‘Genocide Denial Laws Will Shut Down Debate’

‘GENOCIDE DENIAL LAWS WILL SHUT DOWN DEBATE’

Spiked, UK
Feb 6 2007

She’s one of the best-known warriors against Holocaust denial. Yet
Deborah Lipstadt thinks EU plans to ban ‘genocide denial’ are
a disaster.

‘For European politicians, bringing in a ban on genocide denial is
like apple pie. It’s what I call a freebie. They’re doing it to make
themselves feel good. I mean, who could possibly be against standing up
to nasty genocide deniers? Only when you get to the heart of it, this
"freebie", this populist move, could have a dire impact on academic
debate. Even on truth itself.’

Deborah Lipstadt, Dorot Professor of Modern Jewish and Holocaust
Studies at Emory University in Atlanta, may be one of the best-known
warriors against Holocaust denial. But she has no time for the
proposals currently doing the rounds of the European Union which
suggest making it a crime to deny the Holocaust, other genocides and
crimes against humanity in general.

Last week it was revealed that Germany, current holder of the EU’s
rotating presidency, is proposing a Europe-wide ban on Holocaust
denial and other forms of genocide denial. This would make a crime
of ‘publicly condoning, denying or grossly trivialising…crimes of
genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes [as defined in the
Statute of the International Criminal Court].’ (1) In some European
countries – most notably Germany and Austria, which formed the heart
of the Third Reich – it is already against the law to deny or minimise
the Nazis’ exterminatory campaign against the Jews in the Second World
War. This new legislation might also make it a crime, punishable by
fines or imprisonment, to raise awkward questions about the official
history of conflicts that took place over the past 20 years.

‘This is so over the top’, says Lipstadt, in between sips of decaf
coffee in the plush surroundings of the Athenaeum Hotel in Piccadilly,
London. Her earthy New York accent sounds almost out of place in a
building where even the doorman comes across as posh. ‘The question
of genocide, the history of genocide and what you can say about it,
should not be decided by politicians and judges’, she insists.

Lipstadt certainly can’t be accused of being soft on deniers. Her
book Denying the Holocaust: The Growing Assault on Truth and Memory,
published in 1994, meticulously exposed the lies and the underlying
racist agenda of those who deny the truth of the Nazi Holocaust.

Famously (or infamously) she was subsequently sued by the British
historian David Irving, whom she had named in the book as a Holocaust
denier. In January 2000, the 32-day trial, a showdown between an
American-Jewish historian and a far-right British historian, became a
legal debate about the history of the Nazis, and the nature of truth
itself. Irving lost rather spectacularly. The judge branded him an
anti-Semite, a racist and a Holocaust denier who had ‘deliberately
misrepresented and manipulated historical evidence’. Lipstadt recounts
the experience in History on Trial: My Day in Court with David Irving.

Yet this ridiculer of deniers is no fan of the idea that Holocaust
denial or genocide denial should be outlawed. The current EU proposal
to criminalise denial of contemporary genocides and war crimes is an
affront to serious historical debate, she says.

Consider Srebrenica, the massacre that took place at the end of the
Bosnian civil war in 1995 in which it is estimated that 8,000 Bosnian
Muslims were killed. ‘Some people argue that, given there are only so
many tens of thousands of people in Srebrenica and the Serb soldiers
went after an X number of a specific group, then it is genocide. But
someone else might say it’s a massacre of the X population, not a
genocide – because if you’re going to use that word then you have
to go back to what the Nazis did to the Jews or what was done to the
Armenians [by the Turks in the First World War]’, says Lipstadt.

‘That is an entirely legitimate debate to have about Srebrenica. Are
we now saying that the person who says it’s not a genocide will be
fined and punished?’

Lipstadt is also worried about the way in which debate about
the Armenian experience might be closed down. During the First
World War, as Ottoman Turkish forces fought against the Russians,
some of the Armenian minority in Eastern Anatolia sided with
Russia. Turkey responded by rounding up and killing hundreds of
Armenian community leaders in April 1915, and then forcibly deporting
the two million-strong Armenian community in marches towards Syria and
Mesopotamia (now Iraq). Hundreds of thousands died as a result. At
the end of last year, to the fury of Turkey, France made it a crime
to deny that the Armenian tragedy was a genocide, and now Germany
seems to hope that the rest of Europe will follow suit by accepting
its proposals to outlaw denial of all genocides.

‘This is another body-blow to academic debate’, says Lipstdadt. ‘I
know serious historians who do not deny for a minute what happened
to the Armenians, who do not deny the severity or the barbarity of
what happened to them. But they question, they ask intellectually,
"Was this a genocide, or was it a horrendous massacre?" They don’t
ask that question on ideological grounds; they don’t have a shred of
allegiance to Turkey. They ask it intellectually, because they want
to get to the truth.’

‘I happen to think they’re wrong’, she says. She believes the Armenians
did suffer a genocide. ‘But you can, indeed you must, have a vigorous
academic debate about historical events. And in the course of that
vigorous academic debate you probably would illuminate weaknesses
in both sides of the argument, and hopefully sharpen the arguments
as a result. That is what academic debate is about. This kind of
legislation could put a kabash on that.’

Last year, in its reporting of the French decision to outlaw denial
of the Armenian genocide, the BBC was forced to explain why it
put the word ‘genocide’ in inverted commas. ‘Whether or not the
deaths of hundreds of thousands of Armenians during the First
World War amounted to genocide is a matter for heated debate’,
it said (2). Yet if the proposed legislation is passed in the EU,
then such things will no longer be a matter for heated debate; they
will become legally-defined truths that you deny or question at your
peril. Maybe even the BBC will find itself in the dock for putting
‘Armenian genocide’ in inverted commas.

It strikes me that as well as stifling open academic debate the
proposed legislation could criminalise political protest. Very often
these days, Western powers justify wars of intervention abroad in
the language of combating genocide. Bill Clinton and Tony Blair
described their bombing crusade over Kosovo in 1999 as an effort to
stop Slobodan Milosevic’s ‘genocide’ against the Kosovo Albanians. In
truth, the final number of civilians killed in Kosovo – including
both Kosovo Albanians by Milosevic’s cronies and Serbs in NATO air
strikes – was fewer than 3,000. The Nazis were capable of killing
12,000 a day in Auschwitz alone. As Nazi camp survivor Elie Wiesel
said, taking umbrage at the use of Holocaust-talk to justify the
Kosovo campaign, ‘The Holocaust was conceived to annihilate the
last Jew on the planet. Does anyone believe that Milosevic and his
accomplices seriously planned to exterminate all the Bosnians, all
the Albanians, all the Muslims in the world?’ (3) If EU officials,
in their infinite wisdom, decide that a conflict such as Kosovo is
genocide, and therefore the bombers must be sent in, will protesters
who question that line be criminalised under the new legislation?

Lipstadt finds today’s over-use of the genocide and Holocaust
tags, to describe conflicts or political repression, disturbing and
distasteful. She seems still to be reeling from an article she read in
The Times on Saturday, the day before we met. Under the headline ‘We
are vilified like Jews by the Nazis, says Muslim leader’, the paper
reported that Birmingham’s most senior Muslim leader had compared
contemporary political Britain to Nazi Germany.

‘That is ludicrous. It is stupid and ridiculous’, she says. ‘Is
there fear of Muslims today? No doubt. Do some politicians play on
that? Of course. But to compare Muslims in Britain to Jews in Nazi
Germany…that shows an utter lack of historical understanding, not to
mention sensitivity. Here, the police go out of their way to explain to
Muslims what is going on. In Nazi Germany if a Jew spoke to a policeman
he got hit. It was a whole government dedicated to being against you,
to eliminating you. So that is a disgusting kind of analogy. It is
wicked, and cleverly wicked. Sometimes it is done in a calculating
fashion to further your aims by playing that victim card.’

To the ‘befuddlement’ of some of her colleagues, Lipstadt is also
opposed to laws outlawing actual Nazi Holocaust denial. Such laws
already exist in Germany, Austria, Belgium, France, the Czech Republic,
Lithuania, Poland, Romania and Slovakia, and under Germany’s proposals
these will be extended to the rest of the EU and will also cover
genocide and war crimes denial. She points out that there is a huge
difference between those historians who legitimately debate something
like the Armenian experience, and the charlatans who distort the
truth in order to show that the Holocaust didn’t happen and ‘the
Jews’ are all liars. Where ‘genocide denial’ laws might frustrate
serious academic debate, Holocaust denial laws are only aimed at
punishing weird and malicious pseudo-historians. Yet she is against
the censorship of these charlatans, too.

‘I’m opposed to Holocaust denial laws for three reasons’, she says.

‘First because I believe in free speech. Governments should make
no laws limiting free speech, because it is never good when that
happens. Second, because these laws turn Holocaust deniers into
martyrs. Look what happened to David Irving when he was released from
jail in Austria – he became a media darling, given room to spout his
misinformation. We should ignore them rather than chasing them down.

‘And thirdly, and most importantly, such laws suggest that we don’t
have the history, the documentation, the evidence to make the case
for the Holocaust having happened. They suggest we don’t trust the
truth. But we do have the evidence, and we should keep on developing
it and deepening it, and we should trust it.’

Ironically, given her outspoken opposition to laws against Holocaust
and genocide denial, many point to Lipstadt’s legal victory over David
Irving as evidence for why the courtroom is a good place to resolve
historical issues and punish those who lie about or deny historic
tragedies. ‘I wish they wouldn’t do that’, she says. She points
out that her case was not about ruthlessly pursuing Irving in order
to prove the truth about the Holocaust. ‘He came after me! He sued
me! I didn’t want it. I tried to stop it. Our whole legal strategy
was premised on trying to make this guy go away. Only when it was
very close to the case, when I saw the wealth of evidence that showed
how he had lied and distorted the facts, was I glad it had come to
court. Aside from that, I can think of no other instance where history
has benefited from courtroom adjudication.’

‘Politicians should not be doing history’, she says. ‘They have a
hard enough time doing politics right and doing legislation right.

Let them not muck up history, too.’

Brendan O’Neill is editor of spiked. Deborah Lipstadt’s book History
on Trial: My Day in Court with David Irving is published by Harper
Perennial. (Buy this book from Amazon(UK)). Visit her website here.

The photographs of Professor Lipstadt were taken by Sasha Frieze who
blogs at Sashinka.

(1) EU plans far-reaching ‘genocide denial’ law, Bruno Waterfield,
Daily Telegraph, 4 February 2007

(2) Q&A: Armenian ‘genocide’, BBC News, 12 October 2006

(3) Quoted in ‘Exploiting genocide’, Brendan O’Neill, Spectator,
21 January 2006

/article/2824/

http://www.spiked-online.com/index.php?/site

feb/7

Sunday, February 04, 2007
****************************************
REFLECTIONS
******************************
An Armenian bears two crosses, and the heavier of the two is not his own.
*
If talk is cheap and if “he who speaks does not know,” when, O when shall I acquire the wisdom of silence?
*
My critical remarks may damage our prestige in the eyes of the world, I am reminded once in a while. To which I can only say, what prestige? Most people are not even aware of our existence or, if they are, they tend to confuse us with Romanians and Arameans. To the rest we might as well be an open book and a political cliché. If they flatter us it may be because we can be of some use to them. Which means their opinions of us is so low that they think they can manipulate us with phony sentiments. I don’t call that prestige, I call that an insult.
*
When does hatred of the enemy end and self-hatred begin? Muslims in the Middle East today hate one another more than they hate the West, and judging by the venom in our discussions forums, letters to the editor, and our recent history, how different are we?
*
Honorat de Bueil: “Nature is jealous of our prosperity. She allots a longer lifespan to thorns than to roses.”
#
Monday, February 05, 2007
*****************************************
GUESSING GOD
*******************************
If God exists, He wants us to go about our business as though He didn’t. Gone are the days of the Old Testament when He micromanaged human affairs. No more Burning Bushes, Ave-Maria archangels, and prophets. His message to mankind seems to be: If you don’t make use of the brain I have given you, don’t bother me with your problems.
*
What if our ancestors were smarter than we are? Mention if you can a modern figure comparable to Confucius, Buddha, Socrates, and Jesus. What if the writers of the Old Testament were smart enough to know they were writing science fiction? What if a thousand years from now mankind will study the Old Testament the way we study books on Greek mythology today?
*
When speaking of God, it is wiser to ask questions than to answer them. Or, like Buddha, treat Him as though He did not exist.
*
“Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord in vain.” Buddha may be said to have been the only major religious leader who took this commandment so literally that Buddhism is the only major belief systems that is atheist.
#
Tuesday, February 06, 2007
**************************************
CANADIAN ENCOUNTERS
**********************************
The first time I said something remotely critical about an unimportant aspect of Canadian life, an elegantly dressed and attractive lady said: “If you don’t like it here, why don’t you go back where you came from?”
*
When I asked her if she had a favorite painter, a local artist replied: “Eengrass.” It took me a while to realize she had meant Ingres.
*
When after a long interval I met an old friend in the street and asked about his mother, whom I had met on several occasions, he replied: “We don’t know where she is. She ran away with a younger man and we haven’t heard from her since.”
*
A CANADIAN IN ITALY
********************************
“How do you say pizza in Italian?”
*
PATRIOTS
****************************
Our partisans don’t like my kind of writing. They think I insult Armenishness. And what’s even more absurd, they consider themselves competent judges, even though they have more skeletons in their closet than breathing specimens with brains in their living room. Only utter despair can lead a man to believe in his own lies.
*
I’VE BEEN READING
************************************
Barby d’Aurevilly: “The crimes of the most advanced civilizations are greater than those committed by the most backward barbarians.”
*
Blaise Cendrars: “It is in the very things that they share that people differ the most from one another.”
*
Sartre: “Half victim, half accomplice, like the rest of mankind.”
*
Paul Valéry: “To believe that one understands is a very dangerous state of mind.”
*
Balzac: “All power is a permanent conspiracy.”
#
Wednesday, February 07, 2007
**************************************
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
*************************************
Mention an unsolved mystery and someone is sure to spin a conspiracy theory.
*
Ask an unanswerable question and someone is sure to come up with the wrong answer.
*
People who hate fiction don’t see any contradiction in the fiction that is at the base of their belief system.
*
When it comes to understanding, man seems to operate on the verge of starvation: any answer, no matter how untenable and absurd, is better than none.
*
A priest once slapped me because I asked the wrong question. I no longer remember the question, but I remember the slap, which was no answer.
*
MEN AND WOMEN
******************************
To women, men are the most universal sources of disappointment. Did you know that the Chinese word for husband is “go

V. Ayvazyan Is Not A Competitor For ‘Powerful Motherland’

V. AYVAZYAN IS NOT A COMPETITOR FOR ‘POWERFUL MOTHERLAND’

Panorama.am
18:59 06/02/2007

"The position of our party regarding the coming elections will become
clear only during our forthcoming congress. We cannot say anything
concrete today", asked by a correspondent of Panorama.am whether the
information that two leading persons of "Powerful Motherland" party
will be included in the proportional list of "Prosperous Armenia"
party is true, Deputy Chairman of "Powerful Motherland" party,
Chairman of "Javakhk" union, Shirak Torosyan answered.

He is sure that "Union of Vir-Armenians" headed by RA Minister of
Nature Protection, Member of RPA board, Vardan Ayvazyan, is not a
competitor for them at all.

He is sure that during the parliamentary elections the "Union of
Vir-Armenians", which supports the RPA, will not seize the electorate
of "Powerful Motherland".

To Adopt A Law Is A Matter Of Taste, But Of … Legal Taste

TO ADOPT A LAW IS A MATTER OF TASTE, BUT OF… LEGAL TASTE

Panorama.am
19:16 06/02/2007

"Simply there has not been set an issue to once more submit the
constitutional provisions by law", Minister of Justice, David
Harutyunyan, said concerning the draft law "On the formation and
resignation of the Government", submitted in the parliament today. It
should be noted that the parliamentarians did not adopt the bill, which
has 3 articles, noting that nothing is mentioned in the draft about the
authorities of the National Assembly to form a government. According
to the minister, in view of the legislative technique it arouses some
problems and it seems that the law is imperfect. "It is a matter of
legal taste, and if the deputies consider necessary to include relevant
provisions in the text of the law, then it will be done. We don’t
see any problem here", the representative of the government assured.

In the words of the minister, however, if the Constitution gives
general description, then he is not sure that the legislator can more
detail it. "When the National Assembly considers that the government
does not duly fulfill its obligations, then it has all the instruments
to get rid of that government", the minister mentioned.

‘Panama, Belgium And We Have This’

‘PANAMA, BELGIUM AND WE HAVE THIS’

Panorama.am
20:33 06/02/2007

"The legislation has taken the Christian form", Chairman of NA
standing commission on state legal issues, Rafik Petrosyan noted,
concerning the amendments to the Judiciary code made in the period
from the first to second reading. He added that only Panama and
Belgium have the Judiciary code.

He reminded his colleagues that he has voted "for" the draft law,
adopted in the first reading, but now he offers to bring for voting
the bill, taking into consideration the positive conclusion of the
commission.

According to David Haroutyunyan, Minister of Justice, the courts of
bankruptcy have been withdrawn from the list of specialized courts,
besides, 3 criminal, 3 civil and 1 administrative courts will be
created, by the way, they will be formed till Jan 1, 2008.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Conclusions Are Anachronistic

CONCLUSIONS ARE ANACHRONISTIC

Panorama.am
16:17 06/02/2007

We present answers of Executive of the Hye Dat office of ARF Bureau,
Kiro Manoyan, to Panorama.am.

– Aren’t the authorities of Russia consistent in the issue of revealing
and condemning murders on the national ground?

– The fact that, in general, the most part of the murders in Russia on
national ground, not only against Armenians, have not been revealed and
or it is not always that the revealed cases get relevant accusation and
sentence, testifies that not at all levels of the Russian authorities
and not all branches show sufficient consistency. Taking into
consideration that the murders on the national ground testify about
the disease of one part, then the healthy section of the society, the
intellectuals as well have the great thing to do to cure the disease.

– Was the reaction of official Turkey adequate in the aroused
situation, and whether Ankara is ready to reveal the case of the
assassination of Hrant Dink up to the end?

– Official Turkey tried to go out of the situation with minimum
losses. The statements, made with propagandistic view, and the
expressions of condolences did not show that official Turkey does
not concern that the murder of Hrant Dink was committed just through
their fault, that he was killed with just the motivation that the
court of Turkey had judged him. Official Turkey will hardly display
readiness to reveal the case up to the end, because it will mean
a non-official conflict with the structures, which are called an
aboriginal state. Official Ankara will not go to it for the murder
of an Armenian.

– Whether the authorities of Armenia and the Armenian society have
displayed an adequate reaction to the committed crimes. "In one case
they didn’t say anything, in other case were engaged in anti-Turkish
propaganda".

– The assassination of Dink on political ground should not be compared
with the murders being committed in Russia on national ground. The
assassination of Dink was a terrorist act committed by the political
order.

In general the reaction of the Armenian authorities and the society
was adequate. And what happened in Turkey, was a political action to
which an adequate response was given.

– Is it possible that the processes taken place in Russian and Turkey,
will bring amendments in the consciousness of the society, in view
of worsening of Armenian-Russian friendly relations on one hand,
and mollification of Armenian-Turkish hostile relations.

– I have already said, if murders of Armenians on national ground
continue, it is natural that anti-Russian mood will develop in
the Armenian society. And in Turkey the processes are the same as
before the assassination of Dink. The actions of a small part of
the population of Istanbul, including of thousands of Armenians
and non-Turks the day of Dink’s funeral, should not be considered
yet as the beginning of the process. Many distinguished Turks, who
took part in the procession, already state that the behest of Dink,
according to them, was not to use the word "genocide"… The process
is out of question.

Who Will Be The Ninth Of The District

WHO WILL BE THE NINTH OF THE DISTRICT

Panorama.am
17:02 06/02/2007

After the famous resolution of the Constitutional Court the seats
provided to judges in the commissions, were transferred to legal
servants. Head of Legal Department, Ashot Abovyan, was appointed the
member of the Central Electoral Committee by a relevant decree of
the President of Armenia.

However, discussions are being conducted on who will be appointed in
about 2000 commissions, what is the number of legal servants, and will
be their number sufficient for being represented in all the election
districts. For the purpose of getting clarifications "Im iravunk"
applied to the Cassation Court. As the press secretary of the Court,
Alina Yengoyan, said, according to the approved name list of the
Board of Courts, the number of the staff of legal servants is 655,
out of which 50 places are vacant.

In this case in how many elections districts will representatives of
the legal department be appointed?

Alina Yengoyan assured that legal servants would be appointed only in
central and regional electoral commissions. Only 42 legal servants
will be needed for it. Alina Yengoyan found it difficult to answer
who will be appointed in the commissions of polling stations.

AGAPI Does Not Give Money

AGAPI DOES NOT GIVE MONEY

Panorama.am
18:38 06/02/2007

"Agap-Hrat" Ltd tries to transfer the economic argument to the
political field. Clarifications are given by various mass media, trying
to politicize it", Nerses Haroutyunyan, advocate of Martoun Ivanyan who
has made a claim against the "Agap-Hrat" Ltd, told journalists today.

According to Haroutyunyan, his client has signed a service contract
with "Agap-Hrat" Ltd, but the company has not fulfilled its obligations
stipulated by the contract, and has not paid 7 350 000 drams for the
rendered services. Regarding the fact the court of first instance
passed a verdict, obliging the "Agap-Hrat" to pay to the plaintiff
9 048 thous. drams (the court took into account the fines as well).

Though the decision of the court satisfies the claim of the plaintiff,
but the advocate says that the enforcement service has not taken any
steps to exact the amount. Haroutyunan stated, he is going to appeal
the inactivity of the enforcement service.

Isn’t Water Polluted?

ISN’T WATER POLLUTED?

A1+
[05:46 pm] 06 February, 2007

On January 30 "Noushikyan Association" turned to "Yerevan Water" LTD
as the company wanted to get acquainted with the technical conditions
of roundabout way of the water pipeline passing through Aghayan 19
and Teryan 56. But three days ago, the constructors damaged the water
pipeline as a result of which the running water became polluted.

Rouben Torosyan, head of the commission protecting citizens’ rights,
assures that "the project under question hasn’t undergone legal
proceedings and is therefore illegal". In this respect, he submitted
an application to the RA General Prosecutor. On February 8-12 the
court will hold hearings on citizens’ claim against the RA Ministry
of Environment.

Rouben Torosyan assures that the water pipeline was fixed with the
help of wood pieces as a result of which the water became no good
for drinking. The representatives of water irrigation system were
indignant as the company initiated the construction without any
permission and preliminary examination.

Henrik Martirosyan, chief architect of "Yerevan Water" Kentron
branch, told A1+ that it is beyond their jurisdiction to permit the
construction; it is upon the municipality to decide. In case the
municipality submits a decision on construction, they only give the
technical conditions of passing round of the water pipeline.

"We only have a right to make checking in three months and review the
work of technical conditions", says Mr. Martirosyan. As for the water
pollution, Mr. Martirosyan noted that they got no complaint from the
citizens and were unaware of that problem.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Editor In Chief Under Custody

EDITOR-IN-CHIEF UNDER CUSTODY

A1+
[06:03 pm] 06 February, 2007

Novruzali Mamedov, editor-in-chief of "Tolshi Sado" newspaper was
arrested and sentenced to 15-day detention. He was arrested by the
premises of the Academy of Science in Baku.

Two men dressed in ordinary clothes approached him in the street and
demanded to produce documents. In answer to them, the editor-in-chief
asked them for identity cards. Soon afterwards Mamedov was taken to
the police station.

Mamedov’s advocate says he is unaware of the reasons for
arrest. According to official data, Mamedov was arrested for resisting
the policemen.