Love For Those Just Across The Border

LOVE FOR THOSE JUST ACROSS THE BORDER

Kommersant, Russia
Jan 16 2007

// A Survey Looks at Russian Attitudes Towards the Ethnic Groups of
the Former USSR

A public opinion poll commissioned by Kommersant from the All-Russia
Public Opinion Research Center (VTsIOM) shows that rumors of growing
feelings of nationalism in Russia may have been grossly over-inflated,
at least with regard to attitudes towards people from the former
Soviet republics.

Residual Internationalism

The year 2006 in Russia was marred by massive unrest in the small
northern city of Kondopoga; still more xenophobic murders around
the country; checks of people in schools and casinos on the basis
of nationality; inspections of and bans on wine, mineral water,
and other products on a similar basis of nationality; the slogan
"the Russian market is for Russians"; and the regularly-scheduled
(though it was officially banned this time around) fascist parade in
Moscow on National Unity Day.

Under these circumstances, it was decided to compile the results
of a public opinion poll on the attitudes of Russians towards the
constituent nationalities of the former USSR. The fifteen republics
were Russia, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Belarus, Ukraine, Moldova,
Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan,
Tajikistan, and Kazakhstan.

However, the poll, in which people living in Russia were asked to
evaluate their feelings towards the fifteen titular ethnic groups
of the former Soviet republics, showed that the Soviet legacy of
internationalist education remains reasonably strong (here it is
tempting to add the entirely un-Soviet exclamation "Thank God!").

The overall ratings of attitudes towards the fifteen nationalities
all fell between 3.48 and 3.92 on a five-point scale similar to
the one familiar to all Russians from primary school, where a grade
of one is extremely poor and a grade of five is outstanding. Thus,
those in Russia appear to tend predominantly towards neutrality in
their relations with people from the former republics, including
other ethnic Russians.

Care should be taken not to evaluate the poll results with either
undue optimism or excessive pessimism. On the one hand, certain
artifacts of sociological research are well-known, such as the
tendency of respondents to attempt to show themselves to their best
advantage when answering poll questions. For example, to the question
"Who is your favorite composer?", a person will answer "Mozart", even
though he or she actually prefers to listen to cheesy pop stations
on the radio. It is possible that many of those who were polled were
attempting to present themselves as more internationally-minded and
less xenophobic than they really are. Even if this is the case,
however, that means that Russian society currently looks upon
nationalism as something unseemly, something indecent about which it
is better to keep quiet – like a habit of urinating in the stairwell
of your apartment building. Such an attitude towards racism and
xenophobia is not entirely a bad thing.

On the other hand, the largest number of negative responses concerning
attitudes towards a given nationality was almost 18%.

Logically, then, at least one person in five in Russia is infected
with nationalism. In addition, the poll did not include questions
regarding several ethnic groups that are considered traditional
targets of nationalist and racist attitudes, so the discovery of a
high level of xenophobia in 18% of respondents may be an underestimate.

However, the hostile 18% is almost always balanced by a similarly-sized
friendly faction. Relations with all of the ethnicities included in
the poll were graded as "very good" or "excellent" by 13% or more of
respondents. The two roughly balanced factions thus paint an overall
picture of neutrality.

It is probably not necessary to comment at length on the distribution
of the different ethnic groups across the rankings, since the results
are all fairly predictable. In first place, the Russians humbly placed
themselves, followed by Belarussians (a union between the two countries
exists in the minds of many people, even if not in reality). Third
place went to the Ukrainians. The second-to-last place is shared by
Georgians and Lithuanians, and the Estonians come in last. The poor
showing by all three of the Baltic nationalities is in keeping with
the fact that these nations were the first to want to leave and, in
fact, the first to quit the "indissoluble" Soviet Union. In personal
relations, that is often called just plain not getting along.

The lowest percentage of positive responses was received by the Kyrgyz
(13.74%), and the highest percentage of negative responses targeted
Georgians (17.7%).

Of the non-Slavic nationalities, the largest percentage of positive
evaluations was reported for the Azerbaijanis (19.34%), and the
Kazakhs enjoyed the lowest fraction of negative appraisals (6.43%).

Where Internationalists and Xenophobes Live

Let us take a look at who most often claimed to have a positive
opinion of the nationalities of the former USSR.

People with "excellent" attitudes towards other ethnic groups
tended to be between 35 and 44 years of age, while pensioners were
the least likely to have a positive outlook on members of foreign
nationalities. Predominant among respondents who said that they
get along well with people of any nationality are those with less
than a high school education. The most popular occupation for these
internationally-minded individuals is as unskilled laborers. Many
unemployed people also claimed to have good relations with other
nationalities. Internationalists tend to live mainly in large
cities, particularly Moscow and St. Petersburg, and they are also
well-represented in the Northwestern and Far-Eastern federal regions.

Their ranks are fairly evenly split between men and women.

The army and the police love the Ukrainians (not a single negative
comment about people from Ukraine was recorded from representatives
of any of the armed or police forces), while the Belarussians are
the darlings of the business world. Almost no housewife sees a reason
to dislike the Georgians, and the Moldavians and the Kazakhs receive
top marks from unemployed people.

People who described their material situation as very good ("I can buy
an apartment or a car") also turned out to have strong internationalist
leanings. This small group of citizens refrained almost entirely from
making negative comments about people of any ethnicity.

Moving on to those who admitted to having "poor" and "very poor"
relations with their neighbors just across the border, we find that
men and women again each make up around 50% of respondents. In what
may be symptomatic of a worrisome trend, most of them are between
the ages of 15 and 24. Educationally, they are predominantly high
school or vocational academy graduates, and they are chiefly employed
as skilled laborers or as specialists with a college degree who
work in the sciences or the arts. Those involved in business take a
particularly dim view of Azerbaijanis, while students in high school
and vocational schools agree with residents of Far-Eastern Siberia
in their dislike of Ukrainians. The military and police forces have
few kind words for Moldavians. The number of people in Moscow and St.

Petersburg who do not like Armenians and Georgians is unbelievably high
(around 40% and 35%, respectively), and those from the Baltic states
are also unpopular in the two capital cities. Those who most vehemently
dislike people from anywhere in Central Asia are concentrated in the
Volga River region.

For table, see

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.kommersant.com/p-9834/

ANKARA: Insincerity Stemming From The US Raid In Arbil

INSINCERITY STEMMING FROM THE US RAID IN ARBIL
by Semih Idiz

Milliyet, Turkey
Jan 15 2007

Turkish Press Warns Against Turkey-USA-Iraq Confrontation Scenario

The [11 January] raid by US forces on an Arbil office where
Iranians worked and the detention of the people there on suspicion of
"supporting terrorist activities" is interpreted in Ankara as "a sign
of American insincerity".

This event and other recent developments also explain why Prime
Minister Erdogan has accused the United States, which he once called
"our so-called strategic partner," of not being serious in the battle
against the PKK [Kurdistan Workers’ Party].

This is because the raid in Arbil – like the Al-Sulaymaniyah raid that
has gone down in our history as the "hooding incident" – shows that
the US army, which insists that it has "only limited room for military
action" in northern Iraq, can find "room for action" when it wants.

The Arbil raid also refutes the argument that American forces "do not
want to take action against the PKK in order not to anger the local
Kurdish administration." That is because the Kurds insist that the
Iranians who have been detained were there with the knowledge of the
Baghdad government and are upset about the raid.

‘Stay Away from Iran’

In this regard, Iraq’s Kurdish Foreign Minister, Hoshyar Zebari,
disclosed that the liaison office where the detained Iranians were
working has been active in the country for ten years.

Kurdish observers also find it interesting that this raid occurred soon
after the visit Iraqi President Jalal Talabani paid to Iran a short
while ago with the purpose of building new ties with that country. In
sum, this raid is interpreted as a message of "stay away from Iran"
addressed to the Kurds.

Naturally, all these are noted down in Ankara. The anger of the Turkish
side is further fuelled by information that PKK militants on Mount
Kandil have access to various facilities, chiefly health care centres,
in northern Iraqi cities – with the knowledge of the US forces.

Another aggravating factor is that PKK leaders are able to hold press
conferences for the foreign media without any fear of being caught.

In sum, Turkish-US relations will evidently grow even more tense when
the PKK resumes its attacks in the spring. Since this would coincide
with the time when allegations of Armenian genocide will resurface in
the US Congress, bilateral relations are likely to sink to the bottom.

No Support Over PKK

It is now very clear that at this stage the United States will not
offer any support to Turkey on the issue of battling PKK terrorism.

Washington has also invalidated its own excuses for its inaction on
this issue with steps such as the Arbil raid.

If Turkish-American relations have any "strategic importance" left
in them for either side – and these developments make it hard for
us to answer in the affirmative – then the two sides need to create
a political climate that will contribute to their mutual interests
without delay.

Otherwise, it is not inconceivable that the Turkish government and
army might declare the United States, already seen as an "enemy"
by the Turkish people, as an "adversary" more explicitly and the two
sides might confront each other in a dangerous setting in northern
Iraq. This dangerous prospect, which was "inconceivable" in the past,
is on the verge of taking on the status of "certainly possible."

Turkish Nationalists Hacked Website Of Belgian Defence Ministry

TURKISH NATIONALISTS HACKED WEBSITE OF BELGIAN DEFENCE MINISTRY

De Standaard website, Belgium
15 Jan 2007

"Turkish nationalists hack website of Federal Defence Department",

A group of Turkish nationalists hacked the website of the Federal
Defence Department for a while on Sunday [14 January]. The hackers
identified themselves as the "grandchildren of the Ottoman Empire".

The Defence Ministry will lodge a complaint.

On Sunday, the Defence Ministry’s website displayed an unusual page
signed "Hacked by VolTigoRe – Turk Forcers". The normal homepage
had been replaced by a text posted by Turkish hackers. The hackers
wrote in bad English that they are defenders of Islam. The hackers
also mentioned the 1915-17 Armenian genocide and claimed that "the
Turks had been compelled to defend themselves against the Armenians,
who had killed many Turks".

In addition, the hackers wrote that "there is no Kurdish problem
in Turkey" and that the PKK [Kurdish Workers’ Party] is a terrorist
movement that is receiving foreign support. The hackers ended their
text by threatening that they "will never stop hacking your websites
whenever mistakes vis-a-vis Turkey are being made".

This text disappeared later in the day. The website was inaccessible
as of 1330 [1230 gmt]. According to a defence employee, it was to go
back online in the course of the day, but he was unable to say around
what time this would happen.

Defence Ministry will lodge complaint

The Belgian Defence Ministry will lodge a complaint against the group
of Turkish nationalists.

According to Ingrid Baeck, the ministry’s spokesperson, the hacked
website – [1] – does not contain confidential information.

The site is managed by the general directorate for public relations
and image building. The Defence Ministry immediately launched an
investigation to find out how the internet pirates had managed to
hack the site. "We will take additional measures to avoid this from
happening again," Baeck said.

The defence spokeswoman added that websites of other foreign defence
departments, including that of the Pentagon, also fell victim to
hackers in the past.

www.mil.be

Armenian Minister, OSCE Official Discuss Preparations For Polls

ARMENIAN MINISTER, OSCE OFFICIAL DISCUSS PREPARATIONS FOR POLLS

Mediamax, Armenia
15 Jan 2007

Yerevan, 15 January: Armenian Foreign Minister Vardan Oskanian and
the director of the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human
Rights (ODIHR), Ambassador Christian Strohal, discussed issues of
organizing the forthcoming parliamentary election at a meeting in
Yerevan today.

The sides noted the importance of conducting the election in a free
and fair atmosphere. In this context, the OSCE’s role in drawing up
Armenia’s Electoral Code, re-training electoral agencies and rendering
them with expertise was also noted.

They expressed the hope that Armenia will successfully continue the
process of bringing up its legislation into line with the modern
international norms as well as legal and judicial reforms that will
ensure fully-fledged protection of human right.

jan/17

Sunday, January 14, 2007
*****************************************
THE GOOD, THE BAD, THE UGLY,
AND THE ARMENIAN
*************************************************
When it comes to races, nations, and tribes, there are no good guys and bad guys. There are only good and bad human beings, and more often than not, the bad are misguided dupes.
*
To be human means to be prone to error, especially when one is sure to be right. “I may be right” is closer to “I may be wrong” than to “I am right!”
*
It takes a lot of hatred to love one’s country – hatred of past and present enemies, hatred of those who are or have been on their side, hatred of fellow countrymen who do not share one’s love to the same degree, and hatred of those who believe in the brotherhood of all men, which also means hatred of tolerance.
*
To be a good patriot also means to feel guilty by association whenever a fellow countryman is arrested and makes headlines. But guilt by association is a racist concept. Hitler was a racist. Buddha and Christ were not. You may now draw your own conclusions.
*
To fall in love means to kill the rest of mankind, said Camus. If you say that’s going too far, let’s say, passionate love makes us indifferent to the fate of others. But indifference is worse than hatred. In hatred we are connected to those we hate. In indifference this connection is severed.
*
Our enemies “fail to see us as what we really are – a bunch of traumatized half-hysterical refugees and survivors haunted by dreadful nightmares…” I am now quoting from HOW TO CURE A FANATIC (New York, 2006) by Amos Oz. I should like to see one of our Turcocentric pundits produce such a sentence.
#
Monday, January 15, 2007
****************************************
ON BELIEF SYSTEMS
AND RELATED ATROCITIES
*****************************************************
It is in life as it is in lottery: for every winner there will be several million losers. An optimist hopes to win; a realist is aware of the odds and does not believe in miracles; and a pessimist knows it’s a racket.
*
I believe in miracles. I believe the universe to be the greatest miracle of all beside which changing water to wine is no better than an abracadabra trick.
*
Speaking of miracles and abracadabra: I don’t believe which is better or worse: believing in a past messiah or in a future one. As for prophets and belief systems: I see nothing wrong with any of them provided their followers don’t kill one another or themselves.
*
I believe any belief system that legitimizes murder and suicide to be an instrument of the devil.

Not all Turks are born killers or denialists. There is no doubt about that anymore. Likewise, not all Armenians bear a racist grudge against all Turks. With one difference. No Armenian of Pamuk’s or Akjam’s stature has produced a work to point out that fact. If he did, he would be ostracized and silenced as a traitor to the Cause. In that sense, Turks are ahead of us.
*
To kill and die for one’s country fighting an enemy who also kills and dies for his own: does that make any sense to you? I am against capital punishment but I would make an exception of all those guilty of legitimizing and promoting the idea of killing and dying for one’s country.
*
Of the many forms of illusion – I am smarter than you, I understand more than you do, my dick is bigger than yours – surely the most widely entertained and dangerous must be “My god is better than yours.”
#
Tuesday, January 16, 2007
*****************************************
NOTES AND COMMENTS
*************************************
To contradict is not the same as to disagree. Some people contradict automatically, unthinkingly, instinctively – that’s their way of asserting superior wisdom. To pretend to be wiser than one is: I would call that the most universal of all temptations.
*
When we think of experiencing life, we may delude ourselves into thinking that a man who has climbed Everest, or amassed a vast fortune, or slept with two thousand women has experienced life. But what if in the process of doing these things he has succeeded only in diminishing his capacity to feel, to understand, to love, and ultimately, to experience.
*
I once heard someone reading to an audience from one of my books. My first reaction was to beg him to stop. I have a horror of boring people. I would have given up writing years ago were it not for the fact that even people who hate me, read me – judging by the number of abusive e-mails I get.
*
Elfriede Jelinek in THE PIANO TEACHER: “The opposite sex always wants the exact opposite.”
#
Wednesday, January 17, 2007
***********************************************
THE ART OF LIVING
********************************
Wisdom or the art of living consists in minimizing the guesswork and replacing total ignorance with partial knowledge.
*
We may learn to limit the number of our blunders but we have no control over the blunders of others. Which may explain the tragic fate of some of the wisest men that ever lived, from Socrates to Gandhi.
*
And speaking of Christ: if there is a moral in the story of Christianity it is that, not even god can survive human blunders. As for the wisdom of American presidents: in his SHADOW PEOPLE: INSIDE HISTORY’S MOST NOTORIOUS SECRET SOCIETIES, John Lawrence Reynolds writes that the feud between Shiites and Sunnis began in the 7th Century, which means it has lasted for 1,400 years. You may now draw your own conclusions.
*
The universe is the greatest miracle of all – no doubt about that. I may have mentioned that already. What I may have failed to mention is that the second greatest miracle from where I stand is the fact that I have survived, and I have survived not only World War II, the Greek Civil War that followed, and a number of other natural and man-made disasters, but my own blunders.
*
It has been said that the only reality we can come to grips with is the future. There isn’t much we can do about the past. The present is only a fleeting moment that even as we experience it has become the past. It follows, our struggle is with something that is prey to countless factors most of which remain beyond our perception and control.
#

NKR Returned The Azeri Soldier

NKR RETURNED THE AZERI SOLDIER

ArmRadio.am
16.01.2007 15:12

Today the Nagorno Karabakh Republic returned the Azerbaijani serviceman
Eldaniz Nuriev, born in 1976, to the Azeri side, President of the State
Commission on Captives of War and Missing Persons Viktor Kocharyan
told Armenpress.

Let us remind that Nuriev had crossed the Armenian-Azerbaijani border
on December 31, 2006, explaining his step by the fact that he was
oppressed in the Azeri Army and he no more wished to serve in the
Armed Forces of Azerbaijan.

Nevertheless, the captive expressed will to return to Azerbaijan and
with the agreement of both sides the International Committee of the
Red Cross organized his return.

It’s worth mentioning the Nuriev was the second Azeri soldier to
cross the Armenian-Azerbaijani border.

Opening Of Armenian-Turkish Border Will Help To Form Atmosphere Of T

OPENING OF ARMENIAN-TURKISH BORDER WILL HELP TO FORM ATMOSPHERE OF TRUST BETWEEN TWO COUNTRIES, RA DEPUTY FOREIGN MINISTER STATES

Noyan Tapan
Jan 15 2006

YEREVAN, JANUARY 15, NOYAN TAPAN. "In order to establish stability and
security and to develop cooperation in the region, it is necessary
that Turkey establish equal relations with all the South Caucasian
countries and give up its policy of forcing Armenia out of regional
programs, including economic ones," the RA Deputy Foreign Minister
Arman Kirakosian stated during the international conference "The
Social and Economic Consequences of Opening of the Armenian-Turkish
Border" on January 13. He said that Armenia has repeatedly stated
its willingness to establish diplomatic relations with Turkey without
any preconditions.

However, according to him, instead of solving the problem of
establishing diplomatic relations and opening the border, Turkey
puts forward a number of preconditions, the main one of which is the
final resolution of the Karabakh conflict. "In fact Turkey prefers
maintaining its solidarity with Azerbaijan to forming an atmosphere
of trust and cooperation in the region," A. Kirakosian stated.

The deputy minister noted that the Armenian authorities attach great
importance to opening the Armenian-Turkish border, which will not
only be useful for the economies of the two countries but will also
have a positive impact on development of the regional cooperation in
the South Caucasus. A. Kirakosian expressed an opinion that opening
the border will help to form an atmosphere of mutual trust between
Armenia and Turkey and to create more favorable conditions for the
solution of political problems.

The US Charge D’Affaires Anthony Godfrey made a speech at the beginning
of the conference. He stated that the US assists with opening the
Armenian-Turkish border. "Both peoples will benefit from this, the
border’s opening will promote stability in the region," he said.

Experts, scientists and businessmen from Armenia and Turkey
participated in the conference organized on the intiative of the
Armenian International Policy Research Group.

OSCE Odihr Director Hopes That Armenia To Successfully Continue Lega

OSCE ODIHR DIRECTOR HOPES THAT ARMENIA TO SUCCESSFULLY CONTINUE LEGAL AND JUDICIAL REFORMS

Noyan Tapan
Jan 16 2007

YEREVAN, JANUARY 16, NOYAN TAPAN. RA Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian
received on January 16 Ambassador Christian Shtrohal, the Director
of the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights,
who is in Yerevan on a two-day visit.

Welcoming the guests, the Minister mentioned that the Armenian
authorities estimate as positive the OSCE ODIHR activity in the process
of development of democracy in Armenia and attached importance to
Mr.Shtrohal’s visit on the threshold of elections.

As Noyan Tapan was informed by the RA Foreign Ministry’s Press and
Information Department, Ambassador Shtrohal emphasized that the goal of
the visit is to discuss the cooperation of the OSCE ODIHR and Armenia
and issues relating to the coming parliamentary elections of Armenia.

Attaching importance to free and just holding of elections, the sides
touched upon the process of improvement of the electoral system in
Armenia, emphasizing the OSCE role in the issue of working out the
Electoral Code in Armenia, re-training of electoral bodies and showing
them expert’s assistance.

The interlocutors expressed a hope that Armenia will successfully
continue the process of making the inner legislation, reforms of
the legal and judicial system corresponding to modern international
standards, which will support complete security of the human rights
protection.

Reference: Christian Shtrohal was born in 1951 in Vienna. He studied
law, economy, international relations in institutions of higher
education of Vienna, London and Geneva. He started his diplomatic
career in 1975. He was the Ambassador of Austria to Luxemburg in
2000-2003, has been the Director of the OSCE Office for Democratic
Institutions and Human Rights since 2003.

Married, has 3 children.

This Year First Elections Of Local Self-Government Bodies Take Place

THIS YEAR FIRST ELECTIONS OF LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT BODIES TAKE PLACE IN SYUNIK

Noyan Tapan
Jan 16 2007

KAPAN, JANUARY 16, NOYAN TAPAN. The this year first elections of the
local self-government bodies took place on January 14 in the marz
of Syunik, in the rural communities of Antarashat and Dzorastan,
the region of Kapan. As the Noyan Tapan correspondent was informed by
Ramela Hakobian, the Secretary of No38 district electoral commission
of Syunik, 61 people of the 74 voters of the community of Dzorastan
participated in the vote unanimously voted for the only nominated
candidate, acting village head, non-partisan Avetis Avetisian.

All the 4 non-partisan candidates nominated for the councilor of the
community of Antarashat were elected.

Davit Shahnazarian: "Present Authorities’ Efforts In Direction Of Op

DAVIT SHAHNAZARIAN: "PRESENT AUTHORITIES’ EFFORTS IN DIRECTION OF OPENING OF BORDER WITH TURKEY ARE NOT ENOUGH"

Noyan Tapan
Jan 16 2007

YEREVAN, JANUARY 16, NOYAN TAPAN. Putting of the problem of the
international recognition of the Armenian Genocide in the basis of
the foreign policy of Armenia damages interests of Armenia. Davit
Shahnazarian, a member of the Armenian National Movement (ANM)
party board expressed such an opinion at the January 15 press
conference. In his words, the present authorities of Armenia are
not able with such a diplomacy to carry out policy arising of the
people’s interests. D.Shahnazarian mentioned that during the European
Union-Turkey negotiations a favourable period for building relations
with Turkey was created, which was not used in the right way by the
Armenian authorities.

In D.Shahnazarian’s words, because of wrong foreign policy, Armenia
has remained already for few months without a U.S. Ambassador, more,
it became a factor of instability in the region. He also emphasized
that efforts of the present administration in the direction of opening
of the border with Turkey are not enough.

Touching upon the Karabakh problem, D.Shahnazarian mentioned that the
phasal variant proposed still during the years of the ANM power is
put into circulation today. According to this variant the Nagorno
Karabakh status issue will be decided in the last stage. But, in
words of the ANM board member, R.Kocharian and I.Aliyev attempt to
delay the issue settlement. According to D.Shahnazarian’s prevision,
if "these authoritarian orders" are kept in Armenia and Azerbaijan,
a war will start between the two countries.