ANKARA: NGOs Propose Reduction In Article 301 Sentences

NGOS PROPOSE REDUCTION IN ARTICLE 301 SENTENCES
Ercan Yavuz Ankara

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 6 2007

After a round of failed attempts, nongovernmental organizations have
reached an agreement on a joint proposal for changes to Article 301
of the Turkish Penal Code, an issue that has been subject of a heated
discussion since the murder on Jan. 19 of Turkish-Armenian journalist
Hrant Dink.

The NGOs agreed that the term "Turkishness" should be kept in an
amended Article 301 but said the phrase "denigrating Turkishness"
should be replaced with "scorning and deriding Turkishness." The
proposal also foresees a reduction in prison sentences stipulated
by Article 301. The NGOs are now expected to announce the text to
the public at a press conference on Thursday and then present it to
the government.

The government has been under growing pressure to change Article
301 since the murder of Dink, who had been tried and sentenced to
a six-month suspended imprisonment. It has said repeatedly that it
was against outright abolishment of the article, although it could
consider partial changes on the basis of concrete proposals to be
made by the NGOs. Since last November, Turkish NGOs have held several
meetings but failed to come up with a joint proposal on how the
law should be amended. Their last meeting was in Ankara on Friday,
when representatives of labor unions, employers’ associations and
professional organizations left without an agreement.

Convening again on Sunday, the NGO chairmen sought avenues for
agreement. In a move to step up pressure on the government to take
prompt steps for amendments to Article 301, the NGOs decided to
announce the agreed text to the public on Thursday of this week. Only
the Turkish Medical Association (TTB) is reported to have expressed
a dissenting opinion on the draft at the Sunday meeting.

In the agreed text, NGOs do not demand removal of the terms
"Turkishness" and "Republic." But they do redefine "Turkishness,"
although it is not visible in the text of the article, since a
definition of the term is provided in a separate, appended text
explaining the justification for the law. Under that definition,
the term "Turkishness" is explained in reference to Article 66 of the
Constitution, which states "everyone tied to the Turkish Republic by
bond of citizenship is Turkish."

The maximum limit for punishment imposed for crimes mentioned in
Article 301 was decreased from three years to two years. The third
paragraph, reading, "In cases where denigration of Turkishness is
committed by a Turkish citizen in another country, the punishment
shall be increased by one-third," was deleted, meaning that the same
punishment should be applicable irrespective of where the crime has
been committed.

————————————– ——————————————

The existing and proposed texts of Article 301

ARTICLE 301: (1) Public denigration of Turkishness, the Republic or the
Grand National Assembly of Turkey shall be punishable by imprisonment
of between six months and three years.

(2) Public denigration of the Government of the Republic of Turkey,
the judicial institutions of the State, the military or security
structures shall be punishable by imprisonment of between six months
and two years.

(3) In cases where denigration of Turkishness is committed by a
Turkish citizen in another country the punishment shall be increased
by one-third.

(4) Expressions of thought intended to criticize shall not constitute
a crime.

The text proposed by NGOs ARTICLE 301: (1) Public denigration of
Turkishness [a reference to Article 66 of the Constitution is provided
in the ‘reasoned statement’ of the law], the Republic or the Grand
National Assembly of Turkey shall be punishable by imprisonment of
between six months and two years.

(2) Public denigration of the Government of the Republic of Turkey,
the judicial institutions of the State, the military or security
structures shall be punishable by imprisonment of between six months
and two years.

(3) Expressions of thought intended to criticize shall not constitute
a crime.

Worst Year For Freedom Of Speech

WORST YEAR FOR FREEDOM OF SPEECH

Tiscali Europe, UK
Feb 6 2007

In its latest press freedom index, Paris-based NGO Reporters Without
Borders (RWB) says that a record number of journalists and media
workers were killed or thrown in jail around the world in 2006.

The survey, published on 1 February, provides a snapshot of press
freedom in 98 countries. This year – once again – it
highlights North Korea, Eritrea, Cuba and Turkmenistan as the worst
offenders. At the same time, however, the report slams an "alarming
lack of interest (and sometimes even failure) by democratic countries
in defending the values they are supposed to incarnate".

Highlighting the case of Denmark and the inflammatory cartoons of the
Prophet Mohamed, RWB condemns other European states for standing by
impassively while journalists and embassies were attacked.

In Western Europe, philosopher Robert Redeker was threatened in
southern France for a critical article he wrote on Islam, while a
leading opera house in Germany cancelled performances of Mozart’s
opera Idomeneo for fear of Muslim reaction. Other concerns were a
new law in France banning denial of the 1915 Armenian genocide and
Turkey’s frequent use of article 301 of its criminal code to
prosecute journalists and intellectuals mentioning the genocide.

Some five journalists were murdered in the former Soviet bloc
countries in 2006, including leading investigative journalist Anna
Politkovskaya. This, says RWB, shows "the problems this region has
in shaking off its authoritarian past".

In its list of the most deadly places for journalists to work, the
report finds that 65 media workers were killed in Iraq and almost a
dozen murdered in Mexico. Kidnappings and imprisonment of journalists
remained also remained worryingly high in the Middle East and Latin
America in general. RWB also says that African governments, above
all Gambia and Burkina Faso, are sheltering the killers of several
journalists.

Finally, over in Asia, 16 media workers were killed and another 328
arrested. Some 517 were physically attacked or threatened and 478 media
outlets censored in 2006. "Censorship is very widespread and complete
freedom to speak and write is rare in Asia," says RWB. China is also
cracking down on cyber-dissidents and, with at least 60 people detained
around the world for criticism of their governments, it is clearly
being copied by among others Vietnam, Syria, Tunisia, Libya and Iran.

l

http://europe.tiscali.co.uk/110915c06da.htm

Istanbul Police Intelligence Chief Suspended In Probe Into Armenian

ISTANBUL POLICE INTELLIGENCE CHIEF SUSPENDED IN PROBE INTO ARMENIAN JOURNALIST’S KILLING

International Herald Tribune, France
Feb 6 2007

ANKARA, Turkey: Authorities suspended the police intelligence chief
of Istanbul as part of an investigation into the killing of an ethnic
Armenian journalist in the city last month, police said Tuesday.

The Interior Ministry suspended intelligence chief Ahmet Ilhan Guler
on Monday evening following the Jan. 19 killing of Hrant Dink. The
daily Sabah newspaper reported he was removed from his post because
he had ignored a tip about a threat against Dink’s life a year ago.

The 52-year-old journalist had angered Turkish nationalists with
repeated assertions that the mass killings of Armenians around the
time of World War I was genocide.

Interior Ministry inspectors investigating the journalist’s death
reportedly discovered that Guler failed to report a tip – which
he received 11 months before the deadly attack – that some of the
suspects in Dink’s killing were planning to assassinate the journalist.

Dink’s death led to an outpouring of public sympathy for the journalist
and focused attention on a law in Turkey which makes it a crime to
insult the country or the Turkish national character.

Journalists and writers who spoke openly on controversial topics,
including Dink and Nobel Prize-winning author Orhan Pamuk, have been
prosecuted under the law, which critics say hampers free speech.

More than 100,000 people marched at Dink’s funeral, many of them
chanting for Turkey to abolish the law.

The government pledged to hold a speedy investigation into Dink’s
killing, and has already suspended the governor and police chief of
Trabzon, the city on the Black Sea coast where suspects in the killing
lived. Several other police officers were also suspended for posing
with the 17-year-old killer after his capture in the Black Sea port
city of Samsun.

Turkish Officials Sacked In Probe Into Killer Video

TURKISH OFFICIALS SACKED IN PROBE INTO KILLER VIDEO

Gulf Times, Qatar
Feb 6 2007

ANKARA: Two Turkish security officials lost their jobs yesterday in
a widening investigation into video footage that appeared to portray
as a hero the teenage killer of a prominent Turkish-Armenian editor.

The state-run Anatolian news agency said authorities in the Black Sea
city of Samsun had sacked a fifth policeman and transferred a fifth
member of the paramilitary gendarmerie to other duties following
similar dismissals last Friday.

The news agency said that the dismissals were made at the request of
a government inspector but gave no further information.

The video footage showed Ogun Samast, 17, posing in front of a Turkish
flag with security officials shortly after his arrest last month
on suspicion of killing the editor Hrant Dink outside his newspaper
office in Istanbul. He has confessed to the crime.

Dink’s funeral drew 100,000 mourners onto the streets in protest at
the militant nationalism that apparently inspired his killer. Seven
others have also been charged in the Dink case.

Dink had infuriated Turkish nationalists by urging Turkey in his
writings to face up to its responsibility for the mass killing of
Armenians by Ottoman Turks in 1915.

The video footage has revived fears in Turkey of a shadowy "deep state"
working in collusion with criminal gangs.

The "deep state" is code for hardline nationalists purportedly based
in the security forces who are ready to break the law if need be in
defence of their ideology.

Last week, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, under pressure in an
election year for failing to combat crime, vowed to tackle what he
called "gangs within state institutions".

Turkey’s Schizophrenia – Young Turks, Old Turks

TURKEY’S SCHIZOPHRENIA – YOUNG TURKS, OLD TURKS
By Dr Fereydun Hilmi

Kurdish Media, UK
Feb 6 2007

There must have been a time when the Turks thought straight before
they suffered the enormous humiliation at the hands of the British and
French occupiers and their oppressive "Capitulation Laws" allowing
a British or French soldier virtually a free hand in insulting and
overpowering any Turk they wished. My Father describes this condition
vividly in his famous Yaddasgt (Memoirs), in which he also talks
of being personally emotionally moved to the point of having tears
streaming down his cheeks as a result of listening to a young Turkish
poet, disgruntled by all of it. The incident was in 1920 in front of
the mausoleum adorning the front courtyard of the Sultan Ahmad Mosque.

I recite this incident to demonstrate the kind of spirit we possessed
as Kurds and I am sure also the Armenians and other minorities in
the Ottoman Empire and general feeling of belonging and love of our
common homeland which was the entire empire estate.

It was Attaturk who recommended the cocooning of the nation indeed
a hard nationalistic shell after getting rid of the Kurdish leaders
whom he duped into accepting his promises of autonomy and democratic
participation. However we all know that Attaturk was a revel himself
and had a great deal against the ottoman rulers who appointed him
Commander of all the forces in Anatolia in what they considered a
kind of exile to get rid of him. Why then do his modern followers and
those who followed him since his death refuse to admit their mistakes,
treacherous dealings and collaboration with the invaders?

The answer may be nationalistic and racist particularly when it comes
to admitting the Armenian "Homocide", (this is a new term I invent
to avoid the word Genocide which seems to be too cruel for British
and US ears).

And given that we all had a sense of belonging to that homeland what
is it that caused the division which ensued and the animosity which
has been created and enflamed lasting to the year 2003?

The keen observer will see the creation of a state out of the remnants
of the empire based on a single race and dedicated to the service of
one nation of the old emoire albeit a major one. All others must become
subservient and never claim different nationality or language. What is
worse is the fact that this new Turkey which fought the old Sultanate
and Empire is now refusing to admit that those who ruled before had
made any mistakes or committed any crimes.

Today Turkey is in need of all the help it can get. So far they have
received financial and military help as would Pakistan or Afghanistan
or even Yemen. But I know Turkey considers itself a great nation with
empire pedigree and is not a country created by the British as weak
and third-class client states. It is for the Turks to ascertain their
cultural pedigree and e1st century thinking and enlightenment. The
days of the fascist state are over and all nations of the world are
looking to co-exit, those in one state are longing to preserve and
enjoy their full rights and to contribute to the society in every
possible way. Rejecting Kurdish rights and refusing to recognise the
Homocide of the Armenians does not make Turkey a more respectable
country but a much less respected one for it is better to admit the
crimes of a group of blood-thirsty Turks who lived 101 years ago for
a short and turbulent period than to deny it ever happened and thus
be regarded as a stubborn, guilty and mindless nation for the rest of
your lives. I do not think any wise person would want to shoulder the
crimes of some people who lived 101 years ago when you could easily
attribute the crimes to those have been long since dead. Denial means
one thing only: That the Turks support what happened and would not
hesitate to commit the same again. That impression surely is not in
the best interests of Turkey and the Turks.

I am sure not only Kurds, Armenians and Laz people are at the bad end
of Turkish belligerence but many, many Turks as well. I also suspect
that the strict and police-state-like system in Turkey is suffered
by all because of Turkish feeling that the Kurds and Armenians are
the enemies within who will take the first opportunity to split the
country into smaller nations. Thus if only Turkey makes its peace
with these two major minorities within the state they will not have
anything to fear and ordinary Turks would also be liberated from the
rule of the Generals and the "Old Turks".

It is time Turkey including the Kurds and Armenians became the
important nations of the Middle East as well as the entire ex-Ottoman
nations such as the Arabs and Greeks. These nations together gave the
greatest human potential in the world and it is time they contributed
that potential to the advancement of mankind pushing away the
oppressive and decadent values of Bushman and his Robin.

Editorial: Turkish Law On ‘Insults’ An Insult To Turkishness

EDITORIAL: TURKISH LAW ON ‘INSULTS’ AN INSULT TO TURKISHNESS

San Antonio Express, TX
Feb 6 2007

Sometimes an end can signal a beginning.

Such should be the case with the recent assassination of Hrant Dink.

Dink, an Armenian Turk, was shot to death last month outside the
Istanbul offices of his bilingual newspaper, Agos.

Many suspect his death is connected to his outspoken references to a
painful event in Turkey’s history: the 1915 mass killing of Armenians
by Ottoman forces.

Armenians call the slaughter genocide, while Turkish nationalists
deny the label.

Turkey has a sorry record of accusing citizens who refer to the
killing of Armenians of violating Article 301 of the criminal code.

The offense? Insulting Turkishness.

Orhan Pamuk, the winner of last year’s Nobel Prize for literature,
went on trial in 2005, and last year, novelist Elif Shafak was charged
when a character in her novel referred to the event as genocide.

Pamuk’s charges were dropped, and Shafak was acquitted.

Dink, convicted in 2005, was not so lucky.

Shortly after Dink’s death, columnist Ertugrul Ozkok, in the Turkish
newspaper Hurriyet, urged an end to the century-old warring between
Armenians and Turks.

"People need to stop accusing each other of being traitors to the
nation, of being this and being that. And on the other side, people
have to stop labeling those who express their love for country and flag
‘racists fascists.’"

Some of that unity was seen during Dink’s funeral, as thousands
marched holding signs reading "We are all Armenians."

Turkey is facing international pressure to repudiate the law.

It should, because it’s the right thing to do. If the European Union
aspirant hopes to gain entry into the international bloc, it must
fix its atrocious record on free speech.

rials/stories/MYSA020607.01O.Turkey2ed.c148a2.html

http://www.mysanantonio.com/opinion/edito

ANKARA: Santoro’s Family: We Forgive With All Our Hearts

SANTORO’S FAMILY: WE FORGIVE WITH ALL OUR HEARTS
AyªE Karabat Trabzon

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 6 2007

A memorial Mass was celebrated by the head of Italy’s bishops on
Monday for a Catholic priest slain in Turkey at the time of widespread
anger in the Islamic world over the publication of caricatures of
the Prophet Muhammad.

A 16-year-old youth is serving an 18-year prison sentence for the
murder, which was believed to be linked to the outrage over the
publication of the caricatures in European newspapers.

"I hope this service will help deepen our friendship," Cardinal
Camillo Ruini, accompanied by Santoro’s mother and two sisters, told
reporters upon his arrival in Trabzon. "I hope it will help us find
the truth and bring us closer to God," added Ruini.

Maddelana Santoro, the sister of the deceased Father Santoro — a
theology teacher — said that she and her family forgave the killer
with all their hearts and that they still believe in interfaith
dialogue, as did their brother.

In an exclusive interview she gave to Today’s Zaman in the small
and simply decorated working room of Santoro that is adjoined to the
Santa Maria Church where he was killed, Maddelana Santoro said their
brother was very happy to be in Turkey.

"He loved beauty. That’s why he was so happy to stay in Turkey. It
was his decision. From a religious point of view, these are holy
lands. They are the lands of belief; Prophet Abraham was born in this
land and God gave his mission to him here. The Apostles were also in
Anatolia. They came to these holy lands first and announced the New
Testament here. These lands were the center for Christianity before
the message spread to Europe."

She said she visited her brother with 10 of her friends in September
of 2005. She added that Santoro took them to churches on the Aegean
coast and then to the mosques in Trabzon because he believed in
interfaith dialogue.

"While he was here, he used to speak about dialogue between religions
and talked about love and that he was trying to live according to these
ideals. He told us that if you act like sheep, then the people will
approach in an innocent way; if you stay pure and peaceful, people
will love you. He liked to live among people because he believed that
Jesus would carry love to people through his body."

When asked about the wars going on due to conflicts over religion,
she said that this was because people had lost their beliefs.

"People should return back to their beliefs because lack of belief is
replaced by hostility and animosity. This is the main reason behind
all these evil events that we are witnessing. Freedom is the biggest
gift that God has given humanity. But the bases of freedom should come
from love and respect. This must be the starting point. Nothing can
be done by force. As my brother always said, ‘Life is a road and the
human being is walking on this road in order to develop himself.’
This applies to all of us. Eastern and Western countries should
walk together. They need to take this long road throughout life —
we still have a long road ahead of us."

She said that when she heard about the murder of Hrant Dink, she
prayed and wished that one day everybody in Turkey would be able to
voice their ideas in love and respect; everybody should have freedom
of expression. She said that she would always remember her brother
as a person who was enthusiastic and willing to share love. She added
that they never felt any hostility toward anyone following his death.

"We are a religious family. We know the New Testament. Before Jesus
died, he said ‘Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do.’"
When asked if she had forgiven the killer, she replied: "Yes. Yes. My
family and I have forgiven with all our hearts."

Violence against Christians Trabzon, on Turkey’s eastern Black Sea
coast, has come under intense scrutiny following the killing of
Armenian journalist Hrant Dink last month. Dink spoke out about the
mass killings of Armenians in the early 20th century, drawing the
wrath of nationalists.

Prosecutors have charged eight people in connection with the killing,
including a teenage gunman and an alleged instigator, who, like
Santoro’s killer, were from Trabzon.

Pope Benedict XVI remembered Santoro — who worked toward interfaith
dialogue between Christians and Muslims — during his visit to Turkey
in November of 2006.

Santoro’s killing was one of the many recent attacks against Christians
in this predominantly Muslim country. Two other Catholic priests were
attacked last year in Turkey, where Christians have often voiced that
they are of victims of discrimination and persecution.

A group of young men attacked and threatened a Catholic priest in
the Aegean port city of Izmir. The priest, a Slovenian, told Italian
state TV at the time that the men grabbed him by the throat, threw
him into a garden and threatened to kill him.

A French priest, Pierre Brunissen, 74, suffered a hip and leg injury
when a man stabbed him. The attack took place in the Black Sea port
city of Samsun.

Of Turkey’s 70 million people, some 65,000 are Armenian Orthodox
Christians, 20,000 are Roman Catholic, and 3,500 are Protestants.

Around 2,000 are Greek Orthodox while 23,000 are Jewish.

–Boundary_(ID_c4pGfiWNnZjMcFowaBOcKA)–

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Russia, The West And Energy: A Question Of Double Standards?

RUSSIA, THE WEST AND ENERGY: A QUESTION OF DOUBLE STANDARDS?

RIA Novosti, Russia
Feb 6 2007

MOSCOW. (Ian Pryde for RIA Novosti) – It is hardly surprising that the
main headline in the Western media from President Putin’s annual press
conference with Russian and international journalists last Thursday
was his total rejection of accusations that Russia had used energy
as a political weapon in its dispute with Belarus and, last year,
with Ukraine and Georgia.

Let’s take a closer look at Western views on Russia’s energy, although
as usual there was much else of interest in the three-hour question
and answer session.

Writing in the Financial Times’ survey of "The World in 2007" on
January 24, for example, Quentin Peel, the paper’s international
affairs editor, asserted that one "worry is the increasingly
nationalistic behavior of Moscow, with consequences for energy
security," and that America’s "weakness and distraction in the
Middle East seem to provide opportunities for Russian assertiveness,
especially in using its energy wealth."

This is odd. Oil has always been highly political and it is naive to
think it could be otherwise. Why, one wonders, is Russia not allowed
to assert itself and defend what it sees as its national interests?

After all, the most influential school of international relations is
realism, which claims that is precisely what all nations do.

While the West provides ample evidence to support realist notions in
international affairs, its criticism of countries outside the West
often rests on idealism and standards which the West itself fails
to meet as well as it ought to. The inevitable result is that the
West undermines its own influence by leaving itself open to charges
of hypocrisy and double standards, charges which the Third World and
Western left-leaning intellectuals have been making for decades.

During the 1990s, many in the West criticized Russia’s policy of
subsidized energy supplies to the former Soviet republics as being
anti-market, non-transparent and designed to maintain its informal
empire after the collapse of the Soviet Union. The international
financial institutions constantly called for the break-up of Gazprom
and its monopoly and an end to subsidies on the domestic market –
despite the fact that millions of people would be unable to afford the
much higher market prices. Anyone who has experienced a harsh Russian
winter knows this is no joke, but literally a matter of life and death.

Russia’s inept tactics in the gas wars have resulted in a PR disaster
for the country, but it is par for the course that many in the West
have chosen to concentrate on alleged bullying, rather than on Russia’s
broader strategy of ending these massive subsidies of billions of
dollar a year to the inefficient economies of Ukraine, Belarus and
Georgia. As Putin has pointed out, Russia has also increased energy
prices to Armenia, with which it has particularly good relations.

Western realism

It is indeed ironic that the West now criticizes Russia for using the
energy weapon. In the early 1980s, the Reagan administration opposed
construction of the Trans-Siberian natural gas pipeline for fear it
would make Western Europe dependent on the Soviet Union for energy
supplies. It therefore prohibited U.S. companies from supplying
parts to the pipeline and tried to extend the ban to foreign-based
companies that were subsidiaries of U.S. firms or used U.S.-licensed
technology. U.S. Chamber of Commerce President Richard Lesher wrote to
Reagan in February 1982 that the pipeline policy could be likened to a
"strategy of economic warfare." In 1985, the U.S. was more successful
with the energy weapon when it prevailed upon King Fahd of Saudi Arabia
to flood the market with oil in 1985-86 to weaken the Soviet economy.

In mid-2001, the U.S. renewed the 1996 Iran-Libya Sanctions Act (ILSA)
for five years, which penalized any foreign company dealing with Iran
or Libya in amounts of over $20 million, a laughably low hurdle in
the oil and gas business.

Defenders of this approach would doubtless argue that the context
of the Cold War and state-sponsored terrorism make such actions
acceptable, but this hardly applies to the Jackson-Vanik amendment,
which was originally passed in 1975 to punish Communist states
by imposing trade sanctions for their refusal to allow Jewish
emigration. Now, with Russians enjoying more freedom to travel than at
any time since 1914, some circles in America, especially in Congress,
want to retain this wholly anachronistic Cold War relic as a lever
against Russia.

The European Union is also very astute in defending its own
interests. President Putin complained yet again during his press
conference that while Brussels wants European companies to have access
to Russia’s natural resources, the European Union’s single market is
largely closed to Russian exports, an impasse which Putin hopes can
be resolved through normal negotiations.

Nor are the individual members of the EU reticent when it comes to
defending their national interests. The economic absurdities of the
Common Agricultural Policy led the United Kingdom to demand annual
rebates from the EU budget, while the French loudly and vigorously
defend their inefficient farming sector. The Polish vetoing of closer
EU ties with Russia is merely a recent example.

Examples abound in the real world of countries asserting what they
perceive to be their national interests. Indeed, cynics might argue
that nation-states do nothing else, even though this often comes at
a high price to themselves and sometimes other countries as well,
for not all policies are thought through properly, and they often
result in unforeseen consequences.

The EU has frequently been weakened and its decision-making slowed
down or even paralyzed for years in some key areas, while decades
before the current crisis in the Middle East, American foreign policy
was criticized for being against its own national interests.

Russia’s national interests

Certainly Russia has done considerable long-term damage to its
reputation in Europe, more than it realizes.

But the contretemps on energy is no worse, and certainly far less
bitter and extended, than the long-running trade disputes between
Japan and the U.S. in the 1980s and the more recent disagreements
between Europe and the U.S. which culminated in the "banana wars."

In fact, despite the saber-rattling and brinkmanship, Russia quickly
agreed to lower prices and looser conditions than it originally
demanded, with a long transition period which would gradually see
prices rise to European levels.

But of course the entire economy of the developed world is based on
hydrocarbons, and there are simply no other viable alternatives at
the moment. Russia’s actions have inevitably led to a more intensive
European debate on energy and energy security, with Angela Merkel
rethinking the governing coalition’s agreement to scrap nuclear energy.

Russia can hardly afford any repetition of these gas wars, since
the result will be to further undermine the confidence of its main
trading partner and close neighbor, and switching supplies to the
Far East is a less viable option than appears at first sight.

Russia feels that the security of energy supplies to its main customers
in Western and Central Europe are at risk from transit countries. But
one of its proposed solutions, the Nord Stream pipeline running
directly from Russia to Germany under the Baltic Sea, unleashed a
storm of protest in Poland, which would lose out on the transit fees,
and in Germany itself, not least because former Chancellor Gerhard
Schroder is closely involved with Gazprom.

The protests over the Nord Stream pipeline and the gas wars show
just how difficult it will be for Russia to appease certain Western
circles whatever it does.

During her January meeting with Putin in Moscow, German Chancellor
Angela Merkel demanded that in the future, Russia must inform
Europe in good time about any expected interruptions to oil or gas
supplies and suggested setting up a formal mechanism to ensure better
communications.

In contrast to the Soviet Union, however, modern Russia is poor at
communications both internationally and domestically, and no longer
enjoys a frighteningly powerful propaganda machine. At least a partial
awareness of the problem is indicated by reports in mid-January of
Gazprom seeking to engage international PR companies to polish up
its image.

Quentin Peel is wrong when he suggests that America’s "weakness and
distraction in the Middle East seem to provide opportunities for
Russian assertiveness, especially in using its energy wealth."

In the 1990s, following the collapse of the Soviet Union, Russia was
weak, with its economy, like those of the other former republics,
experiencing probably the biggest economic decline seen in peacetime
in the twentieth century.

Long-term trends

It was, however, naive to assume that this state of affairs would
last forever. Russia is becoming more active not only in the Middle
East, but also in Asia and Asia-Pacific, Africa and Latin America,
not to mention Europe and North America.

These trends will continue irrespective of American strength or
weakness for the simple reason that Russia sees itself as a great
power. And, like China and India, Russia is embracing much from the
West, but is doing so increasingly on its own terms.

Russia is by no means above criticism, but Western accusations that
the country uses its wealth as a political weapon – if indeed this was
case – ring hollow and will be rejected by Russians as hypocritical
and self-serving.

Ian Pryde is CEO of Eurasia Strategy & Communications, Moscow.

The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and
may not necessarily represent the opinions of the editorial board.

BAKU: Bryza: "Adoption Of ‘Armenian Genocide’ Bill Can Harm US-Turke

BRYZA: "ADOPTION OF ‘ARMENIAN GENOCIDE’ BILL CAN HARM US-TURKEY RELATIONS"

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Feb 6 2007

"Adoption of draft law on Armenian Genocide in US Congress can
seriously harm US-Turkey relations," Deputy Assistant Secretary of
State for European and Eurasian Affairs, US co-chair of the OSCE
Minsk Group Matthew Bryza stated.

Bryza stated that in case if the Congress passes that bill, the
relations between the two countries can be harmed.

Bryza also said the White House Administration began to work with
the congressmen to prevent the adoption of the bill.

He also added that the White House makes all its efforts to prevent
the alleged Armenian genocide bill from recognition.

The War Of The Words

THE WAR OF THE WORDS
By George P. Fletcher
Project Syndicate News Service

Korea Times, South Korea
Feb 6 2007

Nowadays, words are often seen as a source of instability. The
violent reactions last year to the caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad
published in a Danish newspaper saw a confused Western response, with
governments tripping over their tongues trying to explain what the
media should and should not be allowed to do in the name of political
satire. Then Iran trumped the West by sponsoring a conference of
Holocaust deniers, a form of speech punished as criminal almost
everywhere in Europe.

As Turks well know, it is dangerous to take a position on the Armenian
genocide of 1915. The most recent Nobel laureate in literature, Orhan
Pamuk, was prosecuted in Istanbul for denying Turkey’s official history
by saying that the Armenian genocide actually occurred. Other Turks
have faced prosecution in Western Europe for saying that it did not.

So words are now clearly a battlefield in the cultural conflict
between Islam and the West. The West has learned that, simply as
a matter of self-censorship, not legal fiat, newspapers and other
media outlets will not disseminate critical pictures of Muhammad,
and the Pope will no longer make critical comments about Islam. But
these gestures of cooperation with Muslim sensibilities have not been
met by reciprocal gestures.

Instead, Mahmoud Ahmedinejad, Iran’s president, has threatened to
wipe Israel off the map. The Israeli Foreign Ministry now seeks
prosecution of Ahmedinejad for incitement to commit genocide –
a violation of international law.

But the Israeli press is also bellicose. Israeli newspapers regularly
carry stories about why Israel may need to attack Iran to prevent it
from acquiring an arsenal of nuclear weapons. President George W.

Bush has made similarly ominous, if more vague, statements about
Iran. In Germany, preparing and calling for preemptive military
strikes from within the government are subject to criminal sanctions.

The world’s different legal systems have never been in much agreement
about the boundaries of free speech. Even between good neighbors
like Canada and the United States, there is little agreement about
punishing hate speech. Canadians punish racial insults, but Americans
do not, at least if the issue is simply one of protecting the dignity
of racial minorities.

But threatening violence is more serious. Many countries are united
in supporting the principle that if, say, Ahmedinejad does meet the
criteria for incitement of genocide, he should be punished in the
International Criminal Court. Indeed, the International Criminal
Tribunal for Rwanda punished radio station operators who made
aggressive public broadcasts urging Hutus to pick up their machetes
and murder Tutsis.

A decade ago there would have been a good argument in international
law that the Hutu-Tutsi example supports prosecution only after
the damage has been done. All the international precedents – from
Nuremberg to the present – concern international intervention after
mass atrocities. Domestic police may be able to intervene to prevent
crime before it occurs, but in the international arena there is no
police force that can do that.

It follows, therefore, that the crime of incitement should apply only
to cases like Rwanda, where the radio broadcasts actually contributed
to the occurrence of genocide. In cases where bellicose leaders make
public threats to "bury" another country (remember Khrushchev?) or
to wipe it off the map, the courts should wait, it was said, until
some harm occurs.

But the international community has become ever more intrusive in using
legal remedies against persons who engage in provocative and dangerous
speech. In September 2005, the United Nations Security Council passed
Resolution 1624 – paradoxically, with American approval – calling
upon all member states to enact criminal sanctions against those who
incite terrorism. The model of incitement they had in mind is the same
one that British Prime Minister Blair has publicly invoked: Muslim
leaders standing up in their mosques and urging their congregations
to go out and kill infidels.

Americans have traditionally said that, absent a risk of immediate
unlawful violence, this form of speech should be protected under
the First Amendment. US courts reasoned that it is better to allow
the release of hateful sentiments than to call attention to them by
showcasing them in court. But when it comes to terrorism in today’s
world, most countries, including the world’s democracies, are not as
tolerant as they used to be.

So the traditional liberal position in support of giving wide
scope to freedom of speech, even for extremists, is losing ground
everywhere. When it comes to fighting terrorism and the prospect of
genocide, the world is now becoming afraid of dangerous words.

George P. Fletcher is Cardozo Professor of Jurisprudence at Columbia
University. His latest book is Romantics at War: Glory and Guilt in
the Age of Terrorism.

n/200702/kt2007020617003054330.htm

http://times.hankooki.com/lpage/opinio