ANKARA: Turk and Armenian: Hrant Dink and Talat Pasha Murders

Journal of Turkish Weekly, Turkey
Jan 22 2007

Turk and Armenian: Hrant Dink and Talat Pasha Murders

Monday , 22 January 2007

View by Sedat LACINER (U.S.A.K.)

Hrant Dink is the first and the only Armenian victim murdered by a
politically-motivated Turk in the history of the Turkish Republic. We
hope it’s the last. The investigation continues but we don’t think
this murder is related with the Armenian problem. It’s also
impossible to evaluate the situation as racism. Right after the
murder, both Turkish government and the Turkish people are getting
along with this incident in a good way. After the murder, all of the
Turkish newspapers cursed the incident. Lots of people marched in
Ankara and Istanbul shouting ‘we are all Armenians, we are all Hrant
Dink’. All of the newspapers in Turkey headlined the murder. Hurriyet
for instance declared the murderer as a ‘Traitor to the Motherland’
and Sabah daily headlined the murder as ‘The biggest treason’. Other
headlines were similar. Not even one single Turkish newspaper
including the ultra-nationalist ones protected the killer. Even the
most fanatic nationalists didn’t see the killer as a hero. On the
contrary, the killer was seen as a ‘traitor’ and an ‘ignorant boy
used by the underground and dark powers’.

Turkey has been accused for its possible responsibility in the murder
by foreign press without a cause. Some accused Turkey even of being
racist. All these claims and accusations have no base and just. Omer
Celik, one of the closest deputies to President Erdogan, has recently
offered to put Turkish flag on Mr. Dink’s coffin, a common tradition
for the martyrs’ and famous statesmen’ funerals. No one raised any
objection to this brave idea but lots of people thought that this was
a great idea. As the most important symbol for a nation is a ‘flag’,
it’s unfair to blame the Turkish people of being racist or
anti-Armenian who want to put their pure flag on the coffin of an
Armenian Turkish citizen, Hrant Dink.

President of Turkey, Turkish ministers, governor of Istanbul and top
level officials of security bureaucracy all condemned the murder.
Murderer was caught in 32 hours. President Erdogan said that ‘Dink
was the son of this land’. The main opposition party leader Baykal
expressed his despair by saying ‘We couldn’t let him live’. Almost
every politician’s common attitude was to curse the murderer and they
took the side of Dink. Even the ultra nationalist Turks saw the
murder as the ‘agent of the dark powers’. Not even one politician was
happy of the homicide. No one saw the murderer as a hero. The person
who notified the police was the murder’s own father. None of his
relatives said he did a good job. Their common attitude about the
murder was that it was unacceptable and their son was used by the
evil others. In other words even the killer’s most close relatives
didn’t saw him as a hero and didn’t back him up.

***

There is another story on the other side of the medallion.

When Talat Pasha, the Minister of Interior of the Ottoman Empire, was
killed by an Armenian named Sogomon Tehliryan on March 15 1921 on a
crowded Berlin street (Germany), the attitude of the Armenians were
not similar to the attitude of today’s Turkey people. Ironically
there are many similarities between the murders of Talat Pasha and of
Hrant Dink. As the Turkish historian Murat Bardakci wrote in Sabah
newspaper dated 21 January 2007, both victims were shot from the back
of their head. The bases of the shooes of the both victims were
tattered and holed. Both murders were committed in daylight and on a
crowded street. After the Talat Pasha Murder Tehliryan, the Armenian
murderer was declared as a hero and even today the Diaspora Armenians
and Armenians from Armenia see Tehliryan as a great hero. It was not
just the Armenians but also the German Court strangely judged the
victim instead of the killer. The Armenian murderer was set free
after a short trial. Tehliryan was not the only murderer and
terrorist who were declared as a hero by the Armenians. Lots of the
Armenian terrorists were declared as heroes afterwards. The Armenian
history is full of murderer heroes. Moreover Western courts committed
law crimes again and again and set the Armenian killers free. For
example the Armenian terrorist Max Kilnajian, who attempted to kill
the Turkish ambassador in Bern city, was sentenced to two years by
the French court and released shortly after the verdict. The mostly
known Armenian terrorist Monte Melkonyan made lots of armed attacks
against the Turkish diplomats. In these attacks lots of people were
killed. But the French court released Melkonyan after 3 years in
prison. Afterwards Mr. Melkonyan joined the Karabakh War against
Azerbaijan and he murdered lots of people in that war. But Melkonyan
has not been a terrorist or a murderer for Armenians, he has been
hero to be respected and followed. Armenia gave salaries to many
terrorists and protected them. Unfortunately, while these truths are
clear, Armenia and Armenian Diaspora is blaming Republic of Turkey
for the Hrant Dink murder.

***

The murder of Hrant Dink is one of the most dramatic murders of our
history. But it’s unfair to exert pressure about Armenian problem by
using this unfortunate murder. Also the Armenian Diaspora, who is
blaming Turkey, was criticized many times by Hrant Dink himself. They
were talking about Dink as a "traitor" and "servant of the Turkey"
before, but now they are mongering on his death. Actually this is
what they have done all the time. They are always using the
reciprocal massacres to get the benefit out of it.

I am really sorry about Mr. Dink’s death. Because from now on, it’s
hard to find an Armenian like him. Because he was a Turkish Armenian.
He was son of this land. He was not making politics on death. He was
working for the peoples who live. We have to do just like this from
now on. We must not use the dead as an interest. We must not use a
barbarous murder to attack each others.

22 January 2007

Trns. by Zerin Acar and Kemal Tuzcu (JTW)

Dink’s Murder Becomes Political Earthquake For Inner and Foreign Pol

DINK’S MURDER BECOMES POLITICAL EARTHQUAKE FOR INNER AND FOREIGN POLICY OF
TURKEY, ARMENIAN INTELLECTUALS BELIEVE

YEREVAN, JANUARY 22, NOYAN TAPAN – ARMENIANS TODAY. Hrant Dink’s
murder is logical continuation of Article 301 of the Turkish Criminal
Code which became a political earthquake for Turkey’s inner and
foreign policy. Hayk Demoyan, the Director of the Armenian Genocide
Museum-Institute stated about it at the Armenian Intellectuals’
gathering taken place on January 20 at the "Hayeli" club, on the
occasion of the murder of Hrant Dink, a prominent intellectual
and politician of the Armenian origin from Istanbul. In his words,
Dink’s tragic murder will have deep influence on both foreign and
inner policy of Turkey. "This murder first of all shook the Turkish
society the evidence of what are the publications in the Turkish
press, responses of TV companies and demonstrations of many thousands
organized just by the Turk society," Hayk Demoyan is sure. He assured
that Hrant Dink’s murder will become a unique watershed to change the
Turkish society’s position on the Armenian Genocide issue. "There
were few such people in all the times who did not make compromises
for their ideas and principles. Dink’s death is a great loss for
the Armenian people’s idea and pen," Azat Yeghiazarian, the Director
of the NAS Literature Institute is sure. In his words, in reality,
Dink’s murder is not a deed of two fanatic young people, but is
a consequence of the policy carried out by the Turkish state for
dozens of years. "Yesterday Erdogan did not even hide in his speech
of condolence on the occasion of the murder his repulsive position
saying "the so called Armenian Genocide" speaking about the Armenian
Genocide," Azat Yeghiazarian mentioned. This is a classic example of
intolerance and denial which is characteristic only for the Turkish
policy. Mr.Yeghiazarian led parallels between the murders of Dink and
Gurgen Margarian, an officer of Armenian origin died in Budapest,
mentioning that it is an affirmed Turkish handwriting. "I am sure
that the Turkish society is ill but I’ll suppose that it must be
treated." This was Hrant Dink’s struggle guideline.

According to the estimation of Ashot Melkonian, the NAS History
Institute Director, Hrant Dink was one of those rare intellectuals who
never hated and was not been an enemy for the Turkish people. "He was
an optimist in that issue, but was mistaken. He was mistaken as the
present Turkish authorities and the Kemal policy carried out by them
brought to the yesterday murder, proved that they are their successors
in the Armenian Genocide issue," A.Melkonian believes. A.Melkonian
is sure that those responsible for the Turkish Government can
express condolence but it does not decrease their sin: this murder
is a terrorist act committed at the state level. The murder put a
full stop on the frame of mind that the Turkish society is getting
better. The Turkish soul and nature is not changeable ever. "Hrant
Dink was my friend. He was brave and of principle. He stayed many
times in front of the Turkish Court for his free expression and
brave ideas. His every day could become the last one. He functioned
and struggle just in this reality paying with his life for memory of
his people’s innocent victims and Turkish people’s healthy future,"
A.Melkonian emphasized. In words of Arsen Avagian, the Advisor of the
Foreign Ministry’s Political Programmming Department, Hrant was one
of those unique intellectuals who believed in the Turkish people’s
becoming better, and saw the solution of the Armenian Genocide
issue just with the help of that people. Hrant was sure that outer
pressures would not give anything but additional straining. "Dink
was exceptional both with his ideas and his life. Hrant Dink became
one of the most important pages of the Turkish history," A.Avagian
emphasized. Hrant Dink dreamed of founding in Yerevan a Center on
Turkish Studies and already sent enough literature for the library of
the future center. "I think that we are obliged to found that center
in Yerevan for his memory," he said.

Participants of the gathering were sure that Dink’s murder will
have great influence on the foreign and inner policy of Turkey,
particularly in the sense of that state’s entering the European Union
as well as in the sense of the world community’s attitude towards the
Turkish state. They also mentioned that the murder can be a result
of Turkey’s inner political mess, can be an application of violent
force towards the freedom of expression and display of intolerance
towards dissidence. But, in his words, in all the cases this murder
in the 21st century is the Turkish society’ shame. Those present
spoke against those rumours that Dink’s body must be moved to Armenia
and burried here. They found that Hrant was born in Turkey and is a
citizen of that country, so it will be right that his grave is placed
in the Istanbul Armenian graveyard, near Armenian great people.

Dink’s Murder Is Addressed Against Turkish Intellectuals As Well Who

"DINK’S MURDER IS ADDRESSED AGAINST TURKISH INTELLECTUALS AS WELL WHO TOUCH
UPON ARMENIAN GENOCIDE ISSUE TO FINALLY SILENCE IT"

YEREVAN, JANUARY 22, NOYAN TAPAN – ARMENIANS TODAY. A number of political
parties of Armenia responded with statements the murder of Hrant Dink, the
editor-in-chief of the "Akos" Turkish language newspaper being published in
Turkey. The ARF, particularly, expressed a confidence that "this nasty crime
is a new threat addressed to rights and existence of Armenians of Turkey for
what the Turkish state and authorities bear complete responsibility." In the
party’s estimation, Dink was killed for his political views: he in his own
manner imagined the civil rights of Armenians as well as of other minorities
in present Turkey, the Armenia-Turkey relations and the issue of the
Armenian Genocide recognition by Turkey, always taking into account and
defending interests of "the civilized" Turkey. But he was persecuted by the
Turkish state for those views. "Dink’s murder once more proves the fact that
the dissidence is not tolerated in Turkey," is said in the ARF Bureau
statement. The "Orinats Yerkir" (Country of Law) party, particularly,
mentions that "Hrant Dink was faithful to his title of a journalist and
sincerity of his pen. He was incarnation of solidarity, tolerance and
minorities’ national dignity in the Turkish society. At the same time
according to the estimation of the party, "the committed regour endangers
the right of free expression and may give birth to great anxieties among the
national minorities living in Turkey." The Social Democrat Hunchakian party
considers that "this shameful crime in which the Turkish society has its
part of responsibility, which, with the anti-Armenian, racial discrimination
carried out by it and policy limiting the freedom of expression, encourages
the nationalist elements of the country for the latters function freely and
without fear." According to the party’s estimation, this crime is addressed
against all those Turkish intellectuals who touch upon the Armenian Genocide
issue to finally silence the latters. "We’ll demand on this occassion from
international structures for they closely observe and are seriously engaged
in revealing all the folds of this political murder. We’ll always demand
from the EU for the Armenian Genocide recognition becomes a precondition for
Turkey’s membership to that structure," is said in the statement.

Khoren Palian Passes Away

KHOREN PALIAN PASSES AWAY

YEREVAN, JANUARY 22, NOYAN TAPAN. Senior lecturer of Yerevan State
University, specialist of Old Armenian language, connoisseur of
Armenian spiritual songs, Khoren Palian died at the age of 71. In
the last years he was also actively engaged in public activity,
was a member of Council of Elders of Armenian Forum of Intelligentsia.

My life as a pigeon by Hrant Dink

Open Democracy, UK
Jan 22 2007

My life as a pigeon

Hrant Dink
22 – 1 – 2007

This article was published in the Armenian-Turkish newspaper "Agos"
on 10 January 2007. It was the last Hrant Dink would ever write; nine
days later, he was murdered outside the newspaper’s Istanbul office.

I did not at first feel troubled about the investigation that was
filed against me by the ªiºli public prosecutor’s office with the
accusation of "insulting Turkishness". After all, it was not the
first time to face this charge. I had been familiar with the
accusation because of a similar lawsuit filed against me in Urfa.

Over the last three years, I was being tried in Urfa for "denigrating
Turkishness" on the grounds of having stated in a talk I gave at a
conference there in 2002 that "I was not a Turk … but from Turkey
and an Armenian."

I was unaware about how this lawsuit was proceeding. I was not at all
interested. My lawyer friends in Urfa were attending the hearings in
my absence.

I was even quite nonchalant when I went and gave my deposition to the
ªiºli public prosecutor. I ultimately had complete trust in what my
intentions had been and what I had written. Once the prosecutor had
the chance to evaluate not just that single sentence from my
editorial – which made no sense by itself – but the text as a whole,
he would understand easily that I had no intention of "denigrating
Turkishness"; and this comedy would come to an end.

I was certain that a lawsuit would not be filed at the end of the
investigation. I was sure of myself. But, surprise! A lawsuit was
filed.

But I still did not lose my optimism.

So much so that on a television show that I joined live, I even told
the lawyer (Kemal) Kerincsiz who was accusing me "that he should not
get his hopes too high, that I was not going to be smacked with any
sentence from this lawsuit, and that I would leave this country if I
received a sentence." I was sure of myself because I truly had not
had in my article any premeditation or intention – not even a single
iota – to denigrate Turkishness. Those who read the entirety of my
collection of articles would understand this very clearly.

Hrant Dink was from 1996 the editor-in-chief and a columnist of the
Armenian-language weekly newspaper Agos in Istanbul. The paper aims
to provide a voice for the Armenian community in Turkey and to
further dialogue between Turks and Armenians.

On 19 January 2007, Hrant Dink was assassinated outside Agos’s
offices in Istanbul.

As a matter of fact, the report prepared by the three faculty members
from Istanbul University who had been appointed by the court as
experts stated exactly that. There was no reason for me to be
worried; there would certainly be a return from the wrongful path (of
the lawsuit) at one stage of the proceedings or the other. So I kept
asking for patience …

But there was no such return.

The weapon of sincerity

The prosecutor asked for a sentence in spite of the expert report.

The judge then sentenced me to six months in prison.

When I first heard about my sentence, I found myself under the bitter
pressure of the hopes I had nurtured all along the process of the
lawsuit. I was bewildered … My disappointment and rebellion were at
their pinnacle.

I had resisted for days and months saying: "just you wait for this
decision to come out and once I am acquitted, then you will all be so
repentant about all that you have said and written."

In covering every hearing of the lawsuit, the newspaper items,
editorials and television programmes all attributed to me a remark
that "the blood of the Turk is poisonous." Each and every time, they
were adding to my fame as "the enemy of the Turk." At the halls of
the court, the fascists physically attacked me with racist curses.

They bombarded me with insults on their placards.

The threats reached hundreds, hailing for months through phones,
email and letters which kept increasing day after day. I persevered
through all this with patience awaiting the decision for acquittal.

Once the legal decision was announced, the truth was going to prevail
and all these people would be ashamed of what they had done.

My only weapon was my sincerity. But the decision was made and all my
hopes were crushed. From then on, I was in the most distressed
situation that a person could possibly be in.

The judge had made a decision in the name of the "Turkish nation" and
had it legally registered that I had "denigrated Turkishness." I
could have persevered through anything except this.

According to my understanding, racism was the denigration by anyone
of a person they lived alongside with on the basis of any difference,
ethnic or religious, and there was no way in which this could ever be
forgiven.

It was in this psychological state that I made the following
declaration to the members of the media and friends who were at my
doorstep trying to confirm "as to whether I would leave this country
as I had indicated earlier".

"I shall consult with my lawyers. I will appeal at the supreme court
of appeal and will even go to the European Court of Human Rights if
necessary. If I am not cleared through any one of these processes,
then I shall leave my country. Because, in my opinion, someone who
has been sentenced for such a crime does not have the right to live
alongside the citizens he has denigrated."

As I voiced this opinion, I was emotional as always. My only weapon
was my sincerity.

A dark humour

But it so happens that the deep force that was trying to single me
out and make me an open target in the eyes of the people of Turkey
found something wrong with this press release of mine as well; this
time, it filed a lawsuit against me for attempting to influence the
court. The entire Turkish media had been given my declaration, but
what got their attention was what was written in Agos alone. And it
so transpired that the legally responsible parties in the Agos
newspaper and I began to be tried this time around for attempting to
influence the court. This must be what people call "dark humour".

Who, more than the accused, has the right to try to influence the
judiciary? But in this humorous situation, the accused is tried for
just such an offence.

"In the name of the Turkish state"

I have to confess that I had more than lost my trust in the concept
of "law" and the "system of justice" in Turkey.

How could I have not? Had these prosecutors, these judges not been
educated in the university, graduated from faculties of law? Weren’t
they supposed to have the capacity to comprehend (and interpret) what
they read?

But it so transpires that the judiciary in this country, as expressed
without compunction by many a statesman and politician also, is not
independent.

The judiciary does not protect the rights of the citizen, but instead
of the state. The judiciary is not there for the citizen, but under
the control of the state.

As a matter of fact I was absolutely sure that even though it was
stated that the decision in my case was reached "in the name of the
Turkish nation", it was a decision clearly not made "on behalf of the
Turkish nation" but rather "on behalf of the Turkish state." As a
consequence, my lawyers were going to appeal to the supreme court of
appeals; but what could guarantee that the deep force that had
decided to put me in my place would not be influential there either?

And was it the case that the supreme court of appeals always reached
right decisions?

Wasn’t it the same supreme court of appeal that had signed onto the
unjust decision that stripped minority foundations of their
properties? It had done so, moreover, in spite of the attempts of the
chief public prosecutor.

We did appeal and what did it get us?

Just like the report of the experts, the chief public prosecutor of
the supreme court of appeals stated that there was no evidence of
crime and asked for my acquittal; but the supreme court of appeals
still found me guilty.

The chief public prosecutor of the supreme court of appeals was just
as certain about what he had read and understood as I had been about
what I had written, so he objected to the decision and took the
lawsuit to the general council.

But what can I say: that great force which had decided once and for
all to put me in my place and had made itself felt at every stage of
my lawsuit through processes I would not even know about, was there
present once again behind the scenes. And as a consequence, it was
declared by majority vote at general council as well that I had
denigrated Turkishness.

A pigeon reflex

This much is crystal-clear: that those who tried to single me out,
render me weak and defenceless, succeeded by their own measures. They
managed, with the wrongful and polluted knowledge they injected into
society, to form a significant segment of the population whose who
view Hrant Dink as someone "denigrating Turkishness".

The diary and memory of my computer are filled with angry,
threatening lines sent by citizens from this particular sector, whose
numbers cannot easily be dismissed. (Let me note here that one of
these threatening letters was sent from the neighbouring city of
Bursa, which I found particularly disturbing because of the proximity
of the danger it represented; I therefore handed it to the ªiºli
prosecutor’s office, but have not been able to get a response to this
day.)

How real or unreal are these threats? To be honest, it is of course
impossible for me to know for sure.

What is truly threatening and unbearable for me is the psychological
torture I personally place myself in. "Now what are these people
thinking about me?" is the question that really bugs me.

It is unfortunate that I am now better known than I once was and I
feel much more the people who throw me that glance which says, "Oh,
look, isn’t he that Armenian guy?" And I reflexively start torturing
myself.

One aspect of this torture is curiosity, the other unease. One aspect
is attention, the other apprehension. I am just like a pigeon …

Obsessed just as much by what goes on my left, right, front, back. My
head is just as mobile … and fast enough to turn right away.

And here is the cost for you

What did the foreign minister Abdullah Gul state? The justice
minister Cemil Cicek?

"Come on, there is nothing to exaggerate about (Article 301 0f the
penal code). Is there anyone who has actually been tried and
imprisoned from it?"

As if the only cost one paid was imprisonment …

Here is a cost for you … Here is a cost …

Do you know, oh ministers, what kind of a cost it is to imprison a
human being into the apprehensiveness of a pigeon?… Do you know?…

You, don’t you ever watch a pigeon?

What they call "life-or-death"

What I have lived through has not been an easy process … And what
we have lived through as a family …

There were moments when I seriously thought about leaving the country
and moving far away. And especially when the threats started to
involve those close to me … At that point I always remained
helpless.

That must be what they call "life-or-death." I could have resisted
out of my own will, but I did not have the right to put into danger
the life of anyone who was close to me. I could have been my own
hero, but I did not have the right to be brave by placing, let along
someone close to me, any other person in danger.

During such helpless times, I gathered my family, my children
together and sought refuge in them and received the greatest support
from them. They trusted in me. Wherever I would be, they would be
there as well.

If I said "let’s go" they would go, if I said "let’s stay" they would
stay.

To stay and resist

Okay, but if we went, where would we go?

To the Armenian republic?

How long someone like me who could not stand injustices would put up
with the injustices there? Would I not get into even deeper trouble
there?

To go and live in the European countries was not at all the thing for
me.

After all, I am the kind of person who, if I travel to the west for
three days, I miss my country on the fourth and start writhing in
boredom saying "let this be over so I can go back". So what would I
end up doing there?

The comfort there would have gotten to me! Leaving "boiling hells"
for "ready-made heavens" was not at all right for my personality
make-up.

We were people who volunteered to transform the hells they lived into
heavens.

To stay and live in Turkey was necessary because we truly desired it,
and we had to do so out of respect for the thousands of friends in
Turkey who pursued a struggle for democracy and who supported us.

We were going to stay and we were going to resist.

If, however, we were forced to leave one day … we were going to set
out just as in 1915 … Like our ancestors … Without knowing where
we were going … Walking the roads they walked through … Feeling
the ordeal, experiencing the pain …

With such a reproach we were going to leave our homeland. And we
would go where our feet took us, but not our hearts.

Apprehensive – and free

I wish that we would never ever have to experience such a departure.

We have way too many reasons and hope not to experience it anyhow.

Now I am applying to the European Court of Human Rights.

How long this lawsuit will last, I do not know.

What I do know, and what puts me a little at ease, is that I will be
living in Turkey at least until the lawsuit is finalised.

If the court decides in my favour, I will undoubtedly become very
happy and it would mean that I would never have to leave my country.

>>From my own vantage-point, 2007 will probably be even a more
difficult year.

The trials will continue, new ones will commence. Who knows what
kinds of additional injustices I will have to confront?

While all these occur, I will consider this one truth my only
security.

Yes, I may perceive myself in the spiritual unease of a pigeon, but I
do know that in this country people do not touch pigeons.

Pigeons live their lives all the way deep into the city, even amidst
human throngs. Yes, somewhat apprehensive, but just as free.

ey/pigeon_4271.jsp

–Boundary_(ID_2imLZ107p+b3XQY 04s+/HA)–

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.opendemocracy.net/democracy-turk

Indifference Of Armenia Towards Problems Of Armenians Of Javakhk To

INDIFFERENCE OF ARMENIA TOWARDS PROBLEMS OF ARMENIANS OF JAVAKHK TO
BRING TO DEPORTING ARMENIANS OF THE REGION, "HZOR HAYRENIK" PARTY
CHAIRMAN STATES

YEREVAN, JANUARY 22, NOYAN TAPAN. The Government of Armenia envisaged
this year in total 700 thousand U.S. dollars for Javakhk having
population of 150 thousand people what is not at all enough for
solution of urgent problems of the Armenians of Javakhk. Vardan
Vardapetian, the Chairman of the "Hzor Hayrenik" (Powerful Fatherland)
party made such a statement at the January 22 press conference. In
his words, such an indifferent policy of Armenia towards problems
of the Armenians of Javakhk may become a reason for deporting the
Armenians of Javakhk. He mentioned that as a result of worsening the
Russian-Georgian relations, about 30 thousand Armenians of Javakhk lost
the possibility of outgoing work in Russia, and the Armenian-Georgian
relations, in their turn, still have "place to develop." So, as
V.Vardapetian mentioned, a number of problems arises in front of the
Armenians of Javakhk, and "one must assist the Armenians of Javakhk
as our compatriots there, being citizens of the 21st century, must
live in the proper way."

Police: 2 Confess in Journalist Killing

Police: 2 Confess in Journalist Killing
By BENJAMIN HARVEY

Associated Press
Jan 22 2007

ISTANBUL, Turkey – A nationalist militant convicted of bombing a
McDonald’s restaurant in 2004 has confessed to inciting the killing
of an ethnic Armenian journalist last week, police said Monday.

Yasin Hayal told police he provided a gun and money to the teenager
who is suspected of carrying out Friday’s shooting, the Hurriyet
newspaper reported, citing police records.

The teenager, Ogun Samast, was arrested over the weekend along
with several other people and has confessed to fatally shooting the
journalist, according to a chief prosecutor.

Police confirmed the confession, but gave no details.

Police Chief Celalettin Cerrah of Istanbul said Monday that the
suspect was linked to Hayal.

If accurate, Hayal’s reported statements to police would be a strong
indication that the journalist, Hrant Dink, was targeted because of
his public statements on the mass killings of Armenians by Turks
in the early 20th century, one of the nation’s most sensitive and
divisive issues.

Istanbul Gov. Muammer Guler said prosecutors were still investigating
whether the suspect was linked to any organization, although Police
Chief Celalettin Cerrah had said earlier that there was "no political
or organizational dimension" to the slaying.

Dink, the 52-year-old editor of the Turkish-Armenian newspaper Agos,
had made public his view that the killings amounted to genocide.

Nationalists consider such statements an insult to Turkey’s honor
and a threat to its unity, and Dink had been showered with insults
and death threats.

Dink was gunned down outside his newspaper’s office in Istanbul on
Friday _ a killing that has drawn attention to the precarious state of
freedom of expression in a country vying for European Union membership.

Turkey has no diplomatic ties with Armenia but still invited Armenian
officials and religious leaders as well as moderate members of the
diaspora to the funeral on Tuesday.

The Vienna-based International Press Institute said the killing was
"a terrible event for Turkish press freedom." It urged Turkey to
eliminate its laws inhibiting dialogue about the Armenian killings,
as well as those that make insulting Turkishness a crime.

Police took Samast, who is 16 or 17, to the crime scene late Sunday
and prosecutors asked him to describe how he killed Dink, the Anatolia
news agency reported on Monday. A small crowd of onlookers shouted
at the suspect, "We’re all Hrants. We’re all Armenians!"

Hayal was convicted in the bombing of a McDonald’s restaurant in
Trabzon in 2004 that injured six people. He was released after serving
more than 10 months in prison. At the time, police could not establish
a link between Hayal and any underground groups, and his motive was
never clear.

Turkey’s relationship with its Armenian minority has long been haunted
by a bloody past. Much of its once-influential Armenian population
was killed or driven out beginning around 1915 in what an increasing
number of nations are calling the first genocide of the 20th century.

Turkey acknowledges that large numbers of Armenians died but vehemently
denies it was genocide, saying the overall figure is inflated and
the deaths occurred in the civil unrest during the collapse of the
Ottoman Empire.

Associated Press writers Suzan Fraser and Selcan Hacaoglu in Ankara
contributed to this report.

Armenia Lost to Turkey

ARMENIA LOST TO TURKEY

A1+
[12:28 pm] 22 January, 2007

In the last round of the qualifying phase of the futsal European
championship Armenia lost the match to Turkey 2:5. Before that
the Armenian players had lost the first to matches to Albania and
Finland. Both matches had ended 3:5.

Armenia occupied the third place in group A and disqualified from
the championship.

Armenian Genocide Movie

Armenian Genocide Movie
Last Update: 1/22/2007 9:44:52 AM

CBS 47, CA
Jan 22 2007

More than eighty years after the Armenian genocide of 1915
Armenian-Americans have a documentary to remember the horror.

The movie was brought to Fresno at the request of the Armenian
community.

Carla Garapedian, the film’s director said, "The term screamers comes
from a book by Harvard professor Samantha Howard. She calls a screamer
someone who refused to stand idly by and watch genocides unfold in
front of them. All through history, we’ve had screamers who have
raise a hand and said we’ve got to stop this."

Over the weekend, the film took on extra significance when one of
the interview subjects was killed on Friday, January 19th, outside
his office in Istanbul, Turkey.

Yerevan Press Club: Society Most Sharply Accepts Loss Of Those Who,

YEREVAN PRESS CLUB: SOCIETY MOST SHARPLY ACCEPTS LOSS OF THOSE WHO,
SERVING TRUTH, ARE NOT HONOURED WITH ADEQUATE SYMPATHY AND ASSISTANCE
DURING THEIR LIFETIME

YEREVAN, JANUARY 22, NOYAN TAPAN – ARMENIANS TODAY. "We, the
Yerevan Press Club members, are deeply upset with famous journalist,
"Akos" newspaper editor-in-chief Hrant Dink’s murder," is said in
the statement spread by the Yerevan Press Club on January 20. The
statement text is completely presented below: "This terrible action is
addressed against the freedom of expression, democracy, normalization
of the Armenian-Turkish relations. It once more proves: there are
still very dark, regressive, rough forces which do not want that
our region proceeds in the way of progress. Hrant’s journalism and
public activity is addressed to protect the person’s right of freely
expressing ideas and overcoming traditional stereotypes which hinder
people to communicate, understand and love each other. Both paassing
over in silence the crime committed in 1915 by the Turkish Government
towards the Armenian population and the criminal pursuit for denial of
the Armenian Genocide which is envisaged in the draft approved by the
French Parliament was inadmissible for him. Being one of few people
in Turkey who dared to speak about the genocide, Hrant Dink observed
any person’s condemnation for having other views as a violation of
the human rights. He was one of those people who was supposed to be
a simbol of renovation of Turkey: a process which is contradictory
and collide with powerful resistance and numerous inner and foreign
obstacles. People like Hrant who strive for overcoming their own
and retainers’ fear, complexes, those who are open for every new and
light thing, are most defenceless. His murder, and earlier the Turkish
authorities’ political pursuit and prosecution affirm this sad reality.

Watching the unprecedented response in the world and just in Turkey
on the occasion of our partner’s death, one unwillingly thinks of the
following paradox: the society most sharply and with exclusive feeling
of sin accepts loss of just those representatives who, serving the
truth and justice, were more vulnerable and were not honoured with
adequate sympathy and assistance during their lifetime. Let it be
another lesson for all those countries where journalists are killed,
subjected to violences and pursuits. By feeling deep sorrow, we can
not stand expressing sorrow on the occasion of a number of statements
the authors of which attempt to speculate the tradegy taken place
in Istanbul, spreading ideas alien to Hrant Dink, displaying by it
disrespectful attitude towards his memory. The journalist’s and public
figure’s murder was, surely, a consequence of the political collisions
existing in the Turkish society, and we called to confront using of
the crime for deepening the abyss of imperceptiblity and hatred. We
want to believe that those values in which Hrant Dink believed, the
goals he strived for, will find more and more supporters in Turkey,
Armenia, all our region.

The Yerevan Press Club has been and remains one of them."