Ambassadors of Armenia, Turkey to Italy Took Part in Dink Protest

AMBASSADORS OF ARMENIA AND TURKEY TO ITALY TOOK PART IN PROTEST ACTION
CONDEMNING MURDER OF HRANT DINK

Yerevan, January 30. ArmInfo. A protest action was held in front of
the building of Rome’s municipal administration, the participants of
which expressed their protest against the murder of the
Editor-in-Chief of "Agos" newspaper, Hrant Dink, killed in Istanbul on
January 19.

According to the information, received by ArmInfo from the
press-service of Eparchy of the Armenian Apostolic Church in Italy,
the primate of AAC Eparchy Aren Shahinyan, the Ambassador
Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of Armenia to Italy, Ruben
Shougaryan, the Ambassador of Turkey to Italy, representatives of
Italy’s Senate, as well as tens of representatives of the Kurd and
Turkish communities of Italy participated in the action.

ANKARA: Ashura, pluralism and the creation of a new mosaic

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Jan 30 2007

Ashura, pluralism and the creation of a new mosaic

by KERIM BALCI

Yesterday was the day of Ashura according to the Islamic calendar. In
the Shia world this was a day of mourning commemorating the murder of
Huseyin, the grandson of the Prophet of Islam, Mohammed.
In the northern Sunni world of Turkey, Pakistan, Malaysia and
Indonesia, this was a fasting day. Some Shiites express their
feelings by inflicting pain on themselves, flogging their backs to
the point of bleeding. Sunnis express their feelings at the esoteric
dimension: fasting of the mouth, of the tongue, of the eye.
Fasting in the Sunni world is not only about abstaining from eating,
but also about eating as a congregation. A classic meal for the day
of Ashura is a sweet dessert also called ashura. Probably an Armenian
tradition Islamicized later on, ashura is a mixture of many
ingredients that would not give the sense of a meaningful meal at
first sight. Think of de-husked wheat, chickpeas, white beans, rice,
dried apricots, dried figs, raisins, orange, rose water, walnuts,
pomegranate and sugar in the same cup of sweet! The number of
ingredients are so high that folk legend has it that Noah prepared
this pudding from the last bits of food remaining on the Ark when he
wanted to celebrate the landing of the Ark.
Ashura is a symbol of modern-day life. On December 4, 2004, the
famous Abant Platform was having its eighth meeting in Brussels at
the European Parliament. The topic of discussion was understandably
Turkey’s place in the EU. Then the discussion on Turkey’s bid to join
the EU was concentrated on the `EU’s absorbing capacity.’ Columnist
Hüseyin Gülerce was one of the speakers there and he opened his
speech with a recipe for ashura. Using the symbolism of ashura,
Gülerce told the audience that ingredients that seem to be no match
at first sight might become a delicious delight if put in the hands
of a skilful cook. `Turkey is an ingredient that is hard for the EU
to absorb, but once done, it will enrich the taste of Europe,’ said
Gülerce.
Two years since that speech and today we know that the absorption
issue is a real challenge, not only for Europe but for Turkey too.
Turkey has always been a mosaic of cultures thanks to its Ottoman
past and the central attraction of Anatolia. In the last ten years,
the Aegean and Mediterranean coastlines of Turkey have become
attractions for Northern European ex-pats willing to settle down in a
warm environment. British, Russians, Germans, Dutch and Norwegians
are acquiring houses in Turkey and adding new ingredients into this
mixture of nations, this huge cup of ashura.
The cooks know that ashura is ready to be served by the white beans
in it. This is the most resistant ingredient that needs to be
integrated into the general taste of the delight. Given the perceived
historical realities of the Armenian minority in this country, they
are the white beans of our ashura in this allegory. And on this
Ashura Day, I have more faith in the potential of this nation to
become the tastiest delight of this mosaic world.

Russia Reacts Coolly to U.N. Report on Kosovo

DefenseNews.com
Jan 30 2007

Russia Reacts Coolly to U.N. Report on Kosovo

By BROOKS TIGNER, BRUSSELS

The nations orchestrating Kosovo’s independence from Serbia have
splintered over a new report for achieving that goal, with Russia
alone giving a cool reception to the idea.
The report remains confidential. According to diplomatic sources
here, it studiously avoids any blatant references to the word
`independence’ for fear of stoking tensions – already high – between
Belgrade and Kosovo, and between the latter’s ethnic Albanian
majority and Serb minority.
The much-anticipated report by Martti Ahtisaari, the United Nations
special envoy to Kosovo, was presented Jan. 26 to the six-nation
Contact Group on Kosovo (France, Germany, Italy, Russia, the United
Kingdom and United States). Ahtisaari will travel in February to the
Balkans to unveil the content of his proposal to Belgrade and
Pristina.
As expected, all but Russia approved the report and its
recommendations for organizing Kosovo’s de facto separation. Allied
with Serbia, Russia said it awaits Belgrade’s reaction before drawing
its own conclusions.
Whether that will be officially forthcoming anytime soon is an open
question, however. Following Serbia’s national elections Jan. 21, a
new government has yet to be formed. However, nearly all parties
oppose outright independence for Kosovo.
NATO troops are standing by if there’s trouble.
During a Jan. 26 meeting of allied foreign ministers, for instance,
NATO Secretary-General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer said NATO `fully
supports and will play its part in the U.N.-led process to resolve
Kosovo’s final status.’ The alliance currently has 16,000 troops to
oversee the breakaway province’s security.
Meanwhile, other regions of the world with separatist movements based
on uncertain legal premises such as that of Kosovo are closely
watching what happens in the Balkan province.
In the last year, for instance, Russian officials have made ambiguous
statements about any imposed independence for Kosovo and the
implications for territories such as Moldovo’s breakaway
Transdnistria province or the Caucasus’ three so-called frozen
conflicts – South Ossetia and Abkhazia in Georgia, and
Nagorno-Karabach, the Armenian-ethnic enclave which Azerbaijan lost
to Armenia in 1994.
Armenia’s Prime Minister Andranik Margaryan said last week in Yerevan
that `fresh thinking about Nagorno-Karabach’s status’ was needed and
that `the conventional legal treaties and conventions of the past 100
years do not apply to today’s situation’ in the enclave.
Armenia effectively incorporated Nagorno-Karabach into its territory
as a separate entity, though the international community does not
recognize the enclave’s independence.

Book: A family confronts a time of madness

Christian Science Monitor, MA
Jan 30 2007

A family confronts a time of madness
An Armenian author re-creates memories of the ordeal of her people.

By Yvonne Zipp

Say the word "genocide," and anybody not currently running Iran will
immediately think of the Jewish Holocaust. Cambodia, Rwanda, and
Bosnia might also come to mind. But say Armenia and in the United
States even highly educated people may draw a blank.

Antonia Arslan has taken steps to rectify that situation. Those who
read her unsparing debut novel, Skylark Farm, will never forget the
events of 1914-1918, when more than 1 million Armenians living in
what is now Turkey were massacred in what is widely regarded by the
international community as a genocide.

Arslan’s family was among that number. Her book is classified as
fiction because she uses the structure of a novel to re-create events
that occurred before she was born, but not because she is inventing
them. In "Skylark," the Italian professor of literature has woven her
family’s "obscure memories" together with research, including
interviews with survivors and her own imagination to tell the story
of how three young nieces and one nephew escaped the genocide and
made it safely to their uncle in Italy.

The Arslans were a prosperous family living in the hills of Anatolia.
In 1914, family patriarch Sempad awaits the return of his older
brother, Yerwant, who had gone to Italy as a teenager to study. Both
men engage in elaborate preparations: Yerwant buys a red Isotta
Fraschinni with a silver monogram, so that he can travel in style,
loading it with gold and silver trinkets for everyone in the family.
Sempad, meanwhile, renovates Skylark Farm, the family’s country
house. He orders a stained-glass window from Great Britain, lawn
furniture from Austria, and has the ground dug for a tennis lawn.

But instead of the long-cherished family reunion, World War I begins.
A few weeks before Yerwant and his family are to leave for Anatolia,
Italy closes its borders. Yerwant desperately tries to get
information about his family, not knowing that a campaign to destroy
the Armenian minority had begun in April, and that by May, Sempad’s
tennis lawn had become a mass grave.

In the first part of the novel, Arslan introduces all the members of
the family, laying out who will survive and who will not. The
language in Part 1 can, understandably enough, veer into the
overwrought, and Arslan indulges in a few too many prophetic dreams.
The human warnings that Sempad and his family ignore are
heartbreaking enough, without throwing in green angels and deathbed
prophecies. Also understandably, Arslan tends to have Turkish
characters spout overripe dialogue rather than engage in a precise
examination of the banality of evil. One exception: in a chilling
scene, the Interior Minister Talat Pasha, in a secret meeting, orders
the roundup of Armenian males and then goes off to play backgammon
with Armenian poet Krikor Zohrab. "He’s always right on time, a real
gentleman," Pasha remarks to his aide.

But once the massacre at Skylark Farm occurs – in a powerfully
unflinching scene – the narrative takes hold and Arslan’s writing
surges to meet her material. All the Armenian women, children, and
the elderly are rounded up and forcibly evacuated from the city. They
leave in loaded carriages, but are set on by Kurdish bandits
operating on orders from the Turkish zeptiahs. Those who survive are
forced to march, starving, all the way to Aleppo, where they will be
deported to the desert. No one is allowed to give them food; there is
a law that makes helping any Armenian punishable by death. (Arslan is
careful to mention the brave people, such as the holy leader of
Konya, who defied that order.)

At this point, the race to save the surviving Arslan children takes
on an inexorable momentum. Their unlikely saviors include a Turkish
beggar, a Greek wailer (a professional mourner) and the wife of a
French consul. As they march, Shushanig, the mother, and Azniv, her
second-oldest daughter, do everything to keep the children alive.
(Shushanig only has one son left, her toddler, Nubar. All the men and
boys in their city were murdered. Someone put little Nubar in a dress
as a joke that saved his life.) Azniv’s heroism is all the more
poignant because she could have fled to Paris with a Turkish soldier
who was in love with her.

The strength of the tale is striking: By page 23 readers know what
the outcome will be and yet it’s impossible to stop reading. "Skylark
Farm" operates like "Schindler’s List"; it’s a story of hope that
makes it easier for us to confront the horror of what happens when
evil is allowed to run unchecked.

– Yvonne Zipp regularly reviews fiction for the Monitor.

tml

http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0130/p14s03-bogn.h

ANKARA: Oran: We already see 301’s effects in praising violence

The New Anatolian
via ABHaber, Belgium
Jan 30 2007

Political scientist Oran: We already see 301’s effects in atmosphere
praising violence

A controversial academic, apparently out of favor with state
institutions since he advocated further rights for non-Muslim
minorities in a state-ordered report, yesterday said no good can come
from Turkish Penal Code (TCK) Article 301.

"The article should be completely annulled because the problem isn’t
the article itself but its implementation," said Ankara University
political scientist Baskin Oran, using the words of those defending
the article, but reaching an opposite conclusion.

Apart from several politicians arguing that the article sets up a
wall against insults aimed at the Turkish state and its institutions,
Justice Minister Cemil Cicek laid the blame on the judiciary, saying
that judges should adopt new insights into the article’s
interpretation and implementation.

Cicek on Sunday also responded to accusations that the government
lacks the will to change the article, but is mentioning it to satisfy
the European Union, which has been pushing Turkey to annul or at
least change the article to achieve a fair and transparent penal
code.

Cicek said that the ruling Justice and Development (AK) Party
government has made changes to the article twice and added that if
another change is necessary the government will not shrink from its
responsibility.

He also reiterated his view that several EU member countries also
have similar articles. "Society has split in three over the article,"
said Cicek, adding, "One group says the article should be annulled
altogether, one says it should be kept with a couple of changes, and
the other even goes as far as saying that the penalties should be
increased."

He said he received 12 advisory offers for change so far, adding that
the government has no bias on the change.

However Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, at a press conference
prior to his departure for Sudan on Sunday, said that there is no way
that the article can be annulled, but that the government is open to
any suggestions for change.

"I call upon the academics who want to see the article annulled to
reconsider their views, their suggestions are not viable. There are
several countries with articles similar to our 301," said Erdogan.

He also criticized civil groups for the current wide disagreements
between them. "I personally held meetings with several civil groups
over the article but I saw that they even cannot come to terms with
each other," the premier said.

Baskin applies to prosecutor over threats

Oran, after applying to the Ankara Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office
regarding a threatening letter, said that he has been receiving such
letters since his report about minority groups’ rights, which sparked
tense debates.

"There’s no need to wait to see the implementation of the article
under such an atmosphere praising violence. We are experiencing its
practices on a daily basis," Oran added. He also stood trial on
charges of spreading discriminatory propaganda and provoking hatred
along with another academic, but the charges were dropped.

Oran, accompanied by officials and members of several human rights
groups, told reporters that he applied to the prosecutor’s office
late in 2004 over two threats but his complaint was dropped.

He also handed out copies of letters he was sent. He said that he
asked Public Prosecutor Hasan Dursun to prosecute the senders of the
letters and emails but added that the prosecutor had asked if he
could reach a compromise with those threatening him.

Oran is the third public figure to apply to the prosecutor over
threats or make public threatening messages after Armenian-origin
Turkish journalist Hrant Dink was killed.

Dink was gunned down by a teenager who reportedly wanted to punish
the journalist for his views.

Orhan Pamuk, the Nobel Prize-winning Turkish author, said he has also
been receiving threats. He was given state protection after Dink’s
murder. Both stood trial under Article 301 on charges of "insulting
Turkishness."

Report: Azerbaijan president does not rule out use of force to seize

International Herald Tribune, France
Jan 30 2007

Report: Azerbaijan president does not rule out use of force to seize
Nagorno-Karabakh
The Associated PressPublished: January 29, 2007

PARIS: Azerbaijan’s president said he prefers a peaceful solution to
a dispute with Armenia over the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh, but is
not ruling out military means, a French newspaper reported.

President Ilham Aliev, in an interview in Le Monde daily before
arriving in France for a three-day visit, was quoted as saying the
disputed territory is "issue No. 1" for his oil-rich Caucasus
Mountains country, which is growing bolder as its economic strength
grows.

"It’s clear that our political weight will give us one day the means
to liberate our lands," Aliev, who met Monday with French President
Jacques Chirac, was quoted as saying. "We’d prefer to do it
peacefully, without going to war. But if there are no other means …
we’ll see."

Chirac, in a speech to guests at a state dinner in Aliev’s honor,
made it clear that he favors a peaceful solution.

"France would like to believe that the time for peace has come," the
French leader said. "Getting there requires a final step."

Nagorno-Karabakh, a mountainous territory inside Azerbaijan but
populated largely by ethnic Armenians, has been controlled by ethnic
Armenian forces since the end of a six-year war in 1994. Tensions
remain high between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Diplomats from Russia, France and the United States have headed more
than a decade of efforts by the so-called Minsk Group – part of the
Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe – to resolve the
Nagorno-Karabakh issue.

In a statement Monday, the group said it was encouraged by what it
called the "constructive" approach of the leaders of Armenia and
Azerbaijan as they work toward resolving the Nagorno-Karabakh
conflict.

Azerbaijan has been building up its military with an influx of
revenues from oil. It controls portions of the Caspian Sea, on its
eastern fringe, which has some of the largest oil and gas fields in
the former Soviet Union.

Aliev was quoted as telling Le Monde that he was looking to deepen
bilateral economic ties between Azerbaijan and France.

ANKARA: Do you know these facts?

Turkish Daily News , Turkey
Jan 30 2007

What Others Say
Tuesday, January 30, 2007

Do you know these facts?:

by Emin PAZARCI, Bugün

Turkey has been arguing about Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code
(TCK) for days. What is this article about? Why do they want to
change it? Here’s what it says: Insulting Turkishness, the republic,
the Parliament, the government, the judiciary, military and security
agencies is punishable with a jail sentence from six months to two
years.’ The article also says, `Expressions of thoughts meant to be
criticism cannot be subject to judicial review.’ It is rather
obvious that Article 301 does not ban expressing a thought. It only
regulates insulting or denigrating these institutions. This is the
article they want removed. What is more, similar articles existent in
the penal codes of many European countries. Let’s take a look at who
wants it removed. A demonstration was held in Yerevan following the
killing of Hrant Dink. Only Armenians joined this demonstration,
which protested against Turkey. The protesters unfurled banners
demanding that 301 be abolished. There was another demonstration
organized by the Armenian diaspora, known for its activities against
Turkey, in France on Jan. 27. Participants of that demonstration were
also against 301. In 1970s and 1980s, Armenian militants killed 40
Turkish diplomats abroad. Yerevan didn’t even condemn these murders.
Nobody from Armenia participated in the funerals of our martyrs. On
the contrary, the Armenian government encouraged and praised the
terrorist organization Armenian Secret Army for the Liberation of
Armenia (ASALA) in its statements. The Armenians, which blame us all
as Turks, occupied the Karabağ region of Azerbaijan. Some
Western countries aided them and they committed mass murders there.
The West, which pressures us to remove 301, doesn’t even move a
finger when it comes to Yerevan’s occupation of Karabağ. Turkey
is accused of having closed the Armenian border. Armenia on the other
hand demands part of our territory. It does not recognize the Turkish
borders which it wants opened. In addition, it adds the genocide
allegations against us. The West is walking over us when they should
be walking over Armenia. We should view discussions regarding
Article 301 in light of these facts. Only then can you see why they
want 301 to be abolished!

Intolerance in Turkey

Press & Sun-Bulletin, NY
Jan 30 2007

OPINION
Intolerance in Turkey

The Turks added one more to the slaughtered Armenians of the early
20th Century by the killing of the editor of an Armenian-Turkish
newspaper.

While I am not of Armenian extraction, I did work in Turkey in the
1960s. While there I met Armenians who related accounts of that
terrible 1915-1917 slaughter. I also read that some Armenian children
were scattered in various villages across Turkey.

In a very remote village I met one such loner of a man in his 50s.
Because of his background, we thought he would appreciate a Bible in
Turkish, which while he had never seen, he indeed welcomed. When we
came back an hour later, he was still sitting absorbed, reading his
priceless treasure.

Unfortunately, a similar investigation would reveal that Turkey has
not been very tolerant of any citizen claiming to be a Christian,
especially those who have converted from Islam.

Kenneth Cetton
Port Crane

article?AID=/20070130/OPINION/701300306/1005/OPINI ON

http://www.pressconnects.com/apps/pbcs.dll/

ANKARA: A General – The unlikely agent of change

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Jan 30 2007

Gen. Yaşar Büyükanıt: The unlikely agent of change

by LALE SARIIBRAHIMOGLU

Turkey’s outspoken and hawkish Chief of General Staff Gen. Yaşar
Büyükanıt has long been uneasy over what he sees as indifference
by foreign diplomats to Turkish military deaths from the outlawed
Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) terrorist organization. The
assassination of Turkey’s leading Turkish-Armenian journalist, Hrant
Dink, early this month in Istanbul has reportedly prompted
Büyükanıt to lodge similar complaints to a group of ambassadors
from several countries who visited him recently.
It has become a customary practice for Gen. Büyükanıt to invite
people who seek individual appointments from him all at the same time
when his schedule is busy. In one of those meetings full of
ambassadors, Büyükanıt was again critical of some foreign
diplomats’ decision to attend Dink’s funeral but not that of the
soldiers.
It is worth mentioning here that Gen. Büyükanıt strongly
condemned Dink’s slaying and one of his top generals in İstanbul
was at the funeral, while a wreath was sent on behalf of the Turkish
Armed Forces. I mention this to the readers to prevent a possible
misunderstanding that the Turkish military was indifferent to Dink’s
slaying.
But whether we agree or not, the Turkish Armed Forces (TSK) have long
been uneasy over the absence of foreign diplomats at soldiers’
funerals and apparently seek from diplomats the same sensitivity that
they show to the slaying of the country’s intellectuals and
journalists.
Büyükanıt is keen on meeting with foreign diplomats to express
the military’s views on various foreign policy issues, unlike some of
his predecessors such as retired Gen. Hüseyin
Kıvrıkoğlu , who imposed a ban during his tenure on
such meetings. But during his time no major military reforms were
attempted to reduce the still-existing political power of the
military.
Nevertheless, while meeting with the foreign diplomats, Gen.
Büyükanıt, outspoken by nature, used this opportunity to express
military views on several foreign policy issues.
Here are some excerpts from comments made by Büyükanıt during
his meeting with the diplomats:
`I want the TSK to become smaller in size, but for this to happen we
need modern equipment. Our size is big and people find it difficult
to understand’*
`We won’t send more soldiers to Afghanistan. Turkey has done its bit
in Afghanistan, such as assuming ISAF command twice.’
`NATO needs to do more in Pakistan to solve the situation in
Afghanistan.’
`The damage has already been done in Iraq’s oil-rich Kirkuk, when
records and deeds were destroyed [by the Kurds] soon after the US
invasion of Iraq.’ Büyükanıt implies, for example, that Turkmens
cannot prove that they are from Kirkuk since property records were
destroyed.
`If the US leaves Iraq, the country will disintegrate. As part of
the disintegration, Sunnis and Shiites may decide to attack the
Kurds, who may end up massing on the Turkish border as they did
following the 1991 invasion of Iraq. If the US and other coalition
troops withdraw from Iraq, it would cause instability in the entire
Middle East.’
`The US should increase focus on other parts of Iraq for the
possible stability of the country.’
`Iraqi Kurds [the Kurdish regional government under the Iraqi
Constitution] should be more cooperative with Turkey, and that will
make Ankara more cooperative with them.’
If we put aside the fact that Turkish generals’ keenness to speak
about internal and external politics causes discontent among
foreigners and Turks alike, we have to accept that, paradoxically, it
should be someone like Büyükanıt, supported by both junior and
senior officers, who can teach the powerful military that they must
accept that political authority is higher than military authority if
democracy is to mature in Turkey. But for this to happen, we need
strong a political leadership with the courage to further democratic
reforms.

*I, as a journalist, have heard this argument of the military for
many years, but the main reason behind the military’s difficulty in
downsizing personnel of around 700,000 — most of whom are conscripts
— is political. Through a big army the military maintains its
political power. We all know that ending conscription is the way to
reduce its size.

Crack of Server With RA President’s Site Is Unreal

CRACK OF SERVER WITH RA PRESIDENT’S SITE IS UNREAL

Yerevan, January 30. ArmInfo. It is unreal to crack the server, where
the official site of RA President is located since it is under a
permanent control, the Head of the Computer Department of Presidential
Staff, Gagik Poghossyan, told ArmInfo.

According to him, maximum protective measures are taken to assure the
relevant safety. To note, it has been tow days an Azeri hacker, called
Bacioglu, keeps several Armenian sites under control. To also remind,
Bacioglu has promised today, on the pages of the cracked sites, to
crack the official Internet-site of RA President. "The next site will
be , it is said in the cracked sites.

www.president.am