happy to embrace this logic precisely because of
this expected outcome. Even the democratic Establishment, however,
hesitates at embracing the ultimate logical end of a single world
democratic state, at least until they can be assured of controlling
that monstrous entity.

Short of the world State of their dreams, how does our global
democratic Establishment deal with the crucial problem of where State
boundaries should be? By sanctifying whatever State boundaries happen
to exist at the time. Sanctifying status quo boundaries has been
the axiom of the foreign policy of every U.S. administration since
Woodrow Wilson, and of the League of Nations and its successor the
United Nations, all based on the incoherent and disastrous concept of
"collective security against aggression." It was that concept that
underlay U.S. intervention in World Wars I and II, and in the Korean
War: first we determine (often incorrectly) which is the "aggressor
state," and then all nation-states are supposed to band together to
combat, repel, and punish that aggression.

The theoretical analogue of such a concert against "aggression"
is held to be combating criminal action against individuals. A robs
or murders B; the local police, appointed defenders of the right of
person and property, leap to the defense of B and act to apprehend
and punish A. In the same way, "peace-loving" nations are supposed
to band together against "aggressor" nations or states. Hence, Harry
Truman’s otherwise mystifying insistence that the U.S. war against
North Korea was not a war at all but a "police action."

The deep flaw in all this is that when A robs or murders B, there is
a general agreement that A is in the wrong, and that he has indeed
aggressed against the person and just property rights of B. But when
State A aggresses against the border of State B, often claiming that
the border is unjust and the result of a previous aggression against
country A decades before, how can we say a priori that State A is
the aggressor and that we must dismiss its defense out of hand? Who
says, and on what principle, that State B has the same moral right
to all of its existing territory as individual B has to his life and
property? And how can the two aggressions be equated when our global
democrats refuse to come up with any principles or criteria whatsoever:
except the unsatisfactory and absurd call for a world State or blind
reliance upon the boundary status quo at any given moment?

JUST BOUNDARIES AND NATIONAL SELF-DETERMINATION

What, then, is the answer? What national boundaries can be considered
as just? In the first place, it must be recognized that there are
no just national boundaries per se; that real justice can only
be founded on the property rights of individuals. If fifty people
decided voluntarily to set up an organization for common services or
self-defense of their persons and properties in a certain geographical
area, then the boundaries of that association, based on the just
property rights of the members, will also be just.

National boundaries are only just insofar as they are based on
voluntary consent and the property rights of their members or
citizens. Just national boundaries are, then, at best derivative and
not primary. How much more is this true of existing State boundaries
which are, in greater or lesser degree, based on coercive expropriation
of private property, or on a mixture of that with voluntary consent! In
practice, the way to have such national boundaries as just as possible
is to preserve and cherish the right of secession, the right of
different regions, groups, or ethnic nationalities to get the blazes
out of the larger entity, to set up their own independent nation. Only
by boldly asserting the right of secession can the concept of national
self-determination be anything more than a sham and a hoax.

But wasn’t the Wilsonian attempt to impose national self-determination
and draw the map of Europe a disaster? And how!

But the disaster was inevitable even assuming (incorrectly) good
will on the part of Wilson and the Allies and ignoring the fact that
national self-determination was a mask for their imperial ambitions.

For by its nature, national self-determination cannot be imposed from
without, by a foreign government entity, be it the United States or
some world League.

The whole point of national self-determination is to get top-down
coercive power out of the picture and, for the use of force to devolve
from the larger entity to more genuine natural and voluntary national
entities. In short, to devolve power from the top downward.

Imposing national self-determination from the outside makes matters
worse and more coercive than ever. Moreover, getting the U.S. or other
governments involved in every ethnic conflict throughout the globe
maximizes, rather than minimizes, coercion, conflict, war, and mass
murder. It drags the United States, as the great isolationist scholar
Charles A. Beard once put it, into "perpetual war for perpetual peace."

Referring back to political theory, since the nation-state has a
monopoly of force in its territorial area, the one thing it must
not do is ever try to exercise its force beyond its area, where it
has no monopoly, because then a relatively peaceful "international
anarchy" (where each State confines its power to its own geographical
boundary) is replaced by an international Hobbesian chaos of war
of all (governments) against all. In short, given the existence of
nation-states, they should (a) never exercise their power beyond
their territorial area (a foreign policy of "isolationism"), and (b)
maintain the right of secession of groups or entities within their
territorial area.

The right of secession, if fearlessly upheld, implies also the right
of one or more villages to secede even from its own ethnic nation, or,
even, as Ludwig von Mises affirmed in his Nation, State, and Economy,
the right of secession by each individual.

If one deep flaw in the Wilsonian enterprise was its imposition of
national self-determination from the outside, another was his total
botch of redrawing the European map. It is difficult to believe
that they could have done a worse job if the Versailles rulers had
blindfolded themselves and put pins arbitrarily in a map of Europe
to create new nations.

Instead of self-determination for each nation, three officially
designated Good Guy peoples (Poles, Czechs, and Serbs) were made
masters over other nationalities who had hated their guts for
centuries, often with good reason. That is, these three favored
nationalities were not simply given ethnic national independence;
instead, their boundaries were arbitrarily swollen so as to dominate
other peoples officially designated as Bad Guys (or at best Who Cares
Guys): the Poles ruling over Germans, Lithuanians (in the Lithuanian
city of Vilnius/Vilna), Byelorussians, and Ukrainians; the Czechs
ruling over Slovaks and Ukrainians (called "Carpatho-Ruthenians"); and
the Serbs tyrannizing over Croats, Slovenes, Albanians, Hungarians,
and Macedonians, in a geographical abortion called "Yugoslavia"
(now at least in the process of falling apart).

In addition, the Romanians were aggrandized at the expense of the
Hungarians and Bulgarians. These three (or four if we include Romania)
lopsided countries were also given the absurd and impossible task
by the U.S. and the Western allies of keeping down permanently the
two neighboring great "revisionist" powers and losers at Versailles:
Germany and Russia. This imposed task led straight to World War II.

In short, national self-determination must remain a moral principle
and a beacon-light for all nations, and not be something to be imposed
by outside governmental coercion.

PARTITION AND REFERENDUM

One practical way of implementing self-determination and the right
of secession is the concept of a partition referendum in which each
village or parish votes to decide whether to remain inside the existing
national entity or to secede or join another such nation.

The much-disputed area of Nagorno-Karabakh, for example, would
undoubtedly vote overwhelmingly to leave the hated Azerbaijan Republic
and join Armenia. But what of the fact that Nagorno-Karabakh is not
contiguous with greater Armenia, that there is a sliver of ethnically
Azeri land in-between? But surely good will on both sides (which of
course is obviously non-existent at this point) could permit a free
zone or free entry across that zone. Not only an airpath, but also
a road corridor proved to be viable for decades after the explosive
Berlin crisis.

Partition referenda were used fitfully after World War I; the most
renowned case was the separation of Northern Ireland from the rest
of the country. Unfortunately, the British deliberately promised
referendum for a second partition was never carried out by the British
government. As a result, a large amount of Catholic territory in the
north was forcibly incorporated into the Protestant state, and the
existence of that Catholic minority, which undoubtedly would vote
to join the South, has been responsible for the tragic and unending
violence and bloodshed ever since. In short, a genuine partition
based on referenda, would probably lop off from Northern Ireland the
territories of counties Tyrone and Fermanagh (including the city of
Derry) and South Down. Essentially, Northern Ireland would be much
reduced in land area, and left with a belt around Belfast and county
Antrim. The only substantial Catholic minority would then be in the
Catholic section of Belfast.

One criticism of partition by referendum is that parishes and villages
are often mixed, so that there could not be a precise separation
of the nationalities. In the vexed region of Transylvania, for
example, Hungarian and Romanian villages are intermixed in the same
region. No doubt; no one ever said that such referenda would provide
a panacea. But the point is that at least the degree of voluntary
choice would be enlarged and the amount of social and ethnic conflict
minimized, and not much more can be achieved.

(Transylvania, by the way, is largely Hungarian, especially the
northern part, and the wrong done to Hungary after World War I should
be rectified.)

There is one criticism of the referendum approach that is far more
cogent and troublesome. The Azeri claim to Nagorno-Karabakh rests
on the thesis that, while the Armenians are now admittedly in the
overwhelming majority, the region was, centuries ago, a center of
Azeri culture. This claim from history may properly be dismissed as
the dead hand of the past ruling the living, perhaps with the proviso
that ancient Azeri shrines be protected under Azeri care.

But more troubling is, say, the current situation in Estonia and
Latvia, where the Soviets deliberately tried to swamp and destroy
native culture and ethnic nationalism by shipping in a large number
of Russians after World War II to work in the factories. In Latvia,
the Russian minority is only slightly under 50 percent. Here, I believe
the recency of this migration and its political nature tip the scales
in favor of maintaining native nationalism. In fact, libertarians
believe that everyone has the natural right to self-ownership and
ownership of property, but that there is no such thing as a natural
"right" to vote. Here, it would make sense not to allow Russians to
vote in Latvia and Estonia, to treat them as guests or immigrants of
indefinite duration, but not with the voting privileges of citizenship.

THE HOSTILES: THE LIBERTARIANS

Libertarians are, by and large, as fiercely opposed to ethnic
nationalism as the global democrats, but for very different reasons.

Libertarians are generally what might be called simplistic and
"vulgar" individualists. A typical critique would run as follows:
"There is no nation; there are only individuals. The nation is a
collectivist and therefore pernicious concept. The concept of ‘national
self-determination’ is fallacious, since only the individual has a
‘self.’ Since the nation and the State are both collective concepts,
both are pernicious and should be combated."

The linguistic complaint may be dismissed quickly. Yes, of course,
there is no national "self," we are using "self-determination" as a
metaphor, and no one really thinks of a nation as an actual living
entity with its own "self."

More seriously, we must not fall into a nihilist trap. While
only individuals exist, individuals do not exist as isolated and
hermetically sealed atoms. Statists traditionally charge libertarians
and individualists with being "atomistic individualists," and the
charge, one hopes, has always been incorrect and misconceived.

Individuals may be the only reality, but they influence each other,
past and present, and all individuals grow up in a common culture
and language. (This does not imply that they may not, as adults,
rebel and challenge and exchange that culture for another.)

While the State is a pernicious and coercive collectivist concept,
the "nation" may be and generally is voluntary. The nation properly
refers, not to the State, but to the entire web of culture, values,
traditions, religion, and language in which the individuals of a
society are raised. It is almost embarrassingly banal to emphasize
that point, but apparently many libertarians aggressively overlook
the obvious. Let us never forget the great libertarian Randolph
Bourne’s analysis of the crucial distinction between "the nation"
(the land, the culture, the terrain, the people) and "the State"
(the coercive apparatus of bureaucrats and politicians), and of his
important conclusion that one may be a true patriot of one’s nation
or country while – and even for that very reason – opposing the State
that rules over it.

In addition, the libertarian, especially of the anarcho-capitalist
wing, asserts that it makes no difference where the boundaries are,
since in a perfect world all institutions and land areas would be
private and there would be no national boundaries. Fine, but in the
meantime, in the real world, in which language should the government
courts hold their proceedings? What should be the language of signs
on the government streets? Or the language of the government schools?

In the real world, then, national self-determination is a vitally
important matter in which libertarians should properly take sides.

Finally, nationalism has its disadvantages for liberty, but also
has its strengths, and libertarians should try to help tip it in the
latter direction. If we were residents of Yugoslavia, for example,
we should be agitating in favor of the right to secede from that
swollen and misbegotten State of Croatia and Slovenia (that is,
favoring their current nationalist movements), while opposing the
desire of the Serb demagogue Slobodan Milosevic to cling to Serb
domination over the Albanians in Kosovo or over the Hungarians in the
Vojvodina (that is, opposing Great Serbian nationalism). There is,
in short national liberation (good) versus national "imperialism"
over other peoples (bad). Once we get over simplistic individualism,
and this distinction should not be difficult to grasp.

Murray N. Rothbard (1926-1995) was the author of Man, Economy, and
State, Conceived in Liberty, What Has Government Done to Our Money,
For a New Liberty, The Case Against the Fed, and many other books
and articles. He was also the editor – with Lew Rockwell – of The
Rothbard-Rockwell Report.

ard134.html

http://www.lewrockwell.com/rothbard/rothb

Karen Armstrong Describes Pope’s Words As "Extremely Dangerous"

KAREN ARMSTRONG DESCRIBES POPE’S WORDS AS "EXTREMELY DANGEROUS"
By Lucy Jones

Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, DC
December 2006, pages 28-29

Many European newspapers thought Pope Benedict XVI should have
shown greater sensitivity in his Sept. 12 address to the University
of Regensburg, in which he quoted a Byzantine emperor, Manuel II
Paleologus, as saying: "Show me just what Mohammed brought that was
new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as
his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached."

"Like the Danish cartoons," said the London Times on Sept. 16, "the
pope’s words provide a golden opportunity for Islamist militants to
inflame the millions who have no access to his full speech with a
distorted interpretation of his words and his intentions.

"It might have been wiser," The Times added, "if the pope had excised
from his speech any remark, especially a quotation about the Prophet
Muhammad, that could be taken out of context by those for whom
ecumenism is anathema."

Admonished Britain’s Guardian the same day: "Even if Benedict XVI,
despite his reputation for meticulous preparation, had failed to
appreciate the impact of his thoughts, his advisers should have.

"There might have been less protest had Benedict a clearer record
in favor of dialogue with Islam," the newspaper continued. As a
cardinal in the Holy See, Benedict was known to be skeptical of John
Paul II’s pursuit of conversation, the Guardian noted. One of his
earliest decisions as pope, it pointed out, was to move Archbishop
Michael Fitzgerald, one of the Catholic Church’s leading experts on
Islam and head of its council on interreligious dialogue, away from
the center of influence in Rome, to Egypt as a papal nuncio.

"[The pope] appears to have had no idea that his academic musings at
his old university in Bavaria would have such an impact," wrote The
Independent on Sept. 17, "and that is precisely why he deserves to
be criticized."

Writing in the same newspaper the following day, however, the author
Karen Armstrong found it "difficult to believe that his reference to
an inherently violent strain in Islam was entirely accidental.

"Coming on the heels of the Danish cartoon crisis," she continued,
"his remarks were extremely dangerous. They will convince more Muslims
that the West is incurably Islamophobic and engaged in a new crusade."

In Germany, however, Die Welt said on Sept. 18 that the Islamic world’s
anger about the quote was groundless because it merely expressed a
"historically documented fact."

According to the newspaper, it is neither provocative nor blasphemous
to point out that "Christianity, abuses notwithstanding, is essentially
not a religion of conquest, as practiced personally and successfully
by the prophet of Islam.

"The hysterical reactions from the Muslim world mainly show that there
are enough influential people who take advantage of any opportunity
in order to start a clash of cultures," it concluded.

"The pope does not have to apologize for expressing an opinion," said
Spain’s El Mundo the same day. "He upheld an idea we fully share:
tolerance."

But Germany’s Frankfurter Rundschau of Sept. 18 thought the pontiff’s
remarks were ill-advised.

"A pope is not a scholar who can philosophize for himself without
considering the consequences," the paper argued. "He must put himself
in the place of those listeners who feel humiliated by the West."

Echoed France’s Liberation the same day: "He is not expected to compete
with Bush’s neoconservatives in fueling… a war of civilizations,
but to preach coexistence between religions."

French Genocide Law Said to "Contribute to Dogmatization" "Pointless,"
was how France’s Liberation of Oct. 13 described a bill passed by
the lower house making it a crime to deny that the Turks committed
genocide against the Armenians in 1915.

Even if some dispute the term "genocide," the newspaper editorialized,
"The destruction of the Armenian people of Asia Minor…is an
historical fact which is hard to deny."

It went on to add, however, that the new bill "contributes to the
dogmatization of historical research, the best example which can
be found in Turkey," and concluded, "This law will hinder the very
people who are seeking progress in this area."

"It is not for the law to write history," argued Le Monde the previous
day. "It is for the people of Turkey to remember and for diplomacy
to encourage them to do so."

Turkish intellectuals who already have spoken of the genocide at home,
Le Monde pointed out, believe the French bill "would be grist to the
mill of nationalists ready to demand that Ankara impose…economic
reprisals against France."

It "borders on the absurd," noted Austria’s Die Presse of Oct. 12,
that France may make the denial of Armenian genocide punishable by
imprisonment, while in Turkey prison looms for those who say genocide
occurred.

"How can there be an open, scholarly discussion if this can land you
in prison in two countries?" it asked.

However, that day’s Der Standard supported the bill, which had yet
to be passed by the Senate and president.

While acknowledging that the vote may be the result of "consideration
for the 450,000 French-Armenians in the country," the Austrian paper
went on to argue that the killings seem to meet the genocide criteria
laid down in United Nations conventions.

"This is why the bill passed by the Paris MPs is to be approved
of," it concluded, "even though it may be based on petty electoral
considerations."

Nobel Prize for Turkish Writer Seen as Having "Strong Political Aspect"
In addition to the Nobel Prize for Literature, Orhan Pamuk "could also
have received the Nobel Peace Prize," wrote Spain’s El Pais on Oct. 13,
the day after the Turkish writer was awarded the honor. "He is one of
the intellectuals who has reflected with the greatest brilliance…on
the depravity of national, ethnic or religious fanaticism."

Awarding the prize to Pamuk was "the best decision the Nobel Prize
committee has taken for years," opined Germany’s Frankfurter Allgemeine
Zeitung the same day, likening it to 1970’s Nobel Prize to the Soviet
dissident author Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn.

The Czech daily Hospodarske Noviny of Oct. 13 questioned the judges’
intentions, however. "The Nobel Prize for Literature for a writer
who was charged in Turkey last year for daring to speak aloud about
the Armenian genocide and massacres of Kurds has a strong political
aspect," it said. "Pamuk’s literary qualities are unquestionable,
but the Nobel Prize committee’s decision this year was more political
than literary," it concluded.

Afghanistan Described as "Let Down By the Rest of the World" The
murder in Afghanistan on Sept. 25 of Safia Amajan, director of the
Ministry of Women’s Affairs in Kandahar, emphasized "the despicable
ideology of the Taliban," the U.K.’s Independent wrote the following
day. Amajan had opened numerous female schools and provided hundreds
of women and girls with an education that, only five years ago,
was denied them by the obscurantist Taliban.

Her murder-believed to have been orchestrated by the Taliban-underlines
how shamefully Afghanistan has been let down by the rest of the world,
said the newspaper.

"The reason is neglect," it continued, adding that President Hamid
Karzai’s warnings about the deteriorating security situation in his
country "were ignored by a world preoccupied by Iraq.

"It is now apparent that the battle for Afghanistan did not end in
2001," the newspaper concluded. "The fall of Kabul was merely the
beginning of that struggle. And, as this latest murder shows, the
terrible truth is that the forces of enlightenment and democracy are
in retreat."

Lebanon Cited as Possible Role Model for Palestinian State Germany’s
Die Welt of Sept. 21 welcomed the parliament’s approval for the
dispatch of up to 2,400 navy personnel to patrol Lebanon’s coast.

There are "good reasons" for the deployment, the paper argued, ranging
from the need to stabilize Lebanon to Berlin’s desire to become
"an important player in the Middle East."

That day’s Frankfurter Rundschau agreed, saying that parliament has
taken the correct decision. There is an "historic dimension" to the
deployment, the newspaper noted, because a stable Lebanon could serve
as a template for a future Palestinian state.

"An established state, with Beirut as the capital, in which citizens
take matters that concern them into their own hands, could turn out
to be a model for the center of the Middle East conflict," it said.

Lucy Jones is a free-lance journalist based in London.

06/0612028.html

http://www.wrmea.com/archives/December_20

French Vote On Armenian Genocide Adds To Turkey’s Growing Anti-EU Se

FRENCH VOTE ON ARMENIAN GENOCIDE ADDS TO TURKEY’S GROWING ANTI-EU SENTIMENT
By Jon Gorvett

Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, DC
December 2006, pages 30-31

WITH THE FRENCH parliament passing in early October a resolution to
make denial of the Armenian genocide a crime, the issue of 1915 once
again was buried beneath a mass of knee-jerk responses in Turkey.

Protests were held, tricoleur flags were burned. Calls for a boycott
of French goods were wheeled out of the nationalist garage, where they
had been gathering dust since 2001-the last time the French parliament
had intervened in this dispute-and plenty of brave speeches were made.

Yet while the motion in Paris may have been a storm in an electoral
teacup likely to be quashed by more sober heads in the Senate and
the Presidency-just as it was back in 2001-this time it may not be
a case of plus ca change, plus ca la meme chose.

This is because, nowadays, support in Turkey for the European
Union-of which France is such an important symbol-has never been more
dismal. Illustrative of this was the fact that the resolution was
passed just as Turkey was about to be on the receiving end of another
annual European Commission report on its progress in EU membership
talks. Widespread leaks, and a condemnatory version of the report
from the European Parliament, had left little doubt in Turkey that
this year’s end-of-term grade would have a definite "could do better"
ring to it.

Thus the French vote added to a growing feeling on the Turkish
street that the EU spends all of its time attacking Turkey rather
than helping it.

Some in Istanbul and Ankara also pointed to the bill as illustrative of
a perceived double standard in European attitudes toward free speech.

Only a few weeks before the French vote, Europe had condemned Turkey
for putting on trial one of its most respected authors, Elif Safak.

She had been accused of "insulting Turkishness" under the controversial
Article 30 of the revised Turkish criminal code-the same article used
unsuccessfully last December to try to prosecute recent Nobel Prize
winner Orhan Pamuk.

At a hearing attended by many European Union representatives anxious
to establish their free expression credentials, the Safak case also was
dismissed. But, some columnists asked, how come the Europeans condemned
Turkey for gagging free speech under Article 30 while at the same
time they were busy gagging free speech over the Armenian genocide?

The effect of the French parliament’s decision, therefore, was to
create another sense of grievance in Turkey against the Europeans.

This also plays to a central part of the Turkish national
narrative-that of the persecuted Turks, forced back into Anatolia
via massive bouts of ethnic cleansing in the Balkans, the Middle East
and the Caucasus, as the Ottoman Empire collapsed in the later 19th
and early 20th centuries.

Indeed, in this narrative, which continues to be spread at school
and beyond in Turkey, the Armenians themselves come as essentially
the last straw. Even in Anatolia, the nationalists say, they wanted
to push us out-"they," in this case, being the Armenians, erstwhile
citizens of the same Ottoman Empire, who lived in Anatolia and are
then portrayed as fifth columnists of the Europeans and the Russians.

This allows the nationalists to then claim that it was the Turks,
not the Armenians, who were the victims in 1915.

Challenging this view not only has long been highly dangerous for
Turks, but has only recently been open to debate at all. Whether the
French parliament’s effective closing of the issue to discussion is
at all useful in encouraging openness elsewhere remains to be seen,
but the French vote was largely seen as a setback by those in Turkey
trying to bring the events of 1915 out into the open.

At the same time, it also clearly is a setback for the pro-EU camp in
Ankara, which recently has been under fairly constant shellfire over
foreign policy in particular, and over the perennial Kurdish issue
as well. Joining the barrage with its heavy artillery was the Turkish
military, which launched a series of attacks on perceived concessions
to the European Union over the nation’s fundamental interests.

The first salvo came at the end of September from the head of the navy,
Admiral Yener Karahanoglu, who said that Turkey would never make the
concessions being demanded of it on the path to membership.

These were widely seen as being over Cyprus-where Turkey is being
asked to open its ports and airports to the vessels of EU-member
Cyprus, as represented by the Greek Cypriot government.

Indeed, the Cyprus issue duly arose again, like Banquo’s ghost, to
rattle its chains over the annual membership accession talks between
Turkey and the EU in October. EU Enlargement Commissioner Oli Rehn
warned that unless Turkey made a move on opening its ports, a "last
window of opportunity on the Cyprus issue in the coming weeks or
months for a very long time, perhaps for years" might close.

The other foreign policy issue over which the EU is pushing Turkey is
Armenia, with which Turkey is expected to normalize relations. Since
the Azerbaijan-Armenian conflict in the early 1990s over Nagorno
Karabakh, Turkey has closed its land frontier with Armenia and will
not reopen it until there is a settlement between Baku and Yerevan.

Admiral Karahanoglu’s words were then backed up by the head of the
army, Gen. Ilker Basbug, who warned of "intentional, patient and
systematic attempts" to undermine the achievements of the secular
Turkish Republic. This was interpreted as a widening of the attack
to target the Turkish government, which with its Islamist past has
long been held in deep suspicion by the generals.

Finally, the bunker buster itself was dropped by Gen. Yasar Buyukanit,
the new chief of the General Staff and thereby Turkey’s topmost
military official, when he spoke out to accuse the EU of having
"a hidden agenda" for Turkey.

Given that the governing Justice and Development Party (AKP) comes from
an Islamist tradition that also has long been hostile to the EU-indeed,
it was one of the great achievements of liberals within the AKP to
have turned this around after the "soft coup" back in 1997-support for
"concessions" has never been high among Turkey’s politicians either.

So, with such a basis of mistrust at the highest levels of both
military and government-and a bureaucracy that has a long history
of opposition to the kind of reforms EU membership would entail-it
is no surprise to find that support in society as a whole for EU
membership has plummeted. Recent opinion polls suggest around half
the population support membership. Even five years ago, the figure
was nearer 80 percent.

Nor is Turkey immune to broader global polarizations that have been
underway in recent years. The U.S. also is massively more unpopular
in Turkey now than it was before the "War on Terror." As a Muslim
country, Turkey feels the pull of the widespread condemnation of
Western actions found elsewhere in the Islamic world.

Given such circumstances, the path toward EU membership has been
growing thornier, even as it has seemed to be getting clearer. This
contradiction is evidence of the complexity of Turkish attitudes toward
Europe-and vice versa-while also perhaps serving as cautionary tale
to those who see the world in simpler terms.

Jon Gorvett is a free-lance journalist based in Istanbul.

2006/0612030.html

http://www.wrmea.com/archives/December_

Boxing: Darchinyan Wants More Titles

DARCHINYAN WANTS MORE TITLES

Seconds Out
Jan 9 2007

Vic Darchinyan has just turned 31 but the way he sees it, the best
part of his career is only just beginning.

After bringing himself to the attention of boxing fans in the USA with
three brutal stoppage wins on the Showtime television network in 2006,
the IBF/IBO flyweight world champion is looking for the biggest fights
available in 2007.

"It was a good year for me," he said, "but I want to win more world
title belts and I will move up in weight if I have to. I want to
fight three or four times this year."

Evidence that Darchinyan’s reputation is rising as one of the best
in boxing can be seen in the latest edition of the highly respected
The Ring magazine. In his opening editorial, Nigel Collins suggests a
new list of "dollar for dollar ratings" for world class fighters who
"give boxing consumers the biggest bang for their bucks". Darchinyan
is listed at six behind number one Manny Pacquiao and ahead of other
notable names such as Shane Mosley, Marco Antonio Barrera, Oscar De
La Hoya and Ricky Hatton.

"I was very happy to read that and I am thankful that Nigel Collins
has me on his new list," said Darchinyan. "But I not only want to be
the most exciting fighter in the world, I want to be in the pound for
pound top ten best boxers in the world and become undisputed world
champion in different weight classes. I really want to have The Ring
world champion belt around my waist."

Unfortunately, his promoter Gary Shaw’s attempts to get him a
unification match at flyweight have been unsuccessful so far. WBO
champion Omar Narvaez 23-0-2 (15) has turned down two offers to
fight Darchinyan, while WBC champion Pongsaklek Wonjongkam 63-2 (31)
has never fought in the USA and rarely fights outside of his home
country of Thailand. While he has not fought since December 2005, WBA
champion Lorenzo Parra 27-0 (17) would appear to be the most likely
title-holder at flyweight to face Darchinyan 27-0 (21) this year.

Of course, the biggest fight on paper in 2007 for southpaw Darchinyan
is a clash with Mexican Jorge Arce 45-3-1 (35), who also appeared on
Collins’ new "dollar for dollar" list at No.2. The 27 year-old is a
former WBC interim flyweight and WBC junior flyweight world champion,
who is now campaigning at junior bantamweight.

"Quite a few people I have been talking to in the USA are saying
that Arce and me is the best fight they want to see in 2007," said
Darchinyan. "I have always said I will take that fight at any time,
it is up to the promoters and Arce to make it happen."

Another possible big fight for Darchinyan would be a move up in weight
to face WBO junior bantamweight world champion Fernando Montiel 32-2-1
(24) from Mexico, who is promoted by Oscar De La Hoya.

While flyweights have historically not been a division featured in
big time boxing in the USA, Darchinyan’s last three stoppage wins
over Diosdado Gabi, Luis Maldonado and Glenn Donaire showcased his
aggressive and powerful style and ensured that he will have many new
fans following him in the future. The Showtime network has taken a
liking to his entertaining style and with the ensuing American and
international television coverage of his fights, the "Raging Bull"
from Armenia, who has citizenship of Australia, will be a boxer in
demand for many years to come.

While he is currently waiting to sign a contract for the fight,
it is likely that Darchinyan’s next bout will be a mandatory IBF
defence against the Don King promoted Victor Burgos 39-14-3 (23)
in the USA on March 3, in the main support to the WBC lightweight
champion Joel Casamayor versus WBA lightweight champion Juan Diaz
clash on Showtime. 32 year-old Burgos from Mexico is a former IBF
junior flyweight world champion.

"I’m going to get some tapes of Burgos and look closely at his style,"
said Darchinyan. "I’m already training for the fight and I want to
put on another exciting performance and win for the fans.

This will help me get the biggest fights possible in 2007 and some
more world title belts."

cfm?ccs=473&cs=21093

http://www.secondsout.com/usa/lusal.

Armenian Regulatory Commission Approves Classification Of Voice Comm

ARMENIAN REGULATORY COMMISSION APPROVES CLASSIFICATION OF VOICE COMMUNICATIONS

Arka News Agency, Armenia
Jan 8 2007

YEREVAN, January 8. /ARKA/. The RA Regulatory Commission for Public
Services has approved the classification of voice communication
services and the order of rendering them to the population.

The reporter, Head of the Commission’s Telecommunication Department
Gevorg Gevorgyan said that the Commission’s decision is to take effect
the tenth day after its official publication.

He pointed out that under the decision local and long-distance
bilateral voice communication services will be considered such
irrespective pf the technologies applied.

Gevorgyan stressed that licensed organizations are to present to the
Commission substantiated decisions to terminate voice communication
within three days.

"The licensed companies and individuals are also obliged, within 45
days, to presents to the Commission the quality standards for outgoing
and incoming local and long-distance voice communication services
rendered with the use of the TDM and IP technologies," he said.

Gevorgyan also added that within 30 days the companies are to present
to the Commission proposals for the rendering of voice communication
services by means of the GSM mobile network and the IP-technologies.

Under the decision, the ArmenTel CJSC is to present to the Commission
proposals for the rendering of voice communication services by means
of stationary telephones using the IP technology.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenia’s Population Spends 12.6% Of Its Income To Purchase Exchange

ARMENIA’S POPULATION SPENDS 12.6% OF ITS INCOME TO PURCHASE EXCHANGE IN JAN-NOV 2006

Arka News Agency, Armenia
Jan 8 2007

YEREVAN, January 8. /ARKA/. Armenia’s population spent 12.6% of its
income on the purchase of foreign exchange in January-November 2006
(11.6% in the same period of 2005).

The population’s expenses on the purchase of foreign exchange increased
by 31.1% in January-November 2006, whereas the rise in income made
only 19.3% and overall expenses 19.4%. One percent of the population’s
incomes went on deposits.

The country’s population spent 78.4% of its income to purchase goods
and services in January-November 2006 against 79.4% in the same period
of 2005; a 17.7% increase was recorded in the expenditures compared
with the same period of 2005.

A 13.9% increase was recorded in compulsory payments and optional
contributions, with their share making 5.3% of the overall income.

Over the period, the population’s cash expenditures were 2.7% as
little as its cash income – no change against the same period of 2005.

The population’s cash incomes totaled AMD 1,463,778.5 mln in
January-November 2006 – a 19.3% increase against the same period
of 2005, with the cash expenditures totaling AMD 1,424,490.7 mln –
a 19.4% increase compared with January-October 2006. ($1 = AMD 364.45).

Serbian Military Analyst Faults Foreign Ministry For Arms Ban To Arm

SERBIAN MILITARY ANALYST FAULTS FOREIGN MINISTRY FOR ARMS BAN TO ARMENIA

Beta news agency, Belgrade, Serbia
8 Jan 2007

Belgrade, 8 January: Military analyst Zoran Dragisic said today that
the Ministry of Foreign Affairs committed a "terrible gaffe" over
the problem of issuing a permit to export arms to the Caucasus region.

"I think that this is a very poor political assessment, but it is
important to figure out who is behind that assessment. (…) [as
received] That is a question for the minister of foreign affairs
(Vuk Draskovic)," Dragisic told the Beta news agency.

Dragisic, who is also a professor at the Security Faculty, added
that Russia’s interests were misinterpreted, because that country
has nothing against arms being exported to Armenia.

"If Russia were opposed to that deal, I would understand the state
turning down a 2m dollars deal, because our relations with Russia
are worth much more than that. This way leaves the impression that we
are a Russian colony, a state that is not sovereign and obeys foreign
dictates," he said.

The Serbian defence industry exports arms, ammunition, and military
equipment worth some 300m dollars each year, whereas the former SFRY
[Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia] exported arms worth some
2.5bn dollars.

The arms exported to Caucasian countries are most often rifles,
automatic rifles, and 7.62-mm machine guns.

The latest domestically made automatic rifle, the M-21 with a NATO
calibre of 5.56 mm, is exported to Macedonia, African nations, and the
new Iraqi military and police forces, as well as to British private
security forces working in that country.

The domestic defence industry’s most successful export product is
the Nora long-range self-propelled howitzer, which Serbia exports to
one Asian country and which beat out similar products of the French,
Swedish, Israeli, and South African military industries in competitive
bidding.

BAKU: Committee Set Up In Iranian-Azerbaijan To Curb Kurdish Migrati

COMMITTEE SET UP IN IRANIAN AZARBAYJAN TO CURB KURDISH MIGRATION

Azeri Press Agency
Jan 9 2007

Baku, 9 January: A committee to defend [Iranian] West Azarbayjan has
been set up in Iran. According to the National Awakening Movement of
Southern Azerbaijan, the organization will be engaged in protecting
the rights of our compatriots living in the western part of southern
Azerbaijan [northwestern Iran].

The committee said in a statement that the tearing away of Iravan
[Yerevan] province from Azerbaijan and rampant Armenian crimes in
Karabakh have prompted them to think better of a possible confrontation
in the western part of southern Azerbaijan – Orumiyeh region.

The statement points out with anxiety that the Iranian state is
deliberately trying to cause a confrontation between Azerbaijanis
and Kurds in this area: "By settling Kurds in the western part of
[Iranian] Azarbayjan, they are trying to turn the region into
a hearth of terrorism. The Iranian law-enforcement agencies are
turning a blind eye to the activities of the PKK [Kurdistan Workers’
Party], PJAK [Kurdistan Free Life Party] and the Democratic Party of
Kurdistan. However, any step taken by Azerbaijanis, who own this land,
is kept under control."

In the statement, the committee to defend West Azarbayjan called on
the Turks of the world to support the organization.