ANKARA: Islamist says Dink murder aimed at "destabilizing Turkey"

Yeni Safak, Turkey
Jan 20 2007

Islamist columnist says Dink murder aimed at "destabilizing Turkey"

Political assassinations are the favourite method of those who want
to throw Turkey into chaos and destabilize it. We lost many of our
intellectuals in political assassinations at every critical turning
point. Yesterday it was Hrant Dink’s turn.

The plotters of assassinations aimed at destabilizing the country are
adept at their job. If you were to ask a computer into which you have
entered all sorts of relevant intelligence and identity data who the
most appropriate target for an assassination aimed at creating chaos
would be, Hrant Dink would definitely be included on the list of a
few names. Hrant was a journalist and a member of a minority
community. However, he was an important person quite regardless of
his identity as an Armenian and a journalist. He made efforts as a
citizen of the Republic of Turkey to democratize Turkey, make it a
free country, and remove the obstacles facing it. Those who targeted
him not only ended his physical existence but also intended to damage
the democratization process to which Dink contributed.

A priest was killed in Trabzon about a year ago. After that, an armed
attack on the Council of State was carried out and a number of judges
were shot. The assassination of Hrant Dink appears to be a
continuation of the earlier incidents.

[As the proverb goes,] An ember burns where it falls [used to express
awareness of the pains of the close relatives of someone who has
died]. Hrant Dink’s death has a painful effect on every one of us in
varying degrees starting from those closest to him. Even though I did
not meet and talk with him often, Hrant was a friend whose presence I
regarded as an enriching factor for my country as well as for myself.
For this reason, I am deeply saddened.

It would not be quite rational to try to understand the meaning of
the assassination by concentrating on the fact that Dink was a
journalist who was a member of a minority group. Hrant Dink had
become the subject of a series of judicial investigations and
convictions lately that served to bring him to the fore. There were
probably those who were annoyed by him and held demonstrations to
express their annoyance. A link could be established between the
assassination and the fact that he was prosecuted for "insulting
Turkishness." There are actually those establishing such connections
and linking the assassination to a nationalist escalation.

The assassination actually appears to have been intended to make us
think that way. Even though the identity of the perpetrator or
perpetrators could bring these thoughts to our minds, we would do
well to try to understand the motives by looking at the assassination
from a wider perspective.

We could think that the target of the assassination was Turkey. Those
who planned the attack appear to have intended to damage Turkey’s
stability and darken what everybody could already see would be a
brighter future for this country. Steps are being taken to open the
clogged veins of democracy in Turkey and our country is turning into
a regional power whose word carries weight. Even the initial
sentiments caused by the assassination indicate a vulnerability where
this favourable course of developments could be blocked any time.
Unfortunately this is the case.

The first statement that Prime Minister Erdogan issued on behalf of
the Government shows that the political authority has made a correct
diagnosis of the incident. As in the case of the priest murder and
the raid on the Council of State, it is the Government that has been
placed in the most difficult position by the Hrant Dink
assassination.

Hrant Dink’s loss is a loss for every one of us. Above all, it is
Turkey’s loss.

Marseille money man keeps Eriksson waiting

Sunday Times (London)
January 21, 2007, Sunday

Marseille money man keeps Eriksson waiting

Ian Hawkey

Tycoon Jack Kachcar wants to waken the sleeping French giant -and
there may be a role for Sven-Goran Eriksson

JACK KACHKAR. Good name for football’s latest takeover king, sounding
like something between Jack Cash and the suspicious fans’ question:
"So, where’s the catch?" Kachkar is the Syrian-born,
Armenian-cum-Lebanese Canadian who has just completed the initial
formalities on a E115m (£ 75.5m) purchase of France’s Olympique
Marseille.

And if his is an entirely new name to the game, it is becoming
frequently associated with an old one: Sven-Goran Eriksson.

Introducing himself to Marseille fans in the city after lodging his
pre takeover guarantees, Kachkar distanced himself from the idea that
his first big appointment would be the former England coach. He
confirmed that they had met, but at a coaching conference where their
discussions had served merely to help the businessman to orient
himself around the sport in which he was preparing to make such a
substantial investment. Kachkar had sought information from other
coaches, too, he added, without actually naming them. "We want to
work with the present team," he insisted. The current OM coach is
Albert Emon, who reports to a director of sport, the ex-Marseille
coach Jose Anigo and to the president, Pape Diouf.

That trio have taken Marseille to third in the French championnat,
which is the minimum required by the end of this season for Kachkar’s
ambitions. He wants Marseille not simply to be in the Champions
League -France’s top three qualify -but to win it under his
patronage, a tall order for a club that is not even in European
competition at the moment and with a playing staff who include one
true superstar, the restless Franck Ribery, and their most potent
striker, Djibril Cisse, only there on loan from Liverpool.

Eriksson has made it clear that a requirement for his next job is
Champions League involvement, and he has certainly been watching
Marseille closely. A trip to Dubai he made this month coincided with
that of Marseille, on their winter break. The Swede found himself in
the same hotel as the team’s players and staff, chatted animatedly to
Cisse and some of his colleagues.

Kachkar is understood to believe that Eriksson is the sort of man to
guide Marseille out of a decade and a half of corruption scandals,
frenetic turnover and bad management and place them again among the
Continent’s elite.

Eriksson’s experience at Lazio, whom he took to the Italian league
title in 2000, counts as a recommendation. But his salary
expectations would exceed several times over the wages paid to
coaches in a French league in which Gerard Houllier’s Lyon are easing
towards a sixth successive championship with a lead of 14 points over
second-placed Lens and 17 points clear of Marseille.

For all that, OM are a tempting project. The topsy-turvy 1990s, a
period featuring a European Cup triumph, followed swiftly by
punishments -including relegation for domestic match-fixing and
further scandals and slumps in the past seven years – have not eroded
the club’s status as the best supported club in the country. Or,
better phrased, the French club with the widest support base.
Marseille’s fans have a reputation, as ex-players such as Robert
Pires would bear witness. When fortunes deteriorate, players have
been vulnerable to physical attack. Groups of fans have also, under
some of Kachkar’s predecessors, held considerable power over ticket
distribution and aspects of the club’s merchandising potential.

OM have great commercial potential. The value of all French clubs has
leapt in the past year, since the league signed a television deal
worth about E1.8billion over three years, and there is a logic,
outlined by Kachkar, tothe takeover scramble that is now extending
across the Channel. "I don’t have the money to bid for Manchester
United," he said.

Kachkar is not a sugar daddy, he added, but a businessman, expecting
to make something out of Marseille. He also fits the protoype of the
new football mergers and acquisitions man. He seems to have made some
of his initial fortune out of privatisation in the old Eastern Europe
-Hungary in his case -where he graduated in medicine. He heads a
pharmaceutical company based in New York, with satellite arms in
Britain and Canada. Kachkar assured Marseille fans that he is a
francophile, although he addressed them in English, and spoke of
falling for the club when it won the 1993 European Cup final, 1-0
against Milan.

OM have been drifting for most of the time since then, but they are a
dozing giant, an appetising challenge for any chairman. Or coach.

Turkey detains teenager in journalist’s murder

Agence France Presse — English
January 20, 2007 Saturday 11:26 PM GMT

Turkey detains teenager in journalist’s murder

by Nicolas Cheviron

Turkish police detained a 17-year-old male Saturday suspected of
murdering journalist Hrant Dink, one of Turkey’s most prominent
ethnic Armenians, whose slaying sent shock waves through the country.

Ogun Samast was captured at 11:00 pm (2100 GMT) on a bus in the Black
Sea port city of Samsun, Istanbul Governor Muammer Guler told
reporters.

He was en route to his nearby home town of Trabzon, a nationalist
stronghold, still carrying the gun he allegedly used to shoot Dink,
53, three times in the head and the neck outside the office of his
Agos weekly in downtown Istanbul on Friday afternoon, Guler said.

Six other people suspected of being involved in the assassination
were detained in Trabzon.

The NTV news channel quoted Samsun prosecutor Ahmet Gokcinar as
saying that Samast confessed to gunning down Dink in his first
interrogation.

Samast, a jobless secondary school graduate, was reportedly involved
in extreme nationalist groups.

Dink was one of the taboo-breaking critics of the official line on
the mass massacres of Armenians under the Ottoman Empire, which he
labeled as genocide, and was last year given a suspended six-month
jail sentence for insulting "Turkishness."

Nationalists had branded him a "traitor" and Dink wrote in his recent
articles that he received threats and hate mail.

The hunt for the suspect, caught on the security camera of a bank
near the site of the attack, gained speed after his father called
police to identify the young man in the images.

The images released by the police showed a lean, young man clad in a
denim jacket and jeans and wearing a white beret. He was seen holding
an object, which officials said was a gun, under his jacket.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan hailed Samast’s detention "in the
name of democracy and the struggle for freedom".

All seven detainees were to be flown to Istanbul, where three other
people were taken into custody Friday but later released.

"All their links are being investigated," Guler said. "The
investigation will show whether any (illegal) organisation is
involved."

Samast allegedly came to the Agos office about three hours before the
attack, presented himself as a student and asked to see Dink, Guler
quoted Agos secretaries as telling the police.

He was turned down and when one of the secretaries went out about two
hours later she saw him still standing in the street outside.

Anger boiled over Dink’s murder across Turkey, with the government
under fire for failing to protect a man who had received threats and
hate mail.

In a January 12 column in Agos, Dink also mentioned he was summoned
by one of Istanbul’s deputy governors in 2004 and warned that he
might become the target of nationalist violence if he did not tone
down his writings.

Despite the controversies, the soft-spoken and often emotional Dink
had won many hearts here as a sincere activist for Turkish-Armenian
reconciliation, who also denounced Armenian radicalism and most
recently a French bill to jail those who deny that the 1915-17
massacres constituted genocide.

The press condemned the murder as a "national disgrace" and called
for the journalist’s funeral, scheduled for Tuesday, to become a mass
event in the name of democracy and peace in Turkey.

Dink was convicted under the infamous Article 301 of the penal code,
which has been used against other intellectuals including 2006 Nobel
literature laureate Orhan Pamuk, and which the EU has denounced as a
threat to free speech in the EU-hopeful country.

The EU’s German presidency said Saturday it was "appalled" by the
"abominable killing" and neighboring Greece said the murder was aimed
at undermining Turkey’s EU ambitions.

Armenians at home and elsewhere in Europe expressed their dismay on
Saturday, with scores attending rallies in Armenia and France.

In Istanbul, hundreds of mourners paid their respects at the spot
where the journalist was gunned down, lighting candles and laying
flowers at his portrait. Some groups shouted slogans condemning the
murder.

Thousands also marched in Istanbul late Friday, holding Dink’s
pictures and shouting "We are all Armenians, we are all Hrants."

The police will also look into any possible links between Dink’s
assassination and the murder of an Italian Catholic priest in Trabzon
in February, Erdogan was quoted as saying.

Anger in Armenia at Turkey over journalist death

Agence France Presse — English
January 20, 2007 Saturday

Anger in Armenia at Turkey over journalist death

Armenians at home and abroad hammered Turkey Saturday following the
killing of prominent Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink in
Istanbul.

"Turkish authorities should have guaranteed the security of Dink. He
had received many threatening letters and had told police about
them," said the Aikakan Dzhamanak (Armenian Times) newspaper.

The Aravot (Morning) daily said: "Turkey’s ability to become a
civilised, reformed country and its readiness to integrate with
Europe are in serious doubt."

Dink, who was hated by Turkish nationalists for his views on the
massacres of Armenians under Turkish rule during World War I, was
shot dead outside his office in Istanbul on Friday.

"The murder of Dink is not only aimed at freedom of speech," said a
statement from the youth movement of the Armenian nationalist party
Dashnaktsutyun.

"It is also a sign of the renaissance of anti-Armenian hysteria in
the country (Turkey), which carried out a genocide against Armenians
at the beginning of the last century."

Some 100 of the group’s militants gathered outside the European Union
mission in Yerevan, where they lit candles and laid carnations in
front of Dink’s portrait.

The press service of the Armenian Church said a special memorial
service for Dink would be held Sunday in all Armenian churches,
including the main cathedral of Echmiadzin.

"Dink’s untimely death has shocked all of us. We condemn this murder,
which took away a talented and brave son of his people, with profound
indignation," Armenian patriarch Karekin II said in a statement.

Outside of Armenia, there are many Armenian churches spread across
Europe, the Middle East and the United States, attended by a large
diaspora of ethnic-Armenians.

In France hundreds of members of the Armenian community gathered near
the Turkish embassy in Paris, carrying flags and portraits of the
journalist, while police kept them away from the building.

"The Turkish authorities bear the primary guilt for their prosecution
of this human rights activist," the head of the council of Armenian
organisations in France, Alexis Govciyan, said.

Ara Toranian, editor of the monthly magazine Nouvelles d’Armenie,
said the Turkish state and its "obtuse leadership" were responsible,
adding that Dink was "the latest victim" of the Armenian genocide.

Hundreds more protestors rallied at the Turkish consulate in
Marseille.

Armenian analysts said the killing would have little impact on ties
between Turkey and neighbouring Armenia, which have been effectively
frozen since the fall of the Soviet Union.

"I don’t think the killing will lead to any major changes in
Turkish-Armenian relations," said Alexander Iskandarian, director of
the Caucasus Media Institute in Yerevan.

"Those who were against opening the border with Turkey will say that
a Turk is still a Turk, Turkey is still a dangerous neighbour and the
border shouldn’t be opened," Iskandarian said.

"Those in favour of opening will say that such things happen
everywhere."

The 355-kilometre (221-mile) border between the two countries was
closed in 1993 at the height of the Nagorno-Karabakh war in which
ethnic-Armenian separatists in Azerbaijan took over almost a fifth of
Azerbaijani territory.

Armenia backed the separatists, while Turkey supported Azerbaijan.

In recent months, Armenian government ministers have expressed the
hope that diplomatic relations will be restored with Turkey and the
border reopened in order to boost trade and transport potential in
the region.

Views in Turkey and Armenia over the killings of ethnic-Armenians in
the Ottoman Empire during World War I are still deeply divided.

Armenians say that up to 1.5 million of their kin were slaughtered
between 1915 and 1918 and want the massacres to be internationally
recognized as genocide.

Turkey rejects the genocide label and argues that 300,000 Armenians
and at least as many Turks died in civil strife when Armenians took
up arms for independence.

Armenian churches to mourn slain journalist

Agence France Presse — English
January 20, 2007 Saturday

Armenian churches to mourn slain journalist

Armenian churches throughout the world will hold special remembrance
services on Sunday for slain Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink,
church authorities said.

"Dink’s untimely death has shocked all of us. We condemn this murder,
which took away a talented and brave son of his people, with profound
indignation," Armenian patriarch Karekin II said in a statement on
Saturday.

The press service of the Armenian Church said a special memorial
service for Dink would be held Sunday in all Armenian churches,
including the main cathedral of Echmiadzin.

Outside of Armenia, there are also many Armenian churches spread
across Europe the Middle East and the United States attended by a
large diaspora of ethnic-Armenians.

Armenian media slams Turkey after journalist killing

Agence France Presse — English
January 20, 2007 Saturday

Armenian media slams Turkey after journalist killing

Armenian newspapers criticised Turkish authorities on Saturday for
not doing enough to protect slain Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant
Dink.

"Turkish authorities should have guaranteed the security of Dink. He
had received many threatening letters and had told police about
them," said the Aikakan Dzhamanak (Armenian Times).

The Aravot (Morning) daily said: "Turkey’s ability to become a
civilised, reformed country and its readiness to integrate with
Europe are in serious doubt."

Dink, who was hated in Turkish nationalist circles for his views on
the massacres of Armenians under Turkish rule during World War I, was
shot dead outside his office in Istanbul on Friday.

The killing brought thousands of protestors into the streets of
Istanbul and the Turkish capital Ankara. Turkish authorities have so
far detained three people in the murder inquiry.

Armenian analysts said the killing would have little impact on ties
between Turkey and neighbouring Armenia, which have been effectively
frozen since the fall of the Soviet Union.

"I don’t think the killing will lead to any major changes in
Turkish-Armenian relations," said Alexander Iskandarian, director of
the Caucasus Media Institute in Yerevan.

"Those who were against opening the border with Turkey will say that
a Turk is still a Turk, Turkey is still a dangerous neighbour and the
border shouldn’t be opened," Iskandarian said.

"Those in favour of opening will say that such things happen
everywhere."

The 355-kilometre (221-mile) border between the two countries was
closed in 1993 at the height of the Nagorno Karabakh war in which
ethnic-Armenian separatists in Azerbaijan took over almost a fifth of
Azerbaijani territory.

Armenia backed the separatists, while Turkey supported Azerbaijan.

In recent months, Armenian government ministers have expressed the
hope that diplomatic relations will be restored with Turkey and the
border re-opened in order to boost trade and transport potential in
the region.

Views in Turkey and Armenia over the killings of ethnic-Armenians in
the Ottoman Empire during World War I are still deeply divided.

Armenians say that up to 1.5 million of their kin were slaughtered
between 1915 and 1918 and want the massacres to be internationally
recognized as genocide.

Turkey rejects the genocide label and argues that 300,000 Armenians
and at least as many Turks died in civil strife when Armenians took
up arms for independence.

Greece says ‘atrocious’ murder means to hurt Turkey’s EU course

Agence France Presse — English
January 20, 2007 Saturday

Greece says journalist’s ‘atrocious’ murder means to hurt Turkey’s EU
course

Greece on Saturday condemned the "atrocious" murder" of
Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink as an intended blow to
Turkey’s efforts to join the European Union.

"The atrocious murder of Hrant Dink, a man who fought for the
fundamental right of freedom of speech, is directly aimed at the
efforts of the Turkish people to win their European future," Greek
Foreign Minister Dora Bakoyannis said in a statement.

Greece has publicly supported Turkey’s efforts to join the EU bloc
despite a deep-rooted regional rivalry and tension over the continued
division of Cyprus, whose northern third Turkey seized in 1974 in
response to an Athens-engineered Greek Cypriot coup aimed at uniting
the island with Greece.

Editor of the weekly Agos newspaper, Dink died when an unidentified
gunman shot him three times in the head and neck outside his office
in Istanbul.

The 53-year-old journalist had questioned official versions of
history in Turkey relating to the massacres of Armenians between 1915
and 1918 in the dying days of the Ottoman Empire, which drew the
wrath of nationalists and the judiciary.

ANKARA: Journalist’s funeral to take place on 23 January – Mesrob II

Anatolia News Agency, Turkey
Jan 20 2007

Turkey: Journalist’s funeral to take place on 23 January – Armenian
patriarch

Istanbul, 20 January: Hrant Dink, editor-in-chief of bilingual
Turkish-Armenian weekly Agos, will be laid to rest on Tuesday [23
January] in Balikli Armenian Cemetery following a funeral in Virgin
Mary Church at Kumkapi district. Mesrob II, the Patriarch of the
Armenians in Turkey, said the funeral for Hrant Dink will be staged
on 23 January at 2.00 p.m.

ANKARA: PM says journalist’s killers will not achieve their aim

Anatolia News Agency, Turkey
Jan 20 2007

Turkish premier says journalist’s killers will not achieve their aim

Kizicahamam/Istanbul/Bursa: 20 January: "This murder will not achieve
what it aimed, this game which is played on our country will
certainly be thwarted," Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan told a
consultation meeting of his Justice and Development Party (AKP) on
Saturday [20 January].

"Our nation will give the best answer to those bloody hands by
clinching firmly and by embracing [Armenian Turkish journalist] Hrant
Dink. No bloody provocation will be able to hinder our nation’s march
on the road to freedom and prosperity," he added.

Erdogan also said that the perpetrators of the murder would not go
unpunished and that every effort was being exerted to bring
responsible(s) before justice in the shortest possible time.

Erdogan also praised Turkey’s economic performance in his speech,
saying the steps the government has been taking have given their
fruits.

"Turkey’s economy is a rising star of the region and even of the
world," he said.

"Thanks to democracy, stability and an environment of security,
Turkey has re-entered a process of production and development," he
noted.

"This constitutes an invaluable achievement. There is no turning back
from this point."

Touching on the Cyprus problem, Erdogan rejected accusations that the
government has made concessions regarding the Cyprus issue.

A group of Turkish non-governmental organizations made a call on
Saturday for a "silent march" to be staged on the day of slain
journalist Hrant Dink’s funeral, which is scheduled for next Tuesday.

"Those who do not want us to live together, understand each other are
trying to maintain an environment of fear, violence and conflict,"
author Oya Baydar told journalists after a meeting held between the
NGO leaders.

"Let us not forget the hope Hrant had fostered for this soil," she
said.

Meanwhile, Guenter Verheugen, vice-president of European Union
Commission, strongly deplored [on] Saturday the killing of prominent
Turkish Armenian journalist Hrant Dink.

"I condemn the incident in the strongest possible sense. I appreciate
the stance of the Turkish state on this issue" he said.

"I believe those who aim at harming Turkey will not achieve their
goals. I am confident that the Turkish officials will exert every
effort to bring the situation into the daylight," Verheugen added.

Huge outcry in Turkish press after slaying of journalist

Agence France Presse — English
January 20, 2007 Saturday

Huge outcry in Turkish press after slaying of journalist

Turkish newspapers condemned Saturday the murder of prominent
Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink as "a national shame," calling
for his funeral to become a mass event in the name of democracy and
peace in the country.

"The murderer is a traitor," declared the mass-circulation Hurriyet
on its front page, next to a huge portrait of Dink on a black
background, while the popular Sabah headlined: "The greatest
treason."

Both dailies were using the epithet that nationalists have used to
brand Dink and other intellectuals contesting the official line on
the mass killings of Armenians under the Ottoman Empire, which much
to Ankara’s ire, many countries have recognized as genocide.

"Bullets fired on democracy, fraternity and peace," the Milliyet
newspaper trumpeted, while Radikal wrote "We are all Armenians, we
are all Hrants," using one of the chants that thousands shouted
during a protest march in Istanbul late Friday after an indentified
assailant gunned down Dink outside the office of his Turkish-Armenian
newspaper Agos.

"Our Hrant is murdered," the Islamist Yeni Safak headlined,
describing Dink as "an Armenian son of Turkey, a journalist devoted
to democracy and free thought and a brave man."

"Hrant’s murder is our national shame," Milliyet columnist Semih Idiz
wrote.

"The only way to obliterate at least part of it is to bid him
farewell as a nation — from the president to the prime minister,
from the main opposition leader to the army chief," he added.

Many editorialists let their emotions flow at the loss of a
colleague, who was last year given a suspended six-month sentence for
insulting "Turkishness" in an article about the Armenian massacres
and was frequently threatened by nationalists.

"When I heard of Hrant’s murder, I cried and cried — for him or for
my country, I do not know. What I know is that this shame will haunt
us for many years to come," Sabah’s Fatih Altayli said.

Some commentators saw serious implications for Turkish foreign
policy, with the popular Vatan stressing that Armenian campaigns for
an international recognition of the 1915-17 massacres as genocide
would gain strength.

"This incident also plays in the hands of those who want to cut
Turkey’s ties with the West and block its accession to the European
Union," Vatan columnist Okay Gonensin wrote.

Politicians also came under fire for failing to quell what many see
here as rising nationalism among Turks.

"The politicians and the state establishment should see this
assassination, committed in a time of rising fanaticism in Turkey, as
an alarm bell. The target was not only Hrant Dink, but Turkey’s
stability," Mehmet Barlas wrote in Sabah.