ANKARA: So-Called Armenian ‘Genocide’ Discussion At The Soviet-Polit

SO-CALLED ARMENIAN ‘GENOCIDE’ DISCUSSION AT THE SOVIET-POLIT-BUREAU

Journal of Turkish Weekly, Turkey
Jan 10 2006

* "These subjects never were on our agenda in Lenin times"

In the meeting of 21 Feb. 1985 of the Politbureau under the presidency
of Gorbachov, the genocide charges were discussed.

However, since there was not a similar example in history, and it
would damage the relations with Turkey to the benefit of USA, the
proposition to announce April 24 as Genocide Day, was rejected.

It has been discovered that during the meeting of the Soviet Union
Communist Party’s Polit Bureau held on Feb.21,1985, the subject
of genocide was discussed. An Azerbaijan congressman and scholar
Prof.Dr. Cemil Hasanli, during his research studies in the USA National
Security Archives, found the minutes relative to this meeting which
were brought from Russian state archives. The subject was discussed in
the meeting, under the heading of "Matters to be done, in connection
with the 70th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide" of the meeting
agenda and was brought in the agenda by Gorbachov.

K. Demircian, first secretary of the Armenian Communist Party,
had sent a letter to the Central Committee of the Soviet Communist
Party; the subject was talked over in the Central Committee and later
transferred to the agenda of the meeting of the Polit Bureau.

Those present in the meeting, were M.S. Gorbachov, H.A.Aliyev,
V.I.Vorotnikov, V.V.Grisin, A.A. Gromiko, G.V. Romanov, M.S.
Solomontsev, N. Tihonov, P.N. Demircev, V.I. Dolgih, V.V. Kuznetsov,
B.N. Ponomaryov, V.M. Cebrikov, M.M. Zimyanin, I.V. Kapitonov, Y.K.
Ligacev and N.I. Rijkov. Despite the serious efforts of Gorbachov and
Demircian, the Politbureau did not approve to announce April 24th,
as the Memorial Day of Genocide victims. Experienced members of the
Poliutbureau such as N. Tihonov, A. Gromiko, V. Grisin, stood against
this attempt.

We are releasing for the first time an explicit summary of this meeting
statement, stamped "Top Secret". Translation of the contents from
Russian, has been made by Dr. Mayis Alizade. (Note: This translation
into English is made from the article in Turkish and hence any probable
unintended differences should be excused. SSA)

21st February 1985

GORBACHOV: This subject has been discussed in the Secretariat of the
Central Committee. As you are aware, there were no activities in our
country relating to the 50th anniversary of the genocide. Some time
ago, the subject of the 60th year of genocide was discussed with
Leonid Ilic Brejnev and Mihail Andreyevic Suslov. At that time it
was decided to take some actions which were approved. And now in the
year 1985, in the 70th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide which
was organized by Sultan’s Turkey h,as been put on our agenda for
additional action. According to the organs of the Armenian Party,
these suggestions are brought to ell iminate the accusations of the
of the enemies of the people, to secure the position of the people
classes of the Soviet Union relative to this issue and drop them from
the agenda. There is a large fanfare in the bourgeoisie press. The
USA Congress has taken a decision acknowledging 24th April, as a
"Day of Inhumanity and Armenian Genocide". In France and other
countries, the surroundings of administrative parties, are working
actively. The Armenian Communist Party Central Committee, based on
their experience in the 60th anniversary, requests that that the
24th April is acknowledged by the Soviet Socialist Congress Board as
"Remembrance day of genocide victims" and that the Armenian Communist
Party First Secretary makes a speech on the radio and TV and that
these texts are released in the Armenian press.

To be more open, the Secretariat and ourselves, have decided to put
this matter on the agenda for discussion in the Politbureau, in order
to see the plusses and minuses to be created by such a decision of
the Armenian Parliament

* CIA Heats up this Matter

DEMIRCIAN: It has been spoken here that the 70th anniversary of
genocide is being strongly heated up by CIA and other harming
organizations. There is a large campaign to distort history,
conferences are being arranged (also at international level), books
and magazines are being printed and TV programs are aired. Some of
them, approve that the Turks which had passed on the side of Russia,
have been also suppressed. The Dashnaks are strengthening their own
position against the Soviet. The information contained in several
channels, show that these present new dangers and that the ideological
situation may deteriorate more. Therefore, we are asked to take the
necessary counter measures, inclusive of the "Genocide memorial day".

I wish to underline again, that our suggestions, are connected
to the large campaigns carried overseas. With instructions of USA
information organizations and to spread the anti-Soviet animosity,
they are trying to accuse our country and republic for remaining
uninterested in the 1915 incidents. These ideas are spread around,
through the students being educated in our country and Armenians
placed in our country who infiltrate into Armenia. But I trust that
you will support our suggestions so that we are perfectly organized
not to permit usage of the 70th Anniversary of the Armenian Genocide
for purposes against the Soviets.

* "Wouldn’t this increase animosity?"

TIHONOV: What is your opinion, wouldn’t the TV and radio speeches
increase the animosity between Turks and Armenians?

DEMIRCIAN: In this speech we generally speak of the success of the
Soviet Armenia and that the genocide was organized by the powers in
the administration of, Turkey of the Sultans.

GRISIN: On this subject, we have concluded 70 years, without need
of a decision of the Armenian Republic High Committee. Now, we are
asked to take a decision. Why is this necessary?

GROMIKO: We have to discuss this matter objectively, without
sentiments. Of course this was an arrogant murder of Sultan’s Turkey
and Tsarist Russia. But as you know, during the period of Lenin who
presided oure state for six years, these subjects were never brought
on the agenda.

POMAROV: But at that time, a revolution had taken place in Turkey.

* "Tasnak’s tunes, cannot be taken as a basis for us"

GROMIKO: That was a bourgeois revolution. Therefore we are faced with
such a question: Is it necessary for us to make such an accusation
for Turkey? To my opinion, Tashnaks hate the Soviet Rule, more than
they hate the Turks. Hence, they and their tunes cannot be taken an
as a basis by us. And all this, is being done out of our borders,
during the race of winning votes of the Armenians. Therefore, it does
not look convincing to me, to depend on all types of actions such as
this, in other countries. Yet, of course we should find a way out for
expression of feelings of the people. But is it necessary to do this
with the decision of the Armenian Parliament? As you know, we do not
have any ceremonies even on the date of death of Lenin. Therefore,
I am much hesitant on the subject of the decision to be taken by the
Armenian Parliament.

In the report of the Central Committee of the Armenian Communist
Party they suggest that articles are printed in the Soviet Press
relating to genocide. To my opinion, it is necessary that we do not
involve our "heavy cannons" in this matter. Something must be done
in Armenia and the speech of the first secretary of the Central
Committee can be printed as well, but it is not possible that we
approve the rest. If Turks were to build nuclear rockets in their
country, this will form a larger threat. At the end of my comments,
I want to underline the following: Suggestions that have been made,
should be reconsidered, and additional steps to be taken by us should
be reduced to the minimum, after evaluating how dire they are for us.

* "The decision, will form a document of animosity against Turkey"

ZIMYANIN: Such ceremonies, must be made at the level of civilian
organizations, and not the State. It is clear for me that the
decision of the Armenian Parliament will be a document of animosity
against Turkey. This, undoubtedly will strain the Turkish-Russian
relations. We will profit nothing from this. Therefore, Comrade
Demircian and Armenian Communist Party Central Committee should take
the initiative and act according to the classification position of the
people. And all ceremonies must be carried in Armenia, at civilian
level, without any type of attack on Turkey. In general, relating
to the 70th anniversary of the genocide, I support the opinion of
activities at civilian-historical level.

* "Americans will profit from this"

TIHONOV: I am not kidding. When reading the suggestions of the
Armenian Communist party, I am stressed. We are just beginning to put
our relations with Turkey in order. During my visit to this country,
Turkish leaders have named the Soviet Union as a friendly country and
assured that they will not permit installation of rockets in their
country pointed to us. It is clear that the decision of the Armenian
Parliament, will strain the Turkish-Russian relations and will pull
Moscow into the matter, whether we want it or not. I am asking,
who will profit from this ? It is clear that the Americans will profit.

During my last visit to Turkey, the President and Prime Minister of
Turkey, gave examples of the speeches of Armenian authorities, and
complained for 40 minutes for the Turkish antagonism in this country.

We should not permit this. In general sense, we should always remember
that Turkey holds Istanbul and Canakkale straits, and according
to a suitable article of the Montreux treaty, they can always lock
the passages.

On this subject, I read the article printed in "Pravda" in 1975. In
that article, there are only five lines about the genocide. And
this is correct because our country has lived through much greater
calamities. For example, in White Russia, the fascists have killed
one of every four persons.

Our putting relations into order with the Finns, Greeks and Turks,
causes extreme anger of the Americans, and they want to harm
our relations with neighboring countries, using this genocide
anniversary. It would be desirable that in Armenia, the workers
would tirelessly cooperate with party organization at all groups
without tiring, and the matter of international conduct is organized
and controlled better. Therefore, we should think deeper on this
subject and find a solution at lower levels, without effecting the
international relations.

* "For 70 years, we did not take such a decision, and we shouldn’t:

GRISIN: We understand the feelings of our Armenian comrades and
their initiative for genocide anniversary. But I also think that the
international situation , dictates us to act with extreme prudence.

This is because, all decisions taken by American Congress, do not
suit the interests of the Soviet Union and the Soviet Armenia.

Therefore, we should not depend on those decisions. In a general
sense, I have serious doubts regarding the necessity of the Armenian
Parliament’s taking a decision about the genocide day. For 70
years, such a decision has not be taken and we should not take this
decision. May be we can print some articles in the central press,
and breakdown the ambitions of the imperialist powers to foment
nationalistic ambitions. There is one clear matter. We have to
unite the Soviet citizens better, and mobilize the Armenian party
organization to inspire them with an international spirit.

CEBRIKOV: Of course. We have to preserve our previous actions, without
hampering our relations with Turkey. We cannot give up the ceremonies
to which the people is used to.

TIHONOV: But, we never had any such thing at the time of Lenin!

GORBACOV: If we did not have hesitations, the Secretariat would not
have had it included in the agenda of the Politbureau of the Central
Committee. In principle, we should not permit new activities.

KUZNETSOZ: This is correct.

GORBACOV: We could have permitted only an article in "Pravda" reminding
the genocide. As regards the ceremonies in Armenia, in principle, we
should maintaoin our people’s class position and keep their success
in the Soviet Armenia, above the duties, which must be executed by
the communists in Armenia.

Particularly, we as the Communist Party Central Committee, have a
plan for the future development of Erivan, May be such a decision
can be taken on this subject prior to the genocide anniversary.

MEMBERS of the POLITBUREAU: This is correct.

Decision taken and approved.

— WHO is WHO:

M.S. Gorbachov: 1980 -Elected to Politbureau ; 1985- became Party’s
General Secretary when Cermenko died He became President of the State
in 1988

K. Demircian – First Secretary of Armenian Communist Party

N.A. Tihonov: Prime Minister at that time

V.V. Grisin : Soviet Communist Party First Secretary, 1967-1985,
member of Politbureau since 1971

A.A. Gromiko : Elected to Politburea in 1973. Minister of Foreign
Affairs period of 1957 – 1985

B.N. Ponomaryov: Soviet Communist Party Secretary

M.V. Zimyanin: Pravda Newspaper editor in chief

V.M. Cebrikov : Head of KGB

Translated from Turkish "AYDINLIK" weekly, dt. 7.01.07 No.2016

US President Introduced Hoagland’s Candidature For Post Of Armenian

US PRESIDENT INTRODUCED HOAGLAND’S CANDIDATURE FOR POST OF ARMENIAN AMBASSADOR AGAIN

Regnum, Russia
Jan 10 2006

US President George Bush repeatedly introduced Richard Hoagland’s
candidature to the post of US ambassador to Armenia, the Associated
Press reports.

It is worth mentioning, Armenian society was extremely negative about
Richard Hoagland’s candidature after the diplomat presumed statements
denying the Armenian Genocide in the Ottoman Empire in 1915. But,
despite protests of Armenian society including several NGOs, Richard
Hoagland’s candidature proposed by the president was considered and
accepted. New Jersey Senator Robert Menendez said on it that many,
particularly, the US president avoid giving assessment to the villainy
perpetuated in the beginning of last century in Turkey as genocide,
and Hoagland’s appointment can be a step backwards, which is not in
interests of Armenia of the Armenian Diaspora. After the elections to
the Congress in the end of last year, the Senate in accordance with
its regulations returned Hoagland’s candidature to the president that
was blocked earlier. At the same time, Senators Robert Menendez and
Harry Reid called upon the president to introduce another candidate.

Earlier, U.S. Charge d’Affaires Anthony F. Godfrey announced at a
news conference on November 8 that "despite the fact that Armenian
society was negative about Richard Hoagland’s candidature approved
for the position of the US Ambassador to Armenia, the US government
does not consider any other candidature for the post."

BAKU: Officers Of ICRC Visit Captured Azerbaijani Soldier Eldeniz Nu

OFFICERS OF ICRC VISIT CAPTURED AZERBAIJANI SOLDIER ELDENIZ NURIYEV

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 10 2006

The officers of International Committee of Red Cross (ICRC) visited
Azerbaijani soldier Eldeniz Nuriyev for the fourth time that was
captured by Armenians on December 31 and at present being kept
in occupied Azerbaijani territory, ICRC Azerbaijani Office Public
Relations Department officer Gulnaz Gilyeva told APA.

The officer took soldier’s letter written to his family. His letter
should be delivered to his family today. The officers delivered
Azerbaijani soldier Samir Mammdov’s letter to his family yesterday,
Mammadov was captured on December 24. The officers of ICRC monitored
the detention conditions and physical and physiological situation.

It should be noted that, Samir Mammadov was drafted from Barda
Military Registration Department a year ago and captured in neutral
zone- Gazakh-Ijevan territory on December 24. Eldeniz Nuriyev, born
in 1976, was drafted from Aghsu Military Registration Department in
2005 and was captured in the territory of Fuzuli region on December
31. Azerbaijani Defense Ministry declared that the soldiers got lost.

BAKU: Faruk Logoglu: Turkey And Azerbaijan Should Start Joint Fight

FARUK LOGOGLU: TURKEY AND AZERBAIJAN SHOULD START JOINT FIGHT AGAINST ARMENIAN LIES

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 10 2006

"Both the House of Representatives and the Senate are headed by
democrats who used to support Armenians. Submission of the draft law
on so-called Armenian genocide to the House of Representatives was
always prevented.

But now the probability of its submission and approval is high.

Because, we are aware that the House of Representative and the Senate
promised Armenian lobby to consider the issue", former Turkish
ambassador to Azerbaijan and the USA, Eurasia Strategic Research
Center Chairman Faruk Logoglu told APA’s bureau.

He considered that the approval of the draft law on so-called
genocide is impossible as congressmen and senators do not want to harm
Turkish-US relations. Regarding year 2007 as an "intermediate year",
Faruk Logoglu said that 2008 will be more dangerous. As this is the
presidential election year in the USA, Armenians will try to obtain
candidates’ promises. So their chance to legitimate the "Armenian
genocide" will increase. He also pointed out the necessity for all
Turkish governmental organizations, Parliament, political parties
and NGOs to start fight to prevent the approval of the draft law in
the US Congress.

"Turkish delegations should be sent to the USA in order to deliver
truth to the congressmen. Because, they know the issue as Armenians
informed it. Our embassy in the USA will take appropriate steps and
we should join them", he said.

Faruk Logoglu also answered the question on how Azerbaijan and turkey
should join their forces.

"The governmental and non-governmental organizations should work in
coordination. The common target should be productive actions with
the US congressmen", he noted.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Duty Calls For Minority Groups In Cyprus

DUTY CALLS FOR MINORITY GROUPS IN CYPRUS
By Natalie Aoun

Cyprus Mail, Cyprus
Jan 10 2006

MEMBERS of the Maronite, Armenian and Latin communities in Cyprus may
now be forced into compulsory military service after the Permanent
Secretary of the Defence Ministry, Petros Kareklas, met with
representatives of the religious minorities yesterday.

The government intends to change the law, with a final decision to
be taken by the Council of Ministers.

The authorities believe that if approved, the new law will immediately
overturn a 1994 ministerial decision which confirmed the exemption
of minority groups, allowing them to enlist only if they so wished.

Deputies Antonis Hadjiroussos of the Maronites, Vartkes Mahtesian
of the Armenians, and Benito Mantovani of the Latins were yesterday
notified by Kareklas of the new proposal.

Speaking to the Mail, Hadjiroussos said that Kareklas had expressed
some strong opinions as to the necessity for change. Hadjiroussos
stated that he, along with Mahtesian and Mantovani, had never been
negative towards the proposal, but felt that the current need for
change was unjustified with the reasons given by the government.

He added that Kareklas has called for the change as a result of numbers
not being adequate, which has been caused by the significant amount
of Greek Cypriots requesting exemption from the service, claiming to
be suffering from psychological problems.

The Maronite deputy reiterated that no member of a minority group in
Cyprus had been forced to enlist in the service over the past 40 odd
years, with the reasons cited by previous governments as "security
and language issues".

He repeatedly wondered what had caused the recent u-turn.

The government is reported to have been contemplating the change since
last February, when Ombudswoman Iliana Nicolaou received complaints
from young Greek Cypriots who had appealed to her, saying they felt
discriminated against as members of minority groups were excused from
military service.

It is hoped that the proposed change in the law will promote equality
in a democratic system.

Another issue set to be discussed is the long-running saga concerning
those who try to get out of entering the National Guard by claiming to
be suffering from psychological problems. According to the President
of the House Defence Committee, EDEK leader Yiannakis Omirou, the
Committee has agreed on a proposal for another change in the law,
which will ensure that those objecting to serving will instead be
forced into community service.

It is not yet clear as to the length of community service, with some
calling for it to exceed the 26 months currently spent in military
service.

According to Omirou, "the aim will not be to punish those in question
but rather to offer them an alternative".

Azeri FM Set To Attend Next Round Of Talks On Breakaway Karabakh

AZERI FM SET TO ATTEND NEXT ROUND OF TALKS ON BREAKAWAY KARABAKH

RIA Novosti, Russia
Jan 10 2006

BAKU, January 10 (RIA Novosti) – Azerbaijan’s foreign minister will
participate in the next round of negotiations with the Armenian
foreign minister on the breakaway region of Nagorno-Karabakh, a
Foreign Ministry spokesman said Wednesday.

The conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh, which lies within Azerbaijan,
some 270 kilometers (170 miles) west of the capital Baku, first
erupted in 1988 when it declared its independence from Azerbaijan,
and moved to join Armenia.

Over 30,000 people were killed on both sides in fighting between 1988
and 1994, and over 100 died following a 1994 ceasefire.

Nagorno-Karabakh remains under Armenian military control, and tensions
between Azerbaijan and Armenia have persisted as a result.

The meeting between Azerbaijan’s FM Elmar Mamedyarov and Armenia’s
Vardan Oskaryan is scheduled for January 23 in Moscow.

Residents of Nagorno-Karabakh overwhelmingly voted in a referendum on
the republic’s Constitution last month to reaffirm the predominantly
Armenian region’s independence from Azerbaijan.

More than 100 international observers and journalists from Russia,
France, the United States, Italy, Israel, Serbia and other countries
monitored the referendum.

Azerbaijan dismissed the referendum as a farce.

The United States, the European Union and other international
organizations, including the Organization for Security and Cooperation
in Europe (OSCE), said no country will recognize the referendum’s
results.

The Azerbaijani leadership is determined to restore its control over
the separatist region.

ANKARA: Open Letter From Turkish NGOs:Turks Are Ready To Confront Th

OPEN LETTER FROM TURKISH NGOS:TURKS ARE READY TO CONFRONT THEIR HISTORY, ARE ARMENIANS READY TO CONFRONT THE TRUTH?

The New Anatolian, Turkey
Jan 10 2006

Dear Sir, Dear Madam,

As representatives of Turkish 153 Non Governmental Organizations
(NGOs) we would like to express our deep concern and disappointment
regarding the "genocide" accusation inflicted upon our ancestors.

Herewith, we would like to convey our views and the grounds which
oblige us to explain such allegations.

There are accusations from almost all over the world for an "Armenian
genocide" which derive mainly from the prejudiced sources provided by
the Armenian view. There are various reasons why this view of history
has become the accepted wisdom in the world at large. No single issue
moves the Armenian diaspora as much as what has come to be known as
genocide, and many Armenians, having attained positions of wealth and
influence throughout the western world, have made the perpetuation of
this issue their crusade. As a result, virtually all the information
that we have concerning the tragic events of 1915 comes from Armenian
sources, or of their sympathizers. What works to the pro-Armenians’
advantage is that the western world has failed to regard the two
peoples on an equal plane. The much greater suffering endured by the
Muslims of the period has been almost completely ignored.

The inherent prejudice that prevents most people from analyzing these
events with an open mind presents as significant an obstacle today
as it did during the time of the events. It is unfortunate that the
image of the "Terrible Turk" is still alive and well. Those who can
overcome their ingrained bigotry and objectively look at the genuine
evidence soon become aware that what is known as "Turkish propaganda"
stems mainly from sources without reason to be false. These are the
very western sources that have often maintained their prejudices
against the Turkish people, along with internal Ottoman documents
never meant to be public relations exercises. Today’s so-called
genocide scholars overwhelmingly support the Armenian thesis, but
there are very few historians among their ranks. Many conclude there
was genocide first, and then fit selective evidence to support their
conclusion; in effect, working in reverse of what we would normally
expect of genuine scholars.

After the wave of Armenian terrorism hit in the 1970s and 80s,
this subject began to be studied seriously, and many specialists in
Ottoman history came to reject the notion of genocide. For example,
69 Western academicians signed a 1985 statement to that effect.

Targeted increasingly by ad hominem attacks, most were intimidated
away from this debate. As a result, the pro-Armenians have succeeded
in presenting the image that it is only the Turkish government that
has come to "deny" this alleged genocide.

In the face of this malicious campaign to distort history, what stands
out is that pro-Armenians have rarely expressed willingness to engage
in honest debate. One must ask, if they are so certain of their facts,
what have they got to be afraid of? Why, for example, have they refused
to take their case to the International Court of Justice in The Hague?

The truth is that during World War I, when the Ottoman forces
were fighting on five fronts, they also faced an armed uprising of
Armenians. At the instigation and with the support of Czarist Russia,
Armenian insurgents sought to establish an Armenian state in an area
which was predominantly Muslim. With the Russian invasion of eastern
Anatolia, the degree of Armenian collaboration with the Russian enemy
increased dramatically. The Ottoman army’s rear was gravely threatened
when supply lines were cut by Armenian guerilla bands.

Furthermore, Armenian revolutionary bands massacred the Muslims
of the province of Van, in anticipation of the expected arrival of
the invading Russian armies. The Ottoman government’s response was
to order the relocation of its Armenian subjects from the path of
invading Russians and other areas where they might undermine the
Ottoman war effort.

That the Ottoman State’s Armenian minority launched a bloody
insurrection at the very time the country was fighting a World War
goes a long way towards explaining the resultant suffering that was
borne by Armenians and non- Armenians alike. Most of the casualties
from both sides were victims of famine, disease and exposure, as well
as inter-ethnic clashes and regular warfare. A favorite pro-Armenian
source, Ambassador Henry Morgenthau, himself had written that thousands
of Turks were dying daily from starvation because few were left to till
the fields; he estimated an entire quarter of the Turkish population
had died of starvation alone. It is not correct to deem the great
numbers of Armenians who died from the same causes as ‘victims of
genocide’. Ottoman archives which are now open to research without
any restriction contain tens of thousands of documents shedding light
on the relocation process. Among them are a great number of Ottoman
Government directives ordering the governors, military commanders and
other public officials, to implement the relocation in an orderly way,
taking the necessary measures for the security of those who were
being moved, with maximum care for the protection of their lives
and possessions? (However, it is also a fact that orders from the
central government were not always followed by local officials. As
often happens with operations of great magnitude, particularly those
undertaken at the last minute with limited resources and manpower,
not everything went smoothly.)

In the overall implementation of the relocation the nonexistence of
even a disguised intent to kill and destroy is obvious. This could
also be deduced from the following indications: All along the war the
Armenian population continued to exist in most of western Anatolia,
such as in Istanbul and Izmir where the government was in control,
and were not subjected to relocation. Those who were subjected
to relocation had to travel on foot because of lack of proper
transportation and were unfortunately attacked by lawless bands and
other renegade forces. This is the opposite of what one would expect
if there had been a government implemented policy of genocide.

Meanwhile, high level Armenian bureaucrats continued to serve in the
Ottoman government.

Contrary to overriding belief, the great wave of immigration
of Armenians came well after the war was over, and after many had
returned to their homes in what was left of the Ottoman Empire. The
Armenian Patriarch estimated some 645,000 remained as late as 1921.

500,000 had already mostly traveled, on their own accord, to
Transcaucasia alone, according to a UCLA Armenian professor.

Armenians today concede one million survived. The pre-war population
according to most neutral Western sources of the period (such as the
Encyclopedia Britannica) was around 1.5 million. Pro-Armenian claims
that 1.5 million were killed are arithmetically impossible.

Often called the "foremost authority on the Armenian Genocide," Prof.

Vahakn Dadrian himself had written (in Sept. 21, 2004) that "in
1916 … the genocide had all but run its course." He was referring
to the relocation policy, but it is obvious that such a policy in
itself cannot be termed genocide. (Otherwise, the movement of W.W.II
Japanese-Americans would be similarly defined.) The question must
also be asked that if this process was the kind of Hitlerian "Final
Solution" it is often compared to, why should it have come to a halt
so soon?

The 1948 United Nations Convention on Genocide requires "intent"
to be proven. Aside from hearsay, there is absolutely no factual
evidence proving any such thing. Similarly, the Armenians had been
a "political group" aiming to ethnically cleanse the Turks in a
sizeable part of eastern Anatolia, in an effort to establish their
own independent state. "Political groups" are not among the groups
protected under the Genocide Convention.

A "Nuremberg" was held at the end of the war, in the form of the
Malta Tribunal (1919-1921). The British sought the evidence to convict
accused Ottomans, numbering over 144 at one point. The U.S.

State archives were their last resort (significantly, the very
foundation of most "Armenian genocide evidence" today), and the British
Embassy in Washington delivered the following message on July 13, 1921:
"I regret to inform your Lordship that there was nothing therein which
could be used as evidence against the Turks who are being detained for
trial in Malta." Consequently, without going to trial, every single
prisoner was freed. The point here is that the 144 prisoners were
released without any charges being brought. Some 1,600 Turks were,
on the other hand, taken to tribunals and court-martials during the
war in their own country, for crimes against Armenians. Most were
convicted, and over sixty were condemned to death. These actions are
hardly consistent with an intended genocide.

The truth is that the Armenians’ portrayal of themselves as the
helpless victims of "The First Genocide of the 20th Century"
is without any basis. Even that claim is inaccurate; there were
systematic extermination campaigns earlier in the century preceding
the Armenians, as in Albania, South West Africa, and the Philippines.

Often ignored, the Balkan Turks were victims of an enormous ethnic
cleansing campaign, also preceding the Armenian experience. Once again,
it is prejudice that prevents the world at large from recognizing
the tremendous tragedies the Turks suffered.

During 1918-1920, the newly formed Republic of Armenia systematically
exterminated their own Muslims, constituting some 38% of their
population. During and after World War I, the Armenians also killed
over half a million Ottomans, mostly Muslims including the entire
Jewish population of the caucuses, numbers that are documented in
the Ottoman archives. Few Western sources will corroborate this very
unknown tragedy because Muslim and Jewish lives were insignificant. A
British colonel by the name of Wooley, according to the U.S.

Archives, estimated that 300,000-400,000 Ottoman Muslims were killed
by Armenians in three districts alone. What disturbs us most is that
in the midst of deportations, massacres, ethnic cleansing, and other
atrocities, only the deaths of the Armenians is selected and falsely
characterized as genocide. Genocide can briefly be described as
killing people for what they are, rather than what they have done. No
mention is made of the Greek mass murder of Muslims in Anatolia (well
documented), the mass murder of Muslims when the Russians captured
Erzurum (well documented), the mass murder of Muslims in Van (well
documented), and the mass murder of Jews in Van (well documented).

Uniquely the death of the Armenians is singled out and termed genocide
with lack of any reliable documentation. Turkey does not make light of
its appalling treatment of the Armenians but it seems that governments
in the west have chosen to ignore the deaths of innocent Muslims,
let alone accept that these cases were genocide: government sponsored
elimination of thousands of civilians for no other reason than that
they belonged to a particular religion.

If Armenia adopts a realistic attitude and is not fearful of
confronting its past, a mixed commission to investigate the issue
could be established. In this context, first, the two parties should
set up a mixed committee of Turkish and Armenian historians. Second,
they should declare that they will open their respective archives
without any restriction on research. Third, representatives from an
international organization, for instance UNESCO, should be a part of
this process, assuming the role of public notary.

If the Armenian side is truly certain about the righteousness of
its claim, it should not hesitate to espouse this proposal and thus
contribute to bringing clarity to this period of our mutual history.

Yours sincerely, On behalf of the joint 153 NGOs’ initiative
Prof. Dr. Aysel Eksi [email protected]

Banking System Provides Services To 768,539 People In October

BANKING SYSTEM PROVIDES SERVICES TO 768539 PEOPLE IN OCTOBER

Arka News Agency, Armenia
Jan 10 2006

YEREVAN, January 10. /ARKA/. The number of people who got Armenian
banking system’s services has grown 8663 over October 2006 to 768539,
National Statistical Service says.

Of them, 39473 were legal entities and 729066 individuals.

As of October 31, 929503 accounts were registered in Armenian
commercial banks, of which 872019 were individuals’ accounts.

Armenian Savings Bank has 3469465 clients.

The rest of the accounts attracted by banks from the republic
population reached AMD 110546 million after growing by 2520mln or 2.3%
over the month and by 22997mln por 26.2% compared with the same month
a year earlier. ($1 – AMD 365.05).

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Antelias: HH Aram I Proclaims 2007 "Year of The Armenian Language"

PRESS RELEASE
Catholicosate of Cilicia
Communication and Information Department
Contact: V.Rev.Father Krikor Chiftjian, Communications Officer
Tel: (04) 410001, 410003
Fax: (04) 419724
E-mail: [email protected]
Web:

PO Box 70 317
Antelias-Lebanon

Armenian version:

HIS HOLINESS ARAM I PROCLAIMS 2007
"THE YEAR OF THE ARMENIAN LANGUAGE"

In line with a previously established tradition, His Holiness Aram I
proclaimed 2007 to be the "Year of the Armenian Language." The Pontiff’s
Encyclical will be read during the Sunday Mass in the St. Gregory the
Illuminator Cathedral on January 17.

In 2007 The Catholicosate of Cilicia and all its dioceses and institutions
will focus on the Armenian language. Several events and initiatives
organized by the Catholicosate, its dioceses and Armenian schools in the
Armenian communities throughout the Diaspora will bring under the spotlight
the Armenian language, its preservation and development and specially its
correct usage by the new generations.

The Catholicos’ Encyclical will be read from the altars of all the churches
in the dioceses of the Catholicosate of Cilicia during the next few weeks,
inviting the Armenian nation to reassess the unique importance of their
mother language in Armenian life both in Armenia and the Diaspora.

##
The Armenian Catholicosate of Cilicia is one of the two Catholicosates of
the Armenian Orthodox Church. For detailed information about the history and
mission of the Cilician Catholicosate, you may refer to the web page of the
Catholicosate, The Cilician Catholicosate, the
administrative center of the church is located in Antelias, Lebanon.

http://www.cathcil.org/
http://www.cathcil.org/v04/doc/Armenian.htm
http://www.cathcil.org/

ANCA Opposes Pres. Bush’s Re-nomination of Hoagland

Armenian National Committee of America
1711 N Street NW
Washington, DC 20036
Tel. (202) 775-1918
Fax. (202) 775-5648
Email [email protected]
Internet

PRESS RELEASE
January 10, 2007
Contact: Elizabeth S. Chouldjian
Tel: (202) 775-1918

ANCA OPPOSES PRESIDENT’S RE-NOMINATION OF HOAGLAND

— Controversial Nominee for U.S. Ambassador to
Armenia was Blocked in the 109th Congress

" It would serve neither our national interests
nor the U.S.-Armenia relationship to expect
Ambassador-designate Hoagland to carry out his
duties under these highly contentious and
profoundly troubling circumstances."
— Senator Menendez and Reid, 12/1/06

WASHINGTON, DC – The Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA),
today, voiced its opposition to President Bush’s re-nomination of
Richard Hoagland – a controversial diplomat whose denial of the
Armenian Genocide generated widespread Congressional and Armenian
American community opposition culminating in a Senatorial "hold" of
his previous nomination in the recently concluded 109th Congress.

In a letter circulated today on Capitol Hill, ANCA Chairman Ken
Hachikian called on U.S. Senators to prevent Hoagland’s approval –
stressing that, " A genocide denier must not – and should never –
represent America in Armenia, a nation that rose from the ashes of
genocide."

The Hoagland nomination faced bipartisan opposition in the 109th
Congress – and was ultimately blocked by a parliamentary "hold"
placed by Senator Bob Menendez (D-NJ) – after he disqualified
himself as an acceptable choice by denying the Armenian Genocide.
In written statements, offered in response to questions posed to
him during his confirmation hearing, he went far beyond the bounds
of the Administration’s already deeply flawed policy, actually
calling into question the Armenian Genocide as a historical fact.

A recent poll of Armenian Americans found that 97% opposed the
Hoagland nomination. Ninety-four percent of the respondents said
that they "strongly agreed" with the Senate’s opposition to his
nomination. An additional 3% noted that they "somewhat agreed"
with this opposition. One percent reported that they "somewhat
disagreed" with opposing Hoagland, and 2% indicated that they
"strongly disagreed" with the opposition to his confirmation.

In voting against his confirmation in the Senate Foreign Relations
Committee, Senator Norm Coleman (R-MN) noted last September that,
"I cannot imagine an Ambassador to Israel being effective without
talking about the Holocaust. I am not sure how we can continue to
have Ambassadors to Armenia who can be effective, unless they give
recognition to the Genocide."

In announcing his "hold" last September, the New Jersey legislator
cited the principled stand taken by former U.S. Ambassador John
Evans, who was fired for speaking truthfully about the Armenian
Genocide, underscoring his "great concerns that Mr. Hoagland’s
confirmation would be a step backward."

Citing the opposition of the Armenian American community and the
growing controversy within Congress surrounding the nomination,
Senator Menendez was joined on December 1st by incoming Senate
Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) in calling on President George W.
Bush to withdraw the Hoagland nomination and propose a new
candidate to serve in this important diplomatic post. They
stressed that, in light of the broad-based concerns within
Congress, the extensive media coverage this issue has received, and
the strong stand of the Armenian American community against the
nomination, "it would serve neither our national interests nor the
U.S.-Armenia relationship to expect Ambassador-designate Hoagland
to carry out his duties under these highly contentious and
profoundly troubling circumstances."

On December 8th of last year, after the Senate failed to confirm
Hoagland, his nomination was returned to the President upon the
adjournment of the 109th Congress. With the expiration of the
Hoagland nomination, the President was free to offer a new
candidate for this diplomatic posting in the 110th Congress, but
chose instead to submit the same one, despite strong Congressional
opposition to his confirmation.

More than half of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and more
than 60 U.S. Representatives have raised concerns about the
Hoagland nomination and the State Department’s refusal to explain
the controversial firing of his predecessor, John Marshall Evans,
for speaking truthfully about the Armenian Genocide. The
Department of State has also failed to offer any meaningful
explanation of the role that the Turkish government played in the
Evans issue.

The full text of ANCA Chairman Ken Hachikian’s letter follows.

#####

January 10, 2007

Dear Senator:

I am writing to encourage you to prevent the approval of Richard
Hoagland, a deeply controversial candidate whom President Bush –
over widespread opposition – has re-nominated to serve as U.S.
Ambassador to Armenia.

As you know, the Hoagland nomination was blocked in the 109th
Congress after he disqualified himself as an acceptable choice by
denying the Armenian Genocide. His written statements, offered in
response to questions posed to him during his confirmation hearing,
went far beyond the bounds of the Administration’s already deeply
flawed policy, actually calling into question the Armenian Genocide
as a historical fact. Ambassador-designate Hoagland has since not
provided an unambiguous public statement affirming that he does not
question the clear genocidal intent of the Ottoman Turkish
government against its Armenian population.

His statements are all the more troubling in light of the White
House’s continued refusal to explain why it fired the previous U.S.
Ambassador to Armenia, John Evans, or to reveal the role that
Turkey played in his dismissal. It has been widely reported that
Ambassador Evans was fired for speaking truthfully about the
Armenian Genocide at a community event. The State Department has
denied being pressured by Turkey to fire Ambassador Evans; yet,
U.S. Department of Justice filings demonstrate Turkey’s foreign
agent registering multiple complaints with State Department
officials on this matter.

In a letter sent to the Secretary of State in December, Majority
Leader Harry Reid and Senator Robert Menendez, who has placed a
hold on this nomination, called on the Administration to offer a
new candidate for this important post, noting the broad-based
concerns within Congress, the extensive media coverage the
nomination has received, and the strong stand of the Armenian
American community against the nomination. They stressed that: "It
would serve neither our national interests nor the U.S.-Armenia
relationship to expect Ambassador-designate Hoagland to carry out
his duties under these highly contentious and profoundly troubling
circumstances."

More than half of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and over
60 U.S. Representatives have raised concerns about the Hoagland
nomination and the controversial firing of his predecessor. In a
recent poll, 97% of Armenian Americans supported Senate efforts to
block the Hoagland nomination.

Based on these considerations, I respectfully call on you to
publicly oppose the Hoagland nomination and to use all the means at
your disposal to prevent his confirmation. A genocide denier must
not – and should never – represent the United States in Armenia – a
nation that rose from the ashes of genocide.

Thank you for your consideration of the concerns of the Armenian
American community on this matter. We would, of course, be pleased
to meet with you to discuss this matter in person, or to forward to
you additional materials in support of our request. If you have
any questions, please contact the Armenian National Committee of
America at (202) 775-1918 or [email protected].

Sincerely yours,

Kenneth V. Hachikian
Chairman

www.anca.org