ANKARA: Gul admits article 301 problematic

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Jan 25 2007

Gül admits article 301 problematic

Foreign Minister Abdullah Gül acknowledged yesterday that changes in
a penal code article were necessary, the strongest sign yet from the
government that the law, criticized by the European Union for
restricting freedoms, could be amended.
`We know that there are some problems with Article 301,’ Gül told
reporters before departing for an international donors conference on
Lebanon in Paris. `We see that changes in the article are necessary.’
Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code (TCK) is once again under
the spotlight after the murder of Hrant Dink, a Turkish-Armenian
journalist who had been tried and sentenced to a six-month suspended
imprisonment for `insulting Turkishness’ under the law.

The suspected murderer, 17-year-old Ogün Samast, reportedly told the
police that he had killed Dink because he had said `Turkish blood is
dirty.’
The government has dragged its feet on changing the law, requesting
more time to see how it is implemented and saying that no one, in the
end, has been sent to jail under Article 301. But Dink, in his last
column for his Turkish-Armenian newspaper, Agos, wrote that
imprisonment was not the only punishment that a person could suffer,
complaining that he had come to be known as a person convicted of
insulting Turkishness.
Justice Minister Cemil Çiçek, one of the most reluctant figures
within the government to change the law, said on Tuesday that
possible amendments should be discussed at a later stage, after Dink
was buried.
Dink’s funeral on Tuesday drew up to 100,000 people. Some
participants carried banners reading `Murderer 301.’
`We want free expression of thoughts that do not contain any
incitement to violence,’ Gül told reporters. `We don’t want anyone to
go to jail because of expressing his or her views.’ He added that the
government was in touch with nongovernmental organizations to obtain
their proposals on how Article 301 should change.

Bahçeli: Nationalism under attack
The funeral of Dink, who was shot three times in the neck on Friday
in front of his newspaper office, was widely seen as a call for
reconciliation between Turks and Armenians, with participants
carrying identical black-and-white banners reading `We are all Hrant
Dink’ and `We are all Armenians.’
In another sign that the funeral could lead to the improvement of
relations between Turkey and Armenia, the government invited members
of the Armenian diaspora and Armenian religious leaders to the
funeral.
Devlet Bahçeli, leader of the Nationalist Movement Party (MHP),
criticized mourners for carrying banners reading `We are all
Armenians’ and complained there was a `purposeful lynching campaign’
against the state and Turkish nationalism.
`It has become a tradition to declare the state guilty after every
incident taking place in this country and start a campaign aimed at
eroding trust in the state,’ Bahçeli said.
Bahçeli also lashed out at the Turkish Industrialists and
Businessmen’s Association (TÜSİAD), Turkey’s leading business
group, for calling for education in languages other than Turkish and
measures to allow political parties to do politics on ethnic lines in
a recent study.
According to Bahçeli, this puts TÜSİAD on the same page with the
outlawed Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK). `This shows TÜSİAD
supports the PKK’s politicization project,’ he said.

Nationalism behind editor’s murder worries Turkey’s Jewish community

Jewish Telegraphic Agency, NY
Jan 25 2007

Nationalism behind editor’s murder worries Turkey’s Jewish community

By Yigal Schleifer
January 25, 2007

ISTANBUL, Jan. 25 (JTA) – The murder of an outspoken Armenian
journalist has sent shockwaves throughout Turkey, raising questions
about whether a recent nationalist upsurge in the country has taken a
violent turn against the country’s minorities.
Last week’s murder of Hrant Dink also presents the government with a
serious challenge to its already embattled democratization and
political reform efforts.

RELATED ARTICLES
Turkish Jews watch minorities bill
Although Turkey’s 25,000-member Jewish community has not been
targeted – the 2003 bombings of two Istanbul synagogues were
attributed to al-Qaida-type Islamists rather than Turkish
nationalists – community officials are expressing concern about the
nationalist atmosphere in Turkey.

`The fact that nationalism is on the rise is very troubling for us,’
one senior Jewish community leader said. `As a minority, we see
[Dink’s murder] as a result of the rise of nationalism in the
society, of the encouragement of nationalism in many parts of the
society.’

In a massive outpouring of grief, tens of thousands of Turks gathered
Tuesday in the heart of Istanbul for the funeral procession.

Dink was editor of the bilingual Turkish-Armenian newspaper Agos and
a vocal critic of Turkey’s treatment of its religious minorities as
well as its policy of rejecting claims that the mass killing of
Armenians by the Ottoman Turks in 1915 was genocide.

He had been put on trial several times for `insulting’ Turkish
identity with his writings. In 2005 he was convicted in one case and
given a six-month suspended sentence.

Last Friday he was shot three times near the entrance to the
newspaper’s offices. Turkish police arrested Ogun Samast, 17, from
the Black Sea city of Trabzon, in connection with the murder.

`Those who created nationalist sentiment in Turkey have fed such a
monster that there are many youngsters on the streets who do not find
the state nationalist enough and are ready to take the law into their
own hands,’ Ismet Berkan wrote in Radikal, one of Turkey’s main
dailies.

The last few years have seen Turkey engaged in a deep internal
struggle. The country’s push for European Union membership has
resulted in significant political reforms, particularly regarding
democratization and human rights, and the freeing up of debate on
what previously had been taboo subjects, such as the Armenian
question.

But the E.U.-related reforms have prompted a strong nationalist
backlash. Nationalist lawyers and prosecutors have been able to use a
law, known as Article 301, to charge writers and journalists like
Dink and Nobel laureate Orhan Pamuk with the crime of insulting the
state as a way of stifling the emerging debates and putting the
brakes on Turkey’s E.U. bid.

Some say the backlash also explains why various conspiracy theory
books about the United States and Israel have become popular, as has
a Turkish translation of `Mein Kampf.’ The murder early last year of
a Catholic priest in Trabzon also was seen as an expression of the
nationalist wave.

`In a sense, both sides have been sharpening their axes thinking that
the E.U. question is the final intellectual battle in Turkey,’ said
Ali Carkoglu, a political science professor at Sabanci University.
`It touches on everything that is salient in Turkish politics: the
Islam vs. secularism debate, democratization and the extent to which
individual human rights are to be protected.’

For many Turks, Dink’s murder harkens back to the turbulent 1970s and
’80s, when journalists and intellectuals often were the victims of
ideologically motivated violence. Though Turkey has moved forward
since then, some wonder whether the murder is an indication that the
political gains made over the past few years really have been
consolidated.

`By Turkish standards [Dink] was playing in a way that the
nationalists were not used to,’ said Rifat Bali, a Jewish,
Istanbul-based researcher who studies Turkey’s minorities and is an
expert on the Jewish community. `In a way he took too many risks, he
underestimated his opponents.

`The message of the murder is you shut up, know your limits as an
Armenian or a non-Muslim, and do not go public often and repeatedly,
otherwise it will turn out bad for you,’ Bali said.

Turkey’s government was quick to respond to the murder, sending top
officials to oversee the investigation. The quick arrest of Samast
also is seen as a positive sign, since perpetrators of such crimes
were rarely caught in the past.

According to press reports, Samast has confessed, saying he decided
to murder Dink after reading on the Internet that he had insulted
Turkey.

`A bullet has been fired at democracy and freedom of expression,’
Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan said on television. `I condemn the
traitorous hands behind this disgraceful murder. This was an attack
on our peace and stability.’

But experts here say the murder poses a major challenge for the
Turkish government, led by the moderately Islamic Justice and
Development Party.

`Domestically speaking, we have a big challenge,’ Carkoglu said. `If
we cannot protect our small minorities, other big talk about
democratization in our country is not worth much.’

Dink, who founded Agos in 1996, used his last few columns to write
about his legal woes. His final column dealt with the increasing
amount of hate mail he was getting, including one letter that scared
him enough that he went to the local prosecutor to ask,
unsuccessfully, for protection.

`I don’t know anyone else like him who raised his voice for
minorities and democracy in Turkey,’ veteran journalist and human
rights activist Murat Celikkan said. `Intellectually he was a very
important figure for Turkey. We don’t have anyone else like him.’

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Rwanda: Genocide Will Be Stopped If Perpetrators Are Punished

The New Times (Kigali)
Jan 24 2007

Rwanda: Genocide Will Be Stopped If Perpetrators Are Punished – Wallis

INTERVIEW

Gaaki Kigambo & George Kagame
Kigali

Andrew Wallis is the author of Silent Accomplice, The Untold Story of
The Role of France in the Rwandan Genocide, a new book detailed in
research and unwavering in pointing out the role of the French in the
Rwandan Genocide.

He was recently in Rwanda to continue his research into the truth
behind why the French were here and what their aims and objectives
were and how these aims impacted on the Rwandan people. The New Times
GAAKI KIGAMBO and GEORGE KAGAME caught up with him for an interview.
Below are the excerpts.

TNT: Your book has been published 12 years after the genocide and
behind so many others books about Rwanda. Don’t you think it’s a
little bit too late?

AW: You would hope that after 12 years lessons have been learned by
some of the western powers but as the current events in Darfur prove
genocide is still very much a reality and looking at the French
involvement in other Francophone countries and their heavy support
for dictators with appalling human rights records France seems to
have learnt very little. In fact it still denies heavily its
responsibility of what happened in Rwanda where some nations like
Belgium have made attempts to apologise. It’s still shocking 12 years
they are yet to admit in any way at all what actually they were doing
here and how their policies implicated in allowing the genocide to
happen.

TNT: Silent Accomplice has been launched in London and is scheduled
to be launched in the US this week. How has it been received?

AW: There has been shock from those who reviewed the book and people
have read articles in some of the newspapers I’ve written for. People
who knew very little about the genocide and certainly have no
suspicion at all that one of the five permanent members of the
Security Council could have been heavily involved in arming and
training those responsible for it. So the reaction has been really
absolute shock and almost all editors have taken the view that France
should not be allowed to get away with it and France has serious
questions it needs to ask itself and to come back and attempt in any
way possible to make amends.

TNT: Your book is detailed in research about the role of France in
the genocide unwavering in accusing France of aiding and abetting the
genocide. What has been the French response ever since the book came
out?

AW: There’s certainly been unofficial response; their ambassador in
London was very unhappy about the book and the articles in the
newspapers which proceeded it. However, I’m well aware that this book
is in no way meant to be anti-French. I have great regard for the
French nation but its politicians have for 40-50 years trampled
roughshod over the rights of African nations they say they are
serving. I have French friends who are working as hard as I am to
uncover the truth about what their politicians got up to in 1990-94.
Many of those politicians now incidentally are serving time in prison
or have been implicated in various corruption scandals in France
itself.

TNT: The French government passed a law which would penalise anyone
who failed to recognise the 1915 Armenian massacre in Turkey. It has
also acknowledged its folly in deporting Jews to their death back in
the 1950s. Why is it so silent on Rwanda even every voice out of
Rwanda implicates it?

AW: Genocide is a political crime and if it in any way admits its
responsibility here it would damage the French standing in other
African nations and it’s after all Africa that’s still France feels
makes it a great nation today. So to admit the reality of what
happened in Rwanda would impact on several other francophone
countries. It makes it easy to apologise for its role in deporting
over 100,000 Jews in the Second World War because that was 60 years
ago and most people involved are almost dead. It is also easy to talk
about the Armenian crisis but again that is a political issue and
should be seen in light of France’s bad relations with the Turkish
government and it’s using that particular issue to knock the Turkish
government out [of the EU]. It’s quite another thing to actually
admit something in such recent memory where most of the politicians
involved, apart from Mitterrand himself, are still alive. And for
them to admit that they had a hand in helping to train and arm a
genocide regime is not even something they want to lay in their
consciences. So it is easier to deny it at whatever cost to Rwanda
and its people…

I think after some of the leading players are no longer here it will
be much easier for a French President in 2050 or 2060 to admit the
reality of Rwanda in 1994. But I think while there are so many
strident players in the French military and politicians who are so
stridently anti the present government in Rwanda, it will be
impossible to admit their faults.

TNT: The French-Rwanda relations have soured in the recent months.
None of the western countries has said anything leaving Rwanda to
battle France in a scenario reminiscent of the biblical David and
Goliath epic. Is this another sense of betrayal and abandonment?

AW: In the West, I think that unfortunately Africa is a bit of a lost
continent. Certainly in the UK today Africa is little known about.
When people do find out about it, when it turns up in the news,
people show interest. But it is important that the West puts up its
hands and takes responsibility this is after all the 21st Century we
talk about globalisation and we talk about the world being a smaller
village with telecommunications and satellites maybe that now should
go into politics as well. The West should take the initiative on
this.

TNT: According to your book that the International Criminal Tribunal
for Rwanda (ICTR) operations need viewing. It has handled a few cases
since its inception and some of its judgments leave a lot to be
desired. It has become a source of minting huge sums of money. Are
you suggesting the UN is just trying to be seen to be delivering
justice when actually it has moved on to more serious matters?

AW: Unfortunately, the ICTR is just another institution and like all
institutions it rarely quite manages to hold up to the ideal that it
should be holding up to. It must first of all bring justice to those
who suffered appallingly in 1994. The fact that in many cases
justice, as people would say, has failed. For example, in the very
recent case of Fr Seromba who was convicted of knocking his church on
top of his congregation and killing several thousand people, and he
received a meagre 15 years in prison. There has to be a degree of
thought that the court is bowing to political pressure from outside
countries. In some of the sentencing, sentencing guidelines don’t
seem to count for anything; sometimes people [are] getting life other
times getting 10 years for the same crime. So the problem is politics
coming before justice that cannot always make a right outcome.

TNT: Rwanda is in advanced stages of scrapping the death penalty.
Wouldn’t it be right for some of the cases in Arusha to be
transferred here since the death penalty has been cited as a
hindrance?

AW: The court’s ends it mandate in 2008 so certainly some cases will
now comeback to Rwanda. That’s good; they should face justice in the
country before the countrymen and women where they perpetrated their
alleged crimes. For example, last month four alleged genocide
suspects were arrested in London and the chances are now because of
the removal of the death penalty they will come to stand trial in
Rwanda, which is good for everyone. The Rwandan people can see
justice before their own eyes. Most Rwandans do not know what happens
at the court in Arusha. They’ve never been there. They hear news
reports. In a way justice is denied if you cannot see it happening.

TNT: What is the inspiration of your book?

AW: I was in Rwanda in 1991 just as a tourist going to see the
gorillas and I got fascinated by the country then and indeed fell in
love with the country and its people. Later I went on to do a masters
degree [and] the subject of Rwanda and France relations [came up] and
I think the more I learned about what had happened the more shocked I
was and even more shocked by the fact that there was nothing written
in English about this matter and there was almost complete ignorance
about this matter of injustice. So to me it is a matter of justice
that it is on record what happened. And I think there’s alot more
information still to come out on this matter both in France and
people who witnessed what happened in this country. So it’s an
ongoing project. Genocide can only be stopped if the perpetrators
cannot get away with it anymore. It is very necessary for western
countries to understand that to arm and train people far away still
implicates them. The fact they cannot see the killing doesn’t make
their implication what happened any less.

Turkish city grapples with violent record

Christian Science Monitor, MA
Jan 24 2007

Turkish city grapples with violent record

The teen who killed a Turkish-Armenian journalist came from a small
village that has been front and center in several recent nationalist
incidents.

By Yigal Schleifer | Correspondent of The Christian Science Monitor

TRABZON, TURKEY – This small city on the Black Sea coast is getting
used to being in the headlines – for all the wrong reasons. Over the
past two years, Trabzon – best known for its successful professional
soccer team, nicknamed the Black Sea Storm – has been front and
center in a series of events that have shocked Turkey.

Last week, a local teenager confessed to firing the gun that killed
Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink, whose murder has had
repercussions well beyond Turkey’s borders.

Almost a year ago, a 16-year-old shot and killed an Italian priest
who was working in a Trabzon church. In May 2005, four students
passing out pamphlets about prison conditions were almost killed by
an angry mob of 2,000 who thought they were Kurdish activists.

With the murder of Mr. Dink – whose funeral procession in Istanbul
Tuesday was joined by tens of thousands – Turks inside and outside
Trabzon are now trying to figure out if something has gone dreadfully
wrong in the city.

"For the past 20 years, the politicians have been pumping nationalism
and chauvinism into Trabzon," says Gultekin Yucesan, head of the
local branch of the Human Rights Association, a Turkish watchdog
group.

"I wasn’t surprised to find out he was from Trabzon," he says about
Ogun Samast, the 17-year-old accused of Dink’s murder. "There are
hundreds of other kids like Ogun Samast in Trabzon right now."

Long known as a bastion of nationalism, Trabzon has seen hard times
in recent decades. Once an important commercial port, it is today
more known for the sex trade that brings women from the former Soviet
Union into Turkey. Unemployment in the city is high, while the
countryside around Trabzon, long dependent on hazelnut crops, has
seen its market go from boom to bust.

Black Sea folk have a reputation in Turkey for a culture of violence
(Trabzon has one of the highest gun ownership rates in the country).
Locals say that influence, mixed with the lack of economic
opportunity, creates a worrying situation.

"It’s like a highly explosive material. If it’s not handled properly,
it will explode," says Omer Faruk Altuntas, a lawyer who is the head
of the Trabzon branch of the leftist Freedom and Solidarity Party
(ODP).

"A very ugly atmosphere is growing," he says, speaking in his
book-lined office.

Umut Ozkirimli, a political scientist at Istanbul’s Bilgi University
who studies nationalist attitudes, says Trabzon is a hotbed, but not
an exception.

"Nationalism and bigotry are not unique to Trabzon," he says. "It’s a
microcosm, an extreme example of something that exists in other
places."

According to published reports, Mr. Samast told the police: "I feel
no remorse. [Dink] said Turkish blood was dirty blood."

An unemployed high school dropout, Samast was reportedly part of
group of youths that fell under the sway of a local extreme
nationalist who spent 10 months in jail for the 2004 bombing of a
Trabzon McDonald’s in 2004, becoming something of a notorious local
hero.

The Pelitli area of Trabzon, where the accused murderer grew up, is
built on a steep hill overlooking the Black Sea and the airport
runway. It is made up of rows of afet evleri – "natural disaster
homes" – squat buildings built two decades ago after massive floods
and mudslides displaced villagers.

Residents says there is not much to do except play soccer and go to
one of the two Internet cafes (one has now closed after police
confiscated all its computers as part of its investigation).

"This is like a small village in Trabzon. There are not many options
here, people don’t have jobs," says Talat Alamder, a young unemployed
man standing outside a convenience store.

"Maybe if the young people have a good income, they wouldn’t think
about doing such things," he says, referring to Dink’s murder.

The district’s mayor, Omer Kayikci, says his office is struggling to
keep up with Pelitli’s needs. While the town’s official population is
10,000, the real number is closer 30,000, he says.

"What we are given for one person, we must spend on three," adds Mr.
Kayikci, who has suddenly found tiny Pelitli under the media
spotlight. Satellite television trucks were parked in front of his
office for several days.

"People migrate into this area every day. We have big
responsibilities and we are trying our best to help people, but we
don’t have enough," he says.

Squeezed between the slate-colored waters of the Black Sea and the
pitched foothills of the Kackar mountain range, Trabzon can have an
almost suffocating quality. During the winter, the air in the city is
thick with the acrid soot of cheap Russian coal that many people
burn.

Salih Camoglu, a businessman who publishes two local daily
newspapers, says the city, like other places in Turkey, has not been
unaffected by the rapid changes brought about by the country’s
European Union membership drive and by events in Iraq.

"Nowadays, what’s going on in the region is like an earthquake," he
says. "This can damage places all around it."

Discussing Dink’s murder, human rights activist Yucesan says recent
events have him worried that Trabzon is heading in a dangerous
direction.

"I’m from here, and we locals have brave hearts, but even I am
sometimes scared," he says.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: Bar asks who threatened Dink at Istanbul dep gov office

New Anatolian, Turkey
Jan 26 2007

Ankara Bar asks who threatened Dink at Istanbul deputy governor’s
office

Burak Esen – The New Anatolian / Ankara
26 January 2007

After days of rallies and tears, as interest in Hrant Dink’s killing
fades to join a long list of political murders, the Ankara Bar
yesterday made an attempt to keep the issue alive, at least for a
short while longer.

The bar asked the Interior Ministry to launch a disciplinary and
criminal investigation into an Istanbul deputy governor and two
people with him who allegedly threatened the late Armenian-origin
Turkish journalist, basing this request on a column by Dink telling
of this incident in the deputy governor’s office.

Dink, in his Jan. 12 column "Why was I chosen as a target?" in his
bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly Agos, claimed that he was
threatened by two unknown "relatives" of the deputy governor over one
of his news articles.

The claims were also touched upon by a close friend of Dink following
his murder last Friday. Aydin Engin stated that some time ago an
Istanbul deputy governor called and extended an invitation to Dink.
"When Dink got there, no one paid attention to him," said Ergin.
"There were two people with the deputy governor. He introduced them
to Dink as his friends. Afterwards, one of the two, a man, spoke at
length and said that there are all sorts of people on the streets and
that something bad could happen to him."

Engin added that Dink mentioned the event in his application to the
European Court of Human Rights (ECHR).

Dink wrote in his column that he was invited to the office of an
Istanbul deputy governor and to bring documents about a news story,
but only after he reminded them about the documents did they remember
that they had called him to discuss them.

The documents were about a news story claiming that Ataturk’s adopted
daughter Sabiha Gokcen, Turkey’s first female Turkish pilot, was an
ethnic Armenian, and Istanbul Governor Muammer Guler, in a statement
in defense of his deputy, said that the news had disturbed the
Turkish people.

Guler also said that Armenian Patriarch Mesrob II Mutafyan was
subjected to death threats after the story, which, he remarked, may
have prompted the deputy governor to tell Dink of the unwanted
consequences of his news.

Guler also said, as quoted in the petition, that while the police and
the governor’s office were discussing security measures to protect
Mesrob II, an official responsible for security called Dink to
exchange information with him about threats against the patriarch.

However the governor revealed neither the name of the deputy governor
or the position of people with him during the meeting.

Dink, who explained the reason for the invitation as to examine
documents about the story, also said in his column that both the
deputy governor and the unknown male at the meeting respectively told
him that he was an experienced journalist and that he should write
more carefully.

"Although we’re sure that you have no bad intentions, you may face a
public backlash as not everyone interprets your articles the way we
do," Dink quoted the unknown guest as saying.

The bar’s petition, which asked about the relationship of the two
people to the deputy governor and whether they are public servants,
was given to the ministry by lawyer Kemal Vuraldogan yesterday.

The details the lawyer sought from the ministry on behalf of the
Ankara Bar are as follows:

– Whether the deputy governor has the authority to invite Dink to
discuss documents about a news article he wrote.
– Why the documents brought along by the journalist weren’t examined.
– Whether the two people who attended the meeting are public
servants, and if so, which institutions they work for.
– Why the deputy governor introduced the two as his relatives if
these people were actually public servants and if this could be
considered unethical.
– Under what authority the deputy governor met with Dink, while two
other people accompanied him
– Why the deputy governor failed to record the minutes of the
meeting.
– Why Dink was informed about threats against Mesrob II rather than
Mutafyan himself.
– Whether the deputy governor or the two people threatened Dink.

ANKARA: Pamuk returns home, optimistic about future

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Jan 27 2007

Pamuk returns home, optimistic about future

Nobel Prize-winning Turkish author Orhan Pamuk said "I don’t think of
these things any more" in response to reporters’ questions over
threats as he arrived at the airport in İstanbul.
Pamuk was coming from Cairo where he joined the 39th Cairo Book Fair
as an honorary guest. Reporters asked him about the threat made by
Yusuf Hayal, one of the names behind the murder of Armenian editor
Hrant Dink, Pamuk dismissed claims by saying he was not giving them a
second thought.
Regarding the death of former Foreign Minister Ismail Cem, Pamuk
said, "He was a very valuable author. I grew up reading his works. I
am deeply sorry."
Pamuk underlined the significance of the Cairo Book Fair in
bridging the Turkish and Arabic cultures, as well as the importance
of translating books between the two languages. He said, "Maybe this
Nobel Prize will contribute to that, God willing. Six or seven of my
books have been translated into Arabic and they are going to be
re-released. With support of the Egyptian Ministry of Culture, my
other novels will be translated soon. There is huge interest in all
aspects of Turkish literature and culture. I hope the reciprocal
works continue."
Customs officers at the border offered chocolate to Pamuk on the
occasion of International Customs Day.

27.01.2007

Seyfettin Koçak İstanbul

Killing of Turkish Editor Termed Assault on Free Expression

Washington File, DC
Jan 27 2007

Killing of Turkish Editor Termed Assault on Free Expression

United States, world community condemn murder of journalist Hrant
Dink

By Eric Green
USINFO Staff Writer

U.S. Undersecretary of State R. Nicholas Burns. (File photo; © AP
Images)Washington — The United States and the world community say
the assassination of independent Turkish journalist Hrant Dink
strikes a blow against freedom of expression.

In condemning Dink’s January 19 murder in Istanbul, Julie Finley, the
U.S. ambassador to the Organization for Security and Co-operation in
Europe (OSCE), said the assassination of an independent-minded
journalist like Dink is `an assault that is felt by all.’ Finley
said the United States welcomed Turkey’s `quick and proper reaction’
and promise to solve the murder case as quickly as possible.

Finley added that Turkish President Ahmet Necdet Sezer was right in
characterizing the murder as a `repugnant and shameful attack’ that
`deeply wounded’ Turkey.

Sezer’s wish that Turkey `never experience such a sorrowful event
again’ is the United States’ wish as well, said Finley. She added
that the United States applauded the `new gestures of openness’
between Turkish and Armenian authorities in response to the
assassination.

In an interview with Mehmet Ali Birand of the Turkish television
station Kanal D January 19, Under Secretary of State R. Nicholas
Burns called Dink’s murder "an outrageous act of criminality."

"We look forward to see Turkish justice and we look forward to see
these killers brought to justice," he said. (See related article.)

At a January 23 memorial service in Washington for Dink, U.S.
Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs Daniel
Fried said the slain journalist `stood for a civic virtue higher than
hatred, higher than ethnic stereotypes, higher than fears and
repression and ignorance. His was a vision of a better world. His was
a vision of the best in Turkey’s tradition. The measure of how our
world falls short must be judged by his murder at the hands of an
ignorant, hate-filled nationalist.’

Miklos Haraszti, the OSCE representative on freedom of the media,
said January 19 he was shocked by Dink’s murder.

Dink was one of Turkey’s `outstanding commentators on
Armenian-community related affairs," said Haraszti, adding that `this
is a cowardly act resulting in tragic loss."

The editor and columnist of the bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly
Agos, was gunned down outside his paper’s offices.

PRESS FREEDOM GROUPS UNITED IN CONDEMNATION

The Paris-based press freedom advocacy group, Reporters Without
Borders, said Dink was outspoken in his views regarding the massacre
of Armenians under the Ottoman Empire during World War I. The
organization said Dink’s murder `will distress and disturb all those
who defend the freedom of thought and expression in Turkey and
elsewhere.’ The Ottoman Empire was a vast Turkish state that existed
from 1299 to 1922.

Dink’s murder follows a report by Reporters Without Borders that more
journalists were killed around the world in 2006 than in any year
since 1994. At least 81 journalists were killed in 21 countries
while doing their jobs in 2006. (See related article.)

Reflecting on the dangers facing journalists worldwide, Karen Hughes,
the State Department’s under secretary of state for public diplomacy
and public affairs, told USINFO January 12 that `we live in a time of
unprecedented attacks on the media around the world. Journalists in
many countries face the threat of being harassed, abducted,
imprisoned, tortured, maimed or assassinated just for doing their
jobs. We need to talk much more in international circles about the
extent of this problem — what’s being done about it — and what more
we could do."

Another press freedom group, the New York-based Committee to Protect
Journalists (CPJ), said 18 Turkish journalists have been killed for
their work in the last 15 years, making Turkey the eighth deadliest
country in the world for journalists.

The CPJ said in a January 19 statement that Dink had received
numerous death threats from nationalist Turks who objected to his
views.

The group said that `through his journalism, Hrant Dink sought to
shed light on Turkey’s troubled past and create a better future for
Turks and Armenians. This earned him many enemies, but he vowed to
continue writing despite receiving many threats.’

Koïchiro Matsuura, secretary-general of the U.N. Educational,
Scientific, and Cultural Organization, said January 22 that he
welcomed the speed with which the Turkish authorities were
investigating the case. Matsuura said the swift investigation was
`proof’ of the Turkish government’s determination to not let `this
heinous crime go unpunished.’

The State Department’s Country Reports on Human Rights Practices –
2005 discusses freedom of speech and press in Turkey. For additional
information, see the Turkey section of the report on the State
Department Web site.

(USINFO is produced by the Bureau of International Information
Programs, U.S. Department of State. Web site:
)

e.gov/xarchives/display.html?p=washfile-english&am p;y07&m=January&x0701261230161Xeneerg0.632 3511

http://usinfo.state.gov
http://usinfo.stat

Russian FM discusses prospects of NK peace process with counterparts

ARKA News Agency, Armenia
Jan 24 2007

RUSSIAN FOREIGN MINISTER DISCUSSES PROSPECTS OF NAGORNO-KARABAKH
PEACE PROCESS WITH HIS ARMENIAN, AZERBAIJANI COUNTERPARTS

YEREVAN, January 24. /ARKA/. The Russian Foreign Minister Sergey
Lavrov discussed the current state and the prospects of the
Nagorno-Karabakh peace process with his Armenian and Azerbaijani
counterparts Vardan Oskanyan and Elmar Mamediarov in Moscow.
The Armenian and Azerbaijani Foreign Ministers held their regular
consultations on the Nagorno-Karabakh peace process in Moscow, with
participation of the international mediators – the Co-Chairs of the
OSCE Minsk Group (Russia, USA, and France). Russian Deputy Foreign
Minister Grigory Karasin represented Russia. N.V. -0-

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Kocharyan’s regular visit to Russia evidence of active dialogue

ARKA News Agency, Armenia
Jan 24 2007

ARMENIAN PRESIDENT’S REGULAR VISIT TO RUSSIA EVIDENCE OF ACTIVE
TOP-LEVEL DIALOGUE

YEREVANA, January 24. /ARKA/. RA President Robert Kocharyan’s regular
visit to Russia is evidence of an active top-level dialogue.
The press service of the RF Embassy in Armenia reports that the
Armenian leader’s visit is supposed to raise the level of
Russian-Armenian strategic partnership, strengthen bilateral
cooperation in the most importance spheres, using the potential
created by the Year of Armenia in Russia and the Year of Russia in
Armenia.
"Armenian-Russian relations are described as allied relations and are
distinguished by positive dynamics of development. Regular contacts
between the two countries’ Presidents have become practice and are
distinguished by mutual confidence," says the report.
The sides are to discuss the most urgent issues or bilateral
cooperation and prospects for development. The sides are to discuss
the execution of top-level agreements on further development of
Armenian-Russian cooperation, particularly in the fuel, energy and
transport sphere.
The Armenian and Russian Presidents plan to exchange views on
deepening cooperation with the Collective Security Treaty
Organization (CSTO) and reforming the CIS.
The sides will focus their attention on coordination of efforts to
improve the situation in the Caucasus, create an atmosphere of
confidence in the region, establish cooperation and settle conflicts
on this basis.
The sides will lay emphasis on the settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh
problem.
"Russia welcomes further Armenian-Azerbaijani dialogue at various
levels, first of al between the two countries’ Presidents. We proceed
from the principle that the conflicting parties themselves must find
a mutually acceptable solution to the conflict. We are ready to
render most active assistance both in the bilateral aspect and as
OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chair and become guarantor of a prospective
agreement," says the Embassy’s report.
This year will see the 15th anniversary of fruitful multipronged
cooperation between Armenia and Russia, which has a solid basis – an
Agreement on Cooperation and Mutual Assistance, Declaration on
Armenian-Russian Cooperation oriented at the 21st century.
RF President Vladimir Putin’s visit to Armenia in March 2005 and RA
President Robert Kocharyan’s visit to Russia in January, August and
October 2006 were significant stages of consolidating the strategic
partnership and intensifying bilateral cooperation. P.T. -0–

WB programs contribute largely to Armenia’s economic development

ARKA News Agency, Armenia
Jan 24 2007

WB PROGRAMS CONTRIBUTE LARGELY TO ARMENIA’S ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

YEREVAN, January 24. /ARKA/. The effective and targeted World Bank
(WB) programs were effective and goal-oriented: they contributed
largely to Armenia’s economic development, Armenia’s Minister of
Finance and Economy Vardan Khachatryan said at his meeting with the
WB Regional Director Donna Dausette-Coyrolo and the Acting Director
of the WB Yerevan Office Naira Melkumyan.
Khachatryan pointed out the intention of Armenia’s government to pay
more attention to the development of the country’s rural communities
and small towns in the next few years, a task which can be largely
supported by the WB.
Dausette-Coyrolo gave positive appraisal of the Armenia’s
achievements in comparison with other countries.
Speaking about the strategy of the future WB projects in Armenia,
Dausette-Coyrolo attached importance to providing technical and other
assistance, along with the financial support.
The sides expressed hope for further effective cooperation and
implementation of programs to promote the country’s development.
Armenia has cooperated with the WB since 1992. For the period, the WB
allocated $952.25mln to Armenia for implementation of 44 programs.
N.V. -0–