BAKU: Chingiz Aytmatov: "Solution To The Karabakh Problem Is Deliber

CHINGIZ AYTMATOV: "SOLUTION TO THE KARABAKH PROBLEM IS DELIBERATELY PROTRACTED"

Today, Azerbaijan
Feb 5 2007

"The solution to the Nagorno Karabakh problem is deliberately
protracted," prominent Kyrgyz writer Chingiz Aytmatov told.

Commenting on the settlement of the Nagorno Karabakh conflict between
Armenia and Azerbaijan Mr.Aytmatov underlined that the West assists
the invader by protracting the settlement of the conflict.

He also stressed Russia is not interested in the settlement of the
conflict noting that one of the creators of the problem is Moscow
itself, APA reports.

"I am concerned about the protraction of the conflict. The train
might be missed, I am afraid," Mr.Aytmatov stressed.

At the end the prominent writer also conveyed his best regards to
the Azerbaijani people.

Chingiz Aytmatov is Kyrgyzstan’s extraordinary and plenipotentiary
ambassador to Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxemburg.

URL:

http://www.today.az/news/politics/35915.html

Skirmishes At Border Conditioned By Season Factors

SKIRMISHES AT BORDER CONDITIONED BY SEASON FACTORS

PanARMENIAN.Net
05.02.2007 15:38 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ "Skirmishes at the Armenian-Azeri border are
spontaneous and conditioned by season factors including conduction of
engineer works and shift of the military contingent," RA Deputy Defense
Minister, lieutenant general Artur Aghabekyan said in Yerevan. In
his words, the same can be said as regards the so-called "sniper war"
going on at the frontline.

Armenia doesn’t think that armistice is violated by orders of the
military leadership of the conflicting sides, he underscored, reports
newsarmenia.ru.

Parting Tribute To A ‘Nut Visionary’

PARTING TRIBUTE TO A ‘NUT VISIONARY’
Randall Beach, Register Columnist

New Haven Register, CT
Feb 5 2007

The first time I saw Elizabeth Tashjian, she was dressed in a long,
flowing purple silk gown as she ecstatically flung open the entryway
to her Nut Museum.

Although I was excited to meet her and I got an unforgettable tour,
I had been told not to go there. My wife, who grew up in Old Lyme,
within two miles of Tashjian’s home and museum, told me "the Nut Lady"
was old news, tiresome and self-absorbed.

Sometimes you have to ignore your spouse’s advice. Sometimes you’ll
be very glad you did so.

Yes, I am grateful I was able to spend two memorable afternoons with
one of our state’s genuine characters. And now she is gone; Tashjian
died Jan. 28 week at 94.

Sure, she was self-absorbed. Many of our most interesting people are
that way. You just sit back, listen and enjoy the show.

She didn’t entertain only the people who found their way to her
museum. She also performed for millions of viewers who were lucky
enough to tune in to Johnny Carson’s "The Tonight Show" (four times),
"Late Night With David Letterman" and even Howard Stern’s show.

All of those museum visitors or TV viewers had the privilege of seeing
her 35-pound double coconut from the Seychelles Islands (it looked
like human buttocks) and hearing Tashjian sing her own composition,
"The Nut Anthem." In her high sing-song voice she rhapsodized:
"Nuts can be so bee-yoo-ti-ful"

But of course Carson and Letterman and Stern were making fun of her.

And the audience was laughing at her.

Hers is a poignant story. I’m not kidding. She spent her life on a
serious artistic mission to educate the world about the beauty and
importance of nuts.

This proved to be an impossible dream.

She was such an eccentric that people kept laughing. They always called
her "The Nut Lady," a name she told me she detested. She wanted to
be known as "The Nut Visionary" or "The Nut Culturist."

She said it was a natural choice for her to come to "the Nutmeg
state." The daughter of wealthy Armenian immigrants, she had been
raised in New York City and first beheld the Victorian mansion in
1950 when she came to visit Old Lyme with her mother.

Tashjian said that when she was a little girl she developed a love
and respect for nuts because her family always had bowls of them
around the house.

Recalling her epiphany for a Connecticut Magazine profile, she said,
"And one day I cracked a walnut, and the way it fell out of its shell,
it looked so beautiful, like a butterfly."

Tashjian, a talented painter who studied at the National Academy of
Design, began to paint nuts at an early age. Her artwork was displayed
at her museum.

Embracing her singular vision, she never married. After her mother
died, she lived alone in that house and in 1972 opened the museum.

She became a familiar figure around Old Lyme. People would see her
riding her bicycle to the market; she never owned a car.

My father-in-law often saw her when he was buying groceries.

Inevitably, to his mounting irritation, their "conversation" would
turn to her TV appearances and nut obsession.

When I mentioned Tashjian to him last week and noted her passing,
he said, "She was a nut."

The double meaning of this word was a source of great sorrow and
frustration to her. Shortly after she opened her museum, she told me,
she was shocked to learn "nut" also means "crazy."

"I almost closed the place," she said sadly. "Instead I changed the
purpose from the mere beautification of the nut to ridding it of its
double meaning."

Her final years were also poignant. In 2002 she was found unconscious
at her home. The courts appointed caretakers for her and they stuck
her in a convalescent home in Old Saybrook and sold her home.

When she awoke from her coma, she was enraged. During my visit with
her at that convalescent home in November 2002, she kept saying,
"I want to go home."

She never did. She died in that facility where she felt imprisoned.

But there were moments of light and recognition and respect in
her later years. Chris Steiner, who directs museum studies at
Connecticut College in New London, saw the importance of Tashjian and
her collection. He gathered it together, exhibited it at the college
and invited her to speak at an opening reception.

For those who joined her that night, and for the 15 people who attended
her memorial service Friday, she was never "The Nut Lady."

She was a folk hero.
From: Baghdasarian

ANKARA: Gul’s Gift: The Cargill Law

GUL’S GIFT: THE CARGILL LAW
Kemal Balci

The New Anatolian, Turkey
Feb 5 2007

During his visit to the U.S. this week, Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul
will have a valuable gift in hand. A legal problem faced by Prime
Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan during all his previous U.S. trips,
leading to personal involvement from President George W. Bush,
reached legal assurance through the extraordinary efforts of the
government. Established on first-class agriculture land in Bursa,
the corn factory of U.S. agribusiness giant Cargill seems set to take
a case that it lost in court and win it through politics. Carrying
the Cargill law in hand, Gul expects to get in return a gift basket
containing measures to be taken by the U.S. against the terrorist
Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), an Armenian resolution at the U.S.
House, and the fait accompli of the Greek Cypriot administration on
the island, as well as support on the Kirkuk issue.

However, neither the Cargill law nor similar gifts can meet the
expectation of the U.S. While the Iraq occupation continues to give
big trouble to the government, now the U.S. government has set its
sights on a military operation against Iran. There’s no way the
Turkish government can get what it wants before fully meeting the
expectations of the U.S. regarding Iran.

After Parliament hastily passed the Cargill law, the government may get
the attention of the U.S. a bit, but that’s all. The law was passed by
Parliament last November, yet President Ahmet Necdet Sezer vetoed it
then. Now that the law’s been passed again without any differences,
the president doesn’t have a right to veto it again. So it will come
into force Perhaps the Constitutional Court may cancel the law, but
during this process the Cargill firm will use its "acquired right"
and make the decision to close the plant invalid.

The firm won’t even have to pay any fine, as the government made
the land where the Cargill plant is located into an industrial area
through a Cabinet decision.

Foreign Minister Gul is trying to get the consent of the U.S. to
appease the Turkish Armed Forces’ (TSK) growing impatience to take
action against the terrorist PKK. It’s obvious that the steps taken so
far towards this end didn’t work. Despite giving numerous promises,
the U.S. government has failed to put forth sustained measures
not only on issues regarding military operations against the PKK,
but also on issues like cutting the group’s financial resources or
closing its political bureaus.

The U.S. is afraid that a possible cross-border operation by Turkish
soldiers against the PKK may turn into an active intervention of
Turkey in Kirkuk, northern Iraq. Moreover, Washington fears that
before it becomes official, Turkey may eliminate prevent a state of
"Kurdistan" from being declared in northern Iraq.

The U.S. government is trying to escape from the "big trap" they’re
in in Iraq and to keep up the "huge game" they’re trying to win. The
only sure ally they can find in this process isn’t Turkey — their
official "strategic partner" — but the feudal Kurdish power in the
north. Losing power right now both in Iraq and on the border with
Iran border doesn’t suit the U.S.

But the Turkish government, instead of noticing this huge game and
acting accordingly, prefers to meet its big expectations with small
presents. While facing very serious difficulties, Turkey may fall
into the trap the U.S. government fell into with the mistakes they
made at the beginning of the war.

Following the visit of Gul, Chief of General Staff Gen. Yasar
Buyukanit’s trip to the U.S. next week, on Feb. 11, will reveal whether
we’ve fallen into the trap. Unfortunately we have to sit and wait
until then. It’s only after these trips that we’ll be able to see the
meaning of recent military operations on the Iraqi and Iranian borders.

The End Of An Era In The Armenian Genocide Debate: Will Recognition

THE END OF AN ERA IN THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE DEBATE: WILL RECOGNITION LEAD TO A TURKISH POLICY TRANSFORMATION?
By Mehmet Kalyoncu

Balkanalysis.com, AZ
Feb 5 2007

If Turkey gives up its opposition to potential US recognition of the
atrocities between Turks and Armenians that took place during World
War One as ¦Á ¡°genocide,¡± will its diplomatic hand ultimately be
strengthened? The following article argues that this just might be
the case.

What should have happened ninety-two years ago in 1915 is finally
likely to happen in 2007. Both Houses of the U.S. Congress are expected
to pass a resolution that recognizes the bitter WWI experience of
the Turkish Armenians as genocide after it is discussed in the House
Foreign Relations Committee in April. Ankara reflexively and as usual
warned Washington that bilateral relations may be damaged to a degree
never before seen. A similar resolution was stopped in the year 2000
due to Turkish diplomatic pressure. But times have changed.

For many Turks, passing the resolution will verify their suspicions
of the unfaithful friendship of the United States. Ankara is right
when it maintains that bilateral relations would be damaged severely
during a period in which the United States needs a reliable ally
in the Middle East. Nevertheless, by acknowledging the distinction
between recognizing the so-called Armenian genocide and letting the
U.S. Congress recognize it, Ankara could actually benefit by letting
the latter happen.

A sizeable part of the Turkish public, from officials to intellectuals
and ordinary men on the street, view the recognition of the so-called
Armenian genocide by the US Congress as an opportunity to break free
from an area of coercion in the United States¡¯ allegedly unfaithful
friendship, and from an almost century-long hysteria surrounding
the question of ¡°what if the United States recognizes the so-called
genocide?¡± In this regard, the recognition of the so-called genocide
seems to present a more of a threat to the interests of the United
States than to those of Turkey.

Recognizing the So-Called Armenian Genocide

Mr. Turgut Ozal, former President and Prime Minister of Turkey, was
among the first who sought to get rid of the hysteria by signaling
a tacit approval of recognizing the so-called genocide in 1991.

However, Ozal had to back up when political opponent Suleyman Demirel,
some high-ranking generals and the secular establishment accused him
of not being sensitive to this most important national matter. Nuzhet
Kandemir, then Turkish Ambassador to the US, ironically and yet
somehow proudly notes that he managed to convince Ozal to believe
that such an approval would not serve the Turkish national interests.
[1] More ironically, Ilter Turkmen, former Minister of Foreign Affairs,
suggests that Ozal did not in fact believe in what he said, but just
seemed so in order to stimulate a debate when he asked if it would
not be better for Turkey to recognize the so-called genocide. [2]

It is not clear whether Ozal thought the same way, but today it seems
like the ¡°genocide card¡± is destined to lose its value dramatically
as a foreign policy instrument against Turkey once the United States,
the long-time strategic ally of Turkey, recognizes the so-called
Armenian genocide. For so many years, thinks the majority of the
Turkish public, especially the Western European countries and the
United States have exploited the genocide question as a stick to beat
Turkey when the carrot did not indulge her. Today, US recognition is
likely to make the genocide issue much less effective as a foreign
policy instrument; with the threat of it gone, Turkey will be freed of
a longstanding preoccupation in its relations with the United States.

Although there is no unanimity among them, some in the media and
secular circles have speculated about the aftermath of the genocide
recognition and foresee potential sanctions against Turkey. These
speculations are often countered in the public debate by questions
such as: What happened after France long ago passed the resolution in
its parliament? What happened even after France declared it a crime
not to recognize the so-called Armenian genocide? Would the case be
any different with the United States?

International criminal law does not provide a guideline to deal with
historical atrocities, argues Swedish historian Bertil Dun¨¦r. [3]
Yet international law suggests the creation of an international
expert body representing both historians and the legal profession
to investigate such historical cases, and arrive at an eventual
condemnation of the responsible party or parties. This is actually
not much different from what Turkey, especially during the AK Party
government, has been advocating.

Whether the U.S. recognition makes any difference is something to
be seen in the future. However, it is not difficult to argue for now
that such recognition will have implications at multiple levels.

Possible Implications of the US Congress¡¯ Recognition

Turkey and Armenia are likely to gain from the US recognition of
the so-called genocide, while the United States is likely to lose in
the long term. First of all, the recognition will bring an end to a
prolonged era throughout which Turkey has suffered continuous hysteria
when considering the implications of the United States recognizing
the so-called Armenian genocide. Consequently, by the end of its de
facto liability to the United States for not recognizing the so-called
genocide, Turkey is likely to increase its bargaining power against
the US in their bilateral relations. Secondly, Turkish foreign policy,
which has essentially revolved around three issues throughout the
republic¡¯s history (defending against Armenian genocide allegations,
Cyprus, and relations with Greece), is likely to gain momentum that
could be developed down lesser-explored avenues such as increasing
bilateral relations with non-Western states.

Armenia has suffered profound economic hardship since the break-up
of the USSR. Some of this would have been lessened had the country
been able to develop economic relations with its immediate neighbor
to the west. However, the Armenian Diaspora¡¯s continuous efforts to
inflict pain on Turkey in the international arena have not helped in
this capacity. Beside its occupation of Azerbaijani territory adjoining
Karabagh, Armenia¡¯s constitutionally certified territorial claims on
areas of Eastern Turkey caused Turkey to impose a blockade on Armenia,
shutting off Yerevan¡¯s road and rail links to the West. [4]

However, with the Turkish people¡¯s overwhelming show of sympathy
following the recent murder of Turkish Armenian intellectual Hrant
Dink, Armenia¡¯s Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, Arman Kirakosyan
stressed his government¡¯s readiness to open full diplomatic relations
with Turkey unconditionally. [5] Such a gesture hints that in the
absence of the Diaspora influence, Turkey and Armenia are likely to
sort out the problems hindering the two countries¡¯ ability to engage
in bilateral political and economic relations.

What is in it for the United States?

What are the pros and cons of the US recognizing the so-called Armenian
genocide? Rep. Frank Pallone (D-NJ) notes, ¡°[t]o truly dedicate
ourselves to improving human rights across the world, our government
must first learn from and properly condemn the mistakes of the past¡[6]
in order to express the rational behind his introduction of the
Armenian Genocide Resolution. He is right in that the U.S. government
should learn from and properly condemn the mistakes of the past, but
it hardly needs to look at the mistakes of others or go that far back
into history when it has more than enough of its own indiscretions
to use for that educative purpose. Understandably, however, Pallone
may not be able to distinguish between his own electoral interests
and the US national interests.

US-Turkish relations are unlikely to radically change due to the
Congress¡¯ recognition of the so-called genocide. Nor is Turkey
likely to take any radical action against the United States for that
matter, given the fact that it needs the US support to deal with the
Kurdish PKK separatists and the looming crisis in northern Iraq,
over Kirkuk. Nevertheless, the very fact that the United States
recognizes the so-called genocide would entail structural changes in
Turkey¡¯s foreign policy orientation, which would indirectly rather
than directly impact the US-Turkish relation in the long term.

Diminishing Influence of the ¡°White Turks¡±

There are likely to be losers on the Turkish side of the debate as
well once the so-called genocide is recognized by the US Congress.

These will include mainly the exclusivist and elitist secular
establishment in the state apparatus, its extension within the Ministry
of Foreign Affairs in Ankara, and their contacts in Washington,
who have been reportedly lobbying on behalf of Turkey.

Throughout the republic¡¯s history, a small number of elite members
and diplomats have been considered to have the decisive influence on
Turkey¡¯s foreign policy orientation, formulation and implementation,
serving as a conduit between Ankara and Washington. This diplomatic
elite has earned the popular moniker, Beyaz Turkler (¡°White Turks¡±),
and frequently derive from familial dynasties, some non-Anatolian in
origin. The name implies a sort of ¡°untouchable,¡± elevated image
compared to the unwashed masses.

The prolonged conflicts such as the Armenian genocide issue, Cyprus,
Turkish-Greek relations, which pretty much constituted the triad of
Turkish foreign policy in the second half of the 20th century, entailed
an exclusivist foreign policy apparatus independent of whatever
particular government was in office. Understandably, dealing with
such conflicts required diplomatic expertise and personal connections
in Washington. Yet some have speculated that by prolonging these
conflicts, the very exclusivist ¡°White Turks¡± elite has kept the
Ministry of Foreign Affairs immune from the more traditional-minded
bulk of Turkish society, the so-called ¡°Black Turks,¡± and maintained
their grip on the country¡¯s foreign affairs.

Winds of Change in Turkish Foreign Policy

Nevertheless, in the recent years the so-called White Turks grip on
Turkish foreign policy, which is marked simply by an unconditional
attachment to the West, has started to diminish gradually. Turkish
foreign policy has gained multiple dimensions with the AK Party¡¯s
efforts to reach out to Central Asia, Middle East, Africa and even
Latin America. This new foreign policy orientation has thus opened
the door to those intellectuals who speak the languages, know the
cultures, or have even lived in these new regions of interest.

This expansion of interests represents a welcome breath of fresh
air for a foreign policy establishment that has become somewhat
close-minded due to a limited orientation traditionally focused on
a few narrow issues. By reaching out to other corners of the globe,
Turkey will develop for itself a more sophisticated and cosmopolitan
mindset and inevitably a more prestigious place on the global stage.

The most significant example of the new breed of foreign policy
intellectuals is probably Dr. Ahmet Davutoglu, foreign affairs
counselor to the Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs. He
was allegedly the most influential thinker who crafted the new
multi-dimensional foreign policy paradigm of the AK Party government,
which resulted in closer relations of Turkey with its immediate
neighbors such as Syria, Saudi Arabia, and even Iran. The US Congress¡¯
recognition of the so-called Armenian genocide should only speed
up the transformation within the Turkish foreign policy apparatus,
which is in any case already underway, by eliminating a nagging issue
that has for too long forced Turkey to expend its political capital
in an investment promising little return.

[1]°Soykirimi tanisak daha iyi olmaz mi ¨C Would it not be better
if we recognize the genocide¡±, Hurriyet 7, March 2005, available
at viewid=546223

[2] Ibid

[3] Bertil Dun¨¦r, ¡°What Can Be Done about Historical Atrocities? The
Armenian Case¡± International Journal of Human Rights, Vol. 8, No. 2,
pp. 217¨C233, Summer 2004

[4] Jon Gorvett, ¡°Armenia, Turkey Takes Steps
towards Rapprochement,¡± May 29, 2002, available at
rticles/eav052902.shtml

[5]°Cenazede gordukleri tablo Ermeni diasporasini
sasirtti¡± Zaman, January 25, 2007, available at
rno=492256

[6]°Armenian Genocide Resolution to be Introduced Tomorrow,¡± posted
by N.J. Dem. Rep.

Frank Pallone, January 29, 2007 available at

htt p:// era-in-the-armenian-genocide-debate-will-recogniti on-lead-to-a-turkish-policy-transformation/

–Bou ndary_(ID_h75GYC3dKrdPLV5FYpEOow)–

http://hurarsiv.hurriyet.com.tr/goster/haber.aspx?
http://www.eurasianet.org/departments/insight/a
http://www.zaman.com.tr/webapp-tr/haber.do?habe
http://blog.thehill.com/category/politics/
www.balkanalysis.com/2007/02/05/the-end-of-an-

ANKARA: ‘Dink Case Should Not Pit Police, Gendarmerie Against Each O

‘DINK CASE SHOULD NOT PIT POLICE, GENDARMERIE AGAINST EACH OTHER’

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 5 2007

Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul said yesterday Turkey’s two main
security organizations, the police and the gendarmerie, should work
in cooperation and effectively share intelligence, amid allegations
of a rift between the two institutions.

Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul said yesterday Turkey’s two main
security organizations, the police and the gendarmerie, should work
in cooperation and effectively share intelligence.

Gul, responding to questions on allegations of a rift between the
Gendarmerie Command and the Police Directorate-General after the
murder on Jan. 19 of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink, said
cooperation and solidarity between the two institutions would help
prevent wrongdoing.

Allegations of disagreement between the gendarmerie, attached to the
General Staff, and the police have become widespread after the leaking
to the press of footage showing members of the police and gendarmerie
posing for a "souvenir photo" with Ogun Samast, the prime suspect in
Dink’s murder.

The footage, obtained exclusively by a private television station,
was first reported to have been shot at one of the gendarmerie’s
stations. But the Gendarmerie Command angrily denied the report and
said it had been shot at a police station in Samsun, where Samast had
been captured after a nationwide manhunt. The gendarmerie also said
that gendarmerie personnel seen in the images were personnel assigned
to hand over the suspect to the police and added that the leaking of
the footage to the press was "purposeful," without elaborating.

The police, for its part, have announced an investigation has been
launched to find out how the footage was leaked to the press.

"There should be no dispute between the gendarmerie and the police,"
Gul told reporters in Ankara, just before departing for a visit to
the United States. "These are all institutions of Turkey. These are
institutions that should work in cooperation and should not envy each
other." Samast was seen in the video holding out a Turkish flag and
posing with officers. Behind Samast was a poster with another Turkish
flag carrying the words of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, the founder of modern
Turkey: "The nation’s land is sacred. It cannot be left to fate."

Information overload?

But wary of negative effects that the press coverage may have on
the ongoing investigation, Ýstanbul Chief Public Prosecutor Aykut
Cengiz Engin said most of the information published in the press was
"incorrect" and added, "We are concerned that this kind of wrong
and confusing information might lead to unjustified expectations
in society."

Cengiz also complained that testimonies of the suspects were published
in newspapers and that this complicated the investigation.

"We ask members of the press not to pay attention to statements and
information other than those provided by authorized officials and show
the necessary sensitivity for the well-being of the investigation,"
he said.

Engin noted that some 26 people have been detained in connection with
the murder and that eight of them were later sent to jail.

–Boundary_(ID_iDZjf+yREWTrjRrX0vlZuA)–

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: Turkey’s Strategic Partnership With US Faces Test

TURKEY’S STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIP WITH US FACES TEST

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 5 2007

Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul is in the US invited by US Secretary
of State Condoleezza Rice and will start talks today. This visit is
being made in an atmosphere of Turkish expectations for concrete steps
from the US side in connection with the "Iraq" issue and "Armenian
genocide" claims, both considered by the Turkish government as the
highest ranking items on its agenda for 2007.

Gul’s agenda with top ranking figures in the US administration consists
of measures to be taken against the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) and
a possible cross-border operation, the "Armenian genocide" resolution
to be heard by the US House of Representatives, the referendum in
Kirkuk, developments in Iraq, Iran’s nuclear activities, Cyprus,
Syria and the Middle East.

Gul is expected to clearly state Turkey’s expectations from the US
administation, saying "concerete steps must be taken against the
terrorist organization PKK. Turkey cannot be expected to accept
genocide claims, and therefore, the genocide resolution must be
blocked. No referendum should be held in Kirkuk without a mutual
agreement ensured among the related parties." Ankara wants Washington
to maintain its attitude against the "genocide resolution," assuring
Turkey that the resolution will be rejected. Gul will request the
US administration to throw its weight against the issue, noting
that Turkish-American relations will be deeply affected in case the
resolution is accepted.

In a statement made at Esenboða Airport in Ankara before his departure,
Gul frequently underlined the "joint vision document" pertaining to the
status of relations between two countries. "I believe that this visit
will help to improve the deeply rooted bilateral relations between
Turkey and the US as two close allies in all areas," he said. The joint
vision document, issued during Gul’s visit to Washington in July 2006,
lists actions for further improvements in Turkish-American relations
defined as "strategic partnership."

During his visit, the Turkish foreign minister will meet top US
officials. In Washington D.C. Gul will meet Vice-President Dick Cheney,
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice and the President’s National
Security Advisor Stephen Hadley. He will also have working meetings
with several members of the US Congress. The Congress has recently been
discussing a controversial Armenian Genocide Resolution. Nancy Pelosi,
the Democrat House Speaker is not on Gul’s meeting list. Pelosi is
known to be one of the strongest voices of the pro-Armenian resolution
camp. Gul is going to give a speech at the German Marshall Fund
in Washington.

The new UN secretary-general will be reminded of Cyprus Gul is going
to continue his contacts in New York on February, 4 where he will
meet the new Secretary-General of the UN, Ban Ki-Moon.

Gul will ask Ki-Moon to hold on to the report prepared after the Annan
Plan. Ankara wants to see the report prepared by Kofi Annan after the
2004 referendum in Cyprus discussed in the UN Security Council. The
foreign minister is going to give a speech at the prestigious Council
on Foreign Relations about Iraq and the Middle East. Gul will head
back to Turkey on the evening of February 9. Upon Gul’s return to the
country, the Chief-of-Staff, General Yaþar Buyukanýt will fly to the
US on February 11. Suleyman Kurt Ankara

–Boundary_(ID_pAmRM0EwsUlbDo+D7SBFlg)–

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

In His Own Words: Putin Answers To The World’s Media

IN HIS OWN WORDS: PUTIN ANSWERS TO THE WORLD’S MEDIA

St Petersburg Times, Russia
Feb 6 2007

President Vladimir Putin began his annual news conference with more
than 1,000 national and international journalists on Thursday with an
introductory speech putting his administration’s achievements into
context. Then Putin opened the floor and took questions. Beginning
with the words: "Thank you for your attention. I am ready now to
answer your questions." What follows is an edited transcript of some
of Putin’s answers.

G. FEIFER (National Public Radio, USA): Last year marked a turning
point for Russia’s foreign policy. Moscow demonstrated that it will
use its energy resources in its own interests. At the same time,
relations with Western countries are at their worst levels since 1990,
perhaps even since 1985.

You said recently that the term ‘superpower’ is an outdated notion
from the Cold War era, and you said that it is other countries that
seek to portray Russia as the enemy. Could you please name these
countries? Does this include Washington and London? If not, who is
it specifically that is trying to damage Russia’s image?

VLADIMIR PUTIN: We are constantly being fed the argument that Russia
is using its current and emerging economic levers to achieve its
foreign policy goals. This is not the case. The Russian Federation
has always abided by all of its obligations fully and completely,
and it will continue to do so.

But we have no obligation to provide huge subsidies to other countries’
economies, subsidies as big as their own national budgets.

No one else does this, and so why are we expected to do it? That is
the first point.

Second, our actions, and the agreements we reach with the transit
countries, are aimed above all at ensuring the interests of our main
consumers. I can assure you that the experts understand this full
well. Just recall how it was when we signed a contract each year
with Ukraine for both gas supplies to Ukraine and for gas transit to
Western Europe, and our consumers in Western Europe always depended
on us being able to reach an agreement with our partners in Ukraine.

But now we have separated these two aspects and created market
conditions for transit.

As I just said, the experts understand this situation very well;
thanking us would be more appropriate, but instead, we see a dishonest
attitude to the interpretation of events taking place. This is,
of course, the work of Russia’s ill-wishers.

I am not suggesting that this is something going on at a state level,
but there are people out there who do not wish Russia well. The people
who write these kinds of things, it’s them who are our ill-wishers. So,
if you write these kinds of things, then you are among their number,
but if you give an accurate and objective portrayal of events, then
you are not included in this category.

YELENA GULSHAKOVA (RIA Novosti): In your opinion, what have been the
past year’s main foreign policy results? Several experts believe that
Russia has created a ring of unfriendly neighbors around itself. Do
you agree with this opinion?

VLADIMIR PUTIN: We are building partner relations with all countries
and of course we have closer relations with several countries – for
example with the CIS as a whole – though there are some problems
there. We admit that in the last little while we have in no way
been able to regulate our relations with Georgia. But we have the
Eurasian Economic Community where integration processes are developing
intensively and the Collective Security Treaty Organisation.

As to our relations with other countries, as a whole we are satisfied
with their development. And you know that praising or taking pleasure
from the fact that you are being praised as you betray national
interests is very simple, but to construct pragmatic, business-based
relations while defending your national interests is not always
possible without a certain amount of tension and problems.

But in those cases I always remember a well-known old saying: "If
you become angry then it means that you are not right". We do not
want complications with anyone. When I hear, as you said, that we are
surrounding ourselves with a ring of malevolence, then it is not so.

Last year, at the beginning of the year, Russia had tense relations
with our Ukrainian friends and partners because of energy, because
of energy transport. One – well, I actually remember who, but I am
not going to say so now – of my European partners said: "Look, there
will be political changes in Ukraine. Yanukovich will come to power,
you shouldn’t then change your energy policy." I said: "we are not
going to do this. We made an economic decision, not a political one."

Last year Ukraine received energy and gas for $95 and this year
for $135 despite the fact that well-known, significant political
changes took place in Ukraine. But our relations with Ukraine did
not deteriorate because of this – they became better, stronger and
more reliable, both for us and for Ukraine. We are always ready to
help the Ukrainian people, the Ukrainian government and the Ukrainian
President if they ask for our help and, in this case, in the energy
sector. They know this. We said that we are always ready to help if
necessary, even if it is not compatible with market principles.

But the most important thing we did was agree that our relations
would be market-based. We signed documents on a soft transition to
market-relations with all countries that transport our energy. This
is what we are referring to. This does not depend on our political
relations with these countries. For example, we have very stable and
not simply trusting, but also strategic relations with Armenia. Yet
Armenia pays market prices.

This year we had well-known difficulties with Belarus but we
nevertheless signed an agreement on transport and on energy changing
prices in the future to have entirely market-based relations. And in
the end this is the most important thing. It is not even important how
much Belarus pays today, rather it is important that we have determined
the stages of a transition to market relations in documents. But we did
this softly – over four years – and in an absolutely friendly way. Of
course, [they] might hope for everything that they had before in the
future, but to have the same is not possible. This is not possible
if we are different states. Do you understand?

Belarus and Russia intend to nevertheless continue to build a Union
State – we are very happy with and welcome the changes that the
Belarusian leadership has made to work out common tariffs on crude
oil and oil products. This is a real step towards creating a fully
operational customs union.

We believe that all is not lost with respect to having one currency.

I am confident that our Belarusian partners are in a position to
analyse reality, able to understand the reliability of the Russian
economy and the Russian currency, and perhaps introduce a common
currency. Not the Russian ruble or the Belarusian ruble but perhaps,
as we had initially planned – because we planned to do this – to
first of all use the Russian ruble. This is all possible.

MARINA LAPENKOVA (France Presse): Do you agree with [Moscow Mayor]
Yuri Luzhkov’s opinion that the gay parade is the work of satanists?

VLADIMIR PUTIN: With regards to what the heads of regions say,
I normally try not to comment. I don’t think it is my business.

My relation to gay parades and sexual minorities in general is simple
– it is connected with my official duties and the fact that one of
the country’s main problems is demography. But I respect and will
continue to respect personal freedom in all its forms, in all its
manifestations.

OLGA SOLOMONOVA (Gudok): Please tell us how you rate Sochi’s chances of
hosting the 2014 winter Olympics? And considering the latest reports
[on power cuts], it will probably be difficult and do we really
need this?

VLADIMIR PUTIN: I have already said many times that the 2014 Olympics
would be a good excuse for us to develop southern Russia, Sochi and the
nearby regions. What happened now, a failure in electrical supplies,
happens every year.

When I used to work in the Supervision Directorate of the Presidential
Executive Office, I went to Sochi for this reason, when there was a
power failure. Every year the same thing happens: the wires ice over,
the wires fail and so on. But this should in no way affect our plans
to host the Olympics.

As I already said in my opening address, we are now in the position
to carry out large-scale regional investment projects that we couldn’t
even dream out before. And Sochi is one of these projects.

The planned investments amount to 314 billion rubles [$11.8 billion]
and perhaps even more. If the Olympics take place then it will be
a bit more. And if they do not take place then the amount would be
a little less, because then we won’t need, say, to build two ice
palaces in Sochi – that would simply be superfluous.

But in any case we are going to carry out that investment project
for us, for Russian citizens, so that people have the opportunity
to vacation in their own country, to ski, to relax on the Black Sea
coast. At present we have few opportunities of this kind. And in any
case, we need to develop this. Not only for those who live in Sochi.

For the whole country. And I have no doubt that if the International
Olympic Committee decides in favor of Sochi then we shall certainly
be able to prepare all necessary facilities in time.

STEVEN GUTTERMAN (Associated Press): After Anna Politkovskaya’s murder
you said that there are people hiding from Russian justice who would
like to damage Russia’s reputation. And after Alexander Litvinenko’s
death your aide Sergei Yastrzhembsky said that this could be part of
a plot with that same goal. Can you now tell us a few more details,
several months after the tragedy, or say more precisely who you think
is behind these murders? Do you think they are foreigners or Russians
living abroad? And if yes, then who? Can you name them?

VLADIMIR PUTIN: Only an investigation can determine whoever is behind
these murders. And, moreover, only a court can do so, because at the
end of the day it is the court that, having weighed all the pros and
cons – both the prosecutors’ arguments and the defense of the accused –
makes the final decision.

As to prominent murders, then it is true that the problem of the
persecution of journalists is a very acute problem both for our country
and for many other countries. And we acknowledge our responsibility in
this. We shall do everything possible to protect members of the press.

I recall not only Anna Politkovskaia – she was quite a sharp critic of
the authorities and that is a good thing. I recall other journalists
as well, including Paul Khlebnikov. And not long ago one of our
American partners said something very true: "Paul Khlebnikov died for
a democratic Russia, for the development of democracy in Russia." I
completely agree with him. I fully agree with this evaluation.

As to other well-known crimes, you know that just recently the
investigation into the murder of the Vice-President of the Russian
Central Bank has been finished. I very much hope that the law
enforcement agencies will manage to find the criminals who have
committed other, no less prominent crimes, and ones that are no less
harmful to our country.

With regards to Litvinenko, I do not have much to add here, except
what I have already said. Alexander Litvinenko was dismissed from the
security services. Before that he served in the convoy troops. There he
didn’t deal with any secrets. He was involved in criminal proceedings
in the Russian Federation for abusing his position of service,
namely for beating citizens during arrests when he was a security
service employee and for stealing explosives. I think that he was
provisionally given three years. But there was no need to run anywhere,
he did not have any secrets. Everything negative that he could say
with respect to his service and his previous employment, he already
said a long time ago, so there could be nothing new in what he did
later. I repeat that only the investigation can tell us what happened.

And with regards to the people who try to harm the Russian Federation,
in general it is well-known who they are. They are people hiding from
Russian justice for crimes they committed on the territory of the
Russian Federation and, first and foremost, economic crimes. They are
the so-called runaway oligarchs that are hiding in Western Europe or
in the Middle East. But I do not really believe in conspiracy theories
and, quite frankly, I am not very worried about it. The stability of
Russian statehood today allows us to look down at this from above.

ALEKSEI IAUSHEV (Internet newspaper Fontanka.ru, St Petersburg):
Vladimir Vladimirovich, St. Petersburg’s citizens are divided about
the construction of the Gazprom City tower at the mouth of the Okhta
River. As is well known, it will be more than three hundred meters
high. What is your opinion on constructing a tower in the center of
St Petersburg?

VLADIMIR PUTIN: First of all, I would like to say that it is the
business of the regional authorities – the governor and the deputies
of the legislative assembly.

The second is that you know where they are going to build this tower
(and as far as I know it is not just one tower – they are also planning
other buildings and installations, and talking about constructing a
so-called Gazprom City); they are going to build it by the Okhta River.

I lived there for almost five years, literally close by, and I know
what architectural jewels there are there. These buildings were built
by captured German soldiers after the Second World War, so-called bulk
buildings. I remember the first time I tried to hammer a nail in the
wall, it just fell out! The walls are bad quality, and though from
the outside these buildings do not look bad – they look quite solid –
in general they do not have any value.

I understand the concerns of those who say that it is very close
to the historic center. I basically share these concerns. It is
also certainly true that in earlier generations Petersburg became
an outstanding center for world culture and architecture but our
generations have done almost nothing. And, of course, we need some
fresh air here, we need some centers that would stimulate development,
including business activities.

I repeat once again that I do not confirm that this is the very best
decision and, moreover, I do not want to influence decisions made by
the city authorities. It is certainly true that such buildings would
not damage the city. But where to build them – and I would like to
repeat this once more – is a decision that must be taken at the level
of the city authorities. It is not necessary to give these decisions
to me, I have enough of my own problems.

BBC Correspondent: We would like to know your view on the Iranian
leader’s proposal to create a gas consortium or some kind of
organization similar to OPEC. You are going to visit Qatar and Saudi
Arabia soon, and these are both countries that also have large gas
reserves. Is this visit about energy cooperation between Russia and
these countries?

VLADIMIR PUTIN: A gas OPEC is an interesting idea and we will think
about it. In this initial stage we agree with the Iranian specialists,
with our Iranian partners and with some of the other countries that
are large suppliers of fossil fuels, above all gas, to world markets,
and we are already trying to coordinate our activities on the markets
of third countries.

We have no plans to create some kind of cartel, but I think it would
be a good idea to coordinate our activities, especially in the context
of achieving our main aim of ensuring certain and reliable supply of
energy resources for our main consumers.

The original English-language transcript of the press conference was
taken from

www.kremlin.ru

Nairobi: Tell Us More About Artur Brothers, Raila Tells Govt

TELL US MORE ABOUT ARTUR BROTHERS, RAILA TELLS GOVT
By Peter Atsiaya

The Standard, Kenya
Feb 6 2007

Lang’ata MP Mr Raila Odinga wants the Kiruki report touching on the
controversial Artur brothers and the presence of mercenaries in Kenya,
made public.

Raila said that several months after the commission completed its
investigations on the alleged Armenians’ presence in the country,
the Government has not released its findings to the public.

"Kenyans are eager to know the commission’s findings on the two
brothers who posed a security risk," said Raila.

Addressing a campaign rally at Kapsoas in Ainamoi constituency,
Kericho District on Sunday, Raila said the Government should clear
its name on the Artur brothers’ saga.

He said: "The Government was adversely mentioned in the Artur brothers’
saga and it should come out clear over the issue."

MPs, Mr Joseph Nyaga, Mr Kipkalya Kones, Mr Ochilo Ayacko, Prof Ayiecho
Olweny, Mr Peter Odoyo and ODM-Kenya leaders, Mr Odunga Mamba and
Mr Tony Gachoka, accompanied the Lang’ata MP. Raila said he revealed
the presence of the Artur brothers and their dirty missions but the
Government dismissed him.

The MP noted the Government spent taxpayers’ money on the commission
and it should make its report public.

He questioned why the Government had stopped pursuing the Armenians’
saga for them to face the law. The Armenians are believed to be behind
the raid at The Standard premises that left a trail of destruction.

Armenia: Maneuvering Begins Ahead Of May Parliamentary Elections

ARMENIA: MANEUVERING BEGINS AHEAD OF MAY PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS
Haroutiun Khachatrian

EurasiaNet, NY
Feb 5 2007

With the date now set for Armenia’s parliamentary elections,
political debate is turning to a larger question: Will the vote be
falsified? While officials have vowed to hold a free and fair election
on May 12, opposition parties are questioning how these pledges will
play out in practice.

In recent weeks, the topic of falsification has dominated now-daily
public discussions and party statements. Armenia’s 2003 presidential
election and its 2005 constitutional referendum, two controversial
votes widely condemned for failing to meet international standards,
are the latest standards for comparison, though doubts surround earlier
votes as well. [For background see the Eurasia Insight archive].

"All previous elections were falsified. All those who organized these
falsifications were given posts," said Vazgen Manukian, leader of
the National Democratic Union Party (NDUP), on January 30, the daily
Hayots Ashkhar reported. "How do they dare say that these elections
will be better than the previous ones?"

For their part, election officials do not exclude the possibility of
vote rigging, but maintain that the onus for prevention lies on the
political parties taking part in the May election. Central Election
Commission (CEC) Chairman Garegin Azarian told reporters on January
24 that violations are only possible during vote counts at local
polling stations, which transmit data automatically to the CEC.

One opposition representative on the CEC, however, disputed this
claim. Feliks Khachatrian, a delegate from the opposition Ardarutiun
(Justice) bloc, has charged that gaps in the election code leave
room for falsifications. Khachatrian took issue with the existence of
voter lists for on-duty policemen, along with the infirm and disabled,
which are not prepared by election commissions and which, in theory,
could lead to repeat votes. "Do not have a hope that we will have
normal elections," media outlets reported Khachatrian as saying.

Opposition leaders say that placing active, dedicated party volunteers
at polling stations is the best way to encourage a fair vote. At
a January 24 discussion at the Armenian Center of National and
International Studies, parliamentarian Arshak Sadoyan, a founder
and the president of the National Democratic Union Party, called for
the opposition to unite in its efforts to have enough "strong-armed"
people at polling stations who would be willing to "turn the voting
into a velvet revolution" if officials attempt to rig the balloting.

A week later, Manukian, the NDUP chairman, presented a similar
proposal for opposition parties to create a "coalition of common
interest." However, no concrete actions have been reported yet on
this measure.

Meanwhile, western governments and international organizations are
emphasizing their own interest in a democratic vote. The United States
has launched a $6 million program, in conjunction with non-governmental
organizations and government agencies, to bolster the chances for a
fair vote, including training for election commission officials. The
United Nations Development Programme, the Organization for Security
and Cooperation in Europe and the Council of Europe are running
similar programs.

At a January 24 press conference, US Charge d’affaires Anthony Godfrey,
the US embassy’s senior representative in Yerevan, suggested Washington
might adopt a carrot-and-stick approach to the vote. In terms of
potential punishments, Godfrey noted that The Millennium Challenge
Corporation’s board of directors is on record as stating that "[a]
serious deficiency in the elections" could lead to a reconsideration
of Armenia’s $236 million program. [For background see the Eurasia
Insight Archive].

Opposition members remain skeptical about the effectiveness of
such threats and measures. Despite its training programs, the West
"eventually prefers to trust what the authorities say," Manukian
said, adding that the best use for US funds would be to bring in
enough international observers to monitor the more than 1,000 polling
stations taking part in the vote.

The Armenian government and supporters of the ruling coalition
are less pessimistic. In a February 4 interview with Armenia TV,
Defense Minster Serzh Sarkisian, a leader of the ruling Republican
Party, denounced the opposition’s assertions that falsifications are
inevitable. "I’ll do my best to have the elections honest, free,
fair and transparent," Sarkisian told viewers. "And not only me,
[but] all the authorities will do the same. And this is because the
authorities and the parties who have good chances to win and become
part of the government as a result of the elections are the most
interested in having good elections. No one is more interested in
having good elections," he said.

Earlier, Hrant Margarian, a leader of the Dashnaktsutiun (Armenian
Revolutionary Federation) Party, a member of the governing coalition,
said that his party would try to persuade voters to vote according to
principles, rather than in response to offered "election bribes." The
comment, made January 29, appeared to be a thinly veiled reference
to the Bargavach Hayastan, or the Prosperous Armenia Party, which has
recently been the target of considerable controversy over charity work
done by a foundation that shares the party’s name. [For background
see the Eurasia Insight archive].

Some independent observers share this optimistic view. At a February 3
discussion at the Friday Club in Yerevan, sociologist Aharon Adibekian
argued that although individual instances of vote-rigging are quite
likely to occur, much depends on the behavior of the strongest
political players in the race, the Republican Party and Prosperous
Armenia. "If they reach a gentleman’s agreement and commit as few
violations as possible, it will be possible to have democratic
elections in Armenia," Adibekian said.

Editor’s Note: Haroutiun Khachatrian is a Yerevan-based writer
specializing in economic and political affairs.