ANKARA: ‘Hrant’s death united us’

New Anatolian, Turkey
Jan 24 2007

‘Hrant’s death united us’

Irazca Geray – The New Anatolian / Istanbul
24 January 2007

Font Size: default medium large

An unprecedented throng of thousands joined yesterday’s Istanbul
memorial procession honoring the memory of weekly Agos Editor in
Chief Hrant Dink and bidding the assassinated journalist farewell.

Starting in the early hours, tens of thousands of people walked in
groups to Osmanbey from all over the city to reach the offices of
Agos, Dink’s Turkish-Armenian paper, where the ceremony started at
11 a.m. with speeches delivered in the name of the editor’s family.

The body of the assassinated journalist was laid to rest at the
Balikli Armenian Cemetery.

The funeral was held on the fifth day after the prominent journalist of
Armenian descent was slain at the entrance of his newspaper’s office in
broad daylight on Friday. A 17-year-old suspect, who has been caught,
already confessed to the killing, while the general belief is that
he is only a pawn used to silence Dink, who was outspoken about the
mass killings of Armenians in the early 20th century and encouraged
reconciliation between Turkey and Armenia as well as fighting for the
freedom to express his thoughts. After ultranationalist layer Kemal
Kerincsiz filed a complaint against Dink for violating controversial
Turkish Penal Code (TCK) Article 301 on charges of insulting
"Turkishness," Dink started receiving an increasing amount of threats
both to his and his family’s life as he was seen as a target. Though
he could have left Turkey for a safer life in the West or Armenia,
he kept repeating that his roots were here and that he would not
leave his country. In his very last column, describing himself as a
dove constantly on the lookout for danger, Dink’s final words were,
"I know they don’t harm the doves in this country."

‘You left my embrace but not your country, my love’

In her speech called "Letter to the Lover," Hrant Dink’s widow Rakel
Dink said that the flood of love rushing to the newspaper has given
her and her family strength. "Today with a voice of silence, we are
seeing him off. Whether 17 or 27 years old, whoever the murdered is,
I know that they were once a baby. The environment that made a murder
out of a baby must be questioned."

Rakel Dink ended her words by saying, "What darkness can make me forget
your love? You left your loved ones, your friends, your children,
my embrace, but you did not leave your country, my love."

The long walk started following the announcement of Dink’s close friend
Aydin Engin, who coordinated the ceremony, saying, "Let’s walk in a
fashion that will show everyone what sort of a world we want."

The amazingly crowded group was made of people of all ages and walks
of life. Along with others the famous Armenian folk song "Sari Gelin,"
which is also popular in Turkey, was played from the loudspeakers
both in Armenian and in Turkish. Another song that again accompanied
the tears of many was "Firatin suyu."

‘We are all Hrant’

The group, which walked for about 8 kilometers from Sisli to Taksim and
then to Yenikapi, formed a procession behind a single banner that read,
"We are all Hrant, We are all Armenian." Individuals also carried signs
reading "Murderer 301" and "We are all Hrant." Besides the main street
between Sisli and Taksim, all side roads in Pangalti and Nisantasi were
packed with people as the main road couldn’t contain the crowd. On
the procession route, individuals leaning out of their balconies and
windows also showed support by clapping and throwing flowers.

Despite the request of Dink’s family and friends, who previously
announced that Dink wanted there to be no slogans during the ceremony,
various groups in the crowd shouted slogans like, "We’re all Hrant,
We’re all Armenian," "Shoulder to shoulder against fascism," "Murderer
301," "Murderer state will pay," "Long live the fellowship of peoples,"
"Either all of us or none, there’s no salvation alone." In an attempt
to respect Dink’s wish, many people clapped and shouted to silence
the slogans.

Reaching Agos’ office, whose door was covered in carnations, wreaths
and papers with odes to Hrant, many people again had difficulty holding
back their tears. Old women were heard chanting, "This is where they
brought our great man down."

Security and doves

There was intense security measures across town, included choppers
that circled above the procession at all times. In line with the
earlier statements of Istanbul Greater Municipality Mayor Muammer
Guler, all police leave was canceled and additional security forces
were requested from neighboring towns. Starting in the early hours,
the Yenikapi-Sarachane road as well as the transit from Sarachane to
Unkapani was closed to traffic. Unkapani Bridge was closed to traffic
in both directions. Vehicle entry to Taksim and also from Mecidiyekoy
to Sisli was banned. The route from Sisli to Yenikapi and the roads
around the Balikli Armenian Cemetery were closed to traffic in stages
as of 7:30 a.m., while the Osmanbey metro station was also closed.

By the time the procession reached Taksim Square, the main bus stop
here as well as the square were packed with police officers.

Ironically, the police were standing under a line of doves that
perched upon the electricity wires across the square.

At the Divan Hotel intersection in Elmadag, Dink’s family and the
hearse parted ways with the procession for the funeral ceremony at
the Meryem Ana Church, while the procession stopped and clapped,
waiting for Dink’s relatives to get on the buses. There were also
around 40 municipality buses arranged to take to Yenikapi the elderly
and those not able to walk further. Later the group continued its
walk towards Unkapani.

‘Death brought us together’

The funeral of Dink was the one of the largest public processions in
Turkish history, and perhaps the largest ever for a person lacking
an official title, as while the head of the crowd marching to the
cemetery reached Unkapani the end of the group was still in Taksim.

Thousands of people gathered to say farewell to Dink and reached
Yenikapi Iskele before 2 p.m.

Aydin Engin stated that they will stand to prevent others suffering
the same fate as Dink. "Hrant united us through his death," he said.

A women paying a last tribute to the journalist said, "We are Turks,
Kurds and Armenians and we want to live in peace together."

Despite earlier admonitions not to, the group chanted slogans in
front of a youth branch of the Nationalist Movement Party (MHP).

Head of state missing

President Ahmet Necdet Sezer, Parliament Speaker Bulent Arinc and
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan were absent from the ceremony
due to scheduling conflicts. The government was represented by Deputy
Prime Minister Mehmet Ali Sahin and Interior Minister Abdulkadir Aksu.

Invited diaspora represented

For the funeral, the government invited moderate names of the Armenian
diaspora and the Yerevan government, with which it does not have
diplomatic relations with. In response Khajak Barsamian, the spiritual
leader of Armenians in America, came to Istanbul. Armenian Foreign
Minister Vartan Oskanian was also present at the ceremony.

Eight people from the Federation of Armenian Associations in France
also came to Turkey for the funeral.

The ceremony at the Meryem Ana Church that started at 2 p.m. and lasted
about 45 minutes was directed by Mesrob II, Armenian patriarch of
Turkey. Following the church ceremony Dink’s coffin met the procession
gathered at the Yenikapi Port Square, and the funeral was seen off
to the Balikli Armenian Cemetery.

ANKARA: PACE President: Whole Country Can Not Be Condemned Because O

PACE President: Whole Country Can Not Be Condemned Because Of A Fanatic
Published: 1/23/2007

Turkish Press
Jan 24 2007

STRASBOURG – Parliamentary Assembly of Council of Europe (PACE)
President Rene van der Linden, commenting on the murder of journalist
Hrant Dink, stated that the whole country could not be condemned
because of a fanatic.

Speaking at a news conference, Linden said there were extremists
in every country including the Netherlands, "a country can not be
condemned just because of this," he added.

Expressing Council of Europe`s willingness to contribute to the efforts
to alleviate tension and searches for dialogue, Van Der Linden said, "I
will separately meet the heads of the Turkish and Armenian delegations
in PACE to see what can be done to ease tension."

Kindred groups urging fight against genocide

Los Angeles Daily News, CA
Jan 24 2007

Kindred groups urging fight against genocide
BY BRAD A. GREENBERG, Staff Writer
Article Last Updated: 01/23/2007 10:48:21 PM PST

Before Adolph Hitler began to wipe out Europe’s Jews, gays and
Gypsies, he argued that Nazi Germany’s brutality would escape global
condemnation.

"Who still talks nowadays of the extermination of the Armenians?"
Hitler asked his commanding generals in 1939, The New York Times
reported at the end of World War II.

The first genocide of the 20th century – the killing of 1 million to
1.5 million Armenians by the Ottoman Turks in 1915 – is viewed by
scholars as a precursor to the Holocaust that erased 6 million Jews.

In Los Angeles, which has among the world’s largest Armenian and
Jewish populations, members of the two communities gathered in Encino
late Monday to share their kinship of suffering and motivate their
youths to fight the forces that lead to genocide.

"The question is: Can we teach our young persons something true so
there will be no genocide in their generation?" said Rabbi Ed
Feinstein of Valley Beth Shalom. "Can we acknowledge that there is
something evil in human nature?"

His audience was the 700 who filled his synagogue to watch
"Screamers," a documentary that will open nationwide Friday about
System of a Down and the band’s campaign to have the Armenian
Genocide recognized by the U.S. and British governments.
Director Carla Garapedian, a North Hollywood High School graduate,
and System bassist Shavo Odadjian spoke after the screening.

"A screamer is somebody whose defenses and whose alibis somehow melt
away, and they actually process what a genocide is without defense,
without guile," Samantha Power, a professor at Harvard’s John F.
Kennedy School of Government and author of the Pulitzer-Prize winning
book "A Problem from Hell: America and the Age of Genocide," says in
an opening scene.

"And when you do that, when you actually allow it all in, there is no
other alternative but to go up to people and to scream and say, `You
know, the sky is falling! The sky is falling! People are being
systematically butchered! We can stop it!"’

Ethnic victims of genocide, humanitarian activists and scholars say
the continued refusal by some countries to use the "g" word when
referring to the Armenian massacre is a reason why genocides occurred
with increasing frequency at the end of the 20th century and the
early part of this century – in Cambodia, Rwanda, Kosovo, Darfur.

Genocide recognition

Turkey has branded the killing of Armenians by the collapsing Ottoman
Empire a consequence of war between ethnic groups; monuments in
Turkey memorialize Turks killed by Armenians. But the European Union
has stated that Turkey must acknowledge that the act was genocide
before it can join.

There have been U.S. efforts to recognize the genocide – resolutions
passed the House in 1974 and 1985 – but each has failed because the
government fears offending a military ally.

"Jews have held onto this phrase, `never again.’ I remind people that
`never again’ first appeared in the book of Genesis when God says to
Noah that he will never again flood the Earth," Stephen Feinstein,
director of the Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies at the
University of Minnesota, said in an interview.

"When God speaks, we can believe it. When men speak, it’s a little
harder. `Never again’ is just a clich . Intervention always depends
on national interest. That is as simple as it is."

Band makes you ask

In "Screamers," the four members of System of a Down, who are
Armenian and grew up in Hollywood and the San Fernando Valley, talk
about their missing family trees and protest outside the Illinois
office of former House Speaker Dennis J. Hastert, who has opposed
genocide resolutions.

Wherever the band appears, their fans speak of what happened to the
Armenians – something barely taught in American public schools.

"This band didn’t start to change the world. This band didn’t start
to change your mind," singer Serj Tankian says in a performance at
the Greek Theatre. "This band started to make you ask questions."

Adam Braun, who is Jewish and a freshman at Harvard-Westlake School,
said the band’s music taught him about a genocide he’d never heard
of. "The next step is having the courage to stand against these
things."

Interwoven with concert performances are expert interviews, including
one with Armenian-Turkish journalist Hrant Dink, who was assassinated
in Istanbul last week and whose funeral took place Tuesday; Turkish
protest footage; and photos and footage of genocides from Armenia to
Sudan.

"Why do genocides continue to occur in the 21st century?" says Salih
Booker, executive director of Global Rights. "Because those that
committed it in the 20th century got away with it."

ANKARA: Sezer raises concerns over Poland’s ‘genocide’ resolution

Sezer raises concerns over Poland’s ‘genocide’ resolution
Wednesday, January 24, 2007

Turkish Daily News , Turkey
Jan 24 2007

Turkish Daily News

The alleged genocide of Armenians at the hands of the Ottoman Empire
appeared on the agenda of talks yesterday between Turkish President
Ahmet Necdet Sezer and his visiting Polish counterpart, Lech Kaczynski,
with Turkey voicing its uneasiness over a "genocide" resolution
recently passed by the Polish Parliament, diplomatic sources said.

The Polish president defended his country’s stance, saying that there
is sensitivity in Poland over the genocide issue and that it is very
difficult for a Polish politician to give a negative response to a
"genocide" call. Kaczynski said the Polish Parliament passed the
Armenian "genocide" resolution of 2005 not because they had sympathy
for the Armenians, sources added. The Jews of Poland were subject to
Nazi Germany’s genocidal policies.

Parliament Speaker Bulent Arinc sent a letter to his Polish counterpart
at the time condemning the resolution that recognizes the Armenian
allegations and in a protest move cancelled three parliamentary
activities with Poland in that year.

As part of his meeting in Ankara, Kaczynski repeated his country’s
call to play a mediator role in the normalization of ties between the
two neighboring countries, Turkey and Armenia, the same sources said.

The Polish president said his country is ready to help for the
normalization of Turkish-Armenian ties.

Turkey severed its diplomatic ties and closed its border gate with
Armenia after Armenian troops invaded the Azerbaijani territory of
Nagorno-Karabakh in the last decade. Turkey says normalization of
ties depends on Armenian withdrawal and an end to Armenia’s support
of efforts to win international recognition for the alleged genocide.

Sezer and Kaczynski signed a joint declaration during their meeting at
the Cankaya Presidential Palace. European Union-member Poland extended
strong support for Turkey’s aspirations to join the 27-nation bloc
in the document.

Energy was another issue discussed between Sezer and Kaczynski.

Concerned by Russia’s energy policies, Poland wants to cooperate
with Turkey in that sphere. Poland dissolved its military during
its integration process with NATO. The visiting president has asked
Turkey’s support in the restructuring of the Polish military.

TIME: Editor’s Death Spotlights Turkish Nationalism

TIME MAgazine
Jan 24 2007

Editor’s Death Spotlights Turkish Nationalism
Tuesday, Jan. 23, 2007 By PELIN TURGUT/ISTANBUL Article

ToolsPrintEmailReprints The murder of Armenian-Turkish journalist
Hrant Dink has put Turkish nationalism in the spotlight. The suspect,
17-year-old Ogun Samast, was quoted by newspapers as telling police
he shot Dink because the journalist insulted the Turkish nation.
Local papers are reporting that Samast was allegedly linked to a
small ultranationalist group in his hometown, Trabzon, on the Black
Sea Coast. "Those who created nationalist sentiment in Turkey have
fed such a monster that there are many youngsters on the streets who
do not find the … state nationalist enough and are ready to take
the law into their own hands," wrote Ismet Berkan in his daily column
in Radikal, one of Turkey’s main dailies.

Related
Teen Admits Killing Turkish Editor
The teenage boy suspected of fatally shooting an ethnic Armenian
journalist confessed during initial questioning that he killed the
man
Nationalism in Turkey has been fueled in recent years by the lukewarm
reception of Turkey’s bid for membership in the European Union. Many
in Europe have voiced misgivings over embracing the populous, mostly
Muslim (although officially secular) country. The accession process,
which began with great optimism in 2004, has slowed significantly in
recent months. With Europe appearing ever distant, ambitious
politicians on all sides have stepped up their nationalist,
ethnocentric rhetoric ahead of elections slated for November this
year. The country’s right-wing parties especially have gained
strength. So much so that even traditional leftist organizations like
the Republican People’s Party are campaigning on a nationalist
program. Its leader Deniz Baykal has spoken out against the European
Union and legislation for religious minorities. He has even opposed
lifting an anti-free speech law under which Dink and Nobel
prize-winning novelist Orhan Pamuk were prosecuted.

The E.U. wants Turkey to abolish that law, Article 301, which is used
by nationalist prosecutors and lawyers to charge writers and
journalists with "insulting Turkishness." At Dink’s funeral today,
many in the procession carried posters that read "301 is the real
killer." "His murder has started some soul-searching," says Hakan
Altinay, director of the Open Society Institute in Turkey. "Turks
need to look at themselves and ask how they could have bred the
xenophobia and paranoia that would lead a kid to do this. Everyone
has some degree of responsibility here."

Dink, 52, a widely respected journalist and editor of Agos, a Turkish
and Armenian newspaper, was gunned down in front of his office in
central Istanbul on Friday. He had been branded a "traitor" by
nationalists for his comments on the mass deaths of Armenians in the
then Ottoman Empire during World War I. Hundreds of thousands of
Armenians died in 1915, in what many Armenians – like Dink – say was
systematic policy. Turkey denies any claim of genocide and says the
deaths were part of a partisan conflict in which thousands of Turks
were also killed.

But Dink’s murder may yet serve as a wake-up call. Since Friday, tens
of thousands of people have flocked to his newspaper offices to pay
their respects, many chanting slogans like "We are all Armenians." On
Tuesday, thousands filled the streets to pay homage to Dink, carrying
the same signs. "Everybody here feels responsible," said Ayse Sivri,
a 21-year-old student. "We all saw this coming, but nobody did
anything to prevent it."

Istanbul standstill for Dink funeral

InTheNews.co.uk, UK
Jan 24 2007

Istanbul standstill for Dink funeral

Tuesday, 23 Jan 2007 21:26

At least 100,000 thronged the streets of Istanbul to mourn Hrant Dink

The funeral of a Turkish Armenian journalist attracted over 100,000
mourners in Istanbul today.

Hrant Dink, the 53-year-old editor of Agos magazine, was shot dead on
Friday.

Today’s funeral saw mourners, many of whom carried black signs
reading "we are all Hrant Dink" and "we are all Armenians", throng
the streets of Istanbul as the cortege processed through the city’s
streets.

"We are seeing off our brother with a silent walk, without slogans
and without asking how a baby became a murderer," Mr Dink’s widow
Rakel was quoted by the Reuters news agency as saying in a eulogy to
her dead husband.

Mr Dink was a vociferous critic of the Turkish government’s continued
refusal to accept culpability in the Armenian massacre of 1915, which
many foreign governments have recognised as genocide.

At least one million Armenians are thought to have died in the
killings, which, as today’s events demonstrate, remain a highly
controversial issue in Turkish society.

Nationalists infuriated by Mr Dink’s anger stance against the Turkish
government are believed to have carried out the murder. A 17-year-old
boy has confessed to the killing, according to media reports.

Teenager charged with Dink murder

Teenager charged with Dink murder

BBC
Wednesday, 24 January 2007, 22:45 GMT

Turkish prosecutors have charged a teenager with murdering prominent
Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink.

Ogun Samast, 17, also faces charges of being a member of an armed gang –
along with four other detained suspects.

Dink, 53, was gunned down outside his newspaper’s office in Istanbul last
week. His murder has triggered anger and shock across Turkey.

Dink had written controversial articles about the Armenian "genocide" in
1915 in Turkey, a claim denied by Ankara.

Mr Samast was jailed pending trial on charges of premeditated murder,
membership in an armed gang and illegal possession of firearms, Istanbul’s
prosecutor Aykut Cengiz Engin said.

Four other suspects were charged with involvement in Dink’s murder and
membership in the gang.

Among them is Yasin Hayal, who has reportedly confessed to inciting the
killing and providing Mr Samast with the gun and money.

The charges were brought at the end of the legal four-day detention period.

The date of the trial is yet to be set.

‘Voice of Armenians’

Thousands of people attended Dink’s funeral in Istanbul on Wednesday.

Hrant Dink’s funeral became an extraordinary show of unity
As the editor of bilingual Turkish-Armenian newspaper Agos, Dink was a
well-known public figure in Turkey.

His articles about the alleged mass killings of Armenians by Turks at the
beginning of the 20th Century had sparked huge controversy in the country on a
number of occasions.

In October 2005, Dink was given a six-month suspended sentence under a
controversial law against insulting "Turkishness".

He had reportedly received threats from nationalists, who viewed him as a
traitor.

Hundreds of thousands of Armenians died or were driven out of Turkey in
1915, in what many Armenians say was genocide.

Turkey admits that many Armenians were killed but it denies any genocide,
saying the deaths happened during widespread fighting in World War I.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

The Hague: Demonstration for Hrant Dink

Federation of Armenian Organisations of the Netherlands (FAON)
24 April committee for recognition and commemoration of the Armenian
genocide of 1915
Address: Weesperstraat 91 – The Hague
K.v.K. 27264382
E-mail: [email protected]
Website:
Contact: M. Hakhverdian

Press Release

Demonstration in The Hague for Hrant Dink

Armenians, Turks, Kurds, Arameans for the first time together in a
demonstration; large interest of politics and press; Turkish embassy refuses
to receive declaration.

The Hague, 23 January 2007 – The cooperating Armenian organisations in the
Netherlands held a demonstration and a silent march on 23 January in The
Hague for Armenian journalist Hrant Dink assassinated last Friday in
Istanbul. Approximately 1000 persons gathered at the square Het Plein near
the building of the House of Representatives (Dutch Parliament). The
demonstration started at 1 p.m. Approximately at the time of the burial of
Dink in Istanbul. The square was filled with sounds of Armenian classical
and medieval music.

Armenians coming from all parts of the country, met on the square with
Turks, Kurds, Arameans, Assyrians and Dutch to emphasise their outrage for
the assassination of Dink. The participants were carrying banners, posters
and badges with the portrait of Dink and placards with inscription "We are
all Hrant Dink, We are all Armenians". Also flyers with the portrait and
biography of Dink and the declaration of the organisation in reaction to
Dink murder were distributed. After a two-minutes silence representatives of
Armenian, Turkish and Kurdish organisations as well as Members of Dutch
Parliament from CDA (Christian Democrat), GroenLinks (Greens) and Socialist
Party factions came to the stage to express their indignation at murder of
Dink. Core of the messages was the condemnation of the assassination of
Dink, Turkey being also responsible for the murder in view of the Turkish
Penal Code (TPC) and the lack of required police protection for the
frequently threatened Dink.

In the new form of dialogue and cooperation between the different ethnic
groups – in the spirit of Dink – hope was raised for a better future for all
in Turkey and abroad.

In the House of Representatives a delegation submitted a declaration to the
chairman of the Permanent Commission on Foreign Affairs Mr. Hans van Baalen
(VVD Party). Other members of the Commission, like Mr. Koenders and Mr.
Timmermans (PvdA – Labour Party), Mr. van Dijk (CDA – Christian Democrat),
Mr. van der Staaij (SGP), Ms. Marieko Peters (GroenLinks – Greens) also
attended this meeting. It was remarkable that two Members of Parliament of
Turkish origin, namely Mr. Coruz (CDA) and Ms. Koser Kaya (D66) also were
present.

In the declaration, signed by Armenian, Turkish, Kurdish, Aramean and
Assyrian organisations, the Parliament was asked to adopt a still more
critical attitude towards Turkey with respect to the freedom of speech and
the rights of minorities. This is important, because there is a direct
relation between the condemnation of Dink under Article 301 TPC and the fact
that Dink clearly spoke about the Armenian Genocide and also because he was
an Armenian. Mr. Van Baalen assured the delegation that the Parliament will
follow closely the investigation to the murder of Dink. Mr. Van Baalen added
that according to the motion Mr. Rouvoet of 2004 the Dutch Parliament has
recognised the Armenian Genocide and it will stick entirely to this motion
in its relation with Turkey.

Then in a silent march the participants marched to the Turkish embassy and
assembled in front of the embassy at the Malieveld field. During the march
they were carrying a large portrait of Dink followed by a banner with the
text "Armenian Genocide, when will it stop?" At the Malieveld, a delegation
went to the Turkish embassy to submit the same declaration to the
ambassador. In spite of the fact that it was announced in advance that a
delegation would come to hand over a declaration to the Ambassador, the
doors of embassy remained closed. The Dutch police was charged to bring the
declaration to the embassy later. The participants were disappointed of the
embassy¹s is attitude, because they were hoping that the spirit of dialogue
and openness would have reached also the Turkish embassy.

National and regional TV, radio and other media were present and covered the
event positively.

–Boundary_(ID_oX32f8e7JeUSqThZanTr4g )–

www.24april.nl

ANKARA: Turkey’s parliamentary speaker favours changing article 301

Turkey’s parliamentary speaker favours changing article 301

NTV MSNBC, Turkey
Jan 24 2007

Arinc said that if a bill was tabled to abolish or revise the notorious
article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code, the parliament would quickly
discuss it.

Guncelleme: 09:17 TSİ 24 Ocak 2007 CarşambaANKARA – The
Turkish parliament could consider amending an article of the country’s
penal code that deals with the crime of insulting Turkish identity,
the speaker of the Grand National Assembly said Monday.

Speaking after paying a condolence visits to the family of murdered
Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink and the Armenian Patriarch
Mesrob Mutafyan, Bulent Arinc said that he was personally in favour
of lifting or revising article 301.

However, Arinc said it was not up to him but to the parliament to do
so, adding that no result had been achieved from talks between the
government and NGO on the issue.

There have been a number of court cases opened against Turkish writers
and journalists, including Turkish Noble Prize winner novelist Orhan
Pamuk, under article 301. One of the few found guilty of the charge
was Dink, who was given a six month suspended sentence in late 2005.

MAIN PAGE: Georgian sting seizes bomb grade uranium

Georgian sting seizes bomb grade uranium
By DESMOND BUTLER, Associated Press Writer

Associated Press
January 24, 2007

Republic of Georgia authorities, aided by the CIA, set up a sting
operation last summer that led to the arrest of Russian man who tried
to sell a small amount of nuclear-bomb grade uranium in a plastic
bag in his jacket pocket, U.S. and Georgian officials said.

The operation, which neither government has publicized, represents
one of the most serious cases of smuggling of nuclear material in
recent years, according to analysts and officials.

The arrest underscored concerns about the possibility of terrorists
acquiring nuclear bomb-making material on the black market,
although there was no suggestion that this particular case was
terrorist-related.

"Given the serious consequences of the detonation of an improvised
nuclear explosive device, even small numbers of incidents involving
HEU (highly enriched uranium) or plutonium are of very high concern,"
said Melissa Fleming of the U.N.’s International Atomic Energy Agency.

Details of the investigation, which also involved the FBI and Energy
Department, were provided to The Associated Press by U.S. officials
and Georgian Interior Minister Vano Merabishvili.

Authorities say they do not know how the man acquired the nuclear
material or if his claims of access to much larger quantities were
true. He and three Georgian accomplices are in Georgian custody and
not cooperating with investigators.

Georgian attempts to trace the nuclear material since the arrest and
confirm whether the man indeed had access to larger quantities have
foundered from a lack of cooperation from Russia.

Merabishvili said that he was revealing the story out of frustration
with Russia’s response and the need to illustrate the dangers of a
breakdown in security cooperation in the region.

A message left with the press office of the Russian Embassy was
not returned. A duty officer at the Russian Foreign Ministry told
The Associated Press that there was no one authorized to comment on
Wednesday night.

Russia has tense relations with Georgia, a former Soviet
republic. Georgia has been troubled by Russia’s support for separatists
in two breakaway Georgian border regions, Abkhazia and South Ossetia.

The sting was set up after Georgian authorities uncovered extensive
smuggling networks while investigating criminal groups operating in
the breakaway republics, Merabishvili said.

"When we sent buyers, the channels through Abkhazia and South Ossetia
began to expand and we started seeing a huge flow of materials,"
he said.

"Sometimes it was low-grade enriched materials, but this was the
first instance of highly enriched material."

According to his account, during an investigation in South Ossetia,
a Georgian undercover agent posing as a rich foreign buyer made contact
with the Russian seller in North Ossetia, which is part of Russia.

After the Russian offered to sell the sample, the agent rebuffed
requests that the transaction occur in North Ossetia, insisting the
Russian come to Tbilisi, the Georgian capital.

At a meeting in Tbilisi, the man pulled out from his pocket a plastic
bag containing the material. Uranium has a low level of radioactive
emission and can be transported more safely than other radioactive
materials.

The man was arrested and sentenced to eight to 10 years in prison on
smuggling charges. His accomplices were sentenced on lesser charges.

Russian authorities took a sample of the material but failed to
offer any assistance despite requests for help from the Georgians,
Merabishvili said.

"We were ready to provide all the information, but unfortunately
no one arrived from Russia, not even to interview this person,"
Merabishvili said.

"It is surprising because it is in Russian interests to secure these
materials. There are terrorist organizations in Russia who would pay
huge amounts of money for this."

The Georgians asked for U.S. assistance. Agents from the FBI and
the Energy Department took the material back to the United States,
where it was tested by the Energy Department’s National Nuclear
Security Administration.

"The material was analyzed by agency nuclear experts and confirmed
to be highly enriched uranium," said Bryan Wilkes, a spokesman for
the the agency.

Fleming, of the IAEA, said that the agency was aware of the Tbilisi
seizure and was expecting formal notification from Georgia soon.

The CIA declined to comment on the case. FBI spokesman Richard Kolko
confirmed that the FBI was involved in the investigation and called
it a success, but he would not provide details.

Merabishvili, who was visiting Washington this week, said he did not
have some details of the investigation available, including the exact
date that the arrest was made or the full name of the suspect. Further
efforts to clarify with the Georgian Embassy were not successful.

None of the U.S. officials would confirm the exact weight of the
seizure or its quality, but Merabishvili said it was about 3.5 ounces
of uranium enriched by more than 90 percent.

Uranium enriched at 90 percent is weapons grade.

A nuclear bomb of a design similar to the one exploded over Hiroshima
in 1945 would require about 110 pounds of uranium enriched at over
90 percent, according to Matthew Bunn, a senior research associate
who focuses on nuclear theft and terrorism at Harvard University’s
Kennedy School of Government. Bunn said that a more sophisticated
implosion type nuclear bomb would require 33 to 40 pounds.

According to an IAEA database, there have been 16 previous confirmed
cases that either highly enriched uranium or plutonium have been
recovered by authorities since 1993.

In most cases the recoveries have involved smaller quantities than
the Tbilisi case. But in 1994, 6 pounds of highly enriched uranium
intended for sale were seized by police in the Czech Republic. In
2003, Georgian border guards using detection devices provided by the
U.S. caught an Armenian man with about 5 ounces of HEU, according to
the State Department.

Fleming said that examples of stolen or missing bomb-grade nuclear
material, including highly enriched uranium and plutonium, are rare
and troubling.

David Albright, a former U.N. weapons inspector and head of the
Washington-based Institute for Science and International Security
said that lacking help from Russia, the CIA may be looking to other
allies to help identify who has access to lost nuclear material.

"Russian cooperation in answering these questions is critical but it
has not been forthcoming," he said. "One way to identify who is active
in trading these materials is to conduct sting operations," he said.

Associated Press writer Katherine Shrader contributed to this report.

_go_ca_st_pe/uranium_sting_5

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070125/ap_on