Armenian Courts Allowed To Challenge Utility Fees

ARMENIAN COURTS ALLOWED TO CHALLENGE UTILITY FEES
By Astghik Bedevian

Radio Liberty, Czech Rep.
Jan 16 2007

In a largely symbolic setback for the government, Armenia’s
Constitutional Court rescinded on Tuesday a legal provision preventing
citizens from challenging utility tariffs set by state regulators in
lower courts.

Acting on an appeal filed by 30 parliamentarians, the court declared
unconstitutional a relevant clause in an Armenian law regulating the
work of the Public Services Regulatory Commission (PSRC).

The state body has the exclusive authority to set the price of
electricity, gas and other utilities. Under the existing law, its
decisions are not subject to any appeal.

The legal challenge against it was initiated late last month
by the opposition Orinats Yerkir party of former parliament
speaker Artur Baghdasarian which says the existing utility fees are
disproportionately high. The move was widely construed as the start of
Orinats Yerkir’s preparations for this year’s parliamentary elections.

Making the plaintiffs’ case in the court, Hovannes Markarian, an
Orinats Yerkir lawmaker, said the PSRC should have revised the utility
prices downwards given the dramatic appreciation of the national
currency, the dram, in recent years. He said Armenians should be able
to stop utility companies making extra profits at their expense.

But lawyers from the Armenian parliament’s staff defended the
controversial legal clause. "As an independent state body, the Public
Service Regulatory Commission is not accountable to any branch of
government," one of them, Ashot Khachatrian, said. "Therefore, we
believe that the impossibility of appealing against tariffs in no
way violates the constitution and the principle of the separation
of powers."

The nine judges of the Constitutional Court rejected these arguments
after three hours of deliberations. However, their ruling will not
necessarily have practical consequences as Armenian courts of first
instance will still be unable to set any prices. Lawyers the courts
can now only advise the PSRC to reconsider its decisions.

OSCE Official Discusses Armenian Elections

OSCE OFFICIAL DISCUSSES ARMENIAN ELECTIONS
By Karine Kalantarian

Radio Liberty, Czech Rep.
Jan 16 2007

The head of the election-monitoring arm of the Organization for
Security and Cooperation in Europe wound up on Tuesday a two-day
visit to Armenia that focused on its unfolding preparations for
crucial parliamentary elections due in May.

Christian Strohal, director of the OSCE’s Warsaw-based Office for
Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR), discussed the issue
in meetings with President Robert Kocharian, parliament speaker Tigran
Torosian and other Armenian officials.

Speaking to RFE/RL after a meeting with the chairman of the Central
Election Commission, Strohal said Armenia is "ready" to hold its
first-ever national election judged free and fair by the international
community. "But we shall see after the elections themselves," he said.

The Armenian parliament’s press service quoted the Austrian
diplomat as telling Torosian later in the day that there are "good
prerequisites" for making sure that the forthcoming vote meets
democratic standards. Torosian was quoted as saying that it should
mark a "turning point" in Armenia’s transition to democracy and
European integration.

OSCE/ODIHR observers described as undemocratic the previous
presidential and parliamentary elections in Armenia, giving weight to
opposition allegations of massive vote rigging. The United States and
the European Union have warned that a repeat of serious fraud would
jeopardize Yerevan’s efforts to build closer ties with the West.

Kocharian and other Armenian leaders have assured Western powers that
they will do their best to ensure proper conduct of the next polls.

Strohal’s talks in Yerevan specifically centered on their monitoring
by the OSCE. Visiting the Armenian capital last fall, the U.S.

ambassador at the OSCE headquarters in Vienna, Julie Finley, expressed
concern about the Kocharian administration’s failure so far to formally
invite the ODIHR to send long-term and short-term observer missions.

Both Torosian and other leaders of the parliament majority assured the
ODIHR chief that such an invitation will be extended immediately after
Kocharian sets an official election date. According to the Armenian
speaker, a corresponding presidential decree will be signed early
next month.

"There will be invitations for both short-term and long-term
monitoring missions," Samvel Nikoyan, a senior lawmaker from the
governing Republican Party, told RFE/RL. He said the OSCE will send a
"needs assessment team" to Yerevan later in February before beginning
to deploy observers.

"This means long-term monitoring will last for approximately two
months," said Grigor Harutiunian of the opposition Artarutyun
alliance. "Given the political situation in the country, this is
certainly not enough." OSCE monitoring should have begun last month,
he added.

Strohal insisted, however, that European observers will have enough
time to monitor the entire electoral process. "I understand these
elections might be in May, and it’s now January," he said.

U.S. Study Again Lauds Economic Freedom In Armenia

U.S. STUDY AGAIN LAUDS ECONOMIC FREEDOM IN ARMENIA
By Emil Danielyan

Radio Liberty, Czech Rep.
Jan 16 2007

Armenia continues to boast a more liberal and open economy than most
countries in Europe and the former Soviet Union, according to an annual
survey released by two conservative U.S. institutions on Tuesday.

"The Wall Street Journal" and the Washington-based Heritage Foundation
rated the Armenian economy 32nd freest in the world in their 2007
Index of Economic Freedom covering 157 nations. They again praised the
country’s liberal trade regime, low taxes and uncomplicated business
registration procedures.

"Armenia is ranked 19th freest among the 41 countries in the European
region," concludes the study. "Armenia’s score puts it above Europe’s
average-an impressive feat for an impoverished landlocked country."

The rankings, topped by Hong Kong for a 13th consecutive year,
are based on 10 factors of economic freedom such as the level of
government intervention, trade and monetary policy, property rights
and business regulations. Armenia’s overall score of 69.4 percent,
measured on a scale of 100 percentage points, is considerably down
last year’s level. Still, it remains the highest in the Commonwealth
of Independent States. Even European economic powerhouses like France
and Italy were assigned lower grade.

"Low tax rates, low government expenditure, and low revenue from
state-owned businesses contribute to its impressive fiscal and
government freedom rankings," the study says. "Armenia has low
inflation, and its banking sector is both wholly private and well
regulated.

"Commercial regulations are flexible and relatively simple. There
are few restrictions on foreign investment, except for land ownership."

Neighboring Georgia is 35th in the rankings. Two other regional
states, Turkey Azerbaijan, fare much worse, occupying the 83rd and
107th spots respectively.

The index primarily takes account of the legal framework for doing
business in a particular country. Many analysts would argue that
existing laws and regulations are often irrelevant to economic
realities in Armenia where virtually all wealthy businessman are still
dependent on government connections due to serious problems with the
rule of law.

WSJ/Heritage researchers appear to have partly acknowledged this fact,
putting Armenia’s scores in the Property Rights and Freedom from
Corruption categories well below the world’s average. "The [Armenian]
judiciary is influenced by the executive and is also underdeveloped
and corrupt, substantially impeding the enforcement of contracts,"
they said.

Critics will also counter that the low level of tax revenues, worth
between 15 and 17 percent of Gross Domestic Product, is in fact a
major deficiency that results in a highly uneven distribution of the
benefits of Armenia’s double-digit economic growth. The International
Monetary Fund and the World Bank have long been pressing the Armenian
government to tackle what is widely seen as the result of widespread
tax evasion. President Robert Kocharian admitted the gravity of the
problem at an extraordinary meeting with top government officials
last week.

Turkey: Railway To Link Turkey, Azerbaijan And Georgia

TURKEY: RAILWAY TO LINK TURKEY, AZERBAIJAN AND GEORGIA

AKI, Italy
Jan 16 2007

Istanbul, 16 Jan. (AKI) – Work on a 500-million dollar project for
the construction of a railway running between Turkey, Azerbaijan and
Georgia is expected to start in July 2007, the head of Georgia’s
railway authority has revealed. Irakli Ezugbaya said the 258
kilometre-long railway would be completed by mid 2009. Azerbaijan’s
minister of transport Ziya Memedov visited the Georgian capital
Tbilisi, over the weekend to discuss details of the project.

However the United States, which was to provide some financial support
has pulled out of the project in protest over the exclusion of Armenia
– which borders on all of the three countries – due to its political
problems with Turkey and its territorial disputes with Azerbaijan,
Turkish news reports said.

Lobby groups who are demanding that Turkey recognise that the Ottomans
carried out a genocide against Armenians in the first decades of the
20th century, have persuade Washington to withdraw from the project,
the report said.

The European Union has also announced it won’t provide any finance
for the project.

When completed the new railway line is expected to become
a part of a Trans-Asian railway network connected to the
Baku-Caspian-Turkmenistan-Altmati-China route.

Chess: Anand Held By Aronian In Round 3

ANAND HELD BY ARONIAN IN ROUND 3

Hindustan Times, India
Jan 16 2007

Former world champion Viswanathan Anand was easily held to a draw by
Grandmaster Levon Aronian of Armenia in the third round of the Corus
Grandmasters A chess tournament here.

After a fine victory with black pieces against GM Alexander Motylev of
Russia in the previous round, the Indian ace could not do much with his
first white pieces in the tournament as Aronian sought comfort in his
first love, Marshall Gambit, and got an easy half point after 32 moves.

The draw took Anand to two points out of a possible three so far in
the tournament and he will now meet out-of-sort Magnus Carlsen in
the next round game.

However, there was good news for India in the ‘C’ group with world’s
youngest GM Parimarjan Negi beating local International Master Thomas
Willemze.

On two points, alongwith Anand, was World champion Vladimir Kramnik
of Russia who was held to a draw by Sergei Tiviakov of Holland.

Playing the black side of a Petroff defense, Kramnik was never in
any troubles in this fairly simple encounter and routine trading of
pieces led to an equal endgame in just 28 moves.

Meanwhile in other games ending quickly in the third round, Ruslan
Ponomariov scored his first victory in the event at the expense of
Carlsen who was caught off guard in a relatively simple trap in the
opening itself.

Losing his queen for two pieces early in the game, Carlsen did not
get a second chance and was grinded in just 30 moves.

Czech GM David Navara proved once again that his recent success was no
flash in the pan and drew comfortably with GM Peter Svidler of Russia.

It was a Grunfeld defense game wherein Svidler did not get the
complications he was looking for and played it safe.

At the time of going to press, top seed GM Veselin Topalov of Bulgaria
was seen struggling against Ukrainian Sergey Karjakin.

Results (Third Round): Radjabov beat Shirov, Tiviakov drew with
Kramnik, Anand drew with Aronian, Karjakin drew with Topalov;
Ponomariov beat Carlsen; Van Wely drew with Motylev; Werle beat L’Ami;
Jakovenko beat Georgiev; Bologan drew with Stellwagen; Smeets beat
Atalik; Sargissian bt Eljanov Nijboer beat Kosintseva; Hou Yifan beat
Van der Wiel; Van Haastert beat Jonkman; Berg drew with Nepomniachtchi;
Negi beat Willemze; Krasenkow beat Spoelman; Bosboom beat Peng.

BAKU: Written Question On Foreign Companies’ Involvement In Illegal

WRITTEN QUESTION ON FOREIGN COMPANIES’ INVOLVEMENT IN ILLEGAL ACTIVITY IN AZERBAIJAN’S OCCUPIED LANDS PRESENTED TO THE PACE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 16 2007

Member of Azerbaijan’s delegation to the PACE, MP Ganira Pashayeva,
has presented a written question to the Committee of Ministers of
Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe.

Ganira Pashayeva told the APA that the written questions on the
foreign companies’ involvement in illegal activities in the occupied
territories of Azerbaijan touch upon Armenia’s continuing to occupy 20%
of Azerbaijani territory, ethnic cleansing carried out by the Armenian
armed forces, eviction of some 1 million Azerbaijani people who have
lived under unbearable conditions as Internally Displaced People
(IDP), Armenia’s vandalizing Azerbaijan’s historical and cultural
monuments and trying to wipe out the traces of Azerbaijanis.

"Pace Resolution 1416 (2003) demands that Armenia has to withdraw
from the occupied lands of Azerbaijan and internally displaced people
should return to their homeland.

During the period as from the adoption of this resolution, Armenia
has not honoured the resolution and even enlarged non-compliance
with international legal norms and conventions in the occupied
territories. Anyway, in contradiction to the international conventions,
Armenia and the separatist Nagorno Karabakh managed to attract a number
of foreign companies to make investment in these territories illegally.

At present, some 70 foreign companies have been involved in illegal
activities in these lands without authorization of Azerbaijan. There
are companies of the USA, Canada, France, the United Kingdom,
Switzerland and others among the involved. 897 hectares of forests
were destroyed during the eight-month period of 2006. There are
seven wood manufacturing plants working illegally in the occupied
territories. Armenians waste water resources in Lachin and Kalbajar,
the occupied regions," she underlined.

She said that the questions include the full list of the companies
and the countries.

Ganira Pashayeva referred to Hague Convention IV on Laws and Customs of
War on Land, saying that Article 55 reads: "The occupying state shall
be regarded only as administrator and usufructuary of public buildings,
real estate, forests and agricultural estates belonging to the hostile
State, and situated in the occupied territory. It must safeguard the
capital of these properties, and administer them in accordance with
the rules of usufruct. In other words, title to such property shall
not pass to the occupying State, and upon termination of the war,
the seized items and real estate shall be restored. According to
Oppenheim, immovable private enemy property may under no circumstances
or conditions be appropriated by an invading belligerent. Should it
confiscate and sell private land or buildings, the buyer would acquire
no right whatever to the property… if the occupant has appropriated
and sold such private or public property as may not legitimately be
appropriated by a military occupant, it may afterwards be claimed
from the purchaser without payment of compensation," she mentioned.

Having expressed deep concern over illegal actions of Armenia and the
separatist regime of Nagorno Karabakh, which are contradictory to
the international conventions, Ganira Pashayeva asks the Committee
of Ministers: -Whether Council of Europe would urge member-states
to review and put an end to their respective national companies’
involvement into illegal activities in the occupied territories of
Azerbaijan pursued in collaboration with the occupying authorities
and without consent of the Government of Azerbaijan?

-Why Foreign Ministers of member states don’t provide complete
information on their respective national companies’ involvement into
illegal activities in the occupied lands of Azerbaijan, as well
as in other conflict zones throughout the Council of Europe space
such as Abkhazia and South Ossetia? This could simplify setting up
monitoring group dealing with investigation into the state of the
natural resources in the conflict zones.

-Why the Committee of Ministers refrain from making use of effective
mechanisms at its disposal to influence the Government of Armenia to
abstain in the future from actions that prevent lasting peace in the
region from being achieved, including its continued non-compliance
with PACE Resolution 1416 (2003)?

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Turkish Prime Minister Warns Iraqi Kurds Against Seeking Control Of

TURKISH PRIME MINISTER WARNS IRAQI KURDS AGAINST SEEKING CONTROL OF OIL-RICH KIRKUK

International Herald Tribune, France
The Associated Press
Jan 16 2007

ANKARA, Turkey: Turkey’s prime minister warned Iraqi Kurdish groups
Tuesday against trying to seize control of the northern Iraqi city of
Kirkuk. Kurdish lawmakers responded by accusing Ankara of interfering
in internal Iraqi matters.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said Turkey will not stand by amid
growing tensions among ethnic Turkmens, Arabs and Kurds in Iraq’s
oil-rich north. Turkish lawmakers are to discuss Kirkuk and Iraq on
Thursday, and Turkey’s main opposition party has said it would back
a cross-border offensive to quell a Kurdish rebellion.

Iraqi Kurds, who claim the region as their own and hope to eventually
include Kirkuk in an enclave of self-rule in northern Iraq, responded
by accusing Turkey of interfering in Iraqi internal affairs.

Kurdish legislators in Iraq’s parliament "condemn this interference
in Iraqi affairs by the Turkish government (and) … call upon
parliament to issue a statement condemning them as well," they said
in a statement Tuesday.

Kurdish lawmakers urged parliament to "call upon the Iraqi government
and the Foreign Ministry to take a decisive stance to stop this
interference, and to threaten to cut political and the economic
relations with Turkey in case Turkey keeps its interference."

Turkey fears Iraq’s Kurds want Kirkuk’s lucrative oil to fund a bid
for independence that could encourage separatist Kurdish guerrillas
in Turkey who have been fighting since 1984 for autonomy.

Erdogan chided an Iraqi Kurdish group for denouncing an Ankara
conference on Kirkuk’s future, saying Turkey "cannot digest their
words" and cannot stand such criticism, recalling how Turkey sheltered
more than 500,000 Iraqi Kurdish refugees who escaped the Iraqi army’s
bombardment following a failed Kurdish insurgency in early 1991.

Erdogan reminded Kurds of his country’s historical and ethnic ties
to the region.

"Turkey did not remain indifferent to the plight of Kurdish peshmergas
who were escaping oppression and death," he said. "Today, it will
not remain indifferent to the Turkmens, Arabs … in Kirkuk."

Kirkuk, an ancient city that once was part of the Ottoman Empire,
has a large minority of ethnic Turks as well as Christians, Shiite
and Sunni Arabs, Armenians and Assyrians.

Since the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq in 2003, thousands of Kurds
pushed out of the region under Saddam Hussein’s rule have flooded
back to Kirkuk.

Kirkuk lies just south of the autonomous Kurdish region stretching
across Iraq’s northeast. Kurdish leaders want to annex the city,
and Iraq’s constitution calls for a referendum on the issue by the
end of next year.

U.S. legislators have warned that Kirkuk is a "powder keg" and have
recommended that the referendum be delayed.

Number Of Illegal Migrants In Ukraine In 2006 Increased By 44%

NUMBER OF ILLEGAL MIGRANTS IN UKRAINE IN 2006 INCREASED BY 44%

ForUm, Ukraine
Jan 16 2007

Illegal migrants, established in Ukraine prevail in number in 2006
by 44% over ones, detained in 2005. According to data of the State
Frontier Service, as many as 26,000 illegal migrant were registered
in Ukraine in 2006.

It has been well publicized that migration to Western Europe has
increased significantly over the past 15 years, with Western Europe
receiving 42 percent of migrants from Central and Eastern Europe,
as well as growing numbers of migrants from the former Soviet Union.

What is less known is that on a global level, Germany and France are
the only Western European nations in the top-ten migrant-receiving
countries. Russia is number two after the USA, and Ukraine, Kazakhstan,
and Poland are also in the top ten.

Russia attracts migrants from the rest of the former Soviet Union,
Ukraine and Poland both serve as transit points for migrants on their
way to Western Europe.

2006 saw detention of 9,500 Moldavians, 2,600 Uzbeks, 2,300 Armenians,
2,100 Azeris, 1, 250 Tajikis, 1,230 Georgians and 1,100 Russians.

According to the World Bank report, Ukraine holds the fourth place
in top 10 migrants-receiving countries worldwide.

Ukrainian frontier guards detained as many as 741 Indians, 726 Chinese,
712 Turkish, 522 Pakistanis, 475 Kirgistanians, 365 Kazakhs, 262
citizens of Bangladesh, 195 citizens of Vietnam and 186 Palestinians.

BAKU: Azerbaijani And Armenian Football Federation Presidents To Mee

AZERBAIJANI AND ARMENIAN FOOTBALL FEDERATION PRESIDENTS TO MEET IN GERMANY

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 16 2007

Azerbaijani Football Federations Association (AFFA) leadership will
meet with their Armenian counterpart in the UEFA Congress to be held
on January 25-26 in the city of Dusseldorf in Germany, AFFA Secretary
General Fuad Asadov told the APA.

He said that they will discuss the place of the matches between the
Azerbaijani and Armenian national teams to be held in September.

"We will absolutely meet with the Armenian Football Federation
leadership. We will tell them that we have not changed our position.

We insist on holding the matches on neutral play-grounds," he said.

On January 25 "ArmenTel" To Start Disconnecting From Its Net The Com

ON JANUARY 25 "ARMENTEL" TO START DISCONNECTING FROM ITS NET THE COMPANIES, INVOLVED IN IP-TELEPHONY

Mediamax, Armenia
Jan 16 2007

Yerevan, January 16 /Mediamax/. From January 25 "ArmenTel" will start
to disconnect from its net the companies, involved in IP-Telephony, the
General Director of the Company Oleg Bliznyuk stated in Yerevan today.

Mediamax reports that speaking at a news conference in Yerevan today,
Oleg Bliznyuk stressed that not a single company, providing services
of IP-Telephony, has a corresponding license.

"They steal traffic from us, and we are not going to accept it",
the General Director of "ArmenTel" stated.

He stated that today there are about 300 illegal providers of
IP-Telephony, functioning on the market; however, it is impossible
to calculate their exact number, as they are not registered.

The meeting with the leadership of "ArmenTel", which took place in
Yerevan last week, was visited by only 8 companies, in particular,
Avrora, MediaLink, and "Dashink". Oleg Bliznyuk stated that during
that meeting the providers were proposed to become the dealers of
"ArmenTel". According to him, negotiations are already held with some
companies, and all the other providers will be disconnected.

"If we want others to treat Armenia as a civilized country, we should
act in a civilized manner on the market", Oleg Bliznyuk stated.

Concerning the refusal from monopoly for this kind of services by
"ArmenTel", Oleg Bliznyuk stated, that "this cannot happen in a day,
as the legal documents and the technical basis should be prepared
for that".

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress